ysDU}U QO Q=@v= w O}rwDR @ Cq}yUD...

�1396

u=DUtR�

'h}QW

C}Q}Ot

w`}=vY

|UOvyt

97�91

"X'2/

1|xQ=t

W'33

�1|xQ

wO

Ori

gina

lArt

icle|=ysDU}U QO Q=@v= w O}rwDR=@ Cq}yUD |@=}u=mt

Cr=L Q@ Twmat w s}kDUt l}DUHr xJQ=Bl}uDiQo Q_v QO =@ |iO=YD |=[=kD

C}iQ_ C}OwOLt =@ |awHQt |=yq=m�OWQ= |U=vWQ� |wHWv=O� QwBu=}m Q=}yt

�OWQ= |U=vWQ� |wHWv=O� p=@|r}rH =QyR�O=DU=� �|qwH RQ@} Qi

u=QyD x=oWv=O '|vi |=yxOmWv=O T}OQB '`}=vY |UOvyt |xOmWv=O

w s}kDUt l}DUHr |=ysDU}U QO |@=}u=mt hrDNt |=ypOt |UQQ@ =@ 'xar=]t u}= QOQO Cq}yUD |@=}u=mt |=Q@ |}xJQ=Bl} pOt 'xv}tR u}= QO Q}N= Cq=kt QwQt w Twmatw s}kDUt CQwYx@ u=tRty Qw]x@ q=m u=} QH u; QO xm CU= xOW x�=Q= l}DUHr sDU}U

Rm =Qt 'xOvvmO}rwD Rm =Qt Q}_v |Dq}yUD 'pOt u}= QO "CU= xOW xDiQo Q_v QO TwmatxOW |@=}u=mt 'Cq}yUD OwOLt C}iQ_ uDiQo Q_v QO =@ 'Q=@v= w O}rwDR=@ Rm =Qt 'x]U=w

K}LY OOa 1 w QiY \rDNt |R} Qxt=vQ@ pOt l} 'xar=]t u}= QO |R=UpOt |=Q@ "CU="CU= xOW ^=Lr q=m Twmat w s}kDUt u=} QH u=tRty Qw]x@ u; QO xm CU= xOW x�=Q=

xDUO wO pt=W w xOW xDiQo Q_v QO |iO=YD CQwYx@ =[=kD pOt u}= QO u}vJty"CU= wO xDUO |q=m |=[=kD w O}OH |q=m |=[=kD

[email protected]@[email protected]

pOt 's}kDUt w Twmat l}DUHr 'Cq}yUD |@=}u=mt %|O}rm u=oS=w"|iO=YD |=[=kD '\rDNt K}LY OOa |R} Qxt=vQ@

xtOkt "1pwYLt CWoR=@ =@ \@DQt |=yC}r=ai x}rm Twmat l}DUHr sDU}U [3]"Ov} wo|tOv=CQ=@a =yC}r=ai u}= "OQ=O Q@ QO OvwW|t Ci=} R=@ pt=m Qw]x@ xm |v=tR =D =Q'|R=U?DQt w pwYLt CUD w V}=tR; '|R=Ul}miD '|Q=mR}tD '|Qw;`tH %R='|@=}u=mtp�=Utu} QDtyt R=|m} [5w4]"|@=} R=@ C=}rta|wU x@ p=kDv= w |R=UxQ}NPC}OwOLt uwO@ w C}iQ_ C}OwOLt |=Q=O CQwY wO x@ xm CU= Q=@v= |@=}u=mtu} QD?U=vt uDi=} p�=Ut u}= QO hOy w OQ}o|t Q=Qk xar=]t OQwt Cq=kt QOC}iQ_u=} QDWt x@ T} wQU |x�=Q= w pwYLt Ci=} QO |=Q@ Q=@v= Q=QkDU= u=mt u} QDy@ ww Cq}yUD Q=QkDU= |=yxv} Ry K]U Vy=m Qw_vtx@ ,qwtat =yQ=@v= Q=QkDU= "CU=[7]wW w w�D [6]"OQ}o|t Q=Qk xar=]t OQwt pkv w ptL |=yxv} Ry K]UVy=m u}vJtyRmQtD Q=@v= |@=}u=mt Q@ l}DUHr |xm@W |L=Q] w[wt uwt=Q}B OwN |xar=]t QOl}DUHr |xm@W wv R= Ov=xOQm xQ=W= u; x@ OwN xar=]t QO xm |}xm@W wv "Ov=xOQm=yQ=@v= |yOT} wQU |ovwoJ w Q=@v= |xv}y@ u=mt w O=OaD u}}aD "CU= xOw@ s}kDUtOQwt Twmat l}DUHr XwYNx@ 'l}DUHr |xm@W QO xm CU= |D=aw[wt|xm@W QO |L]UxU |@=}u=mt |=Q@ |rOt xar=]t u}= QO "OQ}o|t Q=Qk xHwDu; QO xm xOWx�=Q= Twmat w s}kDUt l}DUHr sDU}U QO 1�RMN� O}rwDR=@Q=Qk xHwD OQwt |RmQt |=yQ=@v= w O}rwD w O}rwDR=@ Rm =Qt Cqt=aD u=tRty Qw]x@

'|]}LtCU} R p�=Ut uwJ |r}qO x@ =v@ w C=QQkt w u}v=wk Q}}eD x@ xHwD =@C=v=} QH =yu=tR=U w |DavY Rm =Qt R= |Q=}U@ |yOT} wQU K]U w |O=YDk=x@ xDiQxDiQ xm Ov=xOQm OQ=w OwN |m}DUHr sDU}U QO =Q |m}DUHr Twmatu=} QH '|m}DUHr Twmat C=v=} QH R= Qw_vt "OwW|t xOwRi= Rm =Qt u}= O=OaD=yOv=tUB Ovv=t 'xDiQo Q=Qk u=} QDWt xO=iDU= OQwt xm CU= |DqwYLt CmQL =}x@ w OwW|t ?wULt VRQ=|@ |QDWt |=Q@ xm CqwYLt R= |}=yxOv=tR=@ =} w|xOvvmu=}@ l}DUHr s}kDUt u=} QH [2w1]"OwW|t xO=DUQi |@=} R=@ Rm =Qt CtU|Qw;`tH xOvvmu=}@ l}DUHr Twmat u=} QH w CUq=m `} RwD G}=Q w pw=ODt Cr=L|QDWt \UwD |@=} R=@ Rm =Qt x@ CqwYLt uO=DUQi TB =} xOWhQYt CqwYLtu}vJ =m} Qt; Twmat l}DUHr |}=QH= utHv= |wU R= Twmat l}DUHr "CU=

