Architecture and Engineering: Gehry, Schlaich, Calatrava ......Santiago Calatrava, Concert Hall...

84
Architecture and Engineering: Gehry, Schlaich, Calatrava, Virlogeux Methods of form finding in architecture and engineering Invention with cables: Jorg Schlaich Equilibrium and novel structural forms Michel Virlogeux: Many forms many innovations

Transcript of Architecture and Engineering: Gehry, Schlaich, Calatrava ......Santiago Calatrava, Concert Hall...

Page 1: Architecture and Engineering: Gehry, Schlaich, Calatrava ......Santiago Calatrava, Concert Hall (1999-2003), Tenerife, Spain. Courtesy Santiago Calatrava Archives proposed NY residential

Architecture and Engineering:

Gehry, Schlaich, Calatrava,

Virlogeux

Methods of form finding in architecture and engineeringInvention with cables: Jorg SchlaichEquilibrium and novel structural formsMichel Virlogeux: Many forms many innovations

Page 2: Architecture and Engineering: Gehry, Schlaich, Calatrava ......Santiago Calatrava, Concert Hall (1999-2003), Tenerife, Spain. Courtesy Santiago Calatrava Archives proposed NY residential
Page 3: Architecture and Engineering: Gehry, Schlaich, Calatrava ......Santiago Calatrava, Concert Hall (1999-2003), Tenerife, Spain. Courtesy Santiago Calatrava Archives proposed NY residential

3

StructuralEngineering

Efficiency

Safety

Permanence

Architecture (Vitruvius)

Strong(Firmitas)

Useful(Utilitas)

Beautiful(Venustas)

StructuralArt

Efficiency(Scientific)

Economy(Social)

Elegance(Symbolic)

Page 4: Architecture and Engineering: Gehry, Schlaich, Calatrava ......Santiago Calatrava, Concert Hall (1999-2003), Tenerife, Spain. Courtesy Santiago Calatrava Archives proposed NY residential

Frank Gehry

1929 -

Page 5: Architecture and Engineering: Gehry, Schlaich, Calatrava ......Santiago Calatrava, Concert Hall (1999-2003), Tenerife, Spain. Courtesy Santiago Calatrava Archives proposed NY residential
Page 6: Architecture and Engineering: Gehry, Schlaich, Calatrava ......Santiago Calatrava, Concert Hall (1999-2003), Tenerife, Spain. Courtesy Santiago Calatrava Archives proposed NY residential
Page 7: Architecture and Engineering: Gehry, Schlaich, Calatrava ......Santiago Calatrava, Concert Hall (1999-2003), Tenerife, Spain. Courtesy Santiago Calatrava Archives proposed NY residential
Page 8: Architecture and Engineering: Gehry, Schlaich, Calatrava ......Santiago Calatrava, Concert Hall (1999-2003), Tenerife, Spain. Courtesy Santiago Calatrava Archives proposed NY residential
Page 9: Architecture and Engineering: Gehry, Schlaich, Calatrava ......Santiago Calatrava, Concert Hall (1999-2003), Tenerife, Spain. Courtesy Santiago Calatrava Archives proposed NY residential
Page 10: Architecture and Engineering: Gehry, Schlaich, Calatrava ......Santiago Calatrava, Concert Hall (1999-2003), Tenerife, Spain. Courtesy Santiago Calatrava Archives proposed NY residential
Page 11: Architecture and Engineering: Gehry, Schlaich, Calatrava ......Santiago Calatrava, Concert Hall (1999-2003), Tenerife, Spain. Courtesy Santiago Calatrava Archives proposed NY residential
Page 12: Architecture and Engineering: Gehry, Schlaich, Calatrava ......Santiago Calatrava, Concert Hall (1999-2003), Tenerife, Spain. Courtesy Santiago Calatrava Archives proposed NY residential

