D7

E-235 VOL. 27

EGAT - INVESTMENT PROGRAM SUPPORT PROJECT

Resettlement Action Plan for

(1) Krabl Thermal Plant Unit 1

(2) Ratchaburl Thernal Plant Unit 1 & 2

(3) Ratchaburl Combined Cycle Block 1 -3

(4) Wang Nol Combined Cycle Stage 2

(5) EGAT-TNB Stage 2 Interconnection

(6) Transmisson Expansion Project No.9

(7) 500 kV for Hong Sa Power Plant Stage 1-2

June 1998

LAND DIVISION

ELECTRICITY GENERATING AUTHORITY OF THAILAND

Pub

lic D

iscl

osur

e A

utho

rized

Pub

lic D

iscl

osur

e A

utho

rized

Pub

lic D

iscl

osur

e A

utho

rized

Pub

lic D

iscl

osur

e A

utho

rized

EGAT - INVESTMENT PROGRAM SUPPORT PROJECT

Resettlement Action Plan for

(1) Krabl Thennal Plant Unit 1

(2) Ratchaburl Thermal Plant Unit 1 & 2

(3) Ratchaburl Combined Cycle Block 1 -3

(4) Wang Nol Combined Cycle Stage 2

(5) EGAT-TNB Stage 2 Interconnection

(6) Transmisslon Expanslon Project No.9

(7) 500 kV for Hong Sa Power Plant Stage 1-2

June 1998

LAND DIVISION

ELECTRICITY GENERATING AUTHORITY OF THAILAND

ACRONYMS

CC Compensation Committee

CSC Compensation Sub-Committee

DIS Detailed Infbrmation Survey

DIST Detailed Information Survey Team

EGAT Electricity Generating Authority of Thailand

ISC Inspection Sub-Committee

LD Land Division (EGAT)

OEPP Office of Environmental Policy and Planning

PAF Project Affected Family

PAH Project Affected Househoid

PMT Project Management Team

RAP Resettlement Action Plan

RTG Royal Thai Govemment

T/L Transmission Line

WB World Bank

TABLE OF CONTENTS

Chapter 1 Introduction 1

Chapter 2 Scope of Work 2

Chapter 3 The Power Plant and Substatlons 7

Chapter 4 Resettlement Poilcy 8

Chapter 5 Institutlonal Framework 16

Chapter 6 Popular Participation 20

Chapter 7 Complaints and Grievances 21

Chapter 8 Supervision and Monitoring 22

Chapter 9 Implementation Arrangements 24

Chapter 10 Costs and Budgets 30

Appendices 3 1

MEASURES

RAI 0.395 acre

1

RESEfLIEMENT ACTION PLAN

CHAPTER 1 INTRODUCTION

According to EGAT's plan (PDP 97-02 Very Low Load-Case 1). EGAT will

require foreign loan that comes from foreign commercial banks or issuing bonds abroad

in 1 998 and 1 999 at the amount of 700 million USD to finance the projects as follow:

1. Krabi Thermal Plant Unit 1

2. Ratchaburi Thermal Plant Unit 1 & 2

3. Ratchaburi Combined Cycle Block 1 -3

4. Wang Noi Combined Cycle Stage 2

5. EGAT-TNB Stage II Interconnection

6. Power Supply for Greater Bangkok Area Stage 1

7. Transmission System Expansion Project No.9

8. 500 kW Transmission System for Purchased Power Stage 1

9. 500 kV Hong Sa Power Plant Stage 1-2

From the projects above, EGAT had submitted the Resettlement Action Plan

(RAP) for Power Supply for Greater Bangkok Area stage 1 and 500 kV Transmission

System for Purchased Power Stage 1 to the World Bank. EGAT have to summit the

information of all the projects left.

Since the land acquisition for substations and transmission lines is dlfferent

In methodology, we have to separately explain the activities regarding substations in

chapter 3 and T/L in chapter 4 - 10.

1

2

CHAPTER 2 SCOPE OF WORK

The projects' scope of work is as follow

2.1 Krabi Thermal Plant Unit 1

Krabi Thennal Plant unit 1 will be constructed in the old Krabi Thermal Plant

land but there are some activities that are:

1. Constructing a plant in the old Krabi Plant area.

2. Upgrading the Krabi-Pang Nga llne from 1 1 5 kV to 230 kV line.

3. Constructing new 230 kV line from Krabi to Thung Song in Nakhon Si

Thammarat.

2.2 Ratchaburl Thermal Plant Unit 1 & 2

Ratchaburi Thermal Plant Unit 1 & 2 Is constructed in the land that was

acquired since 1995. The activities to facilitate the plant are.

1. Constructing new 500 kV Jom Bung -(Sal Noi)-Wang No! line.

2. Upgrading Ratchaburi-Ban Pong 2 and Ban Pong 2-Sai Noi lines from

115 kV to 230 kV.

2.3 Ratchaburt Combined Cycle Block 1-3

This project uses the land that was acquired together with the land used for

the Ratchaburi Thermal Plant. The activitles to do are:

1. Constructing 2 new 500 kV lines named Ratchaburl Plant-Jom Bung and

Jom Bung-Sai Nol.

2. Constructing 2 new 230 kV lines named Ratchaburi Plant-Ratchabur 2

and Ratchaburi Plant-Samut Sakom 4.

3. Upgrading Ratchaburl 2 substation.

4. Constructing 2 new substations named Samut Sakom 4 and Jom Bung.

2.4 Wang Nol Combined Cycle Stag. 2

This project needs no new facilities according to the land acquisition activity.

2

3

2.5 EGAT-TNB Stage 2 Interconnection.

This project consists of

1. Constructing a new substation at Kiong Ngae.

2. Constructing a new 250 kV direct current line from Kiong Ngae to

Thailand-Malaysia Border.

3. Constructing 2 230 kV lines called Kiong Ngae-Had Yal 2 and Klong

Ngae-Thung Song.

2.6 Power Supply for Greater Bangkok Area Stage 1

This project is now under construction in the land that was already acquired.

(The information was submitted to the Bank together with the RAP for the IPPs)

2.7 Transmission System Expansion Project No.9

This project consists of many activities around Thailand. The activities can

be grouped as:

1. Constructing 14 new lines,upgrading 8 lines,connecting 2 lines to 2

substations and stringing 2 lines to the old towers .

2. Constructing 1 0 new substations and upgrading 30 substations.

2.8 500 kV Transmission System for Purchased Power Stage 1

The full Resettlement Action Plan of this project was submitted to the Bank

for approval before.

2.9 500 kV for Hong Sa Power Plant Stage 1-2

According to this project, EGAT will construct a new 500 kV line called Border

(Nan Province) - Mae Moh 3 (Lampang Province).

The detailed information of all the work above is shown in- appendix 3 and

can be classified as follow

3

4

Table 2.1 Scope of Work

Project Power Statlon and Substations T/L

1. Krabi Thermal Plant Unit 1 Constructing a plant In the old Krabi Plant 1. Upgrading the Krabi-Pang Nga line from 11 5 kV to

area. 230 kV line.

