Post on 09-Apr-2018
8/7/2019 adiabatic formalism
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/adiabatic-formalism 1/156
The Adiabatic Connection:Generating DFT Functionals fromCoupled-Cluster Theory
Andrew M. Teale
CMA-CTCC workshop on computationalquantum mechanics
13th January 2009
1 / 2 8
8/7/2019 adiabatic formalism
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/adiabatic-formalism 2/156
Wavefunction and DFT Approaches to the ElectronicStructure Problem
Wavefunction methods offer a systematic route to theapproximate solution of the electronic Schrodinger Equation
2 / 2 8
8/7/2019 adiabatic formalism
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/adiabatic-formalism 3/156
Wavefunction and DFT Approaches to the ElectronicStructure Problem
Wavefunction methods offer a systematic route to theapproximate solution of the electronic Schrodinger Equation
This means that in principle arbitrary accuracy can beachieved, CCSD, CCSD(T), CCSDT, CCSDTQ, CCSDTQ5 ...
with good control of errors.
2 / 2 8
8/7/2019 adiabatic formalism
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/adiabatic-formalism 4/156
Wavefunction and DFT Approaches to the ElectronicStructure Problem
Wavefunction methods offer a systematic route to theapproximate solution of the electronic Schrodinger Equation
This means that in principle arbitrary accuracy can beachieved, CCSD, CCSD(T), CCSDT, CCSDTQ, CCSDTQ5 ...
with good control of errors.But they are expensive and have unfavourable scaling of thecost with system size N 6, N 7,N 8 ...
2 / 2 8
8/7/2019 adiabatic formalism
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/adiabatic-formalism 6/156
Wavefunction and DFT Approaches to the ElectronicStructure Problem
Wavefunction methods offer a systematic route to theapproximate solution of the electronic Schrodinger Equation
This means that in principle arbitrary accuracy can beachieved, CCSD, CCSD(T), CCSDT, CCSDTQ, CCSDTQ5 ...
with good control of errors.But they are expensive and have unfavourable scaling of thecost with system size N 6, N 7,N 8 ...
Density Functional Theory promises a way to circumvent this
problem - use simple model system with same electronicdensity
BUT, the model Hamiltonian associated with DFT contains acontribution whose form is unknown - must be approximated.
2 / 2 8
8/7/2019 adiabatic formalism
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/adiabatic-formalism 7/156
Wavefunction and DFT Approaches to the ElectronicStructure Problem
The main disadvantage of DFT is that there is no systematicroute to the determination of this unknown contribution andso the accuracy achieved is not easily controlled and can varyfrom problem to problem
3 / 2 8
8/7/2019 adiabatic formalism
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/adiabatic-formalism 8/156
Wavefunction and DFT Approaches to the ElectronicStructure Problem
The main disadvantage of DFT is that there is no systematicroute to the determination of this unknown contribution andso the accuracy achieved is not easily controlled and can varyfrom problem to problem
In a sense WFT and DFT are complementary - one hassystematic control of errors but high cost, the other has lowcost but uncontrolled errors.
3 / 2 8
8/7/2019 adiabatic formalism
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/adiabatic-formalism 9/156
Wavefunction and DFT Approaches to the ElectronicStructure Problem
The main disadvantage of DFT is that there is no systematicroute to the determination of this unknown contribution andso the accuracy achieved is not easily controlled and can varyfrom problem to problem
In a sense WFT and DFT are complementary - one hassystematic control of errors but high cost, the other has lowcost but uncontrolled errors.
In this talk we will examine the link between the two
approaches.
