7/30/2019 Fitzgerald Marine Reserve: Dardenelle Trail
1/41
7/30/2019 Fitzgerald Marine Reserve: Dardenelle Trail
2/41
June
2,
2010
7/30/2019 Fitzgerald Marine Reserve: Dardenelle Trail
3/41
7/30/2019 Fitzgerald Marine Reserve: Dardenelle Trail
4/41
Fitzgerald
Marine
Reserve
Oct.
18,
2012
7/30/2019 Fitzgerald Marine Reserve: Dardenelle Trail
5/41
7/30/2019 Fitzgerald Marine Reserve: Dardenelle Trail
6/41
1/4miletrail Oct. 18,2012
7/30/2019 Fitzgerald Marine Reserve: Dardenelle Trail
7/41
June
2,
2010
7/30/2019 Fitzgerald Marine Reserve: Dardenelle Trail
8/41
7/30/2019 Fitzgerald Marine Reserve: Dardenelle Trail
9/41
June
2,
2010
7/30/2019 Fitzgerald Marine Reserve: Dardenelle Trail
10/41
ConstructioncouldhavebeenrestrictedtouseofaBobcatorothersmallequipmentinthebid
packageandCountyParksplannerscouldhave
reducedtheareatobedisturbedwhentheCounty
PlanningCommissionreducedthetrailwidth.Instead
Parks
contracted
with
a
local
paving
companythatoperatesheavyroadgrading/
pavingequipmenttodevelopthetrail/bridge.
FitzgeraldMarineReserve
DardenelleTrailProject
7/30/2019 Fitzgerald Marine Reserve: Dardenelle Trail
11/41
Oct.
18,
2012
7/30/2019 Fitzgerald Marine Reserve: Dardenelle Trail
12/41
June
2,
2010
3-4wide
7/30/2019 Fitzgerald Marine Reserve: Dardenelle Trail
13/41
Oct.
18,
2012
7/30/2019 Fitzgerald Marine Reserve: Dardenelle Trail
14/41
Theextensivegradingmobilizationbegan
thisfall,thetimingpairedupperfectlywith
therainyseason,andleftmassiveareasof
exposed
soil
to
wash
into
San
Vicente
Creek.Thisalreadyimpairedcreekshouldbeprotectedfrominappropriatelytimed
grading
projects.
Whyweren'tseasonalweatherconditionsfactoredintotheconstructionschedule?
FitzgeraldMarineReserve
DardenelleTrailProject
7/30/2019 Fitzgerald Marine Reserve: Dardenelle Trail
15/41
7/30/2019 Fitzgerald Marine Reserve: Dardenelle Trail
16/41
June
2,
2010
Theproximityofthepondtothetrail
wasnotconsideredbytheCounty,
andthereforenotconsideredbythe
Commissionstafeither.
DardenelleTrail
7/30/2019 Fitzgerald Marine Reserve: Dardenelle Trail
17/41
TheFitzgeraldMarineReserveishome
totheCaliforniaRed-leggedFrog
Oct
31,
2012
7/30/2019 Fitzgerald Marine Reserve: Dardenelle Trail
18/41
During
grading
a
California
Red-legged
frog
was
identifiedattheFMR. Itappearsthatendangeredwildlifemayhavebeendisplacedbythefrogandsnake
exclusion
fencing
along
the
perimeter
oftheDardenelleTrailconstructionzone. The
fencingisstillinplacealthoughworkonthe
projecthasstopped.
WrittenconcernsabouttheCRLFhavebeen
emailedtotheCounty. To-datenoreplyhas
beenprovided.
FitzgeraldMarineReserve
DardenelleTrailProject
7/30/2019 Fitzgerald Marine Reserve: Dardenelle Trail
19/41
7/30/2019 Fitzgerald Marine Reserve: Dardenelle Trail
20/41
June
2,
2010
7/30/2019 Fitzgerald Marine Reserve: Dardenelle Trail
21/41
Theextensivegradingmobilizationbegan
thisfall,thetimingpairedupperfectlywith
therainyseason,andleftmassiveareasof
exposed
soil
to
wash
into
San
Vicente
Creek.Thisalreadyimpairedcreekshouldbeprotectedfrominappropriatelytimed
grading
projects.
Whyweren'tseasonalweatherconditionsfactoredintotheconstructionschedule?
FitzgeraldMarineReserve
DardenelleTrailProject
7/30/2019 Fitzgerald Marine Reserve: Dardenelle Trail
22/41
Oct.