%CU= xOW h} QaD|OwHwt 's=N O=wt u=} QH 'xv} Ry |Ot;Q=m pQDvm '|R=UxO=}B '|R} Qxt=vQ@ Ov}=Qi�hQYt Q_vx]kv R= xm =Q =yu; x@ \w@ Qt C=aq]= w |}=yv CqwYLt 'Ov}=Qi QOTwmatl}DUHr �OQ}o|t Q=Qk |UQQ@ OQwt xv}y@ hQYt =} VRQ= |@=} R=@ Qw_vtx@

pw�Ut xOvU} wv �"1394 11 7 VQ}PB '1394 8 13 x}LqY= '1394 3 24 Ci=} QO %M} Q=D

"""QOQ=@v=

wO}rwDR=

@Cq}y

UD|@=}u=

mt|iO=YD =[=kD u; QO xm Ov=xO=O x�=Q=|rOtTwmatl}DUHr QO swOCUO w|awHQtw |iO=YD |R=Ux}@W R= xO=iDU= =@ xOWx�=Q= pOt C}=yv QO "CU= xOW xDiQo Q_v QOpOt 2014p=U QO [14]u=Q=mty wh} QW "CU= xOWpLl}DvS |Q=mD@==Qi sD} Qwor="Ov=xO=O x�=Q= =Q xrwYLtOvJ Twmat l}DUHr |xm@W l} |@=} Q}Ut � |@=}u=mtw s}kDUtl}DUHr |xJQ=Bl} |xm@Wl} 2013 p=U QO [15]u=Q=mty w|v=[tQu}t= xO=RuUL "Ov=xOQm |L=Q] |iO=YD |xiOyOvJ |xr�Ut R= xO=iDU= =@ Twmat|xQ}HvR |xm@W l} |@=}u=mt |=Q@ |}xiOyOvJ pOt '2013 p=U QO [16]nv=S w"Ov=xOQm x�=Q= '|iO=YD CWoQ@ MQv w =[=kD =@ 'Twmat w s}kDUt |xDU@xkrL u}t-=DK}LY OOa |]NQ}e |R} Qxt=vQ@ VwQ R= xO=iDU= =@ '2009 p=U QO [17]u}ru; |r=tDL= |=[=kD w C}iQ_ C}OwOLt =@ Cq}yUD |@=}u=mt |xr�Ut '\rDNtQO [18]u=U "CU= xOQm pL |Q=mD@= |R=UO=R; VwQ l} =@ =Q u; w xOQm pOt =Q=@ |Q=mD@==Qi VwQ l} R= xO=iDU= =@ =Q Cq}yUD |@=}u=mt |xr�Ut '2012 p=UVwQ OQmrta C=@F= |=Q@ w= u}vJty "CU= xO=O xaUwD C}iQ_ C}OwOLt OwHwp=U QO [19]u=Q=mty w ROv=vQi "CU= xOQm xU}=kt =yVwQ Q}=U =@ =Q VwQ u}= 'OwNsD} Qwor= R= xO=iDU= =@ =Q C}iQ_ C}OwOLt =@ Cq}yUD |@=}u=mt |xr�Ut 2014'TmrBt}U VwQ =@ OwN |O=yvW}B VwQ |xU}=kt R= w OvOQm pLl}DvS |Q=mD@==QiCmrt "OQ=O hqDN= xv}y@ VwQ =@ OYQO 1 3 =yu; VwQ xm OvO}UQ xH}Dv u}= x@|wQ C}OwOLt =@ xm@W |L=Q] w |@=}u=mt |xr�Ut 2001 p=U QO [20]u}mUO w=@ |@=}u=mt |xr�Ut 2014 p=U QO [21]wy "Ov=xOQm pL w xDiQo Q_v QO =Q =[=kD|wHwCUH |Q=mD@= sD} Qwor= R= xO=iDU= =@ =Q `@vtl} =@ wC}iQ_C}OwOLt OwHw|xm@W QO |L]UxU |@=}u=mt pOt l} xar=]t u}= QO "CU= xOQm pL xawvttu=tRty Qw]x@ u; QO xm xOWx�=Q= Twmat w s}kDUt l}DUHr sDU}U QO O}rwDR=@u}= QO "CU= xDiQo Q=Qk xHwD OQwt |RmQt |=yQ=@v= R}v w O}rwD w O}rwDR=@ Rm =Qt Cqt=aDxOW xDiQo Q_v QO |} w} Q=vU w |iO=YD |=[=kD CQwYx@ u=} QDWt |=[=kD xar=]t|mOv= C=ar=]t QO 'u}t-=D |xQ}HvR |xRwL QO xOWs=Hv= C=ar=]t x@ xHwD =@ "CU=u}= &CU= xOW ^=Lr Twmat =} s}kDUt u}t-=D |xQ}HvR QO OwOLt C}iQ_ =@ Q=@v='O}rwD Rm =Qt Cq}yUD Q}=U Q=vm QO Q=@v= |@=}u=mt x@ xar=]t u}= QO xm CU= |r=L QOR= |Q=}U@ QO "CU= xOW xDN=OQB C}iQ_ C}OwOLt =@ x]U=w Rm =Qt 'O}rwDR=@ Rm =Qtu=} QH Twmat w s}kDUtu}t-=D |xQ}HvR |xJQ=Bl} |xm@W QO xOW xar=]t Cq=ktx@ O}rwDR=@ Rm =Qt =} xOvvmO}rwD R= |va} s}kDUt |q=m u=} QH CQwYx@ CWoQ@ QO q=m|=yq=m \ki C=ar=]t u}= QO xm CU= |r=L QO u}= &CU= xOvvmhQYt =} |QDWtCUO |=yq=m |=[=kD 'Q=@ u}rw= |=Q@ xr=kt u}= QO "CU= xOW xDiQo Q_v QO wvu=oOvvmhQYt =} u=} QDWt |=[=kD u}t-=D |=Q@ Twmat |q=m u=} QH QO xm 'swO|}=]N ?} Q[ xar=]t u}= QO u}vJty "CU= xOW xar=]t 'OwW|t xQ}NP Q=@v= QOxwqa xm |}xvwox@ s}=xDiQo Q_v QO q=m |R=UswOat =@ x]@=Q QO x]U=w Rm =Qt |=Q@u}= 'u}t-=D |xQ}HvR |xv=}t QO w x]U=w Rm =Qt Q=vm QO |R=UswOat Rm =Qt Q=QkDU= Q@|xOvvmO}rwD |=yCmQW R= |Q=}U@ "Ov=xDi=} Q=QkDU= R}v O}rwDR=@ Rm =Qt Q=vm QO Rm =Qt

"Ovvm|t xO=iDU= u}t-=D |xQ}HvR u}= R= u=yH QU=QU QO |m}vwQDmr= C=a]k

Rm =Qt ^=Lr =@ xm@W l} QO Cq}yUD |@=}u=mt pOt "3Q=@v= w O}rwDR=@

O}rwDR=@ |xm@W OwN |xar=]t QO 2007 p=U QO [22]wr nv=}m} S w pDUw@ |r=D=vpOt l} |x�=Q= x@ =yu; "Ov=xDiQo Q_v QO =Q CU= |@=} R=@ |=yVwQ R= |m} xm