3 / 2 8
8/7/2019 adiabatic formalism
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/adiabatic-formalism 11/156
The Generalized Lieb Formulation of DFTConsider a generalized Hamiltonian of the form
H λ[v ] = T + λW + i
v (ri ) = −1
2
i
2
i
+ λi > j
1
r ij
+ i
v (ri )
the electronic interaction strength can be varied with theparameter λ
4 / 2 8
8/7/2019 adiabatic formalism
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/adiabatic-formalism 12/156
The Generalized Lieb Formulation of DFTConsider a generalized Hamiltonian of the form
H λ[v ] = T + λW + i
v (ri ) = −1
2
i
2
i
+ λi > j
1
r ij
+ i
v (ri )
the electronic interaction strength can be varied with theparameter λThe ground state energy for an external potential v is
E λ[v ] = inf γ →N
Tr H λ[v ]γ
where the minimization is over all ensemble density matrices γ containing N electrons
4 / 2 8
8/7/2019 adiabatic formalism
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/adiabatic-formalism 13/156
The Generalized Lieb Formulation of DFTConsider a generalized Hamiltonian of the form
H λ[v ] = T + λW + i
v (ri ) = −1
2
i
2
i
+ λi > j
1
r ij
+ i
v (ri )
the electronic interaction strength can be varied with theparameter λThe ground state energy for an external potential v is
E λ[v ] = inf γ →N
Tr H λ[v ]γ
where the minimization is over all ensemble density matrices γ containing N electronsLieb established the mutual Legendre-Fenchel transforms for
the energy and universal functional
F λ[ρ] = supv ∈X ∗
E λ[v ]−
ρ(r)v (r) dr
E λ[v ] = inf ρ∈X F λ[ρ] +
ρ(r)v (
r)dr
4 / 2 8
8/7/2019 adiabatic formalism
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/adiabatic-formalism 14/156
The Lieb Formulation of DFT
The relationships between these conjugate functionals are the
Fenchel inequalities
F λ[ρ] ≥ E λ[v ]−
ρ(r)v (r) dr
E λ[v ] ≤ F λ[ρ] + ρ(r)v (r) dr
5 / 2 8
8/7/2019 adiabatic formalism
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/adiabatic-formalism 15/156
The Lieb Formulation of DFT
The relationships between these conjugate functionals are the
Fenchel inequalities
F λ[ρ] ≥ E λ[v ]−
ρ(r)v (r) dr
E λ[v ] ≤ F λ[ρ] + ρ(r)v (r) dr
Providing that the potential v supports an N -electron groundstate the inequalities may be sharpened into an equality bymaximization wrt v or minimization wrt ρ
5 / 2 8
8/7/2019 adiabatic formalism
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/adiabatic-formalism 16/156
The Lieb Formulation of DFT
The relationships between these conjugate functionals are the
Fenchel inequalities
F λ[ρ] ≥ E λ[v ]−
ρ(r)v (r) dr
E λ[v ] ≤ F λ[ρ] + ρ(r)v (r) dr
Providing that the potential v supports an N -electron groundstate the inequalities may be sharpened into an equality bymaximization wrt v or minimization wrt ρ
So, given a potential v or density ρ for any interactionstrength λ we can determine its conjugate partnerE. H. Lieb, Int. J. Quant. Chem., 24, 243, (1983)
5 / 2 8
8/7/2019 adiabatic formalism
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/adiabatic-formalism 50/156
The Adiabatic ConnectionI t s f th li d H ilt i
8/7/2019 adiabatic formalism
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/adiabatic-formalism 51/156
In terms of the generalized Hamiltonian
H λ[v ] = T + λW + i
v (ri ) = −1
2
i
2i + λ
i > j
1
r ij
+ i
v (ri )
and the ensemble-density matrix γ the universal Liebfunctional may then be written as
F λ[ρ] = inf γ →ρ
Tr H λ[0]γ = Tr H λ[0]γ ρλ
This can be written in terms of the non-interacting functional
F λ[ρ] = F 0[ρ] +
λ0
dF λ[ρ]
dλdλ
7 / 2 8
The Adiabatic ConnectionIn terms of the generalized Hamiltonian
8/7/2019 adiabatic formalism
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/adiabatic-formalism 52/156
In terms of the generalized Hamiltonian
H λ[v ] = T + λW + i
v (ri ) = −1
2 i
2i + λ
i > j
1
r ij
+ i
v (ri )
and the ensemble-density matrix γ the universal Liebfunctional may then be written as
F λ[ρ] = inf γ →ρ
Tr H λ[0]γ = Tr H λ[0]γ ρλ
This can be written in terms of the non-interacting functional
F λ[ρ] = F 0[ρ] +
λ0
dF λ[ρ]
dλdλ
Then applying the Hellmann-Feynman theorem
dF λ[ρ]
dλ= Tr W γ ρλ = W λ[ρ]
F λ[ρ] = Tr H 0[0]γ ρ0 + λ
0
W λ[ρ]dλ
7 / 2 8
The Adiabatic ConnectionThis may be written in the alternative form
8/7/2019 adiabatic formalism
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/adiabatic-formalism 53/156
This may be written in the alternative form
F λ[ρ] = Tr H λ[0]γ ρ0 + λ
0
W c,λ[ρ] dλ, W c,λ[ρ] = W λ[ρ]−W 0[ρ]
8 / 2 8
