y{z 0>< N 0>< =;< 4P:K=rL 4 - Cerfacscerfacs.fr/~cfdbib/repository/TR_CFD_10_29.pdf · 2015. 7....

38

Transcript of y{z 0>< N 0>< =;< 4P:K=rL 4 - Cerfacscerfacs.fr/~cfdbib/repository/TR_CFD_10_29.pdf · 2015. 7....

Page 1: y{z 0>< N 0>< =;< 4P:K=rL 4 - Cerfacscerfacs.fr/~cfdbib/repository/TR_CFD_10_29.pdf · 2015. 7. 31. · [ . ='t < 1wl 4 =>:;0k.5:;< t @g:;='9 . n .5_ @aeg@g:k@g

� � ��������� ������� ��������������� � ��� ������ !��" �#� �����$����� ��%

��� ����� �#� �&���#'��(� *),+ -���� ���� .����� � �/0+1����%2�3�

-�4��� 5"7698 �5��������� ���/:," !��� ;< !������ ������ �

=?>A@CB�DFE?G0HJILKM>AB�DONQPSRUTWVYX�E[ZDFB�D]\,D^B�_`DFB�>aXbHcPFde\gfD^BhfDFX�>aijKSD]khl�D^B�@JKbm

nporqCs�t2u,vxwJy&zL{�v[|O}jv�~e�����es��`�vpzL}Mt��L�S�S���Lt���}Ov[���^��z��U��z����x��|]��v��Mv���t�q��rz�|^��v� �����bq ���C¡ t¢y£z�{Lv[|j}Ov!¤�¥b�����¦�§�L�¨����t�©SuSª«�«��t#¬O��}��­��}®�xv¯��v°�Sv�� ª«u�t`q��rz�|^�¦v

±!²C³x´¶µ�·j¸L´

¹eº$»�¼j½r¾r¿�ÀpÁLÂWÃļ Åjº$»�ÆJÇ ¿°ÈOÇjÉ­Àp¼M¾JÊ2º«Çj¼jËOÁ�¿�Ì5Í2º«¼jËOέ¾�έº«¼j½�ϧ¹eÃAÆCÇ ¿°ÊbÍbТÁ�¿�À�Ñj¿�Àp½rÀp¼M¾rÀpË3Ò�ºL¿¾�Ó À�Ô�ÇjÉ­Àx¿°ÎÕÁL¼ Ö×Ô�ÇjÉ­Àx¿�ÎÕÁL¼/Ø¢Á�¿°ÙLÀ�Ô�ËjË ÌhÚ ÎÕÂ?ÇOÉÕÁ�¾�έº«¼�ϧآÔ2ÚOÐbºL¿�Û�ÀxÌ®¼jº«ÉÕËj½eÜ�ÝLÀx¿°Á�ÙLÀ�ÞßÁ¶Ý®Î­Àx¿�ÖÚ®¾rºLàLÀp½�ϧÛßÜßÞ�ÚjÐ2Ú�ÎÕÂ5ÇjÉÕÁ�¾�έº«¼.ºLÒ�¹eÎÕÀp½rÀpÉ^½�Ñj¿°ÁpÌ�½xá�ÆbÓ Àp½rÀßÈ�º«Çj¼jËjÁ�¿�Ì3â[º«¼jËjÎÕ¾�έº«¼j½�Î�¼jέ¾�ÎÕÁ�¾rÀb¾�ÓjÀ½rÑO¿°ÁpÌ!ÑOÓMÌ®½�Î�âx½2âxÉÕº«½rÀ�¾rº�¾�Ó À�¼ ºLãxãpÉ­À�À[ä Î­¾xå »�ÓOÎÕâ°Ó¯ÁpÝLº«Î�Ëj½b¾�Ó À�ËjÎÕæ.âxÇjÉ­¾�έÀp½�ÉÕÎ�¼ àLÀpË!¾rº�¾�Ó À#ç�¹½�Î�Â?ÇjÉ�Á�¾�έº«¼#ºLÒ^âxÁpÝ�έ¾�Á�¾�έº«¼èåLÑj¿�ÎÕÂ�Á�¿�Ì�Èj¿°ÀpÁ�àSÖ×Ç Ñ�ÁL¼jË5¾�Ç ¿°ÈOÇjÉ­Àp¼jâ[À2ÎÕ¼?¾�Ó À�¼ ÀpÁ�¿rÖ×¼ ºLãxãpÉ­À�¿�ÀxÙ«ÎÕº«¼èáÜe¼/ÎÕ¼�érÀpâ[¾rºL¿�Â�º�Ë ÀpÉèÎÕ½�â[º«Â?ÈOÎÕ¼jÀp˯»�έ¾�Ó,Â�ÁL½�½�ÁL¼jË,Á�ä�Î�ÁLÉ�Â�º«Â�Àp¼M¾�ÇjÂ*â[º«¼j½�Àx¿�Ý�Á�¾�ÎÕº«¼,ÀpêMÇOÁ�Ö¾�έº«¼O½�¾rº�ºLÈO¾�ÁLÎÕ¼,Â�ÀpÁL¼¯Ñj¿�ºLë^É­Àp½�ºLÒCÝLÀpÉ­º�âxέ¾×ÌLå ÝLº«É�ÇjÂ�ÀìÒ�¿�ÁLâ[¾�έº«¼¯ÁL¼jË,Ë ¿�ºLÑOÉÕÀx¾2ËjÎ�ÁLÂ�Àx¾rÀx¿�Á�¾bÁ٫έÝLÀp¼&ËjÎ�½r¾�ÁL¼jâ[À3Ë º¶»�¼O½r¾r¿�ÀpÁLÂíÒ�¿�º«Âî¾�Ó À3¼ ºLãxãpÉ­À5À[ä Î­¾xá^ÃļïºL¿°Ë Àx¿e¾rº¯¾�Á�àLÀ3Î�¼S¾rº¯ÁLâxâ[º«Çj¼M¾e¾�ÓjÀÇj¼O½r¾rÀpÁLËjÎÕ¼ Àp½°½�ºLÒC¾�Ó ÀìÅjº$»�å ÝLÀpÉ­º�âxέ¾×Ì!ÅOÇjâ[¾�ÇjÁ�¾�ÎÕº«¼j½�Á�¿�À�ÁLËjË Àp˯¾rº�¾�Ó À�Â�ÀpÁL¼,Ñj¿�ºLëOÉÕÀLá®ÆbÓjÀp½rÀÈ�º«Çj¼jËOÁ�¿�Ìðâ[º«¼jËjÎÕ¾�έº«¼j½�Á�¿�À ÁL½°½rÀp½�½rÀpË�È®Ì�â[º«Â�ÑOÁ�¿°Î�½rº«¼�»�έ¾�Ó�ËjÁ�¾�Á�º«¼ñÎÕ¼�érÀpâ[¾�έº«¼�ÝLÀpÉ­º�âxέ¾×ÌLå½rÑO¿°Áp̯ÁL¼ Ù«É­À#ÁL¼O˯ÝLÀpÉ­º®âxÎÕ¾×̯Ñj¿�ºLëOÉÕÀp½�Ò�¿�º«Âò¼MÇjÂ�Àx¿�º«Çj½�À[ä�ÑFÀx¿�ÎÕÂ�Àp¼M¾�½xá

ó vxô�õ����r���[öÊ2º«Çj¼jËOÁ�¿�Ì!â[º«¼OËjέ¾�έº«¼èå ½rÑO¿°ÁpÌLåOØJÁ�¿�ÙLÀ#Ô�Ëjˠ̯ڠÎÕÂ?ÇOÉÕÁ�¾�έº«¼£Ï§Ø¢Ô�ÚjÐ�åOÂ�º�Ë ÀpÉÕÉÕÎ�¼ Ù å®¹ìέÀp½�ÀpÉÎÕ¼�éÄÀpâ[¾�έº«¼

÷�ø¦ùÄú�ø°ûÕüFý`þ¶ÿ����.û ýrý×ù�� ý�����þ�ù �$û�ù�ø����°û�ù¦ü��¦ù ���xþ¶ý���ú�ø°û���������

Page 2: y{z 0>< N 0>< =;< 4P:K=rL 4 - Cerfacscerfacs.fr/~cfdbib/repository/TR_CFD_10_29.pdf · 2015. 7. 31. · [ . ='t < 1wl 4 =>:;0k.5:;< t @g:;='9 . n .5_ @aeg@g:k@g

� � �"!�#%$'&�(*)�!�+�$,�

-/.�0213.5476�8�.�9 :;6�0;< 0;=2.�0><?8�.59 @A4CBD@A4�9 0;<�.5=;@A4CB�EGFH=;<�I�< 0><J0>< B�6�EA.5:K@GL�4�=ML�4ON,L�EGEA6C:K.�4P:'< 1Q@A=SR=;@GL�4�=*.�4�TU8V6�< E�9 L�4�=>6�1WN�:K@AL�4MX%Y*LH0;< =>N"< 9 :Z:;[�< =></0;< B�6�EA.5:K@GL�4�= \�4C< ]^9 L�1`_�6�=a:K@AL�4U9 L�4�R9 < NC:K=b@G4dce4P:K< 0;4�.�E/-JL�1`_�6C=>:K@GL�4gfVca-DhUij4�B�@A4C< =`.50;<k_,< @G4�BlT�<�I�< EAL�N,< TMX*YD[�<nmo-D-JcfpmqL�1WL�B�< 4�< L�6�=r-J[�.50;B�<s-JL�1WN�0>< =>=;@AL�4QceB�4�@G:;@AL�4th29 L�1U_�6�=>:;@AL�4vuxw�\�y{z�0>< N�0>< =;< 4P:K=rL�4�<L�8j:K[C< =;<U9 L�4�9 < NC:;= XM|HEG:;[�L�6�B�[}@G:H[�.�==>[�L�]s4~.3B�0><�.5:oN"L�:;< 4P:K@A.�E�\�@�:o=a:K@GEAE20;< �76C@A0;< =�.9 L�1QN�0>< [�< 4�=;@�I�<`]�L�0;��:KLn.5EAEAL�]�.W_"<�:;:K< 06�4�TC< 0;=a:�.�4CT�@A4�BC\�< =>N"< 9 @A.�EAE�Fn]s@G:K[l0;< =>N"< 9 ::KLv9 F79 EG@A9bI5.�0;@A.�_�@GEA@G:;@A< =H]s[�@G9�[�9 .�4�.�NCN"< .�0�@A4�=;L�1Q<�L�N"< 0K.5:;@A4�B�9 L�4�T�@�:K@AL�4�= X'YD[�< =;<I5.�0;@A.�_�@AEG@G:;@A< =�9 .�4�[�.�I�<�.l=>:;0;L�4�B�<���< 9 :bL�4�8V6�< E�9 L�4�=>6�1QNC:K@GL�4�.�4�TdN"L�EGEA6C:K.�4P:K=�.�==;[�L�]s4�_PF��� T�L�0�<�:�.�EDu��5zpXMYD[�<�4�L�4�R�T�< :;< 0>1W@G4�@A=a:K@A9�9�[�.�0;.�9 :;< 0�L�8?:K[�<b:;6�0;_�6CEA< 4C9 <@A=bL�4C<nL�8H:;[�<�N�[�< 4�L�1Q< 4�.�EA< .�T�@G4�B�:KL�:K[C<n9 F79 EG@A9kI5.�0;@A.�_�@GEA@G:eF�X2c�:�9 L�0>0;< =>N"L�4�T�=�:KL:K[�<�1Q@A9 0;L�=>9 L�NC@A9o<�I�< 4�:;=q:;[�.5:D9 .�4n@A4���6�< 4C9 <:K[C<�@A4�=a:�.�4P:�.54�< L�6C=/I�< EGL�9 @G:eFQ��< EGTv.�4�T:K[�<oEAL79�.�E,1W@��7:K6�0><oEA< .�T�@G4�B�:;LbT�@G�"< 0>< 4P:D[�< .5:D0;< EA< .�=;<5\CN,L�EAEG6C:�.�4P:�EA<�I�< EG=D.�4�Tn< 4�B�@G4�<]JL�0;�38V0>L�1�9 F79 EA<�:KL�9 F79 EA<�X

-JL�1QN�6C:�.{:K@AL�4�.�E2��EG6�@AT}�oF74�.�1Q@A9 =Uf�-/����hs@G=o.Q[�< EGNC8V6�E2:KL7L�E'8VL�0H=a:K6�T�F�@G4�Bk=>6�9�[�@A=SR=;6�< = X{YD[�<��q|o� Qfp�s< F74�L�EGT�=2|HI�< 0K.�B�< T`�H.�I�@G< 0SRa 7:;L���< =�h2.�N�N�0>LP.�9�[nu¢¡�z�@G='9 L�1Q1WL�4�EGF6�=;< Td@G4d-/���£:;L}N,< 0a8VL�0;1¤���¥=>@A1`6CE¦.5:;@AL�4�=bu¨§{zpX2mHL�]�< I�< 0 \*.�E�:K[�L�6CB�[�@G:�@G=O9�[�.�0K.�9©R:K< 0;@A=>< T�_PFv0;< .�=;L�4�.�_�EG<�9 L�1WNC6C:�.5:;@AL�4�.�E'9 L�=a:K= \�@G:qT�L7< =H4�L�:o.�EAEGL�]ª:K[C<U=>:;6�TCFvL�8Z:;[�<L�0;@GB�@A4C=UL�8q9 F79 EA@A9WI�.50;@¦.5_�@AEG@G:K@G< = «2�q|o� �9�.�EG9 6�EA.5:K@GL�4dL58o.�B�@�I�< 4�< 4�B�@G4�<nL�N,< 0;.5:K@GL�4N"L�@A4P:s0;< N�0;< =;< 4P:;=H:K[C<O=a:�.5:;@A=a:K@A9 .�EM.�I�< 0K.5B�<�L58�1W.�4PFk9�F�9 EA< =o.5:D:;[�@A=sN,L�@A4P: X

¬ .�0;B�<ki?TCTCF^ �@G1`6�EA.5:K@GL�4­f ¬ i� Ch�=;< < 1Q=`:KL�_,<k_"<�:;:;< 0�.�T�.5NC:K< T�8VL�0U=>6�9�[®=a:K6�TC@A< = \.�=OL�4�< ¬ ir ~L�8s.�B�@GI�< 4d< 4�B�@G4�<WL�N"< 0K.5:;@AL�4�N"L�@A4P:O9 L�0>0;< =>N"L�4�T�=�:;L}L�4�<W@G4�T�@�I�@GT�6�.�E< 4�B�@A4�<W9 F79 EG<�\�9 L�1QN�6C:;@A4�B}EAL79�.�E?.�4CT�@A4�=a:�.�4P:K.�4�< L�6�=���E�:K< 0;< TdN�0;L�N,< 0a:K@G< =3u°¯5zpX ¬ ir ± Í�ºL¿�¿�Àp½rÑ�º«¼jËjÎ�¼ Ù5ÁLÇj¾�Ó ºL¿pájÆJÀpÉ áx²^çLç$Öa³¦ÖV´5µ¶Öp¶�·$Öp¸�¹�¹�¹�º�Ò§Á�äC²FçLç$Öa³¦ÖV´5µ¶Öp¶�·$Ö�µ ¹%¸�»����z����Cz«�«����v¦���[öZ¼�½%¾�¿7À�¼2Á¦ÂCÃ%Ä�Å7½ ¿�À5Æ�ÇP½�È�É?Á�È{Ä Ï§Ø¢Î­º«¼ ÀpÉ"Ê Á�¿�¾�Î�¼ Àxã?Ð�á

y

Page 3: y{z 0>< N 0>< =;< 4P:K=rL 4 - Cerfacscerfacs.fr/~cfdbib/repository/TR_CFD_10_29.pdf · 2015. 7. 31. · [ . ='t < 1wl 4 =>:;0k.5:;< t @g:;='9 . n .5_ @aeg@g:k@g

[�.�='T�< 1WL�4�=>:;0K.5:;< T�@G:;='9�.�N�.5_�@AEG@G:K@G< =,@A4�1W.�4PF9 L�4C��B�6C0K.5:;@AL�4�=ju¨Ë�\�Ì5zP.�4CTO@G4�N�.�0a:K@A9 6�E¦.50@A4�1`6�E�:K@�Re9 F79 EA<J=>@A1`6CE¦.5:;@AL�4`L58�ca-^< 4�B�@G4�<�u°Í�\�w�Î5zpX7Ï}L�0>< L�I�< 0 \�T�6�<D:KL�@�:K=jN,L�:K< 4�:;@¦.�E�:KL0;< =;L�E�I�<DE¦.50;B�<r=;9 .�EA<JI�L�0>:;@A9 < =?.�4�Tb=>L:KLNC0;< TC@A9 :�:K[�</@G4P:K< 0;.�9 :;@AL�4U_"<�:e]J< < 4QT�0;L�NC=?.�4�T.�@A0f�9 .�0;0>@A< 0�N�[�.�=><�h©\ ¬ ir 3@A=D.�EG=;L`L582B�0;< .5:/@G4�:;< 0>< =>:D8VL�0J=;NC0K.�Fk=>@A1`6�EA.5:K@GL�4�= XPce4�T�< < TM\��4�L�]s@A4�B�:K[�<sEG< I�< EtL�8":;6�0;_C6�EA< 4�9 <q@A4P:K< 4�=;@�:eFbB�< 4�< 0;.5:K< T3_PFb:K[�<s=>N�0K.�FQ.�=j]�< EAEt.5=?:;[�<9 L�1QN,L�=;@�:K@AL�4nL�8Z:K[C<�BP.5=q1Q@��7:;6�0;<�@A=sL�8ZB�0;< .5:q@A1QN"L�0a:�.�4C9 <8VL�0s6�4�TC< 0;=a:�.�4CT�@A4�Bk.�4�T1WL7T�< EAEA@G4�BU9 L�1`_�6C=>:K@GL�4�@A4�ca-Ð< 4�B�@G4�< = X

ce4�:;[�@A=]�L�0;�t\*.�4�i?6CEA< 0>@¦.�4~1Q< :;[�L�T~@G=O6C=;< T�8VL�0:K[�<QEA@G��6�@AT�N�[�.�=;<W.�4�T�N�0;<�8V< 0;0>< T:KL3:;[�< ¬ .�B�0;.�4�B�@A.�4}.�N�N�0>LP.�9�[�< =]s[�@A9�[~.�0><U9 L�1W1QL�4�E�F�6�=;< T~@A4�-/���`X"|H1WL�4CBn.�EAEEA@G1W@�:�.5:;@AL�4�=vuxw�w�\Hw%y�\Hw��5zp\/L�4�<�L58O:;[�<�1W.�@A4­TC0K.�]s_�.�9��­L58 ¬ .�B�0K.�4�B�@¦.�4­1Q< :;[�L7T�=@A=n:K[�.5:v.Ñ[C@AB�[gN�.�0a:K@G9 EA<�4�6�1U_"< 0vTC< 4�=>@G:eFg@A=�4�< < T�< TÒ:;LÓ.�9�[C@A< I�<d.^=K.{:K@A=a8�.�9 :;L�0>F.�9 9 6�0K.59 F�8VL�0 ¬ ir "X�YD[�@A=rEA< .�T�=j:KL�.O[C@AB�[�9 L�1WN�6�:�.5:;@AL�4�.5E�9 L�=a:�:;[�.5:r@A=?4�L5:�0>< EG< I5.�4P:@A4W@A4�T�6C=>:K0>@¦.�E,.�NCN�EA@G9�.5:;@AL�4�= X�YD[�@A=�13.�FQ_"<HL�I�< 0>9 L�1Q<_PFWN�.�0K.5EAEA< EA@G=K.5:;@AL�4b_�6�:J:K[C@A=J@G==>:;@AEAE'TC< EA@G9�.5:;<�:KL7T�.�F�\t13.5@A4�E�FkT�6�<O:KLWEALP.�Tv@A1U_�.�E¦.54�9 <�]s[�< 4�N�.�0a:K@A9 EA< =q9 L�4�9 < 4P:K0;.5:K<@A4�=;L�1W<�N�0>L�9 < =>=;L�0>= X

YD[�<k1W.�@A4�T�@GÔQ9 6�EG:eF�@A4�:K[�<W=;@A1U6�E¦.5:;@AL�4�L�8q.��@G< =>< Er=;N�0;.�F�@A=O:K[�<39 L�1QN�EA<©��@G:eF~L�8:K[�<3N�[PF�=>@A9 =b.5:U:;[�<34CL�� � EA<k<©�C@�:U8VL�0O_,L�:K[d:;[�<3EG@A��6�@GT�.�4�TdBP.�=UNC[�.�=;< = X°YD[�@A=b9 L�1bRN�EA<©��@G:eFvEA< .�T�=o:;Lk@A1QN"L�0>:�.54�:HT�@�ÔW9 6�EG:;@A< =q8VL�0q:K[�<U1WL7T�< EG@A4�BW.�4�T�:;[�<`<©�CN,< 0>@A1Q< 4P:�.5EI5.�EA@GT�.5:K@GL�4MX

��L�0s<��C.�1QN�EA<5\�:K[�<�N�[PF7=;@G9 =.{:q:;[�<O4�L�� � EA<O<���@G:q@G=q=a:K0>L�4�B�E�FnEA@G4���< Tv:;LQ:;[�<�_,< [�.�I7@GL�0L�82:K[�<oEA@A��6�@GTW��L�]Ò@A4�=>@AT�<q:K[�<�@G4{Õ>< 9�:KL�0 X�-/.�I7@G:K.5:K@GL�4k1W.�F3L79 9 6�0 \�T�< N,< 4�TC@A4�BbL�4k:;[�<@A4{Õ>< 9 :;L�0�B�< L�1Q< :;0>FÒuxw�¡�zq.�4CT®:K[C<v��L�]�\�.�4�T®[�.�=Q=>:K0>L�4�B�@A4C��6C< 4�9 <lL�4^:K[�<}=;N�0;.�FI�< EAL79 @G:eF�\D.�4�B�EA<�.�4CTÒ.{:KL�1Q@A=;.5:K@GL�4Öuxw%§�\w�¯�\w%Ë%z�XD��6�0a:K[�< 0;1QL�0;<5\/T�6�<�:;L�:K[�<�[�@GB�[=;N,< < TÒ.54�T×[�@AB�[×T�< 4�=>@G:eFÓL�8�:K[�<lEA@A��6�@GT�Õ>< : \�:;0K.�T�@�:K@GL�4�.�EDL�N�:K@A9 .�Eo1Q< :;[�L7T�=k=;[CL%]EA@G1W@�:�.5:;@AL�4�=/8VL�0o:K[�<b1Q<�.5=;6�0>< 1Q< 4P:K=�@G4�:K[�<bT�< 4�=;<�EG@A��6�@AT}=;N�0;.�F�0;< B�@AL�4�X�YD[�< 0;< 8VL�0;<