Twmat l}DUHr |=yxm@W u} QDsyt R= |m} O}rwDR=@ |xm@W "CU= xOW xDiQo?w}at =} xOW xO=iDU= CqwYLt xm CU= |@=} R=@ VwQ l} w xOW |}=U=vW=Q pwYLt u}= u=wD|t &Ovm|t p}O@D O}OH |rwYLt x@ pw= C}i}m u=ty =@ =Qx@ pta ,qwtat "O=O Q=Qk VwQi ZQat QO Q=R=@ QO wv w O}OH |rwYLt u=wvax@CN=U |YYNDVv=O xm =QJ OwW|t s=Hv= pwYLt xOvR=UCmQW\UwD O}rwDR=@2xDU@xkrL |xm@W =Q |}xm@W u}vJ "CU= CmQW u}= CUO QO pwYLt u}=|xr�Ut |D=ar=]t QwQt x@ swO VN@ %CU= u}vJ wQ V}B |xr=kt Q=DN=U "Ovt=v|tswU VN@ QO "CU= xDi=} X=YDN= C}iQ_ C}OwOLt =@ Cq}yUD |@=}u=mtxDN=OQB Q=@v= w O}rwDR=@ Rm =Qt ^=Lr =@ xm@W l} QO Cq}yUD |@=}u=mt pOtsHvB VN@ "CU= xOW x�=Q= xr�Ut |[=} Q |R=UpOt sQ=yJ VN@ QO w CU=VN@ QO w 'xDi=} X=YDN= xr�Ut pL |=Q@ xO=iDU= OQwt Q=Ri=sQv w pL VwQ x@xDiQo Q=Qk |UQQ@ OQwt |OOa p=Ft l} w xOW s=Hv= |D=@U=Lt |=yV}=tR; sWWxOW s=Hv= xOt; CUO x@ |=y|HwQN |wQ |Q}oxH}Dv sDWy VN@ QO ,=D}=yv "CU=

"CU=

C=}@O= QwQt "2|=yQ=@v= |=Q@ |D}t=QB OQm} wQ R= xO=iDU= =@ 2014 p=U QO [8]u=Q=mty w =v=Dvwi|xv}tR QO j}kO |=yVwQ R= |m} |D}t=QB VwQ "Ov=xOQm |@=}u=mt |R=UxQ}NPR= xO=iDU= =@`k=w QO "OWN@|tCrwyUu=Q}Ot|=Q@ =Q?=NDv=C=}rta xmCU=|Ov@x@DQOthrDNt |=yu=mt QO Q=@v=CN=U|=yC} wrw= xar=]tu}= QO xOWKQ]t |=yQ=}atp=U QO [9]u=Q=mty w u}mU; "OwW|t x@U=Lt|@ wN ,=D@UvCkO =@ w OQ}o|t Q=Qk Q_vw 'xDN=OQB|}q=mOvJ |=yQ=@v=|@=}u=mt x@XNWt |OwHwtuDiQo Q_v QO =@ 2013u}OvJ O}rwD R=TB xm |Qw]x@ 'Ov=xOQm|L=Q] xOvvmO}rwD |=Q@l}DUHr |xm@Wl}OQm} wQl} R= xO=iDU= =@ xar=]tu}= QO "OwW`} RwD w x[Qau=WwQixOQN x@O}=@ pwYLtl} QyC}iQ_ u}}aD w =yQ=@v=|@=}u=mt &OwW|t s=Hv= Cq}yUD|@=}u=mt '|[=} QsD} Qwor= R= xr�Ut u}= pL |=Q@ "CU=y|@=}u=mt u}= xrtHR= O}OH Q=@v=T}U-=D |=Q@QO =@ [10]u=Q=mty w xO=RQ=Wi= 2012 p=U QO "CU= xOW xO=iDU= l}DvS |Q=mD@==Qi|R=i|@D=QtxrUrUp}rLD OQm} wQ =@ u=tRty Qw]x@ w '|i}m w|tm |=yQ=}atuDiQo Q_v|@D=QtxrUrUp}rLD OQm} wQ QO "Ov=xDN=OQB Q=@v=|@=}u=mt x@ 'C}a]k sOa\}=QWCLD?U=vt pLt |D=@U=Lt |] TBU w xOW |yOuRw =yQ=}atQ} R w =yQ=}at =OD@= |R=iQO nQR@|v=Btml} |wQ |OQwt |xar=]t xr=kt u}= QO "CU= xOW ?=NDv= Q=@v= |=Q@|=Q@ |@=}u=mt x@ [11]u=Q=mty w xO=RQ=Wi= 'p=U u=ty QO "CU= xDiQo CQwY u=Q}=u=tRty Qw]x@ "Ov=xDN=OQB C}a]k sOa \}=QW CLD |R=i T}UB=D OQm} wQ =@ =yQ=@v="CU= xOW xDiQo Q=Qk Q_v Otj}kLDu}= QO =yQ=@v=|@=}u=mt|=Q@|i}m w|tm|=yQ=}atw CU= C}ty= R�=L =y|v=Btm QFm = |=Q@ j}kLD u}= QO xOW xDiQo Q_v QO |=yQ=}at|xar=]t xr=kt u}= QO "CU=y|v=Btm QFm = |=Q@ |R=UxO=}B p@=k pOt u}= p}rO u}tyx@CUO x@ xQ@N j} Q] R= =yxO=O w xDiQo CQwY |v=Q}= nQR@ |v=Btm l} |wQ |OQwtQ=@v= |@=} Q}Ut � |@=}u=mt x@ 2011 p=U QO [12]u=Q=mty w C=Q u=iDU= "CU= xOt;|}xOvvmx[Qa sDU}U O}=@ |a}@] |=}q@ O=ONQ R= TB "Ov=xDN=OQB u=QL@ \}=QW QOQO "Ovm p=UQ= xO}O xFO=L O=Qi= x@ =Q sRq O=wt =D OwW QkDUt XNWt u=mt l} QO'|OL |xOWC} wkD VwQ w xiOyOvJ |R=Uxv}y@ OQm} wQ R= xO=iDU= =@ xar=]t u}=CUO x@ |=Q@ C}=yv QO "CU= xOW |@=}u=mt xOvvmx[Qa sDU}U u}= |=Q@ |Q=@v=

"CU= xOW xO=iDU= |Q=mD@= |=ysD} Qwor= R= pOt pL w xv}y@ ?=wH uOQw;|=yq=m Q=@v= |=Q@ |Rm =Qt |@=}u=mt |=Q@ [13]nv=w w |=O 2014 p=U QO

92

2/1|

xQ=tW'

33�1

|xQwO'

�1396

u=DUtR�

h}QW

C}Q}Ot

w`}=vY

|UOvyt |t=tD 'pmW u}= |oO}J}B R= |Q}owrH |=Q@ "CU= xOW xO=O V}=tv xOWx�=Q= pOt

u=}@ ,=iQY =D xOW x�=Q= u}O=tv \@=wQ \ki w CU= xOWv x�=Q= QY=va u=}t \@=wQ"Ovm QDxO=U =Q xr�Ut

x�=Q= Cq}yUD |@=}u=mt R= |L]UxU |xJQ=Bl} pOt l} xar=]t u}= QOxOW xDiQo Q_v QO u=tRty Qw]x@ Twmat w s}kDUt |q=m u=} QH u; QO xm OwW|tj} Q] R= u=oOvvmhQYt =} u=} QDWt |=[=kD 's}kDUt Qw]x@ q=m u=} QHQO "CU=u=} QDWt &OwW|t p=UQ= =yQ=@v= |=Q@ w u}t-=D O}rwDR=@ Rm =Qt =} w xOvvmO}rwD Rm =QtO}=@ "Ovvm|t Ci=} QO =yQ=@v= R= =Q OwN |=[=kD OQwt |=yq=m s}kDUt Qw]x@ R}vRm =Qt xmr@ 'OvR=OQB|tv =yq=m O}rwDR=@ x@ =yvD O}rwDR=@ Rm =Qt xm O}W=@ xDW=O xHwDQw]x@ q=m u=} QH QO "OvQ=O =Q |awHQt |=yq=m O}rwDR=@ C}r@=k xm OvDUy |O}rwDu}= R= TBU w OwW|t p=UQ= x]U=w Rm =Qt |=Q@ =OD@= |awHQt |=yq=m 'Twmatu=oOvvmhQYt =} u=} QDWt |=[=kD "OW Oy=wN xO=DUQi O}rwDR=@ Rm =Qt x@ Rm =QtC}iQ_ u}vJty &CU= XNWt=v =} '|r=tDL= '|iO=YD hrDNt |=yw} Q=vU CLD=yQ}eDt w =yQDt=Q=B w pOt |iQat x@ xt=O= QO "CU= OwOLt R}v Rm =Qt R= l} Qy