The Adiabatic ConnectionThis may be written in the alternative form
8/7/2019 adiabatic formalism
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/adiabatic-formalism 54/156
This may be written in the alternative form
F λ[ρ] = Tr H λ[0]γ ρ0 + λ
0
W c,λ[ρ] dλ, W c,λ[ρ] = W λ[ρ]−W 0[ρ]
Term 1 is the uncorrelated kinetic energy plus λ times thecoulomb and exchange contributions. Term 2 is the correlationcorrection required upto the chosen interaction strength
8 / 2 8
The Adiabatic ConnectionThis may be written in the alternative form
8/7/2019 adiabatic formalism
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/adiabatic-formalism 55/156
This may be written in the alternative form
F λ[ρ] = Tr H λ[0]γ ρ0 + λ
0
W c,λ[ρ] dλ, W c,λ[ρ] = W λ[ρ]−W 0[ρ]
Term 1 is the uncorrelated kinetic energy plus λ times thecoulomb and exchange contributions. Term 2 is the correlationcorrection required upto the chosen interaction strengthThe universal functional is then decomposed in the usual
manner
F λ[ρ] = T s[ρ] + λJ [ρ] + λE x[ρ] + E c,λ[ρ]
T s[ρ] = Tr H 0[0]γ ρ0 = Tr T γ ρ0 = minγ →ρ
Tr T γ
J [ρ] =
ρ(r1)ρ(r2)r −112 dr1dr2
E x[ρ] = W 0[ρ]− J [ρ]
E c,λ[ρ] =
λ
0 W c,λ[ρ]d
λ 8 / 2 8
Adiabatic Connection
W ls d fi s t ti f th
8/7/2019 adiabatic formalism
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/adiabatic-formalism 56/156
We can also define a representation for theexchange-correlation energy as
W xc,λ[ρ] = E x[ρ] + W c,λ[ρ] = W λ[ρ] − J [ρ]
E xc,λ[ρ] =
λ0W xc,λ[ρ] dλ
9 / 2 8
Adiabatic Connection
We can also define a representation for the
8/7/2019 adiabatic formalism
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/adiabatic-formalism 57/156
We can also define a representation for theexchange-correlation energy as
W xc,λ[ρ] = E x[ρ] + W c,λ[ρ] = W λ[ρ] − J [ρ]
E xc,λ[ρ] =
λ0W xc,λ[ρ] dλ
The correlation contribution to the kinetic energy may also bedetermined via
T c,λ[ρ] = E c,λ[ρ]−W c,λ[ρ] = λ
0
(W c,µ[ρ] −W c,λ[ρ])dµ
9 / 2 8
Adiabatic Connection
We can also define a representation for the
8/7/2019 adiabatic formalism
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/adiabatic-formalism 58/156
We can also define a representation for theexchange-correlation energy as
W xc,λ[ρ] = E x[ρ] + W c,λ[ρ] = W λ[ρ] − J [ρ]
E xc,λ[ρ] =
λ0W xc,λ[ρ] dλ
The correlation contribution to the kinetic energy may also bedetermined via
T c,λ[ρ] = E c,λ[ρ]−W c,λ[ρ] = λ
0
(W c,µ[ρ] −W c,λ[ρ])dµ
So we can obtain the unknown exchange–correlation andcorrelation contributions via a coupling constant integration of W xc,λ[ρ] and W c,λ[ρ]
9 / 2 8
Adiabatic Connection - Geometrical View
8/7/2019 adiabatic formalism
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/adiabatic-formalism 59/156
10/28
Adiabatic Connection - Geometrical View
8/7/2019 adiabatic formalism
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/adiabatic-formalism 60/156
10/28
Adiabatic Connection - Geometrical View
8/7/2019 adiabatic formalism
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/adiabatic-formalism 61/156
10/28
Adiabatic Connection - Geometrical View
8/7/2019 adiabatic formalism
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/adiabatic-formalism 63/156
Adiabatic Connection - Geometrical View
8/7/2019 adiabatic formalism
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/adiabatic-formalism 64/156
10/28
Adiabatic Connection - Geometrical View
8/7/2019 adiabatic formalism
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/adiabatic-formalism 65/156
10/28
Adiabatic Connection - Geometrical View
8/7/2019 adiabatic formalism
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/adiabatic-formalism 66/156
10/28
Adiabatic Connection - Geometrical View
8/7/2019 adiabatic formalism
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/adiabatic-formalism 67/156
10/28
Calculation of Adiabatic Connection CurvesWe typically choose CC wavefunctions and to begin withd i h CC d i f ll i i h hi i
8/7/2019 adiabatic formalism
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/adiabatic-formalism 68/156
determine the CC density at full interaction strength this isthen reproduced for all values of λ
11/28
Calculation of Adiabatic Connection CurvesWe typically choose CC wavefunctions and to begin withd i h CC d i f ll i i h hi i
8/7/2019 adiabatic formalism
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/adiabatic-formalism 69/156
determine the CC density at full interaction strength this isthen reproduced for all values of λ
Our task is then to perform the maximization
