The Global Energy SuperGrid - W2AGZ

68
The Global Energy SuperGrid Powering the Thousand Year Old Man Chauncey Starr Founder & President Emeritus Paul M. Grant Science Fellow Electric Power Research Institute

Transcript of The Global Energy SuperGrid - W2AGZ

Page 1: The Global Energy SuperGrid - W2AGZ

The Global Energy SuperGrid

Powering the Thousand Year Old ManChauncey Starr

Founder & President Emeritus

Paul M. GrantScience Fellow

Electric Power Research Institute

Page 2: The Global Energy SuperGrid - W2AGZ

The Next 1000 Years: The Global Energy SuperGrid - Paul M. Grant, 23 September 2003

Chauncey Starr

"If scientists and engineers think they can build something, they will invariably do it…

without much thought to the consequences!"

Page 3: The Global Energy SuperGrid - W2AGZ

The Next 1000 Years: The Global Energy SuperGrid - Paul M. Grant, 23 September 2003

Page 4: The Global Energy SuperGrid - W2AGZ

The Next 1000 Years: The Global Energy SuperGrid - Paul M. Grant, 23 September 2003

I. Any discussion of the application of energy technology must involve, from the very start, an explicit social and political scenario

II. The unique aspect of energy as a life-sustaining necessity separates it from the jurisdiction of many of the usual “laws” of economics

The Energy Lemmas

Page 5: The Global Energy SuperGrid - W2AGZ

The Next 1000 Years: The Global Energy SuperGrid - Paul M. Grant, 23 September 2003

The Challenge

•Design a global energy economy to meet the needs of a densely populated industrialized world of 1010 souls in 2050 (1012 by 3000?)

•Accomplish this within the highest levels of environmental, esthetic, safe, reliable, efficient and secure engineering practice possible.

Page 6: The Global Energy SuperGrid - W2AGZ

The Next 1000 Years: The Global Energy SuperGrid - Paul M. Grant, 23 September 2003

A Symbiosis of Nuclear/Hydrogen/SuperconductivityTechnologies supplying Carbon-free,

Non-Intrusive Energy for all Inhabitants of Planet Earth

The Solution

Page 7: The Global Energy SuperGrid - W2AGZ

The Next 1000 Years: The Global Energy SuperGrid - Paul M. Grant, 23 September 2003

“The Magic Words”

• Safe Nuclear Power• Superconductivity• Hydrogen• Energy Storage• Environmentally Friendly• No Greenhouse Gases• Non-Eco-Invasive• Global in Scope

(fission and fusion)

Page 8: The Global Energy SuperGrid - W2AGZ

The Next 1000 Years: The Global Energy SuperGrid - Paul M. Grant, 23 September 2003

Past & Future Energy Supply

Year (Modern Era)

Rel

ativ

e U

nits

Fission

Hydrogen

Page 9: The Global Energy SuperGrid - W2AGZ

The Next 1000 Years: The Global Energy SuperGrid - Paul M. Grant, 23 September 2003

Diablo Canyon

Page 10: The Global Energy SuperGrid - W2AGZ

The Next 1000 Years: The Global Energy SuperGrid - Paul M. Grant, 23 September 2003

California Coast Power

Diablo Canyon2200 MWPower Plant

Wind FarmEquivalent

Page 11: The Global Energy SuperGrid - W2AGZ

The Next 1000 Years: The Global Energy SuperGrid - Paul M. Grant, 23 September 2003

Particle/Pebble Nuclear Fuel

Page 12: The Global Energy SuperGrid - W2AGZ

The Next 1000 Years: The Global Energy SuperGrid - Paul M. Grant, 23 September 2003

High Temperature Gas Cooled Reactor

Page 13: The Global Energy SuperGrid - W2AGZ

The Next 1000 Years: The Global Energy SuperGrid - Paul M. Grant, 23 September 2003

Eskom Pebble Bed Modular Reactor

• Helium gas cooled (Brayton Cycle)– Won’t melt down– Direct turbine drive

• “Baseball” packaged fuel– Continuous fuel replenishment and removal– Theoretical 100% availability

• Modular Design– Scalable: 100 – 500 MW units– High safety and security factor

• Economical– 1.2 cents/kWh … cheaper than coal

Page 14: The Global Energy SuperGrid - W2AGZ

The Next 1000 Years: The Global Energy SuperGrid - Paul M. Grant, 23 September 2003

Hindenburg Hysteria

The Hindenburg did not crashBecause of a hydrogen leak!

