Court of Claims - AG's motion to dismiss breach of contract 10-25-2012
Contract & Claims
-
Upload
sanam20191 -
Category
Documents
-
view
220 -
download
0
Transcript of Contract & Claims
-
7/28/2019 Contract & Claims
1/41
ContractWhat is a contract?
-
7/28/2019 Contract & Claims
2/41
2
Important Points
Legally binding
Legally enforceable
Remedies
Simple contracts Deed
Conveyances of land
Bill of exchange Valid, void, voidable and unenforceable
contracts
-
7/28/2019 Contract & Claims
3/41
3
Law
Law can be divided into differentcategories
Some of those categories are private law v. public law
civil law v. criminal law
-
7/28/2019 Contract & Claims
4/41
4
Law
Private Law deals with therelationships between ordinary
people in everyday transactions That includes you and me, as well
as businesses and companies
Private Law includes the law ofcontract and the law of tort
-
7/28/2019 Contract & Claims
5/41
5
Law
In this category, civil law dealswith the relationships between
individual citizens Its purpose is to settle arguments
between individuals
It helps people to find remedies it doesnt really punish people
Civil Law includes all Private Law
so it includes the Law of Contract
-
7/28/2019 Contract & Claims
6/41
6
What is a contract? Examples
I promise to bring chocolates to the wholeclass. Is there a contract?
I promise to give you INR 100 if ride your
bike to Band Stand and back to College inless than 2 hours. Is there a contract?
I give you INR 20 for your Coca-Cola. Isthere a contract?
I promise to give you a new bicycle if youagree not to smoke for one year. Is therea contract?
-
7/28/2019 Contract & Claims
7/41
7
Definition of a contract
A legally binding agreement
that means there must be some kind of
agreement between two parties However, not all agreements are
contracts because not all agreementsare legally enforceable
legally enforceable means that acourt will say that an agreement is acontract
-
7/28/2019 Contract & Claims
8/41
8
Definition of a contract (cont.)
To decide if an agreement islegally enforceable as a contract, a
court will apply the rules andprinciples of the law of contract
Therefore, knowing a little about
these rules can help businesspeople to create valid contracts
-
7/28/2019 Contract & Claims
9/41
9
Simple Contracts
There is no general rule in Englishlaw that a contract must be in
writing In fact, in many situations people
do not realise that they are makinga contract
Some contract can be madeverbally or by actions
These are Parol (simple) contracts
-
7/28/2019 Contract & Claims
10/41
10
Simple Contracts (cont.)
Although there is no requirementfor a simple contract to be in
writing, sometimes the partiesmight record the contract inwriting
This can be useful later if there is
disagreement about the contract If the contract is important or
involves a lot of money it might be
wise to put it in writing
-
7/28/2019 Contract & Claims
11/41
11
Deeds
Deeds are kind of contract whichmust always be in writing
Conveyances of land: this is thelegal process of transferring theownership of land from one partyto another
This is different from theagreement to sell the land
The conveyance follows the
agreement to sell
-
7/28/2019 Contract & Claims
12/41
12
Contracts which must be in
Writing
Some contracts must be in writingbut they dont have to be by deed
Most of these requirements comefrom Statute
Some examples
bills of exchange contracts for the sale of land
-
7/28/2019 Contract & Claims
13/41
13
Bill of Exchange
Written order used primarily ininternational trade thatbinds one party to pay a fixed sum of
money to another party at apredetermined.
-
7/28/2019 Contract & Claims
14/41
14
Legal Effect
As mentioned earlier, contracts areagreements, but not all agreements arelegally enforceable contracts
In fact, the legal effect of agreementsfall into 4 categories
Valid contracts
Void contracts
Voidable contracts
Unenforceable contracts
-
7/28/2019 Contract & Claims
15/41
15
Valid Contracts
These are agreements which arecompletely binding and
enforceable Parties to valid contracts gain
rights and responsibilities
The courts will make sure that theparties follow these rights andresponsibilities if there is any
argument
-
7/28/2019 Contract & Claims
16/41
16
Essentials of a Valid Contract
Offer and acceptance
Intention to create legal relations
Requirement of written formalities in some
cases
Parties must have capacity to contract
Actual consent by the parties to the terms
of the contract Contract must not be against public policy
-
7/28/2019 Contract & Claims
17/41
17
Void Contracts
In fact, these are not contracts at all
They have no legal effect
There are a number of things which canmake a contract void
e.g. mistake, illegality
The important thing to remember isthat you cannot enforce a void contract
-
7/28/2019 Contract & Claims
18/41
18
Void Contracts - Example
Daniel gives his students somuch homework that they
decide to kill him
They pay a supari to hitmanINR 150000 to kill Daniel
-
7/28/2019 Contract & Claims
19/41
19
Void Contracts Example
(cont.)
However, the hitman simplyspends all the money in bars and
then goes home He does not kill Daniel
The students cannot claim their
money back because it is illegal tohire a hitman to kill someone.
-
7/28/2019 Contract & Claims
20/41
20
Voidable Contracts
This kind of contract is valid unlessone of the parties has it set aside
(i.e. declared void) This could happen where one party
is tricked into entering a contract
by the other party
-
7/28/2019 Contract & Claims
21/41
21
Voidable Contracts - Example
Daniel pays for a holiday in Panchganibecause the travel service shows himpictures of a lovely 5 star hotel.
However, when he arrives, Daniel findsthat the hotel is still being constructed.