F λ[ρ] = maxv
E λ[v ]−
ρλ=1(r)v (r)d r
= max
v [C λ[v ]]
11/28
8/7/2019 adiabatic formalism
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/adiabatic-formalism 70/156
Calculation of Adiabatic Connection CurvesWe typically choose CC wavefunctions and to begin withdetermine the CC densit at f ll interaction strength this is
8/7/2019 adiabatic formalism
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/adiabatic-formalism 71/156
determine the CC density at full interaction strength this isthen reproduced for all values of λ
Our task is then to perform the maximization
F λ[ρ] = maxv
E λ[v ]−
ρλ=1(r)v (r)d r
= max
v [C λ[v ]]
To do this we choose the following form for v
v (r) = v ext(r) + (1 − λ)v ref (r) +
t b t g t (r)
and use the known derivativesδC λδb t
=
[ρ(r)− ρλ=1(r)] g t (r)d r
H ut =
g u (r
)g t (r)δρ(r)
δv (r)d rd r
11/28
Calculation of Adiabatic Connection CurvesWe typically choose CC wavefunctions and to begin withdetermine the CC density at full interaction strength this is
8/7/2019 adiabatic formalism
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/adiabatic-formalism 72/156
determine the CC density at full interaction strength this isthen reproduced for all values of λ
Our task is then to perform the maximization
F λ[ρ] = maxv
E λ[v ]−
ρλ=1(r)v (r)d r
= max
v [C λ[v ]]
To do this we choose the following form for v
v (r) = v ext(r) + (1 − λ)v ref (r) +
t b t g t (r)
and use the known derivativesδC λδb t
=
[ρ(r)− ρλ=1(r)] g t (r)d r
H ut =
g u (r
)g t (r)δρ(r)
δv (r)d rd r
Once maximized the potential is the conjugate partner of thephysical density, at a chosen interaction strength
11/28
Calculating Adiabatic Connections
8/7/2019 adiabatic formalism
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/adiabatic-formalism 73/156
A. M. Teale, S. Coriani and T. U. Helgaker, (accepted JCP)
12/28
Application to Two Electron SystemsRepeating the optimization many times allows us to build upthe AC curve This allows us to determine E via
8/7/2019 adiabatic formalism
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/adiabatic-formalism 74/156
the AC curve. This allows us to determine E xc via
E xc = 1
0W xc,λd λ
13/28
Application to Two Electron SystemsRepeating the optimization many times allows us to build upthe AC curve This allows us to determine E via
8/7/2019 adiabatic formalism
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/adiabatic-formalism 75/156
the AC curve. This allows us to determine E xc via
E xc = 1
0W xc,λd λ
This may be compared with
E FCI xc = E FCI − T s − J − E ne − E nn
13/28
Application to Two Electron SystemsRepeating the optimization many times allows us to build upthe AC curve This allows us to determine E via
8/7/2019 adiabatic formalism
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/adiabatic-formalism 76/156
the AC curve. This allows us to determine E xc via
E xc = 1
0W xc,λd λ
This may be compared with
E FCI xc = E FCI − T s − J − E ne − E nn
The T s component is the only unknown part - this can beobtained from maximizing C [v ] at λ = 0 since F 0 = T s .
13/28
Application to Two Electron SystemsRepeating the optimization many times allows us to build upthe AC curve This allows us to determine E c via
8/7/2019 adiabatic formalism
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/adiabatic-formalism 77/156
the AC curve. This allows us to determine E xc via
E xc = 1
0W xc,λd λ
This may be compared with
E FCI xc = E FCI − T s − J − E ne − E nn
The T s component is the only unknown part - this can beobtained from maximizing C [v ] at λ = 0 since F 0 = T s .
In two electron systems it is also the von Weizsackerexpression (a simple functional of the FCI density)
T s[ρ(r)] = 18
|ρ(r)|ρ(r)
d r
13/28
Application to Two Electron SystemsRepeating the optimization many times allows us to build upthe AC curve This allows us to determine Exc via
8/7/2019 adiabatic formalism
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/adiabatic-formalism 78/156
the AC curve. This allows us to determine E xc via
E xc = 1
0W xc,λd λ
This may be compared with
E FCI xc = E FCI − T s − J − E ne − E nn
The T s component is the only unknown part - this can beobtained from maximizing C [v ] at λ = 0 since F 0 = T s .
In two electron systems it is also the von Weizsackerexpression (a simple functional of the FCI density)
T s[ρ(r)] = 18
|ρ(r)|ρ(r)
d r
To provide estimates of the basis set limit energies and ACcurves we apply basis set extrapolation techniques.