"s} R=OQB|t

|[=} Q |R=UpOt "4Cq}yUD wv Q=yJ |@=}u=mt x@ u=tRsy Qw]x@ xOWx�=Q= pOt 'OW xQ=W= xm u=vJQO OwOLt C}iQ_ ^=Lr =@ �Q=@v= w O}rwDR=@ Rm =Qt 'x]U=w Rm =Qt 'xOvvmO}rwD Rm =Qt�|R} Qxt=vQ@ pOt l} xr�Ut u}= |R=UpOt |=Q@ "OR=OQB|t Q=@v= w O}rwDR=@ |xm@Wu=} QH u=tRty Qw]x@ u; QO xm xOW x�=Q= K}LY OOa w 1 w QiY \rDNt"CU= xOW xDiQo Q_v QO =yv; p@=kDt VvmsyQ@ w Twmat w s}kDUt |q=mu; QO xm OyO|t V}=tv =Q xm@W |ak=w |=yx@vH xOW x�=Q= |[=} Q pOtx@ w |iO=YD CQwYx@ q=m |=[=kD w OvQ=O C}r=ai OwOLt C}iQ_ =@ Rm =Qtx�=Q= xOvvmhQYt =} |QDWt \UwD wO xDUO |q=m w O}OH |q=m CQwY wOxOW x�=Q= |O=yvW}B pOt |=yQ}eDt w =yQDt=Q=B '=yO=tv '=yT}Ov= Q} R QO "OwW|t

"CU=

=yO=tv w =yT}Ov= "1"4&=yxOvvmhQYt =} u=} QDWt %i

&O}rwDR=@ w O}rwD Rm =Qt Q=QkDU= |=Q@ xwkr=@ |=yu=mt %j&x]U=w Rm =Qt Q=QkDU= |=Q@ xwkr=@ |=yu=mt %k&Q=@v= Rm =Qt Q=QkDU= |=Q@ xwkr=@ |=yu=mt %w

"u=} QDWt |=Q@ =[=kD |w} Q=vU %s

=yQDt=Q=B "2"4&s=j u=mt QO xOvvmO}rwD Q=QkDU= C@=F |xv} Ry %fj

&s=j u=mt QO O}rwDR=@ RmQt Q=QkDU= C@=F |xv} Ry %frj&s=k u=mt QO x]U=w RmQt Q=QkDU= C@=F |xv} Ry %fck

&s=w u=mt QOQ=@v= Q=QkDU= C@=F |xv} Ry %faw&s=i xOvvmhQYt =} |QDWt |=[=kD %hi

&s=i |QDWt O}rwDR=@ xO=t; |awHQt CqwYLt u=R}t %hri&s=w u=mt QO Q=@v= C}iQ_ %capw

xU =yvD u; QO xm 'Ov=xDN=OQB Twmat l}DUHr sDU}U QO xJQ=Bl} |L]UwO'1 pmW j@=]t "CU= xOW |@=}u=mt |rY= CN=U RmQt w O}rwDR=@ 'x]U=w RmQt'x]U=w Rm =Qt 'xOvvmhQYt =} |QDWt QYva Q=yJ OwN |O=yvW}B pOt QO =yu;|=[=kD xOWx�=Q= pOt QO "Ov=xDiQo Q_v QO =Q |rY= CN=U Rm =Qt w O}rwDR=@ Rm =Qtp�=k u; |=Q@ C}iQ_ C}OwOLt xvwoI}y R}v w xOW xDiQo Q_v QO C@=F u=} QDWt

"Ov=xOWv=Q [22]wr nv=}m} S w pDUw@ |r=D=v \UwD xOWKQ]t pOt xar=]t u}= QO =t=yvD =Q OwN pOt =yu; "s}=xOQm ?}mQD Q=@v= |@=}u=mt |=ypOt =@ =Q u; w 'xO=O xaUwDTwmat w s}kDUt l}DUHr |=ysDU}U R= xJQ=Bl} |xm@W l} uDiQo Q_v QO =@w x]U=w Rm =Qt |=Q@ C}iQ_ h} QaD =@ =t xar=]t u}= QO xm Cw=iD u}= =@ Ov=xO=O x�=Q=|=Q@ C}iQ_ h} QaD R}v w 'Q=@v= Rm =Qt |xm@W =@ xm@W u}= ?}mQD 'xOvvmu}t-=D Rm =QtCtUk GvB =t xm@W u}= QO "s}=xDN=OQB xr�Ut u}= |R=UpOt x@ 'Rm =Qt u; R= s=OmQy'O}rwDR=@ Rm =Qt 'x]U=w Rm =Qt 'u=oOvvmhQYt =} u=} QDWt %s}=xDiQo Q_v QO =Q sytx@ =[=kD Q}eDt u=oOvvmhQYt =} u=} QDWt CtUk QO "Q=@v= Rm =Qt w xOvvmO}rwD Rm =Qt"OwW|t x�=Q= xOWQ}taD |q=m |=[=kD w wv w O}OH |=yq=m |=[=kD CQwY wO'|UQR=@ w OvQ}o|t Q=Qk xO=iDU= OQwt q=m Twmat |=yp=v=m |=Q@ =yvD x]U=w Rm =Qt|awHQt |=yq=m Ci=} QO 'O}rwDR=@ Rm =Qt u=}t =yq=m `} RwD 'uOQm S=DvwtO '|Q=mR}tD|=yC}r=ai sy= O}rwDR=@ p@=k Q}e |=yq=m |NQ@ uOQm swOat 'u=} QDWt |wU R=w Cq}yUD |@=}u=mt |xr�Ut |rm |=tW 2 pmW QO "OyO|t p}mWD =Q =yu;

uDiQo Q_v QO =@ xm@W l} QO Cq}yUD |@=}u=mt |xr�Ut |rm |=tW "1 pmW"O}rwDR=@ Rm =Qt

uDiQo Q_v QO =@ xm@W l} QO Cq}yUD |@=}u=mt |xr�Ut |rm |=tW "2 pmW"Q=@v= w O}rwDR=@ Rm =Qt

