Agendapeople.stern.nyu.edu/iag/presentations/2009-2010/WEN.pdf · rebranding, management team:...

45
Agenda Sector Trends Company Overview Thesis Risks Valuation Q&A Wendy’s/Arby’s Group (WEN) Rachel Nabatian Will Zhang Mayank Vidyarthi

Transcript of Agendapeople.stern.nyu.edu/iag/presentations/2009-2010/WEN.pdf · rebranding, management team:...

Page 1: Agendapeople.stern.nyu.edu/iag/presentations/2009-2010/WEN.pdf · rebranding, management team: Turnaround fails. Already ahead of schedule, management team: Commodity volatility impacts

Agenda

• Sector Trends• Company Overview• Thesis• Risks• Valuation• Q&A Wendy’s/Arby’s Group (WEN)

Rachel NabatianWill Zhang

Mayank Vidyarthi

Page 2: Agendapeople.stern.nyu.edu/iag/presentations/2009-2010/WEN.pdf · rebranding, management team: Turnaround fails. Already ahead of schedule, management team: Commodity volatility impacts

Agenda• Sector Overview

• Company Overview

• Thesis

• Risks

• DCF

Page 3: Agendapeople.stern.nyu.edu/iag/presentations/2009-2010/WEN.pdf · rebranding, management team: Turnaround fails. Already ahead of schedule, management team: Commodity volatility impacts

Sector Overview and Trends• Customers increasingly price-sensitive

– Unemployment, underemployment remain high– Wealth destruction, increased savings rate

• Conditions strongly favor lower-cost dining– Quick-service restaurants offer best value

• “Magic $5 price point”– Meals for $5 or less (e.g. Subway $5 Foot-

longs)

Page 4: Agendapeople.stern.nyu.edu/iag/presentations/2009-2010/WEN.pdf · rebranding, management team: Turnaround fails. Already ahead of schedule, management team: Commodity volatility impacts

Competition

Page 5: Agendapeople.stern.nyu.edu/iag/presentations/2009-2010/WEN.pdf · rebranding, management team: Turnaround fails. Already ahead of schedule, management team: Commodity volatility impacts

Overview: Wendy’s• Known for square burgers• Wendy’s 99¢ Menu• Historically low margins (around

~11% vs. Industry avg. of 17%)• Margin Improvement Plan Ahead of

Schedule• Average ticket is $4

Page 6: Agendapeople.stern.nyu.edu/iag/presentations/2009-2010/WEN.pdf · rebranding, management team: Turnaround fails. Already ahead of schedule, management team: Commodity volatility impacts

Overview: Arby’s• Specializes in premium roast beef

sandwiches– Unique among QSR’s

• Historically had high average ticket– $7.50 vs. under $5 for typical QSR’s

• Historical margins in line with industry average (~17%)

Page 7: Agendapeople.stern.nyu.edu/iag/presentations/2009-2010/WEN.pdf · rebranding, management team: Turnaround fails. Already ahead of schedule, management team: Commodity volatility impacts

Revenue Breakdown by Operating Segment

Wendy's Company-Owned

Arby's Company-Owned

Wendy's Franchises

Arby's Franchises

59%31%

8%2%

Page 8: Agendapeople.stern.nyu.edu/iag/presentations/2009-2010/WEN.pdf · rebranding, management team: Turnaround fails. Already ahead of schedule, management team: Commodity volatility impacts

Sources of RevenueDelivery of food

Bakery items and kid’s meal

Royalty income from franchisees

Rental income

Startup franchise fees89%

1.9%

8.2% 0.18%

Page 9: Agendapeople.stern.nyu.edu/iag/presentations/2009-2010/WEN.pdf · rebranding, management team: Turnaround fails. Already ahead of schedule, management team: Commodity volatility impacts

Thesis• Merger = Turnaround

–Wendy’s increasing margins–Arby’s offering more value

• Macroeconomic Trends Favor QSR’s Over Casual Dining Outlets

• Short and Long-Term Growth Catalysts

• DCF

Page 10: Agendapeople.stern.nyu.edu/iag/presentations/2009-2010/WEN.pdf · rebranding, management team: Turnaround fails. Already ahead of schedule, management team: Commodity volatility impacts

