Chapter 3Chapter 3
An Introduction to An Introduction to Competitive AdvantageCompetitive Advantage
Chapter 3Chapter 3
An Introduction to An Introduction to Competitive AdvantageCompetitive Advantage
Copyright © 1999 by Harcourt Brace & Company
All rights reserved. Requests for permission to make copies of any part of the work should be mailed to the following address: Permissions Department, Harcourt Brace & Company, 6277 Sea Harbor Drive, Orlando, Florida 32887-6777.
Bourgeois, Duhaime,
& Stimpert
Copyright © 1999 by Harcourt Brace & CompanyAll rights reserved
PrefacePrefacePrefacePreface
The model shown in Exhibit 3.1 suggests that managers must make four types of strategic decisions: Define or position their firms in their competitive
environments based on their understandings of industry structure and dynamics.
Develop a business strategy based on their beliefs about how to compete in their firms’ industries.
Copyright © 1999 by Harcourt Brace & CompanyAll rights reserved
Preface Preface (cont.)(cont.)Preface Preface (cont.)(cont.)
Develop a corporate strategy based on their beliefs about the appropriate scale and scope for their firms, their understandings of how their firms’ businesses are related, and the beliefs about how diversification should be managed.
Create an organizational structure based on their beliefs about how to organize a business firm that will allow them to implement their firms’ strategies.
Copyright © 1999 by Harcourt Brace & CompanyAll rights reserved
Exhibit 3.1:Exhibit 3.1: Model of Model of Strategic ManagementStrategic ManagementExhibit 3.1:Exhibit 3.1: Model of Model of Strategic ManagementStrategic Management
Feedbackreinforces or
suggests changes
in managers'
mental models
Managers' Mental Models
+ Industry environments + How to compete
+ Appropriate size/diversity,
how businesses are related,
how diversification should
be managed
+ How to organize
Decisions about Business Definition
Decisions about
Organizational
Structure
Decisions about
Business Strategy
Decisions aboutCorporate Strategyand Diversification
Market Position,Resources, and
Capabilities
Performanceand
CompetitiveAdvantage
Copyright © 1999 by Harcourt Brace & CompanyAll rights reserved
Chapter ObjectivesChapter ObjectivesChapter ObjectivesChapter Objectives
Provide definition and describe characteristics associated with competitive advantage.
Describe how organizations develop and maintain competitive advantage.
Distinguish between content and process. Emphasize importance of organizational processes
in developing and maintaining competitive advantage.
Copyright © 1999 by Harcourt Brace & CompanyAll rights reserved
Chapter Objectives Chapter Objectives (cont.)(cont.)Chapter Objectives Chapter Objectives (cont.)(cont.)
Introduce concept of value chain and describe its usefulness as tool for assessing organizational capabilities.
Emphasize importance of socially complex resources. For example, trust, culture, and reputation --
based on interpersonal relationships among managers, employees, customers, and suppliers.
Copyright © 1999 by Harcourt Brace & CompanyAll rights reserved
Chapter Objectives Chapter Objectives (cont.)(cont.)Chapter Objectives Chapter Objectives (cont.)(cont.)
Emphasize that any source of competitive advantage can be rendered obsolete very quickly by changes in firms’ competitive environments.
Copyright © 1999 by Harcourt Brace & CompanyAll rights reserved
IntroductionIntroductionIntroductionIntroduction What is competitive advantage?
Set of factors or capabilities that allows firms to consistently outperform their rivals.
Second objective is to allow firms to enjoy sustained levels of high performance.
How is firm performance assessed? Financial performance
• Net income
• Gross margin
• Various ratios: return on sales, return on assets, and return on equity.
Copyright © 1999 by Harcourt Brace & CompanyAll rights reserved
Introduction Introduction (cont.)(cont.)Introduction Introduction (cont.)(cont.)
Stock market performance measures• One- and five-year market returns.
• Earnings per share (EPS)
• Price/earnings ratio (P/E) Market share Others
• Retailing: sales per square foot of retailing space.
• Banking: net interest earned.
