r--a'- i€..',4-

H.P. STATE POLLUTIONTTIM PARIVESII, PIIASE III,

CONTROL BOARDNEIV SI{IMLA-I7I OO9.

"{ Dated:- 1;;!s"'.--;', (109) Krishna Stone Crusher - Riyali/ Kangra/2013-

- Fr.:m: Member Secretary

The Director (Environment, S&T),Department of Environment, Science and Technology,Narayan Villa, Near Wood Villa Palace, Shimla-2. fupl^1ix.,t4,

Subject: Environmental Public Hearing on the proposal submitted bylM/s Krishna Stone Crusher, V.P.O. Riyali,Tehsil Fatehpur, District Kangra, Himachal Pradesh for collection of Sand, Stone and Bajri situated inKhasraNo. 2593, 2594,259512 measuring 13-OO-74 Hectares at village &Mauza Riyali, Teisil Fatehpur,District Kangra, Himachal Pradesh.

Sir,According to the provision of notification No. SO 1533 (E) Dated l4-09-2006 and the procedure prescribed

therein the State Board has conducted the Public Hearing on 14-05-2013 under the Chairmanship of Additional DistrictMagistrate, Kangra on the proposal of IWs Krishna Stone Crusher, V.P.O. Riyali, Tehsil Fatehpur, District Kangra,Himachal Pradesh for collection of Sand, Stone and Bajri situated in Khasra No. 2593, 2594,259512 measuring l3-00-74 Hcctlres at village &MauzaRiyali, Tehsil Fatehpur, District Kangra, Himachal Pradesh.

Further in view of the contents of notification by the State Govt. issued vide No. STE/Restructuring of ST,E, BT & PC (Vol-l')D}A7 dated l3-04-20A7, please find enclosed herewith:- (i) Proceedings of the Public Hearing inHindi with attendance sheet; (ii) Statement olissues in English as raised in the Pubtic Hearing; (iii) CD / Videotape ofthe proceedings of the Public l{earing; (iv) Representations received during the Public Hearing (v) Copy of thecomplaints / representations received in the State Board. (vi) Copies of Public Notices in English and Hindi publishedby the State Board in the news papers.

The proceedings ancl abi--rr,e-mentioned inlornration are beiriq serrt tJ -\'rlu lbr further necessary action invierv of notification ref'ered to above.Encl: - As above.

Yours faithfully,t/'

(Vineet Kumar)Member Secretary

H. P. State Pollution Control BoardHim Parivesh, Phase -lll, New Shimla

Phone No. 0177 -2673766Endst. No. PCB (109) Krishna Stone Crusher - Riyali/ Kangra/2013-1{1fd 6oL Dated: >t4 - j *2a l3Copy forwarded to the following alongwith the proceedings for information and necessary action:-l. The Secretary, Ministry of Environment & Forests, Govt. of India, New Delhi.2, The Secretary (Environment, S&T) to the Govt. of Himachal Pradesh.

3. The Deputy Commissioner, Distt. Kangra, H. P. for displaying the proceedings for public information.4. The Chairman, Zila Parishad, Distt. Kangra, H.P. for displaying the proceedings for public information.5. The Regional Office, MoE&F, Govt. of India, Sector-31-A, Chandigarh for displaying the proceedings for public

information.6. The SDM, Jawali, Distt. Kangra, H.P., for displaying the proceedings for public information. $ :

7. Tje G.M. DIC at Dharamshala, Distt. Kangra, H.P. for displaying the proceedings tbr public information.A./he Assistant Environmental Engineer (lncharge), HPSPCB, Jassur, Distt. Kangra, H. P.

.il Vtl" Ikishna Stone Crusher, V.P.O. Riyali, Tehsil Fatehpur, District Kangra, Himachal Pradesh.

10.The SDBA, Computer Section, HPSPCB Shimla along with soft copy of the proceedings. He is reqgqqled to host

the same on the State Board's website. a: --") +> '2-

(Vineet * 'it,Member Secretary

H. P. State Pollr-rtion Control BoardHim Parivesh, Phase -lll, Nerv Shimla

k4

Phone No. 0]/ -2673765

X '- r{ r\.

*^. -. -.r'(,

I ' rl Puhlic Hearins on the proposal submitted by-:. Proceedings of Environmental Public Hearing on dated: t410512013 on

,^- t: *;;irhna Stone Crusher, Village & Post office Riyali, Tehsil Fatehpur, Distt. Kangra, H'P' for:- \.**;;;; of Stone, Sand & Bajri situated in Khasra No. 2593, 2594,2595t2, measuring 13-00-74

,t Hect., at village and Mauza Riyali, Tehsil Fatehpur, Distt. Kangra' H'P'

Environmental Public Hearing on the proposal submitted by tWs Krishna Stone Crusher, Village & Post

offrce Riyali, Tehsil Fatehpur, Distt. Kangr4 H.P for collection of stone, Sand & Bajri (minor mineral)

situated in Khasra no. 25g3, 2594,259512, measuring l3-00-74 Hect, at village and Mauza Riyali, Tehsil

Fatehpur, Distt. Kangr4 H.P. was organized on 14.05.2013 at 11.00 AM by H'P' State Pollution control

Boa.j, Regional offrce Jassur as per notification No-So-1533 dated 14.09.2006. This public hearing

was organized by the H.p. State Pollution Control Board under the chairmanship of ADM Kangra at

Dharamshala according to prescribed process of public hearing. The attendance sheet of participants

present in the public nearing is enclosed (Annexure-I). In this public hearing SDM Jawali' Distt' Mining

Offrcer, panchayat pardhan of Riyali Panchayat & Residents of nearby Panchayats were present' First of

all Er. S.K.Dhiman, Regional offrcer, HPSPCB, Jassur welcomed the chairmarU offtcers and officials of

various Departments and public, thereafter started the process of Public Hearing' ADM Kangra at

Dharamshala requested the people present in the Environmental Public Hearing to express their views,

comments, suggestions and objections regarding this proposed Mining Lease without any fear and

pressure froq any comer. Then the brief description regarding this proposed Mining Area was given by

the representative of the Stone Crusher and their consultant IWs IDMA Laboratories' Panchkula'

Haryana.

videography of the public hearing was also done. Accordingly the proceedings of the environmental

public hearing were recorded and the same are reproduced here.

pp

,r'1

7-l nrtQtLW-e -U

,{

Issues/Suggestions raisedName &Address

ffituated in this region and

river stream will get channelized automatical

many times his land got affected due to the floods'

The main advantage of this crusher is that the river

stream gets channelized thereby minimizing the flood

risks. He said that BBMB authorities discharge the

water suddenly without any intimatioq causing

major losses and flood in the region' They also faced

the major losses due to floods in past years and there

*.r. ,o crushers in this region at that time' He also

said that as the number of crushers will increase the

Sh. Karan SinghPathania, V.P.OR"y, TehsilFatehpur, Distt.Kangra

ffiple got benefits after the

on the environment and it is only trqylglbqlgqefiE

installation of crusher. Earlier they have to go to

Damtal or Jawali to procure the construction

material. Now, they get the construction material

locally at cheaper rates. After the installation ofcrushlr, the water stream which used to flow beyond

the bridge is now flowing under the bridge' The

installation of crusher is haVing no adverse impacts

Sh. RumailSingh, V.P.OBadukhar,Tehsil FatehPur,

Distt. Kangra

ffi installation ofthese crushers,

the construction material was procured from Damtal

and the crusher owners used to sell their material to

Punjab only and the local vehicles remained unfilled'

Now aftei the installation of crushers at these

locations they get the construction material easily and

also at .o-pu*tir"ly cheaper rates, so they want the

Sh. Sanjeev

Singh, Yill.Rajgir, Tehsil.Fatehpur, Distt.Kangra. (Govt.Contractor)

/

crushers to be operational. He also said that their landis also at village Rajgrr and many times it has beenflown away into the flood. After the installation ofcrusher the water flows into the river stream due toits channelization and due to this the villagers gotbenefit. So they want the crusher to be operational.

