li ,ssN 0222 - r2e2
l/
DMR 1 980
sit{v()t
Rvtlo l .t|Ert l lGl|oprthl ld l l l il|othqu Slv dc IDl lIr
Rdation dministrtionl4 is, rue d'Asss F _ 75006 PARIS
lBoAAt lmt d 'un n :50 Fl, urdo : 27 F
omPte postal : (simvol)22 288 60 _ Pris
(.l!(),l
)|(l|r rPatrrxol ri rtN||l (..ll|ttrn l i l l lrtroro t ||rttsr
l l u t o r l l r J l a r a t r i r l
l | l t t l | l l l l . . . nn.t . | . . Iu i l | | t l l l l .x. or|r , ' r r| l| ! l | .| l r . . |{ J '
4DEMB
, ] 980
Coo ''o'' olloT opeoo otipo,).}., o a ''o.
B'', ' 'oe''.B .pee fpeu yo.lt o
ol: Py, Paa' p ao.y Pee (y aMay'Tyy aoy oley ao.o a) I,t Pa|ireo oo. r p oo.tty' o po tlo e py e x oo P BP yBil'py py. yu]. ro o |,otl, oyIoT eoe o _]|1o.
o P.A
]980 zod l o aouo pu npadoau!||1500 odoul o d poxrde!| ' u, 'Ta oooana''. B cu c TIl !\1 pe np acT ||o2oop',ul',to'' nou !'|e o|racKo'(.
oto cda aulo pt'|o lJro To Jut|upucTuau Qp. eo, To ucTopuec oo ouo al| aa u. B npL a '. o pe oeuL| npdTafl oo Tun o'a, oopl oe o oK o? do o loo cnu: ,,He oe Toil |ou' a uTo nool!uT dul o a dp cou', ( 15'13)' oo2ol1u'. Tuu' -L|ou uI u Ilu. ompu ncT|I|'o| Tarn, odut|ocT, nooc no'|TuT o ru o.
Ha npotuu o o||uta 'u pauonab To'!||ttoou!|||I|b| opt,l, uo l7oo||o daT u ucpnaeonul||u npdo odo?o t|oep poa. odao L c 1loe'1u daT uTaT npedTau o oZT !',|oa!eoi| ]!u|tu,o6,| d'| e pucTuacu pe, t npu To'| u odp Tuno n4oaurccTa, oTopL ul|oda do npedeoauud e c o. pucu o p ad uuu'
oc oaTo |Ipouto' Copeo uutlu nod-pza oau!To cn|Tau' a' npo!\4' u e ldu pcru-oo npouu|oo' Xo noc!.edl1 15-20 cdecTT o Tu-Tl1o u|uu uc!1a otlo' ooao' u lu pJ\|' oltXX a, uu o, aae| nouau coa l||lenu o|l ucau, !4 n dpz no puuarc'Moactpu, uoe npo||o c7a||bl c Tpad, npodoT npu.g !||oode. ou u'|I|||u npouod co.!'| noTII.I roaTIpcu c. oTfl obt op| '|oaoltullu, o npunoo'1e op,|l|ofu| ,up. |ropo Tu no-ucu oTopoJtt!| a pou, tlo o aTo npuod'| 'vooou'\|D{taj4' Moao lruo u noo cu.
o]IBA 3Il
_ lAH BPMtl
.o
oay, oUJ ee x [p oeP oee ee oxa ropo. }'ttaoo oBI, o e yI opoo Papa :oli eI Ioo oe'(Jle ){ ' o oP o.
eoo eo, oeeo opae ,r. .e o eIe orert oPoolo ol,t Py _
o tll^/t, tlo, e' oe eI, r ao ' 'ypo'' oo _ e ya, po. a To tI eyI y ote y ox pT-
Pllllo: N,ly l' yol oo Po l{,r ao}t Pyo opa Pofi oy' 1o o ooPllll a o P l{ B , o Moo illto TI,l l{ oao ooeHI. Hoopr xI o6eyPaI' a a e, o I e IeIl ByT y o oPee o P }l i pea l{ ya' ooPIoot{o tt eelry oPy.
B Io a e pe oe a rltee B oeo )|,l; oy r oa l-T I,l PI r' o oo' o oollo Ia oopl pI''oop'' oBt{ey ' opa. e npoo. oy Blr I ao oto.l.o P xooy Poyx(e _ o opo, a ooPly oTeI' I oe o o Poy)ee ilo eo ooP.
poy}re? o , oIea o o oo ypo Top orl ooy oeee ' PoIe ooea r6e?
B o x o y o o ( ) l D | t l l l l l I l ) | | t l t | | | l ( | ( l ] t l t r < J ( e
eo peaa l too pe MJ JUl11lI l ly l () l I l I l ' | ) l |) | l (|] l I} l l'
r I e o e p . B a e t l I I l ) l l l l t l l I L l ( | l l i l ] L l ( l l l
oe opt olt) l (eo f l tJ l| ' | l\ ' l I l : l l l l t ' ' t i ) l l , l l l l | ] I '
o e B oIt lo l l loeo aJ l l | () l ' i l ()|) l l l l
t o, pa y oP, M| r IIt ,M lI l . l l lI l
P o)t{o ) l l l l l t ' aey' oop o| l I l II(ULltc l ,
oaol t . ooDIe o Ea Boaae.
oe (t, o yey' e e' o e pe.eoo) oa eP IV ee. Bope o oo aPop oa oa xpllaa' N{[p pae' oee yeeo 3 xpa e''epoI ytlo''-yPB o aTo. B ore cIIo paao y yIti; Bolt oBI eP ' 'o.
reo'' , oa aa popea opaore opI.T apo oe >,l. otllloIll{ oeoeoopI ooeo'
p e e e o , ] o , l e e l O t l _ l t t t a
xo e o oo-o t leo aBoplt e o pooepaP. o poo l B eoe ' 'eyl'' ' py.I oaB,l opoIBa' tl opa, o ollHo' Peye e o ollol op3l' tt aari.To aaHe yaoBeIe or.
ppy, Ao B, y|ll opo yepI ya a e yo rI l,l ocoBa a[l, yT e oy o pB oJll{ oaey yooxtt' r ' o ) ro rrer. Co pe ott, o-ap oty' oI Pe{e' oopoe (o e oToPoel rUa Io' Pl{o o ''BoN4y yIlHo,ty''. Hot{ Pyar ey o oo 'o{' Be ay )llloa, e ay )e . o ol\4oir py tlPyy r 'o e o oIo.
opaaopr o}ro oya a xoBet{, oltoBe oHo )lt' e ayivrI.
o PoaI y. o oy Toy ooe
)lll TIrePa' ypeee oee' o olt e eal
ya Be o y' a y Iye o. eil-e[Iol eo oITa' pI opl. ozula t l.yao. Ho ey Artotl oy) y ypoo' , oyB
o' ol{ :lo tlooe, oee poHoe oIioa oo a.B oox ya a ollo To r: pIr
ooe o.Ileo )tl Boil e ll pePa,
e aPa o]tooBeoo ' o to ooI\4 I ',o.
}Io Pp' ' . op, ooo APaay' o ol ' 'a H
a y''. oe, aac o o oBlIIx'
o I Iyet aT Po, yar Ha IIpP o.
oJ1oB yTp' o o eIlTtltlI ll}t aoTooBl
. . I pe oM.o lJI ''ller}ry paoTy''.
'Il.pyo ovo 'rpo oo e Io e P e.
e o e o e o o P . oopl o Blpa,'ro
oo av.a. Hoopre tt op opa eotl
a Tor yaeo: e ''o'', U] tl PU{a
ootlll oyBlll 1 opa' ooPI ol\' tl
ep; Jr ''aop'', aypoal{Ie ,lx oraUl
pot!,t epe yoe, pooe B oeP; ' 'Bo' ' ,
aaBI ya epeBe..'o, fo otr x epBoaI oP o)t-
oBotto lpo eJr; o ool\4y o eoToo
ooTeToBil paI yJIo )KI{ ooy e Mo
epe o oa; py papyti ee o.
e l{ l ooTeT, a To llyo By.
oo opo oaIa' opeo yorio B l]ae
oto ea aIee l{ito' ru eopl' aal''yttI''
opr er ITe peeeN4'
ooo y oepy' o caoo Mo Boo
po oBe opil pIao }loo.
opal opI, ttTo aa,le o aa, a tl,
ce ulo y ''porx'', oxpa' a .
ey. B aoNl.Io lJI }lyllo Io, oI oo o e.
oopooe oooPa, yo to, oI oo oepo
tiIllTa tl.
Tp, o rioo oPa ooeo, apy
aotl orrvo , oo B ToM! o, ay I
opy a )ll l{ pa' ot{ peaBJra oo B e.
p o T e T. yp oea oa xptit l
o' B yoB' ''yooo oMoP' ' , r itl lto y1aa., o Be Mo' oap ' 'py oa' ' . o >eeto yepx(ee eeo eo4Po,l|to, poeoPo I ooo oa ' 'ee ' ' , yrep).e' o , ey a' e opelte o eoPoeo oae Xpo. o po lp l iB pex' o 9 oyx. pale o op ort-eo yBBiUI P .o oel ooeo y]a-tlB y oo oPo PN,l oUt
aoto poa epal.Pre eo ytlBiUI eopae petp: oe
o l oa tlIe , oI e otlfly, ex yoT ) yIIe' e o }l peoo .a oy. oa e yl ol ii oIe ee (o.Ttp, oot{t xoe, oe oJIt lt PeoJlTo opau) ' ee I peo.a y, o o.y e x e cyo eoeeo.
o eopaleo pepe oB, , oo.oeKa: o pyx e o)o oeo epe.o o opoBe y l{e; y}Ioy pyy paBaoo, oooe 3Ilt ie; pte )' oeI, .. )I oeprueo py'
l leooo Py oIlt l' o ] ppt paJ]
ap JIIlB ool]|oo l)PIB o-eBo, o a eI ptr ylt, eI'o yaoBellooo yepcaoo oula' opotu pMepo oy Be Ao Beoo, I lIloe l ^ Be: o )(t{e, I e e pelpI, oopIeAo oeeo yaB ey oo oBo; rtoI Blvt ael ollopeeo yy o pal{oo B oa, o o o , Ao P o le, ' ' ( oKo oll' o ye ooe) oaa eto, oa' ' ' ]o ooey Tolt l .ey oeee N,roa: ' 'oa _ o' o oe o e ! ltt o ' ' . T opao, pt{Ie opt poeIp) e oe-o Po oal]' o oPe o t loBo'o Io plo eoee operu po'
MI ye IJoo N' l,to pot{ o., ooy o are o BI y) oo oIr Be oJ]yrox llPoye o)}io . He.oP'I Mlioo aoe, poxlUx 3 pxy]]' o ox tlaIB o oeo a KypIIIoBeo ., ]x TpyIyp e'
Tep l ocpaeM oP' o I o ePax,oceo Pa oo ooto )t|' oPeeeea ytt' pyl ey o' T yo IIo-o, olloeo yyPo . o o' 01-] oo eT' oo eoo Peoflao TpaEyr|I (VI e) ' o BPe ooo o.poe (I )' Ul or }Gl,l olltoi, oBe-l. a coo o.i e. Hrrree pBo, eaPoo rrpoo op, apye KyypI' oe-e yoHo ) _ e H oop oo o. oe. lll' o e tlIe Nt or e o.o a o)tfiey ltH; ll oo ooy' o ora ye, 1o py e po' o ooNry' o t ' Py ry. a r Pot{oooo, op a ooPy oTBo oo oPoT.
oarp, pHre opo oP MPo yTpo.tlo' o Ee oo ooo o, o T o!e epla }|yPt oil ro|, oPey yxoa yTyp o e) . B o pe' oorrt 't a tloli otioe' Prrte ''o etlTIp'' ilo o1 l o u1y o p-oo. Poao' o oa|P' o poyP oe, 1tllt PMe lloBT oPo }lo.ool oo To llPor oe' N,{o B oaIpap Be o fl llo yrx oBo 'JIeP...
B o oee eoIo yorto l ,rool e err' ottlP' yrrl l eerloti'a ' 'y oeIHoo y}l'' oTlt eN4' B o.oo ytl e oo' tloB' y pooaloo, oor o ] ol yp
' 'ooo o-
ea''. yoHo, oooe llpBl] K.o ep po.
o oyee Booo la; o e ) aKa.''' y oleB Poa}lI oo y''oo'', Pey Jr o)eo poJroo.oKa )(, opttM tloBI ' l lt.I epT y ' 'oo'' o ttll lo oeoM, ooppae opea ToBy.
o oo, ottl po po1oo rro opa-o pop. T, pp, B vI[I eK o opo po pru oo o p aole y
lto yee yP l,I oto e aoo'
l 0 1 l
otloB pB oo eria; oel l.[lpo.ao ''Pa aoo't _ o poo lloelle' le eo yI p ' 'prr oo a''.
H poe oe poollo pae oll-o l{ tl o' oe opao oatP B ot{e tl o pa oo a eooo o, o eo otIP ee l\,too tt. ottIP' afl o' rt PTo Ioeeo 1o oBe, oa oopoo o oo1oa, o oee , otlo BIP' ' 'oI'' ootloltlt{ o ''aool,t'', ao o p o apo.' oopo Te BPll: '',o o1 u Jvt| pu, oo|| 0ut1, _ nod Tpo: odu o, dp1'u ptac, pu,o' pdT' Bc coccT !\||T u cTpada o pde.u CllJ|e odu o!\| da||u oTJ|bI: a*'dt' o oupd, oe?q o|u To',.
Too o tttlo e oa e pepoBa -o y4a Ilaee o!eo To o' Ha-oopo. a)' a o a eooo o.eo, otiIp, o:]BtIJ o oo po o' tlMot l Io o ol.. oee oo. a eo o. e oeJI olp, o e eey e PtBI yotloy poy)e, o]lte otllP tl potlo. oo o e B Molttp oBo, B opa.a oopoo o PMJI ye, pea eo oaIo, otll ]o oo aae oea yyaeo oo, yreil ey MeI{y oo op' Topo ae po o lI e.
' 'popa opa'', a l , ptlo
o PBIe ot. oopetlo yB poe o.' ':oo lt oBa. Pa oPoa; oI lUoI, yePeI pa ee a)(yy o.oe' B o o ooo poe.K .[ popro B oee )y po oBPoee;otloPello, aoaP yye y ooe, apB |opoB |'. B )o. oe o ye o.-]to oJleotlo' oaIe' oo IJoo' poreeTo oUleo oaeI o preyeo. .[yote yt
rroBoo oec oKaa oepo lII o PaH rry.
pyeo oei I op tl )e oPr-
ooo ttl{ Pyo rvI lpyoe e.
r , o e p Ile o oI o
oo ,r. ooo Ao, o ey,
aoee .xiIefl I PeEe Peleyloo lleoa'
oPet{ tIyx' pe ooplx ooeo BIe''MaIe
pa' ' ' 'pooeye p' ' , ePBl{y ooe.
. I pacop op oo epo o opoHo. e
oe To eo o oxo a ]o peByeo II.
po: o e Boo xo, B o.o al
co oPoI poo PP. ot{o ooy iro ppoP-
t loy' pt{ ! poopaIe opl. BoHa
orrrI e. eallt ' oBop o' ,'o.''.
o ol pe o p a' py aI-l B p'
pTIi )' opl Ia P, l ypell.
o'o oo poopar Bex x olo eo
oy' o epl p Be Coop (t2l5 ') .t
oeIlll ap yy]eNr oae oIx oae
yoB. oop P'Jl ooa ye llM yl lt.
}roBle, Pyo oae oy.o yopo}I
opl, l oepe'o pa BeoBilJI o PoTe. t .
l l o oP! I, e oMe, P A.
p pl oye o optooo oa !t
ae apa sotr Pa - yea pKaT t lt l.
o o )t( y)t
o opo trpo o pxo pyoo P' oo-PI I eP aeM Peao. Pe or pePl\' oal\{ opeo oBI poI, ooo.a BIBtl lloBlx yoBtII y); tloIl yBIy oBoe otl}l, ooro po pe' ero oooo' oo e oo op}t' yoeopl '
J]eo, TPe rrrpo o)eo )eo )i
Pa, oopoe oBa oy aoaPoeorilioy TePBy tllil!' Ivlollo' pPo ee or oorllolt (p e oo o). o.oo oPo o ooBl otl' oo e ea ya BHIe o.. ooyeoa oBo tl o IJlo Pe opeo po oee _ Po, , U.l
ooe, o P lll o eeo, o oMooeoI, o Ho' oToPo Mox oaxH .a Tao opoo ooae. oy e Pao o.o' oP li eoopI ple ertl,l' otloIoI pol,l T Bo oBtltio x Parr'ooPle tloliIlc ''ea'' o o. o, ooopotlI, oocoo ot{eo oe, pyo, _ llo e oylo oo, o, aB Bo oerilio oeoT, o)le PI{Byp pyy e }ty PoT.
paorr oo BU.EI pN{el opaae PaI-{.e e)y po orrrueo xIl' Tao oeer' ro oe Boe _ o' e otlot o.ll t{ o llle pI o)lll r t tpaa,ltoT e ee oyI' K oPo, p o.Bltllo x JI eprero. o o .TByr oa ypeo oBpeMeI oo. C Pyo o.potlI - oloy BeyT a.o o. ^[| H ootto a otl|loer ooo oo >tl PeB o pep?
pee ue oy oo BoIIo, oti I BoPoo. MI , o pot ex po BoarroBI oPI Poo rrleo lo,t. Ho uo npoo y) yryr.,r opa oaro -t? ypl ,r-err o |4u |,|Hoi1 o aPaa ' 4eIIeIl Be oo oeT TPe ooB.