93

"""QOQ=@v=

wO}rwDR=

@Cq}y

UD|@=}u=

mts:tXj

Xwj = 1 8w (1)Xw

Xiw = 1 8i (2)Xj

Xk

XRikj = 1 8i (3)Xw

capwXwj � (1��)(1� )Xi

Xs

Xk

p0sihriXRikj 8j(4)X

w

capwXwj � (1� �)(1� )Xi

Xs

Xk

p0sihriXRikj

� YjM 8j (5)Xs=1

(1� �)p0sihriXRikj � Y RjM 0 8i; j; k (6)

Xiw � Y Aw 8i; w (7)

XRikj � Y Ck 8i; j; k (8)

Yj ; Y Rj ; Y Ck; Y Aw = 0; 1 8j; k; w (9)

Xij ; Xiw;XRikj ; Xwj � 0 (10)

Q=Ri=sQv R= xO=iDU= =@ xm CU= xiOylD w |]N pOt l} xOW x�=Q= pOt=yQ}eDt |NQ@ h} QaD =@ pOt u}= QO "CU= xOW |U} wvOm GAMS24.1.2u}= &s}=xO}Wwm hOy `@=D Q=YDN= w uOQm xO=U |=Q@ 'c0rkj w cwi 'cjw Ovv=t

%OvwW|t h} QaD u}vJ =yQ}eDtcjw = ccjw + ccpj

cwi = cwiw + cpw

c0rkj =ccik+ctk(1��)+�ccd+crkj(1��)+cmj(1��)(1� )

+crd (1� �)� (1� �)(1� )cpj

uOQmxv}tm pOt hOy `@=D "Ov=xOW h} QaD nQR@ O=Oa= M w M 0 O=Oa= u}vJtyQ}eDt |=yxv} Ry w Cq}yUD O=H}= C@=F |=yxv} Ry pt=W �� sDU}U |=yxv} Ry pmO}rwDR=@ |=yOL=w R= xm |}=yq=m u=R}t R= Q=@v= |=yC}iQ_ pm &CU= �� Cq}yUD

%CU= xOW ZQi QDW}@ O};|t CUO x@Xw

capwXwj � (1� �)(1� )Xi

Xs

Xk

p0sihriXRikj

O}rwDR=@ Rm =Qt j} Q] R= u=wD|tv =Q u=} QDWt |=y=[=kD pm xm Ovm|t u=}@ ZQi u}=Q_v QO O}rwDR=@ |xv} Ry R= QDW}@ pwYLt OL=w O}rwD |xv} Ry u}vJty "OQm u}t-=Dj O}rwD Qy |=R=x@ xm OR=OQB|t ?r]t u}= u=}@ x@ 4 C}OwOLt "CU= xOW xDiQoCU= |DqwYLt R= QDW}@ OyO|t VWwB =Q =yQ=@v= |=[=kD xm |DqwYLt u=R}txm OR=OQB|t xDmv u}= x@ 5 C}OwOLt "OvwW|t =}L= Rm =Qt w O}rwDR=@ Rm =Qt \UwD xmO}rwD s}kDUt |q=m u=} QH QO |rwYLt I}y OW=@ xDW=Ov OwHw |}xOvvmO}rwD Qo =|=[=kD w =yQ=@v= C}iQ_ u=R}t xm OvQ=O|t u=}@ 3 =D 1 |=yC}OwOLt "OwW|tvRm =Qt w =yxOvvmO}rwD \UwD O}=@ =yxOvvmhQYt =} |QDWt |awHQt |=yq=m w =yq=mxm CU= ?r]t u}= Qou=}@ R}v 7 C}OwOLt "OwW u}t-=D pt=m Qw]x@ O}rwDR=@ w Q}taDO}=@ w Q=@v= R= xm s=i |QDWt |=[=kD C@Uv TB OW=@ xDW=Ov OwHw s=w Q=@v= Qo =

&s=w Q=@v= x@ s=j O}rwDR=@ RmQt =} xOvvmO}rwD R= pwYLt p=UQ= |xv} Ry %cjw&s=w Q=@v= x@ s=j O}rwDR=@ RmQt =} xOvvmO}rwD R= pkv w ptL |xv} Ry %ccjw

&s=j O}rwDR=@ RmQt =} xOvvmO}rwD \UwD q=m OL=w O}rwD |xv} Ry %ccpj&s=i |QDWt x@ s=w Q=@v= R= pwYLt p=UQ= |xv} Ry %cwi

&s=i |QDWt x@ s=w Q=@v= R= pwYLt OL=w pkv w ptL |xv} Ry %ccwi&s=w Q=@v= \UwD pwYLt |Q=Oxov |xv} Ry %cpw

&s |w} Q=vU CLD s=i |QDWt |=[=kD p=tDL= %psi&s |w} Q=vU CLD s=i |QDWt |awHQt |=yq=m Q=Okt p=tDL= %p0si

RmQt x@ s=k x]U=w RmQt \UwD s=i |QDWt |awHQt pwYLt p=UQ= |xv} Ry %c0rkj&s |w} Q=vU CLD s=j O}rwDR=@

&s=k x]U=w RmQt x@ s=i |QDWt R= |awHQt pwYLt p=UQ= |xv} Ry %ccik&s=k RmQt QO VR=OQB OL=w |xv} Ry %ctk&s=k x]U=w RmQt QO uOW MwUvt MQv %�

&s=k x]U=w RmQt QO uOW MwUvt |xv} Ry %ccd&s=j O}rwDR=@ RmQt x@ s=k RmQt R= xOW |UQR=@ pwYLt p=UQ= |xv} Ry %crkj

&s=j RmQt QO O}rwDR=@ |xv} Ry %cmj

&s=j O}rwDR=@ RmQt QO uOW MwUvt MQv % &s=j O}rwDR=@ RmQt QO uOW MwUvt |xv} Ry %crd

"s=j xOvvmO}rwD QO O}rwD |xv} Ry %cpj

|Q}os}tYD |=yQ}eDt "3"4&QiY CQwY u}= Q}e QO w 1 OQ}o@ Q=Qk s=j u=mt QO xOvvmO}rwD Qo = %Yj

&QiY CQwY u}= Q}e QO w 1 OQ}o@ Q=Qk s=j u=mt QO O}rwDR=@ RmQt Qo = %Y Rj&QiY CQwY u}= Q}e QO w 1 OQ}o@ Q=Qk s=k u=mt QO x]U=w RmQt Qo = %Y ck

&QiY CQwY u}= Q}e QO w 1 OQ}o@ Q=Qk s=w u=mt QO Q=@v= Qo = %Y Aw&OwW|t u}t-=D s=j O}rwDR=@ Rm =Qt =} xOvvmO}rwD \UwD xm s=w Q=@v= R= |tyU %Xwj

&OwW|t u}t-=D s=w Q=@v= \UwD xm s=i |QDWt |=[=kD R= |tyU %Xiwx@ s=k |x]U=w RmQt \UwD xm s=i |QDWt |awHQt |=yq=m R= |tyU %XRijk

&OwW|t p=UQ= s=j O}rwDR=@ RmQt"OvDUy nQR@ O=Oa= %M;M 0

uDiQo Q_v QO =@ =Q xr�Ut 'xOW h} QaD s}tYD |=yQ}eDt w =yQDt=Q=B x@ xHwD =@CQwYx@ Q=@v= w O}rwDR=@ 'x]U=w 'xOvvmO}rwD Rm =Qt w =yOL=w R= l} Qy |=Q@ C}iQ_