4. Sh. Kausim,Distt VicePresident, KisanSabha DistrictKangra.

He said that they are Cultivating their land and livingin their houses peacefully. He requested that in futurealso unit should carry out mining in the same manneras they are doing presently. If the operations arecarried out in different manner or at any otherlocation, they will face major losses.

No Reply

5. Suresh Dhiman,Up Pradhan,Gram PanchayatBahadpw

He said that whether crusher o\4rners get benefited ornot, it may be known to crusher owners itself, butcommon people get lot of benefits. In the past tractorowners used to damage the areas nearby due tomining, but now they get the material from thiscrusher at cheaper rates. All the nearbypeople/contractors would not get the constructionmaterial at such cheaper rates anywhere else. Fewpeople would be having their objections, but whenthe flood arises, its natural and then nobody will beable to stop that, even the govemment. What's goingon is better and people are havins benefits overall.

No Reply

6. Sh. SatpalSingh, Distt.Vice President,Kisaan Sabha,Tehsil.Fatehpur, Distt.Kangra.

He said that the Government's Mining policy is onlyfor giving benefits to the crusher owners andcontractors. Common people do not have anybenefits. Due to the floods the stream of.the river andwater in it gets changed as per the availability of theslope of the area. He said that they are not against thedevelopmental activities but it should not be in such amanner that for the betterment of one area the otherarea be destroyed.

ADM Kangra atDharamshala informedthat the issues raised bySh. Satpal Singh arebeing recorded andnoted down and. furtherwill be sent to thegovernmentaccordinslv.

7. Subash

Chander,Presidenq AllIndia AntiComrptionBureau, H.P.

He said that he totally agrees with Kishan Sabha Vicepresident and asked Sh. Asholc Sharm4 Distt.Mining Offrcer, Kangra at Dharmshala tha! whenleases are suspended, then whether mining activitiescan be carried out or not?

He said that mining activities are still carried out. Healso said that 10- 15 people were given emDloyment

Sh. Ashok Sharma,Mining Officer, Kangraat Dharamshala repliedthat the permission to.carry out miningoperations has alreadybeen suspended andafter suspension, nomining activity can becarried out. Whereverthe illegal miningactivities are carried outthe action is taken as

per rule. In KrishnaStone Crusher also theone year permission tocarry out operations inmining area has expiredand the PermanentRegistration of the stonecrusher is alsowithdrawn and the casehas been recommendedfor oower disconnection

N-,

7

-

ltti

,,,'I . '-\ a

It,.r* .

f'

rY

a

o

\

l't^

and heavy machinery is used by the crusher owners.He stressed that for the employment of 10- l5 peopleand for benefits of 100-150 people, it is not correct todestroy the 40,000 lives.

through State Geologist,Shimla to The MemberSecretary, H.P. StatePollution ControlBoard, Shimla forfurther necessary action.

8. Suresh Pathania,PresidengKisaan Sabha,

Mand Region,Distt. Kangr4H.P

He said that during August 2011, when flood camethen the destruction was of about 177 Hectares ofland and the compensation given was Rs.06,27,266.00, in which 52 affected people were givenRs. 1,14000.00. The affected area of Tehsil lndorawas 962 Hectares. The Mand region is having 3065motors md 44 govemment rigs for the irrigationfacilities, which are adversely affected because of theflow of edges of the river stream due to the stonecrusher. He informed that the Kisaan Sabha has

passed their resolution and requests the governmentto declare Mand area as no mining zone as theenvironment of this area is being effected due to theminine activities carried out bv the machineries.

No Reply

9. Sh. SukhdeepSingh, Pradhan,Gram PanchayatR"y, TehsilFatehpur, Distt.Kangra.

He said that their main concem is about the waterdischarged by the BBMB from Pong Dam whichaflects the people a lot. In the past also floods cameand at that time there were no crushers in the regionand the mining was carried out at that time also.People from Punjab took the mineral from this area.Whether the crusher is benefiting or not it is adifferent issue, but they have provided theconstruction material free of cost to 50-60 people. Healso advised that if this river stream is channelizedthe problems get solved. The people think that thewater enters their land/trouses due to the crushers, butit is due to the water released in the river from thedam. Instead of closing the crushers the river streamis required to be channelized.

ADM, Kangra atDharamshala informedthat the flood conditionarises due to thedischarge of water byB.B.M.B from the pongdam, but ifthe mining is

also not carried out inproper way, then alsowater gets its way alongthe village and the floodcondition arises.

10. Puran ChandSharma, MandRegion

He said that among 1000 people only 2 personsagreed upon the installations of crusher and 998 leftout wer€ always against the proposal. The crusherinstallation leads to the accidents, they dig out thedeep pits which lead to the occurrence of accidents ofmany people.

No Reply

ll Sh. Hans raj,Representativeof ParyavaranSamiti

He said that Mand region is a flood affected area-

The 52 no. gates downstream of the pong dam arehaving capacity of 11,000 cusecs. If the waterincreases there, where should the excess water shouldbe diverted?

No Reply as it is notconcemed to the MiningArea.

t2. Sh. RomiThakur,Pradhan, GramPanchayat,Bhadpur,Tehsil.Fatehpur, Distt.Kangra

He said that water flows at an approximate distanceof l0 mtrs from the houses of local people. Theyrequested the Panchayat to 'do the needful butPanchayat could not do anything in this regard. Hesaid that villagers may be asked that; whether thestone crushers have caused any losses in their area?Whether the crushers are responsible for land of thepeople which were flown away in the floods? Ifmining is carried out in wrong/unscientific manner,people can stop that, but if the mining is carried outin proper way and the mining is carried out on the

No Reply

\

t.,

Q,u

edges then water will flow inside the channel of riverstream. He fuither alleged that nobody stops theBBMB from discharging irregular water flow. In thepast also floods came aird at that time there were nocrushers in this area.

l3 Atul Mehta,Bhadpur, TehsilFatehpur, DisttKanga

He said that before the installation of the crusher alsothere used to be flood situation due to which heavydistraction was caused. The crusher alone is notresponsible for this problem. There is no guaranteethat there will be no floods after the closure of thecrusher. Whenever there is release of water in theriver, the water can also divert towards the crusherand even downstream. He said that he agrees to thefact that the crusher alone is not responsible for thefloods. Earlier also there were many losses due to theflood.

No Reply

14. Sh. Abhishek,Vill. Bhogrwan,Tehsil.Fatehpur, Distt.Kangra

He said that:l. From where will the construction material begenerated for the construction activities if thecrushers are closed?2. The accidents also took place in other regions,where there are no crushers.3.In 20ll also the flood came and there were landlosses due to water. Whether there were any landlosses in 2012 when there were no flood conditions?4. In Delhi, people are having their houses adjoiningto railway tracks, then does any earthquake came attheir houses due to the movement ofthe fains?

No Reply

15. Sh. SanjeevPrashar

He said that all the views expressed in favor ofcrusher are political. People came from punjab andbought lands here and the paths meant for the waterflow were obstructed by filling soil/muck. Now,when the water come it goes into agricultural fieldsand definitely cause losses. It is very important tohave crushers and there is no idverse impact of it.Many social activities were done by the crusherowners in the local area. Last year also when water ofthe rivdr came into the fields, they have channelizedthe sffeam and protective measures were taken bythem. He stressed and said that the permission maylggranted to the crusher.

No Reply

16. Nanak Chand,Ex Pardhan

He said that the people who are o,posing thecrushers have come here from 20-30 kms away fromthis place. Crushers are installed correctly and thereare no losses due to the crushers. He said his land isadjoining to the crusher. As the mining will increase,the water level will go down. As already informed,the old river course as diverted time to time havebeen developed by the people and have createdprivate land over there by filling in muck/soil, andwhen water/floods carne, nobody asks BBMBregarding the release of water, but everybody saysclose the crushers.