Page 4: y{z 0>< N 0>< =;< 4P:K=rL 4 - Cerfacscerfacs.fr/~cfdbib/repository/TR_CFD_10_29.pdf · 2015. 7. 31. · [ . ='t < 1wl 4 =>:;0k.5:;< t @g:;='9 . n .5_ @aeg@g:k@g

:K[�<HN�0;@G13.50>Fb_�0><�.���R�6�Nk@A=rT�@�ÔW9 6�EG:r:KL�L�_�=>< 0>I�<<���N,< 0>@A1Q< 4P:�.�EGEGF�.54�Tk9 L�0;0;< =;N,L�4�T�@G4�B1WL7T�< EA=.50;<`4�L5:�<�.�=aFl:;L3I5.�EA@GT�.5:K<5X"ce4~.5T�T�@G:;@AL�4�\,4�6�1Q< 0>@A9 .�E�@G=;=;6C< =�.�0>@A=;<�EA@G4���< T�:KL:K[�<D[C@AB�[bEG@A��6�@AT�I�L�EG6�1W<�8V0K.�9�:K@AL�4b.�4�Tb:K[C<D[�@AB�[`I�< EGL�9 @G:K@G< =/f�_,< :e]�< < 4W¡PÎ�Î�Ø�ÙÛÚ5Ü�Ý�.�4�T¯�Î�Î�Ø�ÙÛÚ5Ü�Ý>hM< 1QN�[�.�=>@A=>< TO_�F�:;[�<jI�< 0>FO=;1W.�EAE5=;9 .�EA< =*L�87:K[C<rNC[�F7=>@A9 =�.5:':K[C<�4�L�� � EG<?<���@G: X��L�0�@A4�=a:�.�4�9 <�\':eF7N�@A9 .�Er�@A< =;< Ej@G4{Õ>< 9�:KL�0>=�[�.�I�<3TC@¦.�1Q< :;< 0;=Wf�Þ�ß�à�áãâ�h�_"<�:e]J< < 4­w�Î�Î�äMØ.�4�Tly�Î�Î�ä�Ø�Xt-JL�4�=>< ��6�< 4P:;EGF�\,]s[�< 4}6�=;@G4�B ¬ i� �=;L�E�I�< 0;=D:KLQ9 L�1QN�6C:;<�:K[�<�:K6C0;_�6�EG< 4P:1W@���@A4�B�E¦.�F�< 0/.{:�:;[�<o4�L�� � EG<o<©�C@�:�\�L�4�<H[�.�=r:KLU@G4�9 0><�.�=><H:;[�<o=>N�.5:K@A.�Et0;< =;L�EG6C:K@GL�4MX�YD[�<0;< =;6�E�:K@A4CBQ=>@A1`6CE¦.5:;@AL�4W9 L�=a:H@G=D:K[�< 4}N�0>L�[�@G_�@G:;@GI�<H8VL�0D@A4�TC6�=>:;0;@¦.5EM.�N�NCEA@A9 .5:K@GL�4�= X

|o=j.H0;< =>6�EG:�L�8�:K[C< =;<DTC@GÔQ9 6�E�:K@G< = \{.o1Q< :;[�L7T�L�EAL�B�F�@A=*N�0;L�N,L�=>< T`8VL�0*@A4{Õ>< 9 :K@GL�4U_,L�6�4CT�R.�0>F�9 L�4�TC@G:K@GL�4�=o:;L�@A4�@�:K@¦.{:K<�:;[�<�=;N�0;.�F~N�[PF�=>@A9 =U.5:O.nB�@�I�< 4�T�@G=>:K.�4�9 <5\'T�L�]s4�=>:;0;< .�18V0;L�1£:K[C<4�L�� � EA<o<���@G: XCYD[�@G=/4�< ]ª�L�]s4�=>:;0;< .�1åce4C��L%]ÒY�6�0;_�6CEA< 4P:sæ�L�6�4�T�.50>F�-JL�4�RT�@G:;@AL�4C=3f��ceY*6C0KæD-Dh�1WL7T�< Ej@A=�N�0;< =;< 4�:;< T�@G4�:;[�<Q8VL�EAEAL�]s@G4�Bn=;< 9 :K@GL�4�= X*c�:�[�.�=O_"< < 4T�< I�< EGL�N"< Tl@G4k:K[�<�9 L�4�:;<��7:HL�8 ¬ ir n_�6C:q9 L�6CEAT�_"<�6�=>< Tv8VL�0s�q|o� n=;@G1`6�E¦.{:K@AL�4�= X

YD[�<�N�.�N,< 0@G=L�0>BP.�4�@G=;< T~.5=8VL�EAEGL%]s=� �< 9�:K@AL�4�y3<���N�E¦.5@A4�=:;[�<b1W<�:K[�L7T�L�EGL�B�F�T�<�I�< E�RL�N,< T�8VL�0Z:K[�<s@G4�@G:;@¦.�EG@A��.{:K@AL�4�L�8��@A< =;< E�=;N�0;.�F�=�@A4�ca-Ñ< 4�B�@G4�< = XPYD[�<H@G4{Õ>< 9�:KL�0j1QL7T�< E�@G=N�0;< =;< 4�:;< T�@A4k �< 9�:K@GL�4k��.�4�T3:;[�<o0>< =;6CEG:K@G4�BUNC0;L���EG< =?8V0;L�1ç:;[�<�ceY�6�0Kæ/-Ó1WL7T�< E,.�0><T�< NC@A9 :;< Tv@A4} �< 9 :K@GL�4�¡�X�YD[�<�1QL�T�< E�I5.�EA@GT�.5:;@AL�4k@G=DT�< =>9 0>@A_,< Tv@A4n:K[�<�EA.�=>:H �< 9 :;@AL�4MX

è éÖêP!%ë2$'&�$,ìV$títî®ï�$t#W!�ë�êl+p��+V!�+�ð�ì�+�ñ ðC!%+V$,�^$tïqñ ò�#%ð�î'ñ3+��®��óôê7��í,+���ê7ñ

õ7öø÷ ù�ú�ûVü�ý þ7ý{ÿAý����ce4ÓL�0>T�< 0�:KL�@A4C@G:[email protected]:K<W:K[�<v=;N�0;.�F^N�[PF�=>@A9 =3T�L�]s4�=a:K0;< .�1 8V0;L�1 :;[�<v4�L�� � EA<�<���@�:�\r.�4@A4{Õ>< 9 :;L�0�1QL7T�< E�@G=r��0>=>:J6�=;< Tk:KLU< =>:;@A1W.5:K<D:K[C<oN�0>L�N"< 0>:;@A< =rL�8M:;[�<H��L%]Ð.{:�:;[�<o4�L�� � EG<<���@G:q=>6�9�[�.�=D:;[�<�EA@A��6�@GTkI�< EAL79 @G:eF�\�:K[�<�<���< 9 :K@�I�<O<���@G:q=>< 9 :;@AL�4}.�4�T�:K[C<O=>N�0K.�Fv.�4CB�EA<5X

¡

Page 5: y{z 0>< N 0>< =;< 4P:K=rL 4 - Cerfacscerfacs.fr/~cfdbib/repository/TR_CFD_10_29.pdf · 2015. 7. 31. · [ . ='t < 1wl 4 =>:;0k.5:;< t @g:;='9 . n .5_ @aeg@g:k@g

YD[�< 4�_�.5=;< T�L�4`:;[�< =><s0;< =>6�EG:;=j.�4�Tb6C=;@A4CB�9 L�4�=>< 0aI�.{:K@AL�4b< ��6�.5:;@AL�4�= \�:K[C<JI�< EAL79 @G:;@A< =�L�8BP.�=�.�4�TbEA@G��6�@ATM\�:;[�<JI�L�EA6�1Q<?8V0K.�9�:K@AL�4`.�4�T`:;[�<JTC0;L�N�EG< :�=;@A� <JN�0>L���EG< =j.�0><JT�< T�6�9 < T�L�4.Uy5�ÐN�EA.�4�<sEAL79�.{:K< TQ.5:�.�T�@G=>:�.54�9 <HÞ��eÚ���T�L�]s4�=>:;0;<�.51 8V0;L�1 :;[�<q4�L�� � EA<s<���@�:�\P9�.5EAEA< T:K[�<~�ceY�6�0;æD- N�EA.�4�<^fV=;< <��*@AB�Xqw%h�XJYD[�< =><�NC0;L���EG< =n0>< N�0>< =;< 4P:}:;[�<~�L�]s4�=>:;0;<�.51ce4C��L�]^Y�6�0;_�6CEA< 4P:�æJL�6�4CT�.�0>F�-JL�4�T�@G:;@AL�4C=rfp�ceY�6�0KæD-DhM:K[�.5:*]s@GEAE�_,<?6�=;< TU:KLq@A4C@G:[email protected]:K<ij6�EA< 0;@¦.54�RSij6�EG< 0;@A.�4 ¬ ir �L58�=>N�0K.�F�@A4%Õ>< 9 :;@AL�4�X

õ7öAõ ����û� �����ú�ûeý���ý���� ÿAú`ú���øû|ª0>< I7@A<�]ÒL58'<���N,< 0;@G1W< 4P:�.�E,0;< =;6�E�:K=/9 L�4�9 < 0;4�@G4�BU:;[�<o=>N�0K.�FW=>:K0>6�9 :;6�0;<�.54�Tk_�0><�.���6�N1W< 9�[�.�4�@G=;1Q=/[�.�=J_"< < 4�9 L�4CT�6�9 :;< Tv_PF� �1W.�EAE�]JL7L7TW<�:q.�E�X�u�w�Ì{z�8VL�0D�@A< =;< E"@A4{Õ>< 9 :;@AL�4MX

YD[�<`��0>=>:�L�_C=;< 0aI5.5:K@GL�4�@A=q:K[�.5:o:K[�<`=>N�0K.�Fl@A=9 L�1WNCEA< :;< E�Fl.{:KL�1Q@A=>< T}I�< 0aF�9 EGL�=;< T�:KL:K[�<r4�L�� � EG<r:;@ANMX�YD[�@G=�.�4�.�E�F�=>@A=2@A=29 L�4C��0>1W< TU_PF��H< ��@�< :�.�EpX�u�w�Í5z�]s[�Lo9 L�4�9 EG6�T�< T�:K[�.5::K[�<�Õ><�:*TC@A=;@G4P:K< B�0K.5:;@AL�4]J.�=�9 L�1QN�EA<�:K<?.5:�Ë�ÙÛ§�Þbßpà�áÛâeX�YD[�@A=21Q<�.�4C=2:;[�.5:�T�L�]s4�=a:K0;< .�1ÖL�8:K[�@G=?T�@A=a:�.�4�9 <�\�:;[�< 0><H@G=j4�L�1QL�0><qNC0;@A1W.�0aFU_�0><�.���R�6�Nk.�4CTQ:;[�<�Õ>< :r@A=j8V6�EGEGF`TC@A=;N,< 0>=;< TMX �< 9 L�4�T�.50>F�_�0;< .���Re6�N�@G=�4�<�I�< 0>:K[C< EA< =;=�=>:;@AEGErNC0;< =>< 4P:�X*YD[�@A=�<�.�0>EGF�T�@G=;@A4P:;< B�0;.5:K@GL�4�@G=13.5@A4�E�F®TC6�<�:KL�:K6C0;_�6�EG< 4�9 <�< �"< 9�:K= \s9 .�I7@�:�.5:;@AL�4×.54�Tg=;< 9 L�4�T�.50>F×��L�] @A4�=>@AT�<l:;[�<@A4{Õ>< 9 :;L�0�4�L�� � EA<du¨y5Î{zpXrc�:Q@G=W@G1WN,L�0>:K.�4P:�.�=Q@G:�9 L�4P:K0;@G_�6C:;< =W:;L�:;[�<v=;N�0;.�F^L�N"< 4�@A4�BCX��6�0>:;[�< 0>1WL�0><�\,.5:H:K[�@G=HT�@G=>:K.�4�9 <5\"EG@A��6�@GTvI�< EAL79 @�:eF�\tI�L�EG6�1Q<O8V0;.�9 :;@AL�4}L�0HTC0;L�N�EG< :H=;@G� <1W< .�4�N�0;L5��EA< =H.50;<���.�6�=;=>@¦.�4�u°y�w�\,y�y�\'w�Í{zpX

æ/.�=>< TOL�4O:;[�@A='=a:K6�TC@A< = \%@G:'@G='N�0;L�N,L�=>< T�:;Lq.�N�N�E�F_,L�6�4�T�.50>F�9 L�4�T�@�:K@AL�4�=2.5:�.DT�@A=a:�.�4C9 <L�8�w�Îb4�L�� � EA<�T�@A.�1W<�:K< 0;=J8V0>L�1å:K[C<�@A4{Õ>< 9 :KL�0/:K@AN�X�|/:s:K[�@G=DT�@A=a:�.�4�9 <O.�4�T�9 L�4C=;@ATC< 0;@G4�B:K[�<W:eF�NC@A9�.5E�4�< .�0`=>N�0K.�F�.54�B�EA< =UL�8D�@A< =>< E�@A4{Õ>< 9 :KL�0;=nfp§��Öw%§}T�< B�0;< < =�h©\�:K[C<k=;N�0;.�F]s@ATC:;[}@G=s_"<�:e]J< < 4~ÎCÙ¨Ì�ØnØ .�4CT�w�Ù¨¯�ØnØ�X��g@G:;[l.5_"L�6�:q:;< 4}4�L�TC< =qL�8�:;[�<�9 L�1QN�6C:�.%R:K@GL�4�.�E?B�0>@AT�.5:�:K[�<3@A4�EG< :�\':;[�@A=�EA<�.5Td:KL�.}1W@G4�@A1`6C1 < T�B�<3EA< 4CB�:K[�_,< :e]�< < 4ÑÌ�Î�äMØ

§

Page 6: y{z 0>< N 0>< =;< 4P:K=rL 4 - Cerfacscerfacs.fr/~cfdbib/repository/TR_CFD_10_29.pdf · 2015. 7. 31. · [ . ='t < 1wl 4 =>:;0k.5:;< t @g:;='9 . n .5_ @aeg@g:k@g

.�4�T�w�¯�Î�ä�Ø ]s[�@G9�[l0>< N�0>< =;< 4P:K=.�B�L7L�T�9 L�1WNC0;L�1Q@A=><_"<�:e]J< < 4~.�9 9 6�0;.�9 Fv.54�T}9 L�1bRN�6C:K.5:K@GL�4�.�EM9 L�=>:s8VL�0s. ¬ ir �L58�=>N�0K.�F�@A4�ca-g< 4�B�@G4�< = X

� �"! ê�)�!�$,#�#d$'&2ê7ìJï�$t#%$�+Vê�ñ ê�ì�ìp+'&têl+��(! ê7)�!%+�$,�)�öø÷ *,+-.���/10,ÿAú2 4�L�]s@A4�BvB�< L�1W<�:K0;@G9�.�E*T�.5:K.vL�8r:K[C<W4�L�� � EG<�\'@G4{Õ>< 9�:K@AL�4�9 L�4�T�@�:K@GL�4�=�.�4�T�9 L�4�T�@G:;@AL�4C=@A4Q:K[�<q9 L�1U_�6�=>:;@AL�4W9�[�.�1`_,< 0 \C.O1WL7T�< E,@G=�_C6�@AE�:j:KLUNC0;< TC@A9 :���0;=a:J:;[�<H=>N�0K.�FQI�< EAL79 @G:eF.5:o:;[�<`4�L�� � EG<U<©�C@�:�.�=q]J< EAE�.�=H:;[�<`=;NC0K.�F�.54�B�EA<5X"YD[C< 4�:K[C<UI�< EAL79 @G:eF�\,I�L�EA6C1W<�8V0K.�9©R:K@GL�4�.�4CT�T�0;L�N�EA<�:o=>@A� <U1W< .�4lN�0>L���EG< =.50;<U9 L�4�=a:K0;6C9 :K< T�.5:Þ3�eÚ��54£w�Î�Þbßpà�áÛâZL�4l:;[�<�ceY*6C0KæD-gN�E¦.�4C<Qf�=;< <` 7< 9 :;@AL�4�¡�h©X

)�öAõ �`ú�ûeú/+-67.�8 �û9�ý:�dý<;�ûøü�ú�=�ú�ÿAý>�/øû9�% �û�ûøü�ú���ý���� ÿAúbú���øû? ��,þ3ûøü�ú�ú'@ú���û9.=�úA��ú���û9�ý:� �+Kú� YD[�<HI�< EGL�9 @G:eFQL�8M:;[�<oEG@A��6�@AToÕ><�:D.5:r:K[�<H4�L�� � EA<H<���@G: \CB�ß�à�áãâe\7T�< N,< 4CT�=/L�4Q]s[�< :;[�< 0J:;[�<��L�]�@G4�=;@GT�<3:K[C<n@A4{Õ>< 9 :KL�0b@A=`9 .�I7@�:�.5:;@A4�B�L�0U1W< 0;< E�F�:;6�0;_C6�EA< 4�: XjY*L~T�<�:K< 0;1Q@A4�<3:;[�<��L�] 0>< B�@G1W<5\C:K[�<�1QL�TC< EML�8Z C.�0>0;<�<�:o.5E�X2u°y��{z2@G=D6�=;< TMX

c�:q@A=q.�=;=>6�1Q< T}:;[�.5:HL�4�E�F3:e]�L3:eF7N"< =HL�8*��L�]Ö0;< B�@A1Q< =s9 .�4}L79 9 6�0q@A4�=>@AT�<�:K[C<�4�L�� � EG<f�=>< <���@AB�X�y�h�«

D c�8s:K[C<kN�0;< =;=>6�0;<v@A4d:;[�< =�ú/�8 E��ý:��û9+� (��û� \GFIHaßKJML{\�@A=UE¦.�0>B�< 0O:K[�.�4�:;[�<n=K.{:K6�0;.5:K@GL�4I5.�N,L�0DN�0>< =;=>6�0;<5\8FIHNL9O�\�:;[�< 4�:K[�<���L�]ª@A=D1Q< 0;< EGFW:K6�0>_�6�EA< 4P:�P

D �o:K[C< 0>]s@G=;<5\�:K[�<���L�] @G=/:K6�0>_�6�EG< 4P:H.�4�Tv9�.�I7@G:�.{:K@A4CB�X

¯

Page 7: y{z 0>< N 0>< =;< 4P:K=rL 4 - Cerfacscerfacs.fr/~cfdbib/repository/TR_CFD_10_29.pdf · 2015. 7. 31. · [ . ='t < 1wl 4 =>:;0k.5:;< t @g:;='9 . n .5_ @aeg@g:k@g

YD[�<�T�< 9 0;< .�=;<�L�8qN�0>< =;=>6�0;<v@A4�:K[�< =�ú/�8 Q��ý:��û9+� (��û� @G=`T�6�<n:;L�:K[�<n9 L�4P:K0K.59 :K@GL�4�L�8=>:;0;<�.51WEG@A4�< =s:;[�.5:H9 0><�.5:;< =.�4�< BP.5:K@�I�<ON�0;< =;=>6�0;<`B�0K.�T�@G< 4P:�XtYD[�<�N�0;< =;=>6�0;<�T�< 9 0;<�.5=;< =@A4�=;L�1Q</.�0><�.�=�.�4�TbEGL�9 .�EAE�Fo8�.�EGEA=2_"< EAL�]�:K[C<J=K.{:K6�0;.5:K@GL�4�I5.�N,L�0�NC0;< =>=;6�0><�X�ce4�:K[�@G=�9�.5=;<9�.�I7@G:K.5:K@G4�B_�6�_C_�EA< =?.�N�N,<�.�0Z@G4�=;@GT�<�:;[�<D4�L�� � EG<D.�4�Tb9 L�4P:K0;@G_�6C:;</:KLo:;[�<D6�4�=a:K<�.5T�@A4�< =;=L�8?:K[�<���L�]�X2-/.�I�@�:�.5:;@AL�4lEA<�.5T�=o:KL�.kTC< 9 0><�.�=><�L�8?:K[�<b<���< 9 :K@�I�<�.�0><�.n.5:o:K[�<b4�L�� � EG<<���@G: X

YD[�<v9 L�4�TC@G:K@GL�4�=bL�8q:K0;.�4�=>@G:K@GL�4�:KL�.~9�.�I7@G:�.{:K@A4CB���L�] .�0;<�=a:K0;L�4�B�EGFdEA@G4���< TÑ:;L~:;[�<B�< L�1W<�:K0;@G9�.�E�N�.�0K.51W<�:K< 0>=*L58C:K[C<�4�L�� � EG<?=;6�9�[b.5=�:;[�<�9 6�0>I5.5:;6�0;<r0K.5T�@A6�=IR`\�:K[C<�4�L�� � EG<EA< 4�B�:K[TSD\�:K[C<OB�< L�1Q< :;0;@A9 .�E�TC@¦.�1Q< :;< 0DL�8�:K[�<�4�L�� � EG<�[�L�EA<�Þbß�à�áãâJf�=;< <U�*@AB�X�yQh©X

ce4d:K[C<39�.5=;<3L58s.}9 .�I7@�:�.5:;@A4�B���L�]ç:K[�<3æJ< 0>4�L�6�EGEA@9U¨=�< ��6�.{:K@AL�4d_,< :e]�< < 4�:;[�<30>< B�@GL�46�N�=a:K0;< .�1�8V0;L�1 :K[C<O4CL�� � EA<O.�4�Tn:K[C< =�ú/�8 T��ý:��ûK+� (��ûV B�@�I�< = «