• “Cycle time” and “time to market”– Time it takes to get new product ideas into production and
available for consumer purchase.
Copyright © 1999 by Harcourt Brace & CompanyAll rights reserved
Introduction Introduction (cont.)(cont.)Introduction Introduction (cont.)(cont.)
Others (cont.)• Customer perceptions of quality and business reputation.
Certain accounting items, such as “extraordinary items” or a series of restructuring charges over a period of several years can have positive or negative impact on a firm’s performance.
Source of performance measurement data.• Annual reports.
• Company 10Ks
• S&P’s Industry Surveys and Moody’s Manuals.
Copyright © 1999 by Harcourt Brace & CompanyAll rights reserved
Introduction Introduction (cont.)(cont.)Introduction Introduction (cont.)(cont.)
Competitive advantage: importance of firm-specific factors and capabilities. Strategies affect performance through the
development of firm-specific factors, capabilities, and competencies that are sources of competitive advantage.
• Business definitions or market positions.
• Strategies.
• Organizational structures.
Copyright © 1999 by Harcourt Brace & CompanyAll rights reserved
Introduction Introduction (cont.)(cont.)Introduction Introduction (cont.)(cont.)
Two studies reported that firms in the same industry pursuing the same strategies had widely varying levels of performance.
One way to explore the firm-specific factors through the “resource-based view of the firm.”
• Suggests firms can be viewed as collections of productive resources.
• Competitive advantage will be determined by capabilities firms bring to their competitive arenas.
– More important than industry-specific factors.
Copyright © 1999 by Harcourt Brace & CompanyAll rights reserved
Criteria which Determine whether Criteria which Determine whether Resources and Capabilities Can Resources and Capabilities Can Provide Firms with Competitive Provide Firms with Competitive AdvantageAdvantage
Criteria which Determine whether Criteria which Determine whether Resources and Capabilities Can Resources and Capabilities Can Provide Firms with Competitive Provide Firms with Competitive AdvantageAdvantage
Resource-based theory suggests that firms will enjoy a sustained competitive advantage only if their capabilities are valuable and rare, lack substitutes, and are difficult to imitate.
SeeExhibit
3.2
Copyright © 1999 by Harcourt Brace & CompanyAll rights reserved
Asymmetric Nature of Asymmetric Nature of Competitive Competitive AdvantageAdvantage
Asymmetric Nature of Asymmetric Nature of Competitive Competitive AdvantageAdvantage
Asymmetry is essential characteristic of competitive advantage. To enjoy a competitive advantage, a firm must do
what its rivals cannot do, or alternatively, if it does what its rivals can do, then it must do it better.
Any resource or capability will only contribute to development of competitive advantage if it is associated with “barriers” that prevent its acquisition or replication by competitors.
Copyright © 1999 by Harcourt Brace & CompanyAll rights reserved
Challenge of Challenge of Defending Against Defending Against ImitationImitation
Challenge of Challenge of Defending Against Defending Against ImitationImitation
More difficult in our society due to accessibility of information.
Studies have shown that ideas and innovation are diffused through the economy in the “S-shaped curve” as illustrated in Exhibit 3.3 on following slide. For a relatively brief time, from t0 to t1, innovations
may be proprietary to one or just a few firms.• The value of innovation will contribute to competitive
advantage only until the diffusion process begins (at t1 in this case).
Copyright © 1999 by Harcourt Brace & CompanyAll rights reserved
Exhibit 3.3:Exhibit 3.3: Diffusion of Diffusion of InnovationsInnovationsExhibit 3.3:Exhibit 3.3: Diffusion of Diffusion of InnovationsInnovations
t1 t2 Time0
100
Percentage of Firms Adopting
the Innovation
Copyright © 1999 by Harcourt Brace & CompanyAll rights reserved
Preventing ImitationPreventing ImitationPreventing ImitationPreventing Imitation
Patents. Exclusive rights for 17 years. Risk of competitor engineering around patent.