No Reply

a

uL

17. SashiChairdhary,Vill. BelaThakra

She said that nobody@mining is to be carried o*. ir,. 'rrl"g; ,hu, ,t.crusher owners dig deep pits in the areal She furtherrequested that they want..No Crusher, No mining,, inthis reeion

No Reply

18. Thakur GianChand

rrt; rrque$req rne commlttee to consider the views ofSmt. Sashi Chaudhary. He told that in India there areimportant places such as India Gate in the capital ofthe country New Delhi where the water of the riverYamuna used to touch this place, but after adoptingmany protective measures (channelization), nJwater/flood comes there and it was protected. Houseswere constructed in past also, but when they will digpits up to 60 feet the floods will definitely come andlosses will be there.

No Reply

19. Kartar Singh,Badala

ns suggesreq ro cnannelEe the river stream to stopthe losses of the Mand region and further said that thlcrushers should not be closed.

No Reply

20. Sh. RajinderSingh PathaniqMember,Damtal TruckCo-OperativeSociety.

rrs saru rnar JUU_4UU vetucles have got employment.People are jealous of the crushers *a tn.r" are oldcrushers in this area and not new. There is a dam inthe upstream and river in the downstream, wheneverthe water is discharged by the BBMB authorities, it isnever informed to the local people in advance whichlead to flood situations. In pasi also when crusherswere not there, the flood situation was there due tothis problem. 300 vehicles mean that around 2000people get employment. He stressed that they wantthe crushers to be operated and the river streamshould be channelized.

No Reply

21. Sh. Prem Singh,PresidenqParyavaranSamiti, Mandreglon

l He said ttrat ttr

I not correct. When the necessary approvals weregrverq_-then no department had raised the objectionsregarding the bridge constructed with Crores ofrupees. Ex- Pradhan issued NOC after indulging incom-rption and the loses of it were faced ly-thevillageS of nearby areas in August 201l. The locationof this area is in 2 to l0 mtr rlop. *O the Beas riveris diverted towards this side due to the mining by thecrusher owners with the JCB. In the past ttriJ UriAgewas at one side and the river stream was on the oGrside, people used to travel in boats. Regarding theterrace place it is submitted that it is not a terraceplace but it is Beas river. The JCB is used to dig 5_gMeters and this is done under the shelter of thedepartments. This has also been published in newspapers many times. He alleged lhat the fine imposedagainst illegal mining is very less. The vehicles areoverloaded and the material is not covered duringtransportation. The industry is operated day & nightlThe mining activities are carried out bv helvumachinery. No plantation is carried out Uv tnl I

industry and neither water sprinkling is carriei out. iNo road has been provided by the unit. He informed I

that BBMB have a ceftifiCate to release 30.000 I

cusecs of water downstream from the dam witilout I

No Reply

,g

.a' .t,f+\rl

i

'1

A'1;--t'

I

In addition to this, 22 numbers of written Issues/suggestions were received during the public

hearing. Enclosed as Annexure- II.

Sh. Rakesh Sharma ADM, Kangra at Dharamshala further assured the people that the public

grievances will be solved on priority bases.

* k, the end, Sh. S.K DhimarU AEE, HPSPCB thanked all the participants for attending thE

Environmental Public Hearing.

%Additional District Magistrate

Kangra at Dharamshala,

District Kangra (H.P.)

any information. Before the monsoon the intimationis given to the local people and the local police

stations to be careful regarding the release of waterfrom the dam.He said that there are advantages of this crusher

because the checkdam constructed by them helps

their children to reach school on time because earlierthey had to wait near the river. He thanked the

crusher owners for this.He said that nobody has given the main reason for the

floods in the area. This is due to the water released

from the dam and also due to the contribution fromthe tributaries of the Beas River downstream of the

dam. If the crusher owners doing mining from the

river bed, it is good for the local people as due to thisthe bed level goes down and help channelizing the

river and reduce the risk of the flood and there willbe no damage to the Mand area. The crusher is

required as they require the material to fulfill their

basic construction needs. The material when required

by the poor people is provided free of cost by the

crusher owners. The river is required to be

channelized in proper manner.

Sh. MohammadRafiq, UpPradhaq GramPanchayat Ray.

He requested to get the river course channelized.

Also he requested that a siren should be provided in

the viltages which should be used before the release

of water from the dam by BBMB.

Sh. SurjeetRanqChairman,Himachal KisanSabha.

'\- :- *-,

f

.t

finn€><_Ltnerysf{ .nqqgro M, ilEiftd fuilr &IErn+wftqrEftilsfrd ftrdr .q.LlNr{r;ro 2 2s94, zs9s/26^a Mwd

L3-00-74 tq{TfTwr

iRqrqa etyr uw s-{qrr ffipr *d avr R-{im u.os.2o13o) qrd, 11:00 sd.nq q ero frqffi, il{$_dEiEgY' fu-dT 6irr., (Ru'1 { ryd eqT €H;nsn, rnq q sro frqrft, il.iftd s-+,,r, fucTr om.sr (Rs) FRr +or nqrff, ils#d FtEgv, fudT fu-dr olrr.sT (trq.) q{,-* ro 2se3. 2se4,2sss/2€-d u-c'd13-w74 *slqq' * i-d' eqff q q-ten d riqE d q-ftnq w qqr-{rr q{ ET{r$ mvrq d wrer ErG gy#d fud d q-rri"r d s*q}fud o1 G t qe qqfur"T qq

ETqr$ q,"f, srs-R trM urft orfur;++ r{o-gsooilo tssg ftqifi u,st,oo6d oiil'id furffrer sfuq d erglri{ *,frftfi fuar qrsr*.*Tfi oirrsr,(Rr) o13*uerilr it slrqifud E1G I Fs qq uilqr$ t sqRerd Eqffi ol qm Hd.=r6-.r qq BqEfeit r rs s{ EilqT$ d +{Tq sqqo-sd 3rM F"Tfr6)*Tfi, s+q ffi 6irr., furo u+q* 6".,Eir=,, q**d ,*n-{ M, erq fuili} d sffi * _o* * ;.ridi d ffi Bq*erd$ t udqQrq Eqqd e-+qT RTaq qqyur fuq=jrr etd d sFdfrD * gpfta gqrr sffqlq, no qqtfiq srBzidTERI "=I

s{-{rs o1Y* xF d *+qr d uqiqq fr eqfuid q-q-s{6 o't a-aq-6 o-wrqr rrril r rf,rq,.rdorFdfrfi fuar q-sTDoffi or,t-gr i sqRero u_{sT6 6) ridltsd ord gg o-er fu $s qq_{ d_d d r{q{TrioHsgure, fuq*gq Rrorqoddi **rqTssq't t raerqrd€rqmyryd qftfrtsr*rq+q fr d qrsq eilv AsBo qqtf,{q yrrrq furt** A ** d w W o) emrrd o_{qrqr rR,, I \qsd sqqr< $unT Td*q"ot ergqfr d wry s{-{d ol qb-qr enEi of G r E-s s{ gTdr{ qn** offi of fffuf'*qfi $ ftt.rS r s$ w gror-g d +rH udiq q\ K* gq Bq q{ of rr$MFT) at offi oT h-wuT frq nox t B,_

q-dTftqT, rtTo q gro

t, fudT qri.rsr

(frq),

t, e{tr o_$ qR qT-fi d onq qe € t r

we qrfr olsT umr t aq er"rT RrqrgR6-d d uini t r gs r*+ merq fi qesrqil t fu TR shrnn elize (uwr