13/28
Application to Two Electron Systems: The H2 Molecule
Recently there has been interest in studying the AC of theprototypical H2 system
8/7/2019 adiabatic formalism
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/adiabatic-formalism 79/156
prototypical H2 system
M. Fuchs, Y.-M. Niquet, X. Gonze, and K. Burke, J. Chem. Phys., 122, 094116, (2005)
M. J. G. Peach, A. M. Teale and D. J. Tozer, J. Chem. Phys., 126, 244104, (2007)
14/28
Application to Two Electron Systems: The H2 Molecule
Recently there has been interest in studying the AC of theprototypical H2 system
8/7/2019 adiabatic formalism
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/adiabatic-formalism 80/156
prototypical H2 system
The dissociation of this molecule is difficult to describeproperly in DFT
M. Fuchs, Y.-M. Niquet, X. Gonze, and K. Burke, J. Chem. Phys., 122, 094116, (2005)
M. J. G. Peach, A. M. Teale and D. J. Tozer, J. Chem. Phys., 126, 244104, (2007)
14/28
Application to Two Electron Systems: The H2 Molecule
Recently there has been interest in studying the AC of theprototypical H2 system
8/7/2019 adiabatic formalism
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/adiabatic-formalism 81/156
prototypical H2 system
The dissociation of this molecule is difficult to describeproperly in DFT
The correct ground state wavefunction is a singlet at allinternuclear separations R
M. Fuchs, Y.-M. Niquet, X. Gonze, and K. Burke, J. Chem. Phys., 122, 094116, (2005)
M. J. G. Peach, A. M. Teale and D. J. Tozer, J. Chem. Phys., 126, 244104, (2007)
14/28
8/7/2019 adiabatic formalism
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/adiabatic-formalism 82/156
Application to Two Electron Systems: The H2 MoleculeRecently there has been interest in studying the AC of theprototypical H2 system
8/7/2019 adiabatic formalism
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/adiabatic-formalism 83/156
p yp 2 y
The dissociation of this molecule is difficult to describeproperly in DFT
The correct ground state wavefunction is a singlet at allinternuclear separations R
This is consistent with ρα(r) = ρβ (r) = ρ(r)/2 and can be
enforced in spin restricted calculationsHowever this gives very poor dissociation energies - these canbe fixed by using a spin unrestricted formalism
M. Fuchs, Y.-M. Niquet, X. Gonze, and K. Burke, J. Chem. Phys., 122, 094116, (2005)
M. J. G. Peach, A. M. Teale and D. J. Tozer, J. Chem. Phys., 126, 244104, (2007)
14/28
Application to Two Electron Systems: The H2 MoleculeRecently there has been interest in studying the AC of theprototypical H2 system
8/7/2019 adiabatic formalism
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/adiabatic-formalism 84/156
p yp 2 y
The dissociation of this molecule is difficult to describe
properly in DFT
The correct ground state wavefunction is a singlet at allinternuclear separations R
This is consistent with ρα(r) = ρβ (r) = ρ(r)/2 and can be
enforced in spin restricted calculationsHowever this gives very poor dissociation energies - these canbe fixed by using a spin unrestricted formalism
BUT the success comes at a price - the spin densities now
localize so that α is on one side, and β is on the other !
M. Fuchs, Y.-M. Niquet, X. Gonze, and K. Burke, J. Chem. Phys., 122, 094116, (2005)
M. J. G. Peach, A. M. Teale and D. J. Tozer, J. Chem. Phys., 126, 244104, (2007)
14/28
Application to Two Electron Systems: The H2 MoleculeRecently there has been interest in studying the AC of theprototypical H2 system
8/7/2019 adiabatic formalism
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/adiabatic-formalism 85/156
p yp y
The dissociation of this molecule is difficult to describe
properly in DFT
The correct ground state wavefunction is a singlet at allinternuclear separations R
This is consistent with ρα(r) = ρβ (r) = ρ(r)/2 and can be
enforced in spin restricted calculationsHowever this gives very poor dissociation energies - these canbe fixed by using a spin unrestricted formalism
BUT the success comes at a price - the spin densities now
localize so that α is on one side, and β is on the other !This is clearly unphysical at R = ∞ we should have two spinunpolarized H atoms
M. Fuchs, Y.-M. Niquet, X. Gonze, and K. Burke, J. Chem. Phys., 122, 094116, (2005)
M. J. G. Peach, A. M. Teale and D. J. Tozer, J. Chem. Phys., 126, 244104, (2007)
14/28
Application to Two Electron Systems: The H2 Molecule
8/7/2019 adiabatic formalism
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/adiabatic-formalism 86/156
15/28
Application to Two Electron Systems: The H2 Molecule
8/7/2019 adiabatic formalism
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/adiabatic-formalism 87/156
15/28
Application to Two Electron Systems: The H2 Molecule
8/7/2019 adiabatic formalism
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/adiabatic-formalism 88/156
15/28
Application to Two Electron Systems: The H2 Molecule
8/7/2019 adiabatic formalism
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/adiabatic-formalism 89/156
15/28
Application to Two Electron Systems: The H2 Molecule
8/7/2019 adiabatic formalism
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/adiabatic-formalism 90/156
16/28
Application to Two Electron Systems: The H2 Molecule
8/7/2019 adiabatic formalism
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/adiabatic-formalism 91/156
16/28
Application to Two Electron Systems: The H2 Molecule
8/7/2019 adiabatic formalism
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/adiabatic-formalism 92/156
16/28