Exclusive access to key resources or assets. Litigation
Copyright © 1999 by Harcourt Brace & CompanyAll rights reserved
Developing Developing Competitive Competitive AdvantageAdvantage
Developing Developing Competitive Competitive AdvantageAdvantage
Competitive advantage most likely to result from development of unique capabilities that are acquired through an on-going process of resource accumulation. Five factors contribute to resource accumulation
process:• Time
• Building on past success
• Interconnectedness of capabilities
• Investment
• Casual ambiguity
Copyright © 1999 by Harcourt Brace & CompanyAll rights reserved
TimeTimeTimeTime
Firm that builds a resource or capability through investments over many years may enjoy significant advantage over firms that attempt to replicate that capability through larger investments made over a shorter period of time. Value of time is directly related to extent of
learning that occurs.
Copyright © 1999 by Harcourt Brace & CompanyAll rights reserved
Building on Past Building on Past SuccessSuccessBuilding on Past Building on Past SuccessSuccess
“Success breeds success.” History of accomplishments makes it easier for
firms to enjoy future success.• Will have more discretionary resources which can
be reinvested to expand their businesses.
• Their reputations for success will also help them attract more assets and resources.
• Venture capital tends to flow to start-up firms that have managers with proven track records.
• Firms on more successful paths will almost always have better array of options.
Copyright © 1999 by Harcourt Brace & CompanyAll rights reserved
Interconnectedness of Interconnectedness of Asset StocksAsset StocksInterconnectedness of Interconnectedness of Asset StocksAsset Stocks
Ability to augment a particular resource or capability may be tied to or depend on the strength or value of other capabilities. Customer service and information from field
regarding future product requirements. R&D capabilities and marketing skills (in
pharmaceutical industry). Computer operating systems and software
program sales (Microsoft).
Copyright © 1999 by Harcourt Brace & CompanyAll rights reserved
InvestmentInvestmentInvestmentInvestment
Important for two reasons: Investments are primary method for developing
capabilities. Resources and capabilities must be replenished if
they are to continue to serve as sources of competitive advantage.
Copyright © 1999 by Harcourt Brace & CompanyAll rights reserved
Casual AmbiguityCasual AmbiguityCasual AmbiguityCasual Ambiguity
Likelihood of maintaining sustained competitive advantage is greatly enhanced if resources and capabilities are shrouded in casual ambiguity. If competitors are unable to determine how or why
another firm is enjoying a competitive advantage, this will greatly complicate their efforts to imitate the high-performing firm’s success.
Copyright © 1999 by Harcourt Brace & CompanyAll rights reserved
How Firms Develop How Firms Develop Competitive Advantage - Competitive Advantage - SummarySummary
How Firms Develop How Firms Develop Competitive Advantage - Competitive Advantage - SummarySummary
Exhibit 3.4 on following slide contains a conceptual flow chart with questions each firm should ask itself when assessing competitive advantage.
U.S. automakers have imitated techniques of their Japanese competitors, yet the Big Three continue to lag behind Toyota and Honda in many capabilities. Imitation did not result in gaining a competitive
advantage.
Copyright © 1999 by Harcourt Brace & CompanyAll rights reserved
Exhibit 3.4:Exhibit 3.4: Competitive Competitive Advantage: A Flow ChartAdvantage: A Flow ChartExhibit 3.4:Exhibit 3.4: Competitive Competitive Advantage: A Flow ChartAdvantage: A Flow Chart
Does the firm do what other firms cannot
do?
Does the firm do what other firms can do, but does it do
better?
Asymmetry
Valuable? Rare? Lack substitutes?
+ Developed over time + Based on past success + Interconnectedness + Investment + Causal ambiguity
Difficult to imitate?
Competitive Advantage
Copyright © 1999 by Harcourt Brace & CompanyAll rights reserved
Specific Routes to Specific Routes to Developing Competitive Developing Competitive AdvantageAdvantage
Specific Routes to Specific Routes to Developing Competitive Developing Competitive AdvantageAdvantage
Competitive advantage will not happen without a strategy. Four ways a firm may gain competitive advantage:
• Business definition and positioning.
• Business strategy.
• Corporate strategy.
• Organizational structure.