7----------- -EA3I

-tE

.,J

t+qrqt7feqT &T) E\ rfr t I Erd. olydrq oq dt ra t r q-Er& rft et-6 en go1

t, qe mqn TS dH ,) r tq qrd \rfiqqqrfr d_s +d t, fus,S gffiH dror t r

ffi qrEr m-qm d.i-i urfl fr qrft

channelize dr.n t

2. *fr vta R-e.no q

sto sqrq{irttrdw.d-6$, fudroi.T-.sr (8.u.1

s€Ii o.ar ftF ;nem Erri t Effijr-g,{rfl $Tr t. qsd mvm (t-d, Nrfr qqen) qrfr gr srerEr * an-n q.sdr Qr,

cn-E fu-{rfi oq t slk mqn 6r ErrT rfi oqt t mqr d.ri d ,it qrft ga d erfl tqrf,I QII 3rq qE ga d {rs (fi+) t qror

t, ofttSsqlddfwnq.frt I q-qf{{q

dr o.I$ gffirr rS t I Td olst g-ftq.re t. Eqr qtri t dri wd rS qsf,r

$ I men or.ri or dri 1qsn rfr qrq-<r

frq,rcflt r

3. S dftq friE

s{+-ffi +#<rq

Tr"frtf{,

oirrgt

fudr

(Rs.)

s€ri o-or ftF qrd Hrqrq srcrdE dTqrqsdr Qrr, ce dr.r cilrql qIFr cqrfl qqrq frffi s), Eqrfr qffi qr$ re .rrft pft

r

qEI d,Ti ET tH Ertrfr

srrq-g,Fr w sfuo ErSi t ft-a rS t r

snft\ sq arri t ft qe mvm qcrdr

vB1 gq-S r+rQr fr Eqrft qfiq.fi"-q {rqrffyd eft d qT-6 GTri rt ve urfr eft, myn

drri t qrff ERqT d qa w B en{ gn-6-r

Tiq e-rdTi o'r oil{ ffii o1 e-gn srrrEr

$il t t sq qrri t fu;nen qoa-or qB t

4. rll o-rf$q, ftb'sn

wqr fuar sqlEzler,

fu-dro.iTq (Rq)

sdri oEr ftb aq emft q+{ d-fi-oTrErE o-q G t sil{ sq qqi q frF*fld-oq 16 € t r Eqlfr errqQ qrQmr t fu,q6 s.;rq fuw trr6 qRqT d os G t TSo.t, fr"{fr ei}r w.re +..t d F+m g6mrq

frdr,n r

6-6r fu ER-61 u.MEr al ryn€rq lFsR qrA A irri w sTrq €rrEft dlqgn sr{fl $n t r qri *ffi qrd +Sd

gffiq o-rA e). rrq s+dr ?ft TEi t srqrq

(Material) fd qrar t rdr rft Tqffidr.r t, s{dr gd"IT qffiI o:n (to,

ffiA) ofi TS frmdT t r gu drii dl

\cw t rne er-c (Flood) 3Trhfr dr

e<vdl dr,ft sfu Bqdl ot{ TS tr6

qrhn t fS zrar t qo eB'qr qar ttridtdrwrcqrfrt t

gTHEIFT rtrIT q=Ir{rd

rr6r<fr, irdrdstry, fu-dl

6trr-.sr (Rq.)

o-6r f6 s*rn 6l trq1

frTS €rq ;nqn d qfrrqit dr sr{rEl

qffi A ftd Tft tl{sfr tffit dr

rrr{rEl t t enq 'rrff dl dl Wor ot{

v.rrEr =rS t, qq * qrft o.r s-qrE dr

orfi qr*r t srror t, ce q{e.n 6. dl{

dt aonq o1 awn qr\*ff t aq rrml d'fudrq. TS t t rrml grft qrR{' q1€NI

ftTd w =rS fu Vo {fl+ d eTHrE

o-{i d ftN Wt wd dt qrqrE otfurqNl

frrsn qtTI fti-dTr

({.TIE?IeI, ildffd.Fi-65q, ftil-dt

oiWI

Gq.)

5.

ElTrq r+,oIezIeT, G.q., 3Tfud

qrrdrq s€Errq

furhft, orqfdq

(All India AntiComrptionBureau)

HqI6 lcrdt grTIrzIH oT erf,

Xfr ore srrld tr f, Eft sTvito qrqf, sfiGTkoFft q-irg Rera trdqndr fudrorl-.sr t ggqr qrfirr tft rl-e sqf qd*1 s-qB fftikn or fr urft t dr wrqqfrh&o1qrso.ftt ?

s€ri 0-6r fu qq drenq$dr 16rt

s€H oET fu, 1o-1s EMi d rtqrrR

ftqr rrqr t, qrfr qqftrfr ol sqfir ff dr

ttT t, 1o-1s EMi o\ gil{ fr.nrqil dFn r

Afuq 1o-1s fri d trq.ni ti oilT

1oo-1so fri o) sr{rEr ti d ftrS

4oooo ffi dt dqrq qfr fr'qr \iT

ffiDdI I

qftTrdr. ftrar 6irrgT i qarqr

ft wr1 qsel t eqt ord o)futfud fuqr rrqr t r qr{qcr ftd.ko dri wqoniTS fuqt qT wrrTr r qei qei

sn o-rd qa Gr t T6i

frqqryqr ffi of trW tre?r it o.rd o-{i o1

irrqrBD rnrTw d T+t t silrridffrr"r rd ftr fur B \qfurS 6rd + trr$ Eqrqartvr vq r{qq Mq drd

olen'+qqfrqrrrqrt, ffiertko t r

s"t"T o{fuorft tnirM furd

trftnmr, fuar o-irrsr i corqr

fuoffiotqr=oltftrQrd ridf6-$rr vg o-r p-qr tfrftft tnrci d ftrS fs fqf+qr.rqr t oilr errffit crnflFd

tr \

6-6I T6, srrRsl2011

sfi, Btrd rzz trer uft-{ s-r gRrrq g3Tr

eil, ffiqTi 627266.00 S0 S3IIirqlrrqr, fus,t t fu s2 sl{rkd Eil'it dr

114ooo.oo so Rq .rg r gst dr$rd

{drur qt s62 t€{ etr $fiBd 93il erT I

qrg fir ii aoos qrft fr1 #t aen ++

w6-o-rft fi M EP+;I +i d ftr$6qr{ q-i t r €rq men d 6Rq Tfr d

frrflt ce qri t g{ Tr Tgd qtlrq w {61

t t s€ri o-sr fu, qw e\a frrsrq qt{r

q6 rftffil qrna tmft t oen sgqn tGrJtrEI o-{e t fu {fl +rs ka o\ qq{trd dIfrd fuqr qrq eitfu gs etd +qqffiq w q#it Er*r s+{ o--G IsrnqryWrt t

6ir.sr, (G.q)

6nrsj furd trf{nmr , i qflrqr

fu fto fto gqo fto d qrft

ffi*drwsnft€lt,qqqR sq1 drr rS etor n-q fiqrft dr qrwr fta qr+r t, ellq

Erq sII qrft t t

o-a ItF, q{r gpq 5qr TE

tq t dI qrft ut.sr rrrar t ffi dr'ii ot

$sH drdr t r qrd fr Ersi erq ong 'gft

s{T srrq q-d o,t{ mqn Tfr er I qq

mqtr TS e) ffi rft tn dror elr, d}q

q"16 t offiFq Td e q-.erq d qrd e) t

mqn t q.rrrfl dr wr t cr =rS qE 31ErrI

erd t, w orri slqi tTiq d so-eo drtit

d gw t to q mft sqffir otqr{ t t

eftqi or vffiTq t, t sarg tt qrror terrrq Eff qtrqr dt channelize (vrwt

f{srn/f{Yn tqT) 6-t ftlqr qd dl

$sr€IT sa dr sfi-ft t t fto ffo gqo fto

futrqT .Irft dr.sdl t frffi o\ qor q-S

6}dr t, ett{ ?rE qrft o-en d oq-q r\ frqEIi qrff $ I otx cq o-{i d q-ud

ERqr dl channelize (vrwt

ftsrn/funtri)frroturi t

qenq qtq qqrqo, tffidroirgI,(8.q.)