Page 15: The Global Energy SuperGrid - W2AGZ

The Next 1000 Years: The Global Energy SuperGrid - Paul M. Grant, 23 September 2003

The Hydrogen Economy

• You have to make it, just like electricity• Electricity can make H2, and H2 can make

electricity (2H2O 2H2 + O2)• You have to make a lot of it• You can make it cold, - 419 F (21 K)

P. M. Grant, “Hydrogen Lifts Off,” Nature, 10 July 2003

Page 16: The Global Energy SuperGrid - W2AGZ

The Next 1000 Years: The Global Energy SuperGrid - Paul M. Grant, 23 September 2003

Fathers of Cryogenics

Dewar Kammerlingh-Onnes

CH4 112 KO 90N2 77Ne 27H2 20He 4.2

Page 17: The Global Energy SuperGrid - W2AGZ

The Next 1000 Years: The Global Energy SuperGrid - Paul M. Grant, 23 September 2003

Thus the mercury at 4.2 K has entered a new state, which, owing to its particular electrical properties, can be called the state of superconductivity

H. Kamerlingh-Onnes (1911)

1911: A Big Surprise!

Page 18: The Global Energy SuperGrid - W2AGZ

The Next 1000 Years: The Global Energy SuperGrid - Paul M. Grant, 23 September 2003

1986: Another Big Surprise!

Bednorz and MuellerIBM Zuerich, 1986

1980 2000

Hig

h-T C

164 K

La-214

Hg-1223

V3Si

1900 1920 1940 19600

50

100

150

200

Tem

pera

ture

, TC

(K)

Year

Low-TCHg

Onset TC = 40 K !

La-Ba-Cu-O

Page 19: The Global Energy SuperGrid - W2AGZ

The Next 1000 Years: The Global Energy SuperGrid - Paul M. Grant, 23 September 2003

1987: “The Prize!”

Page 20: The Global Energy SuperGrid - W2AGZ

The Next 1000 Years: The Global Energy SuperGrid - Paul M. Grant, 23 September 2003

The Future2028

Page 21: The Global Energy SuperGrid - W2AGZ

The Next 1000 Years: The Global Energy SuperGrid - Paul M. Grant, 23 September 2003

HTSC Wire Can Now Be Made!

Page 22: The Global Energy SuperGrid - W2AGZ

The Next 1000 Years: The Global Energy SuperGrid - Paul M. Grant, 23 September 2003

SuperCables

+v I-v

I

H2 H2

Circuit #1 +v I-v

I

H2 H2

Circuit #2

Multiple circuitscan be laid in single trench

SC-LVDC+

LH2

Page 23: The Global Energy SuperGrid - W2AGZ

The Next 1000 Years: The Global Energy SuperGrid - Paul M. Grant, 23 September 2003

LH2 SuperCable

HV Insulation

“Super-Insulation”

Superconductor

Hydrogen

DO

DH2

tsc

Page 24: The Global Energy SuperGrid - W2AGZ

The Next 1000 Years: The Global Energy SuperGrid - Paul M. Grant, 23 September 2003

SuperGrid

C. S. Starr, “Continential SuperGrid,” Nuclear News, Spring Issue, 2002

Page 25: The Global Energy SuperGrid - W2AGZ

The Next 1000 Years: The Global Energy SuperGrid - Paul M. Grant, 23 September 2003

The Standard Model

Page 26: The Global Energy SuperGrid - W2AGZ

The Next 1000 Years: The Global Energy SuperGrid - Paul M. Grant, 23 September 2003

~ 150 m

Next American Big-Bang-atron

Page 27: The Global Energy SuperGrid - W2AGZ

The Next 1000 Years: The Global Energy SuperGrid - Paul M. Grant, 23 September 2003

Low-Field VLHC

Page 28: The Global Energy SuperGrid - W2AGZ

The Next 1000 Years: The Global Energy SuperGrid - Paul M. Grant, 23 September 2003

Battery Powered TBM

Page 29: The Global Energy SuperGrid - W2AGZ

The Next 1000 Years: The Global Energy SuperGrid - Paul M. Grant, 23 September 2003