Reasons for Merger• Wendy’s underperformance since 2002

– Founder Dave Thomas died in 2002• Wendy’s historically low operating margins

– Poor cost control– High breakfast item costs

• Lack of coherent marketing message• Thomas was instrumental in Wendy’s

advertisements

• Arby’s benefits from Wendy’s large size

Page 11: Agendapeople.stern.nyu.edu/iag/presentations/2009-2010/WEN.pdf · rebranding, management team: Turnaround fails. Already ahead of schedule, management team: Commodity volatility impacts

Triarc Acquires Wendy’s• Initiated by Nelson Peltz

– Triarc board member– Well known in the food industry with

turnarounds for• Snapple• Kraft • Cadbury Schweppes• Heinz

– Held 10% of Wendy’s shares

Page 12: Agendapeople.stern.nyu.edu/iag/presentations/2009-2010/WEN.pdf · rebranding, management team: Turnaround fails. Already ahead of schedule, management team: Commodity volatility impacts

Merger Details• Completed on September 28, 2008• All-stock transaction

– Wendy’s shareholders received 4.25 shares of Wendy’s/Arby’s common stock for each Wendy’s share

• Triarc renamed to Wendy’s/Arby’s Group• Triarc CEO Roland Smith becomes CEO

of Wendy’s/Arby’s

Page 13: Agendapeople.stern.nyu.edu/iag/presentations/2009-2010/WEN.pdf · rebranding, management team: Turnaround fails. Already ahead of schedule, management team: Commodity volatility impacts

The Turnaround Artist• Roland Smith, President and Chief Executive

Officer• Turnaround Experience

– Arby’s, 1994 to 1999• Tripled op. profit from 1996 to 1998• Industry leader same store sales growth

– American Golf, 2003 to 2005• Grew revenue and profits • 38% IRR to investors

– AMF, 1999 to 2003 • Out of Chapter 11 • Reduction of total debt by two-thirds• Positive comp sales growth

Page 14: Agendapeople.stern.nyu.edu/iag/presentations/2009-2010/WEN.pdf · rebranding, management team: Turnaround fails. Already ahead of schedule, management team: Commodity volatility impacts

The Turnaround Artist• Gets it done

– Went to West Point– U.S. Army for seven years

• Platoon leader• Executive officer • Deputy director of Army programs • Aide-de-camp • Aviation maintenance officer• Pilot

Page 15: Agendapeople.stern.nyu.edu/iag/presentations/2009-2010/WEN.pdf · rebranding, management team: Turnaround fails. Already ahead of schedule, management team: Commodity volatility impacts

First there was Wendy’s…

Page 16: Agendapeople.stern.nyu.edu/iag/presentations/2009-2010/WEN.pdf · rebranding, management team: Turnaround fails. Already ahead of schedule, management team: Commodity volatility impacts

Then there was Arby’s…

Page 17: Agendapeople.stern.nyu.edu/iag/presentations/2009-2010/WEN.pdf · rebranding, management team: Turnaround fails. Already ahead of schedule, management team: Commodity volatility impacts

And they formed the Wendy’s/Arby’s Group

Page 18: Agendapeople.stern.nyu.edu/iag/presentations/2009-2010/WEN.pdf · rebranding, management team: Turnaround fails. Already ahead of schedule, management team: Commodity volatility impacts

The Turnaround• Combining “best practices”• Margin-focused turnaround at Wendy’s

– Goal: Improve operating margins from 11.7% in 2008 to 16.7% by 2011

• Value-focused SSS turnaround at Arby’s– Goal: Increase SSS by providing value-based

menu offerings• Merger synergies

– $60 M target G&A Savings

Page 19: Agendapeople.stern.nyu.edu/iag/presentations/2009-2010/WEN.pdf · rebranding, management team: Turnaround fails. Already ahead of schedule, management team: Commodity volatility impacts

G&A Savings• Key projects:

– Integrating Shared Services Center– IT systems integration

• Achieved $25M in cost savings in 2008• On pace to achieve $10M - $25M savings

in 2009

Page 20: Agendapeople.stern.nyu.edu/iag/presentations/2009-2010/WEN.pdf · rebranding, management team: Turnaround fails. Already ahead of schedule, management team: Commodity volatility impacts

Wendy’s: Impressive Margin Improvements

• Target: 500 bp operating margin improvement by 2011

• +370 bp improvement from Q2 '08 to Q2 '09– Commodities were flat over this period from

hedging• Margins were 15.9% in Q2 '09, back to

levels not seen since early 2000’s

Page 21: Agendapeople.stern.nyu.edu/iag/presentations/2009-2010/WEN.pdf · rebranding, management team: Turnaround fails. Already ahead of schedule, management team: Commodity volatility impacts