Bo.pIx, Pir,l 'e o}to, ool ePiltlI, op ''o''. Peopaopr, ' xo .oP Heo oe >to,t y oo l{ oo oll.eoo oE' Pxo. eooo Py o).Eeo iEylo peo' ooo e oT Bxope aoe, oopl ?lo.oay oil e, ypo-
yytl'IT . Bo o y ooI popMI, }te oBpe pouo, otloBoooo aPM, yl. oI yer o' ootlo oPT ooProe BetIM a oo poa: ooae aaII e Co oatp Hooo (ep). PeTa
PeoPM, port xvl Be o ePeo, ye)qle
MTro uuo yo e paroo opa.Bo.Bopl, r yPIe aoy x Ie oae.
e oe, ooPI e a o yoy ea.y proy eoxoo ooo. .'eo, a-tl' oopI otl op o opor ''popToPo''' _ oxootttt' PNrp' peo po o ePp'
''o.
xo B epo'', _ aaJl ePePtt o op x
To, ollo' oe y ptl' caoI tt ypopl.
, oe, .TPttl oltlloe o ox oe.
co apIe eo o oo, r o PoP}t.poI lt , _ oee oo opee oe lt{eco [p,o ''tto'', ' e oop, ''eartpo''. aa, ooa Poo eoI Pp' oopr oe oPoHrl Pe a e, aP o' '' x oe''(pep, o oe _ e' o Poo oepaey .Tey H' y oBPlleee?) poe oo, PePa'''' eaeIo oJI o,Bey tl H o. y. cr pH lto oo oroltl,ty' pl{yl e r,i Pea ,r oy.e. aolt o oe a){lI. oHo, e ?loya ee l{, oT I, e e, o' otllto e'
to l,ll erl, oopI Pa a)o oo
lty Bo I ap' .
ilo e oeo o{. op ox oMy rvllloeBo pePo.
Htu oop IoP p oloreo l p]\,toeT oa eooI lIIo t. yoo' ooop oo e ttoo yote. e e o' o.oy'
oe oo Poe ooo B aa oPo: oI ll o 9x eex oo ) o.Bpl o I' o e pooT ay x,l? o
oT o)l(y ) yye? opoy p-
ooBal oT a opoI.
t 6 1 1
l' ae eottl' To o!|)!l )ti oPe)lBaT po' l{EIr o, oy, tl oo a,4oT li:loHl Te' o oTopI ye oBopo Il.Coao' tl'oTollo oo a-o B Iy, aoopr y .a Hoxootl ooBp (aopeo)
oBIllly ' oy, ro l o1^4 oo.BoB r,LI pypoTBo pyyp' B oopr palollo''yuopy'' oBlIGla )
olIB)ltTBo
y PTAII
MAtI
pry o paoe, eooN'lo lte oo oll pee
}lIl leo o' t lo ottoBptl}lo oI T ap.
opoo rr o eort olI lal oopo oorro opa.
tto l o l l
tloey oll it lo}lo oe (oo Jl .
o) opa )+irl. s j lotlol}JleI oo . ooP
pBlIu ]l|l o}.e o1oPo 'Li l l
It|) I leoo]lI lI]lolt opy1lo neae
oaoo l l]poo' rul l()to. l loI oa I p3|tople
elIl o P3rlooP lI l)()lei lt K PIloo Ilot l l lM
]o JI, la pJlIl|n ooo Pl Ili l oPa ).
paoo ol.Io )lo JI, a, a o1.o 10,
ol ytl, o'P) JI 'JI -JooPle Bll ool
l. B'lU]e oIlol llN| J]||\tL' oIlJtj l( '(o )tl
oore. oulBo o'(I lo PaNlIp oo 3 o.
e eo oe' lo l le)t|o BoIla] 'y .
po: ootl oe]o ool l loj|o)tt p.
o pl, i oroa al| ]o pol |.P l:
l. PI opt oaruo )tt ltl lo pe'
] ' o l t oo l l o| f t l H(o ) I l
3' lepoe MotIIlJlo pTIt Bpa.
PALll oPMl ottACo )ltB t|PAtlolvl P
l [luuoptit B Jl poo Iopeo o o aop3Bo Ta y t{oo' t ae. o o Pt). ItJ ooe ao
:to A B IleDo oJloBti l l loo a o P' ' ' ot e
o ooo opoa ' Peea y , opo poorr.T o oo orrry, oop uI oopeerro Peoo oeo. [ op Io yo ey eo.o o)eo aoP o PeoPao oTo.o yu o}GI l opy oP)Io oPoeTerra opooM' .IPEa |,I1 _ a e)eo yBo.op o o xpapo oe ae.e yflel\,l; ol!t Poao poott ltol,t, r or ol{ o,ltl B oelo )'a oPoHoBeIl l, oBll o; o epel otl ,r oo rPyoy oy aoey'
flo e o' r eooPle poTopeo JI aop. pepo y x oolll otl pa Ht{: o at t ea-pt{a' Pye oy yopr , pue,r o B y' To peeo By.e epeoo '(Boltloo orr poeeeoe o'(elM a' ooy o o peMa}ro Ut I poe a Pt|o )epyo tt, a opoM' oiljl oo oT oorr oPo. Hpo, opee eeooo o' o at pe optl oeoll' ol, y yp o l. peo.po e.
B o e pe opet IPo o ,'opoo
o'', oB oe aeex PIxa ye Myl, ae PotIoM. oo ov.a oooo otr t oo ott' o, e'' e o'' ' 'e e apotl Pol{ooo)o'', o eo (rttou oo' ooy o o oe ''tttl'') po"") oo' ol pa a, ' ' y .op aJl o' o o o oc|loR coli -|' o]0|-Ieoo a, B oopo yoe o3ae o ltoeo oo ol!'ea ooB :]re, 4ea |1 p)1-oi' p ]o e l lI | l|pa| ' o rlo.ol oae o ytt ooBpeeo oeooey,efly oepooy'' ( . aefly. [Ipp. ) '
2 l
2. cL't' B a oao oao e ptto r
Boao fy. BIp ' 'B ae oe '' '
Plaeo (uo e oo) oy popoy' po
opae eo oPooaoo yy}l yy .
oo po. p.C y . e y epr e )Pr eI'
)yl B yee py' oypy ll o.e MoJt' tto B oilo otl o o(uc,) , o6Iatt To ooee or (ua) , py.
o (ucol1.) . Xoh oro o e (2), ooplepeo''try oey'' PEo (paab). o.o}lo opo opo oPy)e ye. I x .
o opa _ ooeo fl oooo Tel{ oJlT (upd .l dup)' t p tl 1)e oItt' Dt lH'
Jl y PpI P o eo ye}r. ' '.,a e' oo, poy yI oe.tl .}l Too eooto'' - }lel o
yx o:t. B o yoT
o .'o'' ott y'
p . o epBl olt tpytl ,r'yT or
paca (1,p, ' o _ puo\, KooP opot
Ha l].l3 . ooe t{ epN,ltt 1lu - ',opora,
y'' l e o oo o oD ypoo oo ,
ooBaoe a JrttI pa' oe| o oo.
a' oe pa e:lo Bo yee 1o' oxo)-
yl oy. Ptuy po ottlt}ie oPa
p p 9epo o' ttl ooo popo
l tloee oPlo t, oe PtlU l,
tpo aor' oe e Ba ott o p o-
ulel _ a oPao o eI e ' 'Peao''.
eP oye1B o y yey' Ptt ooe
ry Iti oPttl poM llprto: oy (n'.pd) o r Too o}lo [loB}ioBa yTe' o
olBT eMy Bo l )e !.
o PT o ptlo' Py 'o o-
I. o o ao ep' oeo Po oIPx'till\4l Map au' aa Booe . or.
o' a' Poo)o o ey oley)}t' }lo PeyPo opao o Pyo'oN!
' 'yee''
ePx pB' o M. I1eoope u azl oo Po o oPN,r: ott yPJle.fl| Pa_raBI opoM. rt ep A, tr ''.
' ' poe op aTI pPl lop Jl JIoelx oooB. Tx tlt PouT'|, )K|IeMll u-a (oca oo ,'py''). lla pr*,r 1peBaHL'| R uI'ott ol oB ) e' Ho alr. voB I | |4 . Cp e poo o ' 'ee
otp' ' .
o e o t o . oB y K | l p .ol a MoaK yo B eTo1 oI'e la opotl otttt o PB: opt 6lal PooPal . epo (l500 _l600 o P. .) yeo otll' lU B ea>' |tl l l{I-npaa), u acKe-I| (pJ\aa/, P ('lqpuPa\ .Bye (u) | c| aI ) ' 'oDtlt' '
(cu), ol{ nol io ootle}to u.o.*u,,,.o .,,M,, lo o Poto Peo]oo r. leIB.
C t.A rrJp t (aulp,tt _ oo, otlre t) ' '. ' ') To e. oe y/] 'alr o IlJtIl.tII yo, Pooe|e ao Jlye ' ye -x oe.aopl oT ooo' o ,royr p oo e, o o}|t o1 eoype. poe tl.tt ltep e, eo e B' )DoDtloLjJ TyI ooe, oe}| peT
".,,."" " ,"y,
ypoI aT op ll (n:) , oo o . oPeeyo o NrP' }l Pl , o BDoa pOo oe.
o p e a. oprr,r (Mu) 'aoopo' optae oo: y yr e f l po o ela oo o. Bo oey o ol ptle .o e ( ooc ooy.\lp r ' ') 'epvl My, e oottt loo po' t l e eo. pol JI o.1, o pBy, ptu ry e e)l.eo e oer oeo tlTptt o ' ' ' ' (l l l t\ '
Pe oe eP rre o ye oHltoo ( te, }lo 3aae), otl|le - ooe l lo oI oto, o ooe ' ' ' '
.eT e o'I oo elioT! eoeo' '' ' , oopo e p.
' 'oe, l o) lP ott o ao'
oopoo po yeBa, oToPolvr o )y'
Po, oopoe o opI, ypl o
e p' ' . eo Ie aoo Pe .
oHt l eP oTo y otrri.
o' olry o epe y pert
ar: '' et (o) Ri,Rw1 le (r),
l Bl lt y' p1 lBe e r.
Pe ! ' '
M o t p . truotlt loo o, o o-
ea }I o ptla op o, oex o-
tt't, o otP (opajn) B oBpeeo Ie o
e ol\4ltI paPo. ' o t lxol e-
p olJe po pe pBp, otlIp P.
Jt oo, ootio' rreoe or' e e p.
ol Koo oN'r Peoao 2p'1o eT aaB-
y' o IM ootlt lI y. B oee Beo
eI oalp Ct, Aypo.o, P ap,
Aa) oirlp ope Pprut'
Pa otl o.l l)tl xolT a u{'
y JI)I, K ytl o' 1 y tpoto oa.
, oaT pJIIM; oIl ] loJttl t lo o ea
IrP B oo oxat opo y otr o o.
y o'y r parra' l o lott otlo .
o rpo ol' 3 Itpyle p tlateI
'o o> oa 1 oot ooi P'rj
)Bl le, | pti' oPT o opo'
JI oo, po epo' oy o
Bopoettl oeo: poBee yxa' oy] ypy'
peo' o01t{oI oPrre o o t{.
oo o ooP|e ps pa ' 'opt]I' ' _
y oo.l l loB yI oee Po, y ryl, loB.
Po rypy PIao )t(! l: o oyT yeo, o
o Bel aM' 1 ooBI x' oye o:
oJl o Ix, ool al oa (aa),
ootl el (dp), e (caadu) ' o pyoo.
oo aoo y!{ otlt loT oBo.
pe oo pt (pp apt.. ' ,o te, Coe,
Lo, p' ') .
o B e a . a I ) -riI yol yPe. o o a ooa rta PaBHIo o po, Py )y op.}lM' tt a oo' o f,o oP e'C ppopa opra olll . oooe . y ooeeHo eiry' oIoPI P a otlx'Te, o y y '''' (au-apzo), P ot|y3 oPa oEe' PItTl o oBolviipHo y pe, p'i)tl cyIl'poBl Py, opa o Pe a)e oeo.o. oy oPI a)e p Pyx y: y oa( aa.apa), y oapeo eeoT (ap.pa\,yT llyeto oo Qdlo.o'1 . IIlo Motlxoe ttoo a y ooPtlo Boy ap.epy '
IIpyoa a poI ooy oaM o. e oo' t|o y' o o tl peoye'ooo p' B xpaoIx ya yyoPerroI oeeo PPo oy le Po HoH.yaI (tuo p).
y "
o o l o . yI , t oe yo_ P oIe: yoe oo eo o-ro otll (ca\. ottoooooe yv yt' pa-otlo oeoe ''Ipe B x'] Peae ' o.e e eoP p Pl{ oeo' oopIe oeIolt o.aToaey oo otlx.
o o I o tl lU e o y x o tlolt. y e Berr (oc lttt u'1 o paal (da\,oopoe r-{ ooB oeoo yeo. ee -y loo paa oro I oo oal Ilo e eo.IoIo l,l yotlo eo yyo o [pe' oopoo ro: oeo ylo eI Bo lHeooao oll Deo e.UIx P eo' ootllx Py (da), aoopl e o yo{oo ootloo. y opv. oP yoe oo r o lo '''' _ a ayo' B poo' op ToM eILo 06 aaT-a (opv|p|e oTlnaa) 6 p,t oo pooojlooItiyy.
T opo, y.u' l y e o, oI oo.}l' o e yye oo '''' , oo' e oaa.
25
2] eJl. rr o looPoo Pa oo.
eo ' ' ' ' y oe eae' o oooe o 4P,'6,
peooae (caapa); o ojle opoT! oll
oc7|1t I7paI'
Il p e oTolt! o ooPo tlo e
o3l{tlo, o ot{ ee el, oyo.
tll illto, ool I PtlJIei o e' o
pe epe, oo ope Ho' PIltpa Po eoyotly, oparryl oo.
po ou ttyaIe P-
: ''yecyI o e poeo' Po'
otl}to, opooe' l e o oo He P.oo, f le pltool H oaoo' oPoBoo,
t{xo oo pox(oo' ptlI{eHoo, ottoo, o.
otllloo pa ] t BoMo)e. Ho a yy
To tI poeoe' e pI{eHo' e otltlo, opo.
oel o Boollo Ioo rlrPa 1oo, o po.
o' peo' otlo, ooo' ' ' yoe ae-
l{ r o', ol oT Aoa' tlo
oBoot 01 P ' eoeo' o oo :
ot oe y e epct|o e e otly.'pao' ' .
M o tI || N| |1p ' ellot o a oll ' 'p-
Bao' ' eoye pl{. tlt|I e, o.
eoat, oeer ol,lec oao'
B, ,to o oyT' _ o llol{M yI yyIT cBo apn4
a opo a o otlo oy yeo.
Bai. y opsaT t{oe T oEor oe
y.,'oo Koa rl ol{ po ooI ol
oi. T ox oT p orfl{o Pop.
Tt{ y: o ollx oPe yPeE oae' o
oUre otl rre op, M oP oIlll p .
peo y ae t-t aoP, a K oaxo o..
MllT yy y. B o oeP, oax o}lPooeoa p ''opt ao'' I JI l{ I p.
MPo yoo . T opo, yM oo .}l ypo: ' P PoPeTe Pa y MoIt.
xo _ oo yxorio IlPtltto.
Cy , o ye oHx lt BIoT
eli' Ta a yre ll{e e;
ooMy P,'oe'', yopel 060a. peo err ot,z (Molo) ' oeBe rte. To ooT oy ''o''
(oo ot, peeao opTy B oo) y olr o tIPe etlo, o eooee ee '')e''' Ho rro a, 1o ol}t.e y pa oli a e pe. lto o' top roy oPaytl' ypo poPl Px}ll lo.oo: ooy x pr oPe pao.ol PyaIx opo (pa.x lto o po).