Application to Two Electron Systems: The H2 Molecule
8/7/2019 adiabatic formalism
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/adiabatic-formalism 96/156
Application to Two Electron Systems: The H2 Molecule
8/7/2019 adiabatic formalism
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/adiabatic-formalism 97/156
As the electron-electron interactions are switched on thenature of the wavefunction changes from the KS singledeterminant to the real electronic wavefuntion
This is reflected in the one-electron density matrix. Althoughthe spatial density ρ(r) is fixed
17/28
8/7/2019 adiabatic formalism
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/adiabatic-formalism 98/156
Application to Two Electron Systems: The H2 Molecule
8/7/2019 adiabatic formalism
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/adiabatic-formalism 99/156
As the electron-electron interactions are switched on thenature of the wavefunction changes from the KS singledeterminant to the real electronic wavefuntion
This is reflected in the one-electron density matrix. Althoughthe spatial density ρ(r) is fixed
The eigenvectors / eigenvalues of the reduced one-electrondensity matrix are the natural orbitals / occupation numbers
We can examine the occupation numbers as a function of interaction strength to gauge how the wavefunction evolves
17/28
Application to Two Electron Systems: The H2 Molecule
8/7/2019 adiabatic formalism
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/adiabatic-formalism 100/156
18/28
Application to Two Electron Systems: The H2 Molecule
8/7/2019 adiabatic formalism
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/adiabatic-formalism 101/156
18/28
Application to Two Electron Systems: The H2 Molecule
8/7/2019 adiabatic formalism
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/adiabatic-formalism 102/156
18/28
Application to Two Electron Systems: The H2 Molecule
8/7/2019 adiabatic formalism
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/adiabatic-formalism 103/156
18/28
Application to Two Electron Systems: The H2 Molecule
8/7/2019 adiabatic formalism
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/adiabatic-formalism 104/156
18/28
Application to Two Electron Systems: The H2 Molecule
8/7/2019 adiabatic formalism
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/adiabatic-formalism 105/156
18/28
The Modified External PotentialThe potential was expanded as
v λ(r) = v ext(r) + (1− λ)v J(r) + v xc,λ(r)
8/7/2019 adiabatic formalism
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/adiabatic-formalism 106/156
= v ext(r) + (1− λ)v ref (r) +
t b t g t (r)
T. Heaton-Burgess, F. A. Bulat and W. Yang, Phy. Rev. Lett., 98, 256401, (2007)
19/28
8/7/2019 adiabatic formalism
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/adiabatic-formalism 107/156
The Modified External PotentialThe potential was expanded as
v λ(r) = v ext(r) + (1− λ)v J(r) + v xc,λ(r)
8/7/2019 adiabatic formalism
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/adiabatic-formalism 108/156
= v ext(r) + (1− λ)v ref (
r) +
t b t g t (
r)
The exchange–correlation contribution is then
v xc,λ(r) = (1 − λ)[v ref (r)− v J(r)] +
t b t g t (r)
For 2 electron systems we can also use v x (r) = −12v J (r) toget the correlation potential
v c,λ(r) = v xc,λ(r) +(1− λ)
2v J(r)
T. Heaton-Burgess, F. A. Bulat and W. Yang, Phy. Rev. Lett., 98, 256401, (2007)
19/28
The Modified External PotentialThe potential was expanded as
v λ(r) = v ext(r) + (1− λ)v J(r) + v xc,λ(r)
8/7/2019 adiabatic formalism
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/adiabatic-formalism 109/156
= v ext(r) + (1− λ)v ref (
r) +
t b t g t (
r)
The exchange–correlation contribution is then
v xc,λ(r) = (1 − λ)[v ref (r)− v J(r)] +
t b t g t (r)
For 2 electron systems we can also use v x (r) = −12v J (r) toget the correlation potential
v c,λ(r) = v xc,λ(r) +(1− λ)
2v J(r)
Whilst the potentials may not be unique in a finite basis apenalty function minimization can be performed to givesmooth potentials, changing W λ by less than 10−5 a.u.
T. Heaton-Burgess, F. A. Bulat and W. Yang, Phy. Rev. Lett., 98, 256401, (2007)
19/28
The Modified External Potential: v xc,λ(r)
8/7/2019 adiabatic formalism
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/adiabatic-formalism 110/156
20/28
The Modified External Potential: v xc,λ(r)
8/7/2019 adiabatic formalism
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/adiabatic-formalism 112/156
The Modified External Potential: v xc,λ(r)
8/7/2019 adiabatic formalism
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/adiabatic-formalism 113/156
20/28
The Modified External Potential: v xc,λ(r)
8/7/2019 adiabatic formalism
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/adiabatic-formalism 114/156
20/28
The Modified External Potential: v xc,λ(r)
8/7/2019 adiabatic formalism
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/adiabatic-formalism 115/156
20/28
The Modified External Potential: v xc,λ(r)
8/7/2019 adiabatic formalism
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/adiabatic-formalism 116/156
20/28
The Modified External Potential: v xc,λ(r)
8/7/2019 adiabatic formalism
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/adiabatic-formalism 117/156
20/28
The Modified External Potential: v xc,λ(r)
8/7/2019 adiabatic formalism
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/adiabatic-formalism 118/156
20/28
The Modified External Potential: v xc,λ(r)
8/7/2019 adiabatic formalism