Already at 15.9%, well above 13.3-13.5% target

Page 22: Agendapeople.stern.nyu.edu/iag/presentations/2009-2010/WEN.pdf · rebranding, management team: Turnaround fails. Already ahead of schedule, management team: Commodity volatility impacts

Margin Improvement Areas• Tighter control of controllable costs

– Labor hours– Wasted food (Actual cost – theoretical cost)– Utilities

• Higher same-store sales from new menu items, promotions, marketing campaigns

Page 23: Agendapeople.stern.nyu.edu/iag/presentations/2009-2010/WEN.pdf · rebranding, management team: Turnaround fails. Already ahead of schedule, management team: Commodity volatility impacts

Arby’s: Strategic Shift to Value-Based Menu

• Initiatives aimed at repeat customers– Comprise 50% of sales– 1 extra visit each year =

3% SSS improvement– Offering more value

items• July: $5 BBQ Bacon

Cheddar Roastburger– 1.1% SSS increase

from June to Julyhttp://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ssukzKa5P0w

Page 24: Agendapeople.stern.nyu.edu/iag/presentations/2009-2010/WEN.pdf · rebranding, management team: Turnaround fails. Already ahead of schedule, management team: Commodity volatility impacts

Arby’s: Premium Products For Great Value

• Starting in Q4: $5 premium roast beef sandwich combos– Full-sized sandwich + Fries + Drink = $5.01– Premium quality: “Worth every penny”

• August promotion: 5 for $5 Family & Friends Feast:– 5 Roast Beef Sandwiches for $5 ($1 each)

Page 25: Agendapeople.stern.nyu.edu/iag/presentations/2009-2010/WEN.pdf · rebranding, management team: Turnaround fails. Already ahead of schedule, management team: Commodity volatility impacts
Page 26: Agendapeople.stern.nyu.edu/iag/presentations/2009-2010/WEN.pdf · rebranding, management team: Turnaround fails. Already ahead of schedule, management team: Commodity volatility impacts

Arby’s: Improving Value Improving Same-Store Sales

Coming October ‘09: Introduction of $5 Combo Meals

July ‘09: BBQ Bacon Cheddar RoastburgerCombo Promotion

Average Arby’s Meal Price$7.50 $5

Page 27: Agendapeople.stern.nyu.edu/iag/presentations/2009-2010/WEN.pdf · rebranding, management team: Turnaround fails. Already ahead of schedule, management team: Commodity volatility impacts

Wendy’s: New Menu Items• Boneless chicken wings introduced in

June– 2.0% increase in same-store sales in July

• Premium “Bacon Deluxe” cheeseburger to be introduced in Q4 2009

Page 28: Agendapeople.stern.nyu.edu/iag/presentations/2009-2010/WEN.pdf · rebranding, management team: Turnaround fails. Already ahead of schedule, management team: Commodity volatility impacts

“But aren’t all these turnaround benefits already priced in?”

Page 29: Agendapeople.stern.nyu.edu/iag/presentations/2009-2010/WEN.pdf · rebranding, management team: Turnaround fails. Already ahead of schedule, management team: Commodity volatility impacts

“But aren’t all these turnaround benefits already priced in?”

• To answer your question, Doug, no! – Trading at acquisition values – Does include the predicted synergies of $60M– Does not include:

• Organic op. margin improvements which are ahead of schedule

• Arby’s dramatic SSS improvement• Cost savings beating everyone’s expectations,

beyond predicted $60M

Page 30: Agendapeople.stern.nyu.edu/iag/presentations/2009-2010/WEN.pdf · rebranding, management team: Turnaround fails. Already ahead of schedule, management team: Commodity volatility impacts

Wendy’s: Quality Products

“It's waaay better than fast food... It's Wendy's.”