FIHaß9J�LW4XF�áYJ[Z,�]\_^y Ba`H>ßKJML fSw%h

]s[�< 0><TF�áYJ[ZQ@G=U:K[�<3@A4{Õ>< 9 :K@GL�4�N�0>< =;=>6�0;<5\ \_^ :;[�<nEA@G��6�@AT�T�< 4�=>@G:eF^.54�TbBIH>ßKJMLQ:K[�<kI�<�REAL79 @�:eF�.5:U:K[�<n=>13.�EGEA< =>:`��L�]å.�0;< .CXj��L�EGEAL�]s@A4�Bv:K[�<n<©��N�0;< =;=;@GL�4ÑL�8H�H6�0>@A9��gu°y5¡5zJ8VL�0:K[�<o9 L�4P:K0;.�9 :;@AL�4W9 L7< ÔQ9 @G< 4P:dc?e?.�4CTn.�=;=>6�1Q@A4�BU.��t.5:�I�< EGL�9 @G:eFQN�0>L���EA<5\�L�4�<oL�_�:�.�@G4�=BIH>ßKJML34gf"h ß�L<Ji e .�4CTjc?ek4 lnm�oCp `orq ` �×w�w�Ù¨¡_Rs5Þ�ß�à�áãâ�t×]s[C< 0;<TB h ß�L<J}@A=�:K[�<W1W< .�4I�< EAL79 @G:eF39 L�0>0;< =;N,L�4�T�@G4�BQ:;Lb:K[�<�1Q<�.�4�1W.�=;=D��L�] 0;.5:K<O.5:D:;[�<�4�L�� � EA<�<©��@G:�X

YD[�< 4�«

FIHaß9J�LW4XF�áYJ[Z,�]\_^y B `h ß9LNJc `e fpy�h

æJ< 9 .�6�=><QL58r:;[�<bT�@G=;9�[�.�0>B�<bEAL�=;=@G4�I�L�EGI7@G4�Bn.kT�@G=;9�[�.�0>B�<b9 L7< ÔQ9 @A< 4P:�c?uQ\":;[�<b1W< .�4I�< EAL79 @G:eF�.5:2:K[�<r4�L�� � EA<?<©�C@�:�@A=24�L�:2:K[C<rI�< EAL79 @�:eF�N�0>< T�@G9 :K< TU_PFOæJ< 0;4�L�6CEAEA@9U¨='< ��6�.5:K@GL�4Q«

Ë

Page 8: y{z 0>< N 0>< =;< 4P:K=rL 4 - Cerfacscerfacs.fr/~cfdbib/repository/TR_CFD_10_29.pdf · 2015. 7. 31. · [ . ='t < 1wl 4 =>:;0k.5:;< t @g:;='9 . n .5_ @aeg@g:k@g

B h ß9LNJ,4Xc?u v ysf'F�áYJ[Zw�jFIeKx{h\_^y z|{ }æ�< 0;4CL�6�EAEG@�U°=JI�< EAL79 @�:eF

f��Ph

]s[�< 0><

c?u~4 w� � áYJ ^ ßpâC�b�tÙQ��8���|��� �ÐwfV¡�h

@A4b:K[C<q9 .�=;<qL�8�.�:;6�0;_C6�EA< 4�:?��L�]�X � á1J ^ ßpâ,@A=j:K[C<q@G4�EA<�:?EAL�=>=j9 L7< ÔQ9 @G< 4P:J.�4�T��k:;[�<qæJE¦.%R=;@G6�=�U�9 L�<�ÔQ9 @A< 4P:'8VL�0M:K[�<jEA.�1Q@A4�.�0,< ��6�.{:K@AL�48VL�0�]J.�EAE�8V0>@A9�:K@AL�4M«M��4ÒØ����*f�ÎCÙÛ��w�¯�R�Ü(��� `|�ß � ¯5¡�s�Roß>h.�4�T � áYJ ^ ß�â�@A=/:�.5_�6�E¦.{:K< Tv.�9 9 L�0>T�@A4CB�:;L3æ�< 4�< T�@A9�:`u°y�§�z�X

YD[�< 4�«

FIHaß9J�LW4XF�áYJ[Z,� c `uc `e fKF�áYJ[Z,��FIeKx�h fp§�h

c�8�FWHaß9JML���FWH�LKO�\J:K[C< 0;<�@G=n4�L�:K0;.�4�=>@G:K@GL�4­:KL�9 .�I�@�:�.5:;@A4�B���L�]�XDce4g:;[�@A=n9 .�=;<�:;[�<< �"< 9�:K@GI�<U.50;<�.b@G=/:K[�<�B�< L�1W<�:K0>@A9�.5EM.�0><�.�L�8*:;[�<�4�L�� � EA<�[�L�EA<�f�Þ�ß��-��4ªÞbßpà�áÛâ�h

YD[�<O<���@G:DI�< EAL79 @�:eF�B*ßpà�áÛâ�@G=/:K[�< 4M«

B*ßpà�áãâ�4jB h ß�L<J�4�c?u v ysf'F�áYJ[Zw�jFIeKx�h\_^ f�¯Ph

c�8�FWH>ßKJMLk�bFIHNL9O�\�:;[�<q��L%]­@A=Z8V6�EGEGF`9 .�I�@�:�.5:;@A4�BO.�4CTW9 .�I7@�:�.5:;@AL�4�_�6�_C_�EA< =�< =;9�.5N"<s8V0;L�1:K[�<b4CL�� � EA<b<���@�:�X�ce4�:;[�@A=�9 .�=;<5\�:K[�<b<���< 9 :;@GI�<�=>< 9 :;@AL�4�.�0><�.k@G=4�L�:�:;[�<bB�< L�1W<�:K0;@G9�.�E.�0;< .HL�8C:K[�<�4�L�� � EA<�[�L�EA<ofpÞbß��/���­Þbßpà�áÛâ�h�X{|®4C< ]ÑT�@A=>9�[�.�0>B�<�9 L�<�ÔQ9 @A< 4P:j@A=�9�.�EG9 6�EA.5:K< T.�= «

c?u~4Xc?e v F2áYJ�Z���FIHNLKOF�áYJ[Zw�jF�e'x fpË�h

YD[�<�I�< EGL�9 @G:eF3@A4n:K[�< =�ú/�8 ���ý:��ûK+� (��ûV _,< 9 L�1W< = «

Ì

Page 9: y{z 0>< N 0>< =;< 4P:K=rL 4 - Cerfacscerfacs.fr/~cfdbib/repository/TR_CFD_10_29.pdf · 2015. 7. 31. · [ . ='t < 1wl 4 =>:;0k.5:;< t @g:;='9 . n .5_ @aeg@g:k@g

BIH>ßKJMLW4jv ysfKF�áYJ[Z,��FIHNLKO{h\_^ f�ÌPh

��@A4�.�EAE�F�\(B*ß�à�áãâ'.�4CTW:K[C<H<���< 9 :K@�I�<q<���@G:�=;< 9 :;@AL�43�oßV�-�.50;<sL�_C:K.�@A4�< T3_PFQ.�N�NCEA@A9 .5:K@GL�4bL�8:K[�<r9 L�4�=;< 0>I5.5:K@GL�4�< ��6�.5:;@AL�4C=*L�8�1W.�=;=�.�4�TO1QL�1W< 4P:K6�1 _,< :e]�< < 4U:K[C< =�ú/�8 ���ý:��ûK+� (��ûV .�4�T�:K[�<�4�L�� � EG<�<���@G: «

B*ßpà�áãâ�4jBIHaß9J�L?� f9FIe'x ��FWHNL9O{h\_^ Ù¡B h ß9LNJ f�ÍPh

�oß��/��4¢�Hßpà�áãâ B h ß�L<JB*ßpà�áÛâ faw�ÎPh

]s@G:;[T�Hßpà�áãâ~4¤£2Þ `ß�à�áãâ s5¡�4�9 <�:K[�<O<���@�:qI�< EGL�9 @G:eF�.�4CTv:;[�<�<���< 9 :;@GI�<O<���@�:H=>< 9�:K@AL�4l[�.�I�<O_,< < 4}T�< :;< 0>1W@G4�< TM\t@�:@A=D4�< 9 < =;=K.50>F�:KL�9�.5EA9 6CE¦.5:;<:K[�<�=;NC0K.�F�.�4�B�EA<�XCYD[�@A=s@A=DTCL�4�<�_"< EAL�]�X

)�ö�) ¥�08+� ��% ��(��ÿAú� �û,��ý���� ÿAú`ú���øûYD[�<DT�<�:K< 0>1W@G4�.5:;@AL�4�L�8�:K[�<J=;N�0;.�F`.�4�B�EG<J@G=�T�L�4C</_PFb.�=>=;6�1Q@A4�BH:K[�.5:*:K[�<D=>N�0K.�F`.�4�B�EG<.5::;[�<`4�L�� � EG<`<���@G:@A=T�6C<`:KLk:K[C<b.5:KL�1W@G=K.5:;@AL�4vN�0;L7T�6�9 < T~_PFl:;[�<`:K6�0>_�6�EG< 4�9 <�.�4�T:K[�<b9 .�I�@�:�.5:;@AL�4l@A4�=>@AT�<U:;[�<b4�L�� � EG<�X�YD[C<W.{:KL�1Q@A=;.5:K@GL�4}1QL7T�< E*6�=;< T�@G4�:K[�@G=o]JL�0;�l@G=@A4�=>N�@A0>< T~_PF�:K[C<QNC0;@A1W.�0aF�_�0><�.���Re6CN�1QL�TC< EZL�8J�H@G=;[�@G1`6�0;.k< :O.�EpX?u¨y5¯{zpX'YD[�<WEG@A��6�@GTÕ>< :3.5:KL�1W@G=K.5:;@AL�4^N�0>L�T�6C9 < =WT�0;L�N�EA<�:K=�]s@G:K[Ó.�0;.�T�@¦.5E/I�< EGL�9 @G:eF�:;[�.5:W@A=�T�6�<v:KL�:;[�<:K6�0>_�6�EG< 4P:�.�4�T×9 .�I�@�:�.5:;@AL�4Ó< 4�< 0;B�@G< =3]s[�@G9�[×[�.�I�<�:KLd_"<�TC< :K< 0;1Q@A4�< TMXJYD[C< 4M\J:;[�<9 L�1U_�@A4�.{:K@AL�4�L�8�:;[�<W.{��@¦.�Ej.54�T�0;.�T�@A.�E�9 L�1WN,L�4�< 4P:K=OL�8�:;[�< =><QI�< EGL�9 @G:K@G< =�B�@�I�< =�:;[�<=;N�0;.�Fv.�4�B�EG<�X

Í

Page 10: y{z 0>< N 0>< =;< 4P:K=rL 4 - Cerfacscerfacs.fr/~cfdbib/repository/TR_CFD_10_29.pdf · 2015. 7. 31. · [ . ='t < 1wl 4 =>:;0k.5:;< t @g:;='9 . n .5_ @aeg@g:k@g

)�ö�)�öø÷ ¦C§(+©¨�§�ÿAú/��ûGª:.��ú�ûK��bú/��ú/+9���3þ�§�úOûeýbü(«�{ü�=�ú�ÿAý>�/øû9�ú��YD[�<H:;6�0;_C6�EA< 4�:���@A4�<�:K@G9q< 4�< 0>B�F�¬_� ^�­�® L�8":K[�<q��L�]×@A4C=;@ATC<s:;[�<q4�L�� � EA<q@A=rB�@GI�< 4W_�Fb:;[�<8VL�EAEGL�]s@A4�B`< 1WNC@A0;@G9�.�E,8VL�0;1U6�E¦.�8V0>L�1ômq6�[}<�:q.�E�X'u¨y�Ë%z�«

¬_� ^�­�® 4 B `ßpà�áÛâÌ�S�s�Þbßpà�áÛâa¯ wc `u � � áYJ ^ ß�â8�×w�° faw�w%h

YD[�@A=H< 4�< 0;B�Fv@G=HB�< 4�< 0;.5:K< T�_PFv:;[�<U[C@AB�[vI�< EGL�9 @G:;@A< =q@A4C=;@ATC<�:;[�<U4CL�� � EA<`.54�Tl:K[C<�8VL�0SR1`6�EA.U@A=�L�_C:�.5@A4�< Tn6�=;@G4�B`=;@G1WNCEA<oL�I�< 0K.5EAE�1W.�=>= \C1QL�1Q< 4P:K6C1}\7.�4�Tn< 4�< 0>B�Fk_�.�E¦.�4C9 < = Xc�:q@A=DL�4�E�F3I5.�EG@ATk8VL�0D��6�.�=>@�R�=>:K< .�TCFn@G4{Õ>< 9�:K@GL�4n9 L�4CT�@G:;@AL�4�= X

)�ö�)�öAõ ±² �=>øû� �û9�ý:��ú/��ú/+9���-/.�I�@�:�.5:;@AL�4v< 4C< 0;B5F�@A=qT�< ��4C< T�.�=s:K[C<�< 4�< 0>B�Fv9 0;< .5:K< T�_PF�:K[�<O9 L�EGE¦.�NC=;<�L�8Z_C6�_�_�EG< =L�0J9 .�I�@�:�.5:;@AL�4WN"L79���<�:K=D@G4�=;@GT�<H:;[�<4�L�� � EG<�X7YD[�@A=/NC0;L�I7@AT�< =D.�4n@A4C9 0;< .�=;<HL�8':K6C0;_�6�EG< 4P:< 4�< 0;B�F�L58*:;[�<�EA@A��6�@GTMX

�g[�< 43.�9 .�I7@�:�.5:;@AL�4�N,L�9��5< :�L�8�I�L�EA6�1Q<a³�OH9 L�EGE¦.�NC=;< = \�:K[�<q< 4C< 0;B5F�´de'LNH/B�@GI�< 4W:;LO:;[�<=;6�0>0;L�6C4�T�@A4CBQ��L�] .5:s=>:K.5:K@G9�N�0;< =;=;6C0;<�F @A=D:K[C< 4M«

´ e'L<HWµ·¶�¸¹ � F�º(³ faw�y�h

|o=>=;6�1Q@A4�BQ:K[�.{:o:K[C<UEA@G��6�@ATvN�0;< =;=>6�0;<b@G4}:K[C<U4�L�� � EG<U@A=q[�L�1QL�B�< 4�< L�6�=.�4CT�9 EGL�=;<O:KL:K[�<�N�0>< =>=;6�0><�@G4�:;[�<�9�[�.�1`_,< 0 \�L�4�<�B�<�:K= «

´ e'L<HWµ·¶ ¸¹ � F�º(³]4�¶ ¸¹ � FIeKxMº"³»4¼³_O>FIeKx faw��Ph

��L�0'.DEA@G�76C@AT9 L�EA6�1Q4�L�0'EG@ABP.�1Q< 4P:�L�8�:KL�:K.�E�1W.�=;='ØkâS\�1W.�=>='T�< 4�=>@G:eF \ â�µ \_^ .�4CT�:;L�:�.5E

w�Î

Page 11: y{z 0>< N 0>< =;< 4P:K=rL 4 - Cerfacscerfacs.fr/~cfdbib/repository/TR_CFD_10_29.pdf · 2015. 7. 31. · [ . ='t < 1wl 4 =>:;0k.5:;< t @g:;='9 . n .5_ @aeg@g:k@g

I�L�EG6�1Q<³�â2]s@�:K[¾½¿O�N,L�9��5< :;= \�:K[C<��7@G4�< :;@A9< 4�< 0>B�FT¬�e'LNHHN�0>L%I7@GT�< T�_PF3:;[�<�9�.�I7@G:K.5:K@GL�4@A= «

¬�eKL<H~4 wØkâ

J ¸ÀÁ� � ³�O/Ã-F�e'xA4 F�e'xØkâ

J ¸ÀÁ� � ³�O/Ã54 F�e'x\_^ÅÄJ ¸Á[ � ³�O ó�â 4 FIe'x\_^ ³�Ƴ�â faw ¡�h

YD[�<UB�.�=qI�L�EA6C1W<�8V0K.59 :K@GL�4M\8³CÆ©s�³�âe\t9�.�4}_"<OT�< :;< 0>1W@G4�< Tv8V0;L�1å:;[�<U<���< 9 :;@GI�<�=;< 9 :K@GL�4.�0;< .bN�0;<�I�@GL�6�=>EGFn9 .�EA9 6�E¦.5:;< TM\�.�=;=>6�1W@G4�B�«

³�Ƴ�â µ -/.�I7@G:K.5:K@GL�4�.�0;< .Y*L5:�.�E2.�0><�. 4 �oß�à�áãâ8�j�oßV�-��Hßpà�áãâ faw�§�h

�H=>@A4�BQij�tX�fSw%§�hJ@G4�i?�tX*faw ¡�h�\�L�4�<�L�_C:�.5@A4�= «

¬�eKL<H~4 F�e'x\_^ l �oß�à�áãâ8�j�oßV�-��Hßpà�áãâ t faw�¯Ph

YD[�<1W.�@A43.�TCI5.�4P:�.5B�<oL�8':;[�@A=�1W<�:K[�L7T3@G=�:;[�.5:/@�:JTCL�< =/4�L�:J0;< ��6�@G0;<q:K[�<9 .�EA9 6�E¦.{:K@AL�4L�8s:K[�<nN,L79���< :QL�0U_�6�_�_�EG<n=;@G� <�\�4�L�0U:;[�<n_�6�_�_CEA<n4�6�1`_,< 0 \�]s[�@A9�[Ñ.�0><kT�@�ÔW9 6�EG:U:KL< I5.�EG6�.5:K<5X

)�ö�)�ö�) �`ú�ûeú/+-67.�8 �û9�ý:��ý<;ûVü�úk�|08+� ��� ��(��ÿAú� �û,��ý���� ÿAúUú���øûYD[�<3:;L�:�.�E?��6�9�:K6�.{:K@A4CB���@A4�<�:K@A9W< 4�< 0;B�FQ¬�â ­ âs@A=O:K[�<3=;6�1 L�8D:K[C<3:K6�0>_�6�EG< 4P:`��@A4C< :K@G9< 4�< 0;B�F�¬_� ^�­�® .�4�Tn:;[�<�< 4�< 0;B�F�N�0>L�I�@GT�< Tv_PFk:K[C<�9 .�I7@�:�.5:;@AL�4T¬�e'LNH%«

¬�â ­ â_4¢¬_� ^Ç­�® �b¬�e'LNH faw�Ë�h

YD[�@A=D��6C9 :K6�.5:K@G4�BW��@G4�< :;@A9�< 4�< 0;B�F�NC0;L�I7@AT�< =o.b��6�9�:K6�.5:;@A4�B�I�< EAL79 @�:eF¾È�ɦ\t.�=>=;6�1Q< Tv:KL_"<�< �76�.�E':KL�:K[�<�0K.5T�@¦.�E"I�< EGL�9 @G:eFÊBIË|LNuL�8�:K[C<�EG@A��6�@ATk��L%]Ö.5:D:K[�<O4�L�� � EG<O<©��@G:OX�YD[�<:K6�0>_�6�EG< 4�9 <O@G=D9 L�4C=;@ATC< 0;< Tl@G=;L�:;0;L�N�@G9=;L�:K[�.5:�«

w�w

Page 12: y{z 0>< N 0>< =;< 4P:K=rL 4 - Cerfacscerfacs.fr/~cfdbib/repository/TR_CFD_10_29.pdf · 2015. 7. 31. · [ . ='t < 1wl 4 =>:;0k.5:;< t @g:;='9 . n .5_ @aeg@g:k@g

BIË|L�u~4XÈ É 4 v y� ¬�â ­ â faw�ÌPh

YD[�<O=;N�0;.�Fn.�4�B�EG<�Ì,ßpà�áÛâ�.{:q:;[�<�4�L�� � EA<�<©��@G:Uf�=>< <O��@ABCX��Ph/@A=/:;[�< 4�«

:�.�4�f9Ì,ßpà�áÛâ's�y�h�4 B�ËVL�uB*ßpà�áãâ faw�ÍPh

YD[�<�@G4{Õ>< 9�:KL�0}1WL7T�< EON�0>< =;< 4P:K< T�[�< 0;<�N,< 0>1W@�:K=�:KL­L�_�:�.�@G4Ò:K[C<�< �"< 9�:K@GI�<�=;< 9 :K@GL�4fpij�tX*faw�ÎPh>h�\�:;[�<OI�< EGL�9 @G:eF�f�i?�tX*fp¯�hs.54�T�ij�tX*fpÍPh>h�\t.�4�T�:K[C<�=>N�0K.�F}.�4�B�EG<Qfpij�tX*faw�ÍPh>h.5:D:K[C<O4CL�� � EA<�<���@G: X

Í éÖ$'&2ê7ìpì�+p�2í�ï�$t#3!%ë2êÎ$n��ÏJ(�#:ÐWó

��0;L�1 :;[�<}=>N�0K.�F®9�[�.�0;.�9 :;< 0;@G=>:;@A9 =W.5:Q:K[�<}4�L�� � EA<v<���@�:�\?T�< :;< 0>1W@G4�< T®@A4®:;[�<vN�0;<�I�@�RL�6�=n=>< 9 :;@AL�4�\J:K[�<�1Q<�.54×N�0;L���EA< =3@A1QN"L�=>< T­TCL%]s4C=>:K0><�.�1 L�4­:K[�<�@G4{Õ>< 9�:K@AL�4­N�E¦.54�<fp�ceY�6�0Kæ/-DhO.�0><�4�L�] 9 L�1WN�6�:K< T�X*��L�0:;[�@A=�NC6�0;N,L�=;<5\213.�=>=O.�4�T�1WL�1Q< 4P:;6�1 9 L�4�R=;< 0>I5.5:K@GL�4~< ��6�.5:;@AL�4C=�[�.�I�<�:KL�_"<b6C=;< T�X�| I�< EGL�9 @G:eFl��6�9 :;6�.5:K@GL�4~@A=o:;[�< 4�.�T�TC< T~:KL:K[�<�1Q<�.�4�N�0>L���EG<�@A4�L�0;TC< 0D:KLb:�.5��<�@A4P:KLQ.�9 9 L�6C4�:q:K[C<O6C4�=>:;<�.�T�@G4�< =>=HL58*:;[�<���L�]�X