D . D . | | o o l t { o ' y a o ylee ''Cper y'', 1o Pltl,l ep epl y. eao otlo (' !lo, o )e a opoo oMop' o o PPIx opo PyBIxyepe o Pax:{ ulpJ\|a ' Booe e poo oP B o PaI' r-i o oo poa oPoo. o l oM ltoo M.
povao o I payu1ti le.Bl' oy oB eP|'1 u (xy re t), o o opo o a o a e'T MolPx. Bave l o otpp oo Poo t|oo tl, e Mo po.o oo Po o. oto oflIp Po.ol pyI aerx yll opelro.. Ho oopI o}l Peoaro ea' ortl.|,4'|)( |1| y oe yPoy ope.y. opa i}l oo e' ooy Moe ' 'tll' '
ox Poo1 oIu,ltlo to eoo e l,l e.
yrr Mott e a oTo: ooy oH ]\4oyTepy o . oo l4l{o oIoT ox tl !1ll' B eool x o ppotlo BpeHtlooarBo. B Tae e yeye ottl oo'o|o oooy oOo ae o po ' 'oe
'', pe o a o , o eox e oo ' o ola ooy eo PPop.tltl ya y Pe eo ae'
21
o otlI o oo oype. oo B eoo.pl ottx x oa oT oll otloy op ,6 poly.
o' oo Pori' T oltx eI''aI oyo'' oy xeT' tlo yI Pooe op.ye' Ta a pe rre 1 o olI l\,toa. B .ro, R cKaX pl|||-,|-na' a--na h .pd.nooxo ilo; eoopl o:ltll paox. ooeo Ce Poe J]pr, Po Po oopol rtol oxo ooe tll\/l Tx eTo oaly oly.
y oPy' To o}ta oe eo ae'll. B oeo e' oo eP l{I o}l o'
' 'oo ootlo oo Pexoo pa'' (BoPo B-
a oop' ,Ilapu o oHoe ep llxptt
o).
PAo ot{AlBo PTAttA BPA
o e t l t. pa, pM, oP )
Pax ollxo oaxo ylr' o Pe B
po o ]eI' ex y Py He
opee opa opaoo t, yo.
tro oPreoa. Bllo' oPeo tl otll
]ofo opjel{oafl otloI x .tl: , o.
tIHo oI, oplHllo eal,lMo 'py o Py orII
P Pl] o,ll{ol opa er e o|.
B o, oopl ePeoH yx Moao yllllo
o y B eo rr1oalpe.
P a . e er o ra yoBo y xpa f l
PaB aPa' ao e e oa P!].
o epo: PNiP, naee oHMaJ|o oepItto e' B -
y pe e o po o uo: o
y}lo _ oyeIe oettt ioo l l eo: B .
o o y eoe paaPaI o o)Bllo
Aoto, o oy o' B e
ae pJl Poeo H o p ( N,t.
oooeol\4, oMeo) ' BP Boo.
I{o o3tto oP' o Jle oo oHt PyJloo Po. oo opor, o ey rryoM y.
Mo eollt lHo BJ|e TPI\4Il pal u oele
I oe l lotl tt, yo _ oye
op pyoo aooo, eo oe l t lx
olt{ e)y oeo aooo }to
oo. ooMl a }lo.
o'o oo opeo t{etto tl
HpHx oltao Pyfltlo' a x t|oB.
ao lo1 a PM y' ooPoe o oBey a ooe oopao oPe o ot yoly. 3e oaT Bopo o oeo pTp _
o D ]. y epa o ol Moy o .
opr otltll M ol' p, o1B.l o oI ool{t oro.
l' ooJly o oyoBer av pooo oP' eoI oo. oo opo.
B o p o I P e l l J I ' p e o y e r t epltIx 1o otll,Ua oo e ao' tlo ye Mollo oa., o Pe , opo' y)Bx ooo yye.ttoo oBll.
pr e ltPoootl otlre. B o.IBa' o o Belue oe yoo l{po Pax px oo aeIe oe. B op o oP y1Pe pooe oay
Bo poa, ooPy ott pea ee,tl tlpooo-' o a o oPo a l' o eoePpooe o.ooy opay . o o a)e o' o e N,tota fl Me oe}l tlypeHooe :te: o poe arpooo oeo' P e o oM, o Jlo e oPpoa o B.tl otUo .
Bopo opo ooT PPo. eoto ol' ooBo po Be ooltole e)y oofla otle o. Bo a B opo y pe:
' 'o , o pe pe, eoopl y ll- C _ oyr-Teoe oPTBo Bypeeo ea. _ pe o y oa, oyeeoyep peee otl Hr ? tTT,o aoo}|tl eeo por oooa, o o p? oaoo e oa 1 TpeM(aoolr oooe) ool o eBr.l{y oor o Ao? oy lt or o _ ao-ollll ooo - oeo PT o otoo? ) yy oaoT, 1o a e ae.yU] ae Pep},IT peB yT o-HtI opuo Cae? e oe o o oo e, I oa oo eppl oeo yul, oopo o. py19;,6o,.. , orta o ee?''
ru o p oo a I y'M oT o1 T oIIPo.I! Ml oe oo pe o}lT Me ype oo paHx p, a oHxo.Pr'
3 l
M p o l t I ] t o I { a u I e L I I ' a o , .
tto' o T poj IBal l ye ott ottt.
a' e oe papB o p To eoPeU:
oaIeo ' Pee efo' a op )]t|, KoIopo epo-
ey Po pa ]lI oIT' Bo oy Jl,l}l ooll.
r o e' xp palt oaaM'
pe tllopoB o ye a Ap Co Mo (oopl BIl ot ,rrroa) To Mpoa (o oa y.u,-, B oodeoT l!'oa4 yu Jle), x or tByr ' 'orlo oa lPo B]o.ool'' (A), op eeoo oPea epe.
Po B o ap' 3a Oa eopaa oPoB oollyo e ypeIIeBootll\{a e)i(y xpa epo' T, ye oo otrPl oe (e-ap 1968) ope (op 1973), p .pex (CA, |911\ oee (e, -p la77) ' l A' txo oM pauyo la B p fo' a eaeyroopau o Tx Moaulx )peoI Bpea'
Dit innl d spiI i tul i t, tom l0, art i l r ' .o nahm' ' , o l l525. l56' ' 'L h.
nomn monast iqu ds ls L ig ions non hr6t ienne.. (P iere Massin o.s B ) oight Beuhs' Pa is , 1980 L 'rt i l ' 'onhlsm' ' fa i t l 'ojt d 'u dit ion en
I ivr, sous l t i t lc ' 'Le onhisnre isto iJ t spir i tuaI i t ' ' , (D.s 9) '
.IIxoBIII To
APTI M OHAITBA
M
Heoo>o,aI Pooe ope,eJle }lo1 MollteKo
r, ooy t peJlae l op l.' p-
eri o ' 'pe' ' , a' ' ' ,U''.. oo-
pI oxo oa epI eo' x o,t ,-eIa . ayufl Ily oe oo yrpeeo eaJI.
ooP I o ( l P oJ l o Boe ) '
l ' ooee py
lte ' 'o a po' ' lo y)e aMoM tt
ao)o a Po oo ool oao' o
o )eae e o o Blpaao e pl\4e}la, 'Pa oua (po) Bo I oyl l l{I o M. )t(
o Nlep' o NleP t l p ( 2,8) ' voI oe p
Boplt a oT o eo B ep' lt t
oooaeM aoP PIeB pa' o I ao
|!uu u' ' lp Ho _ aerr' ' (Aro' a
5 '4-45)
B oo opee Ao ap ep a p-
. opo o ya o o1o, oopre ' 'po B oe-
]ioa oooM'', o epy-trt P}ia, oop|e' 'poa Bo yeTo B|Pl|erll : lc oolt t lol]! '
oooB' ' . ' 'o o oLte ltcl]o. l l lNl ao L,ate'
o yIlt l o oo, optL'tI! lI ]"i o|aoy: ' ' e
r oeper, o pol l|\tl l l t |oe pa t-.-
ey o'' ( l9'2l) ' o. yMaB o o. o oa.
e o I poy)erro oo o ylaIe oa oo.
tl lto ey' ' Ao Poa Boe opo }q-re oe.
o e' ' (e Ao 2).
2
Ilo,r, aB Bo yttoB, oop M o eo.o1lo ' ',t opv o oo ya o M oJro eM, oop pa o.N4y ope' o o pa'' (poe >eoo xo.24) '
' 'Boa, x e o p, otl Boll o]I e a . y pa MPe' K po, oopt pll,'tea opy'. (ApT' y' o 345 . ee oe oo 1)
'' ay Prue tuo Ce llcca Xpa pa o o' o}l poo o ooTBl{ ye . oxoo' poox y )}l Bo opyooe tuy oy e'' (op oo r 4.5) .
2. Ho o epoPTl{atrco ort
t e, o lloil y Ao Boo, , o I opey eoo Aya oUIHoMyea oBe ooy oloo oPaa '{' oePyilo orrr (.t[ 2.44.451 4.2-4) ' tlo B aoo a, Ptie y ool epI (l-2).
oa a (P) aK)e opa o.oKo Poxoxttfl ol,eo ):' 'oJl. )l( Po o pMea oloo poo.''.'}o{ AoTooB'' oae llo aoo PoriH' oopy poo' }looIe epye'
o p aooo y o py yoyoo oax(e' Te e, oM oPo ao-ox Pe o oxp oPeo o oep[teB pex p}l' yJr B yI'oe opy opooB' ylttI MTx' olt a 1.Hl opo o P' ooIe' oll l o.lt, r yIltoel ooa eo e ep'oeeo, ee ' o opoa py,oo ooIa 01 oitlx epyr. . oo o oop)loiBa or pa eP) B opoe o Poe-e, Por Booe o )}l Pa o, a IuIJ9|, Lro!\|u' l||toou (o pe. ''oo'' ''o'') .o o ll B ooe! e e. ,r opoat
,r ol TtUI tlI u||ou (o oe. ''o.o'' _ ' 'oee'') ' o oruee .,t e oIle I, ooIe , oMeo oo'' (oe l8, 5) '
3. yoo yeo oooBa oe.e1y
pro ptae o yrio| B pe oa ( l0'38: l6'24). o o eyi e o. (oo|lo peIte oo p. _ p' pe.) Coeo,oll y PI' (o Toy' ooe a e68; eo.aP e. PooB 49).
oto e ooo yeeBy' ' 'o Pee p.e po tlo o ax' opa opy Tpeeyeo. epe ottaruo oll oy ofloee o )''(o. poe e l) '
'. e y Jl o o oeTe l! ptl.MBl]Je Il eIe' a yxoIe pa' p po,t{o tl , o o, oel o o Io[lYol,ty oy eoyp?'' (Meo. p 7, 3).
' 'ao oop p : oe? Itloo a yo? y uo oB' yl\lp pex. yepB eIe yl ro, e Boe o.tl _ I e yllo'' (Ao, ple.a Aa Beoy' B .: ' 'pee oo _ y.Io'' ' t loI op}r, No 600) '
''Iooo y!{! poBlljllt oo . B Toe P e, o}IaJ{' tlllo t{ollo Botlo.le oBl oo, y )e oy' o ye., o Mot{a y yue'' (epo' ooet{ o}t l l5)' epo pMape1 4otlaurey tlKa Jrdeo t|ucTo. (oe 3, 5; l08' 3I)...p
e yoy ptto o|'I tt )l(' ep ore o o o) tl Pa y }lo )totI y..' (o (P). o l8' 7).
Moa Pp oP' ooo MeP o}Iey. Aa BeyPer. o Ao B o oy oto, oopt oop o e: ' ' x e y''.,,(l o l5'l l . Ao Beoo. aoeAaM Be, l9 ' 89 , 9 l ) '
35
y yr ooBoa, I oe' ae.o
ollt{r otloN4e oa. Booe oop, eo
yIll }re ro eo o yeT. oo e o ol.
o y oa aoI, oByro p,]' oM
MyeeBa' o epo e1 ae aoo po ooe.
o aa ytrr, y ac P - ooTr}lo Ao.
' Hopo, Aaa Be oae Parre Ao
o BP oe eto Ipe oel{Ty: ' 'To Ma.
ti lti oe poTB I.[p. tx ot{o or
Aep. Ao, oy o Mo!tT|p' oPoo)|( x'
o oop: IIo N'l opoTc, a poy' oP
ox . ' . o rt yeTa oPjr o o' o e o
a Beoa'' ()e Ao) '
4. opa a
po e )t,l tlyle' otllo epoa,t.
l olur tlaM' eT' pe eo, op eaM
l]B.I]'ee aao, ..BooM, at Bpo
po oecoo' a op e o otlIe (.
yTIttlto)T,Ie' oorto p a P oye 1
Ao Boo' tt}i lto r Aae' ( o,
)tt A}lol{ oJIy) oaoM ylo)ee) '
To (e I aoll ' oeI t potlo'
oo , poo ol,etl' l t.t t.r
'.ptt opt oolt lo y| looJIlo orty tt eJI.o o pe oPaI lo o pl ! lM pa
AttIl o p|1po]\e oJpl't Oll '.
tl oo}lop r J Ie o eoo ' ' (N , l l 8 . |0 ) '
AeI _ . 'Jtulu ( 6' l .3) ' 'otra poo oaJI-y) l l! l loloy o o ]Iy'(ert' ' (o lI Booo l l l o oa r r l e TBo ' 'po ' . ' ' 33 , l 960 . rP .445 ) ,
AI|eJI| Lood () |)?() crl('|!(,?() pa.Ia oir op'IBo ]I coyp
. 'yooJIlo eJ|. OB1.
l l laB [io. Bop.' (Jl ]0'6)
l 7
Aer _ nobl Tuu (Bap '33.35)' y yreeoPrlrea ePaP ([leBo..[I.ol APeo. o eopapx) .
Mo, Pootl ay , ylooeaM Too yoo' tlo' B Ko|!l. le' A ' 'o'' ' 'e opreo opa'', ' ' too 1l' o Il o e yToa pee.'(op ooB 2).
'',roe e att,lo 'e, etl (H' opeo oy e epl H yoBtlIM a,o'' (B B.. Tooae o 1' l)' ',o a eo e,o e opaoM ooo o )tl a e ) yx' a otl pjy eeBel pI e().ueo pot' o }tl o oe ppo e e l Pae , oP Poy oBoo a, o e oJl- o Too oeP pa ao.o po por' ' (Ba.ll B' Ae pooe) ' ' 'orrx epe 'lrlyMoy oae paB afle'' (ap oo oe l l) '
' 'H pe ]lt t{ e[Ie o)l (orraxo). oulao e yro eo }t op ., oeret yoto'' (o oy'Boe peal oa, oa 8' 4)
' 'oooe a oeoo. Jl' yl ,l.tloo oB lu ao o]loB (). o.aflfla't oa oypeEli or'' (o Apo.. o 62)
' 'oaruea >ttl yooe ]l fe' o P. oeI oy; a oa o py lt''(o epa o eoxoo llJl lt o lo(tlooaa 17' 54) '
, 'ooEo ooaN'. IlpI e' r}tllKoB. opre ept pe' ,roo.' (po. o yeapa opa)
Ha oa olt peelt lo o-pa'(a, o}lo aeJla, pL, Ha apo o-poe, opEo MeplooM po Il aaJl | l B. aoMy paJl]{oM oop (.to oPo t|ll ipaflr B ye )' Iropae po B;t1,l i-e ' poM o ' lop lM o pt l l l l l . I l p l r .Pll aDBrr M o '
7' ope poao Ioe A
o peo A,r oa ooo oDtrleoooep: ' 'Coep ro po Pt Ai'. 1Aa,ooe' oyue l,l). Al a oo op, Aal _oe yN,tooeoo oPe (' . o' ooe xp. oo y pee oo. P, |98, cp' 2'46),''.e MoIloB o ' o ee A^,r Btlae' ,o po.e' o o, oul oei aI' o.poIeoy o.a oo'' (oa rraoy' Tooe Ma, o' 68,3) '
oe yIoB o ept o po B rp'oa oBoP o Bo opo pe (. l l.6.8; 65.25). lwBp poPJ] oopo Aflo' ' 'eoo oa ooo x'Ao : oey l pe ? oy Ba e peoo p'u'' ( Ao 50); o o pottia Ito e(e 52) ' B ' 'ye .yoo'' o o ta oo'o yltltt' ooP otl oP oB' o Pyo, oo.pI I paoto l o o ooa ]oy ot. oI Boy; o Pr oL, oopt op eo opoo|\l '
' 'o o oe oae B eoBl B.fl p tlaeTotl eoey, a oa otlltJ] Ay, o oo a op ao o' e oo Dli. llo |t call cxu,'( oo' o r l3). ..oya.
e o3pa ypoa pe', (AoeI, Ao,36) ' 'ar, o Pope foyJ ao Io a Ppoo, oo Ay, o o L B a' o oo yJro oee'' ( yra) '
o reote ppoo Bpe yy oxoB'' 'o iut'' oopIx yKpolapo p: ' 'o, o a orioy oPo, oo. loo o Poey y, oopt e pa- ll ) ol , IKo pl yo' ot xtlIx '' (o e )'
.ea, y _ pea' ap o' t{yy oo oa' o yTpe yy, ooplr o yo yoe. o ' 'oo tl Po aoy LI ' |'1 o|1, oe) o o,oyJl oo, oolrle oeoy ep epe,tl'' (a vII ' ,l2)' B ' 'ra'' oIB.e yu, oa a yy or ' , '
3 8 9
lt o}i opI, o o oo Jlo P]l.a o poD' opyI M, PNt.aePM' ! yoM, o, a.otl a, )l Jtey' Ho e o . l| o oo. Mo o o oop'.(p , I l l , l ) '
8. Hyto o)i(e oPoo plB (apy)
oy P,Jle pp op poo y (M
14 '42 ' ' 25 13: 26 .4 l l . l 5 .6: l ep 5 .8 .9: op l6 .5) ' r
I\4e1 a (626)' t,l, xo (l7'l l o' o.
o pe p)e) .aop aoy e Moax oy]I
' 'eo''
() ' o aoe-o llBl{o o)litl, }lo oe .e oPIt pa. 38I opo:
' '.
p, oo y!' ' arr K I oi{e Bo. ' '.yo.
tl o o Bopoy pru oria )oo}tIx otto
oa'' (. pe. Ct y eooope. , l944, p. l4) .
|\,loa opye p e, l|o P o pIB '
o pyx' o oo oJlpo tl: ' 'Mo
ofo ope oy o Jl e, K | otl
UI oM eto oBeB: o ttop ot o pe 1 oJlllI PT oo'' (o
; toy . ooe M, po ' 55 '5) . ' 'Mo l r o
e x(e oe tle eoB oo: o ol
eT B p'' (o eBIt, e 28), oreTtrlJloa : ' 'oa o, otl o oe o B..(Pyee o oe l24)
9' Mou:e tl rr oo
e ye PeJl Bop Itl eput'l.ou (Top. o o. [pye opp ''Tpe o opl{'' 2.26)' o Ap
' ' lI-
tl '' ' 'po e Maee'' oy o '' '
o 'B oaeo P,tl otl o aMPe eo
K ttI oo: ' 'B yl ooy oo
poy PeB ' Bop, ott' e BtrIe or()tl.o'' (epo. poo o oti), oa yu p'
oopt oo pl l l e a y o.o'' (Hrl C. o 54) '
. 'Aotl. o o |J|
, lt o lr, o ritlo oo' ' (ooe[I'po tlp VI , 33).