Page 31: Agendapeople.stern.nyu.edu/iag/presentations/2009-2010/WEN.pdf · rebranding, management team: Turnaround fails. Already ahead of schedule, management team: Commodity volatility impacts

Casual Dining vs. QSRsCasual Dining

• Cheesecake factory

• Applebee’s• P.F. Chang’s• Denny’s

QSR’s• Wendy’s• Arby’s• McDonald’s• Burger King• Chipotle• Panera• Taco Bell

Page 32: Agendapeople.stern.nyu.edu/iag/presentations/2009-2010/WEN.pdf · rebranding, management team: Turnaround fails. Already ahead of schedule, management team: Commodity volatility impacts

QSR’s Are Undervalued Compared to Casual Dining

• Casual dining trading above year-ago levels

• Short interest as % of Share Float:– QSR’s: 4%– Casual Dining:17%

• High-growth for casual dining = riskier

Page 33: Agendapeople.stern.nyu.edu/iag/presentations/2009-2010/WEN.pdf · rebranding, management team: Turnaround fails. Already ahead of schedule, management team: Commodity volatility impacts

QSR’s: Still Undervalued

Page 34: Agendapeople.stern.nyu.edu/iag/presentations/2009-2010/WEN.pdf · rebranding, management team: Turnaround fails. Already ahead of schedule, management team: Commodity volatility impacts
Page 35: Agendapeople.stern.nyu.edu/iag/presentations/2009-2010/WEN.pdf · rebranding, management team: Turnaround fails. Already ahead of schedule, management team: Commodity volatility impacts
Page 36: Agendapeople.stern.nyu.edu/iag/presentations/2009-2010/WEN.pdf · rebranding, management team: Turnaround fails. Already ahead of schedule, management team: Commodity volatility impacts

Deteriorating SSS for Casual Dining

Page 37: Agendapeople.stern.nyu.edu/iag/presentations/2009-2010/WEN.pdf · rebranding, management team: Turnaround fails. Already ahead of schedule, management team: Commodity volatility impacts

Casual Dining Supply > Demand

Page 38: Agendapeople.stern.nyu.edu/iag/presentations/2009-2010/WEN.pdf · rebranding, management team: Turnaround fails. Already ahead of schedule, management team: Commodity volatility impacts

QSR’s Show Strong Margins

WEN achieved good margins in Q2 09, despite weak performance of Casual Dining Restaurants

Page 39: Agendapeople.stern.nyu.edu/iag/presentations/2009-2010/WEN.pdf · rebranding, management team: Turnaround fails. Already ahead of schedule, management team: Commodity volatility impacts

Short-Term Catalysts• Improving operating margins at Wendy’s• Value-driven same-store sales growth at

Arby’s• New menu item launches at Wendy’s• $50M stock buyback plan

Page 40: Agendapeople.stern.nyu.edu/iag/presentations/2009-2010/WEN.pdf · rebranding, management team: Turnaround fails. Already ahead of schedule, management team: Commodity volatility impacts

Long-Term Catalysts• Breakfast

– Testing phase in select stores• International stores

– 135 stores in Middle East and N. Africa franchised by Al Jammaz Group to open over next decade

• Dual-branded stores– 3 test stores to open in Atlanta in early 2010

• New brand under consideration– $565 million bond offering in June

Page 41: Agendapeople.stern.nyu.edu/iag/presentations/2009-2010/WEN.pdf · rebranding, management team: Turnaround fails. Already ahead of schedule, management team: Commodity volatility impacts

Wendy’s/Arby’s International Presence

Page 42: Agendapeople.stern.nyu.edu/iag/presentations/2009-2010/WEN.pdf · rebranding, management team: Turnaround fails. Already ahead of schedule, management team: Commodity volatility impacts

Comps• Current EV/EBITDA: 7x CY10

– discount to its group at 8x

Page 43: Agendapeople.stern.nyu.edu/iag/presentations/2009-2010/WEN.pdf · rebranding, management team: Turnaround fails. Already ahead of schedule, management team: Commodity volatility impacts

EBITDA Increase• 2Q09: EBITDA of $117.2M Exceeded

consensus est. of $110M– Result of better than expected Wendy’s

margin gains• Future EBITDA increase resulting from

– Decreased labor costs from synergies – Central purchasing unit

Page 44: Agendapeople.stern.nyu.edu/iag/presentations/2009-2010/WEN.pdf · rebranding, management team: Turnaround fails. Already ahead of schedule, management team: Commodity volatility impacts

Potential RisksRISKS MITIGANTS

Competition Turnaround, dual branding, value rebranding, management team

Turnaround fails Already ahead of schedule,management team

Commodity volatility impacts input costs

WEN engages in hedging through forward contracts

Vegetarianism/PETA PETA campaign focused mostly on McDonalds

Increases in minimum wage Will affect entire industry, so overall market share should not be affected

Page 45: Agendapeople.stern.nyu.edu/iag/presentations/2009-2010/WEN.pdf · rebranding, management team: Turnaround fails. Already ahead of schedule, management team: Commodity volatility impacts

Q