2. Constructing new 230 kV line from Krabi to Thung Song

In Nakhon Si Thammarat.

2. Ratchaburi Thermal Plant Unit 1 & 2 1. Constructing new 500 kV Jom Bung-(Sai Noi)-Wang

Nol line.

2. Upgrading Ratchaburi-Ban Pong 2 and Ban Pong 2-

Sai Noi lines from 11 5 kV to 230 kV.

3. Ratchaburl Combined Cycle Block 1 -3 1. Upgrading Ratchaburi 2 substation 1. Constructing 2 new 500 kV lines named Ratchaburi

2. Constructing 2 new substations named Plant-Jom Bung and Jom Bung-Sai Noi.

Samut Sakorn 4 and Jom Bung. 2. Constructing 2 new 230 kV lines named Ratchaburi

Plant-Ratchaburi 2 and Rabthaburi Plant-Samut

Sakorn 4

4. Wang Nol Combined Cycle Stage 2

5. EGAT-TNB Stage 2 Interconnection 1. Constructing new 250 kV direct current line from

Klong Ngae to Thailand-Malaysia Border.

2. Constructing 2 230 kV lines called Klong Ngae-Had Yai 2

and Klong Ngae-Thung Song.

Project Power Station and Substation T/L

6. Power Supply lor Greater Bangkok

Area Stage 1

7. Transmission lExpansion Constructing 10 new substation and upgrading 30 Constructing 1 8 new lines, upgrading 6 lines and connecting 2

ProJect No.9 substations. lines to 2 substations.

8. 500 kV Transrnission System for

Purchased Power Stage 1

9. 500 kV for Hong Sa Power Plant Constructing a new line.

Stage 1 -2 _ l

5

6

Statuis of the roJlcts

According to compensation payment, the projects' status will be as

follow:

- Krabi Thermal Plant Unit 1 0% completed

- Ratchaburi Themal Plant Unit 1 & 2 62% completed

- Ratchaburi Combined Cycle Block 1-3 completed

- Wang Noi Combined Cycle Stage 2

- EGAT-TNB Stage II Interconnection completed

- Power Supply for GBA Stage 1 completed

- Transmission System Expansion

Project No. 9 59% completed

- 500 kV Transmission System for

Purchased Power Stage 1 24% completed

- Hong Sa Power Plant Stage 1 -2 0%/o completed

None of the PAFs compensated have asked for replacement iand.

6

7

C'HAPTE 3 THE POWER P! ANT AND SUBSTATIONS

As mentioned in Table 2.1 in chapter 2, the activities regarding land

acquisition for power plant and substations are

1. Constructing a new plant in the old Krabi Plant area. No need for

new land acquisition.

2. Upgrading 31 substations in the existing area.

3. Constructing 1 3 new substations named.

Samut Sakom 4

- Jom Bung

- Klong Ngae

- Yala

- Phuket

- Nakom Chai Sri

- Thung Song

- Mukdahan

- Sangkha

- Mae Taeng

- That Phanom

- Phang Nga

- Lang Suan

In accordance with EGAT policy, the land used for constructing the

substations and power plants was purchased through an open market transaction and no

tenants occupying or using the land were forcibly removed or resettled.

Of all the 1 3 substations, only Lang Suan substation needs land acquisition

that set to be done in the year 2000 because the others' land was purchased between

the year 1 993 and 1 997. Land for Lang Suan substation will also be purchase through

an open market transaction.

7

g

AIL+E 4 RE TLRr T PO IC'V: R- 1- Princinies, Eig-lbillty

and Entitlements

4.1 RESETTLEMENT POLICY AND PRINCIPLES

The basic principles regulating resettlement and compensation programs (see box

1, below) have been defined taking into account the IBRD O.D. 4.30 and in accordance

with Thailand Law.

RAP: RESETTEMENT CRITERIA.' , ' -

..!...,....,1,,....~~~~~ ~ ~~~~~~~ ,.. ... M ..... .I.... :- . . ' .................... ~~~~~........ .. - '. . . .......... ... -:. :"'4:. !..1. Both resetUement and land acquisition must ~~~~~~~~be minimized as. much as possible,

.:.. :''_'', . _., . ....... :.;. .'. ..- ' _, - :.:,''':""':': '.."'... ". -' '' : '... ''.......' "

~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~.. .... .... ;':

. i. . i... .tandards.

*,'. All !-,'.,,,,, re.id'ng.- cultivating 'a.n n jc bou'da e b e e . . . .. .. .t

, l- tei fsss,hi poisonst ,dbohfrPF with .an, with,ut and title.-- ---.- :

4. CoPensatIonb sould b proih&t te idF n ateratan3dysrortth

start-up date of c:-sti -:tion. ::n ::, -o :: th o e n will be paid at , ;

."' !......,, . . ,

..~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~. ..... .. .ms.. .

least::::::-::1 t90 .d. : ior to tha- construci st,,,' ar-up date.. :::: -:: ..::::-:: -: -:: : :.

. ... ;' , - ; ~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~.. . .... ...omAIPensat'iond orm utpoieaeut institutionalfaranemfentsto

..... warrantffectiveand timelImplementationof resettlementcompensation

programs,t...,-x.,,' to insu.s aprprit coplaint an grievncs procedures - -

....... ... . . . ' .-.' '..

6. -Q ;i.nanci,al,-and:tecnical:.r,e,s,ou;es for, omeaton should :be .available when and --:::

, e ! r i . r - . t .......................................................................... . . . - ; . = ; - - ! ! i.;~~~... . ..... .. .. .. ..

! :_~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~. '.,,";!.:'..... .. ..... . 'j ...'

- I l - . ; i ... . ... . ... . .. . z ' '''' ' .' " :, ..................... ' ,' ',,', .'': '' ' .'s ';~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~......

7.t- Copnsto prgrm shoul ma'intain e. i'f: possible, improve'P pr-po,Ject:i''::!

.. .j...t. . .'''.. ........... . . :' :. .. ,; --. .:-,

:- levels af communi.- se:v.cesia d eso- 's.-

..... .._....

th~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~

9

4.2 ELIGIBILITY TO COMPENSATION AND INCOME RESTORATION

Deflnitlon of Project Affected Families (PAFs)

The PAFs include any families, with or without legal property title, who at the time

electric line laying zone announcements are made will result as permanently or

temporarily affected by the project as listed below:

(a) Families whose homes and other fixed structures are partially or totally

affected by construction of the power transmission lines;

(b) Families whose residential and/or agricultural land is partially or totally

affected by the construction of T/L, substations or any other component

of the subprojects;

(c) Families whose agricultural land is located within the clearance ROW of

the T/L;

(d) Families or parties whose homes, and commercial / industrial buildings

are affected by T/L construction or clearance ROW;

(e) Families affected by losses of crops, trees and other products.