Moatp' ooaI I,t B:tc. l lprr.I a' vo ' 'oo |a eoe oT ool.r, eeJ|a )tl _ ol oo' ' (ropooo. Coo o B BeJIo) B ' ' pI' 'pop oorlo pIlaJI otll l ly Bll l l e oo' .e popo otlo.aeJle oBoP o ' 'oa]o oo.' ( v-ttoT' ' ' 3ol V, 2) '
olt (P) Ioop o oa _ yII|.t l K o ' ' t loIt po oo' ' (.o 4, l) ' ePofi ooP o f,Io oee oo, yp., o oa peoxoJl oo, o
. 'y
po' ' ' ' '} l 3 (c|: T' o ou' oao oepru e oo, tloe 'pe pe.p oo, t|o T, To noLtdo o o, oPo oo pa' ' (epo Hre ' 19). B ' 'CpeoBol op'. ..
oooe opJe Me}ro ..,toeo
JlIre' ' (.6. I lp, l886, p' 05) '
,r opeellt o o)tlo pB pye. Mor.o ^adpo riuc' ll pod.tto Xpuo pdu (oottopyoo orue) ' Moureo _ . 'c||o u. '||. Ido, o _' 'Pe' ' ,
opalB o yo}ry ) ooulopy, oopt y oP| opoe (p l laa- 41 p oo el,I). ox .op - du (aa-
P ) vttl d _ 'ap ( a, arl P.Jlo oo).
Be pre Pxl olll,t] eBylo o oe.r Paoop N,toBllloo Jl _ poop, oopoeO lt py]e yPrro cBa oto e, o eJlor B o o op otlto )H: oll oT' o p. ol l o, t lo eo v)q4 v.
D i l i onn i d sP i r i lUh t . t om l 0 , t i l ' 'Monh i sm ' . , o l ' l 55 l . I 557 . . . L '
uh6|ps' ' (Pirr iul o.s.'). (.opyrl) l Bi luhsn. l). lr ls l980'
40
>F
PAl l APAI
B H|4
Cp T AA
BB.e
B pte e i Bolo yleo oy ]llJlo-
e o e oP ea IIaJI ttol l 'o
. Ca ]o pal )T eI\4rro eoolootl: Bt aa o. a pl o
pPoTprr .)e )totlt. B oeo . ]a pt.
o o 'e Mt|}l].}lo o y eoBy,
[lep>tte eoLlo e[. pl o .\. }MarPLIIoB'y I lp o), oee}io o,l l ooy opy.
o }r!t pep B Ptly. Pdtl oopo ) ' lo
o}tote oeI aa py- Prp polo
op lr, N,ll I,tN,r! o tr e e po ooo
piUI , pBtrlec opr rtoe Bt te.
Haa oxlt o ' 'Be' ' ' 'rrra.' ' ( l ) ' rT otl. y-
e peMBeo P oeptt' epePlo
e lt pottlt le' tlo o a It )
p Me opooe r Jl B, o c' ) o.
y e apo e au(2) ePeaBM ApaM a l
axol po yo Pa' yltpt o
eEI o e .y o lo yoI]o'
B tU P o(o oe l ]rl yo tto ]p| ) la'
* lUIa JI l .oI l l pMt lo l lD l ' l o ,r i o \o] ( l { ' ] J Io
} l l .ep ' .pa' ' t lo o : ]c] l , l l o] lo; t oP .
1 l Mo lp
l ) ' 'Bt ' ' a60ec p L ' lt l l l l l ; . ' l l
U l/ I l . ' e l oJ l or l (oI ooo 700 l o t l : ) ) o l ]
' . I Je. . } lo l 6o j l o:]p l t i t \ap1P
2) Ca ' oo A6oJIa Pa r Io l '
ol ]o l . oTr r r 01 i o: l ' ( a
op ra,ro
Ba P oooaa opy p. B o. oP (popoltl. B rPott ,'po'' (t'olt}tl ooo 1000 700 ' o ..), popoe Tao tlllttI opoool,n' H^na. oo peMe o-opI ot e, o]to)B o ooT tl ooo lt Io-e, y eI\4 ea, o Peaff pIljIeM ol opo yeBo' B o po xI{lll .\' I7aflc py oao. T tlotl ;UI aalxp' o, poeye IPoTB oPooo aJl'oPIJI' 1o oBl ) e ], a yo
or}l . o x oa la oxpa. ' 't' ' .
ApaN' I po, ooo ITIajr tIyT oell pao (Aoo, BI oo). 'pr ap.l r oPl oe ''P''' ApI' x|| \4eqa e!-e' o ay; ao lP r o y. (?p). AtII oy a oooy' oop PoojlJreoo e' HoopI ) oI' o ttJ ae oa aPa JI aoe rr eo rrol. o, ooP, opaoIBa Ia areI plI1 o tlf ' 'e'. '. ' , lo y. ypy' ' .
Bo oo' 'aula'' poeo PN,I}loooeaee' Boo oeo r uto paeeo lp -l I; pa]\,| (rr 7p|) , oTpuu (KII -
owl), (pe, yI! rJlre ut), d p t (a l -
, popao.e) ' Peo oy )l( olJ1ttoo eoBPoo elpe TIla: pLliapull (y, oat opoMyp y o pyosooM p), ?puoxa \o11o ', ltTI, oyro aa tl oBea)epopfl ol'|), anpa (y, olt-l ypye.e oo oao tt Me o y l. oe ooo oe,t' efepo^4y ay), ,}loel l i a ao eo arPo'Ho o yeeoe o' e yaBll, or N{p poxoPP a' a ' lB tUI o pao.
Co o oo,r ''tp'' oltlo ott e oe:lP - o olP, tly oa ooe yo ' B orru{, oe Jt ee oprroo, oB poo, po, poo' o Pylo, _ B ooe,ooPa ooy PopTrr oIT B o o. A.p _ N,lo yo tloo.
4 2 4
Haoee xapapI epTr aa
l' AUrp flIM ypy. ypy e t tlpe e
)t{ rup. )rI Hyoo a{\,r Eo e pea oxo.a o o Ilo yoBo otlott tlo.T. l{M y Ip oTaT oT xaoo. Har
ypy _ po, BoP oo. pyy tloPe.o,r Coo '[ya. py )llBoo pa oo poB- e xPl{tloo PaM. o o r' oo ytl
p, o o Pooa.2' Byr}rr eIe o}t }l e IL eo.
xo )oo Ira apaa. I rup,ra oxI oo-
o)a o PBo opo ua (oP op) n,4 (oyu]e opoe).
y eel: a) aua, ePo. (tp oe oBo, orpJte); ) aTr'N' |\|t
paBEo; B) cu, 1'e' orPx(ae o BoPo 11 o
oo PBoe r Pe oxo (o 'li,pBoe eo l o Uro e oo'N4oT, a)e oaa, e BopoBTo,) ; r) paapb, eo,lyp;1 napupa, !1 oooe o oo o)(a o
Boo yT}loto oa't. paBa el )e o a.
e ' ' x oo aa'' ' '''' c'. a) a, tlype BIle Toi
6\ an' ttt't po' (oe, o ''): ) u.
loLu' |^|1 MeH .oBo tJB , l Ml. palot: r .) d'
e y a{; D) uapanpuda, LI nPe.
PIBlto olle oo (pp' c tloo oott ' etlolo aoo.y poo p\1x 'TpL )
3. ooo' ) or oo BoPa, ott, op. y.
l fa, Be,uie opt oe ao t o lltoBopey yttltI yxooo po' o yp'
o l}l ope oottI pKpI B ooryr cltl' 3aoI, opt oy oooe l p,o
' 'Pa'' (oa o), eI e olo yooo
yoB}I ' Aope oo oo yoo tipet y, ooo oy a:t, pe,.lo o l
oe, oa Po oopo oo oM. o| e
ooo') oooxe o o . Apa ot{
Poo Bo oPI ea, o peptlo
oMIa I My a eoo MoBI. o o pll
B e ooo oe oa e oy P
y oepe e,r. Ta oere ot po.e poopev yxy apar'{a.
4. PoT, p ooBe. o.eIe ePr pay: a' p, ao, ye.tteo. Trra ola po. allp. oele Mey ea apa lo t oeoBl, e oBer,r. B xpcoM a[IpMe ecpoy peoT' tlo e oyBToa.
5. po eo. pooa o) ope paNl.B o Ioo ooT pap e a B.y yxoBlry elltlo. eo oooae l He yIrtllx a ao pa eo' o e oBoe a o..aoeNIy yTBoBa )t(3 tpy oe c oD,Itl.BoM pooo apoa g, pa]] eo op lt
l]eoo opll. B ax aurp,r po ae p.
}lo o' ,II 1oo ajpa e o)KI I t lI o.
oo, oo paoo ao,t.y. yp'q II
p'p. Pyo y xo oItlo ttJ )tt lpa.
o, , I .. B o)KttI ooTeoBa e|
o. B ot oPa yo oJlrty ] '
Cpo pee e otl j] oro po rxpao'
rr.r peJI pe N,ly Moo aoo. oo.
eetl l io o Boo}loM JloPy. l op.
ee o o o Poe pa'
e paa rt yxoo .
ol ott c t{o p ,,l ', rreooo
1 eoopo peaJI o poIl eJlto}lo yx ''
. p o y eoy oIlty. lt ee y.
xoo pooeo' o.TBo oo() eoe ae
ou]yra ol Peo. o e o}ip}toe oee
o tr tll ' oo oopo yoe ' ' ' ' pe
oI' T Ilopeoo ottl l l l o Bor e.
o oo' [|o Pprr.ry' ' 'eJl -t e ol1,
r yxo pooEo' Pe , o a.
P e e a eyafl o, t lo )t( yr).
o' P o Byee epeIt oee P.
olt! I{e oppo o o.. '
o.ttoeMy peoI oBe o o' o
oeo pyB, o oyJl l leop,l ot
o, ot, opt ool t l oo rtoox aaTIll l lrPPe. Pe o op IroBope y
o' o eo t lPoPee poto t loe}too
a o o. Hae oBe Tjl e o'
tloT , oopI ool ' Be
Be Topo pe oPI, oooe' oI{ilIe 0.
pol ot' o atB dpa (aKo|, opJl), oeo|vl
ee T eo oeo Pao yolro )KL| (,,'ao1
oooee, ool laoe ae). .. a o,IT o-
Ee ooI' o pa.
fl xPlt epoB H ItloJlHa o M:
ppIB eP e B ooy lt o pe' epl -
Po ppIBl BypeH T, PI vo
y Plro rr. PBo, eo otl
Pooey rB' oa oJ]o yoBrro p.
etlo oo y. L'o e otty lll
oe Poatl .[I'y' .( y odpare poo ll oaae epeoa a oe Bloy y yxooH tl1oe o peu po-r'
ou Hep re: ''I.{epo e B g ltltla o .oBo oro' oTopo o o l opT oo DBo o o Pe. . to pa oP yet p o ruoo epao' aoBopeoPH' ep, ooBy p PH|' o eo, o| oByro c|,|', ' [epo plp.e K oPl{' oaoe ypx(, o o lloa '' oep or1op. opao1, tto e eo o o, o yoo eo.' oeo, a aoveI yI oy oopx opr' p oI It oI oe otiolx oIt ylx tll7t.lr' r e pIBoeo Bor oTtlo) yo oTBtloT o,oopl ap P op' Ho e eo l1I elloBe opoee' ooIe o)llo a o.roy' o ''ap'' 'II. y >t
' 'to' ' . xp otloB , yo ooe.o }IIrr o lo r oloo poNt oo, opoePaHx rpo ooe Ptl Hoo
PaPI oey''-ro' ' yoT yxoo aJle' ' ' (Hot p, ol opeo . ., l lop, l969) .
Heoxoo pKo' 't' ' oyoea epeTBy-ul ee oaI{ ptlo pa po p.l l oo}llt orr,y oy, o epeo poe'B tuy oxy _ oy peepo poal HotoJlI{l]lo Mea, o opoBIt paoopt to-op,ll llx o Beoo Petl yy, o...ooo eoea' ' _ tlo xpTtl '.a}r.' oe e peo, oopo oo l.[ep oxp oaeo oee eJ,teo Pt|o' oropo T o.MI ;lruo o oorB pTy o oporuoopoo oo IeJI tio , ep oo, Pay c) po pop. l loxoo }loo y ro oa, y e aHeo, y',t ep oo I}loo Cpe ol{oy oti o;l o, e oo' e o oe oplt lBe o ro' o ol{ e Ieox pae' [| tt oy poo p }ly: p}r.e e y3 }l.
' 'o' o xo yae rpMe oep.Tro tl, B ooPo yoo oeo pool l
p rpo P.J{. B ora p.a o) oEol ePa' ' ' r yo Ax.lt ( Co, ee, y' l97).
po e eye Pp pypo ope' tto - ' y'o)t )fle oM yBo-T opo l o o.t loUiey Blo}t e pa:Be oPot{ , o P, o.t loa H' pete.r, t l , l\ 'oo PeyeT o l loolx ao Py oo}lTB pol: l operuo 01 o Mtloo.o yo, o po oJlt{!t, o oyPe' C;r.oe o oI o.o lo yMoo epe:aoopo, eol{ H o , otlo o.lttroBlotlH o aoe.
pe alpar o'(y aooptlo }i t i ootl tit y P PTB . Ha . ePoB o1 tloo T M a}lllll . ooPleP ox oo' o' e. oyye
y x o' Moe op Booy, aepoBBlll oyotll oIo. l.[epo e o-lloo, oH l\4oe oy a rlop' P.a1 ' I ye B eo, eg6e'u.. |-|oeP Poto otlIeoo ' o, eyoo, Poo.eoo eTtII yoB' Ceo' e xPIJ ooo o oe )}ln T oe yoo yp ro' r,Pl ootrI yoop x yorry x(y.
B oa oloo llyKoo e| BlyB.eo e tty. Bo .ro rop Cyo aa: ' 'p-
e' Bl o _ eI pyl{ PEy yovtuy. BI oI PP er P e. Bl, o}to, otllcpe epo e o]o P yy' o' peeeo, opr ep. o p o, o Po.oe ByPerter oPae, o Ttit,t oPo lepy y pe. Bu pK I.{po pil o roe orlo p pyylo, ltltlKe y oooo tlt{ orroy opaH op.to P. BoT oey pBo yopeo }ieruo yoo''.
s, ssy l-dyal ' ' 'Ds shr]s htins n Ind' ' opy' i8ht vi onsre, n'4?/2,
4 8 4 9
N,IOHAIP B Py
oruo pBo B o upe p?B pe, o ' 'yt' ' , t ol l l loBo, po)lt
yeP}|tlo' yT' pBtloyle ItlHo' |' yBB afll oBPerIM eoBeo' I ol i I t l otl l{ )t(' oIa oa ''oa'', l\4o oI ,}lt , 10 )t( Bpe, o, o l o.pTBo yr. t oe o rTo' e P opI.
