The relevant scale for mechanical modelling in additive ... · The relevant scale for mechanical...

18
The relevant scale for mechanical modelling in additive manufacturing technologies Sofiane Guessasma 1 & Sofiane Belhabib 2 1 INRA, research unit BIA, Nantes, France [email protected] 2 IUMR CNRS GEPEA, University of Nantes, France [email protected]

Transcript of The relevant scale for mechanical modelling in additive ... · The relevant scale for mechanical...

Page 1: The relevant scale for mechanical modelling in additive ... · The relevant scale for mechanical modelling in additive manufacturing technologies Sofiane Guessasma1 & Sofiane Belhabib2

The relevant scale for mechanical modelling in additive manufacturing

technologiesSofiane Guessasma1 & Sofiane Belhabib2

1INRA, research unit BIA, Nantes, France [email protected]

2IUMR CNRS GEPEA, University of Nantes, France [email protected]

Page 2: The relevant scale for mechanical modelling in additive ... · The relevant scale for mechanical modelling in additive manufacturing technologies Sofiane Guessasma1 & Sofiane Belhabib2

Basics of FE simulation in structural mechanics

Complex load/geometry + simple mechanical law

Complex mechanical response + simple load configuration

Complexity in both mechanical law + configuration

Page 3: The relevant scale for mechanical modelling in additive ... · The relevant scale for mechanical modelling in additive manufacturing technologies Sofiane Guessasma1 & Sofiane Belhabib2

Fused filament (FDM)

Stereolithography

Droplet-based

Materialdiscontinuity

Source of complexity: material discontinuities

Page 4: The relevant scale for mechanical modelling in additive ... · The relevant scale for mechanical modelling in additive manufacturing technologies Sofiane Guessasma1 & Sofiane Belhabib2

Mechanical response in additive manufacturing

Page 5: The relevant scale for mechanical modelling in additive ... · The relevant scale for mechanical modelling in additive manufacturing technologies Sofiane Guessasma1 & Sofiane Belhabib2

Mechanical response in additive manufacturing

Page 6: The relevant scale for mechanical modelling in additive ... · The relevant scale for mechanical modelling in additive manufacturing technologies Sofiane Guessasma1 & Sofiane Belhabib2

Mechanical response in additive manufacturing

Page 7: The relevant scale for mechanical modelling in additive ... · The relevant scale for mechanical modelling in additive manufacturing technologies Sofiane Guessasma1 & Sofiane Belhabib2

Mechanical response in additive manufacturing

Page 8: The relevant scale for mechanical modelling in additive ... · The relevant scale for mechanical modelling in additive manufacturing technologies Sofiane Guessasma1 & Sofiane Belhabib2

Comsol model:Handelling raster effect filament crossing sequence +45°/‐45°

Regular meshing (2.7 M dof)

Page 9: The relevant scale for mechanical modelling in additive ... · The relevant scale for mechanical modelling in additive manufacturing technologies Sofiane Guessasma1 & Sofiane Belhabib2

Building direction

X’

Y’

Z

In‐plane (XY)

XY

Fused Deposition modelling: printing angle

Page 10: The relevant scale for mechanical modelling in additive ... · The relevant scale for mechanical modelling in additive manufacturing technologies Sofiane Guessasma1 & Sofiane Belhabib2

Local property distribution

Topological law: Young’s modulus = 45°

= 30°= 0°

1.00

1.051.101.151.201.251.30

E (GPa)

Page 11: The relevant scale for mechanical modelling in additive ... · The relevant scale for mechanical modelling in additive manufacturing technologies Sofiane Guessasma1 & Sofiane Belhabib2

Compression behaviour

Heteregeneous strain field

Positive strain Poisson’s expansion

Crack opening (mixed mode)

Page 12: The relevant scale for mechanical modelling in additive ... · The relevant scale for mechanical modelling in additive manufacturing technologies Sofiane Guessasma1 & Sofiane Belhabib2

Explaining effect of raster on performance

Comsol predictions

3D imaging

Page 13: The relevant scale for mechanical modelling in additive ... · The relevant scale for mechanical modelling in additive manufacturing technologies Sofiane Guessasma1 & Sofiane Belhabib2

CAD-based modelling:

Compression performance of

cellular structures

Comparison between FE and

experimental Young’s moduli

Strain field100 150 200 250 300 350 400100

150

200

250

300

350

400

Pre

dict

ed (M

Pa)

Experimental (MPa)

Filament-based simulation R²=0.87 Design-based simulation R²=0.46

Perfect matching

100 150 200 250 300 350 400100

150

200

250

300

350

400

Pre

dict

ed (M

Pa)

Experimental (MPa)

Filament-based simulation R²=0.87 Design-based simulation R²=0.46

Perfect matching

Page 14: The relevant scale for mechanical modelling in additive ... · The relevant scale for mechanical modelling in additive manufacturing technologies Sofiane Guessasma1 & Sofiane Belhabib2

100 150 200 250 300 350 400100

150

200

250

300

350

400

Pre

dict

ed (M

Pa)

Experimental (MPa)

Filament-based simulation R²=0.87 Design-based simulation R²=0.46

Perfect matching

Heterogeneous strain field based on implementation of Filament-trajectory

Filament-based modelling: Best

fit to experimental

conditions

Page 15: The relevant scale for mechanical modelling in additive ... · The relevant scale for mechanical modelling in additive manufacturing technologies Sofiane Guessasma1 & Sofiane Belhabib2

Conclusions

Relevant scale for FE modelling in additive manufacturing : microstructural heterogeneity

Page 16: The relevant scale for mechanical modelling in additive ... · The relevant scale for mechanical modelling in additive manufacturing technologies Sofiane Guessasma1 & Sofiane Belhabib2

Conclusions Filament-based FE simulation: lack of cohesion

between filament + process-induced porosity

Page 17: The relevant scale for mechanical modelling in additive ... · The relevant scale for mechanical modelling in additive manufacturing technologies Sofiane Guessasma1 & Sofiane Belhabib2

Conclusions Unrealistic predictions from CAD-based models

Page 18: The relevant scale for mechanical modelling in additive ... · The relevant scale for mechanical modelling in additive manufacturing technologies Sofiane Guessasma1 & Sofiane Belhabib2

Conclusions Complex deformation mechanisms guided by

process conditions (printing angle)