Copyright © 1999 by Harcourt Brace & CompanyAll rights reserved
Business DefinitionBusiness DefinitionBusiness DefinitionBusiness Definition
Will be covered in further detail in Chapter 6. Business definition answers the “Who,” “What,” and
“How” questions. Describes the customer preferences that the firm
aims to meet, the specific products/services it will provide, and the technologies it will employ to deliver those products/services.
Competitive advantage can be achieved if one’s definition allows it to occupy a unique position in its industry.
• Harley -Davidson.
Copyright © 1999 by Harcourt Brace & CompanyAll rights reserved
Business StrategyBusiness StrategyBusiness StrategyBusiness Strategy
For most firms, competitive advantage depends on being able to to do what other firms also do, but doing it better than they do. Gap Jeans has developed certain firm-specific
capabilities that allow it to be more successful than competitors pursuing similar strategies.
Will be covered in more detail in Chapter 7.
Copyright © 1999 by Harcourt Brace & CompanyAll rights reserved
Corporate StrategyCorporate StrategyCorporate StrategyCorporate Strategy
Chapter 9 will deal with corporate strategies and how they can be sources of competitive advantage.
Corporate strategy addresses several important questions: “What is the appropriate scale and scope of the
enterprise?” “How are the businesses of the diversified firm
related?” “How should the diversified firm be managed?”
Copyright © 1999 by Harcourt Brace & CompanyAll rights reserved
Organizational Organizational StructureStructureOrganizational Organizational StructureStructure
Chapter 10 will examine organizational structure. Importance of routines and standard operating
procedures. Information flows and systems. Organizational culture.
These components of organizational structure can contribute to development of competitive advantage.
Copyright © 1999 by Harcourt Brace & CompanyAll rights reserved
Distinction between Distinction between Content and ProcessContent and ProcessDistinction between Distinction between Content and ProcessContent and Process
Strategy content: What a firm does. Process: How a firm does or decides what it does. Organizational processes not only complement, but
also have distinct advantages over strategy content elements in managers’ efforts to develop competitive advantage. These processes are less amenable to imitation,
because internal organizational processes are much less visible to outsiders.
Copyright © 1999 by Harcourt Brace & CompanyAll rights reserved
Distinction between Distinction between Content and ProcessContent and Process (cont.)(cont.)
Distinction between Distinction between Content and ProcessContent and Process (cont.)(cont.)
Exhibits 3.5 and 3.6 suggest that Merck’s high performance is not due to the content of its R&D strategy, but more likely is due to the processes the firm uses to implement and manage its R&D program in order to yield so many new blockbuster drug products.
SeeExhibits3.5 & 3.6
Copyright © 1999 by Harcourt Brace & CompanyAll rights reserved
Value Chain AnalysisValue Chain AnalysisValue Chain AnalysisValue Chain Analysis
Can be very helpful tool for evaluating the capabilities embedded in organizational processes. Simply a diagram illustrating the various value-
adding processes that occur inside a business (see Exhibit 3.7 on following slide).
Analyzing the various links in the value chain helps managers evaluate the extent to which their organization’s processes contribute to competitive advantage.
Copyright © 1999 by Harcourt Brace & CompanyAll rights reserved
Exhibit 3.7:Exhibit 3.7: Value Chain for Value Chain for
Hypothetical Hypothetical Manufacturing Manufacturing
FirmFirm
Exhibit 3.7:Exhibit 3.7: Value Chain for Value Chain for
Hypothetical Hypothetical Manufacturing Manufacturing
FirmFirm
Engineeringand Design
Purchasing
Assembly andProduction
After-SaleService
Copyright © 1999 by Harcourt Brace & CompanyAll rights reserved
Importance of Socially Importance of Socially Complex ResourcesComplex ResourcesImportance of Socially Importance of Socially Complex ResourcesComplex Resources
Defined as: Resources that enable an organization to conceive,
choose, and implement strategies because of the values, beliefs, symbols, and interpersonal relationships possessed by individuals or groups in a firm.