, ){ll oBlll! t{ oBo etlo .oBee oE; eo' . p pt .oIo, eo o eo poxoell' oPaa' opa ll,oo' aM opo, oyT o o, oopoo re a M.
B p p, t{ ooPoo poxo o P)IIMr, opoy Ce.y, py p, I{1py e op o.
y, Payure, yePay ''p Payrr{'' 1 Iaoy ''oPy.
y' ' ' oTpoHoy a eeoo poo prl{' o
po C.e. B o ep I oyree ' Pyr-yro po I{epo e peor Po .t peopo y epo eo opa' P)t(I
el l oBeP[IaeT MTIloe !l o yBy ' 'Mt]}ltP -
o' ' , o e.tep oepruae xap.Cyo eo a eyro PoI
coa ca' aI CI or: ' 'ove, e MoIol ToII B o pa, o I o o yoo' ' (o l7' l5) '
r o pet B o4 N,r e' ot >lqj Too' rro I e xoM IT aoo tiI\4. MI oT )l oo p, t ol l x ee o Jly rie oo Lio)e; l\4e oo pa ' opo. ytU oye-
T aoe ; 1 . oo p, ol o.
o, po oo e oo p oo o llxy oy' r ee To, ooo y - epo4y oy'ooo MP _ Po e otlxl l.
r o ' 'eBlio t oo o' ' , o IIlae )|(y oprio lo' o oa P.y .il'a' t e oeo yl oo ol tl oB tlyx(; l , oI M l lIToo oy y, 1oI BIe yy o o3p op. Htu pe lB pye p Brae) ylt pepI p [Ieo pe': yeo. pB opeo oP' oopo I .I l 'yxIrPBoBy' r xo oH o yo.t-tl .| I )] o pe. )ql oa.
l pe oePtl oaPrto o e l{.r rte pe o p oNlaeM oto oo ooo op.' 'Moao oe' 'oy) a b' I loyaI poT o. r eya opoo' I TPyoe' oyti, T.e1 ]o oPI, pyo, otlo, yJ]o' oPooyl p, op ao, peoB oPo Ilap, ooPo o T otlo o' l] lx pa. p.
I oeeI oT pa , oItopeo' ottel l\''Pl E ooe ' oIlopeeo' Bo aol\4 ott,
I Be o1 op _ o t l oo)o'o Peo Pop l l l )
' 'tt, f lpe
P.o ape' ' .yoo, oo ao ppI t ttr o
e pa Pa' Bo oey MI e I, e
pI, }r P1I, rr ott}lI ... o ' 'opo'' ' .
oa o prx eo pl{' yJrr yr ' ' opt oo'' oo e o, t' Bo ope' )r o1 ' 'yI'' opoo oPo
,'] oPl eo ooJle. eyToo o o.tloo' ,1 opl o Be, oyoJIa1 oltoBo )},ty-
o oPo oBK' t orr ' 'opoKy yIl'' l l I
oo, oI, ' 'otto a oy' ' , oe t loy poy'
,orl Bttl lio. t prr ro, TolIt M o1 o Po oB' Po'o py'ttoopoo }qj. MI orM, oI }llx oa ula opoe, opo t l[I I\4oBe' eo oo eoey eoo ooo PHoo, opa.
eo, tl pl{ Poa B5ry pa,Pea e oBoPy eey. H o to eoe e pMet oP o B Pe eo-eo' p ooPoo o oo. Heooo o-aIo.ty T ' 'eo'', e o e To' e ' 'o'' po-efl ytlo .yx' l e o oo oePa oa 1oo oeoT ; flooPo, Ml M oeflTBMee oepe ott l to, o '' o, pyoe o''. l pe el{llBtlllo tl oa, o olr,I
op o c o ooP o flr , BeyPQo Potlo IIU-I 'oeo )' eoB,oo poo, po o TyP oe.
o oa - ' 'oo opey'' pooT pe eoB,o oBe _ ' 'opa o'', ' 'eo p'' ' 'xpa Jlyx''. B ]opeoU{e pe eoB o)1 yoeop o '.orr
oo o''. Ho o orue B o p i o M )qtoy . p ''Botr' ', t{o ott e ' 'opo BTI'': ooplB B eM' ,tI I orpa o .
oo . ool ell tt tll|o o oooeo P , y opoe!
oHA||()l: PC|Jo (. l , l l-)t( l ,]Pts tj( I IAP) )
-l To IlooB
B y...
P o p PC
xo yol , popa Mo o.'fa M opolIlI a BIy pooI Pa,
Jl ye ooll po o ror' .aur pe - oepl o. py H lroIteooo opo Pe epB oo Bo oJl] o, JIy oopo ee olrt eE o'
o Co p eo xo l\,tocp MoPBIra' e o' ep ltoo y y Beep.H pe. oop, 'to puyt yep yBo oep.' l. lte oTPMBo' ooo eoy oPoly' lly o. p . otttl|' pMa H, -oao py a e e oI o o ypo. oe oo.o yTll]B oe llllo oya ay oy. pa eyM o lx Boflt opo Moe oMH' [epo,e tlae a oa. oo y o JIIM ay.tt|M opo' e ePe le po py .l{, ' tto, oaa Pey ee o po p.o' Cea yyp B oJl|toM ootl' Be ptl}tlUl pottI oe oPoHo, oer oya ooM.Be y eaflo M oaxa' ,,l ooI ep)a pyacpo JIy o llPBIl{o, Ktl olluro o. oaIlp. e Mo - ttt' olr .oI oJl.
3II ollo,(, o y eoo pa o.p o''Ifly oHtl (, oIoeo /l oo.peBae o yeoBa|l ]T oool PlJtl otl.t ioUl l loJl ax o tsP ,oN'' |\4oJlIe yIoPl rllo x y]l o ojlHttl B pop.
5 l
t{ pe. e, 1o To ype ye ooTy
x ypetl' oax r pe aNl.o apo.
o' Hey e yy e rpRI y? ''I yepe
o?'' ytlllo oa e oarl ao. I
o)e p ri ye x Pl , o.
1o oa y }lo o' o o oe I pt{ Mp'
Ho p o oy.eyoo, ol oo loeo My
( ). e oltlueM otl orrt,
o oToPIx Pe ope ll oo' yyI o.
Port pa. Ho e e o ltlltt, e oP. e x Pojll oeo )g-l. o oo e oli.aI P xpTl,t' Iele' 'oyote' 'ol oloo l ooIe, ap},r' ' oopl
aoT Be, eoe o Ieo 'oalP, _ otll,
B oTopI l tll l lo PpB ep,t? )l i oa Me oo oo , y p
ox ox opfla oo)l(.Bo o Jlyae, oy )t1oy oo i o) llo.
opo BD otl.
r Palre
Mt oo. oao yT o eo' oeI
B pIe ot o a p o lHI o.yye aoe-o oe yPoop ... l to eoopoe .
Iprr' Be o. Bpe o eMe p oBT yl-
' ae .1o pttt l, BMIe IeM Po Mp
ott ooy. e ao-o oyy . B oe
lo y, oopl orrr KyKa aPo.I '
tt-t' LIo B yrr ltl, I'o too e' oJl
pa eT y. o Ie ol' o ep .
1o oae )H ooo eeI{KtlB, opl'llI.o,r
oy l4.o o tteo, oP a Mooo, ojlo.
BI Ulo. Iult{oc' p}io' apey op. BPM o p tt tI oefl pepe' M
Molt ots rae, Nro, ltootlllo' o llllT }l
I o. o' tl , B oo ly '
Cpe op oaxo Pe:ltto luI ]te
pl roo oe l oyll l l to' o pooo.
y t lx y ePee, l y pI. ' o, 3 a
yo' o o: ' 'o
o ,rpet y! Mt Byae e
I eoeo oel !' ' ox
eo, JIt o ox oI ' o ott o l yt . ote, aPoI ll, oe pee o' oo)e P.x Poo' B y e ooI' eoypIe' MoIIoIe paIe' f lo Mee eM poN,lIe eaIe.C' oo aKe yeIe eaN-l pI oa opa ' e' o ott Po e. Ho Be apl
' 'ol ' ' '
o opee e oP o oy, oI o' 'po' ' tio eHo ll l B eHI yx'
H ex ea PIe aaxotlI. oa o e
PaoTII, tl PtlPIl l,llPoo tto, ooPa B l{Hl (e, o e oBT ae ] o) ' o t l po o PIM ortotte ete xI. oll x pa)ao o)e'o o - pxoc e JI plI aox? Moe I,
oE P1 Ho r p yey or o, KooPIM o ep y otloM ooee.
Bpe o pe o.o oRaxo ooo Po oeaP y oly y opoo' py ToT' T) ooltoM' ePe- o u yr oax' o e -1o ep oeBy o ol! l ' }l e oy oKo.ax KoM oll ooaM? Paa, e o
Iooyo, o toElop ey: ' 'aru, a I o oy!' 't la ax o yt. o ool l Ba
tpo, o o )l( Pe oo}ro yo, at o o pe.o, o pell yrr' el e oo l io, I
paeo oIl lo' e o e poa P' oo y, le eo Moo}I' T y pe }Ieo opr p, a oopo o .P)
l r
Jaefa B B a o' lU Ml pIe olltIe peaoBoo)ql o 1o oo y)' o oopo oyI . Jlpye y)l pPeI o Boxoa oaa ey py po P a,(I .P : yP'r. ( ooytl, }l yesy oToo oP'p' pe), epl, Pe, ruo | , eP oe.Pe. Be o oB o}lo}Iy y eo oRxo, p.l lo po l lIloJl MIo yeoe'
Be oao, oooe o ol Be{ oltx yI.o o paoa, a Po t oI Pyx .otio. ooo eoe o olpoop' ! t opo! }l o oaoyBy. op PoI oo pyo' eot MaI Tpl{tlI PBo}llM IrpeMe1 ypI oxo. peo oe To e' Boe oxo ye Htt o ooo.poo, tlo |tcoql1|l |1 .' o po leaTItaBflo llpll oy' xol, B tloee Bp otlIpe' B ot oBP' yrtl, , MPl. t o oye' o tto) lt eo oe.Ho epe M tlo'
--l
' 'ooeo pprro' toopI Moa, rto oo PeeT
eo ooo. Te ojlol o! Koople pay )e pe- llojlo opueo .}ltt, o lo epoIe .r ofloT' o o. e oo MooIe' o a 1pIe oa. f looo p)t( y Mee p''.
T o o B lroe}t e-oe4 e eopeBttoa oo oe4M poo rt.TerrP o apa a oo lpee eooe pyo otl.
Cltee ' o ool e Me)y coo p. erl{ey opy orr opo | ' )t(e tteo{ee}to aoo ylt! oopI oe.To eoo r o pyoaTI to olto y) o p.o^, oI Boe ol. e a e' ol leyao oo )elej eeo ptl ppIa.
Bep. ea tltlo B MIlpe pe yt.a opol opoo B. poM l!,t K.o oo'oo , rrepeBaeo o tiy op. o, oIe or B' o Bpe o l e o oe pooyoop.
Ho tteoe' o e )ooooe e )t{o yB.f o otio )l(y oo. ar yror Jr-) ot{le Me).y ' B yv aNre' aaUl) rlo y y)I]M )e. I]o PIB opoI e9 ya' ooPI olo t{xoI B 3otloot{' (B o yae ri T y' lBHoo e . p MItoeI otl lto' MollIp.pea reI). Pyo opoI' )a, opoootr.I, l , Pee o p! oopo ap opBo.
yx )lBI ' oeo' ytl o oo' oo-oe oT eo' ooP pBp1 o B P - aaoop pore, yotloT yI' oP 3o tt . eeoyro' oJlt{ltlto xpTay I{ti a popeaar.o B BeoM Ic opoI. o.o' .oe,1y.JlaeT e aa xPlt a ee. A oa,pe e o' o o.Bol\4y, eplM eM? Pe otl epIIvI etta. ol o po, ooJl floe oToJlo. o otlo. B olloaMo o My.l
cu e oao' oo Plal , o o _ e,IBo eoooo' oelto. aI\4 otlory: ' 'H| r o' o)! oe oo p Ba tllll IleHe' o o oJlo' ToI oo'p''
o oop To' yep e' o oBa aoTePa JIl x N,lp.
H a I o ti ro' oT}I ooB' epyr o
ox oya' 1Ia yloe oEell' o{ oaoe
e Io o.oey pao. BoNflII o ao ep.
Bo aoB IaT tty' ool yll B eyy' oa
o1 xp P pt e' ooI y Be oPII IlIo.
. o rr' poo' Mo poo o
N,le' o peol{ o,re ee Pr' Pye oPa.
B oool\4. B o o xPa ao]\,tl Myp.
B, ooo ap etl oPo. opooe
. ao eeol a.l ypr a l le? Bopy plllJloo oBe MoI{ B) oo y.o y'
Cy o ' po .e o o opor o tlop,
'oo oa, olo y ye, y p: o o.pa.
y ool io oea o' T e pepo'
ttMoo yB' aa o! a, o B oM ll
By K-o pa,l o. Ho, pylI]BlII' tlaelu y.
Boa' To I{yPtl e)o TBea, aaT.
axory ytt pa. Moax To ep op 11 B p.
o e, te oUtae ptr, tr oTopo pa oll ll oa.
o. py o xoJ1o o IB y. pao Ila
}ltto r pl y ap' yer }ll
pt oo. Koopl ott oo e] oa.
rpe' o o _ p yvaoo prue? Mo I. oo
otlx oea o pe Byt l iI oo: ' 'o
. oo. o o To o' ' . cal" l o Il!
o o >o po o? oe l aa N4oaaN{ o
BoPo '
ae a K}l)a
paru o o o tloto oaa l l1loo'
o B oopoIo e1 Ptlfl oTa. o oae: ' 'o
oy ' Mtlo p e oe e aB. pe.
e, ,toy o tl Blo . rl pa,
. oTe ltaIoe oN'lla B o'y N4oIIaKx Py'
y) P eoo oB e)a y o oN{: ' 'TI e Ml
o e}I -o Jl K-o oao' ' . oe o o
oBoP tt: ' 'op tloo' ' ' oeri a, o Bp' o ) oI,l PaNa, ott 1aHoB JI e}l
o PiM oo a otlM ttpl o Hep.
p' Crryvo, Pa' o, o paB poI
5 9
I oJl pTN,t 10 Ho Py' y o oB. tlp M. oPo,t o eooooorro PoI li oo. Pao tlPoI ppaIeot' ' '
oule PyI' yoyTl M Moxo' oo Bopoo Boo Coopa. Py ootlpeo l.ll ooB. Co pyI ooo aooo' .I{ p e oa oTpa Py pyy BoOMII' e 'e.. ' o e o' To
' 'Po-
ptIIM' ' py lUI py. To r ' ' Pl{. op.
' ' . p o oP opeo y , 10 r ploi, o ole e o. oro' Pl l Po o l loo o. atloB o o ox 1o.
oao eol{o yBy o opoltoe. poe o I o po: ''o >t(oo o oo-o1l aoy o opo' ' . poe oo, oIpe y.
e paoTa oToo epy _ B oo-T riy'( o]t. oo' Motlx - oa .1JIlloI ee Po Pylt{' e o opr' o B oIlTIP ee l. Co.aoe poxor e pT o porI. Hep, oa,Bleunt ypyao peI, t '' pa'' .}lo eyrro! r ,( oll or oPo; ps yHIe
o Btxoll tlpoa. Coo, 'l oea o eTo. o a y rB, o e y o.
oxo paHa . o ya oo .
_ t 3. a' at o Ip..l o oy .' oT otlIll lltllM pyo.
oo ,itl. Col oo _ llo.e .1 P Btt, ' 'pI ,rBt' ' , oPT
e o ytlo )lo,|tt ott|p: ..oo
oPeHoeo yp' ' , ' 'ol olt e ee' ' ' ' ')e.lltlo oyjll }ra yxe'', '' ' oPy-t optxejl ' ' , o
' 'oe)(o oy pae' ' . o e f,To o.To
J | I. o ] 'Hr p yB oyro IoM poo. Tp
Potljo 1 y PNt' yeo ,eIt ,o.l oJlee e pe) lt pyTeTI, po.le pee Beo eypetio' o o}llp tlo M ooeI yoo! e o)tGo o oye oo yxolly' t{o py y' Be e aee oxprre JI oIP Be o e, Moltx
yTePJ o' eer e, o p opI ooo po ye' pyeo o e. op aop o ) lol yre yl oy'
A oo 'y pa? oy. o aPMoll y oa?
o ye o o p p?y opo . o peor, p oo' p p _
nt oMoIl ao' oooy ot{ l lPeooll. .eo o, o pe e a I ''
o ao'', o ey o ot{o po' aa'' 't e oe'' oalp. y PoBIIel}l oooT p pe (ao.l p oopoa-ro) , I oyyee eo yo ePtlo.