Little Bites

Page 30: The Global Energy SuperGrid - W2AGZ

The Next 1000 Years: The Global Energy SuperGrid - Paul M. Grant, 23 September 2003

LOVAT TBM

Page 31: The Global Energy SuperGrid - W2AGZ

The Next 1000 Years: The Global Energy SuperGrid - Paul M. Grant, 23 September 2003

Big Bites

Page 32: The Global Energy SuperGrid - W2AGZ

The Next 1000 Years: The Global Energy SuperGrid - Paul M. Grant, 23 September 2003

Tunnels Have Multiple Uses

• Energy Transport• Communication• People• Material

…and, with minimal maintenance, once constructed, they’re there for millenia! (unless they carry water!)New Yorker, 9/1/03. “City of Water”

Tunnels are an enabling technologyfor the SuperGrid

Page 33: The Global Energy SuperGrid - W2AGZ

The Next 1000 Years: The Global Energy SuperGrid - Paul M. Grant, 23 September 2003

Rock Group

Page 34: The Global Energy SuperGrid - W2AGZ

The Next 1000 Years: The Global Energy SuperGrid - Paul M. Grant, 23 September 2003

H2

e–

H2e–

H2

e–H2

e–

Commercial

Residential

BMW Z9

Heavy Industry

Energy Storage

Solar Roofs

Urban BiomassHTGCR

Nuclear Plant

The US Energy SuperGrid

Page 35: The Global Energy SuperGrid - W2AGZ

The Next 1000 Years: The Global Energy SuperGrid - Paul M. Grant, 23 September 2003

North America

Page 36: The Global Energy SuperGrid - W2AGZ

The Next 1000 Years: The Global Energy SuperGrid - Paul M. Grant, 23 September 2003

China: Present

Page 37: The Global Energy SuperGrid - W2AGZ

The Next 1000 Years: The Global Energy SuperGrid - Paul M. Grant, 23 September 2003

China: 2005

Page 38: The Global Energy SuperGrid - W2AGZ

The Next 1000 Years: The Global Energy SuperGrid - Paul M. Grant, 23 September 2003

China: 2010

Page 39: The Global Energy SuperGrid - W2AGZ

The Next 1000 Years: The Global Energy SuperGrid - Paul M. Grant, 23 September 2003

China: 2015 - 2020

Page 40: The Global Energy SuperGrid - W2AGZ

The Next 1000 Years: The Global Energy SuperGrid - Paul M. Grant, 23 September 2003

“Fuel-Head” and/orNuclear Generation

Pan-Asia

Page 41: The Global Energy SuperGrid - W2AGZ

The Next 1000 Years: The Global Energy SuperGrid - Paul M. Grant, 23 September 2003

Future Power Lines:Southeast Asia

Page 42: The Global Energy SuperGrid - W2AGZ

The Next 1000 Years: The Global Energy SuperGrid - Paul M. Grant, 23 September 2003

Middle East

Page 43: The Global Energy SuperGrid - W2AGZ

The Next 1000 Years: The Global Energy SuperGrid - Paul M. Grant, 23 September 2003

South America

Page 44: The Global Energy SuperGrid - W2AGZ

The Next 1000 Years: The Global Energy SuperGrid - Paul M. Grant, 23 September 2003

Back to the Moon

Page 45: The Global Energy SuperGrid - W2AGZ

The Next 1000 Years: The Global Energy SuperGrid - Paul M. Grant, 23 September 2003

Page 46: The Global Energy SuperGrid - W2AGZ

The Next 1000 Years: The Global Energy SuperGrid - Paul M. Grant, 23 September 2003

The 1000 Year Slide Rule

2001 2010 2100 3000

Cryo-Si GPS-LaserGuided TBM

Fusion

HTGCR RT-SC

Page 47: The Global Energy SuperGrid - W2AGZ

The Next 1000 Years: The Global Energy SuperGrid - Paul M. Grant, 23 September 2003

Page 48: The Global Energy SuperGrid - W2AGZ

The Next 1000 Years: The Global Energy SuperGrid - Paul M. Grant, 23 September 2003

Page 49: The Global Energy SuperGrid - W2AGZ

The Next 1000 Years: The Global Energy SuperGrid - Paul M. Grant, 23 September 2003

