WikiSym 2011 Closing Keynote
-
Upload
ed-chi -
Category
Technology
-
view
1.397 -
download
5
description
Transcript of WikiSym 2011 Closing Keynote
WikiSym 2011 | Closing Keynote!
Model-Driven Research in Social Computing!!
Ed H. Chi!!
Google Research!!Work done while at Palo Alto Research Center (PARC)!
!
!
2011-10-05 WikiSym 2011 Closing Keynote 1
*"/$)'78%"2%!"&'()%!'87()-%'7%9%:&+-%
! J4-&OOOZ&M3"&J90-('4-"?&[ \3'("?&]5#6%"?A"&\$'4"&
! J4-&OOZ&M3"&^.0.9%"&[ \3'("?&J55#-'-.#50&
! J4-&OZ&M3"&O5H.0.9%"&[ \3'(.5A&'4(#00&N'5A8'A"0&
2011-10-05 WikiSym 2011 Closing Keynote
UP(#/&4#/$%"*&-#&0./$%"W&
4
:&+%;;;0%%:6-+,(&+$/%<7"=)$/8$0%%*"/$)'78%"2%>'?'@$/'(%
]8?#0&-#&D#5A6#5&\83C&_.1.&].--8(&
&
U].--8(&"-&'%:C&`aO)<<bW&
U\83&"-&'%:C&I.1.\2/&)<<cW&
U\83C&"-&'%:C&^J\M)<<bW&
&
&
2011-10-05 WikiSym 2011 Closing Keynote 5
A"8'-+'&%B,"=+C%*"/$)%! G4#%#A.4'%&$#$8%'-.#5&A(#6-3&/#?"%&
[ J%0#&?"$"5?&"5H.(#5/"5-'%&4#5?.-.#50&
[ ]C&4'((2.5A&4'$'4.-2&S?8"&-#&("0#8(4"&%./.-'-.#5T&
!
dNdt
= rN(1" NK)
2011-10-05 WikiSym 2011 Closing Keynote 6
D!C"=$,'78E%FG@"+C$-'-%I3'-&?(.H"0&4#5-(.98-.#50&-#&I.1.$"?.'d&
`##$"('-.#5&.0&5#-&-3"&/'.5&?(.H"(d&
! a2$#-3"0.0Z&`#5e.4-0&?(.H"0&/#0-&-3"&4#5-(.98-.#50:&[ a#6&?#&6"&/"'08("&4#5e.4-0d&
! `#5e.4-0&4'80"&4##(?.5'-.#5&4#0-0&-#&A#&8$:&[ a#6&-#&/"'08("&4##(?.5'-.#5&4#0-0d&
! f5"A#-.'-.#5&.0&4(.-.4'%&-#&3"%$.5A&/8%-.$%"&$"(0$"4-.H"0&-#&4#5H"(A"&03'("?&15#6%"?A":g&&[ \-'3%C&@(#8$&`#A5.-.#5C&`3LC&)<<Y&
2011-10-05 WikiSym 2011 Closing Keynote 7
2011-10-05
H"7I'&+JH"",/'7(+'"7%KL$&+-%'7%>'?'@$/'(%
60%
65%
70%
75%
80%
85%
90%
95%
100%
2001 2002 2003 2004 2005 2006
Perc
enta
ge o
f to
tal edits
Article
User
Article Talk
User Talk
Other
Maintenance
(Kittur, Suh, Pendleton, Chi, CHI2007)
WikiSym 2011 Closing Keynote 8
2011-10-05 WikiSym 2011 Closing Keynote
M-'78%*(&C'7$%A$(,7'78%+"%N$+$&+%H"7I'&+-%! `#85-.5A&h`#5-(#H"(0.'%E&%'9"%0&
! B*&4(#00+H'%.?'-.#5C&i)&j&<:Lcb&
0
1000
2000
3000
4000
5000
6000
7000
8000
9000
10000
0 1000 2000 3000 4000 5000 6000 7000 8000 9000 10000
Predicted controversial revisions
Actu
al c
ontr
over
sial r
evisi
ons
9