Guggenheim Bilbao

Page 13: Architecture and Engineering: Gehry, Schlaich, Calatrava ......Santiago Calatrava, Concert Hall (1999-2003), Tenerife, Spain. Courtesy Santiago Calatrava Archives proposed NY residential
Page 14: Architecture and Engineering: Gehry, Schlaich, Calatrava ......Santiago Calatrava, Concert Hall (1999-2003), Tenerife, Spain. Courtesy Santiago Calatrava Archives proposed NY residential
Page 15: Architecture and Engineering: Gehry, Schlaich, Calatrava ......Santiago Calatrava, Concert Hall (1999-2003), Tenerife, Spain. Courtesy Santiago Calatrava Archives proposed NY residential
Page 16: Architecture and Engineering: Gehry, Schlaich, Calatrava ......Santiago Calatrava, Concert Hall (1999-2003), Tenerife, Spain. Courtesy Santiago Calatrava Archives proposed NY residential
Page 17: Architecture and Engineering: Gehry, Schlaich, Calatrava ......Santiago Calatrava, Concert Hall (1999-2003), Tenerife, Spain. Courtesy Santiago Calatrava Archives proposed NY residential
Page 18: Architecture and Engineering: Gehry, Schlaich, Calatrava ......Santiago Calatrava, Concert Hall (1999-2003), Tenerife, Spain. Courtesy Santiago Calatrava Archives proposed NY residential

Jörg Schlaich

1934 -

Page 19: Architecture and Engineering: Gehry, Schlaich, Calatrava ......Santiago Calatrava, Concert Hall (1999-2003), Tenerife, Spain. Courtesy Santiago Calatrava Archives proposed NY residential
Page 20: Architecture and Engineering: Gehry, Schlaich, Calatrava ......Santiago Calatrava, Concert Hall (1999-2003), Tenerife, Spain. Courtesy Santiago Calatrava Archives proposed NY residential
Page 21: Architecture and Engineering: Gehry, Schlaich, Calatrava ......Santiago Calatrava, Concert Hall (1999-2003), Tenerife, Spain. Courtesy Santiago Calatrava Archives proposed NY residential
Page 22: Architecture and Engineering: Gehry, Schlaich, Calatrava ......Santiago Calatrava, Concert Hall (1999-2003), Tenerife, Spain. Courtesy Santiago Calatrava Archives proposed NY residential
Page 23: Architecture and Engineering: Gehry, Schlaich, Calatrava ......Santiago Calatrava, Concert Hall (1999-2003), Tenerife, Spain. Courtesy Santiago Calatrava Archives proposed NY residential
Page 24: Architecture and Engineering: Gehry, Schlaich, Calatrava ......Santiago Calatrava, Concert Hall (1999-2003), Tenerife, Spain. Courtesy Santiago Calatrava Archives proposed NY residential
Page 25: Architecture and Engineering: Gehry, Schlaich, Calatrava ......Santiago Calatrava, Concert Hall (1999-2003), Tenerife, Spain. Courtesy Santiago Calatrava Archives proposed NY residential
Page 26: Architecture and Engineering: Gehry, Schlaich, Calatrava ......Santiago Calatrava, Concert Hall (1999-2003), Tenerife, Spain. Courtesy Santiago Calatrava Archives proposed NY residential
Page 27: Architecture and Engineering: Gehry, Schlaich, Calatrava ......Santiago Calatrava, Concert Hall (1999-2003), Tenerife, Spain. Courtesy Santiago Calatrava Archives proposed NY residential
Page 28: Architecture and Engineering: Gehry, Schlaich, Calatrava ......Santiago Calatrava, Concert Hall (1999-2003), Tenerife, Spain. Courtesy Santiago Calatrava Archives proposed NY residential
Page 29: Architecture and Engineering: Gehry, Schlaich, Calatrava ......Santiago Calatrava, Concert Hall (1999-2003), Tenerife, Spain. Courtesy Santiago Calatrava Archives proposed NY residential
Page 30: Architecture and Engineering: Gehry, Schlaich, Calatrava ......Santiago Calatrava, Concert Hall (1999-2003), Tenerife, Spain. Courtesy Santiago Calatrava Archives proposed NY residential
Page 31: Architecture and Engineering: Gehry, Schlaich, Calatrava ......Santiago Calatrava, Concert Hall (1999-2003), Tenerife, Spain. Courtesy Santiago Calatrava Archives proposed NY residential
Page 32: Architecture and Engineering: Gehry, Schlaich, Calatrava ......Santiago Calatrava, Concert Hall (1999-2003), Tenerife, Spain. Courtesy Santiago Calatrava Archives proposed NY residential
Page 33: Architecture and Engineering: Gehry, Schlaich, Calatrava ......Santiago Calatrava, Concert Hall (1999-2003), Tenerife, Spain. Courtesy Santiago Calatrava Archives proposed NY residential
Page 34: Architecture and Engineering: Gehry, Schlaich, Calatrava ......Santiago Calatrava, Concert Hall (1999-2003), Tenerife, Spain. Courtesy Santiago Calatrava Archives proposed NY residential
Page 35: Architecture and Engineering: Gehry, Schlaich, Calatrava ......Santiago Calatrava, Concert Hall (1999-2003), Tenerife, Spain. Courtesy Santiago Calatrava Archives proposed NY residential
Page 36: Architecture and Engineering: Gehry, Schlaich, Calatrava ......Santiago Calatrava, Concert Hall (1999-2003), Tenerife, Spain. Courtesy Santiago Calatrava Archives proposed NY residential

