Bioreactor Protocol | US EPA ARCHIVE DOCUMENTBioreactor Protocol | US EPA ARCHIVE DOCUMENT Author:...

45

Transcript of Bioreactor Protocol | US EPA ARCHIVE DOCUMENTBioreactor Protocol | US EPA ARCHIVE DOCUMENT Author:...

Page 1: Bioreactor Protocol | US EPA ARCHIVE DOCUMENTBioreactor Protocol | US EPA ARCHIVE DOCUMENT Author: US EPA, Region 5, Office of the Regional Administrator Subject: 2013 State Nutrient
Page 2: Bioreactor Protocol | US EPA ARCHIVE DOCUMENTBioreactor Protocol | US EPA ARCHIVE DOCUMENT Author: US EPA, Region 5, Office of the Regional Administrator Subject: 2013 State Nutrient

Protocol and Interactive Routine for the Design of Subsurface Bi i h MidBioreactors in the Midwest

Ri h d C kRichard CookeNatasha Bell

Page 3: Bioreactor Protocol | US EPA ARCHIVE DOCUMENTBioreactor Protocol | US EPA ARCHIVE DOCUMENT Author: US EPA, Region 5, Office of the Regional Administrator Subject: 2013 State Nutrient

DiversionStructure

Third Generation Bioreactors

Capacity5’ Soil Backfill

Length/width dependent on contributing area

p yControlStructure

Backfill

SectionSection of perforated tile

Woodchips

Trench bottom at thetile invert level

p

Page 4: Bioreactor Protocol | US EPA ARCHIVE DOCUMENTBioreactor Protocol | US EPA ARCHIVE DOCUMENT Author: US EPA, Region 5, Office of the Regional Administrator Subject: 2013 State Nutrient

5’ Soil backfill

Top View

5’ section of non-perforated tile

Capacity controlstructure

Diversionstructure

Page 5: Bioreactor Protocol | US EPA ARCHIVE DOCUMENTBioreactor Protocol | US EPA ARCHIVE DOCUMENT Author: US EPA, Region 5, Office of the Regional Administrator Subject: 2013 State Nutrient

Solid  pipePlastic Liner

Perforated pipePerforated pipe

Solid pipe

Page 6: Bioreactor Protocol | US EPA ARCHIVE DOCUMENTBioreactor Protocol | US EPA ARCHIVE DOCUMENT Author: US EPA, Region 5, Office of the Regional Administrator Subject: 2013 State Nutrient
Page 7: Bioreactor Protocol | US EPA ARCHIVE DOCUMENTBioreactor Protocol | US EPA ARCHIVE DOCUMENT Author: US EPA, Region 5, Office of the Regional Administrator Subject: 2013 State Nutrient
Page 8: Bioreactor Protocol | US EPA ARCHIVE DOCUMENTBioreactor Protocol | US EPA ARCHIVE DOCUMENT Author: US EPA, Region 5, Office of the Regional Administrator Subject: 2013 State Nutrient

• Bioreactor design is a complex balance of flow rate and residence time. 

Hi i h d d il d• Historic weather data, and soil and drainage system layout is used to 

evaluate bioreactor performance within specified levels of uncertainty. p y

• Operational (stop log) settings are incorporated into the design procedure. 

Page 9: Bioreactor Protocol | US EPA ARCHIVE DOCUMENTBioreactor Protocol | US EPA ARCHIVE DOCUMENT Author: US EPA, Region 5, Office of the Regional Administrator Subject: 2013 State Nutrient

Main Interface

Page 10: Bioreactor Protocol | US EPA ARCHIVE DOCUMENTBioreactor Protocol | US EPA ARCHIVE DOCUMENT Author: US EPA, Region 5, Office of the Regional Administrator Subject: 2013 State Nutrient

MS ControlsMS Controls

http://www.wq.illinois.edu/dg/

Sample Files

Page 11: Bioreactor Protocol | US EPA ARCHIVE DOCUMENTBioreactor Protocol | US EPA ARCHIVE DOCUMENT Author: US EPA, Region 5, Office of the Regional Administrator Subject: 2013 State Nutrient
Page 12: Bioreactor Protocol | US EPA ARCHIVE DOCUMENTBioreactor Protocol | US EPA ARCHIVE DOCUMENT Author: US EPA, Region 5, Office of the Regional Administrator Subject: 2013 State Nutrient
Page 13: Bioreactor Protocol | US EPA ARCHIVE DOCUMENTBioreactor Protocol | US EPA ARCHIVE DOCUMENT Author: US EPA, Region 5, Office of the Regional Administrator Subject: 2013 State Nutrient
Page 14: Bioreactor Protocol | US EPA ARCHIVE DOCUMENTBioreactor Protocol | US EPA ARCHIVE DOCUMENT Author: US EPA, Region 5, Office of the Regional Administrator Subject: 2013 State Nutrient