_ o? p o o ya Pa BPo' _ ooPp e. Boe e eoopt pe, e)t(y rIIoaM oa , )y p, .lo oo,B, o oo oytl ! e PPa y,' ooP: ' 'He eo ]'Py''. B To Io To.o ytl.lto ?.I e. B ejlIlo e a yoo oo Pe. B orre ao: ' 'o Py py''.P y. Ba al, Io oBI M!lo,ePe ooe ooyeee. a o ppo! ee py o, poo y }l e eM'' ' Ho oopo ao oo eItloMo K tl e '(e o' aI Il Be e e oaK pa' Iloco,oaot Pe . e' ..Po), oP ooIx a oPa Ie )e lr oI'', t pa Jl yu{oa | }re oMa' o )l(oM p ple epI eofleoe ot.o' .t p e ay, xo' o| ] p )o o ooo'
_ . opoB, Ilo oa oTtl o oo!
- o. l lo otl P[IT' o lloI Mlt o.l' llpor oy oe M' a1Jl lla o y. t x oJ-l PeM ) B o..o ooo ' ' popo'', oo o1PIol,l ooapy Pyy'.I]Jl 'rc, aoopo, oo pI\4 o Mlloo yeeo. oo.reo ao o oPora, o otlo N,!oeoPoJ,l ole otlo[IeHl,l' o Be e ooy PP.'(e' A o ao opolto o, lllll]IottI, o KI pa _ o I Mp. epa eo ol. o' a' o oee eee Moeo ya
60 6 l
}lo yoau{ oa o p o ll'}lp t{ a a eo.
_ o or Bo op) eoe, o oll cao
oxo? o Pa'oatlo' Boo, _ ole p pe.
oo'a, eop a o oly Bao MllootitlI
oya. Ba o| o, oyB B MolIIP'
oy o a oo lM _ l' oe' yxoB.o oppo. Ha ) eo aa H it 4e
o. ]o e o op olp' Teep a. o o.
y y e' ol oooy Io
oaIpoe oya, ytt o1 yT lr, l
eB Il loIA4 ' l o pM o o.o Hoo, p.
_ opo ao oe, ey, ey e, trpxo-
aa zroepet oel . oppI BIIBaT B eo ye yP oMyerr'
oaP o oIo, orieo oIo po
ooo, ' y[le a' oo o o oe aoypr oepltM l\4otllo . Ho o, oeo, pe.
y Pee '
.yoa pya
Hpp, py y oltoJlo Jl ol.o BT e'Br, yI, peo oel, opu, p ya,
ooIlo Py py, po a y, oeeJl ]o' _ ooBp}t oe Map. o ,t l lor ' 'B''
to po eee oflale pyKypI peopM, oopl PB Bopo B oop, uo o rlo p a-oo lt oopox.
prB o o yPto peope' ' 'oo, _ ooo, _ o PI ypve op oot{o. ypaI B)eree o tle ). ooy pupeop e BIlo yIloBoprr. B oe oo ae opa.
a . ee. o eo' tloe oo1o plltill}lo,ITa' I aoo o rl. l lo o l oo.y popy y , lt PII l oopo)lI' y eol e o B)oe ooro _ y tl epo e]ea M oe. o oporo' Ml tuo,t yoax,t .po. B oo tpar y IloBollo ory poa roo ote''.
3e o pot{o Bo r: ' 'B o U]o Bpe,oJl Be p}Io pToll ' o pooaJIo ooo oN'|
;re' Pe l attlx, l Bo o oII
_ Jlpy ro ap..pyy, ey IoB' t l l.a. o ooll l po. Jlroo py) fo l 'o r e etto ' )e ol l, Happ,ep e pe eo
' 'e eo' ' ol yl.Me ae Pe eprto My'
H, .to eoBoe y)o orray. B o l\4HIooB' ox yoo y I' l o.J{l o ' Ho M oti olu p o Mo)e1I, BooU.le oa p. oo a' 1o oHa oo.e ,, l, o Pae ep' }Io tlo ool ) o.oPT o To olt oPoeo _ oo Poy opottyBo yeB, oeo' Jl o}l o poo',r eo oo()eltld
oo o Mp' ooPoo tll'l o-aoly o rp ao?rre pxo'pa Cy oop:_ t p )B' B py Py. a ot 68.o
oa To oPeo oeo _ B)I N4ee ry )t(. Bo o, I trPoo p: oe |)oPy re pe' o oopoy y aepe' o t{ lt oP 'l. B pcae P
a ooy po' eo Tpa oy pl }loB.IeTBa. B' l o Tpay.
p peM oee ooPo:_ orr,ro pTe, oopIe o HaT T )y B
oIpe oa xo a eto pI' eo' otto, yBBo PoI, a o x Pre o e o pl. o oporuo oH' oe oo eT IIo1 BIrIo po B oaItpe) Iloo o ape, yo uIo oa yt' Mo a,o otlo oti poxoll B Tp o eTM' o To a.Hoopt pr or BoP: ' 'Cote pyypI?r xoporuo a. I]oo)t( B Pae? I e o ooeB' He, ! l o tl.' ' o a oM eeoH ao o . Hooo' BoPlt,l Mot{lpe' o}lt{T opoy oI oJIo, yr{y tly$ll opoo e.. '
_ oy BoPoo' ao rtx ollxl _ P.ul ' _ rte o ,l P | yole e., tto aoPe }le' oopIe ay t opo oo?
_ oe x oa oIp' Htu op coiul M IlpTI, oy x oto. Ho BoNt ye' ' o ott p oop o x:
''o
yl'' - oo or oa. Ho o o,o t' B o, o eool yloToP oxtt.Te ool ye yTByT e eoopr jrPuzlqaTu-
u ouo, e oe l Ie , r BI yl
opy JIyy oJIBy lt oye )ll pJlT e
PyN{ _ oe ' y a. o.oy, T x(ytt ooI o' ooPIe pr B tl ,ro.
rraIp. Hru oo y oe, e o)Io a a' ,l-e. e., eoP e Pa, Ee oeo
ootlo flopeTllo' oPerly Mooe) I oeMoe oDaI{tlo.
Heooo aa' To p pe ooeo oo puoTucol\4 o||oflu. o ,r BB o ao-PoaE B3 e' o Moltx Po o ePe
oy l{tl.
oepo
y, Poo)H}Iy )y oM e o o eo eo, oPae otP, x:lo o.a oul oI MLlr. e' oo _ y)tl.llI lllI' tll o)I, poBpB l pap
o opoo aoaIo toTI. Be o px ap Pooo! ot poer e o tt oy )q{e ' o o1tl, oHlx a' opeopoo yI' tl T ee oo.oe aoe oxM oo: ' 'Parue o to telo. eyoo, oal B po ao'o oo/]Jlo. pa, )ye aeo o oTlp' oa p lM py . oy)H o tlt llopoo otloo Mo teoo pllH.'.
B eo o l ol oo oalp .oI{Ko ypo. oo oee oo e;r, To a. pllIJIo e]laT o]yel ooll. opoo oe. oPo y1 oJIy oxoMI e Mo}IIpe. Jleo o oe .1o, o ro p1 Bo ) BP Irr P o ti oaIp oxe Blo e ePao n.Bell, l aMI ppte ea I oyooPeIe ! Poo' a ' oy op o y.o Pey olpo ll. Ho o ooa' oe a oo' poPo _ oo oax yir, l
prrlto Moao: ' 'Pe e yo l loll. aI o ot oo or?' '
_ l l o p! ]o oy.o eeT' o' pe eto' eIe ott' ooP| }I) PttoPN4To'Coo Pyo: pytlo o1o ollI,|{oti, 1oI o e yoB e MotIIp .no}1, ol MI I\ 'o oT e MoIpo' yoo, }to re ott pI{o - o oaepeoeri o poo) eoo ' l ao I-
tll l rr]y o oaII' . t l oaBa ' o oe l o v '
61
re I eoe' o oe oIP'oU-{o To' ll ooPI ooo t{oo Ieo'oxo oa{tl' peax o e oo e.
Moe o' o l{olP' aoP oy o o oo.BPe}ro ri N{o yroo xlt, To' Tlto oaeoe
Poopr oeT' oo d.t}tI yllo' oroPoo oPoo a ooo [.. Ho lo oaI . ''oatp, yorrr o,Il'pp, _ s e ToPoea r' oaIp _ oo .ea aT l{ep' y o B otloI, arr{x e:oTBa PoPtlltTo. oe oo. Ea' )tyl oo yrl yT rrMx P, ooPl )yT Py''.
o orro. oo eye opa tte a oo a.alto Bre' yt{oe s oBr. ott.TI PeIllI e opt eoeo''opvo..,e yoHr Poe attoto oo .
o oxo - opoI P oep e'
Poli?l' 'Teo'' oopoo oyTa ox p-
, ooo PaIeB Tpto oo}l. ott Poootll. '' o x oP e oy p o ye, _
toBoP o-t ' _ e o, To B ''t[t o''
e oepreo Hroott' o Coop ooTeo P
''.Co pyto yx oax _ ToPottlt pJlTuozo
dreu. Oe o' a rr yy opollo oo
tll e Pae l\,t oxa (x ooo a)pa opa oeo o Pyt' oI Molt .oooI opo, a e' oe opTBeIIIIo I,l )llo)
yxe ''oo'', yo yBo, Py Re apu-
a u o d ut u ',Ilpye e Po yy Tporx Typ.
x PHx' o e ooT ' 'ya.
eo ooo'' oe x' To pe ol{.
y' _ aoe ao re P l ool pe alTapI.
oa, aMa}t oo. Jlpye pol ''x.
y'' o eeoo peP yP1 pe rt a opae' o t x (op' ) Beto'
''oeo.
I'' oe) peo po portKo oBP.tlIx yolx ox. B ox, ooPI o.oxoo p' To y ox Bopo xPTIIeoKo
' 'oI' ' Bo eo eoIJ ltto J. l
e oe eyoooo p. Mo Tl o Plopa oBoaeo oPaMr To Poo. o e . o' ' ''eto{'' oPo oillo }r(''e'' _ oo' oopoe ll o oe ), o y pT ooe eoyl. Hpep, B Mox p llo rrooo o. oore plipoeopolo xPepye o o}too Pa: ''pooe oepu- e y oa o ){lo Po e yxoo l,toBea''. orr oo, olp To all aol{I]epo, oae oe. B o .ltep yt.Ty p e -o oPIl oTopl' oo' e eP. e o, ooo oy, To poxo4 o. ''o Iol eBIoo, _ toop otl ooo o, _ ooy ToMI )eI\4 l aoPe, oPooo pl{ ti Te oaIPo lqi. xo, eo' ]\,t)|( o.xa rT oP, tl orlo, oopIe o l pPy.rrl or o' e y lt o)o prT e pli'aPI oIe' oo yy B oeeo Io.o ep''.
y l oooo ol|x o paee oIe _ oe.
a
oy, o oe e pp oo ' o o tloe. B epoeo o ePo.oy t eTtlo Po. o oe PTIelt. 'IIo Il _ ro-pI v oaIP' e a pyl o -a oo' o o yoo oo pllI.
o t oo lr' - oop o _ oe' _.l\'oIP o aooP. B opaop N,IoxIro eo o.rroy' o' a oI aoPoPrr, oHHPpottoe. B or e p otlx o o.oey opoo yoo yo. Coeo, 1o ooPIIoT Bea HIHI' B o>o oy ltlllyIreperty oPMy. o oo a To' o Py.}te ee y. Ho arl a6opop - rre ye p' He,o opop )lI poye ){q{Itrl. o o _ Bop >l, _ yI, oBopT o _ ltoTe' - Be y a' Ho .. ' '
A p ottIp' o o, opopti' o ooo)(' o oaoPI pPoK yly pe )' e BIlY oTo.
6 8 69
_ o al eo, _ oBa ao. _ Hrr o BllI c aoToTo. I M y yoBoT, oa; ar
o _ oBplttBoBT yT PHoIrpMT' ooooa yx ajx lloo _ ra ooHo p' orrr y pey pee' oT eo ep'a! y. ll]!1' o o xoT Ha B -,rorp. oax o)}rly tl Ioe, y)li ttM oepeo B oye }raoKol ol o Pa e )ttt{ Moltlpl oe oepttMIlI' l\4 oe e' Pao oe xoporu' 'e' ' , oarru poe aure opop. Top,ltPMp. poeot aoT' To ll oa o p-paIe poeert. Bypeee op}r oTp)t,t a -o aeBe.
o o, o ox t pop. pr oa.Il, o o e o oeN,re ep'
..o,e o oo o potlo.HI oo tloBo PoLtKoe eBo l\,tc o.
M' ex(y N'oIp oor xly B . o p.po oBepttt lo l loo tt' oporo eo, o ee o oy yoB tll oJll Mx(y eo. peoe'tt ol]l' o o pyoe pe' Ceo. oe t lpoTo Io. Coopll oap l la e ypoBH
I]p, o eooB o p}l. oopo oe ooTBop-. B |959. oy l yttoBtll }loBl tlo y o.tlTIp oTo [po, oe e JIB tto p eBMl o oiull{l l[pe' e.ep pe Ba MollUlee oee oJlee eopeeoo}tl o B 1oo l.(poro. Co aoe pert.
ol lo oee, o oHo, Mee orrl pePex ye, ooPoe oo MoeT lott o [.[p' e'e o ax yH oBoo OPoTo, oo.y oH o Boy p,rHll oattl ' lJo e y,o oBtloe Pop'o jly)ee eee eo ooeoe' o opeo ollo! o e oM-eo, a eoe]l|{o! y oatiB yoBy oe oPl. Tp p Motllp to Boo).IloT oIB' 'pyoBl ot' ' ao.o oP.elllpo' B o roo oo lp|),
B ox o,l aoe vBve a.o o.oeo'
_ H oatp a oo atly a o.ooeo ' Me a'{e' o Eo e oe oti.o otll y o e, Po t lpoo e. Be'
,loooPtl ' ool\4y }Io e oe eo opeoIo-B tl o.o ,ltlBeuo po. p, o p.e oe oo oy 1o. otooe e e ef o.ao pPo oo, aooPo, ooae tlo. , oxo' a poH ].looo P o .oIlPtlI ot\,lo)tloI oo oo, Be y a olp oo, pe A' op oy Io Ixol PI o yoo Pya, K '(.
_ Hy, a ep y a.o ae o?. eo a o],t oefl opoeoMy yy.
otp oeP)
IoBPM tItIo oTo
3AAJIHo o oHAITBA
(Ho l epI)
y o CBPC
1. .I[oyI BTopoo Broro Coopa
llo yooy ooBtt oPeo pI ojx
oee, ) lt elle pl\,tetio ya ao
p oo),1 a oye}IT Bopoo Baoo Coopa:
opooBa 2| o,6p' |964 roa .oa oTy
o ll'p _ ''Ce Hapo'' (ar 5.6) oapooat 28 o-
p l965 oa .'p ''o ootl r'4olteo )I(tl pe.
1,lHo opeeIl,t yoB'' _ ''oepe o,',
lloy oPoy y PToy
Cpa o oya o a' oopI Pao-Tal ooot{ o, tl ooHrio o ''yp.
y op'' a a 5 6 ''e Hpo'', eo BI
a ttoIe eer B Ix TeTa' x otloToprio
yyeo. BPo eye aT, o ooPIe oyer
PBT oo _ o oi aotl oplt aeple
oo peey Coopy o. a,
o o oe oooll ' oopI aa
).eE aI o1oll )tttt pTIltt' tlxo e
oIl '' e p oo'', Be )e BI 5 6 ''a
Hpol'' tlo oaIBa, ''oopeMeBa-re'' oFrrco
) o)rto oI ooyo , 'oopett',
I.{p, ey,r oo, o ope' ooe ex op
oBlio )t-{.
p d l'opu oop t o
e o pe Bopo poo or ( eooplx ouepoo I{t{' ' riap' Po oa' pre) oxooT oo pavr op ovo) lla o e otpe' C Co peo p;r loy' o oaj oe oxoo yoopa3le o oe T [ep, ooJlee. p.ee aI ool x ), . o e oo MolU oe.tI IJ Moy o ya oEplltlo1'
e aee o oay' poo.'U{ 1950 ory P,re, e Po o
''oo.
pIIBIl'' ' Brra oriP' BauI olt.re eN'' ep oT 6 ltpa l956 p,ly ',oo pli''; Bo ee o foy opoy l- ae ll.