O(+'"%"2%O$P$,+$/%H"7+,'61+'"7-%%
Monthly Ratio of Reverted Edits
2011-10-05 WikiSym 2011 Closing Keynote 10
Q'-1()%:7()G+'&-%"P$,%>'?'@$/'(%/(+(%*$/'(+",%R(++$,7%S%5$,,'%!&C'(P" % %.!1CT%$+%()UT%Q:!5VWWX3%
Mediators
Sympathetic to parents
Sympathetic to husband
Anonymous (vandals/spammers)
2011-10-05 WikiSym 2011 Closing Keynote 11
>'?'N(-C6"(,/U&"#%
2011-10-05 WikiSym 2011 Closing Keynote 12
:&+%;;0%Q'-'6)$%!"&'()%!'87()-%2,"#%%!C(,$/%F'8C)'8C+'78%
&
&
]8?#0&-#&N.43'5&a#5AC&N"0&_"%0#5&&
Ua#5A&"-&'%C&J^O)<<LW&
U_"%0#5&"-&'%:C&a`OO&)<<cW&
2011-10-05 WikiSym 2011 Closing Keynote 13
Y'7/'78%(%O$-+(1,(7+%
! J$$(#$(.'-"&7#(&-3",'0.#5&
2011-10-05 WikiSym 2011 Closing Keynote 14
Poor heuristic
Good heuristic
F$1,'-+'&-%
2011-10-05 WikiSym 2011 Closing Keynote 15
DF'7+-E%
Solo
Cooperative (“good hints”)
2011-10-05 WikiSym 2011 Closing Keynote 16
!@(,5(8U1-0%!"&'()%F'8C)'8C+'78%
2011-10-05 WikiSym 2011 Closing Keynote 17
!@(,5(8U1-0%!"&'()%F'8C)'8C+'78%
! !"#$%&'&-'AA.5A&63.%"&("'?.5A&
! a.A3%.A3-.5A&
! \3'("?&5#-"9##1.5A&&
! \3'(.5Ak&
2011-10-05 WikiSym 2011 Closing Keynote 18
F'8C)'8C+'78%(-%;#@",+(7&$%%;7/'&(+",%
recall first-visit
2011-10-05 WikiSym 2011 Closing Keynote 19
! \"50"/'1.5A&-'01&[ P.5?&'5?&("'?&/'-"(.'%&'9#8-&“G5-"($(.0"&):<&/'038$0”&.5&#(?"(&-#&
6(.-"&-6#&"00'20&
! \""?0Z&“"*$"(-”&4#5-"5-&7#(&04'l#%?.5A&[ M'A0&7(#/&?"%:.4.#:80&
[ miN0&7(#/&@##A%"X!'A"i'51&
[ `#50-(84-"?&'5?&-3"5&03'("?&-3(#8A3&0#4.'%&/"43'5.0/0&S.:":C&'&\$'(M'A:80&“7(."5?”T&
! !"(7#(/'54"&Q"'08("0&[ N"'(5.5A&A'.5Z&!("X!#0-&]5#6%"?A"&M"0-&
&
GH'%8'-.#5&M'01&n&Q"-(.4&U_"%0#5&"-&'%:C&a`OO)<<cW&
scorePretest - scoreMax scorePretest -scorePosttest
=Gain
2011-10-05 WikiSym 2011 Closing Keynote 20
R,"&$/1,$%
o"/#A('$3.40&n&!("-"0-&
SF \$'(M'A:80&6.-3&‘P(."5?’&
SO \$'(M'A:80&p5%2&
WS I.-3#8-&\$'(M'A:80&
!#0--"0-&
2011-10-05 WikiSym 2011 Closing Keynote 21
O$-1)+-0%A$(,7'78%B('7%_j;L&&!@(,5(8U1-%Z%Y,'$7/%-1@$,'",%+"%6"+C%'7/'P'/1()%&"7/'+'"7-%_#&?.l"("54"&9"-6""5&-3"&-6#&4#5-(#%&4#5?.-.#50&
2011-10-05 WikiSym 2011 Closing Keynote 22
URL Kind Code Blog B Conference C Employment E MySpartagus M News N OpenSource O Search S Vendor V Wikipedia W Consultant X