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/adiabatic-formalism 119/156
20/28
The Modified External Potential: v xc,λ(r)
8/7/2019 adiabatic formalism
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/adiabatic-formalism 120/156
20/28
The Modified External Potential: v c,λ(r)
8/7/2019 adiabatic formalism
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/adiabatic-formalism 121/156
C Umrigar and X Gonze, Phys. Rev. A, 58, 3827, (1994)
21/28
The Modified External Potential: v c,λ(r)
8/7/2019 adiabatic formalism
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/adiabatic-formalism 122/156
C Umrigar and X Gonze, Phys. Rev. A, 58, 3827, (1994)
21/28
The Modified External Potential: v c,λ(r)
8/7/2019 adiabatic formalism
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/adiabatic-formalism 123/156
C Umrigar and X Gonze, Phys. Rev. A, 58, 3827, (1994)
21/28
The Modified External Potential: v c,λ(r)
8/7/2019 adiabatic formalism
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/adiabatic-formalism 124/156
C Umrigar and X Gonze, Phys. Rev. A, 58, 3827, (1994)
21/28
The Modified External Potential: v c,λ(r)
8/7/2019 adiabatic formalism
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/adiabatic-formalism 125/156
C Umrigar and X Gonze, Phys. Rev. A, 58, 3827, (1994)
21/28
The Modified External Potential: v c,λ(r)
8/7/2019 adiabatic formalism
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/adiabatic-formalism 126/156
C Umrigar and X Gonze, Phys. Rev. A, 58, 3827, (1994)
21/28
The Modified External Potential: v c,λ(r)
8/7/2019 adiabatic formalism
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/adiabatic-formalism 127/156
C Umrigar and X Gonze, Phys. Rev. A, 58, 3827, (1994)
21/28
8/7/2019 adiabatic formalism
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/adiabatic-formalism 128/156
The Modified External Potential: v c,λ(r)
8/7/2019 adiabatic formalism
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/adiabatic-formalism 129/156
C Umrigar and X Gonze, Phys. Rev. A, 58, 3827, (1994)
21/28
The Modified External Potential: v c,λ(r)
8/7/2019 adiabatic formalism
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/adiabatic-formalism 130/156
C Umrigar and X Gonze, Phys. Rev. A, 58, 3827, (1994)
21/28
The Modified External Potential: v c,λ(r)
8/7/2019 adiabatic formalism
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/adiabatic-formalism 131/156
C Umrigar and X Gonze, Phys. Rev. A, 58, 3827, (1994)
21/28
8/7/2019 adiabatic formalism
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/adiabatic-formalism 132/156
Building DFT Functionals Using the ACThe obvious motivation for studying the AC is to developimproved E xc functionals.
Simple forms for approximating W λ can be turned directly
into Exc functionals by integration
8/7/2019 adiabatic formalism
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/adiabatic-formalism 133/156
into E xc functionals by integration.
A. D. Becke, J. Chem. Phys., 98, 1372, (1993)M. Ernzerhof, Chem. Phys. Lett., 263, 499, (1996)
A. J. Cohen, P. Mori-Sanchez and W. Yang, J. Chem. Phys., 127, 034101, (2007)
22/28
8/7/2019 adiabatic formalism
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/adiabatic-formalism 135/156
Building DFT Functionals Using the ACThe obvious motivation for studying the AC is to developimproved E xc functionals.
Simple forms for approximating W λ can be turned directly
into Exc functionals by integration
8/7/2019 adiabatic formalism
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/adiabatic-formalism 136/156
into E functionals by integration.This idea has been followed before,
The Becke H&H funcitonal used linear interpolation with E xfor the W 0 and E LDAxc for W 1
Ernzerhof considered a Pade type form
A. D. Becke, J. Chem. Phys., 98, 1372, (1993)M. Ernzerhof, Chem. Phys. Lett., 263, 499, (1996)
A. J. Cohen, P. Mori-Sanchez and W. Yang, J. Chem. Phys., 127, 034101, (2007)
22/28
8/7/2019 adiabatic formalism
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/adiabatic-formalism 137/156
Building DFT Functionals Using the ACThe obvious motivation for studying the AC is to developimproved E xc functionals.
Simple forms for approximating W λ can be turned directly
into E xc functionals by integration.
8/7/2019 adiabatic formalism
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/adiabatic-formalism 138/156
into functionals by integration.This idea has been followed before,
The Becke H&H funcitonal used linear interpolation with E xfor the W 0 and E LDAxc for W 1
Ernzerhof considered a Pade type formMori-Sanchez, Cohen and Yang considered a variety of simpleforms
We investigated a variety of forms for H2 and the HeliumIsoelectronic series with the input parameters determined fromFCI data.
A. D. Becke, J. Chem. Phys., 98, 1372, (1993)M. Ernzerhof, Chem. Phys. Lett., 263, 499, (1996)
A. J. Cohen, P. Mori-Sanchez and W. Yang, J. Chem. Phys., 127, 034101, (2007)
22/28
Building DFT Functionals Using the ACTwo forms were found to give good performance for these twoelectron systems; A Pade type form and an Exponential form.
8/7/2019 adiabatic formalism
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/adiabatic-formalism 139/156
M. J. G. Peach, A. M. Teale and D. J. Tozer, J. Chem. Phys., 126, 244104, (2007)
M. J. G. Peach, A. M. Miller, A. M. Teale and D. J. Tozer, J. Chem. Phys., 129, 244104, (2008)
23/28
Building DFT Functionals Using the ACTwo forms were found to give good performance for these twoelectron systems; A Pade type form and an Exponential form.
