8/9/2019 Korea Japan Business Ethics Hill English
1/42
The Importance of
Business Ethics Ned C. Hill, Dean
W. Steve Albrecht, Associate Dean
Marriott School of Management B righam Young University
2006
8/9/2019 Korea Japan Business Ethics Hill English
2/42
O utlineWhat is ethical behavior and why is itimportant to business?
The ethical value proposition Laws, policies and ethics Evidence that good ethics means good business
Is ethical behavior improving? Teaching ethicsthe E thics Maturity Model
8/9/2019 Korea Japan Business Ethics Hill English
3/42
Ethical Behavior
Conducting ones life in complete accordwith a firmly held set of values andprinciples
These principles may be derived from religious beliefs, philosophical understanding, etc.Application should be in all areas of ones life:
personal, family, business, social, etc. I ntegrity is the consistent application of ethical behavior.
8/9/2019 Korea Japan Business Ethics Hill English
4/42
8/9/2019 Korea Japan Business Ethics Hill English
5/42
Is There a Universal Ethical Standard?
A re you comfortable with a world withyour standards?
Christian principle: T he Golden RuleT he Golden Rule
Do unto others as you would have them do unto you. L uke 6:29-38Thou shalt love thy neighbor as thyself.
L uke 10:27
Yes I n Principle
8/9/2019 Korea Japan Business Ethics Hill English
6/42
Taught in All CulturesJ udaism: W hat you hate, do not do to anyone.slam: No one of you is a believer until he loves for his brother what he loves
for himself.Hinduism: Do nothing to thy neighbor which thou wouldst not have him do to
thee.Sikhism: Treat others as you would be treated yourself.Buddhism: Hurt not others with that which pains thyself.Confucius: W hat you do not want done to yourself, do not do to others.A
ristotle:W
e should behave to our friends as we wish our friends to behave tous.Plato: May I do to others as I would that they should do unto me.
T REA T PEOPLE TH E WAY YOU WAN T TH EM T O T REA T YOU
8/9/2019 Korea Japan Business Ethics Hill English
7/42
Bad Ethics Increases Transaction Costs
PartyA
PartyB
T rade
SecurityL awyers
Regulators
Delays
I nterestDuplication
T esting
E tc, etc!
8/9/2019 Korea Japan Business Ethics Hill English
8/42
Societal Costs of Unethical Behavior1. L aw enforcement and other security personnel2. Physical protection (locks, electronic security, fences,
vaults, etc.)3. A substantial portion of attorney and court system costs4. Some welfare costs5. Costs of collecting taxes6. Wasted/misused investment funds7. A substantial portion of accounting/auditing costs
8. A large fraction of costs for regulators and examiners9. Some marketing/advertising costs10.Costs for institutions like better business bureaus,
consumer protection agencies11.Some costs of bankruptcy
12.L ack of investment from outside investors, tourists
8/9/2019 Korea Japan Business Ethics Hill English
9/42
Business Costs of Unethical Behavior1. L oss of physical assets2. I ncreased costs of security
3. L oss of customersespecially those who value ethics4. L oss of employeesespecially the more ethical5. L oss of reputation6. I ncreased legal costs7. Higher costs of debt8. L oss of investor confidence (lower stock price, difficulty
in raising funds, problems with lenders)9. Regulatory intrusion10.Costs of bankruptcy
8/9/2019 Korea Japan Business Ethics Hill English
10/42
W hat is the Cost of Lack ofIntegrity in the US?
Employee fraud $400 B Time theft $230 B Industrial espionage $200 B
Counterfeiting $200 B Employee dishonesty $120 B Identity theft $ 50 B
(Quoted in Stephen R. Coveys preface to B usiness with Integrity, p. xx)
8/9/2019 Korea Japan Business Ethics Hill English
11/42
Levels of Constraints on Behavior
E thical B ehavior T ied to Set
of Values
Professional Standards
L egal Requirements
8/9/2019 Korea Japan Business Ethics Hill English
12/42
Ethical Issues Relating to BusinessHonestycommunication and behavior consistent with facts
Disclosure of information Promises/commitments L aws and professional standards
Representation of others like shareholders (applies to board members)Unfair competition Refrain from bribes and excessive gifts (that sway judgment) Avoid quid pro quo transaction Comply with anti-trust laws (these relate to pricing, monopolistic practices)
J ust compensation Respect intellectual property (product piracy) T reat employees fairly
Respecting rights of others T reat others with fairness and respect regardless of age, religion, ethnic group,
sex, economic status, etc., especially children, women, and subordinates Respect the community you operate in by paying fair share of economic costs
you create
Respect others and future generations by treating the environment well
8/9/2019 Korea Japan Business Ethics Hill English
13/42
W hy Ethical Behavior Adds ValueBetter information T rust from investors L ower costs for audits, controls, investigations
B etter allocation of resources Customers will be more loyal (RC Willey example) L ower costs from suppliers (automotive company
example) Attracting and retaining better employees
Fair competition L owers cost of business in economy L eads to better decision-making (do whats best for
firm, not one individual)
I mproves competitive nature of a countrys economy
8/9/2019 Korea Japan Business Ethics Hill English
14/42
W hy Ethical Behavior Adds ValueJ ust compensation Creates a more vibrant, entrepreneurial economy
Attracts and retains better employeesRights of others Draws upon talents of wider set of individuals Develops long-term respect from the community
(Godfrey study) Maintains the environment for long-term value to all
(Costa Rica)
Its the right thing to do!