Santiago Calatrava

1951 -

Page 37: Architecture and Engineering: Gehry, Schlaich, Calatrava ......Santiago Calatrava, Concert Hall (1999-2003), Tenerife, Spain. Courtesy Santiago Calatrava Archives proposed NY residential
Page 38: Architecture and Engineering: Gehry, Schlaich, Calatrava ......Santiago Calatrava, Concert Hall (1999-2003), Tenerife, Spain. Courtesy Santiago Calatrava Archives proposed NY residential
Page 39: Architecture and Engineering: Gehry, Schlaich, Calatrava ......Santiago Calatrava, Concert Hall (1999-2003), Tenerife, Spain. Courtesy Santiago Calatrava Archives proposed NY residential
Page 40: Architecture and Engineering: Gehry, Schlaich, Calatrava ......Santiago Calatrava, Concert Hall (1999-2003), Tenerife, Spain. Courtesy Santiago Calatrava Archives proposed NY residential
Page 41: Architecture and Engineering: Gehry, Schlaich, Calatrava ......Santiago Calatrava, Concert Hall (1999-2003), Tenerife, Spain. Courtesy Santiago Calatrava Archives proposed NY residential
Page 42: Architecture and Engineering: Gehry, Schlaich, Calatrava ......Santiago Calatrava, Concert Hall (1999-2003), Tenerife, Spain. Courtesy Santiago Calatrava Archives proposed NY residential
Page 43: Architecture and Engineering: Gehry, Schlaich, Calatrava ......Santiago Calatrava, Concert Hall (1999-2003), Tenerife, Spain. Courtesy Santiago Calatrava Archives proposed NY residential
Page 44: Architecture and Engineering: Gehry, Schlaich, Calatrava ......Santiago Calatrava, Concert Hall (1999-2003), Tenerife, Spain. Courtesy Santiago Calatrava Archives proposed NY residential
Page 45: Architecture and Engineering: Gehry, Schlaich, Calatrava ......Santiago Calatrava, Concert Hall (1999-2003), Tenerife, Spain. Courtesy Santiago Calatrava Archives proposed NY residential

45

Santiago Calatrava, Concert Hall (1999-2003), Tenerife, Spain. Courtesy Santiago Calatrava Archives

proposed NY residential tower on South Street by Calatrava.

Oriente Station in Lisbon, photo by BWS.

Page 46: Architecture and Engineering: Gehry, Schlaich, Calatrava ......Santiago Calatrava, Concert Hall (1999-2003), Tenerife, Spain. Courtesy Santiago Calatrava Archives proposed NY residential

Michel Virlogeux 1946-

Designer & Engineer

Page 47: Architecture and Engineering: Gehry, Schlaich, Calatrava ......Santiago Calatrava, Concert Hall (1999-2003), Tenerife, Spain. Courtesy Santiago Calatrava Archives proposed NY residential
Page 48: Architecture and Engineering: Gehry, Schlaich, Calatrava ......Santiago Calatrava, Concert Hall (1999-2003), Tenerife, Spain. Courtesy Santiago Calatrava Archives proposed NY residential

-- Michel Virlogeux

Page 49: Architecture and Engineering: Gehry, Schlaich, Calatrava ......Santiago Calatrava, Concert Hall (1999-2003), Tenerife, Spain. Courtesy Santiago Calatrava Archives proposed NY residential

“I think engineers must design structures that are rational, logical, and work in such a way that they make elegant structures based on the flow of forces. The greatest elegance is to design something which is slender and beautiful and well integrated with the site. There are some structures you see where you just cannot understand it — there is no logic in the shapes.”-- Michel Virlogeux

Page 50: Architecture and Engineering: Gehry, Schlaich, Calatrava ......Santiago Calatrava, Concert Hall (1999-2003), Tenerife, Spain. Courtesy Santiago Calatrava Archives proposed NY residential

“Structural mechanics is the basis of engineering. Yes, engineers must have more imagination, more creativity. they must go to concerts and exhibitions of paintings and engage in society and be inspired by all these things — but they must never lose mathematics and structural mechanics. If they lose that, they lose everything. They'll become under-architects.”

