H ayv Ho -reoperh! ecrr i h N4ero!,r! ec<vth xypHan

n PEno[ABAH tAE

I|CTOPUU sMKone'Ifepnogrrecxoe r3AaHxe ocHoBaHo s 1916 r.. eo:o6xoereHo B Mae 7934 r.

Bxo4rr e nepeqeHb Bejavulrx r4r!i5;. -:_.:-1-:: | r'=-a-r;, -.-:a:-'-legguti BAK PO

:'... P,. c c u t t c x o l.t @ ed ep a4u u

_ t'..:,: -.-..

Axryanunafl reMaiir!rr,.-"d*,,

J -|H.IIoOO€Br rpn-ei:as1g i:,lipa3oearerbHbre peCrpcbr -coBpe\reHHrui,Qop-rrar r-re6Hrrr \rareprraroBno r rcTopr rrr r r oortrecTBo3HaHrrro

Vcropua uo6u{ecraoBe4eHHe

12

18

E-d KprovKoBaBocnzrarenrHnui KoMfIoHeHT rrrKonbHoroucropnqecxoro o6pa: aBaHufl. s 6a:osrrxAor{yMeHTax 200 4 - 20 1 4 roAon

E.I4. EensHKoBa(DoplrupoeaHr.re rpa;Klancxori r4AeHTr4rrHocrr4yqailIr4xc-fi Ha )poKax o6rqecreosHaHzr n cpe4HerZIIIKONC

MeroAuxa 22

30

A.B.Ky4p.rBrIeB, C.H. Iynlr na, JL.B. Apnxenallpoexr Me)KAr4cr1r4nnr4HapHoro )poKano r.rcropr4u n o6ulec, Bo3HaHrzro e \4 K,racceno reMe <,tr4eaH Eorogauulth -LIsaH. fposurrrlo

A.H.IygronOrxpururi uHTepHer-napaQoH, nocnxuqeHHufi7 O-,reru t.o fl o6elu e Be,'rzKorZ Ore.recrsesHofisorlHe 1947-1945 roAoB

Ef3r0f3 A.IO. Mopoeontr4cropzxo-reorpaQnu ect<t th TpeHr4Hfrro BHerrrHehnoturuxe CCCP B nepuoA<flepecrpoftxpr,> weu6opau e 1990-e ro:rl

LI.B. Kppona, O.AYeprrFra, P.B. flaerurEfD no o6rqecrnosHaHuro: B3r,[-flJ H3H\TpII

42

48

Is

14.8. Kpyoeo, O.A. gepnyxo, p.B.floszr_l

EI3 no o6lleerBoaHaHrrro: BBr.rr,I rffirryTprd

MLIM MaccOBbrM 3KsaMeHOM rro er,r6opr-.Buecre c reM, coAepxrarenbHa.{ cropoHa 3K_3aMeHa vMeer MHoro npo6aev. ioropore.K COX{atreHIzro, IIUpOKO O3ByTiHBaIOTC_S Hesa _

cro, xorq AoBonr,Ho aKTIiBHo odclx:atcrc_snpaKTtr KaMrr.

B qenax r6ncrpyxrunHoro lna_rora o5oo_HaiIIIM HeKOTOpbIe .IOBO.rbHo HeofHo3Harl_Hbre, Ha Harrr B3r,,rrn) ]{o\reHrrr KZ},Ioe, c ro_TOpbIMIZ HaM npllxo.IrrTc.s cTa_-IKHBaTbc.rI (23_HyTpr4) KaK ytrureJr-\r_[peAMeTHr4KaM, 3KC_rrepTaM, By3OBCKTIM npenoAaBaTeJl_sM MeTo_qrer{ecKlrx KypcoB no o6ulecrnognaHzro. Oco_6oe sga.IeHze gro Mo)Ker ItMerb B KoHTeKcreo6cy xgeuvx o6uoereHHori 4enonepczz Ef g2016 r.

Bna-ra.ile BbIAenIzM HecKoJrbKo IrcxonHblxnns.Hacno:llgufi,

1. KZMu Efg e peanruorZ npaxrure xnlx_IOTCT He TOIrbKo (v3MepuTen.gMII> noAroToB_KIZ IIIKOIIbHIIKOB, HO I{ OKASbIBAIOT OIIPEIEN,q_roulee Bnz.rrHne Ha opraHra3arlr4ro yve6noronpouecca B ruxo,re (yvar rorlly, ero cnparux_Baror Ha crsal.reue).

, 2. Kypc <O6rqecreosgaHue) u3yqaerc.s Ha6asosola ypoBHe B craprxux Kr,raccax 2 .{ n He_Aenro, Ha npoezlurou _ 3 v (c vqeror{ KVp_coB oKoHoMlrwn w fipala _ He rreHee J_5-cn ne4enro). llpo$umHrm ypoeeur, o6vqenrr_s

Kpyrona llpana Bnagruuponna - (aH.fu.rar rre.rarorr_trecKux HayK, Aorleur xa$e4prr reoprzrl u MeroJur(rr rrpeno]a_BaHfi.s ucropxu, o6rqecrnonegeuz_a u npana BfCfll.. irrr.,_oo6 Lu ec r so:Ha Hu.q, r. Boa rorpan; geprrlxa O^.*n,q,"uio.*IeBHa - KaH,qr.rAar rreAaror{qecrrrx Hayx, 4o4enr xa$e.lpbr re-opl1fi n r4eron]1Kr4 npenonaBaH fi , ucropw n, o6uleirsbeeje_Hlu u npaBa BfCflv. prHre,rs nrropt;r u o6ulecrsorHaHlrq.r. bonrorpa.D.i I la3lrH poMaH BIrKTopoBIrq_ yqnl e.-Tb lrcroDnrril.o6uecrsossaHlJr, aBTop noco6Hr rr" noororo"*

^l fl5 r,

I tlA no hcrophn n o6iltecrsolHaunto, r. Cavapa.

_ .E^11i1:vtnjlbrf@mail.ru; chernuha_oxana@mail.ru;PazinRV@gmail.com

49, &Et3 t4 or9

USIo

-EULE

B CrLl\- pa3Hbrr npurrxH ,4OCTyleH AaJreKo HeBCe-\r LIIKO-lE,HIrI{a\{, )(enarcUIIZM U3yr{aTbnpel\rer Ha raxo\r \-poBHe. B V_IX rn.B oSbrcHori tuxo_le Ha II3\-treHIie [peAMera or_Bolrrrcr I c e Hele.rrc. Oar.rop BpeNreHu Aon_;.r\eH _SB.-lsTbc.s ea,(Eer-rurrr\r nprr o[peA erreHuno5l,e\ta, r,rv6nnr,r coJepxaHr{, 3KsaMeHaurr_oHHor.i pa6orbr.