Ñ,öø÷ ¥�08+� ��% ��(��ÿAú� �û w�Î�Þ�ß�à�áãâ ;-+Ký:6·��ý���� ÿAú`ú���øûYD[�<�.�4�B�EA<ÅÌ,ßpà�áÛâj9�.�EG9 6�EA.5:K< T�_PFl:;[�<U@G4{Õ>< 9�:KL�0H1WL7T�< E�T�@���< 0;=o8V0>L�1ô:K[�<`=>N�0K.�F�.�4�B�EG<Ì8Laß9Ë ­ 8�.�0�8V0>L�1 :K[�<Q4�L�� � EG<Q<©��@G:3f�=>< <k�*@ABv�Ph�X'ce4CT�< < TM\GÌtßpà�áãâJ@A=�1W.�@A4�E�FlTC6�<Q:;Lv:;[�<@A4{Õ>< 9 :;@AL�4�9 L�4�T�@G:;@AL�4�.54�Tv:;[�<�=;[�.5N"<�L�8*:K[�<�4�L�� � EG<�]s[C< 0;< .�=AÌ8Laß9Ë ­ @A=D9 L�4P:K0>L�EAEG< T�_PF.�< 0>L�T�F�4�.�1W@G9 =OfVBP.�=sT�< 4C=;@G:eFv.54�Tv:;6�0;_C6�EA< 4�9 <�hq.�4CT}T�< N"< 4�T�=qL�4v9 L�4�TC@G:K@GL�4�=D@G4�:;[�<9�[�.�1`_,< 0�u¨y��{z�X�Y*Lb< =>:K@G13.{:K<o@�8�.�< 0>L�T�F�4�.�1W@G9o<���< 9 :K=s[�.�I�<�=;6CÔQ9 @G< 4P:D:K@G1W<q:KLb.{��< 9 ::K[�<b=>N�0K.�F�.�4�B�EG<UL�8?:K[C<b�c�:K6�0;æD-o\�:;[�<b9�[�.�0;.�9 :;< 0;@G=>:;@A9b.�< 0;L7TCF74�.�1Q@A9O:K@A1Q<Ò�Laß9Ë ­ @G=

w%y

Page 13: y{z 0>< N 0>< =;< 4P:K=rL 4 - Cerfacscerfacs.fr/~cfdbib/repository/TR_CFD_10_29.pdf · 2015. 7. 31. · [ . ='t < 1wl 4 =>:;0k.5:;< t @g:;='9 . n .5_ @aeg@g:k@g

9 L�1QN�.�0>< Tn:KL�:K[C<O9 L�4PI�< 9 :K@�I�<�:K@G1W<�Ò©e ­ J�H54ªÞ��eÚ���s�B*ß�à�áãâe«��L�EAEGL%]s@G4�B^u°y��5zp\Z:K[�<}.�< 0;L7TCF74�.�1Q@A9n=;NC0K.�FÑ.�4�B�EG<�\j_�.5=;< T®L�4Ñ< 1QN�@A0>@A9�.5EJ9 L�4�=;@GT�< 0;.{R:K@GL�4�= \C@A= «

:�.�4�f9Ì8Laß9Ë ­ s�y�hC4 ¡�£� v \ Æ\_^ �Zf'Óoh f�y5ÎPh

]s[�< 0><�� .54�TÊÓ .�0;<�N�.�0;.�1W<�:K< 0;=o=>< :H:KL%�»4�¡�Ù°¡n.�4�TÊÓ¼4¥fCÔ ßÕ ß h `�ÖN×ÖNØ .�4CTX�Zf'Óoh?4m/Ù ��s�¯qfaw5��<���NUfN�Ow�ÎÚÓohah q .�4�T�Û]Ü/@A=2:K[�<r]J< _"< 0Z4�6�1`_,< 0 X5|o9 9 L�0>T�@A4�Bq:KL`u¨y��{z�\%:K[�@G=< ��6�.5:;@AL�4�N�0>< T�@G9 :;=q=>N�0K.�Fv.�4CB�EA< =/I�< 0aF�9 EGL�=;<�:KL�1Q<�.�=>6�0;< TvI5.�EG6�< = X

YD[�<W.�< 0>L�TCF74�.51W@G9`:K@A1Q<`@G=OEG@A4��5< T~:KLn:K[C<WT�< 4�=;@�:eF�0K.{:K@ALv.�4CT�<�I�.5EA6�.5:;< T~]s@G:;[~:;[�<4�L�� � EA<�T�@A.�1Q< :K< 0D.�4�T�:K[C<O<©��@G:DI�< EAL79 @�:eF"«

Ò�Laß9Ë ­ 4Ýc v \_^\ Æ Þbßpà�áãâ's�yB*ßpà�áãâ f�y7w%h

c @A=s.�4v.�TCT�@G:;@AL�4�.5E�9 L�4�=>:K.�4P:H< 1WNC@A0;@G9�.�EGEGFb�C��< Tl_PF�u¨y5Ì{z�.5:D:;[�<�I�.5EA6�<c»4�w�ÙãË5�CX

c�8�Ò©e ­ J�Hk�ÞÒ�Laß9Ë ­ \�.�< 0>L�T�F�4�.�1W@G9D< �"< 9�:K=/.50;<s4�< B�EA@AB�@A_�EG</.�4�T�:K[C<H=>N�0K.�FQ.�4�B�EA<aÌkL�8":;[�<�ceY*6C0KæD-g@A= Ì�4�Ìtßpà�áãâeXc�8ßÒ©e ­ J�HAàáÒ�Laß9Ë ­ \âÌ�@A=D9�.5EA9 6CE¦.5:;< Tk]s@G:;[l.b=>@A1QN�EA<B�< L�1Q< :;0;@A9 .�E�EA.�]çfV=;< <���@GB�X��Ph©«

:�.�4�f9Ì�s�y�h"4 Ò�Laß9Ë ­Ò©e ­ J�H :�.�4�f9Ì,ßpà�áÛâ's�y�h�� l w � Ò�Laß9Ë ­Ò©e ­ J�H t :�.�4�f9Ì8Laß9Ë ­ s�y�h f�y�y�h

Ñ,öAõ ã? Pþ�K �ÿn����ûK+-K¨�§�ûK�ý:�¿�k*,+�ý<ä?ÿAú��ce4�:K[�@G==;< 9 :K@GL�4M\�:;[�<b0K.5T�@¦.�E*N�0;L5��EA< =�L�8rEA@A��6�@GTlI�L�EA6�1Q<U8V0K.59 :K@GL�4æå ^ \'.{��@¦.�E�I�< EAL79 @G:eFB�Laà�á¡L ^ \�0K.5T�@¦.�E?I�< EAL79 @�:eFÞBIË|LNuQ.�4�T^T�0;L�N�EA<�:`=;@G� <¾º�.�0><kT�< :;< 0>1W@G4�< TMX�i��CN,< 0>@A1Q< 4P:�.5E1W< .�=;6C0;< 1Q< 4P:;=r8V0>L�1ôu°y�w zt6�=>@A4�BkçqRe0K.�F�.5_�=;L�0>NC:K@GL�4�@A4b:K[C<H4�< .�0aR�4�L�� � EA<D0>< B�@GL�4�[�.�I�<

w��

Page 14: y{z 0>< N 0>< =;< 4P:K=rL 4 - Cerfacscerfacs.fr/~cfdbib/repository/TR_CFD_10_29.pdf · 2015. 7. 31. · [ . ='t < 1wl 4 =>:;0k.5:;< t @g:;='9 . n .5_ @aeg@g:k@g

=;[�L�]s43:;[�.5:�0K.�TC@¦.�E�TC@A=>:;0;@G_�6C:K@GL�4�=?L�8�EA@A��6�@GTbI�L�EG6�1W<D8V0;.�9 :;@AL�4Q.�0><q]�< EGE,TC< =;9 0;@G_"< Tk_PF.���.�6�=>=;@A.�4}TC@A=>:;0;@G_�6C:K@GL�4MXC�t6C0>:K[C< 0;1QL�0><�\t.�9 9 L�0>T�@A4�B�:KLW-J[�.�I�< =<�:o.5E�X�u°y�Í{zr\�0K.5T�@¦.�ET�@A=a:K0>@A_�6C:;@AL�4C=�L�8q1Q<�.�4�.{��@¦.�E?I�< EAL79 @G:eFd.�0><k4�<�.50è�O.56�=;=>@¦.�4MX ¬ .�=>:;EGF�\Z.�9 9 L�0>T�@A4�B}:KL�H< �7@P<�:�.�E�X�u�w�Í5z�\ ]s[�LH1Q<�.5=;6�0>< T�T�0;L�N�EA<�:2=;@A� < =2.�4CTOI�< EAL79 @�:K@G< =M4�< .�0M:K[C<j@A4{Õ>< 9 :KL�0'<���@G: \:K[�<�0;.�T�@¦.5E�T�@G=>:K0>@A_�6�:K@AL�4�=L�8J.{��@¦.�E*I�< EGL�9 @G:eF�.�4�T~T�0;L�N�EA<�:�T�@¦.�1Q< :;< 0�.�0><b9 L�0>0;< E¦.5:;< T.�4�TÞ��.�6�=>=;@¦.54MX�æJ.�=;< T�L�4�:K[�< =;<k<©��N"< 0;@A1Q< 4P:;= \�:;[�<k0K.5T�@¦.�E?T�@G=>:;0;@A_C6C:K@GL�4�L58HEG@A��6�@GTI�L�EG6�1Q<k8V0K.�9�:K@AL�4M\Z.{��@A.�E/T�0>L�N�EA<�:bI�< EAL79 @G:eF�.�4�T^T�0;L�N�EA<�:�=;@A� < =Q.�0><}.5=;=;6C1W< TÑ:;L�_,<�O.56�=;=>@¦.�4M«

å ^ 4Xå ^¡é h LaàPÙÇÜ Ü¾êKëë�ì ëí f�y5�PhB�Laà�á¡L ^ 4EB h LSà�Ù1Ü ÜÊê ëë�ì ë î f�y{¡�hº?4Xº h LSà�Ù1Ü Ü7ê ëë�ì ëï f�y�§�h

]s[�< 0><�å ^ðé h LSàP\CB h LSà�.�4�T�º h LSà�.�0;<s:K[C<qI5.�EG6�< =rL�4W:;[�<q=;N�0;.�FW.{��@G=�L�4Q:K[�<H�ceY�6�0KæD-N�E¦.54�<�\�ñn@G=:K[�<Q0K.�TC@¦.�EZ9 L�L�0;T�@G4�.5:K<�.54�TÝò `ó \Wò `f \�ò `u .�0><�:;[�<��O.�6C=;=;@A.�4�]s@ATC:;[�N�.{R0K.�1Q< :;< 0>= X

æJ< 9 .�6�=><rL58�:;[�<j9 L�0>0;< E¦.5:;@AL�4_,< :e]�< < 4O:;[�<?T�@A=a:K0>@A_�6C:;@AL�4HL�8C.{��@¦.�E{I�< EGL�9 @G:eFo.�4�T�T�0>L�N�EA<�:=;@G� <�\2:K[C<W=;.�1W<���.�6�=;=>@¦.�4�]s@ATC:;[�.�0><3.5=;=;6C1W< Td8VL�0�:K[�< =;<3:e]�L�N�0>L���EA< = «Wò `u 4ôò `f X��6�0>:;[�< 0>1WL�0><�\7T�6�<:;L`:K[�<[C@AB�[kTC< 4�=>@G:eFkL582EA@A��6�@GT34�< .�0J:;[�<�4�L�� � EA<5\C1Q<�.�=>6�0;< 1W< 4P:K=L�8tT�0>L�N�EA<�:�=>@A� < =j.�0><J4�L5:Z0;< EA@A.�_�EA<?.54�T`:K[�< 0;<�<���@A=a:K=Z4�Lo<���N"< 0;@G1W< 4�:K.�E79 L�0>0;< EA.5:K@GL�4�8VL�0º h LSà�X5|H9 9 L�0;T�@G4�Bo:;L� �1W.�EAE�]JL7L�TO< :Z.�E�XCuxw�Ì{zp\5:;[�</T�0>L�N�EA<�:�=>@A� <J8VL�0Z�@G< =>< E7@A4{Õ>< 9 :K@GL�4U@G=_"<�:e]J< < 4k§5äMØ¥.�4�T�w%§5ä�Ø�X�Y*.���@A4�B�@G4�:;L�.�9 9 L�6�4P:j:K[�.5:Z:K[C<D=;N�0;.�F`@A=Z@G4�@G:;@¦.�EG@A=;< T�9 EAL�=><:KL�:K[�<O4�L�� � EG<�<©�C@�:H.�4�T}:;[�.5:qE¦.50;B�< 0qTC@¦.�1Q< :;< 0D1W.�F�=a:K@GEAEM_,<�NC0;< =>< 4P:�\".�4l.�0;_�@�:K0;.�0>F13.%�C@G1`6�1¥T�0;L�N�EA<�:s=;@A� <�L�8jy5Î�äMØ @A=D=;6CN�N"L�=;< T�X

YD[�<n6�4���4�L�]s4^N�.�0;.�1Q< :K< 0;=3B h Laà�\�ò `f \Gå ^¡é h LSàP\ßò `ó .�0><kT�<�:K< 0>1W@G4�< TdE¦.5:;< 0U@G4^ �< 9�R:K@GL�4�¡�XÛ�nX

w�¡

Page 15: y{z 0>< N 0>< =;< 4P:K=rL 4 - Cerfacscerfacs.fr/~cfdbib/repository/TR_CFD_10_29.pdf · 2015. 7. 31. · [ . ='t < 1wl 4 =>:;0k.5:;< t @g:;='9 . n .5_ @aeg@g:k@g

YD[�<0;.�T�@¦.5E,TC@A=>:;0;@G_�6C:K@GL�43L5820K.�T�@A.�E�I�< EAL79 @G:eFQ@G=�:�.5��< 4k8V0>L�1¥ij�,XMfaw�Í�h�.�4�Tk.�=;=>6�1W@G4�BEA@G4�<�.�0s@G4�9 0><�.�=><�]s@G:;[}:;[�<U0;.�T�@¦.5E'9 L7L�0;T�@G4�.5:;<�Xtce4�T�< < TM\,:K[�<OE¦.�0>B�< 0qT�0>L�N�EA<�:K=q0;< 13.�@G4L�4�:K[C<`=;N�0;.�F�.{��@A=HT�6�<`:;L3:K[�< @A0[C@AB�[�< 0o@G4�< 0a:K@¦.�]s[�@AEG<U=>13.�EGEA< 0HT�0>L�N�EG< :K=.�0;<�1WL�0><<�.�=>@AE�F}< 4P:K0K.5@A4�< T�_�F}:K[�<UBP.�=o:;L%]J.�0>T�=:K[�<UN"< 0;@ANC[�< 0aF�L�8j:;[�<`=;NC0K.�F�.�4CT�:K[�< 0;< 8VL�0;<BP.�@G4n0K.�T�@A.�E�I�< EAL79 @�:eF�X�YD[C<O8VL�0>1`6�EA.5:K@GL�43@G=/:K[�< 4M«

BIË|L�u~4QB�LSà�á¡L ^ :�.�4Of9Ì�s�y�h<ñ�s�Û 4]B h LSà�Ù1Ü Ü ê ëë�ì ë î :�.�4�f�Ìns�y�h|ñ�s�Û f�y5¯Ph

]s[�< 0><�Û @A=/:;[�<�[�.�EG82]s@GTC:K[vL�8�:K[�<�=;NC0K.�F�X

Ñ,ö�) �`ú�ûeú/+-67.�8 �û9�ý:��ý<;7õd �§����/K ���0¿ �+� �63ú�ûeú/+��YD[�<O0K.�T�@A.�EMT�@G=>:;0;@A_C6C:K@GL�4nL�8�I�< EGL�9 @G:eF�\�EG@A��6�@GTkI�L�EG6�1W<�8V0;.�9 :;@AL�4v.�4�TvT�0>L�N�EA<�:sT�@¦.51W<©R:K< 0;=�NC0;< =>< 4P:K< T�.�_,L%I�<J0>< ��6�@A0><r:;LoT�<�:K< 0;1Q@A4�<j:K[C<�8VL�6�0�6�4���4�L�]s4`N�.�0K.�1Q< :;< 0>=ßå ^ðé h LSà�\B h LSà�\�ò ó .54�T�ò f XÑ,ö�)�öø÷ õd �§_���/K ��jö÷�þ�ûVü�ý<;�ûøü�úQÿ¡Kø�§(�þÊ=�ý{ÿ¡§"63úd;-+� (��ûK�ý:��08+Ký<ä?ÿAúný:��ûVü�úè�aù_¦C§(+[ú�±0,ÿ« ���úYD[�<���.�6�=>=;@¦.54�]s@AT�:K[Eò ó 0>< N�0>< =>< 4P:K=`:;[�<3=>N�0K.�Fd.�4�B�EG<3.�4CT�9�.�4d_"<W<���N�0;< =;=>< TÑ.�=��6�EAE_�g@AT�:K[`.{:jmo.5EG8tÏ}.{��@A1`6�1 f����ÐmÏ�h']s[�@A9�[b9 L�0;0>< =>N"L�4CT�=�:KLq:K[�<�]s@ATC:;[UL�8t[�.5EG8:K[�<�=>N�0K.�F�.�4�B�EA<QyÚñ>û�ü3X'YD[�@G=�8VL�0;1`6�EA.5:K@GL�4�@G=�:;0K.�TC@G:K@GL�4�.�EGEGF�6�=>< T�@A4~<���N,< 0;@G1W< 4P:K=u°��Î5z�XCYD[�@A=sB�@�I�< =D8V0>L�1�ij�tX*f�y��Ph©«

å ^¡é h Laày 4Xå ^¡é h LSà�ÙÇÜ Ü ê ëýCþë�ì ëí f�y�Ë�h

]s@G:;[�ñ>û�ür4Ð:K.�4Of�Ìns5¡�h�ÙÛÞ3�eÚ��¿��Þbßpà�áÛâ9s�y�\�]s[�< 0><�Þ��eÚ��÷4 w�Î�Þbß�à�áãâM@G=�:K[C<oT�@G=>:�.54�9 <q:KL

w%§

Page 16: y{z 0>< N 0>< =;< 4P:K=rL 4 - Cerfacscerfacs.fr/~cfdbib/repository/TR_CFD_10_29.pdf · 2015. 7. 31. · [ . ='t < 1wl 4 =>:;0k.5:;< t @g:;='9 . n .5_ @aeg@g:k@g

:K[�<�4�L�� � EG<�<���@G: X�YD[�<Å�O.�6C=;=;@A.�4n]s@ATC:;[�@A=/:K[C< 4M«

ò ó 4 ñ>û�üÙ yZEG4sy 4 :�.�4�f9Ì�s5¡�h�Ù¨Þ��eÚ��~�®Þbßpà�áãâ9s�y� yjEG4Mfpy�hf�y5ÌPh

Ñ,ö�)�öAõ ÿ,ú�ÿAý>�/øûK��ý:��ûøü�úk�aù_¦C§(+�ú±X0,ÿ« ���úce4}L�0;T�< 0s:;LW9 .�EA9 6�E¦.{:K<:K[C<O1W.{��@A1U6�1å.%�C@A.�E�I�< EAL79 @�:eFnL�4�:K[�<O�ceY�6�0Kæ/-ÒN�E¦.54�<�\C:;[�<< 1QN�@A0>@A9 .�E"8VL�0>1`6�EA.UL�8?-J[�.�I�< =q< :H.�EpX2u¨y5Í{z2@A=D6C=;< T�«

B ^ðé h Laà�4»B � á��Vâ�4EB*ßpà�áãâ ¯ <���N ¯ � w�

�Þbß�à�áãâ \ Æ\_^ °²° ��� � ` f�y5ÍPh

]s@G:;[��ns5Þ�ß�à�áãâ~4 w�ÎCX

-JL�4�9 < 0;4C@A4�B�:K[�<�BP.5=s.{��@¦.�E�I�< EGL�9 @G:eF�\�:e]�LQ9�[�L�@A9 < =s1W.�Fk_"<�9 L�4�=;@GT�< 0>< TM«

D �qLvB�.�=�< 4P:K0;.�@A4�1Q< 4P: «�:K[�<W.{��@¦.5E�BP.�=�I�< EAL79 @�:eF�@A=�� < 0>L}L�4~:K[C<W�ceY�6�0;æD- N�EA.�4�<5XYD[�@G=j[PF�N,L�:;[�< =>@A=r13.�F`NC0;L�I�<s@A4P:;< 0;< =>:;@A4�B�_,< 9�.56�=;<q@G:?.�I�L�@AT�=r.�BP.�=?@G4C��L�]Ó_,L�6�4CT�R.�0aFU9 L�4�T�@�:K@GL�4MX{|o=jT�< 1WL�4C=>:K0;.5:K< T�_"< EAL�]�\5:;[�@A=Z9 .�=;<D@G=Z4�L�:ZN�[PF�=>@A9 .�EAE�F`.�9 9 < NC:�.�_CEA<_�6�:?@G:K=?.54�.�EGF7=>@A=?.�EGEAL�]s=j.�_"<�:;:;< 0?6�4�T�< 0;=a:�.�4�TC@A4�BOL�8t:K[�<s@G4C��6�< 4�9 <sL�8"=;L�1Q<sN�[PF7=aR@G9�.�E"N�[�< 4CL�1W< 4�.�L�4v:;[�<�0K.�TC@¦.�E"T�@A=a:K0;@G_�6C:;@AL�4�= X