[6-$,P(+'"7%miN&].5?& `#?"&
D%#A& D&
`#57"("54"& `&
G/$%#2/"5-& G&
Q2:\$'(-'A:80& Q&
_"60& _&
p$"5\#8(4"& p&
\"'(43& \&
^"5?#(& ^&
I.1.$"?.'& I&
`#508%-'5-& q&
2011-10-05 WikiSym 2011 Closing Keynote 23
Q"7%O$-+",L%;-")(+'"7%KL$&+%.\]993%! J0&'$$%."?&-#&3.A3%.A3-0C&-3"&!"#$%&'(")*$+'",-(+"#$&*&.($
08AA"0-0&-3'-&("'?"(0Z&
! ()*#&+",#&-#.-/'$#-"#'5?&&! (0*#1+)2"#34)&#%$#5)26+,C&&! 63"-3"(&-3"&.57#(/'-.#5&.0&./$#(-'5-&#(&5#-:&
[ _.0-&'5?&a#A("9"&Lb&
2011-10-05 WikiSym 2011 Closing Keynote 24
:&+%;0%%;7P'-'6)$%^,"?$,(8$%!'87()-%(&,"--%A(781(8$%^(,,'$,-%
r#.5-&6#(1&6X&N.43'5&a#5AC&@("A#(.#&`#5H"(-.5#&
&
Ua#5A&"-&'%:C&O`I\Q&)<;;W&&
2011-10-05 WikiSym 2011 Closing Keynote 25
!"&'()%!+,$(#%O$-$(,&C%! M6""-&("4#//"5?'-.#5&S`3"5&"-&'%C&`aOE;<&n&`aOE;;T&
! M#$.4+9'0"?&4%80-"(.5A&n&9(#60.5A&-6""-0&SD"(50-".5&
n&a#5A&"-&'%C&mO\ME;<T&
! P'4-#(0&./$'4-.5A&("-6""-'9.%.-2&S\83&n&a#5A&"-&'%C&OGGG&
\#4.'%&`#/$8-.5AE;<T&
! N#4'-.#5&K"%?&80"(&$(#K%"0&Sa"43-&n&a#5A&"-&'%C&
`aOE;;T&
! [,8(7'&%_`:%6$C(P'",-%aR(1)%$+%()T%;H>!*b\\c%
! A(781(8$-%1-$/%'7%5='++$,%aF"78%$+%()T%;H>!*b\\c%
2011-10-05 WikiSym 2011 Closing Keynote 26
*"+'P(+'"7%2",%!+1/G'78%A(781(8$-%
! M6.--"(&.0&'5&.5-"(5'-.#5'%&$3"5#/"5#5&
[ Q#0-&("0"'(43&7#480"?&G5A%.03&80"(0&
[ V8"0-.#5&'9#8-&A"5"('%.s'-.#5&-#&5#5+G5A%.03&
[ m5?"(0-'5?&4(#00+%'5A8'A"&80'A"&?.l"("54"0&[ o"0.A5&./$%.4'-.#50&7#(&.5-"(5'-.#5'%&80"(0&
! i"0"'(43&V8"0-.#50Z&
[ I3'-&.0&-3"&%'5A8'A"&?.0-(.98-.#5&.5&M6.--"(d&
[ a#6&?#&80"(0&?.l"("5-&%'5A8'A"0&80"&M6.--"(d&
[ a#6&?#&9.%.5A8'%&80"(0&0$("'?&.57#(/'-.#5&'4(#00&%'5A8'A"0d&
&2011-10-05 WikiSym 2011 Closing Keynote 27
N(+(%H"))$&+'"7%`%R,"&$--'78%
&M6.--"(&0-("'/&
&;<Y&%'5A8'A"0&&
<YX;LX;<+<BX;FX;<&SY&6""10T&&
&F)Q&-6""-0&
@##A%"&N'5A8'A"&J!O&n&N.5A!.$"&
M#$&;<&%'5A8'A"0&
2011-10-05 WikiSym 2011 Closing Keynote 28
5"@%\W%A(781(8$-%'7%5='++$,%
%%A(781(8$% %%%%%5=$$+-% %%%%d% %%%%%M-$,-%
K78)'-C% ,;CcB)CcFY& e\U\% BC)L)CFBb&
f(@(7$-$% ;;CcbBCY)c& \]U\% ;C,,BC<bY&
R",+181$-$% BCcc,CBLY& ]Ug% cc,C<L,&
;7/"7$-'(7% ,CYL,CLY)& eUg% ,,LC;;F&