Page 50: The Global Energy SuperGrid - W2AGZ

The Next 1000 Years: The Global Energy SuperGrid - Paul M. Grant, 23 September 2003

Page 51: The Global Energy SuperGrid - W2AGZ

The Next 1000 Years: The Global Energy SuperGrid - Paul M. Grant, 23 September 2003

Page 52: The Global Energy SuperGrid - W2AGZ

The Next 1000 Years: The Global Energy SuperGrid - Paul M. Grant, 23 September 2003

Page 53: The Global Energy SuperGrid - W2AGZ

The Next 1000 Years: The Global Energy SuperGrid - Paul M. Grant, 23 September 2003

Page 54: The Global Energy SuperGrid - W2AGZ

The Next 1000 Years: The Global Energy SuperGrid - Paul M. Grant, 23 September 2003

Page 55: The Global Energy SuperGrid - W2AGZ

The Next 1000 Years: The Global Energy SuperGrid - Paul M. Grant, 23 September 2003

Page 56: The Global Energy SuperGrid - W2AGZ

The Next 1000 Years: The Global Energy SuperGrid - Paul M. Grant, 23 September 2003

Page 57: The Global Energy SuperGrid - W2AGZ

The Next 1000 Years: The Global Energy SuperGrid - Paul M. Grant, 23 September 2003

Mega-Cities

Page 58: The Global Energy SuperGrid - W2AGZ

The Next 1000 Years: The Global Energy SuperGrid - Paul M. Grant, 23 September 2003

DiscoverersDiscoverers

PractitionersPractitioners

Fathers of Electricity

Page 59: The Global Energy SuperGrid - W2AGZ

The Next 1000 Years: The Global Energy SuperGrid - Paul M. Grant, 23 September 2003

Page 60: The Global Energy SuperGrid - W2AGZ

The Next 1000 Years: The Global Energy SuperGrid - Paul M. Grant, 23 September 2003

Diablo Canyon

TwoDiabloNukes

6.3 miles

Wind Farmequal toONE

Diablo Unit

11001 MW

Towers,1000 ftapart

Page 61: The Global Energy SuperGrid - W2AGZ

The Next 1000 Years: The Global Energy SuperGrid - Paul M. Grant, 23 September 2003

Diablo Canyon

Page 62: The Global Energy SuperGrid - W2AGZ

The Next 1000 Years: The Global Energy SuperGrid - Paul M. Grant, 23 September 2003

1967: SC Cable Proposed!

100 GW dc, 1000 km !

Page 63: The Global Energy SuperGrid - W2AGZ

The Next 1000 Years: The Global Energy SuperGrid - Paul M. Grant, 23 September 2003

Distribution

10 MW CommunitySubstation

-----------dc XFMR

-----------Reversible Fuel Cell

-----------H2 Storage

Page 64: The Global Energy SuperGrid - W2AGZ

The Next 1000 Years: The Global Energy SuperGrid - Paul M. Grant, 23 September 2003

End Use

Streetside Service-----100 A @ +/- 25 Vdc--------H2 @ 200 K, 100 psi-----PLC @ 5 MHz

H2 Heat Exchanger for AC----------------------H2 for Heat/Hot H2O----------------------Household Fuel Cell----------------------Inv/Conv for Electricity----------------------H2 Storage for Auto

Page 65: The Global Energy SuperGrid - W2AGZ

The Next 1000 Years: The Global Energy SuperGrid - Paul M. Grant, 23 September 2003

Energy Intensity Factoids

80004000Therm40002000ElectPeakAvgWatts

Grant Household Power Requirements

Peak Power for 250,000 GHE’sElectrical: 1000 MWThermal: 2000 MW

Does not include 3 automobiles!

Page 66: The Global Energy SuperGrid - W2AGZ

The Next 1000 Years: The Global Energy SuperGrid - Paul M. Grant, 23 September 2003

Global Electrification

Page 67: The Global Energy SuperGrid - W2AGZ

The Next 1000 Years: The Global Energy SuperGrid - Paul M. Grant, 23 September 2003

More Examples:South America

Page 68: The Global Energy SuperGrid - W2AGZ

The Next 1000 Years: The Global Energy SuperGrid - Paul M. Grant, 23 September 2003

The 1000 Year Slide Rule