-- Michel Virlogeux

Page 51: Architecture and Engineering: Gehry, Schlaich, Calatrava ......Santiago Calatrava, Concert Hall (1999-2003), Tenerife, Spain. Courtesy Santiago Calatrava Archives proposed NY residential

Major structures:

Page 52: Architecture and Engineering: Gehry, Schlaich, Calatrava ......Santiago Calatrava, Concert Hall (1999-2003), Tenerife, Spain. Courtesy Santiago Calatrava Archives proposed NY residential
Page 53: Architecture and Engineering: Gehry, Schlaich, Calatrava ......Santiago Calatrava, Concert Hall (1999-2003), Tenerife, Spain. Courtesy Santiago Calatrava Archives proposed NY residential

Girder Bridges

Page 54: Architecture and Engineering: Gehry, Schlaich, Calatrava ......Santiago Calatrava, Concert Hall (1999-2003), Tenerife, Spain. Courtesy Santiago Calatrava Archives proposed NY residential

Wilson Bridge 1810, 1982

Page 55: Architecture and Engineering: Gehry, Schlaich, Calatrava ......Santiago Calatrava, Concert Hall (1999-2003), Tenerife, Spain. Courtesy Santiago Calatrava Archives proposed NY residential

La Flèche Bridge 1983

Page 56: Architecture and Engineering: Gehry, Schlaich, Calatrava ......Santiago Calatrava, Concert Hall (1999-2003), Tenerife, Spain. Courtesy Santiago Calatrava Archives proposed NY residential

Re Island Bridge

Page 57: Architecture and Engineering: Gehry, Schlaich, Calatrava ......Santiago Calatrava, Concert Hall (1999-2003), Tenerife, Spain. Courtesy Santiago Calatrava Archives proposed NY residential

Movable Bridges

Page 58: Architecture and Engineering: Gehry, Schlaich, Calatrava ......Santiago Calatrava, Concert Hall (1999-2003), Tenerife, Spain. Courtesy Santiago Calatrava Archives proposed NY residential

Rouen 6th Bridge, or Gustave Flaubert Bridge 2008

Page 59: Architecture and Engineering: Gehry, Schlaich, Calatrava ......Santiago Calatrava, Concert Hall (1999-2003), Tenerife, Spain. Courtesy Santiago Calatrava Archives proposed NY residential

Bacalan-Bastide Bridge 2010

Page 60: Architecture and Engineering: Gehry, Schlaich, Calatrava ......Santiago Calatrava, Concert Hall (1999-2003), Tenerife, Spain. Courtesy Santiago Calatrava Archives proposed NY residential

Arch Bridges

Page 61: Architecture and Engineering: Gehry, Schlaich, Calatrava ......Santiago Calatrava, Concert Hall (1999-2003), Tenerife, Spain. Courtesy Santiago Calatrava Archives proposed NY residential

Clos-Moreau Bridge 2005,

Page 62: Architecture and Engineering: Gehry, Schlaich, Calatrava ......Santiago Calatrava, Concert Hall (1999-2003), Tenerife, Spain. Courtesy Santiago Calatrava Archives proposed NY residential

Languedoc Bridge

2008

Page 63: Architecture and Engineering: Gehry, Schlaich, Calatrava ......Santiago Calatrava, Concert Hall (1999-2003), Tenerife, Spain. Courtesy Santiago Calatrava Archives proposed NY residential

Languedoc Bridge

2008

Why might Virlogeux need

fewer verticals than Maillart?

Page 64: Architecture and Engineering: Gehry, Schlaich, Calatrava ......Santiago Calatrava, Concert Hall (1999-2003), Tenerife, Spain. Courtesy Santiago Calatrava Archives proposed NY residential

Cable Stayed Bridges

Page 65: Architecture and Engineering: Gehry, Schlaich, Calatrava ......Santiago Calatrava, Concert Hall (1999-2003), Tenerife, Spain. Courtesy Santiago Calatrava Archives proposed NY residential

Vasco da Gama Bridge 1998

Page 66: Architecture and Engineering: Gehry, Schlaich, Calatrava ......Santiago Calatrava, Concert Hall (1999-2003), Tenerife, Spain. Courtesy Santiago Calatrava Archives proposed NY residential