fiEr fr. tooo e,nEfiqi i'€ R+s z

orTqfi ql-da t fu 6-sR an qrfu ege drr

gt

otwr, (Es) T€l qrrd fiF ovrq ai t oqn m16Sffi E\ rS t, .r6t ssB o.r fri qrft

t ffi o{ dr.r Eq gde-{Bit sT prn-n

eqqrttI11.

sfrfrD, qqtw r

rifr'fr

s€rq o-61 IrF, qoe *; \|-6 Et-6 Irrrrfud

et t I s2 qo fu d qT-fr N ol errar

11ooo qq.fi-o. t t qR gs$ wrqr qrff

dr.s qrt rT dt enqr qrft 01 frffi Girr

tvur*.n,12. sll {rfr 6r€{, rrETH

rrq qqrqa qrEg{,

ils$-d m.ilEgt,

fu-dro.irrgr (B.s)

sdq o-Er lrF,5qpqqqr+d + qrffi+ Eti t ro fto aqr qFft qrr r6ltr t r sriqpqf, dt ff s-6r, efu-{ qqmd rft qEq-& 6r wot r fri d pr urS fu qEi

d 5gun ovrq i fuqr t Eir.ri of "1fttqe G , eqr dt oqm i fuu1$z orrrr rtEt-fl

Tftdtwf *ntdreilqvtffi lwqR sS arftS q q drar t ERqr +ffii qr sr1 drdr t dr qrft qRqr +fi-q t fr qrlrr r ffo fro 1'ro fio dr o.IiTfr trs-dT t q-rd fi T6i qre on{ B treT6i ot$ oqn qlfr *or en I onuT sf,dlo.sruRs$tdt r

13. srga q-sdr

qrEs{,

s-+Es,

o.Frvr (R.s.)

ilgrftd

fu-dT

s€Ii o-6r FF, ovn er.ri tffiEE.qre cng t Gllt rnfr grypq $il t I o-rgerd-A $fi wrrwn S frq mffi rS t r

o-{R q< E}i fr ot$ Guarantee(frrffi) T$ fu er-E T$ uffi1qdta1 qnr t qe fr qrft dr.er qror t qe

ovrs d uw rft gs ffiDilr t r fti o1

aqq' fi gg rrirdr t r t-*r qm{r } foo-vrc erd-d fr eE oi ftr*qri rfr |

T6-A fi "t) eTe Gn$ t ss-rt o-{ TffiqSnt I

14. &li ertrt$ff, anT{qi, s€Iq o-61 ]-rF,

il6€Id st-69r,

fuarolrrsr (8.s.)

(1) fcril{r t+qlrr 6rd d wr t srrdGtf,,EsfrqFeno-dfrGTrifi |

e) 'ilr gf-id qk dr rS t TEr q5telri t fr E) € E, rr$ o.vru c-S t r

(e) zotr fr rft d er€ en{ T{ Trrr zorz iifrffiqtrrfi-{qrffqefrt r

(+) frd ri dr'ri S w td qft qdNi dwq eilrt t, d qqT Brrd ql1 ii ot{Tpqenort t

13. qT FSIq STYTT,

fumroiqgr (8.q.)I s€ri oer fr , oqm d q€T='H--m-

l* € t qe ve irsfttun tr fri iI .iqn rt eno-r qftt rrftfr, ofh qrft otfuorm d ftr$ d {rd ffid a} s{rtfrcd glET or Eir.ri i q< q-t ftqr t r

Girr sr qrft orrTr t d tri t qrlrn ot*gffiq dr dr.n A I Etr{ ** rgo w{tt Ssfr sti 1oiniT € t.r 6rht$rqrfuo Efld Eqd Frtr ffi ,ri t r

M q{ $ qq qrfi tri t effqr, dr

frsmr/f{yn tfl) fr;+r slk rqrq doqq rori I $d: f; qrEmr { fu ovn o\or5qhtuffiqrRt I

I

15. q<,tnrTd sEnq, fudronr-sr (Es.)

B€ti 6-6r fr, dt Eir.r o-snffiq.o-d E't t qe zo-go fu'o fto W t onif; I trvn rir ?rn t frdEg e*, an t,E{ffir dr-i fqwn rS t r tfi q,frq wrel

fr ilq-ft t, fuilfl wrfl sat dr.n, srqrfr qT-ft ftn qr$.n r dr,r qifr zo-go fuoffo $ t orrrr o-yn or f+trq or G t,+sr fu qEA ff oEr rrfl t fu gq om izrd qr q) q.re qrfr d ft-mrff d frrn{S.rg ,ff Erd gEi-i GTqft u#i cqr d*q qq fr ql-ft error t dr ffo fto wo fto

_-E;f/Lt

lt{/,*!

l: ,*?;g

Eif,' 'lil

7

tfuo-grqsqs-{kqrqr$ r

fudro.rwr (Ru.)E;-6I ltF, oH,ft gs 6**,o-

t-dr fu qq hrfl *ftqr il6 fuqr wqrqrtr$ I q6 dFr Fs eb it.rdi g-sg ovtd t r Eq qrEA S fu rs $-d t r fi oHuqmdrSqqSqqldr

rdr€{ 5Fr Tq,fudTsnt-€T (R.r.) gsrqi w rllq fr,qr !ilrt I u€ri ftrrqr fu

qmd q o-i qEEWf qrn6 t r ff$ fuqfuqrfudfuvr-qqrftffidtrcdqT{r ;rfr El qrff ffi Td glr{r rrufrfi'l u- qT qrdl elt, Tt {elrer6 gqrqe[rflt S qrE vsrr e?re fuqr rrrrr deil3rq a-d qrfr GTQr+r q|E TS snft t *F.rqTrA $ il{rt qrd e}, dfu-{ Hrd_qrd(60-60) Ee lsa .rEt ov frn qri tYs-S et-6 dt on$rft ft $sH rft dr.n r

Tsrf,r, fudr oiqsr(Er1

s-6r lfr, eqnr qfr Usrq FE, qdt avru sq ffi wt qm Tfi o.rchannelize (vrwr frer*Zfuir A_qr)

frqr qr$, dTfu fuft rft ef, o) rsorlwrqqdr I

sqRr, sqErFr tr6wfrfr

o-6I kb', drl?il soo_+oo

+q.rrt frddr t r drq sq E'yni fr sdi€Pfqr) t eily qE 6-yR qq € EFfi Snit t wr qiq t frn qRqr t, Eirr eTd;qrff ffi t, re ffi o) qfi {drd drqT-.fi d) sTr}rn E cnt1 I qFA rft qei erd3Ir$ t qtr q-qm qfi Qi t. o-yn or qEisprEr S B I soo rnHf or qo-aq t fuzooo dr.iio) trq.rT{ ft-dr t tEq