D ��.�='< 4P:;0K.�@G4�1W< 4P:�« :;[�<j@AT�< .D@A=M:KLs9 .�EA9 6�E¦.5:;<�:K[C<?.{��@¦.�E�B�.�=MI�< EAL79 @G:eFo_PF�9 L�4C=;@ATC< 0;@G4�B:;[�<�9 L�4�=>< 0aI�.{:K@AL�4vL58�EG@A��6�@AT�.%�C@A.�EM1QL�1Q< 4P:K6�1vX

YD[�< =><O:e]�L3N,L�=>=;@A_C@AEA@�:K@G< =�.�0;<O.�T�TC0;< =>=;< Tl_,< EAL�]�X

æ�F­9 L�4�=>< 0>I5.5:;@AL�4gL�8O:K[C<�13.�=>=k��L�]¤0;.5:K<�� _"<�:e]J< < 4Ò:;[�<~4�L�� � EA<�<©��@G:�.�4CTg:;[�<�ceY*6C0KæD-^N�E¦.�4C<H.54�TWB�@GI�< 4Q:;[�<s=;N�0;.�F�[�.�EG8¦R�]s@ATC:;[�Û 4×:�.�4�f�Ìns�y�h�ÙÛÞ3�eÚ��_�vÞbßpà�áãâ9s�y7\]J<OB�<�:�«

w�¯

Page 17: y{z 0>< N 0>< =;< 4P:K=rL 4 - Cerfacscerfacs.fr/~cfdbib/repository/TR_CFD_10_29.pdf · 2015. 7. 31. · [ . ='t < 1wl 4 =>:;0k.5:;< t @g:;='9 . n .5_ @aeg@g:k@g

�»4»B*ßpà�áãâ�ÙÇ�HßV�-�PÙ \_^ 4 ` o¹ �Õ¹ � ñÚå/f'ñ�h[B`fKñ�h \_^ º_ñ�º�� fp��ÎPh

æJ< 9 .�6�=><dL�8O:K[�<�9 L�4�=;< 0>I5.5:K@GL�4ÐL�8`.%�C@A.�EEG@A��6�@AT­I�< EGL�9 @G:eFg.�4CTÒ@G4Ð:;[�<~9�.�=><�L�8U4�L< 4P:K0;.�@A4C1W< 4�:�fV4�LQT�0K.�Bb8VL�0>9 <�hDL�4�<�B�< :;=kB h Laà�4»B*ßpà�áÛâe«

�j4�y�� \_^ Õ¹ � ñ�åJfKñ�h�B`fKñ�h�º_ñk4ªy�� \_^ Õ¹ � ñ�å ^¡é h LSà�B*ßpà�áãâ{<©�CN Ü%ê ëë�ì ëí <©�CN Ü ê ëë�ì ë î º_ñ fp��w%h

 �@A1QN�EG@G8øF7@A4�BO]s@G:;[�:;[�<�N�.�0;.�1W<�:K< 0;=dò `Ý 4 ` ëí ë î ëí p ë î .�4CTv@G4P:K< B�0K.5:;@A4�Bb_PF�N�.�0a:K=sB�@�I�< = «

�j4 \_^ å ^ðé h LSà�B*ßpà�áãâ�� ò~`Ý ¯ w ��<©��N Ü � ëì ë� ° fp��y�h

YD[�6�= «

å ^¡é h Laàß4 �oß��-��aò `Ý ¯ wd��<���N Ü � ëì ë� ° fp���Ph

c�8�:;[�<�BP.�=/I�< EAL79 @�:eFk@A=s� < 0;LC\�:K[�<�EA@G��6�@ATn.%�C@A.�EM1QL�1Q< 4P:K6�1 @A=D9 L�4�=;< 0>I�< TM«

B `ßpà�áãâ Ù��oß��/��Ù \_^ 4 ` o¹ �Õ¹ � ñÚå/fKñ�h�B ` f'ñ�h \_^ º�ñÚº�� fp�5¡�h

ce4P:K< B�0K.5:;@A4�B�_PF�N�.�0a:K=DB�@�I�< = «

Ba`ßpà�áãâ Ù��oß��/��Ù�4��kBA`ß�à�áãâ å ^ðé h LaàMò~`` ¯ wd��<©��N Ü � ëì ëë ° fp��§�h

]s@G:;[Tò `` 4 ` ëí ë î` ëí p ë î�H=>@A4�BQij�tX�f����PhJB�@�I�< = «

w%Ë

Page 18: y{z 0>< N 0>< =;< 4P:K=rL 4 - Cerfacscerfacs.fr/~cfdbib/repository/TR_CFD_10_29.pdf · 2015. 7. 31. · [ . ='t < 1wl 4 =>:;0k.5:;< t @g:;='9 . n .5_ @aeg@g:k@g

ò~`` ¯ w �d<���N Ü � ëì ëë °�4æò~`Ý ¯ wd��<���N Ü � ëì ë � ° fp��¯Ph

YD[�@A=Q< ��6�.5EA@G:eF�@A=�I�< 0>@G��< TÓL�4CEGF^@G8�w sÚò `f 4 ÎC\Z:K[�.{:31Q<�.�4C=Q:;[�.5:�:K[�<}[PF�N,L�:;[�< =>@A=L�8D.Ê�O.56�=;=>@¦.�4�N�0;L5��EA<�L�4~:K[�<�I�< EAL79 @�:eF~@A=�]s0;L�4CB�X2YD[�@A=O@A=�@A4�9 L�4�:;0K.�TC@A9 :;@AL�4�]s@�:K[]s[�.5:�@A=�8VL�6�4�T�<���N,< 0;@G1W< 4P:�.�EGEGFÑu°y�Í{zpX2ce4�9 L�4�9 EG6�=;@GL�4M\M:K[C<¾��.�6�=;=>@¦.�4�=;[�.�N"<WL�8J:;[�<EA@G�76C@ATv.{��@¦.�EMI�< EGL�9 @G:eF�\tL�_C=;< 0aI�< T�<���N"< 0;@G1W< 4�:K.�EAE�F�\�@G=qTC6�<�:;LW:K[C<�<©�C9�[�.�4�B�<`L58j.{��@¦.5E1WL�1W< 4�:;6�1 I7@A.�TC0K.�Bb8VL�0>9 <�_"<�:e]J< < 4l:;[�<�EA@G�76C@ATn.�4CTv:;[�<�BP.�= X

��6�0>:;[�< 0>1WL�0><�\�:K[C<J1W.�=;=�.�4�Tb.{��@A.�E�1WL�1Q< 4P:;6�1Ö9 L�4C=;< 0aI5.5:K@GL�4`T�LH4�L�:Z9 L�4�=a:K0K.5@A4�:;[�<N�.�0;.�1W<�:K< 05ò `ó X�YD[�<��O.56�=;=>@¦.�4�=;[�.�N"<�L�82:;[�<�EA@A��6�@GT3I�L�EA6�1Q<8V0K.�9�:K@GL�4n@A=DT�6C<�=;L�EG< EGF:KL�:K[C<q=>N�0K.�F�L�N,< 4C@A4�B�_PF�.5:;L�1W@G=K.5:;@AL�4�X���L�0jN�0;.�9 :;@A9 .�E�N�6�0>N"L�=;< = \�:K[�<s[PF7N"L5:K[�< =;@A=rL�8.W� < 0;L3.{��@¦.�E'B�.�=DI�< EGL�9 @G:eF�@G=q4CL�:o9 L�1QN�.5:K@G_�EA<]s@�:K[�:K[�<O[PF7N"L�:;[�< =>@A=HL�8?.3�O.�6C=;=;@A.�4T�@A=a:K0>@A_�6C:;@AL�4nL58Z.{��@A.�EMEA@G��6�@AT3I�< EGL�9 @G:eF�X

��L�0r:;[�< =><0;< .�=;L�4�= \�:K[�<H9�.�=><L�8'4CLU< 4P:;0K.�@G4�1W< 4P:/@A=rT�@G=;9�.50;T�< Tn.�4�T38VL�0r:;[�<o0>< 1W.�@A4�RT�< 0�L�8r:K[C<QN�.�N"< 0 \M:;[�<�BP.�=�I�< EAL79 @G:eF�[�.�=O.T�O.�6C=;=;@A.�4~=;[�.5N"<�=;6CN�N"L�=;< Td=;@A1Q@AEA.�0s:KL:K[�.{:sL�8�:;[�<�EA@A��6�@GTk0K.5T�@¦.�E�T�@A=a:K0;@G_�6C:;@AL�4M«

BIÆ�4QB�Æ é h Laà�Ù1Ü Ü ê ëë�ì ë î fp��Ë�h

|o=�T�@A=>9 6�=>=;< TbN�0;<�I�@GL�6�=>EGF�\�:;[�<�B�.�='I�< EGL�9 @G:eF�@G=2:;[�<r0;< =>6�EG:*L�8CT�0K.�Bo.�4�TO=;LHT�< N,< 4�TC=ZL�4:K[�<OEA@G��6�@ATnI�< EAL79 @�:eF�XtYD[�< 0>< 8VL�0><�\t:K[�@G=s[�F7N,L�:K[C< =;@G=o=>< < 1Q=H:;LW_,<�I�.5EA@AT�X�YD[�@A=q@A1QN�EG@A< =:K[�.{:D:K[�<�BP.�=sN�[�.�=;<O.�4�T�:K[C<OEG@A��6�@GTnN�[�.�=><�.50;<�0K.�NC@AT�E�F3@G4v< ��6�@AEG@A_�0>@A6�1vX

Y�.5�7@G4�Bd@G4P:KL�.�9 9 L�6�4P:3:;[�<lT�< 9 0><�.�=><�L�8�.%�C@A.�EsEA@G�76C@AT�I�< EAL79 @G:eF^_PFÑ<���9�[�.54�B�<l]s@�:K[:K[�<bB�.�=N�[�.5=;<}f|B h Laà¾�rB*ß�à�áãâ�h.�4�T�6C=;@A4CBk:K[�<b1W.�=;=�9 L�4�=>< 0>I5.5:;@AL�4�< ��6�.5:K@GL�4M\"L�4�<L�_C:K.�@A4�= «

w�Ì

Page 19: y{z 0>< N 0>< =;< 4P:K=rL 4 - Cerfacscerfacs.fr/~cfdbib/repository/TR_CFD_10_29.pdf · 2015. 7. 31. · [ . ='t < 1wl 4 =>:;0k.5:;< t @g:;='9 . n .5_ @aeg@g:k@g

å ^¡é h Laàß4 B*ßpà�áãâ��oßV�-�B ^¡é h Laà�� ò `Ý ¯ wd��<©��N Ü � ëì ë� ° fp��ÌPh

YD[�<U9 L�4�=>< 0>I5.5:;@AL�4vL�8?.%�C@A.�E'1QL�1W< 4P:K6�1�L58�:K[C<U=>F7=a:K< 1 U°BP.�=[��EG@A��6�@GT~U�_,< :e]�< < 4�:;[�<4�L�� � EA<�<©�C@�:q.�4�T�:K[�<O�ceY�6�0Kæ/-ÐN�EA.�4�<F7@A< EAT�= «

Ba`ßpà�áãâ Ù��oß��/��Ù \_^ 4 ` o¹ �Õ¹ � ñÚå ^ fKñ�h�Ba`^ f'ñ�h \_^ º�ñÚº��%�

` o¹ �Õ¹ � ñÚåWÆ5f'ñ�h[BA`Æ f'ñ�h \ Æ/º_ñ�º�� fp��ÍPh

�H=>@A4�Bb:K[C<O< ��6�.�EA@�:eF¾å�Æ�fKñ�h÷4 wd��å ^ f'ñ�h©\�L�4�<�L�_C:K.�@A4C=s.58ø:K< 0D@A4P:K< B�0K.5:;@AL�4�«

B `ßpà�áãâ Ù��oß��/��Ù \_^ 4�Ba`^¡é h LSà å ^ðé h Laà \_^ ò~`` ¯ w5��<���N Ü � ëì ëë °���B `Æ é h LSà \ Æ/ò `f ¯ w ��<©��N Ü � ëì ë î °���kBa`Æ é h LSà å ^¡é h LSà \ Æ-ò~`` ¯ wd��<���N Ü �÷ëì ëë ° f�¡�ÎPh

]s@G:;[Tò `` 4 ` ëí ë î` ëí p ë î�H=>@A4�BQij�tX�f���ÌPhJL�4C<�B�< :;= «

Ba`ßpà�áãâ Ù��oß��/��Ù \_^ 4QB ^ðé h Laà B�ß�à�áãâ.�HßV�-�ò `Ý ¯ wd��<©��N Ü � ëì ë� ° \_^ ò�`` ¯ wd��<���N Ü � ëì ëë °���Ba`Æ é h LSà \ Æ/ò~`f ¯ w ��<©��N Ü � ëì ë î °�B `Æ é h Laà B*ßpà�áÛâ'�oßV�-�B ^¡é h LSà>ò `Ý ¯ wd��<���N Ü � ëì ë � ° \ Æ/ò `` ¯ wd��<���N Ü � ëì ëë ° f�¡Cw%h

ò `ó 9�.�4Ó_"<}<���N�0;< =;=>< Tg@A4Ñ:K< 0>1W=WL�8ò `f _PF®6�=;@G4�B�:;[�<lN�.50K.�1Q< :;< 0 � T�< ��4C< Tg_PFò `ó 4 � ò `f X�YD[�6�= \8ò `` 4 ``�� p Ý ò `ó .�4�TTò `Ý 4 `� p Ý ò `ó Xw�Í

Page 20: y{z 0>< N 0>< =;< 4P:K=rL 4 - Cerfacscerfacs.fr/~cfdbib/repository/TR_CFD_10_29.pdf · 2015. 7. 31. · [ . ='t < 1wl 4 =>:;0k.5:;< t @g:;='9 . n .5_ @aeg@g:k@g

B*ßpà�áãâ�4jB ^¡é h LSà f � �gw%hfpy � �gw%h

¯ wd��<©�CN Ü�� ë���� ��� � ëë�ì ëí °¯ wd��<©�CN Ü � ��� ��� � ëë�ì ëí °

� �OÙðB `Æ é h LSà Ù�ò `ó Ù \ Æ� B*ßpà�áÛâeÙÇ�HßV�-��Ù \_^ ¯ wd��<���N Ü � � ëì ëí °� f � �Ðw�h

f�y � �gw%hB `Æ é h LSà \ ÆB ^¡é h LSà \_^ ¯

wd��<���N Ü � ë���� ��� � ëë�ì ëí °¯ wd��<���N Ü � ��� ��� � ëë�ì ëí ° f�¡Py�h

YD[�<O0;< 1W.�@G4�@A4�BU6�4���4�L�]s4lN�.50K.�1Q< :;< 0;=q.�0>< � .�4CTXBIÆ é h LSàPXce4�L�0>T�< 0s:KLWT�< :;< 0;1Q@A4C<èBIÆ é h LSàP\,@G:q@A=q.�=>=;6�1Q< T}:K[�.5:q:K[C<UEA@G��6�@AT�R�BP.�=D< �76C@AEA@G_�0;@G6�1å@G=0K.�NC@AT�E�F.�9�[C@A< I�< TMX�ce4�:;[�@A='9 .�=;<?BIÆ é h LSàk4¼B ^ðé h Laà�X ¬ <�:26�='9 L�4�=;@GT�< 0':K[C<j9�[�.�0K.59 :K< 0;@G=>:K@G9:K@G1W<����©\�]s[C@A9�[�@G=O:;[�<W:;@A1Q<�8VL�0O:;[�<3BP.5=O:;L�.�9 9 < EG< 0;.5:K<Q8V0;L�1 � < 0;L}:KL}:;[�<3EG@A��6�@GTI�< EAL79 @G:eF�X�YD[�@G=o:K@G1W<�@A=TC< :K< 0;1Q@A4�< T�6�=;@G4�Bk:K[C<b.{��@¦.�E*1WL�1W< 4�:;6�1 < ��6�.5:;@AL�4�L�8j:;[�<BP.�=sN�[�.5=;<�\�9 L�4�=>@AT�< 0;@A4CBQL�4�EGFW:K[�<�T�0;.�Bb8VL�0;9 <�«

åWÆ \ Æ BIÆ é h LSà��� µ¼å ^ð\_^ B ^ðé h LaàÒ�O f�¡��Ph

YD[�<�:K@A1Q<o8VL�0/:;[�<�BP.�=/:;L3.�9 9 < EA< 0;.5:K<8V0>L�1�� < 0;L�:KLb:;[�<�EA@A��6�@GTkI�< EAL79 @G:eF3@A=/:;[�< 4M«

���²4 å�Æ \ Æå ^ð\_^ Ò�O f�¡�¡�h

]s@G:;[�Ò�O�:;[�<�0;< E¦.{�C.5:;@AL�4k:;@A1Q<T�< ��4�< Tv8VL�0s.bT�0;L�NCEA< :sL58�T�@A.�1Q< :K< 0dºWT�<���4�< T�.�= «

Ò�Oßµ º ` \_^w�Ì5ä�Æ f�¡P§�h

��L�0/:K[�<�]�L�0;=a:q9�.�=><�\�]s@G:;[vTC0;L�N�EG< :;=DL�8ZT�@A.�1Q< :K< 05º�4ªy�Î�äMØ�\�L�4�<�L�_C:�.5@A4�= «

���²4 w�ÙÛ�Cw�Î Ü � Ú

y�Î

Page 21: y{z 0>< N 0>< =;< 4P:K=rL 4 - Cerfacscerfacs.fr/~cfdbib/repository/TR_CFD_10_29.pdf · 2015. 7. 31. · [ . ='t < 1wl 4 =>:;0k.5:;< t @g:;='9 . n .5_ @aeg@g:k@g

]s@G:;[kä�Æ?4 y�Ù�w�Î Ü � F��(s�Ú�\ \ Æd4Ò��Î_¬ !Cs{Ø#"�\¿å�Æd4ÐÎCÙ¨ÌC\¿å ^ 4ªÎ�ÙãyO.�4�T \_^ 4ÐÌ�Î�Î_¬$!¿s5Ø#" XYD[�< =><�4�6�1Q< 0;@G9�.�EDI5.�EG6�< =W9 L�0>0;< =>N"L�4�TÓ:KL�:K[�<}<���N,< 0;@G1W< 4P:kL�8O-J[�.�I�< =n<�:n.�EpXqu¨y�Í{zT�< =>9 0>@A_,< Tv@A4�=;< 9 :K@GL�4l§�XÛ��X

YD[�@A=�:;@A1Q<`@A=�=;[CL�0>:;< 0�:K[�.{:�:K[�<�4�< < T�EG<WL�N,< 4C@A4�Bn:K@G1W<nf�µåÎCÙÛy5ØvÚ%h�X'-JL�4�=;< ��6�< 4P:KE�F�\@G:q@A=q.�=>=;6�1Q< T}:K[�.5:q:K[C<�BP.5=qI�< EAL79 @�:eFn0;< .�9�[�< =o:K[�<OEA@G��6�@ATnI�< EAL79 @�:eF�_"<�8VL�0;<�:K[�<O4�< <�RT�EA<Q[�.�=�9 L�1QN�EG< :K< EGF�L�N"< 4�< TMX*ce4�.�T�TC@G:K@GL�4M\MTC6�0;@G4�B}:;[�@A=ON"< 0;@GL�TM\':;[�<W��L�]£@G=O8V6�EGEGF6�4�=a:K<�.5TCF�]s@G:;[^.�=;N�0;.�F�.�4�B�EG<3I5.�0>F7@G4�B�@A4d:;@A1Q<n.�4�T�:;[�<n1QL�T�< EJN�0>< =>< 4P:K< TÓ[�< 0;<T�L7< =�4�L�:O.5@A1 :KL�_"<bNC0;< TC@A9 :;@GI�<�XMYD[�<�[PF7N"L5:K[�< =;@A=�BIÆ é h LSà34 B ^ðé h LaàQ@G=:K[�< 4~I5.�EG@ATMX��6�0>:;[�< 0>1WL�0><�\t.�:K6�0>_�6�EA< 4P:H��< EATv]s@AEAE'_,<O@A1QN"L�=>< TvL�4�:K[�<�_"L�6C4�T�.�0aF�9 L�4�TC@G:K@GL�4�=;L:K[�.{:j:K[�<qN�0;< 9 @G=;@AL�4QL�4¾BIÆ é h LaàH@A=j4�L5:�9 0;6�9 @¦.�EpX�YD[�<q@A1QN,L�0>:K.�4P:j@AT�< .�@A=Z:KL�< 4�=;6�0><q:;[�<9 L�4C=;< 0aI5.5:K@GL�4�L�8�:;[�<�13.�=>=s.�4�Tv1WL�1W< 4�:;6�1 ��6���< = X

��@A4�.�EAE�F�\7@A4�L�0;TC< 0/:KL���4�T � @G:s@A=s.5=;=;6C1W< Tv:;[�.5:�«

¯ w �d<���N Ü � ���:ë � � ëë��"ì ëí °¯ w �d<���N Ü � ��� ��� � ëë��"ì ëí ° µ®w f�¡�¯Ph

ce4v:;[�<�=K.�1Q<]J.�F�@�:s@A=DN�0>< =>6�1W< Tv:;[�.5:O«

¯ w �d<���N Ü%� ë�"ì ëí °%µ®w f�¡PË�h

YD[�@A=�@G=:K[�<�=K.51W<Q.�=�@A4P:;< B�0;.5:K@G4�Bn13.5=;=O.�4�T�.{��@¦.�E*1WL�1W< 4�:;6�1¤��67�C< =�_,< :e]�< < 4�Î.�4�T'& @A4�=a:K<�.5TkL�82Î`.54�T�Û X7i?�tXMf�¡�y�hZ:K[C< 4k_,< 9 L�1W< =/.U=>< 9 L�4�TnL�0>T�< 0�< ��6�.5:;@AL�4W@A4� «