_ 3. EfO oprzeHrrzpoBaH Ha fOC 2004 r..Paspa6orxa, o6rqecrnenuoe o6cy)K.{eHr4eu yrBepx(Aeuze IIOOil COO no OfOC sa_nnaHzpoBaHbr Ha BTopyro nonoBr4uy 2015 r.,a6co.nroruoe 6o:rlruzncreo rrrKorrE,HrrKori

:TqaHbr B craprxux Kraccax y-i.Ll.tcn no foc2004 r, O4naro B MeroArrrrecKrrx peKoMeHAa_r\ut;:r Qtr4flLI 2014 r. yKasr,rBaerc_s cneryrc_rrlee: (OneMeHTaMu npoBepKr4

"urary.rla.ArzAaKTZrrecKue en.urr.u\br sttauvit 11 Tpe6oBa_Hrrr no $oplrnponaHr.rro yMeHr4ll, saxpen_reHHbre e (De4epa,ruHoM KoM[oHeHTe rocv_AapcrBeH_Horo o6pasonare,rbHoro arurr4upiu2004 r. Y-{urrrearcrc-s raK)Ke rpe6onaiuxK ypoBHro rroAroToBKrr BbrnycKHriKoB, Bbr_ABI4HyrbIe so OfOC)1. B eroil cs.ssz He .scHo_Ha KaKrre KoHKperHo rpe6onanrn-a u norreMynorlxeH opileHTnpoBarbcs yrtHTeru. Dro ge_rqercq ocnoeofi In_rr npor43Bo:ra e or6ope co_ilepr(aHu_s u npoBepKe y Me:nr4ir rrrKorrbHt4KoB.AaHHoe noloxeHr4e rpe6yer KoHKperr{3a_UII II.

{. Kl4l\irr EfO 4o_rrxnr,r 6aszpoearrc_aIi \.qIiTF,IBaTb coAep)KaHze ruro-rtnrrx y_Ie6-HIIKOB no o6rqecreo3uaHl4lo, u*rrro.ra""",*B repeseHb AeucrByroulrax. llprz oroM cneAveroTMeTUTb, qTo cyqecTByroT Cepbe3Hbre Bo_npocbr K Kpnrepz.rru or6opa coAepx(aHLr,sx Aei crByrotrlr4 M AnAaKTzrrecxriM eArrHrirraMcraHAaproB ocnoeHorz u cpeguerZ rurolrr. .{y_MaeTcq, r{To He BCe OHII OnpaBAaHEr C TOqKIT3peuvq ucuxororo-Bo3pacrHbrx oco6ennoc_reri urro,rtur4 KoB 14 qelerZ rypca.

I

I

(

1

I

t

!

c

x

E

E

n

A

q

T

I

J]

Ta

c(

B

l:l,t:. I

5. 3aganul, Kprrrepnu orleuzBaHr4.s, Bapv_ITbr orBeroB Aonrrnbr 6rnr, rroH.rrrHbrKOrrbHt4KaM, OTpOKaTb r4x MrrpoBo33peHrlec_rrZ, nospactnoll, no3uaBarenrnurZ ypoBeHr,tBBvITrrg, coquaarnrrrt orrblT, coorBercrBo_nr o6qenpuH.trTbrM HayqHbrM 3rraHn.EM rlor3oBbrM ,rlnr Kypca o6rqecrnosH.rHlr.s npeA_3TaM, HaytIHbIM MeTOArrtIecKEM IOAXOAaMopraHrz3arlvr4 y cBoer.lrfr pe6aoro coAepx(a_t\.

O6parnvcx. HenocpeAcrBenrio K saaaHvsMYAeIIIIM BIlvIMaHvIe ToJIT,KO TeM TUrraM 3a.rla_tri, Koropr,Ie, IIo HarrreMv MrreEI{Io, aKTyanb_r EIlq Bepcwr HoBoro )'se6Horo roAa.Baxturrl.r, c roqKn 3peEnr ocBoeuras o6rqe_

BoBeAr{ecKoro Kypca, sntserts ycBoeHueElecrBoBeAsecKr{x troE;rruit. 3nasne o6rqe_BoBe4rrecKux [on_{'rrrfr, yMeHr{e AaBarb I4MfpeAeneHrre HaxoIEr OTp.l)KeHne B saila1nkrl(C5). Brrecre c re!d, rrpegaraeMbre K pac-bITI4IO IIOH-f,TII.f, ITHOTJA BbI3bIBAIOT, C HA-lrt ToqKv 3peHrirr, EeKoropoe HeAoyMeHVe,trprrMep, <KpumE uir ucml+tbL>>, <<o6oercmottxdaucrcozo npak,, krruroAeKb>> z Ap. Te nrEo IIoHrTI4ff, KOTOpbre Jo;f)KHbr 6rrTb n rypcetrIecrBo3HaHlr-q ycBoeEr

"" ypo"rra aro"n_E (a He Ha ypoBEe rrpeJcraBnenuirureprrrn_r)? Ilonaraelr, B 3ToM Eer Ha ueo6xoazrrao_x, Hrr rlenecoo6pasnocru. K rorr.ry x(e y yrrr4 _

ur Ha ypoKe HeT IOCTaTOWOTO KonuqecTBaFMeHu, .rro6rr pa6orat c grr{Mu Kareropu_ts Ha rarou ypoBne.Yvzrenx-upaKTrKx orlteqaror, .rro Efg

r o6ulecrnosHag[ro Bbrnvx.traer Ao [peAenacMaru3vrpoBarl o6mecrso"..n"ec*o. io4ep_r{ve, npeBpaqau ero B rprry np,ueHa*o",goe, Synrqufi w lolp. A se.xb Ea srane cra_BreHIr-{ coBpeMerrEoro o6mecreoBeArrecKo_(ypca B 1990-e rr. oH Bu:re;lc.r KaK npeAMer,€rcttlr4lU Bax(Hoe 3Haqepne J]g. co\vanr43a_u yqenzKa. Hacronxo 3u2gree oupeAene_f, roHrrn-f, (ga u nonxrue ;ra?) <xpurepuir.Tr4Hbr> cuoco6crnyer co\vaJurca\unronrurzra?Pacrprrrrae coAep)KaHzrr trorr rrr{e npeAlo_

taeT BbrAeneHr4e poAoBbrx E BqlIOBbrx rlpv_rros. AHanras rrrKoJrbHhD( yve6nrmou, lre:ro _

qecKrzx paspa6oror, Bapr{aEToB zaaayuirorBeroB, [peAnaraeMbrx paspa6orvrara:raur B paMKaX pe€urbHoro 3K3aMeHa, TaK r{ B IIo_lufrx Anfr froAroToBKI{ K SK3aMerry [oKa3br_3T, .lro aBTopbr s 6ortrur,rncrBe clryrraeB ca_