4.3 UMITATIONS TO EUGIBIUTY

Households that occupy land or build houses and structures in project affected

areas after the electric line laying zone announcement date will not be considered as

legitimate PAHs and therefore will not be compensated for their losses. These

households will have to vacate the occupied plots when required, however no fine or

sanction will be imposed on them. The ELZA date Is announced in the district offices and

village offices in the project area.

Compensation for house/structure shall be calculated on the basis of the state

of the affected items as they were at the time the announcement was made.

4.4 ENTITLEMENT POUCY

All legitimate PAHs with or without title who have been listed In the inventory are

entitled to compensation for their losses of house/structure, land, and crops. In case of

lack of land use certificate, those households are still compensated for the losses.

9

10

4.4.1 Compensation for PAHs Affected by Agricultural Land Losses

For those losing less than 25% of their agricultural land, cash compensation at

the market value of the affected land will be given. For those losing more than 25% of

their land holdings due to construction of T/L tower, an option of replacement land

equivalent to the area covered by the base of the T/L tower will be offered. However, the

PAHs can also choose cash compensation based on their preferences.

Households affected by temporary agricultural land losses due to construction

works will receive cash compensation at market prices for the crops lost and will be

allowed by EGAT to resume cultivation activities (excluding trees higher than allowed) on

the old plots after the conclusion of construction activities.

4.4.2 Compensation Options for PANs Losing Agricultural Produce

Cash compensation at market price for agricultural products and trees shall be

calculated based on the existing growing and quality of trees and agricultural products.

Affected agricultural products and trees shall be divided into various categories:

a) Category 1 (paddy and annual crops)

Compensation shall be based on the harvests lost.

b) Category 2 (green and wooden trees)

The compensation rate shall be based on the types and ages of

trees.

c) Category 3 (fruit and other commercial trees)

The compensation rate shall be based on the types and ages of

trees.

4.4.3 CompensatIon Options for PAH Affected by House/structure Loss and

Resettlement

Affected houses and structures will be compensated in cash at substitution

rates, free of demolition expenses and salvage materials. Compensation shall be

calculated on the basis of the type and quality of the house or house portion lost, and

will be equivalent to the replacement cost of the affected asset.

Houses and structures affected for more than 25% of their entire area will totally

be compensated.

10

11

Houses and structures affected for less than 25% of their entire area will be

compensated in cash for the affected section of the house plus eventual structural

damages to the part of the house/structure left standing. Compensation shall

correspond to the type and quality of the partiy demolished building.

If the demolition of the part of the house/structure affected by the project should

cause damages to the point that repair is impossible, the house shall totally be

compensated as the houses losing more than 25%.

4.4.4 Compensation for ResIdentIal/premises Land Losses

Residential/premises land losses will be compensated along the same line as

the losses for agricultural land (see section 4.4.1).

4.5 COMPENSATION POUCY

Compensation for land and fixed buildings and assets will conform to EGAT

criteria for acquisition in transmission line project and taking into account the IBRD O.D.

4.30 requirements.

4.5.1 Land Compensation

PAFs whose holdings are affected will be compensated in cash at the market

value of affected land, to be established by the compensation committees. The rates

represent a variable scale reflecting the amount of disturbance to land use caused by

different components and aspects of the transmission system (see section 4.2, above).

According to EGAT regulations in fact compensation rates for transmission lines ROW are:

100 % of valuation paid for land used for siting a transmission tower

90 % of valuation paid for residential land

70 *,4 of valuatlon paird fnr nerennial crop and tree areas

50 X. of valuation paid for annual crop or the other areas

11

12

The rate of land compensation is based on unit prices established in reference

to the rate of the assessment values estimated for fees to register ownership and

juristic act and adjusted to meet current market prices at the time the electric line laying

zone announcement is made.

It should be noted, however, that the PAH can continue to cultivate the land in

the ROW after construction of the T/L.

4.5.2 Houses and Building Compensation

Compensation for housing and other buildings and structures will be based on

the Expropriation of Immovable Property Act (1 987) which value the property on the

basis of:

* Dismantling and damage costs associated with removal

* Transportation costs for removal to the new area

* Cost of reconstruction of the house, buliding or structure iost

Every PAF belonging to the eligibility categories and losing a home or any other

building shall be entitled to full compensation at substitution rates corresponding to the

type of home or building lost. According to baseline information the TGRP will affect 3 types

of houses. The compensation value of buildings combining the features of different

building types will be adjusted during the compensation negotiations to fit the actual

substitution cost The types of building affected by the TGRP are:

a) TYPE 1 High Quality buildings of one or more storeys, combining cement

foundation, reinforced cement structure, high quality wood or brick walls, and high quality

corrugated metal or tiled roofs.

b) TYPE 2 Medium quality buildings with no reinforced cement structure.

These buildings have a cement base, wood or brick walls, corrugated metal roofs with or

without Insulating ceiling.

b) TYPE 3 Low quality buildings without reinforced cement structure and

cement base, low quality wood or leaves walls, thatched or simple corrugated metal roofs

with no insulating ceiling.

12

13

4.5.3 Crop Losses Compensaton and Rehabilitation

PAFs affected by crop losses shall be entitled to cash compensation corresponding

to the full mar,iet value of harest5 affe.ted bhv pnrnipct in case of loss of fruit or industrial

trees these will be compensated in cash at full replacement costs.

4.6 ALLOWANCES AND BENEFITS

Included in the compensation for the houses lost, the PAFs will be entitled to the

following allowances in cash as they apply to individual situations according to eligibility

categories defined above:

I) A 'Resettlement Allowance' to cover secondary resettlement

expenses (operation costs) corresponding to the 10% of the value

of lost buildings.

ii) A 'Demolition Allowance' corresponding to the 30% of the value of

lost buildings.

iII) A 'Transportation Allowance' corresponding to the 5% of the value

of lost buildings.

4.6.1 Secondary Beneflts

This RAP also provides the following:

a) That the PAFs affected by home or other building loss will have the right to

keep any material salvaged after the demolition of the old house. Such a

dght should not entail any cost or any detraction from the compensation

received for the new house construction. However, such a right is annulled

when the demolition of the old house is not carried out within the limits

defined by the established resettlement schedule.

13

14

(b) That in case the PAFs residential land or house is only partially affected

by the project and the remaining part of the structure remains habitable

they will have the option to choose between partial or total

compensation.

c) That PAFs will also be provided with full replacement costs for any other

fixed asset affected by the project. These would include animal barns, wells,

grain storages, fishponds, ancestral or family tombs and any other kind of

building or fixed asset. Entitlements for the above buildings and assets are

the same as those defined for the houses.

4.7 EGAT POLICY ON POST-PROJECT LAND USE

According to EGAT regulations the PAFs' post-project rghts on land use will vary

according to the degree of impact of the different components of a project.

Land used as premises land for substations and other fixed structures will be

definitely bought from the owners directly.

Land used as bases for T/L towers (22 X 22 m squares including 14 m of T/L

tower base plus 4 m. of clearance are on each side of the towers) will remain property

of the PAFs but will have to be permanently cleared of any crop and tree. Although these

areas will remain property of the PAFs these latter will lose all cultivation rights on them.