"lE_d t

fu, 6yrq q+fl qrtr$ eil-.r qRqT dIchannelize (vrrcr FsjiT/frqT t_{D

+iil

qqf-drrr rrfrfr, qus

etr, fudr-n*(Eu.;

o6r ttF, qq1 H'YTT

Location (wrnrrEl t qe fqa.r-drd tedifu. *r 16 qqff fr rr{ me ffi fifr+mT i 6rhdt oo t qi Tqfiqn ga ddri qv ot$ onqfr Tfi q-or{ r X"d utnqrrq {qrqo i qsrqn q;q efiqrqfr rqrurqe (NOC) ft rfi fus61 gRr1q onnqrs d qlft.nqt d eFrw zorr ii Urrmrrw I Vs {nd of rxri16 fteft Td tqR-4q o1 GN z * ro fio aerq of ti ,rqE-qR FNr do*ft0ft0 fr q+r o-r ss_orT6 drd ftqr qqT, fffi qrs q-ft wa-rq o) Td rrg. fus-ol mrq Esd 6nqe-qfq S{ qE $ q-drfi t I qrd T6 gdF mtq'err dQr q-fr fi .-re ffi n-wer I vw sqq drq ffitrdt fr glrqrqr$

o-$t a) I Terrace place of qrd o-S qrrS * fu Terrace rS arrur q-fi t I Gnqermff o) qrq otT{ wq$il:qT qr rer tq$fu ftqFfr o1 vnor d do$ofto ts-e fto mo rq}fl qT qEr t ffi Eft qo-$.em nrffirn qrt d fi rorRrd fuqr.rqr t I v*FR FRr qq drft w frqrqri erd WfqT rfi e-ga o-q t r rr&dt {sTfrqrrur rcoyo t r qrHt t n-rqrd qSt q-{fu elqi mqrn qr t fuqr t fu arrn$ w il{qta dr.n t q A ssfr qr qrftor fu-sorq fuqT qm B I IndustryF-stq) frq {rf, qa-ft t wqfu qe qrsd tfu Industrf gupl M frq d Ttrftt r qrff qefl=rff mT q-*q fu-fi qmr t r

gqtniquT rR s-Si qErH Terqq tw$+rq qrfl r geiltqrr G qt-fi

-v'g

{

1-.*i; .;

$s, ;I d 6RTfl B I E-YR qflEf6l gNI

fl.g-q' rF.r ftqtur q'q ril-{ t t qrcrqrd dftrn ilerfr qr*t or rdFr dl q6r B t fto

fto wo fto i qR qiq r{rqr d dFit dr

{qri d ffi q-+r+r eltr t$ d ser<q dftrt r;nqr t fto ffo so fio d sTfrrqre

+ qrt d ff qor+ qrftTI {fu telz t ffofro wo fto i trq ftrqr w fu soooo

q{Rr6 vtfi frtfr rfi wErq dr.sr ut sFdI

|lcrwra + $ fro fto wo fto sm

venftq q;rdl our gftrs Atfudt dlqTqtrrftr{qntfrqrfft t

oA 1rF, o.qn dtTq g sT{rEI

@ifu gdH d eiEI E:{rfi t gtrfi 6qrt

qd sqq t ffi.a q-gq qrd t t wdERqr qt sff sr {ffiTR o-sr tr.strt s]I I

t vgo oTFTr€t i I

m-6r ]itr, qr6 3Trq sT 5Uq tE,rtul

Eiq t qrft dr.sr rnr'+r t, oil{ dl qrfr EitI

d ftn qrsqfrt ffi qrff or;qqHiii error $ I otx qR rft + ftii frqsq6{ rt t dr q* utj dr ot{ Tn{rqTS dr.n r efr ffiq o'rd + ftd ovrq

dri qTF6q q'difu ffiq srqft ol wo-ra

+fr t I @-qR qrA Eqrt o-{i d srgsT{

3Tfr .rftq qRqn (BPL family) m1

Mq q1rft gw t t tfr tt=rfr dr

orrn 6q t channelize firc<t

ksTqT/fuTr t{r) frt+t uri dl qo-s S,tl=IqT{Ffl I

qqFT, t, fuf,r

oiwr G.q)

channelize (rrrtr fusrfl/f€n a-{r)

fuqr qrq oqn fro fro so fto grr gtr

ffi qq dqrrrT rrrq frrrfi-r g{iqrd qisl

orr{fl, Eqlqd

ftrgH {{t{f

-a

sft vrd{I Yrqf (3TFdfrffi ltrdr rc[FsTfr) 6i.rgl furo ua*r, fuor orqsr, (8.q.) i enrqrfiqr{qr fr dHi of Ei} sqsrs t F+ qprfu*dr d ernm w E?rfl-qr qran, I

, .ifr q S Evhd E.,{ fiq*, qo qqf{wr s{frdiilr, vrw rqw ftrifl q1g, 6Rr rqf*ur w grorgit wp* srft oilrii ot qq Eil{d q qFr *i oremilr soz frur r

Ofrrn-4,--,oTFdftffifuarsugrM

o,iwTfurdq{qnar.

fuorotqg6.o.

qfud6-{i+6qfuqrffi r

$sd GTPdfrffi sil Srirr€ d +nr zz frks gwrq, fuulr qri Rpil.{rit rft qFH fi, Orm Td w {frerftn t r

l--n

tfr nnu >Lure -E

Haryana.

Videographyofthepublichearingwasalsou":::111.*llgytheproceedingsoftheenvironmentalpublic hearing were recorded and the same are reproduced here'

t

statement of rssues raised in Environmentar public Hearing on dated: l4tostzol3 on the proposal

, submitted by IWs Krishna Stone Crusher' Village g posiOtfice Riyali' Tehsil Fatehpur' Distt'

- Kangra, II.P. for collection of stone, sand & nalri situated in Khasra No' 2593' 2594' 259512'

_ measuring 13-00-74 Hect, at vilage "r;*;; Riyati, Tehsil Fatehpur' Distt' Kangra' H'P'

. Environmental public Hearing on the proposal submitted.by lws Krishna Stone crusher' village & Post

' off"" Riyali, Tehsil Fatehpur, Dirtt. K;;; H.P for collection of Stone' Sand & Bajri (minor mineral)

situated in Khasra no.25g3,2594,25g5ri],n"**irg 13-00-74 Hect' at village and Mauza Riyari, Tehsil

i Fatehpur, Distt. Kangr4 H'P' was organized on 14'05'2013 at 11'00 AM by H'P' State Pollution Control

Board, Regional offrce Jassur as per notification No-So-1533 dated 14.09.2006. This public hearing

wasorganizedbytheH.P.StatePollutionControlBoardunderthechairmanshipofADMKangraatDharamshalaaccordingtoprescribeop..",.ofpublicl..**Theattendance-sheetofparticipanspresent in the public hJaring i, .ntto"i 1e*t*u"-t)' In this p"utit hearing SDM Jawali' Distt' Mining

officer, panchayat pardhan of fuyari ranchayat & Residents of n.urby panchayats were present' First of

all Er. S.K.Dhimaru Regional offrcer, ,pspcg, Jassur *.t.*.J the chairman' ofFtcers and officials of

various Depaflments and pubric, thereafter started the process of pubric Hearing' ADM Kangra at

Dharamshala requested the people present in the Environmental pubric Hearing to express their views'

comments, sr,rggestions and objections regarding this proposed Mining Lease without any fear and

pressure from any corner. Then the brlroJr"ripion regarding this proposed Mining Area was given by

the representatiue or the stone crusher and their .o*uirin vryr iorrrre Laboratories, panchkul4

$J

C*AS"gg.stions raisedName & Address

anY times his

land got affected d* t;';;;;::l'-f:"-"1*l1tffi,liiil;

fff'f;"J1ff"1,i1[i;";;;shers will increase the river stream will

set channelized automaticallY' = ,r , ;-;;

:H:r3:;,ffi[,: fi:, ;; g.,1,t q".rized thereby minimizing

the flood risks. He ,.id;#B;MB authorities discharge the water

suddenly without *V'i"iit"tion' causing major losses *q fl:ol.i"

the region. They also'il;;;il'*ajor l'osses due to floods in past

years and there were'G;:;f;t*:::g::?[Tliff;# 11fi

Sh. Karan Singh Pathani4

V.P.O RuY, Tehsil

Fatehpur, Distt. Kangra

of crusher'