18,
2012
7/30/2019 Fitzgerald Marine Reserve: Dardenelle Trail
23/41
June
2,
2010
7/30/2019 Fitzgerald Marine Reserve: Dardenelle Trail
24/41
7/30/2019 Fitzgerald Marine Reserve: Dardenelle Trail
25/41
DARDENELLE
FITZGERALDMARINERESERVE
7/30/2019 Fitzgerald Marine Reserve: Dardenelle Trail
26/41
June
2,
20103-4
wide
7/30/2019 Fitzgerald Marine Reserve: Dardenelle Trail
27/41
Oct.
18,
2012
7/30/2019 Fitzgerald Marine Reserve: Dardenelle Trail
28/41
Oct.
25,
2012
7/30/2019 Fitzgerald Marine Reserve: Dardenelle Trail
29/41
Nov.
25,
2012
7/30/2019 Fitzgerald Marine Reserve: Dardenelle Trail
30/41
Dec.
2,
2012Failed
exclusion
netting
and
erosion
fencing.
7/30/2019 Fitzgerald Marine Reserve: Dardenelle Trail
31/41
7/30/2019 Fitzgerald Marine Reserve: Dardenelle Trail
32/41
Dec.
2,
2012
Failedexclusionnettinganderosionfencing.
7/30/2019 Fitzgerald Marine Reserve: Dardenelle Trail
33/41
TheDardenelleTrail/Bridgeprojectplansdidnot
adequatelyaddresshydrology,andthesegmentof
theDardenelleTrailthatcrossestheseasonalcreek(nearthebridge)willcontinuetohaveerosionproblems. Thephotosoffailederosionfencing
documentrunofcarryingdebrisintothecreek.
Writtenconcernsaboutrainyseasongrading,
seasonalcreekrunof,andhydrologyhavebeenemailedtotheCounty.
FitzgeraldMarineReserve
DardenelleTrailProject
7/30/2019 Fitzgerald Marine Reserve: Dardenelle Trail
34/41
SanMateoCountyProjectPlans
DrainageisnotdiscussedinExhibit
No.
2,
detail
3
of
the
DardenelleTrailProjectPlans(page8of8)
7/30/2019 Fitzgerald Marine Reserve: Dardenelle Trail
35/41
Dec.
2,
2012
Failedexclusionnetting
anderosionfencing.
7/30/2019 Fitzgerald Marine Reserve: Dardenelle Trail
36/41
Failedexclusionnettinganderosionfencing.
7/30/2019 Fitzgerald Marine Reserve: Dardenelle Trail
37/41
Followingrecentwinterstormsthetide-poolareaonthenorthsideandadjacenttothe
mouthofSanVicenteCreekhadextremelymurkydarkbrownturbidwater,thatlookstobeinveryfinesuspension(claysize,finerthan
sand/silt).
WhydidSanMateoCountyParksplanners
allowcontractorstoleavethesiteunfinished
forweeksfollowingtheinitialmobilization?
FitzgeraldMarineReserve
DardenelleTrailProject
7/30/2019 Fitzgerald Marine Reserve: Dardenelle Trail
38/41
Oct.
25,
2012San
Vicente
Creek
7/30/2019 Fitzgerald Marine Reserve: Dardenelle Trail
39/41
Dec.
2,
2012San
Vicente
Creek
7/30/2019 Fitzgerald Marine Reserve: Dardenelle Trail
40/41
The2002FitzgeraldMarineReserveMasterPlan
recognizedthearea'srichnaturalresources
throughitsguidingprinciples:
"Thefundamentalconceptunderlyingthe
MasterPlanisthatprotectionofthe
outstandingnaturalresourcesoftheFitzgerald
MarineReserve
will
require
a
new
approach
to
managementofecologicalsystemsandvisitors
infutureyears,andthebestwaytoaccomplish
thisgoalistoemphasizethesensitivityofthe
resource,toenhancetheeducationalvalueof
theReserve,tomanagevisitation,andtolimit
useoftheReserveasarecreationdestination."
7/30/2019 Fitzgerald Marine Reserve: Dardenelle Trail
41/41
Thankyou
www.PelicansEye.comSabrinaBrennan
Dec. 13,2012
AppealA-2-SMC-11-010
http://www.pelicanseye.com/http://www.pelicanseye.com/http://www.pelicanseye.com/http://www.pelicanseye.com/http://www.pelicanseye.com/http://www.pelicanseye.com/http://www.pelicanseye.com/http://www.pelicanseye.com/http://www.pelicanseye.com/http://www.pelicanseye.com/Top Related