• Examples: Organizational culture; trust and friendship among managers in an organization; reputation of an organization among its customers; teamwork among managers and workers.
Copyright © 1999 by Harcourt Brace & CompanyAll rights reserved
ConclusionsConclusionsConclusionsConclusions
Asymmetric nature of competitive advantage described. Firms enjoy competitive advantage by doing what
other firms cannot do, or by doing what other firms do but do it better.
Firms can enjoy sustainable competitive advantage by possessing capabilities that are causally ambiguous and difficult to imitate.
Copyright © 1999 by Harcourt Brace & CompanyAll rights reserved
Conclusions Conclusions (cont.)(cont.)Conclusions Conclusions (cont.)(cont.)
An organization’s internal processes are more likely than strategy content variables to be sources of sustained competitive advantage.
Factors which contribute to the development of unique and valuable capabilities: Time Past success Interconnectedness Investment Causal ambiguity
Copyright © 1999 by Harcourt Brace & CompanyAll rights reserved
Conclusions Conclusions (cont.)(cont.)Conclusions Conclusions (cont.)(cont.)
A particular internal process can quickly be rendered obsolete due to environmental shifts, such as changes in regulations or technologies. Therefore, managers need to acquire and develop
resources that enhance their firm’s current position, while being mindful of the kinds of resources and capabilities that will be needed in the future.
Copyright © 1999 by Harcourt Brace & CompanyAll rights reserved
Key Points Key Points Introduced in Introduced in Chapter 3Chapter 3
Key Points Key Points Introduced in Introduced in Chapter 3Chapter 3
Definition for competitive advantage: Set of factors or capabilities that allows firms to
consistently outperform their rivals. Without resource “mobility barriers” to prevent the
transfer of resources and skills across firms, capabilities and other sources of competitive advantage tend to be quickly diffused through an industry and the entire economy.
Copyright © 1999 by Harcourt Brace & CompanyAll rights reserved
Key Points Introduced Key Points Introduced in Chapter 3 in Chapter 3 (cont.)(cont.)
Key Points Introduced Key Points Introduced in Chapter 3 in Chapter 3 (cont.)(cont.)
Firms that enjoy a sustained competitive advantage possess factors, capabilities, or competencies that are valuable, rare, lack substitutes, and are difficult to imitate. As a result, a key characteristic of competitive
advantage is asymmetry.• Firms enjoy a competitive advantage by either doing
what other firms cannot do, or if they do what other firms can also do they must do it better.
Copyright © 1999 by Harcourt Brace & CompanyAll rights reserved
Key Points Introduced Key Points Introduced in Chapter 3 in Chapter 3 (cont.)(cont.)
Key Points Introduced Key Points Introduced in Chapter 3 in Chapter 3 (cont.)(cont.)
Five factors that contribute to the development of sustained competitive advantage are: Time Past success Interconnectedness of resources Investment Casual ambiguity
Copyright © 1999 by Harcourt Brace & CompanyAll rights reserved
Key Points Introduced Key Points Introduced in Chapter 3 in Chapter 3 (cont.)(cont.)
Key Points Introduced Key Points Introduced in Chapter 3 in Chapter 3 (cont.)(cont.)
Because they tend to be casually ambiguous and difficult to imitate, a firm’s internal processes are more likely than the content of its strategies to be sources of sustained competitive advantage.
Socially complex resources such as reputation and organizational culture can also be important sources of competitive advantage They are so difficult to imitate.
Copyright © 1999 by Harcourt Brace & CompanyAll rights reserved
Key Points Introduced Key Points Introduced in Chapter 3 in Chapter 3 (cont.)(cont.)
Key Points Introduced Key Points Introduced in Chapter 3 in Chapter 3 (cont.)(cont.)
The value chain can be a very useful tool for analyzing organizational capabilities and processes and to assess competitive advantage.
A source of competitive advantage in one time period can become dated and useless in a later time period, so a key management responsibility is to be mindful of how vulnerable resources and capabilities are to imitation and obsolescence and to anticipate the kinds of resources and capabilities that will be needed to compete effectively in the future.
Top Related