Earlier they have to' !i" ;;;i;l ": ":1t:-i:^,,["t*",.i1]::#Ji:'lffi 'lllllii i'"";; in*. t"1.the construction materiar

locally at cheaper tu"t'^ettt it't i"ituffution of crusher' the water

stream which used to -i;Qft

ih' .b'f 1s- :l: ::: ^1,::T?-T*:

stream wllruu Lrreu Lv

;,1";;f ;.her is having no adverse impactsthe bridge. The install

on the environment and it is only havilg the b-en'?4ts-' ------- ---

Sh" Rumait Singh, V'P'oBadukhar, Tehsil FatehPur,

Distt. Kangra

crushers' theHe.--------e suid that b"fote the installafion 9

construction materi al ;;p';;;J a": ?l,l?1,.1'1-f:-:"i'*:1:ffi#"HLT'::fi'#* il;"; .-p"iuu onry and the rocar

vehicles remained t'i'il;' \i;'ft"t the installation of crushers at

these locations they get the corstruction material easily and also at

comparatively ctreaper tui"t' 'o they

- want the crushers to be

operational. He also JOttt"''t"ir lani is also at village Rajgir and

manv times it has ;;;-fl";, away into the flood. After the

installation of crusheJilie *u*' flows into the river stream due to its

channelization and O" io this the villagers got benefit' So they want

.ieev Singh, Vill'Raieir. Tehsil' FatehPur,

Di;[. Kangra. (Govt'

Contractor)

si

(

location, they will face major losses'

living in their houses

peacefully. He requested that in future also unit should carry out^^ +L^., o-o 'l^inc nmentlv If fhe

mining in the same manner as they are doing presently' If the

;;t%"; are carried out in different manner or at any other

Sh. Kausim, Distt Vice

President, Kisan Sabha,

Distict Kangra.

benefits. ln the past tractor owners used to damage the areas nearby

duetomining,butnowtheygetthematerialfromthiscrusherat

"t"up", rates]'All the nearby people/contractors would not get the

.orti*.tio, material at suitr- ctreaper rates anywhere else' Few

;ild;;rld be having their objections, but when the flood arises,

its natural and then riobody *itt bt able to stop that' even the

lor.*."nt. What's going on is better and people are having

fited or not' it may be

known to crusher owners itself, bui common people get lot .offfi Dhimaru upPradhan, Gram PanchaYat

BahadPur

area the other area be

i is onlY for giving

benefits to the crusher owners and contractors' Common people do

""ifr*. any benefits. Due to the floods the stream of the river and

water in it gets changed as per the availability of the slope 9f.1he

area. He sai-cl that *,Jy *. not against the developmental activities

but it should not be in such a munt et that for the betterment of one

Str- SatPal Singh, Distt.

Vice President, Kisaan

Sabha, Tehsil. FatehPur,

Distt. Kangra.

the 40,000lives.

Vice President' and

asked sh. Ashok sharma Distt. Mining offtcer, Kangr.a. at

orrarmshala that" when leases are suspended, then whether mining

activities can be carried out or not?

He said that mining activities are still carried out. He also said that

1-0- i5 people were-given employment and heavy machinery is used

by the "*it"t o*nJrr. He sresied that for the employment of l0-

13 people and for benefits of 100-150 people, it is not correct to

Subash Chander, President,

All India Anti ComrPtionBureau, H.P.

the mi-nine activities carried out by the machineries'

ood came then the

destruction was of about 177 Hectares of land and the compensation

!ir"" *ut Fts.06,27,266.00, in which 52 affected people were given

R..1,14000.00.-The.affectedareaofTehsillndorawas962Hectares. The Mand region is having 3065 motors and 4'{

g"**.*, rigs for the Inigation facilities, which are adversely

Iffected becauie ofthe flow of"dg"r ofthe river stream due to the

,tor,. ,*t "..

He informed that ttt" x.itu- Sabha has passed their

resolution and requests the government to declare Mand area as no

.iring zone as the environment of this area.is being effected due to

Suresh Pathania, President

Kisaan Sabha MandReglon, Distt. Kangra, H.P

er discharged bY the

BBMBfromPongDamwhichaffectsthepeoplealot..Inthepastalso floods came and at that time there were no crushers in the

,*on and the mining was carried out at that time also. People from

ir?i"U took the miieral from this area' Whether the crusher is

L"rlitting or not it is a different issue, but they have provided.the

constructtn material free of cost to 50-60 people. FIe also advised

that if this river stream is channelized the problems get solved' The

p.opr"thinkthatthewaterenterstheirland/housesduetothe

".urh.rr, but it is due to the water released in the river from the dam'

Instead of'closing the crushers the river stream is required to be

Sh. SukhdeeP Singh,

Pradharu Gram PanchaYat

Ruy, Tehsil FatehPur,

Distt. Kangra.

10.

11

t2.

Puran Chand Sharma,

Mand Region@people only 2 persons agreed upon the

installations of crusher and 998 left out were always against the

proposal. The crusher installation leads to the accidents, they dig out

ih"-d..p pits which lead to the occurrence of accidents of many

people.

RepresentativeParyavaran Samiti

EJ,of

Hanssh. @on is a flood affected area. The 52 no. gates

downstream ofthe pong dam are having capacity of 11,000 cusecs.

If the water increases there, where should the excess water should be

diverted?

Sh. Romi Thakur, PradharL

Gram Panchayat BhadPur,

Tehsil. FatehPur, Distt.Kangra

oximate distance of 10 mtrs from

the houses oflocal people. They requested the Panchayat to do the

needful but Panchayat Codd not do anything in this regard. He said

that villagers may be asked that; whether the stone crushers have

caused uny loss.Jin their area? Whether the crushers are responsible

for land of tn" people which were flown away in the floods? Ifmining is carried out in wrong/unscientific manner, people can stop

thaq b-ut if the mining is carried out in proper way and the mining is

carried out on the edges then water will flow inside the channel ofriver stream. He furttier alleged that nobody stops the BBMB from

discharging irregular water flow. In the past also floods came and at

that time there were no crushers in this areU13

14.

15.

Atul Mehta BhadPur,

Tehsil FatehPur, DisttKangra

n of the crusher also there used to

be flood situation due to which heavy distraction was caused. The

crusher alone is not responsible for this problem. There is no

guarantee that there will be no floods after the closure of the crusher.

fuh.n"r". there is release of water in the river, the water can also

divert towards the crusher and even downstream. He said that he

agrees to the fact that the crusher alone is not responsible for the

floods. Earlier alsothere were many losses @Sh. Abhishek, Vill.Bhogrwan, Tehsil.Fatehpur, Distt. Kangra

He said that:1. From where will the construction material be generated for the

construction activities if the crushers are closed?

2. The accidents also took place in other regions, where there are no

crushers.3. In 2011 also the flood came and there were land losses due tp

water. whether there were any land losses inillllwhen there werE

no flood conditions?4. In Delhi, people are having their houses adjoining to railway

tracks, then doei any earthquake came at their houses due to the

movement of the trains?

Sh. Sanjeev Prashar ed in favor of crusher are political'

People came from Punjab and bought lands here and the paths meant

for itre water flow were obstructed by filling soil/muck. Now, when

the water come it goes into agricultural fields and definitely cause

losses. It is very important to have crushers and there is no adverse

impact of it. Many social activities were done by the crusher ownefs

in ihe local area. Last year also when water of the river came into

the fields, they hdve channelized the stream and protective measures

were taken by them. He stressed and said that the permission may be

sranted to the crusher.