8/9/2019 Korea Japan Business Ethics Hill English
15/42
Is There Evidence that Ethical BehaviorYields Increased Value?1.Study of 2,100 firms with very strong,
well-governed boards of directors
outperformed overall market 15% vs. 12.5%in 20052.Firms with high level of democracy
outperformed dictatorial firms by 8% per
year in the decade of the 1990s.3. Philanthropy: Firms that contribute ahigher portion of their assets to thecommunities in which they reside fare
better in an economic downturn.
8/9/2019 Korea Japan Business Ethics Hill English
16/42
H ow Important is Integrity in a Leader?
In a survey of 54,000 people Integrity was by far the number one attribute desired ina leader
(Quoted in Stephen R. Coveys preface to B usiness with Integrity, p. xx)
8/9/2019 Korea Japan Business Ethics Hill English
17/42
Short-Term vs. Long-Term
O ne party may gain temporary advantage by unethical behavior E nron L ivedoor Ghana Airways
But in the long-term, individuals,companies and society are hurt
8/9/2019 Korea Japan Business Ethics Hill English
18/42
Q uestionable State of O ur Integrity
Did You Cheat to Get Into Graduate School?
Yes 43% L iberal Arts 52% E ducation
63%L
aw and Medicine 75% B usiness
Source: Rutgers University survey of students
8/9/2019 Korea Japan Business Ethics Hill English
19/42
Q uestionable State of O ur Integrity
MB As
76% were willing to understate expenses that cutinto their companies profits Nearly all believe shareholder value is moreimportant than customer service
Convicts in 11 minimum security prisons hadhigher scores on an ethical dilemma exam thanMB As
8/9/2019 Korea Japan Business Ethics Hill English
20/42
Q uestionable Integrity at W ork
76% of employees observed a high level of illegal or unethical conduct at work in the
past 12 months49% of employees observed misconduct
that, if revealed, would cause their firms to significantly lose public trust
KPMG 2000 O rganizational Integrity Survey
8/9/2019 Korea Japan Business Ethics Hill English
21/42
Survey of EmployeesMost (65%) dont report ethical problemsthey observe96% feared being accused of not being ateam player 81% feared corrective action would not betaken anyway68% feared retribution from their supervisors
Source: Society of Human Resource Management
8/9/2019 Korea Japan Business Ethics Hill English
22/42
D eterioration in H onesty over Time
Y ear Y ear
College students who cheated in H.S. 1940 (20%) 2002 (75-98%)Self-reported cheating 1983 (11%) 1993 (49%)B elieve cheating is common 1940 (20%) 1997 (88%)Used cheat sheets 1969 (34%) 1989 (68%)L et others copy work 1969 (58%) 1989 (98%)Willing to lie to get job 2000 (28%) 2002 (39%)Students who had stolen 2000 (35%) 2002 (38%)
(B ased on several different ethics studies)
8/9/2019 Korea Japan Business Ethics Hill English
23/42
Another Study of Student H onestyResponses 50,000 college students at 69 schools26% of business majors admitted to serious cheating onexams
54% admitted to cheating on written assignments Journalism majors were worse with 27% admitting tocheating on exams.
The most honeststudents in the sciences (19% reportedcheating on tests)
Author observescheating has increased since he begandoing surveys 15 years ago
He partly blames technologymakes it easier to cheat
B iz Majors Get an F for Honesty by Donald McCabe published on February
6, 2006, by the Center for AcademicIntegrity
8/9/2019 Korea Japan Business Ethics Hill English
24/42
W ill O ur Ethics Improve?S urvey of High S chool S tudents
74% (71%) cheated on an exam in the last year;45% (45%) said they did it at least twice in the lastyear 93% (92%) lied to their parents in the past year;79% (79%) say they lied twice78% (78%) have lied to their teachers37% (27%) said they would lie to get a job38% (35%) took something from a store in the lastyear
J osephson (2002)(2001)
2002 2001
8/9/2019 Korea Japan Business Ethics Hill English
25/42
8/9/2019 Korea Japan Business Ethics Hill English
26/42
W hy Is D ishonesty Increasing?Bad Modeling/Lack of Good Modeling Makes up our news
more explicit than ever Focus of T V/movies Dishonest leaders Sports, business,
entertainment heroes Good models are rare
Lack of PositiveLabeling Home.average
family spends 10 hoursless time together aweek than 20 years ago
Vocabulary of
kindergarten children Schools Churches
8/9/2019 Korea Japan Business Ethics Hill English
27/42
Confession of Fraudulent Executive Even when put in jail, I didnt feel like a criminal. I
somehow felt we were different and I started noticingevery white collar guy I did talk to began every sentencewith: all I did was. O nce youre in jail and you startfeeling the animosity the other prisoners have towardwhite-collar guys, where they say to you, youre nodifferent than us, youre just a thief, you use other words. E ven the word embezzlement is a nicewordthey said youre a thief, you lie to people and taketheir money, thats what I do to and that hit me like a tonof bricks.