2. ooerr oIpo )rt
o Boporo B ruqKo?o oop
B o B tlilo oPoe olp. oo.pI pPoP leo' o o Ap' B ] ott.Ip rraa oPeea o]t' oorto PoyB[raeoe o)ll I poI o}toB. o EaJ,'loe ootloe epJtl B B 15 epe ' 'Copre
o'', e lo ]]'ao yae ',oe Pol oaoe oo ya B lt eTo oulr''.
B e'e e oatp }lPo Mee Coe pore o.oylll lt o epIeo}l' x oelteoe oBooBe ooo Il tlo.opoo IIoBopll ' 'oue aru''. ' ' , paoo o oyy tIoB' oopt Poo. ,'o p.o yp Boepy, o oooBeTt pooo _ ' 'peo''. ey , ayp Boep, ooaelloHlP po' oo o ta LjJ MIro .pTp MoItTIpo )t(l{, e oo poIl MoIl. PIe oeI' tto oeIlo' oPa optloltoe pa y tt4 epooa _ ae
'72
oo p pl{o t{ olralpo eM' oay' aI IIPol otlx.oy,a' oyx(Too BIIypee l a oe ePo
HT.orrr _ B oe o pyx eetlcx o.
eg!He|/^i1, l893 oy oluIx B oHa.
eeJ,t '
o y ttuyoN,t(yr oH, t{ o }to 'y.' o)o Po o, Peyo oopo ytl l l5 p
''Cop.Iea o''.r o p Bopo poo or eoopI e (o-
rrlp p x, orpo oeee C.o)olEoeo o,lTBoJ]oB poIx oo.oyo oeo olM oBeI oolleM! oTopoe o BoeryType BIopy o oe aoo yoe 'ooo-Be ePooaxo' Ho ooo Pooo py o.Tx _ Pep' o' o aao o' potx Moo p-llx ooB, poMIx. B 1948 oy epo vtlpo, eBlI.{ oeor yprle PBax poIMollo ePooao. o aeprr 1958 oy, o lyp a pa oex(e epoB o)Btlo Pot$tlt oaee oI, aEI o ,lBo Polx o-xoB.oyroB'
Coo ae l5 epa ' 'Coeprua o'', a PolMoaa.oJlyla oli| l pI ) oao' a Py rH oae ol (Poer pa oao, ''oopI BIT1 pyoooerl o }to cer a''). To ltpepootl.l oe,tIlo oor TPye, o aoeMpIx oal]Jx oe l.o PloT opoot{aIP' ooPI oo a,a.
oc depe''Coeptro o''
o apooa ePea''Coeprue o'' yp'o oaro ot aa o Te eP' oopl o.a ee oT Py.
!.pe ''Copta o'' I ooe Py oy.M. oaT, o oeP)a}r oyTa pa o.I oJloBa' t{flI BTaKo Kolrpea. uI Moa.e ea: orI TooBa oaa o tloo.eI' o ae Boa roopa rieyePeo ooJII{o
Too' eyeT PoP rt p ''Copl o''. o y Io e Ho a' lIo per o.It aoM opo y o o' ooptya I y l{ MoHlT' orooHaeo ).
poe oo, opea o 6I, ooe o}l.HI yoB o llo pr, rpoa ou ,lpr, o1oPle ro t oP o poe el oee,otp; op T ooo o yTolt aPPoore ex(y e oe otp IIoIIo.
.[ep ''optu o'' PToP x pa1
oo | eP' I or poa oltli' o oopl oJ]I{ t{ a IioB oIyx o-tllP pyooe yr oo (yeIe .f otlo ooT o o p|l^|l [J'po ptle.t ll oeo _ p' p').
B Pr o pl (Bpuyp, 19?5) pe. P' 'Copr o' ' t ool lIpeeo 1llI yo (tpa a o. - ''o or oux''); op Toy pe'a. pe
''Copre o', t ooI . To aoe potlxoo pyx pa' Mo-ltly oxoo oyal oeI [.M, o oo a o _ oaITyIo &ioy ITpTI o IJpB y o oo-t l'
Xpope upl oou!| a cop^|||l|olq Tan
o o MoaIpttx oP, oeHI peope,pooo yT oltr o'e, o y oopIClr peoo ol yaa orio yao eoTo.pl pTPrire ePI' t|y oPeeI oare o.a (olr aTo ooyroT oltt p or,lIllo oll] Pop [epax) ' Bo vpI'
1, Hoo ypaeT' o otll o eT Peeo o Po (o o co oop ' 'Ce Hapo''44 ''olea o'' 2 6, o oore epoBool or-t oP oay p' oTop oo- Hooy y).
peo l{ep il ooo apt(aoa), pcyt r!4ollloy p. eo,e oy' o ae eo oaleoe pae BIBaIo
e co flo yueru,r o ep' oIopI E oPeoo
aI{,ya Coo. o a oo eollo
y err-r ooe o oP olEo ,
oopy poo,r y ePa p||cnaflcKafl o.ora Pye.
2 oeo aee y opo.P y.oBIII eoooe e oB ytl o ep.
B y oo pa, plle Poo e.o
ePotl3aI P, aPaKpttI t o',t o
ox, UI yIaI tl 3aeEI Py' ooBat a
Co rr. o ole p oeH
oo oe' peT oo o po ''.,yooo pyoo.
a' ' .o ae Ptl ollTIpx o, o JraoP
oorxeN,Iy epy Io' o oH ott op-
yo ae: eo ''llooe poe'' Btl oa.
tpc o Be BtI,r I oHTIPNI t{ ToJIo
Py Boollo oPtlT' o ot{ oooPo
yyee.3. oo aoap yooy ooa o epoHo
oltIplt oI oy ott' o oIp _ o MTo
yxotloto ootl e' Tao otiTIPo aootto rrPoBIIo ooHtlo B oI, oeoBaBI a oopo.
B eo aaoo tltto' o a coo ee.
_ ee eo Ul otto )t{ ItoooalT yoar o,r op yo' a-ee epI .
yopeo T oM! oooopoo oo e oo ea oJI ol{o.oe rt eMoe o poo. poey oo.' apMP' PacoPo ooye, ltMIe p. oy ooo.
o o x orrrx oHt{ Bey o'
o1opIx ooe otlt{oo ooye.
4' pae epoo To eq oo PIoarp o oTHolII py. o eoxoo, oI a'oao o Bopoo aoo Coop, ao yao.
B ) Be ep, tlo.aoeMy y yoB )tltlPTaIr Mpy.
Doap PI ^'oarp irPey py xae'ye Py' o oePe' oy o}l' o Mollleoooe, oaIPoe aoT' Be py ''oepeI I{ep'' (''e Hpoa', 44) . [Iotle, oBeTo _ ''a.
tloo opooe poPooe oPoee Too' o eI.lepo''. Too opeo aoo pp o ollorrlelt My olu ox oeT pou HaKoeol\4ye oty I(ep o py, pyyy e.
opere opI ]oo pr p yy, o.tlo' P,1lI' :ll1o o opy orp..I|o oepa oT oHoBIIIl!'' eo eyT Pa-Tp K aty opy oTo.
3. MoarTo yierco )l(e
lo Bopoo Bauoo Coopa
3aaoe orTBo aio tlPT Ttlo ye Bo e eP ' B !lo' yetteo ooB e oPIB Toy, pooJlIeoo B p ''Coprue .o'', op. H pey a pIa epeee'ylroN' eye a :
1 ooae 1926 oy A epo oyo (1873-l960) ,lorp, oopt BoI rt{oll a}ioo o1oooopo. (oIP o 1839 oy peee o.)
2 _ Hryro l95 oy Hep ee-y tlo.
3 - yvee Boor l.I'ep, Pepoe ]930 oy C.o (Be).
B e ay-pay cy oy Ioop tllt'
e op Pye Mol Ba yeoat. Ta, a o epee (yep 1946 oy)pll A o ye ol{eBa yp .Itl oapx otlxoB. (Aae ooaa 193loy, ap aa') Heoopr Mollx Map x p. y epe . ap, a a)e poe riIpy, altl\4rx oPlll BoPo' Bo pa
'76
B o I ey yoyT per o aooTTo
ye _ Jl Poo yee Bp a
ylly aypy. o p pol
Pa ye yI ee ooooo .
TyT 1oo Cep (p, Cpeoe oop), a .
e ettl ' o ' a tp a.
Te}ry po paPoe oPa x Hee (A' e'' 'ooo y 1oo p,,. |914, P' lI.
114) .
ee oaI, ]e Bo Pe o
oy' BoooB oJI ooa olrt, Bo p
oeo peIlt ope o, Pooe B o.
rpe C-Ae Pe, o lII o pJ]
Pa,pr yex oTao' oe
olioBe o|x o (yeru tty
Hep, y o ytl aoo oo.
o C.M Tpp), yrx .
eoo oe P erleo ope' l l Bopo
Bo oop Io o1o ooo o p
y Pe oo P Pee.
t l l x '
o e Bopoo Bau ' o o o opo
o ye ye olto ypJr otlo
ey Too ePo pI PeoMa o.
tIM ey o, o }ta yPo}ll ot|tP oB'
Pooulx P l968, pyoil
ae BooIr oa, e eetll
Pa Tee. Cye )e oIly otil aM
olllo, y}loel o.po P' eo:
peyo oHa1o lt oP aoee o.
tt ptlx otp (o, ePl969 . ) .
pev Moa A poPa o ooy B.
I{oT po oo p a Meo .
tt Poo otlo .'eo Boo Poe C[tlA
4' otp ouI Peop IJp
u o, oa orte Artao p(opo'rle ellao ee) o oept pa.Ip, o o opoBo opotll{o ri tlo.10 ooe oo Moltea. M Ile o Bopoo Baaoo oop oopIe o Hro py o P yl{e ]yNlee Bpt i ot l'
B plt, Po,le Popu, o (o eoBo) tlooeIe pyt , poBox olop ). Pe XPTB, foxy oert MotI.tp, PyI Bo, ol oov [ep o-By, _ ooel l l lo' oe po Bopo Poo ol. oBe e o ttMe]Itlo, ,Io pMa . p o op ee lPoo ppoTp}to Bprro ool l le o.ry:' 'pol 1Moltlee poe yeoI
oe o, ' ' oopI o lt ooo o ooo ' ' (B. t t) .
poo ot le' 'ep po oI. '( ' eep) ooe Peaee o oM' o otll|pf o yxotloo ooPe , l B Ba|Iopo opot epB Ji opl yotlo.Pole o}t'
o o r o o
Bt t.v u npo o tt u a p
op oo l]ro pB o}tooB)eIl Peop ePBa o oIBa, o Ealllrlltl oo J]B(etI, otloIBatoo a oeeo p, Io y)e y rop o toI|e e oo Bopotl y Po}IoB oo )3tl ooeo, oorreo ila Peoa ope, o ooo Beprry o|lIlo olo , ooooMy' o lo tio l\''
Mrl L d ll t d u u
B op ooe ootll B pru.roy po]l, oo)l(lto, Ipao oopee vy I.lp,
'78
potl o pee po poo ot a y o.
o (Poo yap), y ooIx pTtlo.'',.e o ooe)K'', oIlo aa B
epoao t{ lee ePo, oepBa.
l eeI rBlo''Bapoe'' o po
poo or oett, oPo''Aoa e-
o oox''. eo o oPall to''oe p'', tto . 1935 oy _ ' 'pao
Boo a'', e aoee pe]Ttio
oo. oo yy llpy pyIIM}r I{ot{ pytl, ey oePy PaoTy yp TPI,
oao' o PHeH ''oM BToo Mxa'', 1
PyI oa }lpaBo e oo o.
ToPTeo.
uu oat
poy eI{teex tpy' pool otlyt ,
opoa N'ltoollI or oeN,r
oooB (P. yap}r) ' oa (o. a, . ),
TyPa (. ap) ' yl\4ea (. MeP, . eep):
oKI o' IIpe Bo' BIl all]!'' oopo
l1I xa p p aa'
T opao, yTaoBo oPyrreo paIx oo.
oBx ax, B aToT' o yptI op.
l op epooo yT.
p oo, 8 1943 o ' . Pp, o Itx oooo''p oo Ma'', pIIT B B o Il; Ta Bcp r oo.
oBa apao .-' o (yy o .
o VI), . eepoo ( pour,ro _ poe) pxe-
ooo . ypyo. Bo peM ay-{ Pp By aIIr u o ''pe Boo x''.
epe Ceeo peo oo po-
etlx [J'px oa o; oaKt
Pooa P opeTe ToJ]ex ).B' oo.
PIe ll3ria JI oo Ililtr tlpoB.
,o uo.
oo yaope ooPy yoBy} oT y apIoe oPe opolll Ppax [p.ax pB orla ouleoo xap'
Paa lle pyIt Mo>tto yItB'
vo y Mopx p ppy o o o a-
Pl oec oPe}t ! o p a o,ooa Tepeo (l697.1769), oa o tpe.llI oarlJe apPo.
yI o' otIoBaI T. epo(l800.l864)' A _ a p (l?80.t845), o pa -opo AriTytlo Bp (1799-1864) oo Me,ope oo) }l I(eH oPa, aMe toop.}loT; oo e e) a, app, oe''Bee'' aype.
.py oee' poTEr ''Btoo [p'' l''peopoa Popx ee o e, vo ae x .aa ya'', ollpyT o oo eea, 6oa pc oo'
Cp o )lIIx yx ) t,oopr orue Poox yeoBT o e, Da L ooaI o Bopo pooBoI' BaaT P Botlt{ oe ri; x oIe. o oey pTepy ox ooo Ha PaepoBo yMEy. Tot,p,rep,' 'pcopoo'' C _ o-te Nryti eE' )
oc a lrd p.ltlu
oe ott | tlo|tl, ol oeT tl pot|l.Uo PM. B .t pep I ytlotlM p .
.l yue o ecp p flpru.
3apee o ot Bao ep)tol otl.l tIx ' o t l ootlo ypo Pr-opo B o | l H l2 rp 1944 o' ooHolo Ppyllt !apr, poy MoooIx eye oo opol( ){(Boe yo l loa|l opa o p. yru pe o oy, lor ylt tI Boo ao,a Po, peoe eBP' B ooy o ' yuroo oeo o]| [io pure o oIloT ol leoa a po' o ,t peo oJ1tloy PoBoltt 0 p l947 o ' 'o-
I Ceep lr, lp' ' 'Blo oo M . yIe :)(!e.
y paeo o o]trt )l l e JII]oB opae ooPoy ( l.48 2.5) '
o oye ot| urpo ooa ope.o''eBeJlpy T' ' , o e ptteotypte . o p3Il pJltoy Pypy' l l Pl lx(.l lI ol.l\ ' opy oTBHItIe op,It KoopI o,l P, potl o.o.a ooa o J| pDel o|rI.
2 [lo, poo, orrr o y oJIoB' y Poetl.oB B]a o T. aao' o e oo oeaoe (pop) Poep , o o pl ypru l(et, tlP tl, oooa Tee'ooo ,ttl e poe oleT o p.
or o oe o Prl)o1. ' 'oto
ee' ' '(e lopo Me pItoJloe a o Bx Be pooo l),l'
oo eo oI _ , oaet l95].1953 r ' (t lcoo p ePe e). Ceye oM, o ]o y ePB oe el oHoM _ ooJlo ]Ieo, yyte'r ol.
82
ou{, r opoe M' Po)l P -
e opo B Coop. C e op otl e oo oTo.
oo P p To o.
y e yo o yre llll oo.
Ho Jlo yP epo . o
ye Pe o pT aMI oeotlttI. eI
otl oo Po ,,.l Pl.}t I t|oT]Iolllx
oe ]Py.l (po opIx Pox' o.
e ooelx ooPo Ur
PH) ' or e pe ooMl Poul-
aoM yep yPa}toT
p, apep' po. o Te oo
.rto ''Moo't Coop'', o Porl o tlo.
x P,' 'o;ror CoopI' ' oo oo-
pao Bo Be P' yo pB
IJp MtIo)o e, axox '
Cy ee P oepy]' o y yP.
e or op B yoo yTBe []p e.
eo oI oo oeepotroy ooe.
ou{r Pr e tl p, PI
x po' oTo '{ oep. o' o oe y, se
o e. Ceo y ooo op.
la tlo or .
B ae po P pca'
oet' ' I oo }( eo o.
t. JI.y pe po yy ya oo
ea' o, l oe' o He orT oooo
B.
J. B ' ooo l. }|xo,l y)o potlIrp oe. Jlyoo o tto a oHaIM o; ro p MolP oo Po PPo TPtl o}lIp' o eI p ooee oo ,tp yBo |oIe TP e.e' otp o yeIy ye o lI I' o Io 1975 oy' H o PyToir pIBTe Ceepo p'
3ro
Papa eITe' oeoBee Bopr Baa. Coopo, o l{I' Io otlto o Po eyepeo o PoB. Copao ilo rrtx oIyB oaTIpl ooy o o e o lltoHxo o e.r. fl.na 1964 oa oo ooIo y yo oalp eoo a oeytx. o ee oil'oo pH c clnlt]n' aPaeI{rl-r
''oopeeae''
ep.B e yru o e pelo l0 %, orroe
oI olPe, Pe)e eo, paa peeo Mp ae-y yyree.
