Corporate Crime Legal Research Refresher

Post on 16-Dec-2014

1.061 views 1 download

Tags:

description

Quick legal research refresher for the Corporate Crime class.

Transcript of Corporate Crime Legal Research Refresher

Corporate CrimeLegal Research Refresher

Charlotte Gill

Research Librarian, Law

Aug 2014

© Copyright 2013 Singapore Management University, Li Ka Shing Library. All Rights Reserved

Outcomes Research Strategy Search Tools and Techniques Case Study Resources Tips

Outline

© Copyright 2013 Singapore Management University, Li Ka Shing Library. All Rights Reserved

Objective

Refresh your legal research skills

Highlight some of the relevant resources.

© Copyright 2013 Singapore Management University, Li Ka Shing Library. All Rights Reserved

Research Strategy

Have a plan!

April 10, 2023

© Copyright 2013 Singapore Management University, Li Ka Shing Library. All Rights Reserved

Legal Research Process

Identify the scope of the legal question

Start by consulting a secondary source

Identify the relevant legislation

Identify the cases that are on-point

Confirm the authority is still good law

Expand your search to fill any gaps

Keep a record of your research trail

(Modified from http://denning.law.ox.ac.uk/Irsp/overview/process.php)

April 10, 2023

© Copyright 2013 Singapore Management University, Li Ka Shing Library. All Rights Reserved

Search Tools and Techniques

April 10, 2023© Copyright 2013 Singapore Management University, Li Ka Shing Library. All Rights Reserved

Identifying alternative keywords

April 10, 2023

© Copyright 2013 Singapore Management University, Li Ka Shing Library. All Rights Reserved

Connectors

Connect the terms in a way computers can process them.

April 10, 2023

© Copyright 2013 Singapore Management University, Li Ka Shing Library. All Rights Reserved

Phrase

Phrase Search – use “__”

E.g.

“poison pill” means the words must appear in the specified order.

April 10, 2023

© Copyright 2013 Singapore Management University, Li Ka Shing Library. All Rights Reserved

AND

Boolean ANDX AND Y both X and Y must be present

negligence AND causation

YX

April 10, 2023

© Copyright 2013 Singapore Management University, Li Ka Shing Library. All Rights Reserved

OR

Boolean ORA OR B either A or B is present

equitable OR beneficial AB

April 10, 2023

© Copyright 2013 Singapore Management University, Li Ka Shing Library. All Rights Reserved

Truncation

Truncation (!) gets all variations of word endings

reason! reason, reasons, reasoning

April 10, 2023

© Copyright 2013 Singapore Management University, Li Ka Shing Library. All Rights Reserved

Truncate Carefully

Think about where you truncate your search terms.

E.g. Negligen!Negligence, Negligent

E.g. Defam!defamation, defame, defamed

E.g. Def!defined, definite, deface

April 10, 2023

© Copyright 2013 Singapore Management University, Li Ka Shing Library. All Rights Reserved

Proximity Operators

pay w/3 television

design w/s defect

utterance w/p hearsay

Proximity operators

(w/n, w/s, w/p) determine how close the terms appear in the document.

It increases the probability that the terms are related.

April 10, 2023

© Copyright 2013 Singapore Management University, Li Ka Shing Library. All Rights Reserved

Parentheses

Parentheses ( ) to group terms you want processed first.

Compare the two search statements

journalist AND (defamation OR publish)

(journalist AND defamation) OR publish

April 10, 2023

© Copyright 2013 Singapore Management University, Li Ka Shing Library. All Rights Reserved

Search Statements

Circumstances w/s mitigat!

(“take over” OR takeover) W/p “poison pill”

Putting all the pieces together!

April 10, 2023

© Copyright 2013 Singapore Management University, Li Ka Shing Library. All Rights Reserved

LawNet, Lexis, Westlaw

Search Function LawNet Lexis Westlaw

And AND AND &

or OR OR a spacee.g. lawyer counsel

And NotBut Not

NOT AND NOT %

Phrase searching Simply enter the phrase the way it ordinarily appears.

Simply enter the phrase the way it ordinarily appears.