Mike Morze, ZZZZ B est
8/9/2019 Korea Japan Business Ethics Hill English
28/42
Can Ethical Values be Taught?Level 1: The Foundation
Personal Ethical UnderstandingRight/wrong, Fairness, Honesty, Personal Integrity, Respect for Others
8/9/2019 Korea Japan Business Ethics Hill English
29/42
P ersonal Ethical Understanding
Concepts of right and wrong, fair play, respectfor rights of others, honesty, personal integrity
Best learned in the home at an early ageandfollow-up is needed throughout life
Institutions (churches, schools, etc.) can helpDifficult to back fill in adulthood
8/9/2019 Korea Japan Business Ethics Hill English
30/42
A pplication of Ethics to Business SituationsFraudulent Practices, Misleading Advertising, Unfairness
Level 2: Application to Business
Personal Ethical UnderstandingRight/wrong, Fairness, Honesty, Personal Integrity, Respect for Others
8/9/2019 Korea Japan Business Ethics Hill English
31/42
Application of Ethics to BusinessSituationsFraudulent practices, misleading advertising,unfairness
Can be taught in management education andorganizationsprovided students have a personalunderstanding of ethics
Taught by modeling (cases and personal exampleare helpful)Can be reinforced by policies, codes of ethics,training
8/9/2019 Korea Japan Business Ethics Hill English
32/42
Application of Ethics to BusinessSituations
Businesses can teach through proper modeling:
Companies also have to further strengthen ethicsmanagement and social responsibility activities toimprove their public image
Korean Commerce- Industry- E nergy Minister L ee Hee-beom
8/9/2019 Korea Japan Business Ethics Hill English
33/42
Ethical CourageWillingness to Pay the Price for Ethics
A pplication of Ethics to Business SituationsFraudulent Practices, Misleading Advertising, Unfairness
Level 3: Ethical Courage
Personal Ethical UnderstandingRight/wrong, Fairness, Honesty, Personal Integrity, Respect for Others
8/9/2019 Korea Japan Business Ethics Hill English
34/42
Ethical Courage
It is not sufficient to simply understand ethical
principles O ne must have the courage to pay a price for being ethical
Examples can be helpfulcase studies showing people willing to stand up for ethical principlesAgain, it helps to have practiced ethical
behavior over many yearsespecially in smallthings
8/9/2019 Korea Japan Business Ethics Hill English
35/42
Ethical LeadershipHelping Others to be Ethical
Ethical CourageWillingness to Pay the Price for Ethics
A pplication of Ethics to Business SituationsFraudulent Practices, Misleading Advertising, Unfairness
Level 4: Ethical Leadership
Personal Ethical UnderstandingRight/wrong, Fairness, Honesty, Personal Integrity, Respect for Others
8/9/2019 Korea Japan Business Ethics Hill English
36/42
Ethical Leadership The ability and willingness to encourage others to behave ethically
Can be taught through cases, problem solving,study of successful organizations
Includes Developing an organizational climate that fosters
ethical behavior Structuring policies that encourages ethics B ehaving ethically while facing the pressures of
leadership
8/9/2019 Korea Japan Business Ethics Hill English
37/42
The Importance of Ethical Leadership
Swing GroupCould Go E ither Way
Dishonest EmployeesPolicies Wont Help Much
Honest EmployeesWill be Honest Always
Ethical Leadership will significantly impact anorganization since the vast majority, in this view,
can be influenced to behave ethically.
8/9/2019 Korea Japan Business Ethics Hill English
38/42
Importance of Ethical Leadership
Swing GroupCould Go E ither Way
Dishonest EmployeesPolicies Wont Help Much
Honest EmployeesWill be Honest Always
Strong Ethical Leadership induces the middlegroup to behave as if they were the honest
employees.
8/9/2019 Korea Japan Business Ethics Hill English
39/42
Importance of Ethical Leadership
Swing GroupCould Go E ither Way
Dishonest EmployeesPolicies Wont Help Much
Honest EmployeesWill be Honest Always
Weak Ethical Leadership permits the middlegroup to behave as if they were the dishonest
employees.
8/9/2019 Korea Japan Business Ethics Hill English
40/42
W hich W ay W illYour O rganization
Swing?
8/9/2019 Korea Japan Business Ethics Hill English
41/42
Good Ethics MeansGood Business
8/9/2019 Korea Japan Business Ethics Hill English
42/42
Questions?
Top Related