7/25/2019 RULE 73

1/5

VENUE AND PROCESS

RULE 73

VENUE

AND

PROCESS

ANG~CABRERA~CALDINO~CHUPUNGCO~JOSOL~MARAVILLA~SAGUINSIN~SAN JOSE~SUVA~TOLENTINO~TOLENTINO~UY

SPECIAL PROCEEDINGS(SBCA, Monday Class)S.Y 2012-2013 Page367

7/25/2019 RULE 73

2/5

VENUE AND PROCESS

LIM vs. COURT OF APPEALS

G.R. No. 112229, Ma!" 1#, 199$

D%&'s(') *+ C"/&!o, Aa%' R.

FACTS The case is a complain !iled "y Ma#i"el C#$% !o# child s$ppo# on "ehal! o! he# da$ghe#

&oanna Rose agains Raymond 'ho, Ma#i"el claims, is &oannas !ahe#

*n +7-, Ma#i"el 'as a pa#.ime s$den 'ho also 'o#/ed as a #ecepionis a Tonigh0s Cl$" along

Ro1as Bl2d, Manila 'he#e she me Raymond Peiione# 'ooed he# and she #ecip#ocaed his lo2e

They soon li2ed ogehe#, 'ih Raymond paying he #enals *n &$ly +-+, Ma#i"el le! !o# &apan,

al#eady p#egnan ha ime, and #e$#ned o Manila he#ea!e# The co$ple ne2e# ma##ied "eca$se

peiione# claimed ha he 'as no !inancially sa"le n &an$a#y +7, +-4, Ma#i"el ga2e "i#h o

hei# da$ghe# a he Ca#dinal Sanos Memo#ial 5ospial The "ills !o# Ma#i"el0s h#ee.day

con!inemen a he hospial 'e#e paid !o# "y Raymond and he also ca$sed he #egis#aion o! he

name &oanna Rose C Pe Lim on he child0s "i#h ce#i!icae A!e# &oanna Rose0s "i#h, he lo2e

a!!ai# "e'een Ma#i"el and Raymond conin$ed To'a#ds he lae# pa# o! +-3, Ma#i"el noed

ha peiione#0s !eelings o'a#d he# sa#ed o 'ane 5e s$"se6$enly a"andoned he# and &oanna

Rose Ma#i"el #ied o s$ppo# he#sel! "$ i 'as ne2e# eno$gh She as/ed peiione# !o# s$ppo#

"$, despie p#omises o do so, i 'as ne2e# gi2en

ISSUE hehe# o# no he#e is clea# and con2incing p#oo! ha Raymond is he !ahe# o! &oanna

ELD 8es Peiione# has ne2e# con#o2e#ed he e2idence on #eco#d 5is lo2e lee#s o Ma#i"el

2o'ing o "e a good !ahe# o &oanna Rose, pic$#es o! himsel! on 2a#io$s occasions c$ddling

&oanna Rose and he Ce#i!icae o! Li2e Bi#h say i all

*n Al"e#o 2 Co$# o! Appeals, 'e said9

:hen a p$ai2e !ahe# mani!ess openly h#o$gh 'o#ds and deeds his #ecogniion o! a

child, he co$#s can do no less han con!i#m said ac/no'ledgmen As he immo#al "a#d

Sha/espea#e pe#spicacio$sly said9 0Le yo$# o'n disc#eion "e yo$# $o#; s$i he acion o

he 'o#d, he 'o#d o he acion:

7/25/2019 RULE 73

3/5

VENUE AND PROCESS

EIRS OF SPOUSES SANDEAS vs. LINA

G.R. No. 11435 F'*a+ 6, 2001

Po/'/(' Pa/&a/%*a/,

D%&'s(') *+ C"/&!o, Aa%' R.

FACTS n

7/25/2019 RULE 73

4/5

VENUE AND PROCESS

Eliodo#o S#0s sha#e o! he disp$ed #ealy .. 'ill $nnecessa#ily p#olong he selemen o! he

inesae esaes o! he deceased spo$ses

The s$spensi2e condiion did no #ed$ce he condiional sale "e'een Eliodo#o S# and #esponden

o one ha 'as :no a de!inie, clea# and a"sol$e doc$men o! sale,: as conended "y peiione#s

Upon he occ$##ence o! he condiion, he condiional sale "ecame a #ecip#ocally demanda"le

o"ligaion ha is "inding $pon he pa#iesThaAcebedo case also in2ol2ed a condiional sale o!