Also in this case these areas will be compensated in full to their original owners or

users.

Land Included in the right of way of T/L (a 40 m. wide corridor for 230 kV T/L

and a 60 m. wide corridor for 500 kV T/L) instead, will be given back to their previous

owners before construction. After construction the PAFs will retain annual crops

cultivation rights on these lands. However, the right to cultivate perennial crops and trees

will be subjected to a number of limitations. For 230 kV T/L these are:

a) All trees within a 6 m. wide corridor (3 plus 3 m. on both sides from the

center of the corridor) will have to be permanently cut.

b) All trees growing between the above corridor and a distance of 20 m.

from the center of the T/L should not exceed 3 m. in height.

14

15

Since the original owners or users of these plots will retain a large degree of

cultivation rights on their land compensation will be given in proportion to the degree of

right losses.

Finally, EGAT regulations require the dis,,,antlement of a!! houses hbuildings and

other fixed constructions laying within the right of way of T/L. Although the PAFs will

retain rights over their old residential plots. These plots will lose their residential status.

15

16

CHAPTER 5 INSTITUTIONAL FRAMEWORK

5.1 INSTITUTIONAL FRAMEWORK

5.1.1 EGAT's Role

EGAT, the projects owner, has overall responsibility for every aspect of the TGRP

including planning, implementing and financing resettlement programs according to the

provisions specified in this RAP. EGAT will also be responsible for coordinating the

necessary action with appropriate local govemment agencies and with the PAFs'

representatives.

EGAT will exercise its functions through two of its subsidiary agencies; namely

the Land Division and the Transmission Construction Division. Though most of the

activities will be carried nut in c-ino coorna.tin w,ith the P5an-` the iouai authorities

at various levels, the officials of EGAT and its two subsidiaries will have responsibility to

ensure that implementation will comply with the provisions of this RAP.

In addition, EGAT will be responsible for coordinating the disbursement of funds

and for assuring the proper implementation of resettlement and compensation

procedures, the proper functioning of complaints and grievances mechanisms and proper

monitoring tasks.

5.1.2 The Compensation Committees' (CCs) Role

The execution of resettlement tasks on the ground will be supervised by

Compensation Committee(CC) of each province affected by the projects. CCs include

members from regional and provincial level govemment agencies. The CCs are chaired by

the Provincial Govemor or his representative who usually be Vice-Provincial Govemor of

each province, and will include senior officers from local govemment interest and from

EGAT. (See more detail in appendix 1 and 2)

The CCs will discuss the matters conceming compensation rate for land,

structure, trees and crops.

The land compensation rate will start with unit prices established in reference to

the rate of the assessment values estimates for fees to register ownership and juristic

act and adjust to meet current market price.

16

17

The compensation for any houses, buildings or structures will base on the price

of material and labor cost component and add the resettlement allowance, demolition

allowance and transportation allowance to make sure that the compensation set will be

reasonabiy accepted.

The compensation for trees and crops will base on the existing growing and

quality of trees and agricultural products (see more detail in section 4.4.2).

CCs will have their sub-units at District level (DCC) which will organize and

supervise the execution of RAP action at the lower administrative levels.

Under the Compensation Committee, a number of task forces (TF) and sub-

committees (SC) will be formed to respectively carry out and supervise specific aspects

of the resettlement and compensation program. Composition of these TFs and SCs will

reflect the assigned tasks and will include both EGAT staffs and provincial government

and land related regional officers, community representatives.

The activities carried out by these ground level units will also involve by village

heads who are the truly representatives of the people's interests. Moreover, each of the

affected person signs the survey record if he is satisfied with the details of his property

recorded on the survey form. Land and property can only be acquired if the affected

person signs the compensation form. In Thailand, especially for EGAT, there is time

respected tradition of consultations with and participation of the people in all matters

which affect them. Most of the activities mentioned in the RAP were and will be carried

out with the involvement of the village heads, which are truly representatives of the

people's interest.

5.1.3 Task Forces Roles

The first task force organized in close collaboration by LD were the Survey

Teams (ST) composed by EGAT staffs and advised by village heads. The activity

assigned to the STs was to gather the information necessary for the inventory of affected

persons and properties presented in chapter 4. The survey record, prepared by EGAT

surveyors, was inspected and approved by the ad hoc sub-committees and was finalized

in the presence of the affected person, village head or his representative.

vther irS and SCs tIhat th ! be fonrmed in the future will be:

i. Detailed Inventory Survey Teams (DIST) which will be carrying out

the definitive base-line information gathering, including the DIS

and the socio-economic census.

17

1I

ii. Inspection Teams and Inspection SCs. (IT and ISC). The goal of

these will be to carry out and supervise the final negotiations

between EGAT and PAFs that will be allowed to fix the final

compensation to be given to each PAF. These units will be also

responsible for assistance in post-compensation tasks such as

monitoring and complaints and grievances issues.

iii. Compensation Teams and Compensation SCs (CT and CSC). The

goal of these will be to carry out and supervise actual

compensation and implementation processes.

5.2 LEGAL FRAMEWORK

The principles, modes of compensation, regulations and implementation schemes

outlined in this RAP were defined and prepared in accordance with Thailand law (Land Code

of 1954; the ExproDriation of Immovable Prmnertv Act of 1 8R7 and the 19D6

Announcements of Prices for Land Evaluation of The project affected provinces). The

overall objective of this RAP is also guided by Govemment policy (Cabinet resolution of

10/1 0/1 963) and is regulated by Section 30 of the EGAT Act.

According to the EGAT Act , EGAT has the power of compulsory acquisition of

land and properties and/or of sanctioning activities in the following cases:

* when land is needed to place or set up posts for transmission or

distribution lines;

* when land is needed to place or set up substations or other

accessories;

* when land which is declared as electric line laying zone is needed;

* when crops, trees, houses and any other fixed asset stands on the

right of way of a transmission line. (see EGAT Act Section 29(3))

Simultaneously, however, the EGAT Act (Section 30) requires fair compensation

for land, housing, structures, crops, and trees affected by T/L and other construction.

Section 30 of EGAT Act provides that EGAT shall pay fair compensation to the owner/

possessor or holder of any other right of property needed as specified above. Fair

compensation Is deemed to be equivalent to the replacement cost of the affected asset.

18

19

If needed, EGAT may compensate properties and assets at that the rates

published by the Announcements of Prices for Land Evaluation published by Provincial

Governments. However, in case the published rates are lower than the replacement cost

of atfected assets, the co,iipe,nsation committees may request EGAT to paycompensation higher than the published rates.

19

20

CHAPTER 6 POPULAR PARTICIPATION

PAFs PARTICIPATION IN PROJECT SCHEMES.

The PAFs may participate in resettlement and land acquisition schemes. They may

be consulted by the competent authorities and may be requested to participate in public

meetings held by EGAT in cooperation with the CCs. These meetings are an occasion to

discuss resettlement and land compensation issues and may provide a forum in which the

affected population may express its opinions and offer suggestions.