!@(7'-C% )Cc,;C<)B& hUX% b<FCB))&
o8-43& LL,CcY)& ;:Y& )YbCB)c&
]#("'5& bBYC;Lc& ;:)& ;;FCB<F&
P("543& F<,Cb<F& ;:<& )F;CYL;&
@"(/'5&& BLLCY<c& ;:<& ;c)CYbb&
Q'%'2& BBcC,L;& <:c& ;L<C;Yb&2011-10-05 WikiSym 2011 Closing Keynote 29
F1#(7SH"/'78%!+1/G%! )C<<<&('5?#/&-6""-0&7(#/&F)Q&-6""-0&
! )&38/'5&>8?A"0&7#(&"'43&-#$&;#&%'5A8'A"0&&
[ 5'-.H"&0$"'1"(0&#(&$(#K4."5-&[ ?.04800&-#&("0#%H"&?.0'A(""/"5-&
! a'(?&-#&K5?&O5?#5"0.'5&n&Q'%'2&>8?A"0&
! !("0"5-"?&)C<<<&-6""-0&-#&"'43&>8?A"&
! r8?A"&0"%"4-"?&-6""-0&.5&3.0X3"(&%'5A8'A"&
2011-10-05 WikiSym 2011 Closing Keynote 30
:&&1,(&G%"2%A(781(8$%N$+$&+'"7%
! M6#&M2$"0&G((#(0&
[ 7-&#'2#,%2/$89%:5#1'6"8#;32,#<#&3%&#'#&--9$-=3)&#,-%"8#4)>S?"-"4-"?&'0&J7(.1''50T&
[ a.A3&"((#(&('-"&7#(&-6""-0&;t)&6#(?0&
2011-10-05 WikiSym 2011 Closing Keynote 31
*(&C'7$%P-U%F1#(7%%%A(781(8$% %%%%%5SR% %%%5Si% %%%YSi% %%YSR% %%%%%%H"C$7b-%<(@@(%
K78)'-C% ]Xh% ]X\% VW% 9e% WU]e%f(@(7$-$% ,b<& ;CBcB& <& ,B& WU]h%R",+181$-$% ;b<& ;CL<,& ;c& L& WU]V%;7/"7$-'(7% ;<F& ;CLbB& ;B& Y& WU]\%!@(7'-C% cF& ;CLLc& ;;& Y& WU]V%N1+&C% ;L& ;CcbL& )& )& WU]W%<",$(7% )Y& ;CcbF& <& <& \UWW%P("543& ;,& ;CcL<& <& b& <:bc&
@"(/'5&& ;)& ;Ccbc& )& b& <:b)&
Q'%'2& L& ;Ccbc& Y& c& <:BB&
5SR0%+,1$%@"-'+'P$T%5Si0%+,1$%7$8(+'P$T%YSi0%2()-$S7$8(+'P$T%YSR0%2()-$%@"-'+'P$%2011-10-05 WikiSym 2011 Closing Keynote 32
*(&C'7$%P-U%F1#(7%
%%A(781(8$% %%%%%5SR% %%%5Si% %%%YSi% %%YSR% %%%%%%H"C$7b-%<(@@(%
P("543& ;,& ;CcL<& W% X% <:bc&
@"(/'5&& ;)& ;Ccbc& V% X% <:b)&
Q'%'2& L& ;Ccbc& h% ]% <:BB&
• P("543Z&BXb&P+!&3'H"&)&6#(?0&
• @"(/'5Z&;X)&P+_&3'0&;&6#(?u&FXb&P+!0&'("&.5&G5A%.03&
• Q'%'2Z&,XY&P+_0&n&bXc&P+!0&'("&.5&O5?#5"0.'5&
2011-10-05 WikiSym 2011 Closing Keynote 33
H"##"7%5='++$,%H"7P$7+'"7-%C(-C+(8%
MOA%#$7+'"7%
,$@)G%S$"(+-6""-&/"-'?'-'T&
,$+=$$+%2011-10-05 WikiSym 2011 Closing Keynote 34
M-$%"2%MOA-%'7%gV*%5=$$+-%
%%A(781(8$% %MOA-%
/,,$ V\d%
G5A%.03& )Bv&
r'$'5"0"& \9d%
!#(-8A8"0"& \9d%
O5?#5"0.'5& \9d%
\$'5.03& ;Bv&
o8-43& ;bv&
]#("'5& ;bv&
P("543& 9Xd%
@"(/'5&& 9]d%
Q'%'2& ;bv&
! J%%&S);vT&
! v&43'5A"0&'4(#00&%'5A8'A"0&
! @"(/'5&'5?&P("543&3'H"&3.A3&v&
! r'$'5"0"C&!#(-8A8"0"C&'5?&
