Army Compatible Use Buffers to Support Army Testingproceedings.ndia.org/jsem2007/4175_Grain.pdf ·...

21
Army Compatible Use Buffer Program Janmichael Graine / IMEA-TRS / 410-436-6981 / DSN 584-6981 / [email protected] 1 of 26 16 May 2007 Janmichael Graine Biologist Training Support Division, U.S. Army Environmental Command Army Compatible Use Buffers to Support Army Testing Joint Services Environmental Management Conference Columbus, OH 22 May 2007 Leading Change for Installation Excellence

Transcript of Army Compatible Use Buffers to Support Army Testingproceedings.ndia.org/jsem2007/4175_Grain.pdf ·...

Page 1: Army Compatible Use Buffers to Support Army Testingproceedings.ndia.org/jsem2007/4175_Grain.pdf · 2019-12-02 · Army Compatible Use Buffer Program Janmichael Graine / IMEA-TRS

Army Compatible Use Buffer Program

Janmichael Graine / IMEA-TRS / 410-436-6981 / DSN 584-6981 / [email protected] 1 of 26 16 May 2007

Janmichael GraineBiologist

Training Support Division, U.S. Army Environmental Command

Army Compatible Use Buffers to Support Army Testing

Joint Services Environmental Management ConferenceColumbus, OH22 May 2007

Leading Change for Installation Excellence

Page 2: Army Compatible Use Buffers to Support Army Testingproceedings.ndia.org/jsem2007/4175_Grain.pdf · 2019-12-02 · Army Compatible Use Buffer Program Janmichael Graine / IMEA-TRS

Army Compatible Use Buffer Program

Janmichael Graine / IMEA-TRS / 410-436-6981 / DSN 584-6981 / [email protected] 2 of 26 16 May 2007

Purpose

• Discuss the Encroachment problem at Testing Installations.

• Provide an overview of the ACUB program on testing installations.

Page 3: Army Compatible Use Buffers to Support Army Testingproceedings.ndia.org/jsem2007/4175_Grain.pdf · 2019-12-02 · Army Compatible Use Buffer Program Janmichael Graine / IMEA-TRS

Army Compatible Use Buffer Program

Janmichael Graine / IMEA-TRS / 410-436-6981 / DSN 584-6981 / [email protected] 3 of 26 16 May 2007

Military lands become refuges of biodiversityMilitary lands become refuges of biodiversity

San Diego fairy shrimp

13,000 acres critical habitat

Cam p P endleto n

0 10 205 M iles

Los Angeles

San Diego

California Gnatchatcher

51,000 acres critical habitat

Page 4: Army Compatible Use Buffers to Support Army Testingproceedings.ndia.org/jsem2007/4175_Grain.pdf · 2019-12-02 · Army Compatible Use Buffer Program Janmichael Graine / IMEA-TRS

Army Compatible Use Buffer Program

Janmichael Graine / IMEA-TRS / 410-436-6981 / DSN 584-6981 / [email protected] 4 of 26 16 May 2007

1982 19932000

Reilly Road

Military Boundary Line

New elementary school

and residential development

Page 5: Army Compatible Use Buffers to Support Army Testingproceedings.ndia.org/jsem2007/4175_Grain.pdf · 2019-12-02 · Army Compatible Use Buffer Program Janmichael Graine / IMEA-TRS

Army Compatible Use Buffer Program

Janmichael Graine / IMEA-TRS / 410-436-6981 / DSN 584-6981 / [email protected] 5 of 26 16 May 2007

Ft. Bragg, NC

Firing Ranges

Installation Boundary

Suburban Sprawl

Page 6: Army Compatible Use Buffers to Support Army Testingproceedings.ndia.org/jsem2007/4175_Grain.pdf · 2019-12-02 · Army Compatible Use Buffer Program Janmichael Graine / IMEA-TRS

Army Compatible Use Buffer Program

Janmichael Graine / IMEA-TRS / 410-436-6981 / DSN 584-6981 / [email protected] 6 of 26 16 May 2007

Testing Impacts of Encroachment

• Installations impact neighbors• Noise• Smoke / dust• Electromagnetic

• Neighbors impact installations• Complaints• Light pollution (night ops)

• Testing restrictions (type, timing, and location)

• Habitat loss (increased conservation burden)

Page 7: Army Compatible Use Buffers to Support Army Testingproceedings.ndia.org/jsem2007/4175_Grain.pdf · 2019-12-02 · Army Compatible Use Buffer Program Janmichael Graine / IMEA-TRS

Army Compatible Use Buffer Program

Janmichael Graine / IMEA-TRS / 410-436-6981 / DSN 584-6981 / [email protected] 7 of 26 16 May 2007

Page 8: Army Compatible Use Buffers to Support Army Testingproceedings.ndia.org/jsem2007/4175_Grain.pdf · 2019-12-02 · Army Compatible Use Buffer Program Janmichael Graine / IMEA-TRS