The affected populations will be publicly informed by the pertinent authorities of the

details of resettlement and land compensation schemes. Damage occurring dates,

entitlements, definition of eligibility, modes of compensation, complaints and grievances

procedures may be made public by means of speaker announcements, pamphlets

distributed in project areas, billboards posted in public offices, newspaper announcements,

and radio broadcasts in accordance with EGAT policy.

According to EGAT regulations guided by the government policy, all activities

relating to fing and payment of compensation may be carried out with the participation

of the affected people and their representatives. The affected communities and villages

may be informed about the project as soon as the proposal to implement the project is

finalized.

20

2 1

CHAPTER 7 COMPLAINTS AND GRIEVANCES

Complaints and grievances related to any aspect of the RAP will be handled through

negotiation aimed at achieving consensus.

Settlement between the PAP and EGAT in coordination with local govemment will

be first attempted at the level of district in guidance of the village leader. If this first

conciliation attempt fails, the case will be discussed second time in the Inspection

Subcommittee and, if the case cannot be settled, it will be proposed to Compensation

Committee where the Committee will decide the matter.

In case where, despite the above efforts, no agreement is reached between the

parties, the PAP can submit the case to the court.

PAPs who present their cases to the District and Provincial Authorities, will be

free of charge. PAPs who bring their case to the court, will have to follow the prevailing

laws.

21

221

CHAPTER 8 SUPERVISION AND MONITORING

Implementation of the RAP will be regularly and monitored by EGAT with

supervision of local administrations

Intemal monitoring and supervision will

(a) verify that the census and socio-economic survey of all PAPs that

has been carried out and that property assessment and

compensation has been carried out in accordance with the provisions

of the RAP;

(b) oversee that RAP is implemented as approved; and

(c) verify that funds for implementing the RAP provided in a timely

miianiner are suiiiienrit ror their purposes, and are spent in

accordance with the provision of the RAP.

A specific unit for intemal monitoring will be formed, consisting of staffs from the

Land Division and the Environment Division of EGAT, and also with participation of

district and provincial officials. Intemal monitoring will be done on monthly basis during

the period of Implementation. Monitoring report will be prepared on a quarterly basis and

submitted to EGAT management and WB.

8.1 INTERNAL MONITORING

8.1.1 Intemal Monitoring Indlcators

These indicators will be monitored:

(a) Payment of compensation for land, houses, crops and other assets.

(b) Adequacy of the timing of payment of compensation.

(c) House relocation and reconstruction.

(d) Utilisaton of cash compensation- purchase of alternative Income generation

assets.

(e) Allotment of altemative land.

22

8.1.2 Reporting Requirement

The organisation set for internal monitoring will submit the semi-annual reports

to the Land Division of EGAT FArh renort will discuss the follow up of recommendation

of previous report.

8.2 EXTERNAL MONITORING

8.2.1 External Monitoring Indicators

Extemal monitorng will be carried out by an agency approved by OEPP, on a

semi- annual basis until the satisfactory is proved to be by EGAT. In addition to

confirming the result of intemal monitoring, extemal monitoring will focus on:

(a) The level of satisfaction among PAPs with the amount of compensation paid.

(b) Whether they are able to reconstruct houses and replace affected assets

with the compensation.

(c) Utilization of compensation paid for land. Whether the people can replace

affected land with other income generating assets or investments.

(d) Whether the compensation for PAPs were paid in advance sufficient. Whetherthey were able to reconstruct houses prior to the date they were required to

vacate.

8.2.2 Reporting Requirement

These requirement will be

(a) The extemal monitoring agency will submit the report to EGAT who will

forward the report to WB.

(b) The report will be discussed at the PMT where the Land Division attends.(c) Each report will discuss follow up of recommendation of previous report.

23

24

CHAPTER 9 IMPLEMENTATION ARRANGEMENTS

9.1 IMPLEMENTATION MEASURES

9.1.1 DIS and Soao-Economic Census

A fundamental condition for the starting of implementation activities will be the

completion of the DIS and the Socio-Economic Census.

Information for the DIS will include the production of 1:5,000 maps. Moreover,

all PAFs shall carefully listed detail about the following Information:

- Number of households

- Amount of agricultural land available to each PAF before

project. This figure shall also provide secondary data on relative amounts of agricultural

land per land type, type of crop cultivated, and location type

- Ust of house(s) and buildings owned by the PAFs before the

project. This information shall detail type of house/building and house/building area.

- Ust of houses/buildings affected by the project. In addition

this information shall clearly detail the area and the proportion of the house directly

affected by project.

9.1.2 Public Announcement

The PAFs may be informed of their right and the specific policies of this RAP at

least nine months before construction begins. The announcements to the PAFs may

include eligibility provisions; entitlement policy; modes and rates of compensation,

schedules and complaint and grievance rights. According to EGAT's rules and regulations

and Thailand law, such information may be delivered to the PAFs by EGAT through

meetings in city ward offices, through posters hung in local administration quarters and

in major public places such as markets, ralhway stations or hospitals, through pamphlet

to be distributed to each PAH and through announcement in local newspapers and

through radio broadcasts.

24

Public announcement tasks will be implemented immediately after RTG and WB

approval of project is obtained. The announcements and pamphlets may clearly describe

RAP policies, including in particular:

i) electric line laying zone announcement date (legally

damage occurring date)

ii) the principle that households who have occupied affected

land after the damage occurring date (i) are not

legitimate PAHs and therefore will not be compensated;

iii) that all households owning, leasing or using affected land

at the time of the announcement shall be considered

legitimate PAHs and therefore shall be compensated;

iv) That legitimate PAHs are both households with or without

land title or lease receipt.

v.) Public announcement may also detail implementation

rights and duties of the PAHs including compensation and

resettlement deadlines.

9.1.3 Compensation and Resettlement Deadllnes( PAHs rights)

Compensation for building losses whether total or partial shall be provided at

least 90 days before the beginning of construction work.

Resettlement allowances shall be provided together with compensation for

buildings losses 90 days before the beginning of construction work. The resettlement

allowances shall be given accordingly but shall be paid in one installment only.

Cash compensation for perennial crop losses shall be given at least 30 days

before construction work. Seasonal crops which are allowed to grow in the ROW shall be

compensated after construction work.

9.2.4 Compensation and Resettlement Deadllnes( PAHs obligations)

PAHs affected by resettlement or loss of residential land shall vacate the old

houses and plots completely at least 30 days before the beginning of construction

works.

25

26

PAHs affected by resettiement shall have demolished the reclaimed buildings or

portions of buildings at least 30 days before beginning of construction. In case this has

not occurred, the appropriate authorities shall carrying out the demolition work with their

own means while the old owners have to be responsible for the all the costs occurred.

9.2 RAP IMPLEMENTATION PROCESS

Action for the implementation of this RAP will apply immediately after RTG and

WB approval to the work that is prior to the beginning stage.