O5?#5"0.'5&3'H"&%#6&v&
! G5A%.03&S)BvT&?.l"("5-&7(#/&
#-3"(0&
HC'%!j1(,$%+$-+-%&"7k,#$/%+C(+%/'L$,$7&$-%6G%)(781(8$%(,$%-'87'k&(7+%2011-10-05 WikiSym 2011 Closing Keynote 35
!'87'k&(7+%H,"--SA(781(8$%N'L$,$7&$-%
%%A(781(8$% %F(-C+(8-% %*$7+'"7-% %O$@)'$-% %O$+=$$+-%
/,,$ \\d% h]d% 9\d% \9d%
G5A%.03& ;Yv& Ybv& )cv& ;,v&
r'$'5"0"& ed% Y,v& ,,v& Xd%
!#(-8A8"0"& ;)v& B<v& ,)v& ;)v&
O5?#5"0.'5& ed% XVd% VWd% 9]d%
\$'5.03& ;;v& BLv& ,cv& ;Yv&
o8-43& ;,v& B<v& ,Bv& ;;v&
]#("'5& ;;v& X9d% e]d% ;;v&
P("543& ;)v& YLv& ,Fv& cv&
@"(/'5&& \ld% 9gd% )Bv& Lv&
Q'%'2& ed% F)v& ),v& )cv&
HC'%!j1(,$%+$-+-%&"7k,#$/%+C(+%/'L$,$7&$-%6G%)(781(8$%(,$%-'87'k&(7+%2011-10-05 WikiSym 2011 Closing Keynote 36
;#@)'&(+'"7-%%%A(781(8$% %MOA-% %F(-C+(8-% %*$7+'"7-% %O$@)'$-% %O$+=$$+-%
?11# );v& ;;v& Ycv& ,;v& ;,v&
<",$(7% ;bv& ;;v& X9d% e]d% ;;v&
B$,#(7&& 9]d% \ld% 9gd% )Bv& Lv&
! m0"&M6.--"(&7#(&0#4.'%&5"-6#(1.5A&H0:&.57#(/'-.#5&03'(.5A&?.l"("5-&.5&?.l"("5-&%'5A8'A"0&
! o"0.A5&("4#//"5?'-.#5&"5A.5"0&[ ]#("'5&80"(0Z&$(#/#-"&4#5H"(0'-.#5'%&-6""-0&
[ @"(/'5&80"(0Z&$(#/#-"&-6""-0&6.-3&miN0&
2011-10-05 WikiSym 2011 Closing Keynote 37
!+1/G'78%^')'781()%^,"?$,-%! O/$#(-'54"&9(#1"(0&
[ \-(84-8('%&3#%"0&SD8(-Ec)TC&N.H"r#8(5'%&Sa"((.5A&"-&'%E<bT&
! o"K5"&9.%.5A8'%&9(#1"(0&'0&m0"(0&63#&-6""-"?&.5&'&
$'.(&%'5A8'A"0&
! `'H"'-&
[ m5?"(+"0-./'-"?&?8"&-#&Y+6""1&-./"&%./.-&
[ pH"(+"0-./'-"?&?8"&-#&%'5A8'A"&?"-"4-.#5&"((#(0&
2011-10-05 WikiSym 2011 Closing Keynote 38
i1#6$,%"2%^')'781()%^,"?$,-%
E% J% P% I% S% D% K% F% G%
J% 140,730&
P% 488,545% 13,228&
I% 230,023& 4,825& 29,405&
S% 359,117& 10,139& 112,524& 36,068&
D% 150,041& 6,383& 30,855& 34,906& 30,916&
K% 19,722& 6,384& 906% 2,014& 1,109& 972%
F% 194,931& 10,463& 53,607& 34,586& 49,445& 33,568& 1,244&
G% 110,748& 6,053& 22,106& 21,471& 21,989& 22,162& 786% 24,763&
M% 148,365& 4,208& 31,184& 135,427&
31,967& 29,331& 1,518& 30,257& 18,301&
2011-10-05 WikiSym 2011 Closing Keynote 39
!C(,'78%MOA-%:&,"--%A(781(8$-%E% J% P% I% S% D% K% F% G% M%
E 3,013& 18,399% 985& 4,986& 1,144& 212& 1,791& 1,647& 540&
J% 3,013& 77& 37& 58& 29& 43& 59& 46& 18&