"s}vm|t |R=UpOt xJQ=Bl}

xr�Ut |[=} Q pOt "5min z =

Xj

fjYj +Xj

frjY Rj +Xk

fckY Ck+Xw

fawY Aw

+Xj

Xw

capwXwjcjw +Xw

Xi

Xs

cwipsihiXiw

+Xi

Xs

Xk

Xj

c0rkjp0sihriXRijk

94

2/1|

xQ=tW'

33�1

|xQwO'

�1396

u=DUtR�

h}QW

C}Q}Ot

w`}=vY

|UOvyt "s}kDUt u=} QH � xJQ=Bl} pOtQO xr�Ut pL R= pY=L xv}y@ G}=Dv "1 pwOH

Qy R= =[=kD <=[Q= syU=[=kD |QDWt=yxOvvmO}rwD R= l}

11 9 50 0 15 15 10 10 0 10 20 3 9 12 30 15 3 18 40 0 5 5 50 19 5 24 64 1 6 11 715 1 0 16 85 8 0 13 922 0 0 22 1019 0 0 19 1120 0 0 20 1285 57 43 185 pm200 60 50 C}iQ_

C=aq]= "CU= xOW |Qw;`tH Twmat l}DUHr QO u=} QDWt =} u=oOvvmhQYt =}"s}yO V}=tv �3 pmW� xm@W CQwYx@ s}v=wD|t =Q xr�Ut

|=yxv} Ry '=yp}]DUt R= l} Qy |q=@ QO xOW xO=O V}=tv O=Oa= 3 pmW QOR}v =yp}]DUt R= l} Qy uwQO O=Oa= "OvQ=O|t u=}@ =Q p}yUD wv Q=yJ C@=FQw]x@ xm OyO|t u=Wv =Q |awHQt CqwYLt u=R}t w CqwYLt |=[=kD K]Uw CU= 15 pwYLt |=[=kD 1 u=mt QO p=Ft |=Q@ "Ov=xDiQo Q=Okt |iO=YDl} Qy u=}t |xrY=i '\w]N |q=@ O=Oa= "CU= 20 |awHQt CqwYLt u=R}txwkr=@ |=yu=mt Qou=Wv |mWt |=yxQ}=O uwQO O=Oa= "OyO|t u=Wv =Q =yu=mt R=xHwD =@ =[=kD |=[Q= |=Q@ xOW xDiQo Q_v QO |xv} Ry "Ov=p}yUD wv 4 Q=QkDU= |=Q@0 08 Twmat u=} QH QO w 0 1 s}kDUt u=} QH QO =[=kD OL=w w Ci=Ut OL=w x@OL=w |xv} Ry '7 pwYLt O}rwDR=@ OL=w |xv} Ry '20 pwYLt OL=w |xv} Ry "CU=&CU= xOW xDiQo Q_v QO 2 x]U=w Rm =Qt QO VR=OQB |xv} Ry w '4 pwYLt |Q=Oxovu}vJty "CU= 0 2 R}v Twmat u=} QH QO Cq}yUD R=l} Qy |R=UswOat |xv} Ry

"CU= xOW Qw_vt � = 0 6; = 0 3RmQt wO w O@=} Q=QkDU= 11 u=mt QO xOvvmO}rwD l} Qo = xm OyO|t u=Wv G}=Dvw 6 |=yu=mtQO x]U=w RmQt wO u}vJty w OvwW QkDUt 9 w 5 |=yu=mtQO O}rwDR=@=[=kD w q=m u=} QH 1 pwOH 'OvwW QkDUt 3 w 1 |=yu=mt QO R}v Q=@v= RmQt wO w 7l}DUHr QO =Q u=oOvvm hQYt =} u=} QDWt w O}rwDR=@ Rm =Qt w xOvvmO}rwD Rm =Qt u=}t =Qu=Wv u=oOvvmhQYt =} u=} QDWt w Q}taD Rm =Qt u=}t =Q q=m u=} QH 2 pwOH w s}kDUt

"OyO|txm CU= =[=kD OL=w 85 pO=at s=11 xOvvmO}rwD \UwD pwYLt O}rwD u=R}t2007 p=U QO [22]wr nv=}m} S w pDUw@ |r=D=v \UwD xOW x�=Q= xH}Dv x@ C@UvRm =Qt QO xOW O}rwD sHL wtHt u}vJty "CU= xDi=} Vy=m OYQO 40 OwOL\UwD xOW x�=Q= |xH}Dv x@ C@Uv xm CU=[=kD OL=w 100 pO=at 9 w 5 O}rwDR=@xDW=O V}=Ri= OYQO 58 pO=at 2007 p=U QO [22]wr nv=}m} S w pDUw@ |r=D=v

s=i |QDWt |=[=kD C@Uv OW=@ xDW=O OwHw Q=@v= Qo = w OwW|t QiY OwW u}t-=DRmQt Qo = xm OQ=O|t u=}@ R}v 8 C}OwOLt "OwWv =} OwW u}t-=D s=w Q=@v= R= Ov=wD|tOwHw x]U=w RmQt Qo = w 'OQ=Ov OwHw O}rwDR=@ RmQt TB OW=@ xDW=Ov OwHw |}x]U=wRm =Qt u}= R= l} Qy \UwD O}=@ xm |awHQt CqwYLt C@Uv `tH OW=@ xDW=Ol} Qy Qo = xm OR=OQB|t xDmv u}= u=}@ x@ 6 C}OwOLt "Ow@ Oy=wN 1 Q@=Q@ OwW u}t-=DQiY |awHQt CqwYLt u}t-=D QO =yu; syU OvW=@ xDW=Ov OwHw O}rwDR=@ Rm =Qt R=R= |D@Uv CU= QO=k |va} CU= |i=[= C}OwOLt u}= CQwYu}= Q}e QO w CU=u; |=Q@ |}q=@ OL u=wD|tv xm |Qw]x@ 'Ovm u}t-=D =Q |awHQt CqwYLt |=[=kDw CU= xOQm |iQat 1 w QiY CQwYx@ =Q =yQ}eDt 9 |=yC}OOLt "CiQo Q_v QO

"Ovm|t u=}@ =Q =yQ}eDt uOw@ |ivt Q}e 10 C}OwOLt

|D=@U=Lt |=yV}=tR; "6'xOW x�=Q= K}LY OOa w 1 w QiY \rDNt |R} Qxt=vQ@ pOt OQmrta |@=} RQ= |[email protected] Q=Ri=sQv R= xO=iDU= =@ |irDNt |D=@U=Lt w |OOa |=yV}=tR;xt=O= QO xOW s=Hv= |D=@U=Lt |=yV}=tR; R= pY=L G}=Dv |x}rm "CU= xOW pL

"CU= xOW xOQw;