Since construction will last about two years and not all PAHs will be affected in

the same moment (various components of the project will be constructed in different

times), some of the RAP activities will have to be repeated for each project component.

In addition, some types of action will be continuous and will last from the beginning of

ImlelmenIIIGctation tu six months after implementation conclusion.

RAP action is thus divided in three categories: a) General Action: action

performed only once at the beginning of RAP implementation; b) Component Specific

Action: action performed several times once for each project component; and c)

Continuous Action: action performed continuously for all the period of RAP and

construction implementation plus six months.

9.2.1 General Acton

ACTION 1 The task forces on the ground begin action.

ACTION 2 The STs carry out the definitive inventory and the

socio-economic survey and CC simultaneously fixes the

already adjusted prices, or if necessary readjusts them

again so that compensation at market and substitution

rates is warranted.

ACTION3 Immediately at the end of the final inventory survey EGAT

will take care of installing sign posts declaring the

unavailability of the reclaimed land shall be planted along

the perimeters of the affected areas.

26

27

ACTION 4 EGAT may arrange for public announcements specifying

areas reclaimed and RAP policy, eligibility, entitlements

and schedules to be carried out by means of posters

hung, in rniihlir' nfFir,'Q annd imnportant civil nlaces such as

marketplaces, railways station, hospitals and through

newspapers and radio announcement. This action may be

done according to EGAT rules and regulations and Thailand

law.

ACTION 5 A meeting between the EGAT, CC and the PAH is

organized. During the meeting all aspects having to do

with eligibility, entitlements, compensation and

implementation action may be discussed with the PAHs.

8.2.2 Component Specifliation

ACTION 6 All PAHs are notified of the specific time frame of their

compensation. This will include when their property will

have to be vacated, when, how, and how much they will

be compensated. In addition, this document will also

specify the amount of allowances. This document shall

be signed by the PAHs' heads and countersigned by a CC

member and by a local community representative.

ACTION 7 Compensation delivery. The CC will deliver all the

compensation and allowances for land, trees and houses

Is given to PAH.

ACTION 8 A month before the beginning of construction all plots

within areas reclaimed by the project shall be vacated and

all buildings within those areas shall have been

demolished. In case some building is still standing in

whole or in part it shall be demolished by the PMT.

ACTION 9 At the conolusion of construction the PAHs who occupied

areas only temporarily affected by project will be allowed

to return to their old plots to continue their previous

activities.

27

28

9.2.3 Cortinuous Action

ACTION 1 0 Complaints and grievances emerging at any point of RAP

implementation until six months after conclusion of

project will be handled as specified in chapter 6.

ACTION 11 All along the execution of RAP programs the set unit will

carry out intemal monitoring activities.

9.3 CORRELATION OF RAP IMPLEMENTATION AND CONSTRUCTION

SCHEDULE

it is one of the provisions of this RAP that its implementation should be carried

in such a way as to respect the basic RAP principles and objectives. This means that

construction programs would reasonably follow and not precede the execution of RAP

programs. In other words, in case of retards in RAP execution, the delay may be reflected

In construction programs.

Necessary time allowances have been enacted for RAP programs that require the

beginning of construction work after the end of the harvest.

The PAPs will be Informed by project authorities about the detailed description of

project impacts and properties to be acquired at least 5 months before the start of

construction on their properties and will be required to vacate the reclaimed plots no

sooner than 30 days prior to the beginning of construction.

Payment of compensation for houses and other buildings will be provided at

least 90 days prior to the deadline for house vacation. Payment of compensation for

agricultural land, crops and trees will be done 30 days prior to the construction start-up

date.

28

29

9.5 IMPLEMENTATION ARRANGEMENTS

Although EGAT has the power of compulsory acquisition of land under the EGAT

Act, the preferred method is to undertake a system of negotiation to come to an

agreement with the landowners on the monetary value that is acceptable to both parties.

This is under the direction of the Compensation Committee (see Chapter 9 )

EGAT will inform the concerned districts about the resettlement program and direct

them to take steps necessary for compensation and resettlement of the PAPs within

their jurisdiction. EGAT, as a secretary of Compensation Committee, will inform the PAPs

and the respective local authorities about the project, the resettlement and construction

program and coordinate its activities. The Compensation Committee will be responsible

for fixing compensation levels for various types of affected properties. Payment of

compensation will be carried on by EGAT and its agencies. The District Director and

village head will be in charge of informing the PAPs about the project impact and

implementation schedule, to strengthening the grievances redress and to act as a

communication link between the PAPs and the Compensation Committee and EGAT.

Most routine activities will be coordinated directly by the district authorities. EGAT will

finance the total cost of the RAP and ensure timely availability of funds. These tables

show the activities that need to be carried out as part of resettlement and construction

program and the organizations responsible for it.

Table 9.1: Agencies Responsible for RAP Activities

No RAP acdvity Responsible Agency

1. Inform the PAPs about the Project and the Land Division (EGAT) , District

resettlement program authorities and village head

2. Conduct survey to determine affected land and Land Division(EGAT)and village

properties head

3. Conduct details survey for fixing compensation Land Division (EGAT),

Compensation Sub- committee and

village head

4. Fixing compensation rates Compensation Committee

5. Fixing compensation for each property Land Division (EGAT), Compensation

Sub - Committee

6. Paying compensation Compensation Sub-

A Committee

29

30

CHAPTER 1 0 COSTS AND BUDGETS

Cost Krabi Ratohabuld T. Ratohabud C. EGAT-TNB TSEP.9 Hong Sa Total

Survey Cost 2.0 50.9 40.0 56.1 23.3 9.1 181.4

Compensation

Land 31.1 1,366.5 910.0 960.3 917.2 183.8 4,368.9

Houses 1.1 7.0 25.3 14.3 25.0 24.3 97.0Tree/crops 17.8 24.0 67.0 500.5 83.8 19.7 712.8

External Monitoring 1.0 - - - 6.5 1.0 8.5

Administrative expense 2.6 72.4 52.1 76.5 52.5 11.8 267.9

Contingencies (20%) 10.9 304.2 218.9 321.5 220.3 49.7 1,125.5

Total Budgeted Cost 65.5 1,824.9 1,31 3.3 1 ,929.3 1,322.1 298.5 6,762.0

30

31

APPENDIX 1 CC, SC and TF members

Compensatlon Committee: Authorized to set compensation rate and redress

grievance.

Provincial Governor Chairman

Provincial Police Commander

Provincial Land Officer

Provincial Agricultural Officer

Provincial Forestry Officer

Provincial Public Work Officer

Chief, Provincial Govemor Office

District Director

EGAT Representative

EGAT Operational Region Director

EGAT Law Division Representative

EGAT Compensation. Department Chief

EGAT Land Coordination Department Chief Secretary

inDpmlon Subommlttees: set to inspect TF's property survey work and

grievance redress.