lrz npene6peraror grr4M MeroAzrrecKzM TDe_6oeaHze\a. Moxno, KoHerIHo, , *u"aar"" *o"_TpapryMeHTa BO3pa3uTb, qTo rrrKoJrbHr4KlrAODKHbI CaMOCTO.rrTerrbHo yMeTb onpeAen.rrTbpoAoB[,re 14 Bt4AoBbre nprr3HaKr{. Oqnaro anxroro, vro6rr groMy :rray-vvrrbcs., y Hr4x Aonx{HbIobrrb oopa3qu u yre6nzrax, noco6nxx, TaKr{erpe6onanzx Ao.Dr{Hbr flpeAT,.rrBrr.rrrb cs uM HagK3aMeHe. Moxer 6rrtr, sro r4Meer cMbrcn or_pa3rrrb B Kpzrepr{.sx orIeHKz saaavufr32 rc5\?Ha cerognautrurt 4eut ctrcreMa nou.srr4ri .re_pes BrrAeneHrre poAoBrrx rr Brr,qoBbrx nonqruftB rrrKoJrr,Hbrx yue6nurax ue Bbrcrpoeua. Cnox_nocrr @opiuynupoBoK nou.sruri s yre6HuxaxoprreHTzpyeT yqatqvxc.s Ha r4x MexaHzrrecKoe(nonyMexaHravecroe) sasy6pusanve. llp"STOM CneAyeT oTMeTr4Tb, sTo B MeTonrrqecKr4xpeKoMeHAarlusx QI,IIII4 (2Ot+ r.1z o6parqaer_cfl BHrrMaHrre y.rureleri Ha coorHotxeHue po_AoBbrx t4 BuAoBtrx uon.srzri. Ognaro Bbl4erre_HI1Ie poAoBbrx r4 Br{AOBbrx [pv3rraKoB He BCerAanpocroe c ToqKrr 3peHz.fi npeAMeTHOrO coAep_)rr.an:Lrg. rr Bo3Jlaraerc.E, no eceri szrzl4ocrz.Ha frr.rrenr. XaparrepHori [oKa3iuracb curya_rII{r: B yKa3aHHbrx MeToAvrrecKvx peKoMeHAa_rltz-rrx npu paa6ope rr{[r4qHbrx ourz6or B Kaqe_crBe [pr{Mepa npv Bo4trTc_s rreBepHoe BbrAene_Hrre poAoBoro npr43HaKa (<nonumuuecrcuil De_)KttM>, <onpeDeneuuqs cmpaHa> gn^ ,orri^,<Qedepa4un>). B rr,rero4zrrecKoM noco6nu,opzeHrr4poBaHHoM Ha [oAroroBKy K EfO2015 r., c yqacrveM Toro )Ke aeropa: cMbrcrrtrorflrr4n "Qopua meppumopuaa uio- zocyilap_cm6e H H o z o ycm p o rt c m 6a> pacKpblBaercf, cneAy_t,lllr o6pasorra:

"Qopma zocydapcm\euuo:zonpauneHufr ompaxaem cucmeMy 9sauuoomuo_weHuu qeHmp aJLbt.tbLx u p e?uoHaJrauom op zauo 66nacmu> (c. 238) - neaepnrrri pogouoii .rp"-3HaK; B olpegeneHr{rr <eopruot zocy0apcm6eu_uo zo np a4n euutrr> Harrr4cano: <e opma ) o cy\ap _

cmheuuozo npaLneuwr ompuKaem opzauuia_quto 4btcwux opzauo| Bnacmu> (c.26Ij - poAo_nori npzsuax orcyrcrByer; KropuAwtecKi, om_&emcm&euuocmu> orrpel\er_{ercfi KaK <<nDLtJveHe-Hue

^K nu4y, co\epwuhtueuy npa\ouapyuteuue,

npelycMompeHHbtx saKoHoM d,tep rcpu\uuecrcoirom&emcmheuHocmu>> (c.367) - ne eu4enen oo_,uoBorrt fiprr3HaK, an4oeori npv3HaK c$opr,ry_nrrpoBaH HeKOppeKrHo.

Orgenruo ocraHoBr{Mc.s Ha 3anaH:zLr26 (B5), Koropoe opraeHrupoBaHo Ha npoBep-Ky yMeHn.rr IrrKorrl,Hr KOB <pasIll{qaTb B COUI4_

ET3 U O130

anr,Horl uH$opMalluu Sart'r Ir MHeHii.q, ap-ryMeHrbr Ir BbrBoAr,I> (IOC 2004 r.). Heo6xo-AHMo orMerhrb, rlro coBpe\leHHblfi BbIil\'cL-uur, 6y,4yrqntl arrusHr'ul Je-sre.rE coqIl\'\Ia)AerlcrBnrenbHo AoJIi4ieH \'\Ierb opIIeHrIlPo-BarE,cq B cTpeMuTe.-IbHo Bo3pacTalo[Ie-\I IiH-

SopuaquouHoM [oroKe, r-\Ierb Bbltre.]Is'tb ryun$opnaauurc. Koropas Hocrlr KaK SaxrNuec-xurl/reoperti.iecritlli. rat I,I oueHoe H t'Ifi( cy6rerrilnnrui ) xapaxrep,'rro6bl aHaJrtr3rl-

poBaTb ee, KpriTur{ecKl4 ocMblcrluBaTb, coua-Llrarbcs c Hei\ vnv ner. Brulec:re c reM, 3To 3aAa-

HHe Bbr3blBaer 3HarrllTerbHble TpyAHocTI4 He

rorrbKo y BbrnycKHuKoB, Ho 14 y yqvTeneil.OcHoeHaq ilpo6neMa 3aKrlroqaerc.s B ToM,

rrro orcyrcreyror oslrqlra.rlbHble MeroAlrqec-Kr4e peKoMeH L\A\VV C KpI4TepI'LtrMrt BblrrotlHe-uun zagauvfi uogo6uoro poAa. B LlHcrpyKul4--{x I4 MeroAuqecKl4x nocoou.sx Her rrerKoro ar-roPriTMa onpeleneHtrfi Teoperr4rrecKoro, sax-Tzr{ecKoro r4nr4 oqeHorrHoro xapaKTepa cyx(-geuuh. Y.rzre.n-s BbIHyN(AeHbI caMocro-are:rb -

no pas6rzparbc-a B oco6eHHocrsx BblnorHeHu.{

AaHHoro 3ara:r^ilfr 11 Ha ocHoBe co6ctseHHorocy6rerrueuoro noHIrMaHr{s o6T,.scHqrb Mexa-

Hlr3M ero Br,rnorHeHus yrreHlrKaM. OAun rze

caMbrx pacupocrpaHeHHblx cnoco6os - o6pa-rueHrre K noco6r4.sNl QI4[LI, cBepKa sag.a:oLrli'

c orBeraMrr. fleircrnyrourue yve6Huxu o6rqe-crBo3HaHu.fl He MoryT oKa3aTb no\{olIIII B pe-rxeHrrrr gaHuolr npo6neurr: B HItx Her nolo6-Hurx gaaaurfi fi LlHcrpyKuufi no ttr Bbtllo-lHe-nuro. B ct,l'3tt c err4Mtl, o6cro.qre,rL'crBa\IllilpaKTr.rqecKa.a noAroroBKa x EfE yilureJlr\Illupr.ro6peraer xapaKrep cKopee HeocN{blcireH-

nrr11, cy6rerrr.rsHE'rI1. Taroe nennr.rMaHrre pa3-

pa6orvuros K oroMy Blrry 3a[iaHvtl He onpae-Ar,rBaeTc.fi eilIe r4 TeM, rrro npaBvnbHoe BbInoJr-

HeHue AaHHoro 3aAaHrrs ol1eHlrBaerc.a 2 6atJraN{r{, T. e. r<naccrzSulrl4pyerc.q B coorBer-crBurr co cneqll$uraquetr Ktr4M KaK 3aAaHI4e

IIoBbllrreHHoro ypoBHt cJro)KHocTIi.