Normandy Bridge 1995

Describe the overall cable stay form here, cables/pylons

Page 67: Architecture and Engineering: Gehry, Schlaich, Calatrava ......Santiago Calatrava, Concert Hall (1999-2003), Tenerife, Spain. Courtesy Santiago Calatrava Archives proposed NY residential

Térénz Bridge 2010

Page 68: Architecture and Engineering: Gehry, Schlaich, Calatrava ......Santiago Calatrava, Concert Hall (1999-2003), Tenerife, Spain. Courtesy Santiago Calatrava Archives proposed NY residential

Millau Viaduct

Page 69: Architecture and Engineering: Gehry, Schlaich, Calatrava ......Santiago Calatrava, Concert Hall (1999-2003), Tenerife, Spain. Courtesy Santiago Calatrava Archives proposed NY residential

Millau Viaduct 2004

Page 70: Architecture and Engineering: Gehry, Schlaich, Calatrava ......Santiago Calatrava, Concert Hall (1999-2003), Tenerife, Spain. Courtesy Santiago Calatrava Archives proposed NY residential
Page 71: Architecture and Engineering: Gehry, Schlaich, Calatrava ......Santiago Calatrava, Concert Hall (1999-2003), Tenerife, Spain. Courtesy Santiago Calatrava Archives proposed NY residential
Page 72: Architecture and Engineering: Gehry, Schlaich, Calatrava ......Santiago Calatrava, Concert Hall (1999-2003), Tenerife, Spain. Courtesy Santiago Calatrava Archives proposed NY residential
Page 73: Architecture and Engineering: Gehry, Schlaich, Calatrava ......Santiago Calatrava, Concert Hall (1999-2003), Tenerife, Spain. Courtesy Santiago Calatrava Archives proposed NY residential
Page 74: Architecture and Engineering: Gehry, Schlaich, Calatrava ......Santiago Calatrava, Concert Hall (1999-2003), Tenerife, Spain. Courtesy Santiago Calatrava Archives proposed NY residential
Page 75: Architecture and Engineering: Gehry, Schlaich, Calatrava ......Santiago Calatrava, Concert Hall (1999-2003), Tenerife, Spain. Courtesy Santiago Calatrava Archives proposed NY residential
Page 76: Architecture and Engineering: Gehry, Schlaich, Calatrava ......Santiago Calatrava, Concert Hall (1999-2003), Tenerife, Spain. Courtesy Santiago Calatrava Archives proposed NY residential
Page 77: Architecture and Engineering: Gehry, Schlaich, Calatrava ......Santiago Calatrava, Concert Hall (1999-2003), Tenerife, Spain. Courtesy Santiago Calatrava Archives proposed NY residential
Page 78: Architecture and Engineering: Gehry, Schlaich, Calatrava ......Santiago Calatrava, Concert Hall (1999-2003), Tenerife, Spain. Courtesy Santiago Calatrava Archives proposed NY residential
Page 79: Architecture and Engineering: Gehry, Schlaich, Calatrava ......Santiago Calatrava, Concert Hall (1999-2003), Tenerife, Spain. Courtesy Santiago Calatrava Archives proposed NY residential
Page 80: Architecture and Engineering: Gehry, Schlaich, Calatrava ......Santiago Calatrava, Concert Hall (1999-2003), Tenerife, Spain. Courtesy Santiago Calatrava Archives proposed NY residential
Page 81: Architecture and Engineering: Gehry, Schlaich, Calatrava ......Santiago Calatrava, Concert Hall (1999-2003), Tenerife, Spain. Courtesy Santiago Calatrava Archives proposed NY residential
Page 82: Architecture and Engineering: Gehry, Schlaich, Calatrava ......Santiago Calatrava, Concert Hall (1999-2003), Tenerife, Spain. Courtesy Santiago Calatrava Archives proposed NY residential

Who is Michel Virlogeux?

Page 83: Architecture and Engineering: Gehry, Schlaich, Calatrava ......Santiago Calatrava, Concert Hall (1999-2003), Tenerife, Spain. Courtesy Santiago Calatrava Archives proposed NY residential

83

Current practitioners

• Gehry

• Calatrava

• Schlaich

• Virlogeux

• Architect

• Architect/Eng.

• Engineer

• Engineer

• Buildings

• Buildings/Bridges

• Bridges/Roofs

• Bridges

Page 84: Architecture and Engineering: Gehry, Schlaich, Calatrava ......Santiago Calatrava, Concert Hall (1999-2003), Tenerife, Spain. Courtesy Santiago Calatrava Archives proposed NY residential