District Director Chairman

District Land Officer

District Agricultural Officer

District Office Work Officer

Village Head or Representative

EGAT Land and Property Inspection Section Chief Secretary

CompnaM set to pay compensation to PAPs

District Director Chairman

District Land Officer

Village Head or Representative

EGAT Cash-compensation Section Head

EGAT compensation Section Head Secretary

Task Fo.em6 consists of EGAT staffs and Village Head or his representative.

31

32

APPENDIX 2: Provincial CCs set

Project Province Duration

Krabi Thermal Plant Unit 1 Krabi

Phang Nga Nov. 1 997

Nakom Si Thammarat

Ratchaburi Thermal Plant Ratchaburi

Unit 1 & 2 Nakom Prathom

Kanchanaburi Mar. 1 996

Pranakom Si Ayuthya

Nonthaburi

Ratchaburi Combined Ratchaburi

Crvr,i Rinr!k 1-3q Nakom Prathom

Kanchanaburi Mar. 1 996

Samut Sakom

Nonthabun

EGAT-TNB Stage 2 Song Khla

Interconnection Nakom Si Thammarat Jan. 1995

Pattalung

500 kV for Hong Sa Power Nan

Plant Stage 1 Phrae Apr. 1996

Lampang

Transmission Expansion Buriram

Project No.9 Chaiyaphum

Chiang MaiJan. 1995-Nov. 1996

Chonbuni

Kham Phaeng Phet

Lampang

32

33

Project Province Duration

Transmission Expansion Lopbur Jan. 1 995 - Nov. 1996

Project No.9 Maha Sarakham

Mukdahan

Nakom Phathom

Nakom Si Thammarat

Nakom Phanom

Narathiwat

Nong Bua Lamphue

Phang Nga

Pattnni

Petchburi

Phuket

Prachinburi

Prachuab Khiri Khan

Ratchburi

Roi-et

Saraburi

Si Sa Ket

Singburi

Song Khla

Sra Kaew

Surat Thani

Surin

Ubon Ratchathani

Udon Thani

Ygk-

33

34

APPENDIX 3: Project Informations

Kiabl Thermal Unit 1

Area of Land Affected by Transmisslon Unes

Length ROW Ended Tower Afteed Land| Houes Trees Total

T/L A| . Ages Cpsn Quanttty Cpsn Opan Cps

(km) (i.) (v.1) (-l) (mB3) (iB) (mB) (mB)

' 1. Krabi-Phang Nga 2 98.5 50 Dec-99 63.3 63.3 1.1 0 0 0 1 1

2. Krabl-Thung Song 79.0 50 Dec-99 50.8 2.468.8 30.0 12 1.1 17.8 48.9

Tast 177.5 = 114.1 2532.1 31.1 12 1. 1 17.8 50.0

Reconstruction in the Existing ROW

35

Ratchaburi Thermal Unit 1 & 2

Area of Land Affected by Transmisslon Unes

Lengtu ROW Ended Tower Affected Lnd House Tre. Total

T/L Area A OCpen t Cpun Cpen Cp

(ion) (re) (rat) (mB) (mB) (mB) (mB)

1. Jom Bung-(Sal Noi)-Wang Nol 197.0 60 Sep-98 170.3 7.387.5 1,183.0 88 7.0 24.0 1214.0

'2. Ratchaburi 2-Ban Pong 2 41.2 40 Aug-99 26.5 26.5 21.0 0 0 0 21

*3. Ban Pong 2-Sai No! 53.6 40 Aug-99 34.5 34.5 27.0 0 0 0 27

4.Samut Sakorn 4-Samut Sakom Junction- 8.0 24 Aug-98 3.6 3.6 2.5 0 0 0 2.5

Samut Sakom 2

Total 299 8 _ 234.8 7452.1 1233.5 88 7.0 24.0 1264.5

Reconstruction in the Existing ROW

Ratchaburl Thermal Unit 1 & 2

Area of Land Acquired for Substations

Ar No. Date Amount

Subvtton0 Prnhee paid Uae

(ml) (ra) (mB)

1. Jom Bung 550 6 Jul 6. 95 49 Paddy field

2. Sumut Sakom 4 102 2 Dec 21,95 84 Orchard

Total 652 8 133

Ratchaburi Combined Cycle Block 1-3 36

Area of Land Affected by Transmission Une

Length ROW Ended Tower Affected Land Houses Trees Total

T/L Area Area Cp Qnty Cpsn Cpsn Cpen

(kn) (m.) (ral) (ral) (MB) I (mB) (mB) (mB)

1. Ratchaburt Plant-Jom Bung 26.7 60 Jun-98 23.1 1.001.3 136.0 7 1.0 4.0 141.0

2. Jom Bung-Sal No! 103.0 60 Jun-98 89.0 3,862.5 531.0 80 9.2 20.0 560.2

3. Ratchaburi Plant-Ratchaburl 2 21.0 40 Dec-97 13.7 525.0 70.0 11 1.2 9.0 80.2

4. Ratchaburi Plant-Samut Sakom4 36.6 40 May-98 23.5 915.01 73.0 41 1 3.9 34.0 220.9

Total 187.3 149.3 6303.8 910.0 139 25.3 67.0 1002.3

37

EGAT-TNB Stage 11 Interconnection

Area of Land Affected by Transmission Unes

Length ROW Ended Tower Affected Land Houses Trees Totl

T/L A,a A,ea Cpun Qnty Cpsn Cpen Cpsn

(km) (m.) (rul) (tml) (mB) (mB) (mB) (me)

1. 250 kV Direct Current Kiong Ngae- 24.0 50 Dec-97 17.0 750.0 92.7 31 1.l 63.3 157.1

Thalland-Malaysia Border Une

2. Hat Yai 2 - Kiong Ngae 30.0 50 Dec-97 21.0 937.5 190.3 31 2.4 77.9 270.6

3. Klong Ngae-Thung Song 210.0 50 Jul-98 143.0 6562.5 605.3 224 10.8 359.3 975.4

Tofta P-264.0 = 181.0 8250.0 888.3 286 14.3 500.5 1403.1

Area of Land Acquired for Substation

ArEa No.of Date of Amomnt Pueviocs

Substation (rai) Dn Pichmes paid Usage

_______ (i)_D_P (mB)

Kiong Ngae 192 4 Dec 23,93 72 Rubber

Plantation

38

Transmission System Expansion Project No.9

Area of Land Affected by Transmission Unes

* Lnth ROW Ended Tower AffectId Land Houses Trees Total

T/L Area Aea Cpn Qnty Cpen Cpsn Cpen

(1on) (in.) (l) | () (mB) (mO) (mO) (mO)

'1. Ban Pong 2-Ban Pong 1 -Nakom Chaisri- 43.0 40 Jan-98 27.6 27.6 21.5 0 0 0 21.5