Bvecre c reM, aHaIrLr3 npeAcraBneHHblxsaAaHI4ila no38oir-ser cAenarb cneAyrorrlrre BbI-

nogrr. llpaxruqecKlr B Ka)KAoM BapI4aHTe

npucyTcTByroT cylKAeHI4s, nprrHaAne)KHocTbK lpaKTaM, Or{eHKaM Vlrtt reopvtv KoropblxorreHb rpyAHo onpeAenlrrl. O6parqeuue K or-BeraM, [peAcraBneHHbrM B KoHIIe [OCOOI4q,

TaKt(e He noMoraeT, nocKonbKy rracTo Iroxo-)Kr.re IIo cTpyKType noJro)KeHr{.s B oTBeTax

rpaKryrorcfl Iro-pa3HoMy. Haupvr'aep, nPeI-

noxeHuq <I.Iumepuem npoqrro \outen 6 uauty)Klt3Hb> (c. 168), <ConpomuLneuue npuaafiauOOH x etn)teHe cuepmuou rcasuu 6o MHo?uxpe?uoHax xupa npon1ntemcfl 4octnamo'4uoctrJtbuo >) ( c. 1 3.1 ) IlHrepnperr4pylorc-fi aBropa-Mu noco6uq KaK olreHorlHrre. B ro ,Ke BpeM.s

raKr4e cyrr<AeHu.s KaK nCyr4ecm6enuo no9uLcu-

nu c6oe clcmofrHue pa6omuurcu mopzo9otx

Qupu, (c. 93) u <3a zodor cyu4ecm6o6auun

emort [uaccohort] rcynamypbl 3HaqumenbHo u3-

MeHltllLtcb mexHuqecKue cp ed cm\a, ucnonb 3ye-

uarc dns ee coslauu;r u muptuKupo9auus>>(c. 1.75) yKa3aHbI rar $artlrvecrue. KarosarrorrrKa r{HTeplrperalluz - HenoHsrno. He qc-

HO, rAe UCTVTHa, BeAb Bo Bcex [peAcTaBJreH-

HE rx cy)KAeHvtrx trpu cy T cTByror ctloB a, froKa-3r,rBarolque oTHorxeHI4e aBTOpa.

Ha6nroAaerc.s exre oAHa reHAeHrII4-s - B 3a-

AaHLrsx npeAnaraloTcq crox(Hble npeAno)Ke-

Hr4q> Koropble BEI3bIBaror y o6yvarorquxc.a Bo-

npoc, KaKyIo qacrb [peAno)KeHuq ueo6xogrz-uo az$QepeHlrrrpoBarb) nocKonbKy I4HorAa

B oAHOM CyTKAeHLIIi ilpeAcraBneH I'1 lpaKr,rr orIeHKa. llpurvrepolr roMy Mo)Ker cny)KrrrbcneAyroqee npeAnolKeHrr e'. <Ilpomu6onpa6-uoit rcoumeum - o)ua us zna9uatx npo6neu co-qualrbubtx cemei.t, u nonbLmKut o?paHu4eHufr do'cmvno demefi rc couualbHbLM cemflM He nuuleHbts0pa6ozo cMbtcna,> (c.37 I - oueHoqHoe.

Hepe4xo xapaKrep cy)KAeHuq HacroJrE'Ko

rpyAHo onpeAeJrrlTb, rrTo 3aAaHr4e, cKopee Bce-

ro, noKaJblBaer crpeMneHi4e aBTopoB noco6lrsIIpoBepriTb v BbTIIyCKHI,IKOB He yMeHrre pa3nl4-

carb B coqua.nrnort ran$oprrraqurz $axrlrII \IHeHIls, a CTeIIeHL' pa3BIlTIlg. y HI X tIHTyI4-urrri. HanpuMep, KaK yrll4Tenb AontKeH o6t.sc-HrlTb, lrro cneAyroql4e cyx(AeHrr-g Hoc.qr oIIe-uocurrri xapaxrepr <Cma|rca 6rcta0o6 6cez0a

treHee 3HaLlumenbHa, qeM pocm uuQnn4uu"(c. 158), nCw4ecm9yrou4ue meopuu olum noKa

ue 1arortt ortr\etna Ha MH0zue nparmuuecrcue 6o-

npocbL cLszauuue c Qopuupo&auueu npa6nu4e-

zo clrofl> (c.77), u!,anaueinuee HapacmaHue He-

pa\encm\a Mo/Kem npuhecmu rc 0ecma6unusa-

4uu 6ceu )KLL3H+ o64ecmha> (c. 93), <B uayrce

ue 6afiaem c,tyuartuam omrcpatmui> (c. 109XTapre Ao clrx nop na6nrogalorc-a ArrcKyc-

ctlv cpe4v ylrtTenev orHocrrrejrbHo onpeAe-rreHAA xapaHTepa raKhx cyx(neHuil, xar, Ha-

nprrMeP, <Kapn Maprcc nuca.fl...> tt <<flo Mue-

uwo Kapna Mapxca... > llepnoe yrBep)KAeHrre

nocr.rr Qaru.r-recxuli xapaKTep, a Bor KaK uH-

5(}

US=co

-EuL-

& rre t4 \JIJ

repnperr.rpoBarb Bropoe? Oqenovnoe oHovnv lpaKrnqecr<oe? llpercran,rxerc.,r, qro pa3_pa6or.rrlxu K14lvl Et3 -to.t,hHbr

".r*o onp.p._

JIt4Tb 3TO i.I XaTb coorBeTcTByro[Ir4e lreiOAr_rlecKue peKolleHlaurirr \^IzTeILgM U yrreHlr_KAM.

llo.naraerr. rrro B onpeAenenHorl KoppeK_UIILI HV)KfaeTc.s iI \fo_le--Ib TecToBOIO 3ana:ts{ur!HarrpaBireHHax ra nlr5op HecKorrbKZX uoro_)KeHrzri u3 nepesHr 1, 9, 12, 16, 20, 2I).B $oprrv;urpoB(e Bonpoca ueo6xo4uuo rrer_Ko fipoflrrcbrBarb. cKo.]bKo Hy)KHo nrr6parrnpaBrrnbHbr\ otBe:oB rI\aK 3TO C4elauo e EfoIIo IICTOPUIi ). Halprruep, 3 nepnr,rx ArrcTpaK-Topa rz3 6 rr.rrr I ;i: _i. BosMolK"o, aro",,6a4uorleHrlBarb faH{,-r!r \loferrb s I 6ann. llolo6_na.a lroalrSrrHa.:ur -triKTyerc, o[peleneusorlcJrolr{HocTbro s 3r,16cpe anbTepHaTnB, no_cKotrr,Kl- oco6es:rocrrr [peAMerHoro coAep_>r<aHr4s. He no3BO.l_FroT rrHorAa oA"osrruv"o pi_IIIrrTb \/qaulet.l:-;_E 3a_laHlre I43_3a ao^4"rrarroHbrx i.r-lrr o5nr;rr eopuy.nrzponoK BonpocoB14 OTBETOB.

