NeuCo's MaintenanceOpt Great Catches
Transcript of NeuCo's MaintenanceOpt Great Catches
Great Catches:How Equipment HealthDetection & DiagnosticSystems are Improving
Great Catches:How Equipment HealthDetection & DiagnosticSystems are ImprovingPlant AvailabilityPlant Availability
Coal Gen 2010Ray JohnsonNeuCo, Inc
Optimization Software & Availability
� Optimization helps improve availability/reliability by:� Using predictive analytics to identify potential
equipment health issues� Providing early warnings for impending failures� Minimizing unnecessary outages� Minimizing unnecessary outages� Sponsoring better use of planned down-time� Reducing tube leak outages
Proprietary and Confidential
MaintenanceOpt®
� What it does:Automatically alerts users to symptoms of potential equipment healthissues (efficiency, capacity or reliability based) and allows quick easydrill down to uncover actionable responses to diagnose and remedythe underlying problems.
� Using:� Neural Networks
Proprietary and Confidential
� Expert Rules� Other Optimizer Alerts
� To Improve:� Unit up-time� Speed of issue resolution� Efficiency
Equipment Types
� Air heaters� Auxiliary equipment (ESP, FGD, SCR, crusher, etc.)� Boiler
MaintenanceOpt may be used to detect problems in a fossilgenerating power plant associated with the following types ofequipment:
Proprietary and Confidential
� Condenser� Fans and drives� Feedwater heaters� General (flows, heat rate, etc.)� Pulverizers� Pumps� Turbine
Examples of Potential Problems
The types of problems that can be detected aredependent upon the type of equipment. For example, forair heaters, the following provides a list of potentialproblems that may be identified:
� Inaccurate leakage calculation due to stratification or instrument error
Proprietary and Confidential
g� Basket damage� Ash or salt plugging� Bearing inadequate oil cooling� Shaft misalignment� Bearing failure
Indicators of Potential Problems
� High AH air or gas side pressure drop� High AH cold end average temperature� Low AH cold end average temperature
The following process values associated with an airheater are monitored as part of an early warning system:
Proprietary and Confidential
Low AH cold end average temperature� Air Heater leakage increasing� Increasing APH coil differential pressure� Bearing temperature increasing
Problem Identification
Proprietary and Confidential
� Model is used to predict equipment performance� Model output is compared to actual performance� If difference is larger than a threshold, an anomaly is
detected
Diagnosis Flow Chart
A flow chart for diagnosinga potential problem isshown
Proprietary and Confidential
How Alerts areManaged & Maintained
Proprietary and Confidential
Managed & Maintained
NeuCo Customer Support
� Answer any questions related to the products� Provide software updates� Update system configuration� Provide weekly reports� Monitor for high urgency alerts
Proprietary and Confidential
g g y� Monitor performance of the optimizers� Provide additional training� and more…
Automated Alerts Management
TriggerService
EmailComposer
ProcessLink at Site
EmailServer
CustomerSupportInterface
Customer Support
EmailServer
Proprietary and Confidential
Service
HistoricalData
Composer at Site
CompositeTrigger
Database
Interfaceat NeuCo
Automated Reporting HelpsExtract Maximum Value
� KPIs Reflect Your Asset Management Metrics� EFOR/EFOR-D� Heat Rate (rolling average, vs. targets, etc.)� Emissions (cumulative tons, rolling average, vs. targets, etc.)� Revenue (vs. targets, historical benchmark, etc.)� Profitability (gross & net margins, vs. target, etc.)
B ilt I B h ki� Built-In Benchmarking� What benefits have been achieved?� Additional benefits that could be achieved� Changes in performance over time and implications
� Demystification Sheds Light on Key Processes� What optimizers are doing and why� Where the most important trade-offs are occurring� How are constraints limiting benefits and what can be done?
Proprietary and Confidential
MaintenanceOpt Weekly Report
Proprietary and Confidential
Example Recent Catches
� High ID fan motor temperature
� Low oil on a fan bearing
� Condenser air evacuation problem
� Increasing turbine bearing vibrationg g
Proprietary and Confidential
MaintenanceOpt: ID Fan Motor Temperature
� Unit: PRPA Rawhide Unit #1, 300 MWs.� Usage: The following problem was identified
during a routine review of MaintenanceOptalerts.
� Incident: The temperature of an ID MotorStator Temperature had increased over apseveral week period. This issue wasrecognized by Customer Support. Earlywarnings were sent to the client about thisissue. Based on the warnings, the clientcleaned the filter and performance returned tonormal.
ID Fan Problem
� ID Fan problem is shown on the MaintenanceOptHome page.
Proprietary and Confidential
Issues to Screen
The ID Fan problem is also shown on the MaintenanceOptIssues to Screen page along with the context data.
Proprietary and Confidential
Alert DataReviewing the alert data, the problem had started threeweeks earlier and had been getting progressively worse.The client had been notified about this issue.
Proprietary and Confidential
Diagnosing the Problem� By clicking “show causes”, we are able to investigate the
potential causes of the problem. The rule for Dirty Filter isshown below. Variables associated with this rule are highlightedincluding data for the other ID stator motor.