� ` � `G�Þ� Ý � �Þ� � 4~Î f�¡�ÌPh

]s@G:;[M«

y�w

Page 22: y{z 0>< N 0>< =;< 4P:K=rL 4 - Cerfacscerfacs.fr/~cfdbib/repository/TR_CFD_10_29.pdf · 2015. 7. 31. · [ . ='t < 1wl 4 =>:;0k.5:;< t @g:;='9 . n .5_ @aeg@g:k@g

� ` 4�y�B*ßpà�áãâ8�bB ^¡é h LSàw� B ^ðé h LSà \ Æ\_^ f�¡�ÍPh

� Ý 4QB*ßpà�áãâ8�bB ^ðé h LSàA� y(��Ù¡B `Æ é h Laà Ù \ Æ%Ù�ò `óB*ß�à�áãâeÙ��oßV�-�PÙ \_^ � B ^¡é h Laà \ Æ\_^ f�§5ÎPh

� � 4�� �OÙðB `Æ é h Laà Ù�ò `ó Ù \ ÆB*ß�à�áãâSÙÇ�HßV�-��Ù \_^ f�§7w%h

YD[�<j:e]JLs=>L�EA6C:;@AL�4C=ML�8�ij�,X7fV¡PÌPh�.50;<�« � Ý 4 Ü L � p Ù L � ë Ü � L ë L*)` L ë .54�T � ` 4 Ü L � Ü Ù L � ë Ü � L ë L*)` L ë XæJ< 9 .�6�=><Å� ` �×Îb.�4�T�� � �ÓÎC\C:K[C<OL�4�EGFWN"L�=;@G:;@GI�<�=;L�EG6C:K@GL�4k@A= � Ý X�YD[�<�4�< BP.5:K@�I�<�=>L5REA6C:;@AL�4 � ` @G=�T�@G=;9�.50;T�< Tb_"< 9�.�6�=><D@G:*EA< .�T�=*:;L�.o4�L�47�O.�6C=;=;@A.�4`=>[�.�N,</L�4`:K[C<JI�< EAL79 @G:eFT�@A=a:K0>@A_�6C:;@AL�4�XP��@A4�.�EAE�F�\���4�L�]s@G4�B � Ý .�4�T�ò `ó .�4CT36�=>@A4�B�:K[�<q<���N�0>< =>=;@AL�4%ò `ó 4 � ò `f \L�4�<�L�_C:K.�@A4C=5ò `f .�4CT�:;[�< 4Êå ^¡é h Laà�]s@G:;[lij�tX�fp��ÌPh�X

Y*LQ0;< =;6�1Q<�\�:;[�<O8VL�6�0a�O.�6C=;=;@A.�4�N�.�0;.�1W<�:K< 0;=H.�0;<�L�_C:K.�@A4C< T�6�=;@G4�BWi?�tX*f�y�Ë�hJ8VL�0dò `ó \ij�,X*fpy�ÍPhr8VL�0AB ^¡é h LSà�\tij�tX�f�¡PÌPh�8VL�05ò `f .�4CTlij�tX�fp��Ì�h�8VL�0då ^¡é h LaàPXÑ,ö1Ñ ¦C§(+©¨�§�ÿAú/��ûw¨�ý:§(�,þ_ �+/�%��ý:�,þ�øûK�ý:�¿�YD[�<ON�0;L���EA< =D]�<�[�.�I�<�L�_C:�.�@G4�< T�8VL�0/:;[�<�_,L�6�4CT�.�0>Fk9 L�4�TC@G:K@GL�4�=s.�0><�1W< .�4}NC0;L���EG< = X| TC0K.�]s_�.�9��ÑL�8:;[�<}_,L�6�4CT�.�0>FÑ9 L�4�T�@�:K@AL�4�=�@A=�:K[�.5:Q:K[C<}[�@G=>:;L�0>F^L�8o:K[�<vBP.�=3.�4�TEA@G�76C@ATW��L%]s=s_,< :e]�< < 4v:;[�<�@A4{Õ>< 9 :;L�0/<���@�:s.�4�Tk:;[�<��ceY*6C0KæD-×N�E¦.54�<@A=JEAL�=a:�X��tL�0J:K[�@G=N�6�0>N"L�=><�\�]J<o6�=;<H6�4�=>:;<�.�T�F3_,L�6�4�T�.�0>FQ9 L�4�T�@G:;@AL�4C=r:;[�.5:J.�EAEGL%]Ó6�=�:;LU0>< N�0>L�T�6C9 <H:;[�<6�4�=a:K<�.5T�@A4�< =;=L58Z:K[�<���L�]�T�6�<O:KL�:K[�<O��L�]�@A4�=>@AT�<�:;[�<U4�L�� � EG<U.54�T}:;[�<�:;6�0;_�6CEA< 4C9 <B�< 4C< 0K.{:K< T3_"<�:e]J< < 4k:K[C<o4�L�� � EG<H<©�C@�:/.54�TW:;[�<�ceY�6�0Kæ/-®N�E¦.54�<�X�c�:�@A=�.�=;=>6�1W< T3:K[�.5::K[�<���L�]ªL�4v:;[�<O�ceY*6C0KæD-gN�E¦.�4C<�@A=s.b9 L�4C=;< ��6�< 4�9 <UL�8*:;[�< =><O:e]�LQN�[�< 4CL�1W< 4�.CX

ce4®L�0;T�< 0�:;L~9 0;< .5:K<v.�:K6C0;_�6�EG< 4�9 <v��< EAT�]s@�:K[Ñ.�B�@GI�< 4Ñ=>:�.{:K@A=a:K@G9�.�E/NC0;L���EG<�\j.�4�L�4�RT�@A1Q< 4C=;@AL�4�.�E'[�L�1QL�B�< 4�< L�6�=H��6C9 :K6�.5:K@G4�B3I�< EAL79 @�:eFn��< EGT�@A=qB�< 4C< 0K.{:K< T�X�YD[�@G=H��< EATl@G=:K[�< 4W0>< =>9�.�EG< TQ.�4�TQ.�T�TC< T�:KL:K[C<q1Q<�.54`I�< EGL�9 @G:eFUN�0;L���EA<DL�4`:;[�<q�ceY*6�0;æD-�8VL�0j_"L5:K[EA@G�76C@ATb.�4CTWBP.5=jN�[�.�=>< = X�YD[�<s1Q< :;[�L�Tb@G=j_�.�=>< TQL�4b:K[�<D]�L�0;�`L58 2 0K.5@A9�[�4�.54lu��Cw�z,.�4�T

y�y

Page 23: y{z 0>< N 0>< =;< 4P:K=rL 4 - Cerfacscerfacs.fr/~cfdbib/repository/TR_CFD_10_29.pdf · 2015. 7. 31. · [ . ='t < 1wl 4 =>:;0k.5:;< t @g:;='9 . n .5_ @aeg@g:k@g

.b=;@A1Q@AEA.�0J1Q< :;[�L7Tv@G=D6�=;< T}_PF} �1Q@A0>4�L�Ik<�:o.5E�XAu°�Py�zpX

YD[�<b6�=><bL�8?:K[�< =;<`:K6C0;_�6�EG< 4P:�_,L�6�4�T�.�0>Fl9 L�4�TC@G:K@GL�4�=o.�=o]�< EAE�.�=o:;[�< @G0@A4C��6�< 4�9 <bL�4:K[�<�=>N�0K.�Fn8VL�0>13.5:;@AL�4W]s@AEAE"_"<�T�< =;9 0;@A_,< Tv@A4v.`8V6C:;6�0;<�N�.�N,< 0 X

+ ,Oð�ì�+p&2ðC!%+V$,�

YD[�<`1QL�TC< E'8VL�0s:K[�<U�ceY*6�0;æD-ª@A=sI5.�EA@GT�.5:;< Tv@A4}:e]�Ln=>:;< N�= XM��@G0;=a:�\t_PF}9�[C< 9���@A4�Bk:;[�<4�L�� � EA<q<���@�:�I�< EAL79 @�:eFQ.�4�TW=;N�0;.�FW.�4CB�EA<5\�:K[�<q@A4{Õ>< 9 :;L�0�1QL7T�< E�N�0>< =>< 4P:K< Tn@A43 �< 9�:K@AL�4k�@A=qI�.5EA@AT�.5:K< TMXtYD[�< 4~_PF�9 L�1WN�.�0;@G4�BW:;[�<`1QL�T�< EAEG< Tl0;.�T�@A.�E2T�@A=a:K0;@G_�6C:;@AL�4�=qN�0>L���EA< =L�8I�< EAL79 @G:;@A< =q]s@�:K[�<©�CN,< 0>@A1Q< 4P:�.5E*0>< =;6CEG:K=H:K[�<�9 L�4�=a:K0>6�9 :;@AL�4�L�8�:K[�<è��.�6�=>=;@A.�4�N�0>L���EA< =@A4} �< 9 :K@GL�4�¡3.50;<�.�=>=;< =>=;< TMX

-Pöø÷ ù/�/.�ú���ûK�ý:�Î=�ú�ÿAý>�/øûK�YD[�<UI5.�EG@AT�.5:;@AL�4nL58Z:K[�<O:K6�0>_�6�EG< 4�9 <�Re9 .�I�@�:�.5:;@AL�4}1WL7T�< E�@G=o.59�[�@A<�I�< T�_PF}9 L�1QN�.�0>@A=>L�4]s@G:;[v:;[�<�<���N"< 0;@G1W< 4�:K.�E'1Q<�.�=>6�0;< 1W< 4�:;=HL58 ¬ < @G9��k< :H.�EpX2u����5z2L�_C:K.�@A4C< Tn8VL�0D:e]JLQT�@�8¦R8V< 0>< 4P:sN�0;< =;=>6�0;< =q@G4k:K[�<o9�[�.�1`_,< 0OfV=;< <�Y*.�_�EG<`w%h©XCYD[�<I�< EAL79 @�:eF31Q<�.5=;6�0>< 1Q< 4P:K=s.�0><13.5T�<�.5:�w�Ù¨Í�ØnØ 8V0>L�1 :;[�<�4�L�� � EA<�<©�C@�:q.5:q.�4�@A4%Õ>< 9 :;@AL�4�N�0>< =>=;6�0><�L�8Zy�y�Ï10*.�]s@�:K[.b4�L�� � EA<�T�@A.�1W<�:K< 0/L�8/w�§5¡�äMØ�X

|o=D=>[�L�]s4}@G4nY�.�_CEA<`w�\7:K[�<�NC0;< TC@A9 :;< T�<���@�:DI�< EGL�9 @G:;@A< =J.�0;<I�< 0aFn9 EGL�=;<o:;L`:K[�<�<©��N"< 0aR@A1Q< 4P:�.5E�1Q<�.�=>6�0;< 1W< 4P:K= X�YD[�<k0;< E¦.5:;@GI�<3T�@���< 0;< 4C9 <n@A=U�CÙ¨¯�2 ]s[C@A9�[�@A=�L�8s:K[�<3=K.�1Q<L�0;TC< 0q.�=D:K[�<�<©�CN,< 0>@A1Q< 4P:�.5EMN�0;< 9 @G=;@AL�4M\���2å.59 9 L�0;T�@G4�Bb:KL ¬ < @A9��3< :H.�E�XMu°���5z�X

y��

Page 24: y{z 0>< N 0>< =;< 4P:K=rL 4 - Cerfacscerfacs.fr/~cfdbib/repository/TR_CFD_10_29.pdf · 2015. 7. 31. · [ . ='t < 1wl 4 =>:;0k.5:;< t @g:;='9 . n .5_ @aeg@g:k@g

-PöAõ ¥�08+� ��% ��(��ÿAú��� �û,��ý���� ÿAú`ú���øûYD[�<~=;6�_7Re1QL�T�< EA=38VL�03:K[�<�=>N�0K.�Fg.54�B�EA<�.�0;<�I5.�EG@AT�.5:;< T­_PFÓ9 L�1QN�.�0>@A=;L�4­]s@G:K[­:;[�<<���N,< 0;@G1W< 4P:�.�E,T�.5:K.UL�8�æJEG< =;=>@A4�BU< :D.5E�X"u�w ¡�z�\7]s[�L`1Q<�.�=>6�0;< Tn=;N�0;.�Fk.�4CB�EA< =�8VL�0r:K[�0>< <4�L�� � EA< =HTC< 4�L�:;< T�w�\ãy�.�4�T}�W@G4}Y*.�_�EG<Uy7X�YD[�<U4�L�� � EG< =q6�=;< Tl[�.�I�<UT�@���< 0;< 4P:H9 L�4C@A9�.5E=;[�.5N"<38�.59 :KL�0;=`EG<�.�T�@G4�B}:;L�T�@���< 0;< 4P:b=>N�0K.�Fd.�4�B�EG< =�T�6�<k:KLl9�.�I7@G:�.{:K@AL�4MX2YD[�<n=;N�0;.�F.�4�B�EG< =s.�0><�1W< .�=;6�0>< T}.5:D:K[C<O4CL�� � EA<�<���@G: X

�o:K[�< 0=;N�0;.�F�.�4CB�EA<O1W< .�=;6C0;< 1Q< 4P:;=13.�Fv_,<U8VL�6�4�Tl@A4~ C.5EA@A_�.Q<�:�.�EpX�u���¡�zp\".5:�y5ØnØ8V0;L�1 :K[C<b4�L�� � EA<`<©��@G:�.�4CT�8VL�0T�@���< 0;< 4P:�_�.�9���N�0;< =;=;6C0;< = X��s< =>6�EG:;=�.�0;<UT�< N�@G9 :;< T~L�4��@ABCXC¡�X

mH< 0;<�.�BP.5@A4M\t:K[�<`.�9 9 6�0K.�9�F�L�8?:;[�<b1WL7T�< E*N�0>< T�@G9 :;@AL�4�=o@A=oB�L�L7TM\�< =;N,< 9 @¦.�EGEGF�8VL�0H:;[�<9�.�=>< =bL�8qæ�EA< =>=;@G4�B�< :b.�E�X�uxw�¡�zpXZÏ}L7T�< EJ0;< =;6�E�:K=b.50;<kEG< =;=U.�9 9 6�0K.{:K<38VL�0O:K[�<39�.�=>< =bL�8 C.�EG@A_�.�< :/.�E�X,u���¡�z,_�6C:�:K[�<H@A4�9 0;< .�=;<HL�8':K[�<o.�4�B�EG<D]s@G:K[W:K[�<H_�.�9���N�0;< =;=>6�0;<5\�.�4k<���< 9 :T�< =>9 0>@A_,< T�_PFl:;[�<`.�< 0;L7TCF74�.�1Q@A9 .�E*=>N�0K.�Fl.�4�B�EG<nfV=;< <b �< 9�:K@AL�4�¡�X�w%h�\,@A=H0;< NC0;L7T�6�9 < TMXYD[�<�13.{��@G1`6�1 TC@G�"< 0;< 4�9 <~@G=}.5_"L�6�:~w�T�< B�0;< <�]s[C@A9�[Ð@A=nL�8�:K[�<~=K.51W<~L�0>T�< 0�L�813.5B�4�@G:;6�T�<�.5=s:;[�<�I5.�0;@A.5:K@GL�4kL�8�:K[�<�=>N�0K.�Fv.�4�B�EA<�T�6�0>@A4�B�@G4{Õ>< 9�:K@AL�4MX

-Pö�) 3d��K �ÿ�=�ú�ÿAý>�/øû9�k08+Ký<ä?ÿAú� �û w�Î�Þbßpà�áãâ ;-+�ý:6 ��ý���� ÿAúUú���øû-J[�.�I�< =n< :3.�E�XHu°y�Í{zH[�.�I�<�1Q<�.5=;6�0>< TÓ:;[�<}0;.�T�@A.�EsT�@A=a:K0;@G_�6C:;@AL�4^L�8:;[�<l=>N�0K.�F®.{��@¦.5EI�< EAL79 @G:eF.5:��ns�Þbßpà�áÛâ�4�w�Î/8V0;L�1Ð:K[�<?4�L�� � EG<j<���@G:�fV=;< <?Y*.�_�EG<?�Hh©X�YD[�@G='9 L�0>0;< =>N"L�4�T�=2:KL.��@A< =>< E�EG@A�5</EA@G�76C@AT`@G4{Õ>< 9�:K@AL�4`]s@G:K[CL�6C:?9�.�I7@G:K.5:K@GL�4�.5:?.�1QL�TC< 0K.{:K<DN�0>< =;=>6�0;<Uf4�èF]4w�Î�5�F��7hH@A4P:;Ln.3��6�@A< =;9 < 4P:OT�< 4�=><�.�@A0`fp��5 F��7h�X"YD[�<`@G4{Õ>< 9�:KL�04CL�� � EA<UTC@¦.�1Q< :;< 0o@G=Þ 4 y�Î�Î�ä�Ø�X�YD[�<�1W< .�=;6C0;< 1Q< 4P:;=H.50;<�1W.�T�<�.58ø:;< 0/:K[C<O@G4{Õ>< 9�:K@GL�4n0;< .�9�[�< =H.b��6�.�=;@�R=>:;<�.�TCF�=a:�.5:;<�X�YD[�<OæJ< 0;4�L�6�EAEG@�I�< EAL79 @G:eF3@A=�w%§{¡�ÙãË{ØTs�Ú�8VL�0/:;[�@A=D9 .�=;<5X

y5¡

Page 25: y{z 0>< N 0>< =;< 4P:K=rL 4 - Cerfacscerfacs.fr/~cfdbib/repository/TR_CFD_10_29.pdf · 2015. 7. 31. · [ . ='t < 1wl 4 =>:;0k.5:;< t @g:;='9 . n .5_ @aeg@g:k@g

|­��0;=a:r@A4P:K< 0;< =a:K@G4�B�L�_�=>< 0>I5.5:;@AL�4�@G=�:K[�.{:j:K[�<s.�_C=;< 4C9 <qL�8,9�.�I7@G:�.{:K@AL�4b@A=Z@G4�.�B�0;< < 1Q< 4P:]s@G:;[^:;[�<vN�0;< T�@A9�:K@AL�4�L�8o:;[�<�@A4{Õ>< 9 :KL�0b1WL7T�< E�fpij�tXofp§�h;h©XZYD[�<v=;< 9 L�4�T®@A4P:K< 0;< =>:K@G4�BL�_�=>< 0>I5.5:;@AL�4df�=>< <OY�.5_�EA<O�Ph/@A=D:;[�.5:s:K[�<OT�@G=;9�[�.�0>B�<�9 L7< ÔQ9 @G< 4P:H1W< .�=;6�0>< T}_�F�u°y�Í5z2@G=.�EA=>Lb]J< EAEMN�0>< T�@G9 :;< Tl_PF�ij�tX*f�¡�h©X

��0;L�1 :K[�<n=>[�.�T�L�]sB�0;.�N�[PF^N�0;L�I7@ATC< TÑ_�Fgu¨y�Í{z�\�:;[�<�=;N�0;.�F^.�4�B�EG<k@A=b1Q<�.5=;6�0>< T®.�4�T9 L�1QN�.�0>< T3:;L�:;[�<oI5.�EA6C<HL�_�:�.�@G4�< TQ]s@G:K[W:K[�<H1WL7T�< EpXP|oBP.5@A4M\P:K[C<�.�B�0>< < 1Q< 4P:J@A=?I�< 0aFB�L7L�T�fV=;< <OY*.�_�EA<���h�X

��6�0>:;[�< 0>1WL�0><�\*ij�,X/f�¡�Ë�hO@A=�.lB�L7L7T�[PF�N,L�:;[�< =>@A=b.�= \*8VL�0�:K[C@A=U9 .�=;<5\*:;[�<kN�.�0;.�1Q< :K< 0N�0;L�I7@ATC< T�_�Fl:K[�<�1QL�T�< EZ.�0><n«�ò ` 4£Ë�ÙÛË�w�Î7Ü$6�\ � 4çÎCÙ°¡PÌC\�Û 4¥Ë�Ù�w�Î7Ü ��.�4�T�:;[�< 4

¯ w �d<���N Ü7� ë�"ì ëí °¤µ£ÎCÙ¨Í�Í�ÍCX,YD[�<bN�.�0;.�1Q< :K< 0 � 4 ÎCÙ°¡PÌ31Q<�.54�=:K[�.{::K[�<7�O.�6C=;=;@A.�4

L�4n:K[�<�EG@A��6�@ATkI�L�EA6C1W<8V0;.�9 :;@AL�4n@G=s.�_"L�6C:D:e]JL�:K@G1W< =/E¦.50;B�< 0/:K[�.�4n:;[�<��O.�6C=;=;@A.�4�L�4:K[�<k.{��@¦.�E?EA@G��6�@AT�I�< EGL�9 @G:eF�X*YD[�< 0;<�8VL�0;<5\Z[�@AB�[�I�< EAL79 @�:K< =�T�0;L�N�EA<�:K=b.�0><39 L�4�9 < 4P:K0K.{:K< T4�<�.50o:K[�<b=>N�0K.�F�.{��@A= X,ce4�.�T�T�@�:K@GL�4M\�:K[�<U1WL7T�< E�B�@�I�< =å ^¡é h LSà74 Î�ÙãyQ]s[�.5:�9 L�4C��0;1Q=:K[�.{:/:K[�<�=>N�0K.�Fn@G=J8V6�EGEGFQT�@A=>N"< 0;=>< Tdf�4�LbEG@A��6�@AT39 L�0><�h/.5:/:;< 4�4�L�� � EG<�T�@¦.�1Q< :;< 0>=J8V0;L�1:K[�<�4�L�� � EG<�<���@G: X