Popup Help ScreensPopup Help Screens

Page 15: Bioreactor Protocol | US EPA ARCHIVE DOCUMENTBioreactor Protocol | US EPA ARCHIVE DOCUMENT Author: US EPA, Region 5, Office of the Regional Administrator Subject: 2013 State Nutrient

Contributing AreagBased on size and slopeBased on size and slope of outlet pipep p

sdA 5.067.2

3110nDc

Ac 311.0

Page 16: Bioreactor Protocol | US EPA ARCHIVE DOCUMENTBioreactor Protocol | US EPA ARCHIVE DOCUMENT Author: US EPA, Region 5, Office of the Regional Administrator Subject: 2013 State Nutrient

Contributing AreagBased on tile lengths andBased on tile lengths and intersection anglesg

2SIESLA

)cos(8SSLAc

Page 17: Bioreactor Protocol | US EPA ARCHIVE DOCUMENTBioreactor Protocol | US EPA ARCHIVE DOCUMENT Author: US EPA, Region 5, Office of the Regional Administrator Subject: 2013 State Nutrient

Contributing Areag

Page 18: Bioreactor Protocol | US EPA ARCHIVE DOCUMENTBioreactor Protocol | US EPA ARCHIVE DOCUMENT Author: US EPA, Region 5, Office of the Regional Administrator Subject: 2013 State Nutrient

Woodchip PropertiesWoodchip Properties

Page 19: Bioreactor Protocol | US EPA ARCHIVE DOCUMENTBioreactor Protocol | US EPA ARCHIVE DOCUMENT Author: US EPA, Region 5, Office of the Regional Administrator Subject: 2013 State Nutrient

Sizing CriteriagFlow rateFlow rate

Residence time

PerformancePerformance

Page 20: Bioreactor Protocol | US EPA ARCHIVE DOCUMENTBioreactor Protocol | US EPA ARCHIVE DOCUMENT Author: US EPA, Region 5, Office of the Regional Administrator Subject: 2013 State Nutrient

Design Flow Rateg10‐year, 24 hour drain10 year, 24 hour drain outflow eventoutflow event • Grassed waterwaysGrassed waterways 

(NRCS‐412) 

• Constructed wetlands (NRCS‐656)

Page 21: Bioreactor Protocol | US EPA ARCHIVE DOCUMENTBioreactor Protocol | US EPA ARCHIVE DOCUMENT Author: US EPA, Region 5, Office of the Regional Administrator Subject: 2013 State Nutrient

Design Flow RategDRAINMODDRAINMOD Sim lationsSimulations

• Weather• Soils• Drainage System Layout• Drainage System Layout

Page 22: Bioreactor Protocol | US EPA ARCHIVE DOCUMENTBioreactor Protocol | US EPA ARCHIVE DOCUMENT Author: US EPA, Region 5, Office of the Regional Administrator Subject: 2013 State Nutrient

Midwest Database

Page 23: Bioreactor Protocol | US EPA ARCHIVE DOCUMENTBioreactor Protocol | US EPA ARCHIVE DOCUMENT Author: US EPA, Region 5, Office of the Regional Administrator Subject: 2013 State Nutrient

NRCS Midwest DWM States

Page 24: Bioreactor Protocol | US EPA ARCHIVE DOCUMENTBioreactor Protocol | US EPA ARCHIVE DOCUMENT Author: US EPA, Region 5, Office of the Regional Administrator Subject: 2013 State Nutrient
Page 25: Bioreactor Protocol | US EPA ARCHIVE DOCUMENTBioreactor Protocol | US EPA ARCHIVE DOCUMENT Author: US EPA, Region 5, Office of the Regional Administrator Subject: 2013 State Nutrient
Page 26: Bioreactor Protocol | US EPA ARCHIVE DOCUMENTBioreactor Protocol | US EPA ARCHIVE DOCUMENT Author: US EPA, Region 5, Office of the Regional Administrator Subject: 2013 State Nutrient
Page 27: Bioreactor Protocol | US EPA ARCHIVE DOCUMENTBioreactor Protocol | US EPA ARCHIVE DOCUMENT Author: US EPA, Region 5, Office of the Regional Administrator Subject: 2013 State Nutrient
Page 28: Bioreactor Protocol | US EPA ARCHIVE DOCUMENTBioreactor Protocol | US EPA ARCHIVE DOCUMENT Author: US EPA, Region 5, Office of the Regional Administrator Subject: 2013 State Nutrient
Page 29: Bioreactor Protocol | US EPA ARCHIVE DOCUMENTBioreactor Protocol | US EPA ARCHIVE DOCUMENT Author: US EPA, Region 5, Office of the Regional Administrator Subject: 2013 State Nutrient

EDF for Daily Flow

Page 30: Bioreactor Protocol | US EPA ARCHIVE DOCUMENTBioreactor Protocol | US EPA ARCHIVE DOCUMENT Author: US EPA, Region 5, Office of the Regional Administrator Subject: 2013 State Nutrient