Erue orrrrtrr lro5_reMHbIM MecroM 3K3aMe_Ha _sBJ'LseTct. a: IaIx B3UI'A, He_scHocTb u He_rrerKocrE, So:,..1-;.rrrpoBoK, Koropbre Bcrpeqa_IOTCI B pall-::_\- Trlnax 3aAaHuri z oTeeroeK HuIr. flpr ::,t:.: cJorxHocrrz B rroHriMaurzt{CyTIj 3aAaI]IW- ir LTIBeTOB MOryT BO3HI{KaTb HeTOIIbKO \- I:i,l.t5HIINa, HO I4 lleAarora, r{ 3KC_nepra. B rio;--:-neu cnf{ae oro onpenen_se.r.noBbrttleH]ji :._-.:;I ci.dreKTr{BHocr},t np, oua_Hr,rBaHHn pae,.-.:;r. flpreelela fipriMepbr He_yAaqHbr\, c ll:rren rocKri 3peHug, Soprury.nv_poBoK. 3a-:=;:t 3Brnrl1 cle4yrorqzna o6Oa_gorr:

"Firr-ii:.,,1-: nrpy cy1tercma zpax1auciuxnpa6 u ll;rr-.-:!":i ,,rcdtrc xapaKmepHyro qepmyrcaxdozo ri-i irrr.- . Coiepxanue [paBnnbHorooTBera ral\o3La: iusu.recrcue nu4a (zpax\auerc a rc Q u s t i,, t ;1 ! j t

=- .j i. i i (7 o 6n aO an m

"il 6 o rln i i o, iI,tocmbn 1, .r;;.-,;..;.rf4 \cmbrc); npu\uuecrcuenu4^a ftnter,,: -.,:?eieteuuoe uuyu4icm6o 6 co6_cfttaeHHoCtlti+ :t ?.€ j.,.Il

_ttuyr4ecm^euHyto om_6emcm\euuoltrr,r clot)au); zocy\apcmilou )pyzue uvdt u4 Ht.-- itlo6o6uLe o6p aso'ilauix (zocy0apcm6o, rw;rt:lt;...s tl tntyu4ecm\eHHbLx om_rloLueHufrx, 4ucnt,,ltsen ua pa\uam Hel4anax

t a p ! r,ylt " !:,

6b e x m ttt t t t, p *rd o r * o, " ;; 16:;l;;

(c. 262). I4crors u3 +op-\iv.rapoBxrr 3anaHvrrHe coBceM rroH_qTHO, o KaKr.lx xapaKTepHbrxqeprax cy6:beKroB rparlt:aHcKxx npan ueo6_xo.IIr4Mo Becrn pecb. Eue otso 3alaluei (Ha_

3o6ume mpu 6u0a dozo6opo6 u KpamKo oxapaK_mepu3yime rcax)oLir ux HLtx>, (c. l16). B noa_BHIr,Hbrx oTBeTax yKa3brBaeTc, cneAyroillee:< o o ? o 6op K y nn u- np o daxu npednon a?aem nepe-dauy deuez 6 o6ueu ua mo6ap; dapeuue npedno_ra?aem 6ea6osues0uyto nepeOaiy uuyu4ecm6aootluM nul4oM d^pyzouy: 0ozo6op apeu\at npe\_nora?eem nepedauy uuyu4ecm6a do hpeueiuoenonbs06aHue 3a nramy>6 (c. 235). B saganuz neyKa3aHO, .rro Heo6xo4rlMo Ha3BaTb BrinbrrrMeHHO rpalKAaHCKO_npaBoBF,rX,qoroBopoB,rrro npeAnonaraerc_s B orBere. y-{eHIzK Mo)KerAarb rrHyro xlacczer.maqzro AoroBopoB: rpy_,qoBorz, 6pavHLrrt u rpaxAaHcoo-rrpuuoubrz,qro He npeAycMarprrBaerc, (ue 4onycxaercl)(KJIIOqOM>.

llpu erola cne,qyer uoHuMarb, rrro rrprr or_Berg Ha Bonpocr,r B 3al.a:r.vnx 30 (C3 ), : i (C+),33 (C6), 34 (C7) rrrKorrbHrrK Mo)Ker err6DarrIZHyIO IOrI4Ky, I{HbIe BapIzaHTEI OTBeTa, rIeMnpeAno)KeHr,r B (graJJoHe)

An_rr 3Kcnepra. OA_HaKo AoBonbHo x(ecrKoe rpe6oeanue coorBer_CTBII,'I OTBCTA BI,INYCKHI4KA (KJTIOqY) BENCTK 3aHri)KeHr{ro 6ar_,roe SKCrrepTaMrl. llOlo;re_HIIe O TOM, r{TO OTBeT MO)KeT COAepxaTb rIHbIeanbrepHarn Bnsre Sopv y,r rpo"*r, Ha aile rrrr fr_ur4.sx HepeAKO CTaHOBTZTC.q KaMHeM npeTKHO_BeHr,rr. Moxer 6urru, nveer cMbrcr nporrrcbl_BaTb B (STatIoHe> He TpII_n.sTb BO3MOX{HLIXrorox(eHuI^, a Izx MaKcI4 MarlbHoe KorrzqecrBoulrrt )Ke orKa3arbc.q or <xltoqett> BoBce, orpa_HrzqrrBrrrrr cb o 6u1zuz Kp r4.r epvsMrr orl eHr4 Ba_rrng.?.

Bo-rrtruorl o6telr npoBep.seMoro Ha EfOo6rqecrnoeeAqecxoro coneplKa:avs. no rny 6v._He IZ lI]l4poTe qBHO npeBoc-tonI4T KOII4\iecTBoIIACOB, OTBEAEHHbIX HA CrO U3YIICHI,IE B IIIKO,IEHe roJrE,Ko ua 6asoeov, Ho rr Ha npoSzlrt,nouypoBHe. Oro uaxogllr orpalreHve B Heo)Krr_AaHHbrx Bonpocax w 3anaHw1x. HanplrivrepT,recroBbre Bo[pocbr o peeepenmro,r

-rpyrro*

!c. lra.), percpeamu\ioi -Qyr*t4ru "ceMbu(c. l5a) unr43a1a:rrvre33 o6 ocuo\auuqxnonyqe_uun zpaxdaucmha pe 6 ynpou4euuou nop;AKe(c.307). Kar<rzlr o6pasou yrrr4renb Aon)KegnpeAyraAarr, rty6vuy u3yvenprfr rrpeAMera)ec,rrz AeTarrbHa.fi pernaMeHTa\vn He HaxoAt{To'Tpax{eHrre B HOpMaTr4BHbrx AoKyMenrax?tr4 cattoe DraBHoe, B3_sr.r, crorbKo BpeMeHrf Hacronb nonpo6Hoe usyvenue Marepvaila $ar_TV rlecKr..I Heorl{yAa. Ecnw, geneuvrq (MoHonco_}lntl>>, <<3JracTl{rrHocTrl Cnpoca u upeAnox{e_

14E t-3 o r3 * 51

IJI4g)r, <<oT IIWVfl npvIBvnerr4poBaHHblx aKUVLtoT IPOCTL,TX) Iz np. r43yqarcTcr B Kypce 3KoHO_MrrKtr Ha npo$unE,HoM ypoBHe, ,o ,rupy-a-Iorc.g npaBa IrrKojrbHuKoB, o6yvaeurlrxcfl Ha6asosola ypoBHe qacro B cr4ny orcyrcrlLrsnpoQrrnbHbrx KjraccoB B ,\leCTaX VX frpo)Kr4Ba_HIIfi, rITO HecnpaBennlrBo.