��@A4�.�EAE�F�\t:K[�<�0K.5T�@¦.�E�T�@A=a:K0;@G_�6C:;@AL�4�=oL�8/1Q<�.�4�.{��@A.�EZ=;NC0K.�F�I�< EAL79 @G:eF�.�0;<�0>< N,L�0>:;< T�@A4��@ABQ§b.�4CT}9 L�4C��0>1W=D:K[C<OB�L�L7TnN�0;< T�@A9�:K@�I�@�:eFkL�8�:K[C<O1QL7T�< E�8VL�0/:K[�<�1Q<�.�4�N�0>L���EA< = X

8 ó�$,�*)Pì�(�&*+���í�#%ê"#�ð�# &'ñce4Ó:K[C@A=QN�.�N,< 0 \�.�1QL7T�< ED8VL�0QEA@G�76C@AT^@A4{Õ>< 9 :;@AL�4®_"L�6C4�T�.�0aF®9 L�4�T�@�:K@GL�4�= \j9 .�EAEG< TÓ�c�RY*6C0KæD-o\,[�.�=s_,< < 4lN�0;< =;< 4P:;< TMX,YD[�<U1QL7T�< E'6�=>< =H9�[�.�0K.59 :K< 0;@G=>:K@G9�8V<�.5:;6�0;< =HL�8*:K[�<O@A47RÕ>< 9�:K@AL�4U:KLH_�6�@AEGT`.�4`.�EAB�< _�0K.5@A9?T�< =>9 0>@ANC:;@AL�4`L58t.�EAE�=>N�0K.�F�9�[�.�0K.59 :K< 0;@G=>:K@G9 =j.54�T`N�0>L���EA< =4�<�.50s:;[�<�4�L�� � EA<�<©��@G:�X

y�§

Page 26: y{z 0>< N 0>< =;< 4P:K=rL 4 - Cerfacscerfacs.fr/~cfdbib/repository/TR_CFD_10_29.pdf · 2015. 7. 31. · [ . ='t < 1wl 4 =>:;0k.5:;< t @g:;='9 . n .5_ @aeg@g:k@g

YD[�< =><WNC0;L���EG< =9 .�4~_"<b6C=;< T�.�=�_,L�6�4�T�.�0>Fl9 L�4�TC@G:K@GL�4�=o8VL�0o:K[�<�ij6�EG< 0>@¦.�4�Reij6�EA< 0;@¦.54=;@G1`6�E¦.{:K@AL�4L�8C�@A< =>< E� 7N�0K.�F7=*< =;N,< 9 @¦.�EGEGF@G4 ¬ .50;B�<?ijT�TCF� 7@A1`6�EA.5:K@GL�4MX æ�F�@G4�@G:;@¦.�EG@A=;@G4�B:K[�<�=;N�0;.�F�=>EA@GB�[P:KEGFT�L�]s4�=>:;0;<�.51 8V0>L�1 :K[�<�4�L�� � EA<r<���@�:�\�:K[�<J�ceY*6C0KæD-d1QL�TC< E7.�EAEGL�]s=���ç=;@G1`6�E¦.{:K@AL�4l]s@G:;[�L�6C:�=>L�EGI7@A4CBk:K[�<b9 L�1WNCEA<���=;N�0;.�F�N�[PF7=;@A9 =U.{:�:K[�<b4�L�� � EG<�<���@G: X��6�0>:;[�< 0>1WL�0><�\�:;[�@A='1Q< :;[�L�TCL�EAL�B5F�.�I�L�@GT�=':KLq1W< =;[�:K[�<?4�L�� � EG<?<���@G: \%.q� L�4�<r0;< ��6�@G0;@G4�BI�< 0>F�=;1W.�EGE�1Q< =;[v=;@G� <5\�0;< =>6�EG:;@A4�B�@G4�.QT�< 9 0><�.�=><�L�8�:K[C<O9 L�1QN�6C:�.{:K@AL�4�.�E�9 L�=>: X

YD[�<�_"L�6C4�T�.�0aFg9 L�4�TC@G:K@GL�4�=v.�0><�_�.�=;< T L�4Ò.�4ª@G4{Õ>< 9�:KL�0n1QL�TC< E:K[�.5:lTC< :K< 0;1Q@A4�< =]s[�< :;[�< 0/:;[�<H��L%]Ð@G4�=;@GT�<H:;[�<4�L�� � EG<o@A=�9�.�I7@G:K.5:K@G4�B�X 2 4�L�]s@A4�BU:;[�<o��L�]Ð0;< B�@A1Q<H.�4�T:K[�<3@A4P:K< 4�=;@�:eFdL�8D:;6�0;_C6�EA< 4�9 <n.54�T�9�.�I7@G:K.5:K@GL�4M\':K[C<3I�< EAL79 @G:eFd.�4�T�:K[�<k=>N�0K.�F�.�4�B�EG<.5:J:;[�<4�L�� � EG<<���@�:D.�0><T�< TC6�9 < TMX�YD[�< 4M\�_PFW:;[�<�.�NCN�EA@G9�.5:;@AL�4QL�829 L�4�=;< 0>I5.5:K@GL�4nE¦.�]s= \I�< EAL79 @G:eF�\2EA@A��6�@GT�I�L�EG6�1W<�8V0K.59 :K@GL�4M\2.�4CTdT�0>L�N�EA<�:U=>@A� <WN�0>L���EG< =`.50;<Q9�.�EG9 6�EA.5:K< Td.5:U.B�@GI�< 4`TC@A=>:K.�4�9 <JT�L�]s4�=a:K0;< .�1 8V0>L�1 :K[C</4�L�� � EA<�<���@G: \{]s[C@A9�[`0>< N�0>< =;< 4P:j:K[�<�_"L�6C4�T�.�0aF9 L�4CT�@G:;@AL�4^�ceY�6�0Kæ/-oXjYD[�< =><}1Q<�.�4^N�0>L���EG< =�.�0><�.�=;=>6�1W< TÑ:;L~_"<���.�6�=;=>@¦.�4�XZYD[�<�O.56�=;=>@¦.�4�]s@AT�:K[�=2L�8�I�< EGL�9 @G:eF.�4�TOEA@A��6�@GTI�L�EG6�1Q<Z8V0K.�9�:K@AL�4�.50;<Z8VL�6�4CTO:;LH_,<jT�@G�"< 0>< 4P:.�4�T�:K[�<O9 L�4�=;< 0>I5.5:K@GL�4vE¦.�]s=HL58Z1W.�=;=q.�4�T}.{��@¦.5E'1WL�1Q< 4P:;6�1�N,< 0;1Q@G:/6�=q:;LW<©��[�@A_�@�:.b0;< EA.5:K@GL�4n_,< :e]�< < 4}:K[�< 1}X

YD[�<�1WL7T�< EM[�.�=D_,< < 4vI5.�EG@AT�.5:;< T�.�B�.�@A4�=a:D4�6�1Q< 0;L�6�=D<���N,< 0;@G1W< 4P:K=sB�6�.�0;.�4P:eF7@A4�B�0;<©REA@A.�_�EA<H_"L�6�4�T�.�0aFn9 L�4�T�@G:;@AL�4C= X

YD[�<�@A1QN�EG< 1Q< 4P:�.5:;@AL�4�L�8��ceY�6�0;æD-­@A43:;[�<|:9�æ;0®-/�Z�Ö9 L7T�<�u��P§%z�[�.�=/_,< < 4nT�L�4�<5X¬ i� �L�8��@G< =;< Ej �NC0K.�F7=O6C=;@A4CBk:K[�< =;<��ceY�6�0KæD-Ö@A=o6�4�T�< 0�N�0;< N�.�0K.{:K@AL�4~.�4�T�]s@AEGE*_,<N�6�_�EG@A=>[�< Tv@A4�.b8V6C:K6C0;<�N�.�N,< 0 X

y�¯

Page 27: y{z 0>< N 0>< =;< 4P:K=rL 4 - Cerfacscerfacs.fr/~cfdbib/repository/TR_CFD_10_29.pdf · 2015. 7. 31. · [ . ='t < 1wl 4 =>:;0k.5:;< t @g:;='9 . n .5_ @aeg@g:k@g

< ê�ï�ê�#%ê���)�ê7ñ

u�w z �sF�.�4�Y�X���X�\'-/.5EAE¦.5[�.�4lY�X>=CX�XMmHL�1WL�B�< 4�< L�6�=�-/mH.�0;B�<b-JL�1WNC0;< =>=;@GL�4�ceB�4�@�:K@GL�4fpm-D-Jcah/L�8��@A< =;< E2�t6C< E�X ¥?3A@CB$D�÷P÷$D�E�ö w�Í�Í�¯�X

u¨y%z ¬ 6�çHRS-oXG\C-J[�< 4%��X�\�mH6�.�4CB7F�X�X�|g8V6�4�T�.51W< 4�:K.�E,=>:K6CTCF3L�4W:K[C<o9 L�4�:;0;L�E,L�8M:;[�<m-D-Jc�9 L�1`_�6�=a:K@AL�4�.�4�Td< 1Q@A=;=>@AL�4C=�_PF~8V6�< ErT�< =;@AB�4�9 L�4C9 < N�:b9 L�1U_�@A4�< T�]s@�:K[9 L�4P:K0>L�EAEA.�_�EG<�i��O��XG0�.50>:�w�X�YD[�<O_�.�=;@G9�9�[�.�0K.59 :K< 0;@G=>:K@G9�L�8jmo-D-Jc/9 L�1U_�6�=>:;@AL�4�XH §�ú�ÿ�ö y�Î�ÎP§"P¨Ì�¡�«�w�ÎPË{¡5R�w�Î�Ì��CX

u°�{z ��� T�L�0j�OXG\��6�EAB�< 0?Ï�X�\� �[�< 0?iDXGX�-�F79 EA@A9/I5.�0>@¦.�_C@AEA@�:eF�@A4b=>N�.�0>�U@AB�4�@G:;@AL�4�< 4�B�@G4�< = X|ÖEA@G:;< 0;.5:K6�0><=;6C0>I�<�F ¥?3A@/ö w�Í�Í�¡CP¨ÍP§�Î�¯�Ì��CX

u�¡5z ¬ .56�4�T�< 0oæoX¨iDXG\� �N�.5EAT�@G4�B3�`X,æoX�X ùX �ûøü�ú/6� �û9��� �ÿW63ý þ7ú�ÿ1�bý<;OûK§"+©¨�§7ÿAú/����ú ö |o9 .{RT�< 1Q@A9�0j0>< =;=�w�ÍPË�y7X

u¨§%z �0K.��5<nÏ�XÛ-oXG\*mo.�]�L�0>:;[^�`XGX2|HTCI5.�4�9 < T�BP.�=>L�EA@G4�<�< 4�B�@G4�<3TC< I�< EAL�NC1W< 4�:U6�=;@G4�BL�NC:K@G9�.�E*T�@¦.5B�4�L�=a:K@A9`.�4�T~4�6�1W< 0;@G9�.�EZ1QL7T�< EG@A4�B *,+Ký>��ú�ú;þ�.�(�:�3ý<;`ûVü�ú ��w ��â ¥â�Ú67I0�ý>�/.§"6KJ'ù-��û�öML3ý:�j±�ý:6�¨�§���ûK�ý:�ONk¦Mü�ú3±�ý:6�¨�§_��û9�ý:�¾ù/�¿��ûKøû9§7ûSú ö y�Î�Î�Ë�X

u°¯{z  C.�BP.�6�:P0*X�X�Q �+9�7úR@/þPþ��j¥â.67§7ÿ« �û9�ý:�¢;�ý:+Î.����ý:6A08+Kú����/K¨ ÿAúTSsý:öß� X  �9 @G< 4P:K@���99 L�1QN�6C:K.5:K@GL�4n=;< 0;@A< =� �NC0;@A4CB�< 0SRU9?< 0>E¦.�BQy5Î�Î�ÎCX

u¨Ë%z  �< EGEA< ¬ XG\"æJ< 4CL�@G: ¬ X�\V0*L�@G4�=;L5:Y�X�\M�H@G9 L�6CT��JX�\ 2 0>< _�= ��XGXW=�L�@A4P:o6�=;<�L�8�-JL�1bRN�0;< =;=;@G_�EA< ¬ .�0>B�<�Rei?TCTCF  �@A1`6CE¦.5:;@AL�4Ö.54�T mq< EA1QL�E�:K��=;L�EGI�< 0;=~8VL�0~:K[�<®.�4�.�E�FPR=;@A=�L�8H0;L5:�.5:;@A4�B~1QL�T�< =b@A4®.�4Ñ@A4�T�6C=>:K0>@¦.�EJ=>]s@A0>EA< TÑ_C6�0;4�< 0 ±�ý:6�¨�§_��û�ö H ÿ« �63ú öy�Î�Î�¯¿P�w�¡�§7«Gw�Í5¡5Ray�Î�§�X��H�JX

u°Ì{z  �9�[�1Q@G:;:�0*X�\X0*L�@G4�=;L�:oY�XY=CX�\' 79�[76C< 0;1W.�4�=æoXG\���< @AB�EA< 2 X�X ¬ .50;B�<©Re< TCTCFv=;@A1U6�E¦.{R:K@AL�4�.�4�Tl<���N"< 0;@G1W< 4�:K.�E�=a:K6�T�FlL�8?[C<�.5::;0K.�4C=>8V< 0 \�4�@�:K0>@A9OL���@GT�<U< 1W@G=;=;@GL�4�=o.�4�T9 L�1`_C6�=>:;@AL�4�@A4C=>:�.5_�@AEG@G:[email protected]=>]s@A0>EA< T�:;6�0;_C6�EA< 4�:�[�@GB�[�N�0;< =;=>6�0;<�_�6�0;4C< 0�Z ö H ÿ¡§"�þù�ú���ü¿ ������� ö y�Î�Î�Ë"Pã§�Ë�ÎC«�w%Ë%Re¡�¯CX

u°Í{z �q@G9�[�.�0;T� ,XG\2-JL�EA@A4��`X�\W9?< 0>1WL�0;< Ej�bX�\'æJ< 4���< 4�@AT�.v|�XG\M|H4�B�< EA_,< 0;B�< 0O-oX�\W9?< FPR4�.�4P:K<��`X�XCY�L�]/.�0>T�=sE¦.�0>B�<o< T�TCFn=>@A1`6CE¦.5:;@AL�4QL�8*9 L�1`_C6�=>:;@AL�4n@G4k=;N�.50;�k@GB�4�@G:;@AL�4

y�Ë

Page 28: y{z 0>< N 0>< =;< 4P:K=rL 4 - Cerfacscerfacs.fr/~cfdbib/repository/TR_CFD_10_29.pdf · 2015. 7. 31. · [ . ='t < 1wl 4 =>:;0k.5:;< t @g:;='9 . n .5_ @aeg@g:k@g

< 4�B�@G4�< = *,+Ký>� ö?ý<;�ûøü�ú3±�ý:6�¨�§���ûK�ý:��ù/�¿��ûKøûK§�ûeú ö y5Î�ÎPË"P¨�Cw�X�:;N�@A1�8ø:�Xu�w�Î5z[9?< 0;1QL�0>< E"�`XG\7�s@A9�[�.�0>Tn "X�\C-JL�EA@G4k�`X�\7|H4�B�< EA_,< 0;B�< 0J-oXG\�æJ< 4C��< 4C@AT�.`|�XGX�Ï}6�E�:K@�R

9 F79 EG< ¬ ir �=;@G1`6�EA.5:K@GL�4�=�L�8/��L%]¥.54�Td9 L�1`_�6�=a:K@GL�4d@G4�.10?��c� �c�¡5R�I5.�E�I�<�N�0>L5RT�6�9 :;@AL�4�< 4�B�@A4C< ¥?3A@ *X3A*\@�ã õOE�E?]/I^E�÷�I^E�÷�-P÷Pö y�Î�Î�Ë�X

u�w�w zO|o_�0;.�[�.�1_=CXGX��g[�.5:�ce=�|oT�< ��6�.5:K<Q�s< =>L�EA6C:;@AL�4l@A4�:K[C<W�q6�1Q< 0;@G9�.�EZ-JL�1QN�6C:�.%R:K@AL�4�=DL�8*Y*0;.�4�=;@G< 4P:�=�< :;=a` ¦¿+� ��¿� öjý<;�ûVü�ú¥?3�@/ö w�Í�ÍPË"P�w�Î�¯C«�w�¡�w RKw%§�§�X

u�w�y{zOc�F�< 0[9`X�\'|o_C0K.�[�.51b=CXGX:0�< 4�<�:K0;.5:K@GL�4�.�4�T��@A=;N,< 0>=;@GL�4~L�8JY�0K.54�=;@G< 4P:Å�O.�=c=�<�:K=.�4�T} �N�0;.�F7= ±�ý:6�¨�§���ûK�ý:�,öI¥~�/�öG ��,þݦ,ú���üCöøö w�Í�ÍPË(PGw���ÎC«Û��w%§%RS���P§�X

u�w��5zU �6�_�0;.�13.54�@¦.�1  "XG\J��UÛ�sL�6�0>��<10*X�XJ�q6�1W< 0;@G9�.�EH-JL�4PI�< 0;B�< 4�9 <�L58:K[�< 2 cU9�|sRS�-JL�T�<q8VL�0J �N�0K.�F7=D.�4CT3c�:K=Jce1WN�EG@A9 .5:K@GL�4�=Z8VL�0JÏ}L7T�< EG@A4�B7Q ý>�d3oÿ« �63ý>� Q _¨�ö~ãsú|0�öe ãfI*BhghI*-�ÑWD�-�N Q ý>��3oÿ« �63ý>�aNjiqù�ö w�Í�Í�ÌCX

u�w ¡�z�æJEA< =;=;@G4�B�Ï�X�\ 2 4�@GB7�bXG\ 2 0;B�< 0D-oX�\�Ï}@G9�[�< EG=5��X�\� 79�[�]J.�0>�A9`X�XC|o4�.�EGF7=;@G=JL�8'��L%].�4�TÓ9 .�I�@�:�.5:;@AL�4ÑN�[�< 4�L�1Q< 4�.�@A4ÑT�@A< =;< Eq@A4%Õ>< 9 :;@AL�4®�HL�� � EG< =3.�4�T­@�:K=�< �"< :;=kL�4=;N�0;.�Fn.�4�Tv1W@���:;6�0;<8VL�0;1W.5:K@GL�4 ¥?3�@Dö y�Î�Î��¿Pãy5Î�Î��{ReÎCw R�w��P§�ÌCX

u�w�§{z�mH@A0>L�FP.�=>6�m�X�X� �N�0K.�F�_�0><�.���Re6CNd1Q< 9�[�.�4C@A=;1 8V0>L�1 :K[�<Q[�L�EG<�R�:eF�N,<Q4�L�� � EA<3.�4�T@G:K=s.5N�N�EA@G9�.5:;@AL�4C= 3oûeý:67«�> �û9�ý:�X ��,þè¥�08+� ��>� ö y�Î�Î�οP�w�ÎC«Û§�w�w�Ra§�y�Ë7X

u�w�¯5zU �L�6�|�XG\"mHL�=>L��{.�]/.� "X�\�Y�L�1Q@GF�.�13.�|UX�X"ij�"< 9�:K=�L�8Z9�.�I7@G:�.{:K@AL�4l@A4�.34�L�� � EA<�L�4.kEA@A��6�@GTQÕ>< :O.{:KL�1Q@A� .5:K@GL�4 ù-��û�ö Z ö\kOú� �ûa ��,þnùæ :���æ¦C+� ��¿�';�ú/+ ö y�Î�ÎPË"PÛ§�ÎC«¨�P§�Ë�§%R�P§�ÌPy�X

u�w�Ë{z�mo.�_,9�[�@�-oX�\P�6�1QL�4P:���X�\� �@A1QL�4�@G4`�`X�XPÏ}6CEG:K@GT�@A1Q< 4C=;@AL�4�.�E7 �@G1`6�E¦.{:K@AL�4�L�8"-/.�IPR@G:�.{:K@A4CB���EAL�]s=s@A4}�@A< =;< E2ce4{Õ>< 9 :;L�0;=q_PFl.QmHL�1WL�B�< 4�< L�6�=oÏ}1W@��7:K6�0><UÏvL�T�< EA@G4�B|oN�N�0>LP.�9�[ 3oûSý:67«�> �ûK�ý:�X ��,þ�¥�08+� ��>� ö y5Î�Î�Ì¿P�w�ÌC«�w%y�Í{RKw�¯Py�X

u�w�Ì5zU �13.5EAEG]�L7L�T �bXG\A��6CEAT�< 0��`XGXl9@G< ]s=�L�4Ò:K[�<�=a:K0>6�9 :;6�0;<�L�8b:;0K.�4C=;@A< 4P:�T�@G< =;< E=;N�0;.�F7= 3oûSý:67«�> �ûK�ý:�X ��,þ�¥�08+� ��>� ö y5Î�Î�οP�w�ÎC«¨�P§�§%Re��Ì�¯CX

u�w�Í5z��H< ��@"m�X�\�ce=;[�@GT�.`�`X�\��o.�BP.5476C13.UÏ�XGXC �@G1`6�EG:K.�4�< L�6�=�Ï}<�.5=;6�0>< 1Q< 4P:K=/L58m9?< EGL�9©R@G:eFQ.�4�T3=;@A� <oL�8MT�@A< =;< Et8V6�< E�4�< .�0J4�L�� � EG<HL�0;@G��9 <o_PF ¬ .�=;< 0sy%Re�tL79 6C=rI�< EAL79 @G1W<�:K< 0]s@G:K[�Ïv@A9 0>L5Ra 79�.�EG<`N�0;L�_"<`I�L�EA6�1Q<`YsmqcSi� �i ¬ y5Î�Î�¡v-JL�4C8V< 0;< 4�9 <�L�4~YD[�< 0;1QL5R

y�Ì

Page 29: y{z 0>< N 0>< =;< 4P:K=rL 4 - Cerfacscerfacs.fr/~cfdbib/repository/TR_CFD_10_29.pdf · 2015. 7. 31. · [ . ='t < 1wl 4 =>:;0k.5:;< t @g:;='9 . n .5_ @aeg@g:k@g