HaI otloBl Iae yy6 yrB epBl-t,oToPo' ir r y oepil, ee o poo MeI{o1l ''oopeere'' oyoc ye peaBopoo Boo ooPa.
Bpe oao, uo l.lepo oo Toa IB o otlo.y' oa oBoytro B oMt(I ltepa, p-P, px P TPeero P aaT oeo (xo,oeol Pa Ioto apI otlIp Plo o a epI).
B o ot{I yoHy ''^[epe o oepo ee.o eP''' oop owro PoyeT a oll.e y}| oIx l.I'px.
epeo oM' o y otllI e yy, otloBll o e, o o oo o.ir poo qeooo' P eoo olllI poooo1r-{ e po tto ooMy, o ollo o e epo y) oaj oeH ooHHo llol{oo pyooo.
3o opoo tlo eltx MoalPe B- y po Hoo, e Potta Pao ooH oy ooe. ol,r ''o opI''(p.o' o ooPoy tIPoooooo o e oy ya Eppo o _ p' p') opae PB' p.yoPt tli MoalP o' o ee Po.' . e o ooo oaxM ptt ao y s oHo.}l tlleo oIPo ePe oIe ooop.}ll tlDBl.
Ditionnire de sptitul it6, lom l0' t i l ' 'onhism' ' ' ol ' l609.l6l7. ' 'I,esp.
l ivs lul ls' ' (I]mD]nuI von svIus)' oPyl ight Beuhsne, Pais l980'
84
xPotIA
PoBtIA ) l(3H
IIA Ax
paIo . ABP
r oPoT ott' o o xpr.aa Ha o A. He ee 9Uva ollaee (oo.o 40 .roo o) oyT y Hy PaoI{oPaa. x 92% _ o. B e l'eMop I| BeIee' ooPor o poBo' ito ooilPoEIl a ptt, opN'rpoeo oe'or.
Cr oe pe I o )l(y out epe, o e ooo yPEo, _ o, eBoo otllt' lle aIe. ooPI MI Too Topo,t' Tay eo oee opeI. Ho oe opoy o lo eoT l,t o.To.My oy y o Ipo BoIIoPye m{oLlep? oe e o I Mo o' oa o p- a. Cao o o o apoo,r ye oBTo fl Bopol.
Too o lloe e ey PaapBat' a poeeoBepoo e' o opee PoTo Poe oeao PeoT' oop xaPPy oi oI{p oel,r e ooP ooo y M JIe a'oa Pell po Ptt otlllo ooe. po pHHoI oll B eyr eao po:oTHoltl [J,p oe' y poey r*'oo opMypoa a opo: a opo [epo o o o poPo.y M B yox opltoo pela? o opo' oopI, eo, o}t tlo oBe, ! oe o eP orroBI'
ap, aer er Bolloto ooe
el'oP oo Bopo ooo ' B TeI e.eTl oI UIo oao e' oopoe e ee.I oo peo tlo}l|x eaP.llx o Ip o Be ,1l loo aooa yTP o. o ooa, opo.ot qae E oalttt are poo Po p paox accoat,rfl ooepo' ' }lttll oooaJ peooa fl ' tloI oP oTPep' o PorU,ro, o ao l lo' o otioey)JIa' M Tpyo oey D}l ooeP' llo-oo ee ypa e ot{Koo epeopo' oye eTPyro ro pr B oe, poflo o.l lt{o tl ' '' ' ' 'Ix' ' , o, r ool\4e'tBa' opeootl}l py ' '' ' , ox 5% ooeo t{ll' a ( oila oileya'
pxt PI o oeo po, opoo .e Porrl y>t
''r'', opo o }l peIte pa
poBlro eo, rlo ]oHoM ot{e- BoPoc, o o o' B ye ] tllTa oo oo Po a o oPotlI pBI{eetrlx eoI Pyo o o p,r l lpl alt
' 'oo
plopa' ' yp o I{p, Io! e{ ooB, o-a T oorx e ypa, o oreB ejlItof)e o,,r l]ep.
eeo, y oe trleTI e roo oaoeo otlIl\4 ' , pyypl Po.po BIaJI )lg4ti Bopo o oo ottoapeopI oo Ba. oo, Botlul o .e aP' oiJ,I ooe pel y.tITol a )' xo oPo e t|, o oaoB. ooo epB, BrtHa otlI peo.Po, ' al lo oy, peaeo oltopoo o re ye pee Bryo pepe, aeo o poy)H oetloo Moo.' oaett oooBo, paPTlBul pol aIBeoo ' 'oooBI,l oot' ' (o o Pola op rupoyro eo) .
fiooo aere o}l l.[p o yyurrro:roo oo' t l o P MPe, l ooe
eorrl t{o ep ' 'r' '
P eIa }Ie oee B TP}l 1912 ro Botloo oo)ett,
L e ooa P'oal' o oo o ll o9'IIPottoB Poe fol. t
,lo ot l7 eoo l7 oTe otp (y-x ). o to pBo tioc Blylt oBottoo ooe B P. oo eo o peeflo poa y lloN{.
l9?3. B ap oPol\l op (ePo oJle eBotloo oo B p) o| oIT,II Poperool per po. oel ot peo. .
aePo' oo' o ePB oPo Ka oooooe eo oe tlpo, o .l}| y .M. o e pao BIya e o oe. BoPo . e o}lT l,t oo -oa oee? o opo e oyJl yo]IeopToopPerrr. H uto oyo oe ooo a.ltoo oye. B o)o,l ye oo o oeoIloo)t(. oo oeoo oe' oloPo olt o.y)o eoa oJty. yI. , .ol oy opooJl oio oe lPKoeoa o e!,t P' Hao oattoal IIot{ oJlo eo . eo| olTl{ooB tloopl ur ooe oll l ?UIopo ry ae' aoUl yo otloope' Bo,t, ol, o, Ul e| oM Ilo..o o }lo ootlI ' B e ox}t Pyut o.o pt o, o lo tlo, o otly, oorro opo olloo oo. l.I'po ' el ott' eol.
|9.l4. Hx oM oP eoI tipE npeypoy 'ro o poo op}l po o}tlioo OJlo.)ll B p}l oItto pe aa ot' oe o1o . Be e .Jl oo oo o epI oM lpoe o o o{oe}lo oJroto oo)e.oopoe Ppro yyuxulo
l975. |912 ro pee pt.t opoa oopepeyoB o ol]'y Boeoo oo) (' '' ' ' 'PoB''?)
rooPI py Bono ype po. p o e-et PM ol erel o ]o ot lIroo poT Poy ol\,loo eoPeBtlo y.oB ypert oypol\4. Be I xoporuo, e 6l e oo: pepyt norrtI,t o, y-r lU 1oo, ol tlp Py Bo flot{o op. Hol
90 9 l
pepy,r peoo PoB l9?5 o, }lo oBype{ Pol , BllI tlooo yH)tt oeo oo.Il :l Po p tloo' poI I|ep., ooeo e' o PH y oo aooe,ttil oop o ooe. ot oe oP ypoyrt oyo oN,ttt' ooPo o oooPe ottoo yo, ooP peepey oo
o oe TIeo ooBopI ool oye.IBee pB ooa. Bopo o ooe oB oPll,o (, o paPBa o oyMll opo o p.' py )e o, o eye ea' oPypoIeB o}l yoB e yy errI.
l976. Ceyu ppy oco op oa JlePolloto t}|B oo''e, eporu aru'' 'ApBr oe oo oPerr, ll [ooeTo.l' l l o Bl oa, oyo o' ooPoapoe oN,I}tl 1975 o lo ooo a oM.tl o oI\4' o ye eepey I oPJIttlM oM Px
oo l oao Tl' e o oa a oeTooo o' oTopoo oT eo oa'
l9?9. .I]'o op )T pe l I.[o .o tl BI opao' rr 1' oo - ooPtlo _ aT ''l e!t'' ltp. Ho
eprre - oo a oy y_p,r {I py
ooo po poB oyopee, oyl oo,1T' e o o pt{ yo poa, P o.lloptlo' oel Botloo oo Tpae. B py ePxxeoI' Pa o IIoooxoTI' oo o P!lN|Py.B ept a op ecoI' oPe ooepe' oyo oo pio, pelteooeperr, o, oopo Poiut a Prx'T eI. o o pyao o oao e oee T.oo lt' ya e oxprr pe) ooee' P o.oPo ooTye eyepl pooJl.
o xPooooe Pe oeo or{ rt. ooB yo ooo oJlo)e p o'oeo' otlt oot pP' r lro e zul oPyx, I oPl apeP' o oIax alopo- y o' yx o oPoI Hyu Po yp'Mt y' TlloT, oyapeoo pap B,oy opearo n oPe oaxo. Ho tI{ eoo o.oy' o ylr, o tlI ery- PI' papl o ep,fl p o -a eI oo eP: eol,P' oll p. Too otl oyr pert ao a-PB y e o l.lepo.
r ea ao aa o Pltl yaTe Bo e I or-T oax, ex ltpx' Bo o ya' oItoyBpT' o or pPy x tl. Aoaol o}tII eo lp ootlo )lypoJr B l >to't eP olx yJlox. eo otoiopypo Brpae''pveoe opy..to'' y.eJo ooli eo op oo ooo otlo.erl o ey, oy oI|\4 ooe pe. oIae to po eo, o-ltlo oToP aotlooT tl py oTeo ey ooPoo' Hro po eo oo a r-t o oH.
o oy e oe p' o oo.y' To olt' e eT' e pooo' .
92
lpoy py IIo I]p, , ooplpal e (po, , yt e eyu). o v, vo tltt lPa y apoee o l]ep. oe r, ' o r, e _PyIto T. o , ro T, ol oe arlo a.T opo oti oilI' o PB oa' o'(ay, o oee e. }ioopo, oo.ool{ poerto eoo oPee' pe .e' ee y o I.lp.
. oor D
r, pe! ooPIe oeHo BlB' Ur oepooPr, o Poo poooo)lIl-t. Be e,}top rreoopy oy eoT, oPy ettoB B oee oIN,t. oe I prrl pTI'TeM jx ooy lo: pat' eIe' .pTI - Pe ro ooy' o all ea yy.e a ll oe opaK (oro e pI\4Ipo11 pr''ooo e'' [ep, ootoltolil r e o' o ae) ' oy .po }rPo tlo P oo x.o .oP, art oo. oo t paMoTpe oep, oopo o}to Parrlx o oey yoaTpoe py.ax, oayx I]po, 1o' pyI opee I.{po'o p ep' pe' lI o[otll a ao oP.e oo oollti oo. To oxol,lo eT rHoo c|ta|. Co' yp oHoBrtlx y'eyu o}| p, _ patlo' l o, oopIe o yx yx, o o 'Byx ''aa'' [(po aK uuTIt., [epo r.a pod'
oop o I]ep a o y T opT ]IBoll a epp opo ePPy B' PBrllio oBPr'||17 pfll|l, tl Poo yo' , oPool{o yl ooy oor e,x }lIx BoTy Poy lox' tt oo-o ye B oypHI allIx ype-x' tt toopeo ope' yoo ooPeoo, aoy o ex, oao oeP ePoBlo,' p' Too ee p.
oop o [ep o Poe 1 I a ptl{ yae ptl Poo rr oy erBo'
oHI,t aPooit ll prtl, orre oPooiro ti pa., ay ooa o' ro P l I,l oo, e poJII oooe o eo aPoaoeo' opal{ oo oy)la , oyo Peo' oa Poo Boo Po ol\'o.u!, aoy o Potl or, yep}r or pee.o BepI,oy o Poo3, ooepa orx eelfl{'
'e pyr ao I{p, olttlo' tl I py pyt. oeo o}Iol To ooo eT tlll oy 3 Ixty o.o oeo oe},t l{ep, o Paeo Poolo eep a . Tol poI' ooPt, ]ra, eoxo,ro irPoB tl oopt lo)lI pIl,lt' o o o atIPaeH y rrpo cMo o Toot aoy ey [p pay olaee' o' o oePe' IIoB oo at oJut oo or [ep'
Papa, a P oI' Bll, ollt! Pe P r otlPHl oee poet, eo Pa.tIT o, To of o eoo ( oeoM T, eoo o pel) .
Coo' a' tl tl oa ep Iy' Be ye Ptl yPeyeooe:
l ' pee eo l.lepo o yot|o oop o po' eo IIoa' yP oypBo .. -
e Eaxoll e oe.2. 'D o oe IJ'p ooro oTo.
o, Tot oyaPTBo oBao Peoy oo, To pBo aoo P)tqla BIp oT o oo ol}to, po [.(p To JI oep ooy,po l.(ep lol, p, ot ..
3. CoI aoo _ o oToPTe eo,BH ool pp Poero foooo PB.
l.|po a.o opo yye B ooeo' o o l ooy, 1o Pos oo aoIuto yPo3(), ooly' 1o PaBIee}lte olloBe o.t tloMel o ep o oPoa pBo,opT' poooHl TBl T aeJrllIooJIe aa ypoa yeo al Qo ooo oo (to. ollM '.).
4' o Bex oaI BoPoax' ox o ee o.!v| xPapoNI' ePo oIt oT o-tltl ooIx ptto' lx ex y 'aa otipe.le ya ptto oo Ty'
9495
5. otl, IJ'po o yeTo oat eI; oTo o - Ta el KK pe, Pla.o po-tx.
Te e, o paP po po' rra a .y ooex:
l. yeee tcl,rc I{p e oo' eo y' ee eoB e oo K JlB.yy' o K e or. T oPo, pae aPol r po' eo ooe, fotloMeo, ol-aoe yoo ro. oy )t(e Toottl ) po pa-Mpar ao B |o Pyt PyoM.
2' T e' 1o B p ool oPy oee'ao y o() Io opt ro ll ooPeo3o ool, a p o oo oo, }re oo o oye o plIT' tlo' a o}ll{oTe' pPytl o Jlo}ro BooI,
3. or eo [.{p ott o oR.e Po oa' p tl oJlo oJle' tloa olloex (tlooy otl e o op aar llHltllo To B oBIteo eeo l.I'p) ;a eeoI ori oBo olpo Po' o-oHoo Po ooy oeo ooo ooa'aPo, al oopoo ee oy oeIlo y-ye B )tl o oa.
4. B o eIo l]p oe popoo, eyoope llj 11oe MoPtllx nHoB' llo)Bye oJIo tle aPoo' op p.te MeTe ox ollo xp oeo eo e olrpol aTpytl' }ro pa.PB oooe yoll' aoB t{oo opo.eo[o y)e ll'p'
5. , oytl ]oo rlooo pttto t o tl o oo eo, lt yT pTB' ooByre o}IoB}llo oo'' l.(ep -Ho''.
ppo oal o B o oot|o xeTo' Booo' o p oTpo e o}lell l.|ep, ya ll x ttoIotto tlooo oooae, a Ia o'o oaye t{I E oolil lp o,lltoyl l.[p. e p yy pat' Ho oea ]To, o oll ttc oxo'(e Py a py p o l.[p. _ [epo y epoB tlpo' eao oT
oo, oooal{t o ooo lt T' oPol y)e oaP I oBPeo o [!p. Pa- _ Jry eeJIo I{p oe' ]oo.e Pyx ox )tr aPo yo l{ooopea' aeo, paJIeo oa oe rtpeooolltloo op, _ 1 a a oT p ' pl.Ta o [ep )e rreoolo ope oK{J ]l eTeo' tto oot o)lt.
' 'ueo op'o'' opo?
oflPre e}to o eP, aoo po o oo otl l.I'ep. Ia a yooopo ep, o po e paB pyeTeo Pot{I pyyp' pe) o' poa lo' aIIl eyr yy e Pe P-o po ]tlI. pyo ) oPotlt. tl ti' 'apoo'' opo I{p, o po ye po B o
!tl,l'lloBlitlIx TPoB' a, oJIe oo
oo poa: rpoa, pr oea' B eopo rl eprl. t yM ]oM yyy Poa' pol y)l el' oBl'IB y ax.o otlo.yJlyP}|Ix ooellB o }loeBa: y}rtlIe, epal, l, ole ]ll]'.
T o aoPo ooJlo M' e oJI)lt pplB
et{oI P, eo opao oLlt, uer o) .aT a pl B', aK H oo aMa tlooNrae o.paoy oM Pyo ye' o loPlttx eyx l1 oPt x y y ato.Ptloy' Ca r' oTopr pll pa, pI: B olto,r y poee oT P ,lr
oIBa, B Pyo epep oo oe]. olt Pee orr y'y pI,r. B ePe l(epo e.
Peo EeT opyI{a ll. o
Top Related