“ _”

Truncation * (? – single letter)

! !

Wildcard * * *

Within N words w/n W/N /n

Precedes by N words PRE/N +n

In same paragraph W/P /p

In same sentence w/s /sApril 10, 2023

© Copyright 2013 Singapore Management University, Li Ka Shing Library. All Rights Reserved

Database Help Sheet

Available on the Law Research Navigator

© Copyright 2013 Singapore Management University, Li Ka Shing Library. All Rights Reserved

Case Study

Review the law regarding corporate criminal liability in the United Kingdom.

© Copyright 2013 Singapore Management University, Li Ka Shing Library. All Rights Reserved

Secondary Resources

© Copyright 2013 Singapore Management University, Li Ka Shing Library. All Rights Reserved

Texts & Articles

© Copyright 2013 Singapore Management University, Li Ka Shing Library. All Rights Reserved

Lexis Library – Commentary

© Copyright 2013 Singapore Management University, Li Ka Shing Library. All Rights Reserved

Narrow by Source or Topics

© Copyright 2013 Singapore Management University, Li Ka Shing Library. All Rights Reserved

© Copyright 2013 Singapore Management University, Li Ka Shing Library. All Rights Reserved

Narrow by Source or Topics

Halsbury’s Laws of England

© Copyright 2013 Singapore Management University, Li Ka Shing Library. All Rights Reserved

Search

© Copyright 2013 Singapore Management University, Li Ka Shing Library. All Rights Reserved

Browse the Index

© Copyright 2013 Singapore Management University, Li Ka Shing Library. All Rights Reserved

Index

© Copyright 2013 Singapore Management University, Li Ka Shing Library. All Rights Reserved

© Copyright 2013 Singapore Management University, Li Ka Shing Library. All Rights Reserved

© Copyright 2013 Singapore Management University, Li Ka Shing Library. All Rights Reserved

© Copyright 2013 Singapore Management University, Li Ka Shing Library. All Rights Reserved

© Copyright 2013 Singapore Management University, Li Ka Shing Library. All Rights Reserved

© Copyright 2013 Singapore Management University, Li Ka Shing Library. All Rights Reserved

Stop Press

© Copyright 2013 Singapore Management University, Li Ka Shing Library. All Rights Reserved

Annotations

© Copyright 2013 Singapore Management University, Li Ka Shing Library. All Rights Reserved

Status Snapshot

© Copyright 2013 Singapore Management University, Li Ka Shing Library. All Rights Reserved

Find related commentary

© Copyright 2013 Singapore Management University, Li Ka Shing Library. All Rights Reserved

Find related cases

© Copyright 2013 Singapore Management University, Li Ka Shing Library. All Rights Reserved

Find related explanatory note

© Copyright 2013 Singapore Management University, Li Ka Shing Library. All Rights Reserved

© Copyright 2013 Singapore Management University, Li Ka Shing Library. All Rights Reserved

© Copyright 2013 Singapore Management University, Li Ka Shing Library. All Rights Reserved

© Copyright 2013 Singapore Management University, Li Ka Shing Library. All Rights Reserved

Hansard

© Copyright 2013 Singapore Management University, Li Ka Shing Library. All Rights Reserved

© Copyright 2013 Singapore Management University, Li Ka Shing Library. All Rights Reserved

Law Commission Report

© Copyright 2013 Singapore Management University, Li Ka Shing Library. All Rights Reserved

© Copyright 2013 Singapore Management University, Li Ka Shing Library. All Rights Reserved

© Copyright 2013 Singapore Management University, Li Ka Shing Library. All Rights Reserved

Hansard

© Copyright 2013 Singapore Management University, Li Ka Shing Library. All Rights Reserved

Case Law

Research Tesco Supermarkets v Natrass Use JustCite – locate the case and note up. Available in LawNet

© Copyright 2013 Singapore Management University, Li Ka Shing Library. All Rights Reserved

Locate the case

© Copyright 2013 Singapore Management University, Li Ka Shing Library. All Rights Reserved

Subsequent Treatment (Note Up)

© Copyright 2013 Singapore Management University, Li Ka Shing Library. All Rights Reserved