Army Compatible Use Buffer Program

Janmichael Graine / IMEA-TRS / 410-436-6981 / DSN 584-6981 / [email protected] 8 of 26 16 May 2007

ACUB Testing Installation Status

Fort Carson, CO

Approved ACUB Proposals

Aberdeen Proving Ground, MD

Pending ACUB Proposals

Fort Huachuca, AZ

Yuma Proving Ground, AZ

Page 9: Army Compatible Use Buffers to Support Army Testingproceedings.ndia.org/jsem2007/4175_Grain.pdf · 2019-12-02 · Army Compatible Use Buffer Program Janmichael Graine / IMEA-TRS

Army Compatible Use Buffer Program

Janmichael Graine / IMEA-TRS / 410-436-6981 / DSN 584-6981 / [email protected] 9 of 26 16 May 2007

Aberdeen Proving Ground, MDChurchville Test Area

ObjectiveProtect important testing areas from potential development and to preserve the county’s agricultural heritage.

CA partner: Hartford Land Trust

Other partners: Harford County Government and Sate of Maryland department of natural resources.

Page 10: Army Compatible Use Buffers to Support Army Testingproceedings.ndia.org/jsem2007/4175_Grain.pdf · 2019-12-02 · Army Compatible Use Buffer Program Janmichael Graine / IMEA-TRS

Army Compatible Use Buffer Program

Janmichael Graine / IMEA-TRS / 410-436-6981 / DSN 584-6981 / [email protected] 10 of 26 16 May 2007

Aberdeen Test Center Background

• Aberdeen Test Center (ATC) is tenant at APG and DoD lead for automotive testing for all manned and unmanned wheeled and tracked vehicles

• Churchville Test Area (CTA) is non-contiguous to APG and located in rural, farming area mostly surrounded by permanently-protected agriculture land

• CTA includes 244 acres, 11 miles of test courses with extremely hilly and cross-country terrain at grades of 7-29%

• CTA accommodates minimum test and evaluation training to standard for wheeled and tracked vehicles and is only such facility in the US

Page 11: Army Compatible Use Buffers to Support Army Testingproceedings.ndia.org/jsem2007/4175_Grain.pdf · 2019-12-02 · Army Compatible Use Buffer Program Janmichael Graine / IMEA-TRS

Army Compatible Use Buffer Program

Janmichael Graine / IMEA-TRS / 410-436-6981 / DSN 584-6981 / [email protected] 11 of 26 16 May 2007

Aberdeen Test Center Details

• 163 acres with development rights to subdivide for 11 houses is only remaining adjacent parcel without permanent protection from development

• Partner with Harford County and Harford Land Trust to purchase development rights and ensure continued agriculture use

• 25% partner contribution for total Army cost of $980K

Page 12: Army Compatible Use Buffers to Support Army Testingproceedings.ndia.org/jsem2007/4175_Grain.pdf · 2019-12-02 · Army Compatible Use Buffer Program Janmichael Graine / IMEA-TRS

Army Compatible Use Buffer Program

Janmichael Graine / IMEA-TRS / 410-436-6981 / DSN 584-6981 / [email protected] 12 of 26 16 May 2007

ATC ACUB Benefits

• All land surrounding CTA will be permanently protected from development

• Protect water quality from increased runoff and sedimentation

• Premier military wheeled and track vehicle testing site will remain critical DoD asset with no time-of-day or location restrictions on testing

Page 13: Army Compatible Use Buffers to Support Army Testingproceedings.ndia.org/jsem2007/4175_Grain.pdf · 2019-12-02 · Army Compatible Use Buffer Program Janmichael Graine / IMEA-TRS

Army Compatible Use Buffer Program

Janmichael Graine / IMEA-TRS / 410-436-6981 / DSN 584-6981 / [email protected] 13 of 26 16 May 2007

Fort Huachuca, AZ

Objectiveprevent high density land development:

-Avert increasing threat from frequency interference.

-Encumber land to prevent uses for commercial telecommunications and other EM spectrum users

Coordination Zone required area

Test Range ‘minimize sources’ requirement

–AZ Military Installation Fund --Santa Cruz and Cochise County --AZ Open Land Trust

Page 14: Army Compatible Use Buffers to Support Army Testingproceedings.ndia.org/jsem2007/4175_Grain.pdf · 2019-12-02 · Army Compatible Use Buffer Program Janmichael Graine / IMEA-TRS

Army Compatible Use Buffer Program

Janmichael Graine / IMEA-TRS / 410-436-6981 / DSN 584-6981 / [email protected] 14 of 26 16 May 2007

• Electronic Proving Ground (EPG):–UAV testing in the isolated frequency environment of R2303

airspace–communications equipment, networks and end items for C4

equipment loading to ensure performance to standards • Joint Interoperability Test Command (JITC)

–Ensures joint Federal interoperability for C4ISR products–information technology/national security systems

