NATIONAL SCHOOL DEBATING CHAMPIONSHIP 2010

Adjudication Sheet

Round : _______________________________________________________ Room : _______________________

Chairperson : _____________________________ Timekeeper : _____________________________________

Motion : __________________________________________________________________________________________

Judge : _________________ (mandatory to fill)

PROPOSITION : ___________________________________________

Order Name STYLE(24 - 32)

CONTENT(24 - 32)

STRATEGY(12 - 16)

Total(60 -80)

83)

Time(normal: 8min.)

1st

2nd

3rd

(Reply speech is scored as half of substantive speech) (12-16) (12-16) (6-8) (30-40) (normal: 5 min.)

Reply

Final Score

Opposition : _____________________________________

Order Name STYLE(24 - 32)

CONTENT(24 - 32)

STRATEGY(12 - 16)

Total(60 -80)

Time(normal: 8min.)

1st

2nd

3rd

(Reply speech is scored as half of substantive speech) (12-16) (12-16) (6-8) (30-40) (normal: 5 min.)

Reply

Final Score

Winner : Affirmative / Negative Close / Clear

Best Speaker : _____________________ Margin : _____________________

Marking ScaleSome scenarios of Substantive speeches (1st, 2nd, and 3rd)

are marked as follows : Judge Point Total Score Meaning Decision Winning

TeamDefeated

Team60-61 Very poor Unanimous 3 062-65 Below average – Poor

66-69 Pass Split 2 170 Average

71-73 Slightly Above average, a more solid analysis and structured speech

Single Adjudicator Clear Debate

74-76 Advanced analysis, outstanding persuasiveness

3 0

76-79 Advanced analysis, outstanding persuasiveness, excellent structure

Close Debate

80 Prophetic 2 1

NATIONAL SCHOOL DEBATING CHAMPIONSHIP 2010

Adjudication Sheet

CHA