Articles

© Copyright 2013 Singapore Management University, Li Ka Shing Library. All Rights Reserved

Precedent Map

© Copyright 2013 Singapore Management University, Li Ka Shing Library. All Rights Reserved

Other tools for case law

LawNet Westlaw Lexis i-law.com

© Copyright 2013 Singapore Management University, Li Ka Shing Library. All Rights Reserved

Journal Articles

Westlaw World Journals

© Copyright 2013 Singapore Management University, Li Ka Shing Library. All Rights Reserved

© Copyright 2013 Singapore Management University, Li Ka Shing Library. All Rights Reserved

© Copyright 2013 Singapore Management University, Li Ka Shing Library. All Rights Reserved

© Copyright 2013 Singapore Management University, Li Ka Shing Library. All Rights Reserved

i-law.com

© Copyright 2013 Singapore Management University, Li Ka Shing Library. All Rights Reserved

© Copyright 2013 Singapore Management University, Li Ka Shing Library. All Rights Reserved

i-law.com

© Copyright 2013 Singapore Management University, Li Ka Shing Library. All Rights Reserved

© Copyright 2013 Singapore Management University, Li Ka Shing Library. All Rights Reserved

© Copyright 2013 Singapore Management University, Li Ka Shing Library. All Rights Reserved

© Copyright 2013 Singapore Management University, Li Ka Shing Library. All Rights Reserved

Google Scholar

© Copyright 2013 Singapore Management University, Li Ka Shing Library. All Rights Reserved

Locating journal article by citation

© Copyright 2013 Singapore Management University, Li Ka Shing Library. All Rights Reserved

© Copyright 2013 Singapore Management University, Li Ka Shing Library. All Rights Reserved

News Search

Factiva Over 28,000 sources from 157 countries in 23

languages, including nearly 600 continuously updated newswires like Dow Jones and Reuters. More than 2,300 sources are available on or before the date of publication.

Find listed Singapore and international companies information under Companies/Markets and browse selected newspapers under News Pages.

© Copyright 2013 Singapore Management University, Li Ka Shing Library. All Rights Reserved

News – NLB e-resources

Library PressDisplay   provides full-colour digital replications of hundreds of newspapers from around the globe. It offers full content and interactive access to more than 1,000 newspaper titles, from more than 80 countries and published in over 39 languages.   Available from home. The Straits Times is available in libraries only.  

© Copyright 2013 Singapore Management University, Li Ka Shing Library. All Rights Reserved

News NLB e-resources

NewspaperSG   is an online resource of current and historic Singapore and Malaya newspapers. You can search our digital archive of newspapers published in Singapore, or find information on over 200 newspaper titles in the National Library's microfilm collection.   Unlimited archive access is via the multimedia media stations at the libraries. Full article access from home (watermarked) is from 1831 to 1989 only.

© Copyright 2013 Singapore Management University, Li Ka Shing Library. All Rights Reserved

Blog Search

© Copyright 2013 Singapore Management University, Li Ka Shing Library. All Rights Reserved

Blogs

© Copyright 2013 Singapore Management University, Li Ka Shing Library. All Rights Reserved

Other Jurisdictions

© Copyright 2011 Singapore Management University, Li Ka Shing Library. All Rights Reserved

© Copyright 2013 Singapore Management University, Li Ka Shing Library. All Rights Reserved

Corporate Crime Guide

© Copyright 2011 Singapore Management University, Li Ka Shing Library. All Rights Reserved

Tips

Spend 10-15 mins identifying the issues and the scope of the research.

Establish a time frame Identify the potential resources to search Start with a secondary source Use Terms & Connectors/Boolean Take notes of sources and keywords Seek help early.

© Copyright 2013 Singapore Management University, Li Ka Shing Library. All Rights Reserved

April 10, 2023

Need help?

Email libresearch@smu.edu.sg

© Copyright 2013 Singapore Management University, Li Ka Shing Library. All Rights Reserved

April 10, 2023

Thank you

© Copyright 2013 Singapore Management University, Li Ka Shing Library. All Rights Reserved