To ;re Kacaerc.s r.r neperrH_s HopMarnBHErxAoKyMeHroB, Koropr,re Aon)KHr,r 6r,rrt rzsyve_HL,r rrrKoJrr,HuKaMr4 B Kypce <O6rqecrnosua_Hr4e>) rro MHeHizro paspa6orvrzr<os KZM EfEa.He o.reHt qcHo, Ha KaKtre pecypcEr BpeMeHuo p u e H rrrp o B anv cL, cn e U 14 arturcr br e l4f ILI np nero cocTaBIeHI4r4.

Oco6oe HeAoyMeHr4e Bbr3r,rBaer y Hac 3a.ua-sue J5 (C8), npoeep{rculee yMeHr{e Bbrny*i-Hr{Ka cocraBr_srr, [raH. llo cnoerray 3aMbrcJry,crIIITaeM, 3TO 3aAaHve trBlt'leTc'' oIHrlM rI3nyqruux B 3K3aMeHarlzonuorZ pa6ore, cruMy_nvpyrcrqrrM pa3Brrrrre qenoro pxAa yweuuhIIIKOJIF,HTIKOB : noHI{MaHLf _E nporII4TaHHOIO,auarrrr3a u o6o6l1euvtr, crpytTypr4poBaHilrrI4 rlorvrrHoro u3ro)KeHl4_s uuSopr,aaqzlr, qrooprreHrrzpyer yqeHriKa Ha qenocrHoe ycBoe_Hre yve6uoro Marepr{ana

OAnaro B crrny oco6esnocrerl oqeHunanrEagroro saAaHr{x, cneqr.r$zxr4 npeAnaraeMr,rx o6_pa3uoB, efo pasBnBatoutnrj noreu qi4ar oKasar_c.q Bo l{HOrO\I \/TpaqeHHbllur. llonl urrr, MaKcr4_va-rrr,nriir 5uLt t:,3 5a-r.ra ) \ro,(Ho, Kar.i flpaBr.jno,He npl4 vcroBnll B.lafeHns r-.re5Hlnt colepxa_}lldeM U COOTBeTCTBVTOIUTI\IIr \-\reHrr.s\1ri. a |IpIly CIIoBUT4 HHTyHTIIBHO| O nonaf aHr L B,lorrrK\-aBTOpOB 3anaHvfl 14 yra-lbiBaHilq n\.HfiTOB n.taHa, Koropbre paspa6orvrlxu flocqrrra-lir ooqsa-TenbHErMr4 An-a pacKpbrrv.s relvrbr. flprr erorrcrpyKTypa rrrraHa, ero rorr4Ka, sL,rtrereHrre o5q_3aTeIIbHbIX nyHKTOB trHorAa ocTaIoTC' He.sc-HI,IMI4 HE TOJIbKO YIICHI,TKY, HO II YIIATEXIO,I4 oKcnepry. B pxge cnyqaeB B AocrarorrHocrpaHHyro no3r4ur.no 6sreaer fiocraBrreH 3Kc_nepT, KOTOpOMy npeAnararoT r4crro,rrb3oBaTbBecb_\,Ia HeonHo3HartHulri c pasnurx roqeK 3pe_HLrtr BapIaaHT rrrraHa KaK STaJrOH npr4 npoBepKeorsaMeHaur4oHHbrx pa6or. Tax, nanpzuep,B oroM roAy npu arrecraqrru 3KcneproB e Bor_rorpaAe An.q oqeHKrl pa6or r,rlr 6nr:r npe4noxeun-rraH <Opranbi rocygapcrneunorl Bnacrr{ B yc-roBr4.rrx AeMoKparrrri>. llo unenuro paspa6or_TTLIKOB, OAHtlM II3 BO3MOXHT,IX BapI4aHTOB pac_KpbrTu_fi AaHHOt4 TeMbr Mo)KeT sBrrfrTbcrr cneny_rourifi (ntrtgnsHys n/x aeropoe crartn ):

52 & E 13 t4 \-,/ | J

1. focygapcreenHrrfi MexaHrl3M KaK crrcre-Ma cneur4albHbrx opraHoB.

2. Pasge-rreHue snacrert rax arprz6yr 4er,ao-Kparur{ecKof o o6rqecrea:

a) saxouo4arerbHa.s Bnacrb;6 ) r.rcno.nuur errb*atr Bnacrr,;n) cy.ee6na.q Brracrb.3. llpe,lcrau.rrerrbHbre opraur,r rocyAap_

CTBEHHOU B;IACTTI:

a) ncexapoguoe u36paHue rrapJraMeHra;6) eaxonogare.rrbHar Qymqna;e) <caepxxrr) u (nporlrBoBecbrD B Aer-

Te.rrbHocTrI napnaMeHTa,4. 74cno ntuterrbHbre opraHbr Brracrrr :

a) cucrerra uatttpanuttitx a perr4oHanbHr,ixopra HoB Hcno. r Hurer buori elacrn;

6) ocnonrrrre @ynrqulr opraHoB rrcrroJr-HI4TCJIbHOII B JIACTII:

n) rrparure.tbcrBo B crrcreMe opraHoB tlc-rrotrulrreJrbuor{ BJracrrr, noprAoK ero eop_Mr,rpoBaHu-s.

5. Po.ru cyge6Hori n.rracrr{ B AeMoxparlrqe-cKoM rocyAapcTBe.

6. Cucreua fipaBooxpaErrrenbnbrx opra-HOB rOCyAapcTBa.

7. Mecrrmre opraHbr Btracrr,r r{ MecrHoe ca_MOyrrpaBneHrre.

B na.recrne o6_ssaretrr,Hrrx BbIAerieHbI JIIo-6r,re gea nyHrra us 2,3 r.r 4(5) nyHrroB nrraHa.flo,qaraev, Ltro crpvr..rvpa rr-raHa, ero fioroxe-Hu-s He rpe5r'ior cneurlarlublx KoMMeHTaDI{_ee. florooFrsre BapHaHrbr nJTaHoB Bcrpeqaror-.r qa.ro. Kpoue roro, rrpeAcrasnnrcics ly6--'rripr-I6s111111i fpyr Apyra HepeAKO BcTpeqarc_ulilecfi [\-HKTbI OAHOTO I4 TOrO ]Ke rIJTaHa: rlo_Hfi,uc - npH3HaKh, Synr<urau - 3HaqeHHe.Ooprlr'-rlrpoeKu niraHoB rarxe noporl Bbr3br_Baror c,lor{iHocrlr B rroHrrMaHr4lr: <[IDa6a? Ptt^t)LtHrrHn rcax cy6z,exma omHou,teHuu, Dezy-,1 upr' *rbtx zp (DKaaHCKuM sarco uo\am enucm\ouP@, u ttx 3nL4uma> (arrecraqzonHarr pa6ora-r.rr rr\creproe, BorrorpaA, 2015 ), ^O6w,e-cmr3euuoe rrpous\oDcm\o MamepuarrouaLx 6nazu e?o oLHodHate Qasar,,o tc. zos), u6noxem-uo-uanozo1oe pezynupo\auue 6 ycnohunx poLu_rca>t0 (c.9l).

flpeJcrae,rxerc_rr, r{To t43MeHeHr4e e 2013 r.KpiZTepLIeB OII eHI4BaHU.s aJIbTepHaTI4B HOIO3al.aHvrfl 36 {C9) no HaftrzcaHilto rt.a trpilBenoK pocry cy6rerrunuocrr,r B ero oLleHrdBaHrn.Cvnraev, vro rpe6onaHrze pacKpbrrvx npo6-neMbr B HecKoJrbKr4x acrreKTax (ue ueHee