Monthly Design Flowsg

Page 31: Bioreactor Protocol | US EPA ARCHIVE DOCUMENTBioreactor Protocol | US EPA ARCHIVE DOCUMENT Author: US EPA, Region 5, Office of the Regional Administrator Subject: 2013 State Nutrient

Performance Curve

Page 32: Bioreactor Protocol | US EPA ARCHIVE DOCUMENTBioreactor Protocol | US EPA ARCHIVE DOCUMENT Author: US EPA, Region 5, Office of the Regional Administrator Subject: 2013 State Nutrient

Illinois Performance CurveBIOREACTOR EFFICACY CURVE

Lake Decatur and Lake Bloomington WatershedsLake Decatur and Lake Bloomington Watersheds

Lr = 95 31Ld‐0.36180

90

100

(%)

Lr = 87.29Ld‐0.343

Lr = 95.31LdR² = 0.94

50

60

70

uctio

n Lr (

R² = 0.99

Lr = 95.42Ld‐0.435

R² = 0 4420

30

40

Load

 Red

R  = 0.44

0

10

0 5 10 15 20

Loading Density Ld ( Acres/100 sq.feet of the bioreactor)2008 2009 2010 2008 2008‐2009 2008‐2010

Page 33: Bioreactor Protocol | US EPA ARCHIVE DOCUMENTBioreactor Protocol | US EPA ARCHIVE DOCUMENT Author: US EPA, Region 5, Office of the Regional Administrator Subject: 2013 State Nutrient

Cost Analysisy

Page 34: Bioreactor Protocol | US EPA ARCHIVE DOCUMENTBioreactor Protocol | US EPA ARCHIVE DOCUMENT Author: US EPA, Region 5, Office of the Regional Administrator Subject: 2013 State Nutrient

Length/Width Effectsg /

Page 35: Bioreactor Protocol | US EPA ARCHIVE DOCUMENTBioreactor Protocol | US EPA ARCHIVE DOCUMENT Author: US EPA, Region 5, Office of the Regional Administrator Subject: 2013 State Nutrient

Length/Width Effectsg /

Page 36: Bioreactor Protocol | US EPA ARCHIVE DOCUMENTBioreactor Protocol | US EPA ARCHIVE DOCUMENT Author: US EPA, Region 5, Office of the Regional Administrator Subject: 2013 State Nutrient

Manual Optimizationp

Page 37: Bioreactor Protocol | US EPA ARCHIVE DOCUMENTBioreactor Protocol | US EPA ARCHIVE DOCUMENT Author: US EPA, Region 5, Office of the Regional Administrator Subject: 2013 State Nutrient

Automatic Optimizationp

Page 38: Bioreactor Protocol | US EPA ARCHIVE DOCUMENTBioreactor Protocol | US EPA ARCHIVE DOCUMENT Author: US EPA, Region 5, Office of the Regional Administrator Subject: 2013 State Nutrient

Incorporating Performance

Page 39: Bioreactor Protocol | US EPA ARCHIVE DOCUMENTBioreactor Protocol | US EPA ARCHIVE DOCUMENT Author: US EPA, Region 5, Office of the Regional Administrator Subject: 2013 State Nutrient

Report Generation

Page 40: Bioreactor Protocol | US EPA ARCHIVE DOCUMENTBioreactor Protocol | US EPA ARCHIVE DOCUMENT Author: US EPA, Region 5, Office of the Regional Administrator Subject: 2013 State Nutrient

Report Generation

Page 41: Bioreactor Protocol | US EPA ARCHIVE DOCUMENTBioreactor Protocol | US EPA ARCHIVE DOCUMENT Author: US EPA, Region 5, Office of the Regional Administrator Subject: 2013 State Nutrient

Future Work: Residence Time

Page 42: Bioreactor Protocol | US EPA ARCHIVE DOCUMENTBioreactor Protocol | US EPA ARCHIVE DOCUMENT Author: US EPA, Region 5, Office of the Regional Administrator Subject: 2013 State Nutrient

60 ft x 2.5 ft 40 ft x 3.5 ft

80 ft x 3.5 ft

Page 43: Bioreactor Protocol | US EPA ARCHIVE DOCUMENTBioreactor Protocol | US EPA ARCHIVE DOCUMENT Author: US EPA, Region 5, Office of the Regional Administrator Subject: 2013 State Nutrient

Preliminary Results

Page 44: Bioreactor Protocol | US EPA ARCHIVE DOCUMENTBioreactor Protocol | US EPA ARCHIVE DOCUMENT Author: US EPA, Region 5, Office of the Regional Administrator Subject: 2013 State Nutrient

Future Work: Nitrate Loads

Page 45: Bioreactor Protocol | US EPA ARCHIVE DOCUMENTBioreactor Protocol | US EPA ARCHIVE DOCUMENT Author: US EPA, Region 5, Office of the Regional Administrator Subject: 2013 State Nutrient