Q=@v= w O}rwDR=@ Rm =Qt ^=Lr =@ Cq}yUD |@=}u=mt pOt "7s} Q}o|t Q_v QO =Q |OOa |xr�Ut xOW x�=Q= |@=}u=mt pOt |}=Q=m uO=O u=Wv |=Q@xOvvmO}rwD Rm =Qt |@=}u=mt |xr�Ut =@ x]@=Q QO 1995 p=UQO [23]u}mDUO |=k; xm[22]wr nv=}m} S w pDUw@ |r=D=v =yOa@ &Ow@ xOQm KQ]t s}kDUt l}DUHr |xm@W QOTwmat w s}kDUt l}DUHr |xJQ=Bl} |xm@W QO =Q xr�Ut u}= 2007 p=U QOpL x@ w OvO=O xaUwD u=WpOt Twmat l}DUHr QO O}rwDR=@ Rm =Qt uDiQoQ_vQO =@Rm =Qt xm CU= xOW xDiQoQ_v QO u=} QDWt |=Q@ u=mt 12 xr�Ut u}= QO "OvDN=OQB u;=yv; QO Q=QkDU= |=Q@ xwkr=@ Qw]x@ u=wD|t =Q x]U=w Rm =Qt w O}rwDR=@ Rm =Qt 'xOvvmO}rwDu}= R= =t "O}vm|t xOy=Wt 3 pmW QO =Q xr�Ut u}= |rm |=tW "CiQo Q_v QORm =Qt 'xOvvmO}rwD Rm =Qt� Cq}yUD wv 4 Q=QkDU= w |@=}u=mt |=Q@ xwkr=@ u=mt 12xO=iDU= xOW x�=Q= |xm@W w pOt QO ZwQit �Q=@v= Rm =Qt w x]U=w Rm =Qt 'O}rwDR=@Rm =Qt C@=F |=yxv} Ry '|awHQt |=yq=m xR=Ov= p}@k R= sRq C=aq]= "s}vm|tu=} QDWt |wU R= |awHQt |=yq=m |=Q@ x]U=w Rm =Qt |=yxv} Ry w 'Q=@v= w O}rwDR=@

"xOW pL xvwtv xr=Ut xm@W "3 pmW

95

"""QOQ=@v=

wO}rwDR=

@Cq}y

UD|@=}u=

mtxm CU= |D=aw[wt R= |m} xJQ=Bl} w s-=wD CQwYx@ s}kDUt l}DUHr w TwmatC}ty= R= Ov=xDiQo Q=m x@ =Ql}DUHr |=ysDU}U xQ=wty xm |}=yu=tR=UC} Q}Ot QOQO C=ar=]t w C=k}kLD s=Hv= ' w[wt u}= C}ty= x@ xHwD=@ "CU= Q=OQwNQ@ |}q=@l}DUHr |=ysDU}U |R=Uxv}y@ w |R} Qxt=vQ@ |xv}tR QO xS} wx@ 'l}DUHr |xv}tRR�=L w sRq |Qt= xJQ=Bl} w s-=wD CQwYx@ s}kDUt w Twmat l}DUHr ^=Lr =@x@ xHwD =@ Twmat l}DUHr s}y=it R= |}xtOkt xar=]t u}= QO "CU= C}ty=xOW x�=Q= |@=}u=mt pOt "CU= xOW x�=Q= Q=@v= Rm =Qt w O}rwDR=@ Rm =Qt Q=QkDU= C}ty=u; QO xm CU= s}kDUt w Twmat l}DUHr R= xJQ=Bl} pOt l} xar=]t u}= QO"CU= xOW xDiQo Q_vQO u=tRty CQwYx@ Twmat w s}kDUt CQwYx@ q=m u=} QH|xm@W QO |L]UxU |@=}u=mt pOt l} xar=]t u}= QO xOW x�=Q= |[=} Q pOtw |@=}u=mt x@ u=tRty Qw]x@ xm CU= s}kDUt w Twmat l}DUHr |xJQ=Bl}�Q=@v= Rm =Qt w O}rwDR=@ Rm =Qt 'x]U=w Rm =Qt 'xOvvmO}rwD Rm =Qt� Cq}yUD wv Q=yJ Q=QkDU=|R} Qxt=vQ@ pOt l} xr�Ut u}= |R=UpOt |=Q@ "OR=OQB|t OwOLt C}iQ_ ^=Lr =@4 pt=W |O=yvW}B pOt "CU= xOW x�=Q= K}LY OOa w 1 w QiY \rDNt |[=} QTwmat l}DUHr |xJQ=Bl} |xm@W QO u=tRty Qw]x@ xm CU= Cq}yUD wvxOW x�=Q= pOt R= xO=iDU= =@ w O@=}|t Q=QkDU= OwOLt C}iQ_ ^=Lr =@ s}kDUt w

"OW Oy=wN sy=Qi Q=QkDU= Cr=L u} QDy@pDUw@ |r=D=v \UwD xOW x�=Q= pOt R= |OOa xr�Ut l} G}=Dv |xU}=kt =@xm CU= xOw@ |}xvwox@ O}rwD Rm =Qt Q=QkDU= xm xOW xO=O u=Wv [22]'wr nv=}m} S wxO=O u=Wv u}vJty &CU= xO=O Vy=m OYQO 40 =D =Q |O}rwD |=yxv} Ry u=R}t58 u=R}t x@ ?U=vt |=yu=mt QO Q=QkDU= =@ xr�Ut u}= QO O}rwDR=@ Rm =Qt xm xOW=@ "Ov=xO=O V}=Ri= QwmPt |xr=kt QO xOW x�=Q= G}=Dv x@ C@Uv =Q O}rwDR=@ OYQOw xOW x�=Q= pOt R= xOW G=QNDU= G}=Dv |xU}=kt w xrY=L |OOa G}=Dv x@ xHwDQO "CU= xv}y@ G}=Dv |=Q=O xar=]t u}= QO xOW x�=Q= pOt G}=Dv QwmPt |xr=kt pOtxOW RmQtDt O}rwDR=@ Rm =Qt Q@ Twmat |q=m u=} QH QO =[=kD |=[Q= 'xOW x�=Q= pOtCq}yUD Q=QkDU= uDiQo Q_v QO xm xOW xO=O u=Wv u}vJty xar=]t u}= QO "CU=Q=Qk Q}F-=D CLD =Q s}kDUt w Twmat l}DUHr |xm@W Q=DN=U 'u=tRty Qw]x@OQ=Po|t Q}F-=D xm@W |xv} Ry Q@ O}rwDR=@ 'O}rwD hrDNt |=yxv} Ry u}vJty "OyO|tpm |xv} Ry O}rwD |=yxv} Ry Vy=m p}rOx@ O}rwDR=@ OYQO V}=Ri= =@ xm |Qw]x@K}LY C=aq]= ?Um w ?U=vt |=ys}tYD P=ND= =@ u}=Q@=v@ "O@=}|t Vy=m xm@W=D =Q |awHQt |=yq=m u=wD|t �O}rwDR=@ Rm =Qt� |@=} R=@ Cq}yUD ?=NDv= OQwtQO?=vDH= =Hx@=v O}rwD w |R=UswOat |=yxv} Ry R= w xOQm O}rwDR=@ w Q}taD u=mt= OL

"OQm

"Twmat u=} QH � xJQ=Bl} pOt QO xr�Ut pL R= pY=L |xv}y@ G}=Dv "2 pwOH|=yq=m <=[Q= syU

|=yq=m sHL |QDWtQy \UwD |awHQt|awHQtQ=@v= Rm =Qt R= l}

9 50 20 20 10 5 5 240 0 40 310 0 10 40 2 2 515 0 15 60 5 5 70 8 8 84 3 7 92 15 17 100 10 10 115 3 8 1276 71 147 pm100 50 C}iQ_