There is a room where he can stay, but
not all the facilities are available andthe hotel certainly doesnt look like thepictures
-
7/28/2019 Contract & Claims
22/41
22
Voidable Contracts Example
(cont.)
Assuming that the travel company knewabout the hotel, then they have made amisrepresentation to Daniel which made
him enter into the contract for theholiday
Daniel could now choose to set asidethe contract
However, he could decide that thingsare not to bad and that he can still havea good holiday
-
7/28/2019 Contract & Claims
23/41
23
Voidable Contracts Example
(cont.)
So the contract is notautomatically void (like with the
hitman), it is voidable at Danielschoice
-
7/28/2019 Contract & Claims
24/41
24
Unenforceable Contracts
These are agreements which arelegal but which cannot be enforced
in court for some reason For example, a time limit for
enforcing the contract may have
expired
-
7/28/2019 Contract & Claims
25/41
25
Why have a Law of Contract?
As we saw from the examples,contracts arise in simple, everyday
situations Modern society operates by people
and companies exchanging goods
and services The Law of Contract helps to give
a structure to this
-
7/28/2019 Contract & Claims
26/41
26
Why have a Law of Contract?
The Law of Contract is part of PrivateLaw so it is concerned with relationshipsbetween parties
It helps us to decide what is a validcontract
The Law of Contract is also part of Civil
Law so it is also concerned withremedies
It helps us the other party to a contract
does not keep to the agreement
-
7/28/2019 Contract & Claims
27/41
27
Summary
a contract is a legally bindingagreement
simple contracts do not have tobe in writing
the legal effect of contracts fallinto 4 categories: Valid contracts
Void contracts
Voidable contracts
Unenforceable contracts
-
7/28/2019 Contract & Claims
28/41
28
Summary (cont.)
Business is an important part ofmodern society
The Law of Contract tells us whatis necessary to make a validcontract
It also gives us remedies whereanother person does not follow theterms of the contract
-
7/28/2019 Contract & Claims
29/41
29
MCQs
Which of the following relationshipsmust exist between the parties inorder that a contract is enforceable?
a. Social relationship.
b. Moral relationship.
c. Legal relationship
d. Casual relationship.
e. None of the above.
-
7/28/2019 Contract & Claims
30/41
30
MCQs
A accepts B telephonic invitationfor dinner. This is
a. A valid contract.
b. A invalid contract.
c. A voidable contract.
d. A void contract.e. Not a contract
-
7/28/2019 Contract & Claims
31/41
31
MCQs
A contract wholly performed by oneof the parties is called as:
a. Unilateral contract
b. Bilateral contract.
c. Executed contract.
d. Executory contract.e. Quasi- contract.
-
7/28/2019 Contract & Claims
32/41
32
MCQs
A,B and C enter into an agreementto divide among themselves all thegains acquired or to be acquired in
future by fraud. Is it a validagreement?
a. Yes, as all of them agreed to share
the gains.b. No, as the object is unlawful and
fraudulent
-
7/28/2019 Contract & Claims
33/41
33
MCQs
c. Yes, as they are using their skill togain something.
d. Yes, as all the essentials are present
in the contract.
e. None of the above.
-
7/28/2019 Contract & Claims
34/41
34
MCQs
Anish aged 17 years, borrowed moneyfrom a money lender representing himselfto be a 21 years old. Identify legalconsequence:
a. Anish can be sued for fraud.
b. Anish can not be sued for fraud
c. Anish is liable to repay the amount.
d. Guardian of Anish is liable to repay theamount.
e. Both a & c above.
-
7/28/2019 Contract & Claims
35/41
35
MCQs
General insurance is a .
a. Voidable Contract.
b. Wager.c. Contract of Guarantee.
d. Contract of Indemnity
e. None of the above.
-
7/28/2019 Contract & Claims
36/41
36
MCQs
Which of the following is an exampleof the contract of indemnity?
a. Contract of Life insurance.
b. Contract of General Insurance
c. Contract of service.
d. general Lien.e. None of the above.
-
7/28/2019 Contract & Claims
37/41
37
MCQs
Which of the following is a contract ofbailment?
a. Property deposited with the court inpursuance of its order.
b. Deposit of money in a bank.c. Agreement between a retailer and theGovernment for distribution og foodthrough a fair price shop.
d. Goods dispatched on consignment basise. Loan given by a bank to one of itscustomers.
-
7/28/2019 Contract & Claims
38/41
38
MCQs
Who among the following enjoys theright of subrogation in a contract ofindemnity?
a. Creditor.
b. Principal debtor.
c. Indemnifier
d. Indemnified.
e. Both a and b above.
-
7/28/2019 Contract & Claims
39/41
39
MCQs
The bailment of goods as security forpayment of a debt is:
a. Lien.
b. Mortgage.
c. Hypothecation.
d. Pledgee. Assignment.
-
7/28/2019 Contract & Claims
40/41
40
MCQs
A contract is said to have been dischargedby operation of law on ---
a. Performance of the contract by both theparties.
b. Mutual consent of both the parties.
c. Lapse of time in performance of thecontract.
d. Insolvency of either of the partiese. Breach of contract by either of theparties.
-
7/28/2019 Contract & Claims
41/41
41
MCQs
A agreed to sell his car to B, atgun point. This contract is void as itinvolves ---------
a. Undue influence.
b. Compulsion.
c. Coercion
d. Defamation.
e. None of the above.