The Pade type form is
W AC1xc λ = a + b λ
1 λ
8/7/2019 adiabatic formalism
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/adiabatic-formalism 140/156
xc,λ +1 + c λ
E AC1xc = a + b
c − loge (1 + c )
c 2
a = W xc,0 = E x
b = W xc,0 = E GL2c
c =W
xc,0
W xc,1 −W xc,0− 1
W xc,1 =
Ψ1 ˆW
Ψ1
− J
M. J. G. Peach, A. M. Teale and D. J. Tozer, J. Chem. Phys., 126, 244104, (2007)
M. J. G. Peach, A. M. Miller, A. M. Teale and D. J. Tozer, J. Chem. Phys., 129, 244104, (2008)
23/28
Building DFT Functionals Using the AC
The Exponential form is
W AC6xc,λ = a + b exp(c λ)
8/7/2019 adiabatic formalism
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/adiabatic-formalism 141/156
, p( )
E AC6xc = a +b
c (1− exp(−c ))
b (1− exp(W xc,0/b )) = W xc,0 −W xc,1
a = W xc,0 − b
c =W
xc,0
b
M. J. G. Peach, A. M. Miller, A. M. Teale and D. J. Tozer, J. Chem. Phys., 129, 244104, (2008)
24/28
Potential Energy Curves of H2 from Approximate FormsThe potential energy curves for the H2 molecule determinedwith accurate input parameters are
8/7/2019 adiabatic formalism
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/adiabatic-formalism 142/156
25/28
Potential Energy Curves of H2 from Approximate FormsThe potential energy curves for the H2 molecule determinedwith accurate input parameters are
8/7/2019 adiabatic formalism
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/adiabatic-formalism 143/156
25/28
Potential Energy Curves of H2 from Approximate FormsThe potential energy curves for the H2 molecule determinedwith accurate input parameters are
8/7/2019 adiabatic formalism
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/adiabatic-formalism 145/156
Comparison with the Accurate Integrand
8/7/2019 adiabatic formalism
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/adiabatic-formalism 146/156
A. M. Teale, S. Coriani, and T. U. Helgaker (accepted, JCP)
26/28
Comparison with the Accurate Integrand
8/7/2019 adiabatic formalism
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/adiabatic-formalism 147/156
A. M. Teale, S. Coriani, and T. U. Helgaker (accepted, JCP)
26/28
Comparison with the Accurate Integrand
8/7/2019 adiabatic formalism
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/adiabatic-formalism 148/156
A. M. Teale, S. Coriani, and T. U. Helgaker (accepted, JCP)
26/28
Comparison with the Accurate Integrand
8/7/2019 adiabatic formalism
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/adiabatic-formalism 149/156
A. M. Teale, S. Coriani, and T. U. Helgaker (accepted, JCP)
26/28
Comparison with the Accurate Integrand
8/7/2019 adiabatic formalism
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/adiabatic-formalism 150/156
A. M. Teale, S. Coriani, and T. U. Helgaker (accepted, JCP)
26/28
8/7/2019 adiabatic formalism
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/adiabatic-formalism 151/156
ConclusionsWe can calculate AC curves corresponding to accuratecoupled cluster wavefunctions
The resulting curves accurately reproduce the CC density and
the correct exchange–correlation energies
8/7/2019 adiabatic formalism
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/adiabatic-formalism 152/156
27/28
ConclusionsWe can calculate AC curves corresponding to accuratecoupled cluster wavefunctions
The resulting curves accurately reproduce the CC density and
the correct exchange–correlation energies
8/7/2019 adiabatic formalism
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/adiabatic-formalism 153/156
The direct optimization approach provides a rapidlyconvergent scheme, this is ensured by our calculation of thesecond derivative
27/28
ConclusionsWe can calculate AC curves corresponding to accuratecoupled cluster wavefunctions
The resulting curves accurately reproduce the CC density and
the correct exchange–correlation energies
Th di i i i h id idl
8/7/2019 adiabatic formalism
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/adiabatic-formalism 154/156
The direct optimization approach provides a rapidlyconvergent scheme, this is ensured by our calculation of thesecond derivative
The curves provide the missing link between constrainedsearch methods which provide the Kohn-Sham potential butno associated energy functional and approximate energyfunctionals suitable for practical use
27/28
Conclusions
We can calculate AC curves corresponding to accuratecoupled cluster wavefunctions
The resulting curves accurately reproduce the CC density and
the correct exchange–correlation energies
Th di i i i h id idl
8/7/2019 adiabatic formalism
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/adiabatic-formalism 155/156
The direct optimization approach provides a rapidlyconvergent scheme, this is ensured by our calculation of thesecond derivative
The curves provide the missing link between constrainedsearch methods which provide the Kohn-Sham potential butno associated energy functional and approximate energyfunctionals suitable for practical use
The curves determined are useful for understandingapproximate exchange–correlation forms and the developmentof new ones
27/28
Acknowledgements
Trygve Helgaker Sonia Coriani