US-co

EUo_-

AByx) nosBor.qro qerKo auQSepenqrrpoBarbpa6orr,r no ypoBuro Hailtrca:nuq.. Kprlreplrrtlrnntocrp14poBaHrrr npuMepaMr4 ($axrrzvec-Ka.s apryMeHraqna) B groM cnyqae lror 6r,r yc-TpaHr4Tb HbrHemHut4 HeAOCTaTOK HepaBHO3_HarrHocru rervl. Buecro nog6opa rrpr4MepoB rr3pa3Hbrx HcrorlHHKoB (vro He Bcertra Bo3\roifiHO NO MHOTI4M SKOHOMI4IIECK'IM 14 NDABOBbI\1pa3Aena\4 xypca ) $axrrzrecxan apf v_\reHra-rlrr.s Morna npriBoAr4Tbc_f K pa3HbrM acneKra\rerr6panHor.r .npo6leur,r Arr.fi HanacaHrrr 3 cce.Kpove roro, noraraeM, rrro $arrnvecxriri ap-ryMeHT LIIfl <3acllt4-tblBaHI4.S> AOjIr+\eH Il-l.lrcC_Tpt4poBaTb KoHKpeTHOe TeOpeTr.rcecKoe no_lo_iKeHue, a He rrpocTo (npltcyTcTBoBaTb,, B pa_6ore.

Tax;re B groM Sagauutt \Io;+.Ho 1-ToqHurt,Kpr.rrepr4u orIeHr4BaHZq e o5_rac-n BBe-teHri_stp a nalJLI LL ( AOCTaTOT{H OCTI I H C-t 0 iTdT r. a,, TeO-perr4rrecKorz apryMeHTaurrrr. a raKT{e oueHr.r-B allv fl cMblcroBol4 r1 Ko -\ r rr rl3 I i u I t o H H oii u e:ro _

CTHOCTI4, JrorurrHocTrr Ii B epHocTI r \-TBeprI{Ae_nzrl. 9ro no3Bo.;Irr-lo 5s: r-q.;;5 Ha-tilrrl4e He-BepHbIX noJroifieHllri ts :111.-T:oeHrlII CTpyKTy-pbl 3cce, a Taxj+.e 3BeCT;1 rperrtianrnr,rri6an,rr> sa orc\-TcTBrre o:lli16Lr:i I :cce (nlrecro(IrlTpaoHoro' Kari cericac

O6o6ura-s Bce Bbrrlecxa3aHHoe. npernara-ev r< o6cyx4eHIIlo c.-ief\-kr!u;f e no.roifieHItr:

1. .{ugarrnvectrre e.luHrrubr. BbrHocr4MbreHa npoBepKy na Ef3, fo-tj+iHbr npoBep.rrrbcsHa ypoBHe, cooTBeTcTByrolre\1 rI\ pacKpr,rTr.lrcB rrrKotrbHr,rx yve6uuxax 5asoeoro \.poBH.s(fOC 2004 r.). Heo6xoar4-\ro onpcre-'ririo n.-peqeHb [poBep.rreMbrx ocHoBHbrr noHarrarl,rreTKo oT,qennB rIx oT ArIAaKTUrrecKrrI eJr.IHriu.u3yr{aeMr,rx Ha ypoBHe rrpeAcraB.reHrli tr rep_MIZHOB.

2. B rrore:ur 3al.attrfr na eEr6op HecKoJrb-Krrx no--rod\eH nh (4, 9, 12, 16, 20,2i ) rr: nepev-H.{ r{eTKO nponr{caTb KO.TII{TIeCTBO BepHbIXcyx{AeHrirl l.;r_s oTBera.

3. B rrerofrr.recKlrx peKoMeHAaqu_sx K oK-3aMeHy cerxo o6ogHar{rirb Kprzrepr,rr4 orHece-Hz.s cyxJeHrrr"i K Teoperl4rrecKrrM, earrnvec_KIIM LIIIH OUeHOTIHsII,I B 3a'aHlz't4 26.

4. C qe.rr,ro pa3Buru_s yMeHvit rrrKonbHr4-KOB CaMOCrOsre.tbHo pacKpbrBaTb coAeplKa_Hrze noHsTurr oTpa3rlTb BbrAeJreHrre poAoBbrxrr Br{AoBbrx nprr3HaKoB B KprlTepri.sx orleHKrrB saIaHW 32 (Hanpnrrep,2 6anna - 3a rpa-Br{rrbHoe BbrAeneHrie potroBofo rr BrrAoBErX

rrprr3HaKoB, | 6ann - 3a KoppeKTHoe BbrAene-Hr4e TOJTbKO pOAOBOTO tlnr4 cytuecTBeHHbrx Bu_AoBbrx npv3HaKoB; | 6atn sa npe4loxeuze),4aBarb crpyKTypHo qerKne z 6esoruu6o.rHrreeopMyntrpoBRw noHflTluir B (Kr'l roqax >.

5. llo sagauz-rrM, uMerorquM Bapvarr.rBubreorBerbr (30, 31, 33, 34), lrz6o yrasueartB <K,TIIOqAX) MAKCVMA'IbHOC III4CJIO BO3MOX-Hbrx noJTo)Kelnuh, nu6o orKa3arbcq or yKa3a-Hr{.s KoHKpeTHbIX rroJro)Keuuh. u orpaP'n-syrfrr_ctr lrpvrepr4flMrr rro rvrrry 3a1a:ov_s 36. Oma_saTbcs. or npaKTr4KrZ XeCTKTIX Tpe6oBaHnit co-oTBeTCTBrl.g OTBeTa yrIeHI4Ka <KJIIOTIaM).

6. llo sa4anuro 35 (cocrae.neHze nnaua)cneAyer vcKrrroqrrrb rpe6onanze (yraAbrBa-Ht4.S) AByX O6_sgarerrlHL,rx nyHKToB rrrraHa.Y,ue,rart B (K,rrloqaxD oco6oe BH14MaHne Kop-peKrHocrr4 $opuyrnpoBoK [J.raHa, ero crpyr{-Type, coorBeTcTBrrro nono;reHurl I]JraHa co_Aepx(aHrrro 6asoerrx rrrKoJrbuL,rx yve6nzroe.Bo3iraonHo, AoBeprrrr, oKcnepry orleHuBarbnonHoTy pacKpbrTl4.fi TeMEr, OTKa3aBIIII4Cb OTnPaKTIZKI4 (KIrO.Ier4> B STOM 3aIaHI4I4,

7 . flnn 3aqanvtr 36 (ecce) nog6uparn sapu-aHTr,r cy)KAeHrrrr > trB rr frrotquec.s AocTynHbrMr{AJI-{ IIOHr{MaHu_g UIKoIF,HI4KOB, COOTBeTCTBy_rcilIrre coAepx{aHuro u,rrorr4Ke vgy.clelHn s, rlre6 -HOrO MaTepuana. c r]enE,ro nonbrurenz_s o6t-eKrrzBnocru orleHKrr rrpu npoBepre pa6orrruenecoo6pa3Ho BepHyTbc_s K Heo6xoA tlMo c.tr4BbrAeneHv.s HecKorrbKrrx acneKToB [pr{ pac_Kpbrrrrrr reurr (npo6;reulr), a raruKe yrorr-HrrTr, ocTaJrbHr,re KprzTeprru orleHuBaHu.s.