.�4�Tn��6�@GT}�oF74�.51W@G9[0?0>L�9 < =>=;< =q@A4v�@G< =;< E2ij4�B�@A4C< =Hy�Î�Î�¡CXu¨y5Î5zU �L�:K< 0;@GL�6 -oX�\3|o4CT�0;<�]s=Ò��X�\n �1Q@G:;[ôÏ�X�Xn�@A0>< 9�:­@A4%Õ>< 9 :;@AL�4��@A< =>< El �N�0;.�F7=

.�4�TÓ:;[�<~iZ��< 9 :nL�8�-/.�I7@G:K.5:K@GL�4×.�4CTgmqF7T�0K.56�EA@G9v��@GN×L�4­|/:;L�1W@G��.5:;@AL�4 ¥?3A@/öw�Í�ÍP§"P¨ÍP§�Î�Î�Ì�ÎCX

u¨y7w z�nr6�<�n`XG\l0�L%]�< EGE�-oXÛ�JX�\l0*L7L�E¦.Ñ��XG\?�d.�4�Bo=CXG\H �9�[�.5EAEA< 0p=CX 2 X�XGXlq6�.�4P:;@G:�.{:K@GI�<1W< .�=;6�0>< 1Q< 4P:K=�L�8,T�@A< =;< E78V6�< EC=;N�0;.�FU9�[�.�0;.�9 :;< 0;@G=>:;@A9 =�@A4U:;[�<D4�<�.50aRe4CL�� � EA</0>< B�@GL�46�=;@G4�B`�7R�0K.�F�.�_C=;L�0>NC:K@GL�4 3oûSý:67«�> �ûK�ý:�X ��,þ�¥�08+� ��>� ö y�Î�ÎCw�P�w�w�«°¡�Ë�w R�¡PÍ�ÎCX

u¨y�y{zOY�.�4C4�< 0g�JX�ç`X�\k��< @GB�E 2 XW|UX�\�-J@¦.5:>:K@l "Xk|�XG\k<�:g.�EpXn 7:;0;6�9�:K6�0><ÖL�8�[�@AB�[7RI�< EGL�9 @G:eFvT�< 4�=;<b=>N�0K.�F7=�@A4l:;[�<`4�< .�0aR�4�L�� � EA<�0;< B�@AL�4 3oûeý:67«�> �ûK�ý:�Q ��,þ%¥�08+� �� � öy�Î�Î�¯¿P�w�¯C«Û§�Ë�Í%Ra§�ÍPË7X

u¨y5�5zU C.�0;0><O-oXG\ 2 L�4�BQ "XÛ-oXG\t�s< @�:K����XÛ�`X�X�Ï}L7T�< EA@A4CBU:K[�<OiZ�"< 9 :;=sL�8�ce4{Õ>< 9�:KL�0q�HL�� � EG<��< L�1W<�:K0aFkL�4v�@A< =;< E� �N�0K.�F7= ¥?3A@ *X3A*\@�ã ÷�B�B�B�I^E�÷�I^E�BP÷�õ7ö w�Í�Í�ÍCXu¨y{¡�z��H6�0>@A9��7��XÛmOXGX��0;@G��9 <o9 .�I�@�:�.5:;@AL�4W.�4�Tn@�:K=r< �"< 9�:DL�4k=>N�0K.�Fk1Q@���@G4�B�Z ý:§(+-�8 �ÿ2ý<;

H ÿ¡§"�þ:��@w�(��.��ú�ú/+-.�(�Pö w�ÍPË5¯¿PÛÍ�ÌC«Û¯�ÌCw RS¯�ÌPË�Xu¨y�§{z�æJ< 4�< T�@A9�:H�OXG0�XGX H §(�,þ_ �63ú/��ûV �ÿ1��ý<;?0810�ú�Sqý:öß� XG�g@GEA<�F�\��q< ]rnrL�0;��w�Í�Ì�ÎCXu¨y5¯5z��H@A=>[�@A1U6�0K. |UX�\ |o=>=K.�4�@G= �`X �OXGX | ÏvL�T�< E 8VL�0 0j0>@A1W.�0>F �@A< =;< E

�t6C< Ed|/:;L�1Q@A��.{:K@AL�4 æ/.�=>< T L�4 -/.�I7@G:�.{:K@AL�4 æJ6�_�_CEA<£-JL�EGE¦.�NC=;<çij4�< 0;B�F¤@A4ùÚ± Q 3k¥�¥tõOE�E�E fs0�.�=;.�T�< 4�.C\t-J|hqy5Î�Î�ÎCXu¨y�Ë{z�mH6�[ 2 XtnbX�\���L�=;1W.�4Ñ|UX¨�`XGX?| N�[�< 4�L�1Q< 4�L�EGL�B�@G9�.�EsÏvL�T�< ED8VL�0Q�@A< =>< EH �N�0;.�F

|/:KL�1Q@A� .5:K@GL�4kce4P:K< 0;4�.5:;@AL�4�.�E2-JL�4C8V< 0;< 4�9 <U�4�Ï}6CEG:K@GN�[�.�=><���EAL�]s=©UÛÍCw�w�Í�ÍCw�Xu¨y5Ì5zU�7U¨�sL�6�0;�5<A0�XY=CX�\�|H1W=>T�< 43|UX7|UX�X7YD[C<o:�.�_W1W<�:K[�L7TW8VL�0�4�6�1Q< 0>@A9�.5E,9 .�EA9 6�E¦.{:K@AL�4

L�8�=>N�0K.�FnTC0;L�N�EG< :s_�0><�.���6�N ¥?3A@/ö w�Í�ÌPË"P¨ÌPË�y5Î�Ì�ÍCXu¨y5Í5zU-J[�.�I�< =~mOXG\ 2 @A0>1W=><d-oX�\��_,< 0>1W< @A< 0v�JX�Xd9?< EAL79 @�:eFg1W< .�=;6C0;< 1Q< 4P:lL�8bT�< 4�=;<

T�@A< =;< E"8V6�< EM=>N�0K.�F7=s@A4nT�< 4�=;<�.�@G0 3oûeý:67«�> �û9�ý:�X ��,þ7¥�08+� �� � ö y�Î�Î5¡CPGw ¡�«ã§5Ì�Í{RS¯�Î�ÍCXu°��Î5zc0*L�]J< EAE�-oX¨�JX�\�[email protected]:;:;@2 "X�|�XG\,-J[�< L�4�B3 "X¢R 2 XG\ ¬ 61=CXG\C�d.�4�Bu=CX�XCçHRS�q.�Fk|H_�=;L�0>N�R

:K@AL�4lÏv<�.�=>6�0;< 1W< 4�:;=L�8?�@G< =>< E* �N�0;.�F7=o.�4�T}:;[�<�ij�"< 9�:K=L58j�HL�� � EG<���< L�1W<�:K0>F¥?3A@ *X3A*\@�ã õOE�E/ÑGI^E�÷�IeõOE�÷P÷Pö y�Î�Î�¡�X

y�Í

Page 30: y{z 0>< N 0>< =;< 4P:K=rL 4 - Cerfacscerfacs.fr/~cfdbib/repository/TR_CFD_10_29.pdf · 2015. 7. 31. · [ . ='t < 1wl 4 =>:;0k.5:;< t @g:;='9 . n .5_ @aeg@g:k@g

u°��w z 2 0;.�@A9�[C4�.�4Q�OX¨m�X�XP�@���6�=>@AL�4b_PF�.O�q.�4�T�L�1v9?< EGL�9 @G:eFb�*@A< EGT *?ü(� �/�����ý<; H ÿ¡§"�þ:� öw�ÍPË�οP�w��C«Ûy�y%Re�Cw�X

u°��y{zU �1W@G0;4�L�IW|UX�\t �[�@� ,XG\t-J< EA@G�Wc�X�Xt�H.54�T�L�1¥��L�]ªB�< 4�< 0;.5:K@GL�4n:K< 9�[�4�@A��6�<�8VL�0DEA.�0;B�<< T�TCF�=>@A1`6CE¦.5:;@AL�4�=�.�4�TQN�.�0a:K@A9 EA<©ReTCF74�.�1Q@A9 =Z1QL�T�< EA@G4�B ¦C+� ��¿� öG3�¥�ùp@/ö Z ý:§"+-�8 �ÿý<; H ÿ¡§(�þ:�A@,�(��.��ú�ú/+/.�(�Pö y�Î�ÎCw�P�w%y��C«¨�P§�Íxw7�PË�w�X

u°���5z ¬ < @A9��10?[�XG\2æJ@�:;:;EA@A4CB�< 0���X�\MY�0;L�N,<�.v-oX�Xm9?< EAL79 @�:eF�Ïv<�.�=>6�0;< 1W< 4�:;=�@G4�:K[�<b4�< .�04�L�� � EA<r0;< B�@AL�4�L�8t9 L�1W1QL�4�R�0K.�@GE�T�@G< =;< EC=>N�0K.�F7=j.5:*< EG< I5.5:K< T`_�.�9���R�N�0;< =;=;6C0;< =sw�Í{:K[|o4�4�6�.�E�Ïv< < :;@A4�BQL�8*YD[�<Oce4�=>:;@G:K6�:K<�8VL�0 ¬ @A��6�@GTn|/:KL�1Q@A� .5:K@GL�4�.�4�Tl �N�0;.�F� 7F7=aR:K< 1Q=Ofpij6�0>L�N,<�hsy�Î�Î�¡CX

u°�5¡�zU C.�EA@G_�.���XG\?æJ.��nc�XG\r-J[�.�1WN,L�6�=>=;@G4o={RS-oXG\ ¬ .�4�9 <}Ï�XG\rÏ}.�0;@l={R ¬ X�X?-/.�I7@G:K.5:K@GL�4< �"< 9 :/L�4k:K[�<�4C<�.�0/4CL�� � EA<=>N�0K.�FkTC< I�< EAL�NC1W< 4�:s@G4k[�@GB�[kN�0>< =;=>6�0;<�T�@G< =>< E�@G4{Õ>< 9©R:K@AL�4MX*w�Í5:K[�|H4�4�6�.�E?Ï}< < :;@A4�BnL�8rYD[�<bce4C=>:K@�:K6C:;<`8VL�0 ¬ @G�76C@AT�|/:KL�1W@G��.5:;@AL�4l.�4�T �N�0K.�Fv �F�=a:K< 1W=Ufpij6�0>L�N"<�hsy�Î�Î�¡�X

u°��§{zUÏ}L�6�0><�.�6�9`X�\ ¬ .�0>:;@AB�6C<²��X�\% �L�1W1Q< 0>< 0Xn`XG\�|H4�B�< EG_"< 0;B�< 0�-oXG\{-JL�EA@A4O�`X�\y0*L�@A4�=>L�:Y�XGX%�q6�1W< 0;@G9�.�EP1Q< :;[�L�TC=M8VL�026�4�=>:;<�.�T�F�9 L�1QN�0;< =;=;@G_�EA<j1U6�EG:;@�Re9 L�1QN"L�4C< 4P:'0;< .�9 :aR@A4�Bn��L�]s=UL�4��C��< T�.�4�Td1QL�I7@A4�B�B�0>@AT�=%Z ý:§"+-�8 �ÿJý<;T±�ý:6A08§7ûV �ûK�ý:�8 �ÿß*?ü(� �/���� öy�Î�Î�¡CPÛy�ÎPy7«ãË�w�Î{RaË���¯CX��H�JX

��Î

Page 31: y{z 0>< N 0>< =;< 4P:K=rL 4 - Cerfacscerfacs.fr/~cfdbib/repository/TR_CFD_10_29.pdf · 2015. 7. 31. · [ . ='t < 1wl 4 =>:;0k.5:;< t @g:;='9 . n .5_ @aeg@g:k@g

z`έ٫Ǡ¿°À?³�á¶Ü�½�â°Ó ÀpÂ.Á�¾�ÎÕâ�¿�ÀxÑj¿°Àp½rÀp¼S¾�Á�¾�ÎÕº«¼�ºLÒ�¾�Ó À�É­º�âxÁ�¾�έº«¼�ºLÒ®È�º«Çj¼jËjÁ�¿°Ìßâ[º«¼jËjÎÕ¾�έº«¼j½�Ñj¿�º$Ý®Î�Ë ÀpËÈ®Ì�¾�ÓjÀ#¹eÃAÆCÇ ¿°ÊbÍ7Â�º�Ë ÀpÉ á

�Cw

Page 32: y{z 0>< N 0>< =;< 4P:K=rL 4 - Cerfacscerfacs.fr/~cfdbib/repository/TR_CFD_10_29.pdf · 2015. 7. 31. · [ . ='t < 1wl 4 =>:;0k.5:;< t @g:;='9 . n .5_ @aeg@g:k@g

z`έ٫Çj¿�Às·®áOÞ�º«Â�Àp¼jâxÉÕÁ�¾�Ç ¿�À#ºLÒC¾�ÓjÀ�ÎÕ¼�érÀpâ[¾rºL¿bÙLÀxº«Â�Àx¾r¿�ÌLá

�Py

Page 33: y{z 0>< N 0>< =;< 4P:K=rL 4 - Cerfacscerfacs.fr/~cfdbib/repository/TR_CFD_10_29.pdf · 2015. 7. 31. · [ . ='t < 1wl 4 =>:;0k.5:;< t @g:;='9 . n .5_ @aeg@g:k@g

z`έ٫Ǡ¿°Àeç®ájÚ�â°Ó ÀpÂ�À�º«¼!¾�Ó ÀßËjÀx¾rÀx¿°Â�ÎÕ¼jÁ�¾�ÎÕº«¼�ºLÒ¢½rÑO¿°ÁpÌ�ÁL¼ Ù«ÉÕÀßÁ�¾�ËjÎÕ½r¾�ÁL¼jâ[À|{~}�����Ë º$»�¼j½r¾r¿°ÀpÁLÂÒ�¿�º«Â0¾�Ó À?¼ ºLãxãpÉ­À�À[ä Î­¾xá

���

Page 34: y{z 0>< N 0>< =;< 4P:K=rL 4 - Cerfacscerfacs.fr/~cfdbib/repository/TR_CFD_10_29.pdf · 2015. 7. 31. · [ . ='t < 1wl 4 =>:;0k.5:;< t @g:;='9 . n .5_ @aeg@g:k@g

Í�ÁL½rÀ à ðÃ

ÃA¼�éÄÀpâ[¾�έº«¼/Ñj¿�Àp½�½�Çj¿�À�� áYJ�Z ÏøÊ��CÁSÐ ·�· ·�·

Í�ÓjÁLÂ?È�Àx¿�Ñj¿�Àp½�½�Çj¿�Àd� eKx ÏøÊ��`ÁSÐ ¹�á�³ ·

Ú®Ñj¿°Á¶Ì�À[ä Î­¾�ÝLÀpÉ­º�âxέ¾aÌ£Ï����/��Ð>²jÀ[ä�Ñ�Àx¿°ÎÕÂ�Àp¼M¾ ·�³�¹�Öp·�·�¹ ³©»�¶$Öp·�¹%¶

Ú®Ñj¿°Á¶Ì�À[ä Î­¾�ÝLÀpÉ­º�âxέ¾aÌ£Ï����/��Ð>²OÂ�º�Ë ÀpÉ ·�·�» ³©»%µÆCÁ�ÈOÉ­À�³Í2º«Â�ÑOÁ�¿°ÎÕ½rº«¼¯ºLÒ`½rÑj¿�Áp̯À[ä�ÎÕ¾�ÝLÀpÉ­º®âxÎÕ¾×̯»�έ¾�Ó¯À[ä�Ñ�Àx¿°ÎÕÂ�Àp¼M¾�ÁLÉèËjÁ�¾�Á�ºLÒ�� çLç��

��¡

Page 35: y{z 0>< N 0>< =;< 4P:K=rL 4 - Cerfacscerfacs.fr/~cfdbib/repository/TR_CFD_10_29.pdf · 2015. 7. 31. · [ . ='t < 1wl 4 =>:;0k.5:;< t @g:;='9 . n .5_ @aeg@g:k@g

ÞeÇjÂ?ÈFÀx¿�ºLÒC¾�Ó À#¼jºLãxãpÉ­À Ú®ÑO¿°ÁpÌ!ÁL¼ Ù«É­À�ϧˠÀxÙL¿°ÀxÀp½�Ð Ú®Ñj¿�Áp̯ÁL¼ Ù«É­À.ϧˠÀxÙL¿�ÀxÀp½¦Ð

Ô�ä®Ñ�Àx¿°ÎÕÂ�Àp¼S¾ ¹eÃAÆCÇ ¿°ÊbÍ

³ ¶®á°¶ ¸

· ³�¹ �®á°¸

ç ³pç ³pç®á°¶ÆCÁ�ÈOÉ­Àq·Í2º«Â�ÑOÁ�¿°ÎÕ½rº«¼¯ºLÒ�¾�ÓjÀ#½rÑj¿°Á¶Ì,ÁL¼ Ù«É­À�Ñj¿°ÀpËjÎÕâ[¾rÀp˯ȮÌ!¾�ÓjÀ#Â�º�Ë ÀpÉè»�έ¾�Ó/¾�Ó À�À[ä�ÑFÀx¿�ÎÕÂ�Àp¼M¾�ºLÒ��ã³K´x�Ò�ºL¿b¾�Ó ¿�ÀxÀ?ËjÎY��Àx¿�Àp¼S¾b¼jºLãxãpÉ­Àp½xá

�P§

Page 36: y{z 0>< N 0>< =;< 4P:K=rL 4 - Cerfacscerfacs.fr/~cfdbib/repository/TR_CFD_10_29.pdf · 2015. 7. 31. · [ . ='t < 1wl 4 =>:;0k.5:;< t @g:;='9 . n .5_ @aeg@g:k@g

0 0.5 1 1.5 2 2.5 3 3.5 4 4.5 5Backpressure (MPa)

6

8

10

12

14

16

Spra

y an

gle

(°)

Saliba 50 MPaDITurBC 50 Mpa

z`έ٫Ǡ¿°À�´ áCÍ2º«Â�ÑOÁ�¿�ÎÕ½rº«¼&ºLÒ2¾�Ó À.½rÑj¿�ÁpÌ&ÁL¼ Ù«É­À�Ñj¿�ÀpËOÎÕâ[¾rÀpË&ÈMÌ&¾�Ó À�Â�º®Ë ÀpÉ`»ßέ¾�Ó&¾�Ó À�À[ä�Ñ�Àx¿°Î ÖÂ�Àp¼M¾�½bºLÒ�� ç ´y�JÁ�¾�����·��7� Ò�ºL¿�ËjÎ��FÀx¿�Àp¼M¾bÎÕ¼�érÀpâ[¾�έº«¼¯Ñj¿°Àp½�½�Ç ¿�Àp½pá

��¯

Page 37: y{z 0>< N 0>< =;< 4P:K=rL 4 - Cerfacscerfacs.fr/~cfdbib/repository/TR_CFD_10_29.pdf · 2015. 7. 31. · [ . ='t < 1wl 4 =>:;0k.5:;< t @g:;='9 . n .5_ @aeg@g:k@g

� áYJ[Z ³pç�¹

� e'x �

¹ìÎÕ½�â�ÓjÁ�¿�ÙLÀ#â[º®Àxæ.âxέÀp¼M¾ {$�§z À[ä®Ñ�Àx¿°ÎÕÂ�Àp¼S¾ ¹�á°»�»

¹ìÎÕ½�â�ÓjÁ�¿�ÙLÀ#â[º®Àxæ.âxέÀp¼M¾ {$�§z Â�º®ËjÀpÉ ¹�á°»�»

Ú®ÑO¿°Áp̯ÁL¼ Ù«É­À {$�§z À[ä®Ñ�Àx¿°ÎÕÂ�Àp¼S¾�ϧˠÀxÙL¿�ÀxÀp½¦Ð »®á°¶

Ú®ÑO¿°Áp̯ÁL¼ Ù«É­À {$�§z Â�º®ËjÀpÉ�ϧˠÀxÙL¿�ÀxÀp½�Ð µMᨵÆCÁ�ÈOÉ­À#çÍ2º«Â�ÑOÁ�¿°ÎÕ½rº«¼ ºLÒeËjÎÕ½�â�ÓjÁ�¿�ÙLÀ,â[ºMÀxæ�âxέÀp¼S¾�ÁL¼OË ½�Ñj¿°ÁpÌ ÁL¼ Ù«É­À¯Ñj¿�º$Ý®Î�Ë ÀpË ÈMÌY¾�Ó À,Â�º®ËjÀpÉ�»ßέ¾�ÓÀ[ä�Ñ�Àx¿°ÎÕÂ�Àp¼M¾�ÁLÉèËjÁ�¾�Á�ºLÒ\�¢·y���

�PË

Page 38: y{z 0>< N 0>< =;< 4P:K=rL 4 - Cerfacscerfacs.fr/~cfdbib/repository/TR_CFD_10_29.pdf · 2015. 7. 31. · [ . ='t < 1wl 4 =>:;0k.5:;< t @g:;='9 . n .5_ @aeg@g:k@g

-4 -2 0 2 4 6Radial Distance / Nozzle Diameter

0

0.2

0.4

0.6

0.8Sp

ray

velo

city

/ B

erno

ulli

velo

city

Measurement (Chaves[2004])Mean velocity profile (Chaves[2004])DITurBC

z`έ٫Ǡ¿°À�¶®á«Í2º«Â�ÑOÁ�¿°Î�½rº«¼�ºLÒj¿�ÁLËjÎÕÁLÉSËOÎÕ½r¾r¿°Î­È^Ç ¾�έº«¼ìºLÒO½rÑO¿°ÁpÌ�Á�ä ÎÕÁLÉMÝLÀpÉ­º®âxÎÕ¾×Ì#»ßέ¾�Ó�À[ä�Ñ�Àx¿°ÎÕÂ�Àp¼M¾�ÁLÉËjÁ�¾�Á�ºLÒ��¢·y�/�¢Á�¾\����{ ßpà�áãâ �Ó³�¹

��Ì