-

g.{g

i.i

a-L

{6. Nanak Chand, Ex Pardhan He said that the people who are opposing the-rushers hM comehere from 20-30 kms away from this place. crushers are installedcorrectly and there are no losses due to the crushers. He said his landis adjoining to the crusher. As the mining will increase, the waterlevel will go down. As already informed, the old river course asdiverted time to time have been developed by the people and havecreated private land over there by filling in muck/soil, and whenwater/floods came, nobody asks BBMB regarding the release ofwater, bu! everybody says close the crushers

17. Sashi Chaudhary, Vill.Bela Thakra

she said that nobody looks after upto which@carried out. she alleged that the crusher owners dig deep pits in ttrearea. She further requested that they want.No Crusher, No mining,'in this region

18. Thakur Gian Chand He requested the committee to consider the vGws of Smr Sashichaudhary. He told that in India there are important places such asIndia Gate in the capital of the country New Delhi where the waterof the river Yamuna used to touch this place, but after adoptingmany protective measures (channelization), no water/flood comesthere and it was protected. Houses were constructed in past also, butwhen they will dig pits up to 60 feet the floods will defrnitely comeand losses will be there.

19. Kartar Singh, Badala He suggested to channelize the river stream to stop the losses of theMand region and further said that the crushers stroutd not be closed.

20. Sh. Rajinder SinghPathani4 Member, DamtalTruck Co-OperativeSociety.

He said that 300-400 vehicles have got employrnentJeople arejealous of the crushers and these are old crushers in this area and notnew. There is a dam in the upstream and river in the downstream,whenever the water is discharged by the BBMB authorities, it isnever informed to the local people in advance which lead to floodsituations. In past also when crushers were not there, the floodsituation was there due to this problem. 300 vehicles mean thataround 2000 people get employmint. He stressed that they want theglgshefs to be operated and the river stream should be channelized.

2t Sh. Prem Singh, President,Paryavaran Samiti, Mandregion

I He said that the location of Krishna stone crusher is not correct.

I When the necessary approvals were given, then no department had

I raised the objections regarding the bridge constructed with crores drupees. Ex- Pradhan issued NOC after indulging in comrption andthe loses of it were faced by the villages of nearby areas in August2011. The location of this area is in 2 to l0 mtr slope and the Beasriver is diverted towards this side due to the mining by the crusherownefs with the JCB. In the past this bridge was at one side and theriver stream was on the other side, people used to travel in boats.Regarding the terrace place it is submitted that it is not a terraceplace but it is Beas river. The JCB is used to dig 5-g Meters and thisis done under the shelter of the departments. This has also beenpublished in news papers many times. He alleged that the fineimposed against illegal mining is very less. The vehicles areoverloaded and the material is not covered during transportation.The industry is operated day & night. The mining.activities arecarried out by heavy machinery. No plantation is carried out by theindustry and neither water sprinkling is carried out. No road hasbeen provided by the unit. He informed that BBMB have acertificate to release 30,000 cusecs of water downstream from thedam without any information. Before the monsoon the intimation isgiven to the local people and the local police stations to be careful

lggqding the release of water from the dam.

He said that there are advantages of this crusher because the

checkdam constructed by them helps their children to reach school

on time because earlier they had to wait near the river. He thankedthe crusher owners for this.

Sh. Sunil Kumar

He said that nobody has given the main reason for the floods in the

area. This is due to the water released from the dam and also due tothe contribution from the tributaries of the Beas River downstream

of the dam. If the crusher owners doing mining from the river bed, itis good for the local people as due to this the bed level goes down

and help channelizing the river and reduce the risk ofthe flood and

there will be no damage to the Mand area. The crusher is required as

they require the material to fulfill their basic construction needs. The

material when required by the poor people is provided free of cost

by the crusher owners. The river is required to be channelized in

Sh. Mohammad Rafiq, UPPradhan, Gram Panchayat

Ray,

I{e requesteri to get the river course channelized. Also he requested

that a siren should be provided in the villages which should be used

before the release of water from the dam by BBMB.

Sh. Surjeet Rana,

Chairman" Himachal KisanSabha.

In addition to this, 22 numbers of written Issues/suggestions were received during the public

hearing. Enclosed as Annexure- II.

Sh. Rakesh Sharma, ADM, Kangra at Dharamshala further assured the people that the public

grievances will be solved on priority bases.

In the end Sh. S.K Dhiman, AEE, HPSPCB thanked all the participants for attending the

Environniental Public Hearing.

f\f^.-.f-,----Additional District Magistrate

Kangra at Dharamshal4

District Kangra (H.P.)

IE

SE''i

I

-----.+

t-linn€')tu,Le-J

Atffiuce.sheetforEnvironmentalPubticHearingondated:l4l01l20l3ontheproposalsu6ed.by IWs Krishna Stone Crushero Vitlage & Post office Riyali, Tehsil Fatehpur'

Ilistf. Kangra, H.P. for collection of stone, sand & Bajri situated in Khasra No' 2593;

25*259512, rneasuring 13-00-74 Hect., at village and Mauza Riyari, Tehsil Fatehpurl

Dlstt Kangra, H.P.

SignatureSr.No.

Name & Designation Address

/rDt"Y l{ry t@^-,l

\-

I IH RNK€JI{- ,AnH 7(aa9v<JtrrtR4r$ b/ca?o-

1t/ Jl1 9uRefiH JntDnt-I At, JAi9frLl

-

,/99 h..) s-S 1.-\*-

J 3H: -fr .r-!"f-f,{f "#,h" ./V)irytk>t-2,, q{W}T)rBff ,(&flf*q- -MH,

7 ?t+ t. K- ?Ar"-'.tn' i.On - *t e.tlc { i b5 t*ryyy^ ^€*yi"'

- AIE , HftPt h Jh,t!.rn_t.

I)-l..xqf"-*'i fl -,1 il-€,..t:t__:71__-.t-

,.*i-,,-^-\f'ra-b'

_____z

I

{ i;t-.!.'.i,r{ 1r ii:'r^1-.1- L-'l'u ' r,}'r

tr1:.-rJ..1,-,r i":Y. I i:'111 ---

\,f:o F-te-l"- E.["-'ri t=,*al*-Sr.':,-,:: -. --'-

*="tq@o

<-"-*l+,bv *k;\ [,re-tt G.U'Y'i

,14 ' Ut"*)'t'^-

.{rI

l,

$+

Vi Qlr+l Krzt A E* frftf etl Jqr rc1-'

1aprrc0 {est,!-

YP.a' A?tI t --

-TV lo rdXkftP e"t Je*e^.

Llt.- A* lrwoul,l<t4k-4,yi

<at+#VlhaLlqg.t-r.

'frr-t, P"fu" q\/+/C B*il*€"'7o'

*o{^n S'^^5 u

\,/,,(( )P"- Dr'7rn".

Vr#l

Siqq tn 7 bettW

nldvqI

' K,r-,(.">

A" n"$nghr g{';.4r

ah€(* / c*-

-2.(?p)2

Jil#C ?6,11 4 *1r"l

?HFl='

{ :- -l --{:lif-i; -rL:*;n !" I

,r *-)i ."7

, / ' f)t*... llx v WWt)/e -r-, t^Lru U

( -a

ft

67--AffiI w*Ott"l

c\EGr1r Qcle\ r

?a -.ffiil ;; "^G t\)1t-t\.=#?)/

13

D-*.bh q-s,.r)r 0!](\* q,,€^d'U*q. * .)Lf

---K-a.ta,re-'

t/*aa-

vira*,lAu*tc

-

tt*=r 5ffi--ir--

L\, , ^,.,n lJ , r 1ar rr,{L,At-r*r.. lI.rlla{

t/-r1?o*r*-

.t _)G>

-. i i" I

'1,'{ , /\ tL L[ 1 da

V r'ln*d{tvll,r a e.i /*^-'*t* -.

'-.] '-] ),.\*-1r-*l]\'i'tt I filt"''- --

I

r[^4O4tl>1'.>

sIFt o/gz___

Sp*vs&

R"lA

l4crrfl^ st1 'r

l: + .11

"-i/''.,, lry ii.'^,,,)uL-",{-,\- L ,:L-9-

-"i^.i #, t-.* u'-

II

I

,>i+

{' TL"rl4."\. i

l'*aJ Yuv\LAU

'o o) ,/

t{{:+ {,*r Li