OL=w 57 w sHvB O}rwDR=@ RmQt x@ \w@ Qt u; OL=w 43 OL=w 100 u}= R= "CU=pOt s-=wD uDiQo Q_vQO =@ xm OwW|t xOy=Wt "CU= syv O}rwDR=@ RmQt x@ \w@ Qt u;w xm@W Q=DN=U w KQ] 'Q=@v= Rm =Qt Q=QkDU= Cr=L QO s}kDUt w Twmat l}DUHr|=[=kD s}kDUt l}DUHr QO |@=}u=mt pOt QO "OyO|t Q=Qk Q}F-=D CLD =Q pOtw[wt u}= =t= 'OwW xO=O MU=B XNWt p}yUD l} \UwD O}=@ u=} QDWt R= l} Qy

xOvvmO}rwD Cq}yUD u=mt u}= Q@ xwqa "CU}v Q=QkQ@ xW}ty Twmat l}DUHr QO2 w 1 pw=OH x@ xHwD "CUq=m Twmat w s}kDUt u=} QH u=}t|tm |x]@=Q x@ xDU@=w

"OR=U|t uWwQ QDW}@ =Q w[wt u}=

|Q}oxH}Dv "8OQwt QDW}@ 'Q}N= p=U OvJ QO CqwYLt Ci=} R=@ Ovv=t Twmat l}DUHr s}y=itl}DUHr uDiQo Q_vQO "CU= xOW xDiQo Q=m x@ Q=}U@ R}v pta QO w xOw@ xHwD

=yCWwv=B1. Re-manufacturing network2. close-loop network

�References� `@=vt1. El-Sayed, M., A�a, N. and El-Kharbotly, A. \A stochas-

tic model for forward{reverse logistics network designunder risk", Computers & Industrial Engineering, 58(3),pp. 423-431 (2010).

2. Fleischmann, M., Beullens, P., Bloemhof-Ruwaard, J.M.and Van Wassenhove, L.N. \The impact of product re-

96

2/1|

xQ=tW'

33�1

|xQwO'

�1396

u=DUtR�

h}QW

C}Q}Ot

w`}=vY

|UOvyt covery on logistics network design", Production and Op-

erations Management, 10(2), pp. 156-173 (2001).

3. Diabat, A., Abdallah, T., Al-Refaie, A., Svetinovic, D.and Govindan, K. \Strategic closed-loop facility loca-tion problem with carbon market trading", EngineeringManagement, IEEE Transactions on, 60(2), pp. 398-408(2013).

4. Louwers, D., Kip, B.J., Peters, E., Souren, F. and Flap-per, S.D.P. \A facility location allocation model forreusing carpet materials", Computers and Industrial En-gineering, 36(4), pp. 855-869 (1999).

5. Beaulieu, M., Martin, R. and Landry, S. \Logistique �arebours: Un portrait nord-am�ericain", Logistique & Man-agement, 7(2), pp. 5-14 (1999).

6. Sharma, R.R.K. and Berry, V. \Developing new for-mulations and relaxations of single stage capacitatedwarehouse location problem (SSCWLP): Empirical in-vestigation for assessing relative strengths and computa-tional e�ort", European Journal of Operational Research,177(2), pp. 823-812 (2007).

7. Teo, C.P. and Shu, J. \Warehouse-retailer network de-sign problem", Operations Research, 52(3), pp. 396-408(2004).

8. Fontana, M.E. and Cavalcante, C.A.V. \Use ofpromethee method to determine the best alternative forwarehouse storage location assignment", InternationalJournal of Advanced Manufacturing Technology, 70, pp.1615-1624 (2014).

9. Askin, R.G., Ba�o, I. and Xia, M. \Multi-commoditywarehouse location and distribution planning with in-ventory consideration", International Journal of Produc-tion Research, 52, pp. 1897-1910 (2013).

10. Afsharzadeh M., MokhatabRa�ei, F. and Zare., Z. \Theapplication of fuzzy analytic hierarchy process approachfor the selection of warehouse location: A case study",International Journal of Business and Social Science,3(4), pp.112-125 (2012).

11. Afsharzadeh, M., Mokhatab Ra�ei, F., Mollaverdi Isfa-hani, N., Zare, Z. \Application of fuzzy TOPSIS methodfor the selection of warehouse location: A case study",Interdisciplinary Journal of Contemporary Research inBusiness, 3(9), pp. 655-671 (2012).

12. Rath, S. and Gutjahr, W.J. \A math-heuristic for thewarehouse location{routing problem in disaster relief",Computers & Operations Research, 42, pp. 25-39 (2014).

13. Dai, L.F. and Wang, X.F. \Research on mixed intelli-gent arithmetic of reuse reverse logistics centers' loca-tion model", Advanced Materials Research, 945-949, pp.3246-3251 (2014).

14. Sheri�, K.M.M., Subramanian, N. and Min, H. \Com-bined location and routing problems for designing thequality-dependent and multi-product reverse logisticsnetwork", Journal of the Operational Research Society,65, pp. 873-887 (2014).

15. Ramezani, M., Bashiri, M. and Tavakkoli-Moghaddam,R. \A new multi-objective stochastic model for a for-ward/reverse logistic network design with responsive-ness and quality level", Applied Mathematical Modelling,37(1-2), pp. 328-344 (2013).

16. Hassanzadeh Amin, S. and Zhang, G. \A multi-objectivefacility location model for closed-loop supply chain net-work under uncertain demand and return", AppliedMathematical Modelling, 37(6), pp. 4165-4176 (2013).

17. Lin, C.K.Y. \Stochastic single-source capacitated facilitylocation model with service level requirements", Int. J.Production Economics, 117, pp. 439-451 (2009).

18. Sun, M. \A tabu search heuristic procedure for the ca-pacitated facility location problem", J Heuristics, 18,pp. 91-118 (2012).

19. Fernandes, D., Rocha, C., Aloise, D., Ribeiro, G.M., San-tos, E. and Silva, A. \A simple and e�ective genetic al-gorithm for the two-stage capacitated facility locationproblem", Computers & Industrial Engineering, 75, pp.222-228 (2014).

20. Melkote, S. and Daskin, M.S. \Capacitated facility lo-cation/network design problems", European Journal ofOperational Research, 129, pp. 481-495 (2001).

21. Ho, S.C. \An iterated tabu search heuristic for the sin-gle source capacitated facility location problem", AppliedSoft Computing, 27, pp. 169-178 (2014).

22. Lu, Z., Bostel, N. and Dejax, P. \Plani�cationhi�erarchis�ee des syst�emes logistiques incluant la logis-tique inverse: Probl�ematique et mod�eles strat�egiques",Actes du 4e Congr�es International Sde G�enie Industriel(GI2001), Aix-en-Provence-Marseille, France, pp. 1141-1151 (2001).

23. Daskin, M.S., Network and Discrete Location, Models,Algorithms, and Application, Wiley: Wiley-IntersciencePublication (1995).

97

ysDU}U QO Q=@v= w O}rwDR @ Cq}yUD...

Documents

Transcript of ysDU}U QO Q=@v= w O}rwDR @ Cq}yUD...