Sam Phran 2

2. Bor Win-Ban Bung 27.0 24 Apr-98 12.2 405.0 66.4 4 0.2 3.9 70.5

3. Connectl 15 kV Une Singburl-Lopbun 1 2.0 24 Apr-98 0.9 30.0 0.6 0 0 0 0.6

to Tha Wung Substation

4. Tha Lan 3-Sara Burl 1 15.0 24 Mar-98 6.8 6.8 10.4 0 0 0 10.4

5. Tha Lan i-Tha Lan 3 5.0 24 Mar-98 2.3 2.3 3.2 0 0 0 3.2

*6. Ratchaburi-Phetchabun 54.0 24 May-98 24.3 24.3 3.6 0 0 0 3.6

7. Prachin Burl 2-Wattana Nakom 67.0 24 Apr-98 30.2 1.005.0 10.4 10 2.5 1.6 14.5

8. Mukdahan 2-That Phanom 36.0 24 May-98 16.2 540.0 9.4 1 0.1 0.8 10.3

9. That Phanom-Nakhom Phanom 59.0 24 Jan-98 26.6 885.0 17.8 2 0.4 1.9 20.1

10. UdonThani 2-NongBua Lam Phu 61.0 24 Feb-99 27.5 915.0 14.7 8 2.0 1.3 18.0

* 11. Roi Et-Phayakkaphum Phi Sai(Stringing) 84.0 24 Oct-97 0.0 0.0 0 0 0 0 0

12. Phayakkaphum Phi Sal-Surin 80.0 24 Dec-97 36.0 1,200.0 18.5 5 0.9 2.2 21.6

* 13. Surat Thani-Bandon(Strlnging) 14.0 24 Oct-97 0.0 0.0 0 0 0 0 0

14. Chalya Phum-Bumnet Narong 58.0 24 Mar-98 26.1 870.0 18.2 3 0.7 1.9 20.8

15. Ubon Ratchathani 2-Kanthararak 55.0 24 Mar-98 24.8 825.0 17.1 3 0.3 1.1 18.5

16. Surtn-Sagkha 49.0 24 Jun-98 22.1 735.0 11.5 8 0.9 0.9 13.3

*17. Thung Song-Nakom Si Thammarat 54.0 50 Dec-97 34.7 34.7 5.2 0 0 0 5.2

*18. Surat Thani-Thung Song 122.0 50 Jul-98 78.4 78.4 11.8 0 0 0 11.8

19. Klong Ngae-Yala 2 120.0 50 Mar-99 77.1 3.750.0 90.8 4 0.8 28.4 120.0

*20. Phang Nga-Phuket Junction 76.0 50 Oct-98 48.9 48.9 10.3 0 0 0 10.3

21. Phuket 2-Phuketjunction 12.0 50 Oct-98 5.4 5.4 1.1 0 0 0 1.1

22. Yala-Narathtwat 61.0 50 Jan-99 27.5 1,906.3 f08.8 20 5.0 34.8 148.6

23. Lan Krabu-Kham Phaeng Phet 47.0 24 Jul-99 21.2 705.0 5.7 10 3.0 0.6 9.3

* Reconstruction In the Existing ROW.

39

LeUgih ROW Ended Tower Affected Land Houses Tres Total

T/L A,a Area Cpen Qt Cpsn Cpsn Cpen

(km) ()ml) (ral) (ms) (mB) (mB) (mB)

24. Mae Moh 3-Lampang 2 27.0 24 Feb-98 12.2 405.0 11.0 2 0.2 0.7 11.9

25. Chiang Mai-Mae Taeng 42.0 24 Aug-98 18.9 630.0 18.3 20 8.0 3.7 30.0

*26. Connect 230 k Line Ratchaburi 2- 11.6 40 Mar-98 7.5 7.5 1.0 0 0 0 1.0

Prachaub Khirikhun to Hua Hln Substatlon

TOM _ _ 1281.61 614.91 15042.1 487.3 100 25.01 83.8 596.1

Reconstruction In the Existing ROW.

Transmission System Expansion Project No.9

Area of Land Acquired for Substatlone

Ams I No.et Daft of Amn.t Prevous

S~~~~etuUuw ~ ~ ~ ~ OnmPwdhma paM U11ageS d_______________ (al) (va1) (MO) _al___

1. Yala (230 kV) 92 1 Dec 16,96 20.0 Orchard

2. Phuket (230 kV) 57 7 Jun 18,97 60.0 Orchard

3. Nakom Chal Srd (230 kV) 25 1 Oct 25,96 95.0 Orchard

4. Thung Song (230 k/11S kV 100 1 Jun 21,96 75.0 Orchard

Expansion Area)

5. Mukdahan 2 (230/115 kV) 353 1 5 Jul 2,97 121.0 Orchard

6. Sangkha (115 kV) 30 3 Nov 13,97 2.0 Orchard

7. Mae Teang (115 kV) 20 1 May 29,97 0.3 Orchard

8. That Phanom (115 kV) 1 0 1 Feb 3,97 2.2 Orchard

9. Phang Nga (230 kV) 81 8 Jan 15,97 14.5 Orchard

10. Lang Saun (230 kV) 60 2 2000 40.0 Orchard

I Totfa: R _ .. Lt..-..4 4 3 0 .n

40

500 kV For Hong Sa Power Plant Stage 1 & 2

Area of Land Affected by Transmission Unes

Lenglh ROW Ended Tower Ld Hou"ses Trees Toftl

T/L Ae Area Cpen Cp pn CpUn

(kn) (m.) ("I) (l) (m.) (mB) (mB) (mB)

Border(Nan province) -Mae Moh 3 245.0 80 Aug-99 21 1.8 9.18S7.5 183.8 182 24.31 19.,7 227.,8- - - - - _

r

Information of all the Projects 41

Area of Land Affected by Transmission Unes

Length ROW Ended Tower Affected Land Houses Ties Total

T/L Area Area Cpsn Qnty Cpen Cpsn Cpsn

(bn) (m.) (ral) (tn) (me) (mB) (mB1) (mB)

1.Krabl 177.5 50 Dec-99 114.1 2,532.1 31.1 12 1.1 17.8 50.0

2.Ratchburl T. 299.8 Aug-99 234.8 7,452.1 1233.5 88 7.0 24.0 1264.5

3.Ratchburd CC. 187.3 50 Jun-98 149.3 6,303.8 910.0 139 25.3 67.0 1002.3

4.Wang Noi - - _ - _ _ _ _

5.EGAT-TNB 264.0 50 Jul-98 181.0 8250.0 888.3 286 14.3 500.5 1403.1

6.Pover Supply for GBA 113.1 40 jui-98 99.2 99.2 316.0 0 0 0 316.0

7.TSEP No.9 1281.6 Jul-99 614.9 15042.1 487.3 101 25.0 83.8 596.1

8.Lam Thakhong - - _ _ _ - _ _ _

9.TS for Purchased Pauer 980.8 Sep-00 775.7 32266.3 4166.6 386 72.7 607.9 4847.2

1o.Hong S 245.0 60 1 Aug-99 211.8 9187.5 183.8 162 24.3 19.7 227.8

Tote 3549.1 I23808 81133.1 8216.6 1174 169.7 1320.7 9