#eal p#ope#y p#o2es ha he e1isence o! he s$spensi2e condiion did no #emo2e ha p#ope#y

!#om he =$#isdicion o! he inesae co$#

ANG~CABRERA~CALDINO~CHUPUNGCO~JOSOL~MARAVILLA~SAGUINSIN~SAN JOSE~SUVA~TOLENTINO~TOLENTINO~UY

SPECIAL PROCEEDINGS(SBCA, Monday Class)S.Y 2012-2013 Page370

7/25/2019 RULE 73

5/5

VENUE AND PROCESS

7ARRETTO REALTY DEVELOPMENT INC. vs. COURT OF APPEALS

G.R. No. L-4231-33, A&s( 31, 19#

Po/'/(' G(%''8, .

D%&'s(') *+ C"/&!o, Aa%' R.

FACTS: A peiion !o# p#o"ae o! >icolai D#epins holog#aphic 'ill 'as iniiaed a!e# his deah

D#epin le! se2e#al pa#cels o! land and he only 'ay o pay he c#edio#s claims is o sell he same

D$#ing D#epins li!eime, a oal o! - heca#es had "een sold o Mosla#es 5o'e2e#, i 'as no

#egise#ed ye $nil he "alance o! he p$#chase p#ice has "een paid S$"se6$enly, Mosla#es and

D#epin ene#ed ino a &oin Fen$#e Ag#eemen (&FA) 'hich lised D#epin as he #egise#ed o'ne# o!

he los and denominaed Mosla#es as de2elope# as/ed 'ih he con2e#sion o! he lands ino a

#esidenial s$"di2ision Be!o#e he &FA co$ld "e implemened, D#epin died

Mosla#es inimaed 'ih he co$# ha he 'as al#eady he o'ne# o! he los and p#oposed ha he

"e pe#mied o pay he "alance on he sale 'ih mo#gage in acco#dance 'ih he e#ms o! his

'#ien p#oposal The co$# g#aned he same

Mosla#es 'as no a"le o pay on ime, so he p#o"ae co$# iss$ed an o#de# a$ho#i%ing he

adminis#ao# o ene# ino an ag#eemen 'ih any pa#y ine#esed in "$ying he p#ope#ies o! he

esae in o#de# o pay D#epins c#edio#s Mosla#es !iled a moion !o# #econside#aion 'hich 'as

denied The los 'e#e s$"se6$enly sold o Pio Ba##eo Realy Mosla#es !iled an U#gen Moion !o#

Reconside#aion 'hich 'as again denied 5e hen !iled a peiion !o# ce#io#a#i "e!o#e he Co$# o!

Appeals 'hich iss$ed a empo#a#y #es#aining in his !a2o#

ISSUE hehe# o# no he #esponden =$dge aced 'iho$ o# in e1cess o! =$#isdicion o# 'ih g#a2e

a"$se o! disc#eion in #e!$sing o e1cl$de he s$"=ec pa#cels o! land

ELD >o. The Co$# held ha e2en 'ih s$ch p#es$mpion and #e!$sal, he #esponden co$# sill

aced 'ihin is =$#isdicion and no 'ih g#a2e a"$se o! disc#eion A!e# all, he =$#isp#$dence and

#$le a#e "oh o he e!!ec ha he p#o"ae co$# :may: p#o2isionally pass $pon he 6$esion o!

e1cl$sion, no :sho$ld: The o"2io$s #eason is he p#o"ae co$#0s limied =$#isdicion and he

p#inciple ha 6$esions o! ile o# o'ne#ship, 'hich #es$l o incl$sion in o# e1cl$sion !#om he

in2eno#y o! he p#ope#y, can only "e seled in a sepa#ae acion 5ence, e2en i! #esponden co$#

p#es$med he 'ay ha he p#ope#ies sold "y D#epin o peiione# 'e#e pa# o! D#epin0s esae, ha

'o$ld no p#e2en no# de!ea peiione#0s #emedy in a sepa#ae s$i Conse6$enly, in #e2ie'ing he

e1e#cise o! s$ch limied p#o"ae =$#isdicion, he Co$# canno o#de# an $n6$ali!ied and $n6$ali!ied

and !inal e1cl$sion o! he p#ope#ies in2ol2ed, as p#ayed !o#; o do so 'o$ld e1pand he p#o"aeco$#0s =$#isdicion "eyond he pe#imee#s se "y la' and =$#isp#$dence

ANG~CABRERA~CALDINO~CHUPUNGCO~JOSOL~MARAVILLA~SAGUINSIN~SAN JOSE~SUVA~TOLENTINO~TOLENTINO~UY

SPECIAL PROCEEDINGS(SBCA, Monday Class)S.Y 2012-2013 Page371