8. llponogurr, 6onee rllarenr,Hyro oKcnep-Trr3y SK3aMeHarIr{oHHbrx r{ TpeHrrpoBor{Hbrx3al\a}l]lr4 Ha npeAMeT I{CKIIOTIeHU.{ BO3MOTK-nlrx olrz6oK, HerrerKr4x r4 HeKoppeKTHbrx$opvynzpoeoK canaut,tfi u orBeroB.

9. Cvurael,r, qro Atrr{ noBbl[reHIz.s KarlecrBaKZMon, a rarcKe Ar.q tso3Mo)KHocrrr MaKcrr-Marrbno o6rexrzenoro pa3perxeHu.E crropHr,rxcvrryarJLrfi cneAyer nocne npoBeAeHHr gK3aMe-ua ny6nuxoBarb BaprzaHTbr 3KsaMeHaur4oH-ur'rx pa6or, BKnroqa-s (K,TIOr{u) K HIrM.

10. llo.naraelr, vro ueo6xorr{Mo oprautr3o-BbrBarb o6cyxreHr.re npeJ[onaraeMirx Hsnae-ueuuk MoAenz KZM EfD He MeHee qeM sa ABaroAa, a He oceHblo yue6Horo ro,4a, B KOTOpOMnpeAcrorrr cAaBarb gK3aMeH. Oro noseorurBbLsBt4Tb MHeHIie Cneut4aJ'II4cTOB nO lrpeAno_)KeHHbIM HOBaIIr4.gM r.I aAalTI4pOBaTbC_fi K HIrMo6pasonare,rbH ori o4creMe.

E r3 t4 or3& 53

Kroqesue caoea: Et3, KoHmponb, Klllvlbt no o6qecneo-3HOHUA.

Keywords: Uniforn State Exam, test, KIMs by society.

Ilpuneuaruun

t JIase6uurcoBa, A.IO. MeroAz.recKze pe*o_MeHnaqnu no HeKoTopbrM acleKTaM .ouap'-.rr_crBoBaH'u.rr npenonaBarrrr" oorqaa""oariul"",94ny M., 2014. unr:htipTiiot..-J.i#1,*fi i I tllr1

:s/d.oc umen r/ I 40 s i i i i i i ;,i.;_ ;:i:m_ob_2014.odf

- taMXe.3 JIase6uurco6a, A.IO.. pymrcohcrcas

E.,U., Kopona-::6: _E:C

EIO 2015. O6rqecrrosHa uue. 25 Bapual_ToB TzloBr,rx recroBbrx 3a1aHr4ir r, aro4aorou*uK Br,rnorrrennro qacrrl 2. M' 2015.

+ Tau xe.qd- raMXe.

^^,6 Jlase6uurco\a A.IO., pymrcohcrcan E.JL Elg2015.- O6ruecrBo3Ha're. T;";;;;;;";;;; #"nns.M.2075.

7 Jla^se6uuro6a, A.IO., pymrcoilcrcan E.JI., Ko_ponurcoAa E C. EfO 20I5. O6rqecrBo;;^";;.';;;^prlaHTOB Tr.lrroB6rx TecTcKa K Bbrrorrlre rro rurrluT.';;.:it1{.^

z rloAroroB-8 Cneqrz$rlxaqrzr x

:::1 il""p "."o" o,,n 'pooJ##xxtriffj#:ff _r{oro rocyIaPCTBeHHOfo

11",rc: .u n i, n ttp,lrri;, ffiUJ_Til: ;irH:ff _sii-specifikacii-kodif ikutu.ye Jlaze6nuro6a, A.IO., pymxoilcrcax E.JI., Ko_ponurcoqa E C. EfD zots. O6rqecrs;st-;H;;.';r';:

plraHTOB TArroBbrx TecToBrrix 3aAaHIirt " ,rooaoro"_Ka K,Bbrno,rHeHr.trc vacrh 2. M.,2015.

,,,;'Jt:;::i::::"!,? +,!::::!:ras E rl EtEnus. M.,2075.

r arroBbre TecToBr,re 3aAa_

fleop y4earHoro KHr3, XII eexaCodepxauue

flsop y4ersuoro xHlc,4croMyaa'4uaQry,,l'.il"i#l;:'i;J:f..55ir:'T:iifffffi::,ff

Jfl 1.,:-JJ,Iilil.#iil;::f,ffiilT',.,i:'J?i:T:,X",Hfi,.;#T,H::*:::l ::l'ere,bcrBv,or'nnb,By,!',e no peKe mopeo'ue cy.a.uo e n dpvxuuuu"u"nefes KH'3eM cro'r,(p ,rrurf,lolii.,'.ffixi:yfi:r:::iiT:::;i';^:::::tr::"ii'!ii;i iil,i:lli,i,7i[,]d';:;!,:;';::::^;*';:i: ^"x,r

orpoK, cton,4uilno npaByo py*y or KH,3,. KsR:u cu-

fr:Y:::;:::J'J:,X*0""b' h HoBue Bopoma'::":::::::::1"#:;ffT:H;:::j:::;Z:':'r::t;::::BilHa Ha noAHoce,.,",r::;','.H;',.ffi;i Xllll,,iiiillil;:,,:::::**,,o6p,x.,,, 0,poi..'u.,.,;KpecnoM u npvcran'Ho ua6nrc4aroqero - r.oo" -'re norBr4rcr rh B HeM r..j;#,ljlilr#,ir.:r.*

3a KHrxr4M

MemoduxaKapruta Moxer ilcnc

i:;,;:Wff f,'#itrfu J,T,3HA'fr H*'#:,":.fi .'#T:i'fi 'i:l'#X":::i\;!il::::?;1. Hari4r,rre Ha KaprilHe 06".*rr,,,r,n.r.rri,t'r r.**a.2. Oreersre Ha Bonpocbt.Kax egr c,.thtaere, K Ka

6paxeH ,. ;;;;;;l*otU pefiloHy Pyoa nepuo4a pa:4po6reHnoc'4 orHoc

MeHraMu KaprHHbr. rropo4cxofi pyt'' ctttpo-docro'r'rofi Pycu unu-

"-r;;t;;.u#t;;ffi:?j:ffi:Jta;::-Kax ilseecrHo' yAe' pa3B/Bancr (no BocxoArqei)) ecnil B HeM HarilqecrB(3eMnff. npoxo4rqui roproaur i,r nyrs, cuntua, ,;;;; B,racrb uorcyrcrBr4e ,rr""^n^ 4 ycnoeua: nno4opoAHat

ffitJ#;.1'JJ'1il'-'J#fiojf"'o KaprilHe'

'oo"u'l"v.' "o6pu**"r,r;.#ffiffii:i::Jiil1i1;l:l'*_^_.nr*-rtraatHo, ABop yAerbHoro xHsgs 6srr aoeHFlftan*oil torrrrr,. li.* r;; xynoxHr4rc orpa3unr, .r.:1t;j;r';JuTBeHHbrM

t4 a}Mu{ucrparuauur"r qeurporv geo-

US-o

EUE

v Et9 n Of o