Proprietary and Confidential
Identifying the Problem� The temperature of both ID fan motor stators are analyzed. The
temperature on ID Fan 102 is increasing while the temperatureon ID Fan 101 is normal. This is consistent with the rule for adirty filter.
Proprietary and Confidential
Customer Support Sends Warning
Proprietary and Confidential
Verifying the Problem
� An operations crew inspected the filter. It was foundto be dirty and is thus subsequently replaced. Thetemperature returned to normal.
Proprietary and Confidential
Good Catch
Proprietary and Confidential
Low Oil Example
� Unit: NRG Limestone Unit 2, 913 MW� Users: Maintenance Supervisor and Performance
Engineer.� Usage: Both work 4/10 shift Monday to Thursday.
They check MaintenanceOpt each morning whenthey are at site.
� Incident: Low oil on a primary air fan bearingsystem was found on Monday during routine login toMaintenanceOpt.
� Fix: Oil was added to the bearing system severalhours after the problem was identified. Thetemperature returned to normal.
Problem Alerted by MaintenanceOpt
� In a routine login to MaintenanceOpt, the users find an alert for abearing on a primary air fan. The bearing is at 174 degrees whileit is expected to be at 150 degrees.
Checking Alert� Chart shows the actual temperatures for all bearings on this fan.
Also shows expected value for the bearing of interest. Only thetemperature of bearing associated with the alert looks abnormal.
Actual vs. Expected� Actual and expected (neural network) value of applicable bearing
temperature shown. Incident starts Friday afternoon at around 1pm with nomaintenance personnel on site. Value stayed under the points DCS alarmtrigger value. This view is from Monday morning during a routine check.
Diagnosing the Problem
� One likely cause is inadequate lubrication or cooling. Rule clauses arehighlighted below. Temperature is increasing but vibrations are normal.
Fixing the Problem
� Customer fixes the low oil problem within hours of finding it. Temperaturereturns to normal.
Closing the Alert
� The alert is closed and a comment is posted in MaintenanceOpt’s database.
UserComment
Turbine Bearing Vibration
� Unit: APS Four Corners Unit #4, 800 MW� Usage: Routine checks of MaintenanceOpt made
daily� Incident: During a routine check, it was observed
that a turbine vibration was increasing. Noimmediate action was necessary but problem neededt b it d d ilto be monitored daily.
� Fix: Problem was fixed at the next outage
Vibration Alert� Vibration on bearing #7 has triggered. Note that alert had been
triggering >50% of the time over the past week and month.
Proprietary and Confidential
Increasing Vibration� Turbine bearing vibration increasing for past month (green). Neural model
adapting to the change but not as fast as vibration increase (blue).
Proprietary and Confidential
Monitoring the Problem� User has flagged problem so that it stays on the Issues to Screen tab. The
user also entered a comment. Monitoring continued until next outage.
Flagged
Proprietary and Confidential
ggitem
UserComment
Benefits of ProcessLink® Integration
� PerformanceOpt indicates equipment degradation through high-fidelitymodel of thermal processes
� MaintenanceOpt indication of equipment degradation through empiricalmodels of on-line signals as well as potential problems detected throughmanual inspection
� Some problems that would escape notice through one or the other
Proprietary and Confidential
� Some problems that would escape notice through one or the othermethodology become obvious when viewed through both
� MaintenanceOpt also surfaces problems detected by NeuCo’s closed-loop optimizers
� PerformanceOpt informs closed-loop optimizers though virtual on-lineanalyzers indicating important boiler performance parameters not directlymeasured� Coal quality, boiler efficiency and heat rate for CombustionOpt� Boiler cleanliness and heat rate for SootOpt
Condenser Problem
� Unit: APS Four Corners Unit #2, 190 MW
� Usage: During a check of PerformanceOpt andMaintenanceOpt by NeuCo, we noticed a largechange in condenser performance. Plant was notifiedvia email of the problem.
� Incident: During routine maintenance on thed th i t h d i d t tlcondenser, the maintenance crew had inadvertently
disconnected both vacuum pumps causing a largeincrease in backpressure
� Fix: The maintenance crew was notified of theproblem and then properly connected a vacuumpump. Th.e performance returned to normal
M’Opt and P’Opt In Action� Routine review of triggers show alerts on condenser backpressure and
cleanliness have triggered. Backpressure is at 3.05 when expected to be2.2, and cleanliness is at 0.55 when expected at 0.88.
BackpressureAlert from M’Opt
Proprietary and Confidential
CleanlinessAlert from P’Opt
Condenser Cleanliness
� Condenser Cleanliness significantly changes fromexpected at around 10 am.
Proprietary and Confidential
Condenser Backpressure
� Condenser backpressure also significantly changesat the same time.
Proprietary and Confidential
Diagnosis
� Low condenser cleanliness and high condenser backpressureindicates inadequate air removal equipment performance.
Proprietary and Confidential
Resolution� Maintenance crew reconnects the vacuum pump and
performance returns to normal.
Proprietary and Confidential
Questions?
Proprietary and Confidential