P 18,399% 77& 74& 1,644& 198& 2& 453& 168& 123&
I% 985& 37& 74& 67& 64& 1& 53& 38& 279&
S 4,986& 58& 1,644& 67& 139& 0% 286& 139& 53&
D 1,144& 29& 198& 64& 139& 2& 112& 126& 48&
K 212& 43& 2& 1& 0% 2& 3& 3& 1&
F% 1,791& 59& 453& 53& 286& 112& 3& 157& 53&
G 1,647& 46& 168& 38& 139& 126& 3& 157& 40&
M 540& 18& 123& 279& 53& 48& 1& 53& 40&
2011-10-05 WikiSym 2011 Closing Keynote 40
!C(,'78%F(-C+(8-%:&,"--%A(781(8$-%
E% J% P% I% S% D% K% F% G% M%
E% 8,178& 33,197% 14,969&
27,284& 6,685& 798& 9,410& 7,208& 5,517&
J% 8,178& 331& 135& 351& 218& 149& 352& 260& 100&
P% 33,197% 331& 535& 4,682& 604& 13% 1,231& 580& 400&
I% 14,969& 135& 535& 762& 684& 25& 713& 415& 6,046&
S% 27,284& 351& 4,682& 762& 819& 28& 1,468& 708& 463&
D% 6,685& 218& 604& 684& 819& 26& 851& 769& 424&
K% 798& 149& 13% 25& 28& 26& 25& 18& 20&
F% 9,410& 352& 1,231& 713& 1,468& 851& 25& 879& 411&
G% 7,208& 260& 580& 415& 708& 769& 18& 879& 265&
M% 5,517& 100& 400& 6,046& 463& 424& 20& 411& 265&
2011-10-05 WikiSym 2011 Closing Keynote 41
;#@)'&(+'"7-%! O5?.4'-#(0&4#55"4-.#5&0-("5A-3&9"-6""5&
%'5A8'A"0&[ _8/9"(&9.%.5A8'%&9(#1"(0&
[ J4-0&9(#1"('A"Z&03'(.5A&miN0&n&3'03-'A0&! G5A%.03&6"%%&4#55"4-"?&-#&#-3"(0C&'5?&/'2&
7854-.#5&'0&'&389&
! _""?&-#&./$(#H"&4(#00+%'5A8'A"&4#//85.4'-.#50&
? �2011-10-05 WikiSym 2011 Closing Keynote 42
>C(+%N'/%>$%A$(,7m%! M3"&`#//#5&M3("'?Z&
[ m-.%.s'-.#5&\#4.'%&\.A5'%0&7#(&N"'(5.5A&'5?&O57#(/'-.#5&J44"00&
[ 63"-3"(&.-&.0&.5H.0.9%"C&H.0.9%"C&'5?&'90-('4-"?:&
! M3"&G0-'9%.03/"5-&`#//#5&@(#85?&[ O/$%.4.-&`##(?.5'-.#5&
[ G*$%.4.-&`##(?.5'-.#5&[ _"A#-.'-.#5&
! fJ%%&4#%%"4-.H"&'4-.#50&'("&98.%-&4#//#5&A(#85?&'5?&.-0&'448/8%'-.#5:g&[ `%'(1&'5?&D("55'5C&;cc;&
2011-10-05 WikiSym 2011 Closing Keynote 43
B,(7/%M7'k$/%5C$",G%"2%!"&'()%R(,+'&'@(+'"7%
2011-10-05 WikiSym 2011 Closing Keynote 44
Scale! Time Unit! Band!
107 s! Months!
106 s! Weeks! Social!
105 s! Days!
104 s! Hours!
103 s! 10 min! Rational!
102 s! Minutes!
101 s! 10 seconds!
100 s! Seconds! Psychological!
10-1 s! 100 msec!
10-2 s! 10 msec! Biological!
5C(7?%G"1n%! 43.w'4/:#(A&
! 3--$ZXX"?43.:5"-&
2011-10-05 WikiSym 2011 Closing Keynote 45