• Intelligence and Electronic Warfare (IEWTD)–All Army operational testing on C4ISR and CIED systems

and rapid initiatives–Active open-air jamming of military and commercial

frequencies and GPS

Test Missions

Page 15: Army Compatible Use Buffers to Support Army Testingproceedings.ndia.org/jsem2007/4175_Grain.pdf · 2019-12-02 · Army Compatible Use Buffer Program Janmichael Graine / IMEA-TRS

Army Compatible Use Buffer Program

Janmichael Graine / IMEA-TRS / 410-436-6981 / DSN 584-6981 / [email protected] 15 of 26 16 May 2007

• Primary (Restricted airspace to protect Testing mission):– Protect up to 50,000 acres of land under R2303 airspace

used for Army UAS testing– Prevent high density land development that results in

frequency encroachment– Protect critical EM spectrum required to manage

‘background’ electronic noise, light, line of site, and surveyed position network

• Secondary (Meet T&E requirements):• Leverage partner funds and avoid restrictions due to

Huachuca water umbel in the Upper San Pedro basin

Huachuca ACUB Purpose

Page 16: Army Compatible Use Buffers to Support Army Testingproceedings.ndia.org/jsem2007/4175_Grain.pdf · 2019-12-02 · Army Compatible Use Buffer Program Janmichael Graine / IMEA-TRS

Army Compatible Use Buffer Program

Janmichael Graine / IMEA-TRS / 410-436-6981 / DSN 584-6981 / [email protected] 16 of 26 16 May 2007

Irreplaceable and Non-replicable Assets

Unique natural topography and geology protects EM spectrum and shields developed areas from jamming activities

Increased residential and commercial development migrating inside the bowl encroaches on EM spectrum

Fort Huachuca

Page 17: Army Compatible Use Buffers to Support Army Testingproceedings.ndia.org/jsem2007/4175_Grain.pdf · 2019-12-02 · Army Compatible Use Buffer Program Janmichael Graine / IMEA-TRS

Army Compatible Use Buffer Program

Janmichael Graine / IMEA-TRS / 410-436-6981 / DSN 584-6981 / [email protected] 17 of 26 16 May 2007

increased development increased frequencies reduced testing capability

• AZ laws favor development and hinder local control • High density development means fewer commercial technology frequencies for

use with testing

Increased background radiation from developmentUrban area

FH area

Ag use area

Page 18: Army Compatible Use Buffers to Support Army Testingproceedings.ndia.org/jsem2007/4175_Grain.pdf · 2019-12-02 · Army Compatible Use Buffer Program Janmichael Graine / IMEA-TRS

Army Compatible Use Buffer Program

Janmichael Graine / IMEA-TRS / 410-436-6981 / DSN 584-6981 / [email protected] 18 of 26 16 May 2007

Restricted Airspace to Protect Testing Mission

Mission use in the airspace• UAV Testing • High hazard laser testing• SEMA/Guardrail• DHS Predator• Any high-hazard test

mission (Hunter Stand-off Killer Team, PROPHET)

• AZANG Predator B (2011)

Page 19: Army Compatible Use Buffers to Support Army Testingproceedings.ndia.org/jsem2007/4175_Grain.pdf · 2019-12-02 · Army Compatible Use Buffer Program Janmichael Graine / IMEA-TRS

Army Compatible Use Buffer Program

Janmichael Graine / IMEA-TRS / 410-436-6981 / DSN 584-6981 / [email protected] 19 of 26 16 May 2007

Impacts without ACUB• Degradation of isolated radio frequency environment

for electronic testing• Human health and safety from inadvertent UAV

landings • Frequency encroachment from and on local

community • Increased land values and massive su bdivision• ESA requirements on and off post from the 1997

listing of the Huachuca water umbel in the San Pedro River watershed

• Missed opportunities to receive strong partnership contributions

Page 20: Army Compatible Use Buffers to Support Army Testingproceedings.ndia.org/jsem2007/4175_Grain.pdf · 2019-12-02 · Army Compatible Use Buffer Program Janmichael Graine / IMEA-TRS

Army Compatible Use Buffer Program

Janmichael Graine / IMEA-TRS / 410-436-6981 / DSN 584-6981 / [email protected] 20 of 26 16 May 2007

• Fort Huachuca has irreplaceable and non-replicable testing assets

• High density land development threatens the testing environment

• Available electromagnetic spectrum use must be maintained for rapid turnaround for mission critical warfighter support

‘The battlefield should not be the testing ground’

Bottom Line

Page 21: Army Compatible Use Buffers to Support Army Testingproceedings.ndia.org/jsem2007/4175_Grain.pdf · 2019-12-02 · Army Compatible Use Buffer Program Janmichael Graine / IMEA-TRS

Army Compatible Use Buffer Program

Janmichael Graine / IMEA-TRS / 410-436-6981 / DSN 584-6981 / [email protected] 21 of 26 16 May 2007

A new way of thinking for the military

"There are two things that interest me - the relationship of people to each other and the relationship of people to land."

~ Aldo Leopold (Sand County Almanac)