WHAT’S IT ALL ABOUT?

Political campaigns

What are elections for?

• To determine who will hold governmental positions– Not all positions

• To maintain public control over the government– Throw the rascals out

• To re-legitimize the system and the regime– Government claim to consent of the governed– Elections as rituals

What are campaigns for?

To inform the public of what the government has been doing and to critique the performance of officials

To stir up excitement for the system, and for politics in general

To inform officials of the preferences of the electorate and to set priorities for action Agenda setting

Do elections do what they are supposed to do?

NOT ALWAYS

Many examples of politicians who have been found guilty of crimes were returned to office.

Candidates who are in other ways unfit are returned to office Candidates who are at death’s door, etc.

Do elections do what they are supposed to?

Incumbency determines Since World War II, 92% of incumbents who ran for

reelection were successful. (Wikipedia) However, high-quality challengers are not always

available Incumbents with serious problems may not run again

Advantages incumbent Congresspersons hold

Experience – an incumbent by definition is experienced. He or she has already won at least one election.

Franking – congressional privilege that allows congresspersons to send out mail to their constituents for free. It’s in the Constitution.

Free Media – local media like covering congressman. Furthermore, they can go on national TV shows, they have an office in Washington that can create media releases.

Advantages incumbent Congresspersons hold contd.

Money – congressmen bring federal spending into their local areas to benefit the district (which thus increases goodwill in the district for them).

Casework – when individual constituents have a problem and call their congressman. It’s an easy, non-controversial way of making voters happy. People helped (no matter what party) will be more likely to vote for him and they will tell their friends.

Campaign finance – officeholders have a big advantage over challengers because they are already in congress with a vote over legislation and thus interest groups will attempt to influence them (whatever their party). Wikipedia

Election outcomes

There are at least some scholars that argue that the outcome of elections does not seem to reflect public opinion Candidates are elected that appear to oppose majority

opinion on a wide range of topics Decisions based on emotion and/or peripheral issues

rather than rational self-interest, which is supposed to rule

Why NO Third Party Candidates?Americans want Name Recognition

Americans want to back a sure thing – even if they don’t really like it!

American’s FEAR “Wasting their Vote”

Peer pressure to back someone that their friends and family will agree with.

WHEN IT COMES TO VOTING – ARE AMERICANS REALLY INDEPENDENT?

Do campaigns do what they are supposed to do?

• Voters rarely know very much about most of the candidates on the ballot– Name recognition may determine winners

• Even when they are acquainted with candidates voters often do not know much about those seeking office– Few can actually identify candidate background, issue

positions, etc.• False beliefs common

– Assume policy agreement where none exists

Information gain

• A great deal of research indicates that members of the electorate gain only limited information about candidates during the campaign

• Much of what the public learns is questionable, inaccurate or biased

• Focus is often on peripheral cues rather than issues – Physical attractiveness, speaking tone, height– Kennedy / Nixon TV appearance as prime example.

Videos from “The Living Room Candidate”

http://www.livingroomcandidate.org/commercials/type/backfire

Information gain

Biased reception The same information gained about a favored

candidate and a disfavored candidate would be interpreted differently

Vote intention

Traditionally, there has been little change in vote intent during the campaign Most people’s votes can be predicted from

demographic information prior to the beginning of the campaign

Content of campaign communications

Distortion, untruthImages and symbolismPropaganda techniquesHooplaHow could anyone make an intelligent

decision based on all this junk?

Politics as marketing

The candidate is the ‘product’ What are the ‘attributes’ of the candidate?

A one-day ‘sale’ Date is predetermined

The monetary ‘price’ is zeroFar more competitive/antagonistic environ

than most ‘products’

Marketing strategy and political campaigns

Goal is to winUse methods developed for marketing

branded productsHistorical transition from product orientation

to sales orientation to marketing orientation

Marketing strategy

• Image/positioning– Limited by prior performance of candidate

• Market research– Polling

• Targeting– “Two campaigns”– Likely voters– Persuadable groups

• Communication channels– Interpersonal– Mediated– New media

• Message– “Product attributes”– Critique of opposition (far more prevalent in political

campaigns)

• Fundraising• PR– ‘Earned media’– Press relations

• Development of organization– Pre-existing organization in traditional marketing

campaigns

• GOTV

Image

Targeting

• Primaries v. general election• Voters v. non-voters– Talking to those who vote– Convincing those who are supportive to go to the polls

• Demographics• Persuasibility• Accessibility• Popular vote v. electoral college– Gore won popular vote

Communication channels

Interpersonal Face-to-face

Too time-consuming for major elected office Still the main means for local

Public meetings Speeches at gatherings Debates

Media TV ads still most significant

Lion’s share of campaign budgets in higher office Radio important for targeting

Latino Newspapers mainly for elite

New media Growing importance Innovative area Micro targeting

Message

Issue“Character”Positive v. negative toneIssues of distortion, dishonesty

Fundraising

• Classic model– PACs– Large donors, dinners, etc.– Large portion of candidate’s time personally soliciting

donations• Concern over undue influence

• New model– Obama

• Vast numbers of small donors/Internet

• Public funding (McCain/Feingold)– Limits on spending

• Other groups– 527 groups

PR

Media relations are tremendously important Spin

Interaction with candidateSupporters providing press with background,

etc.On-air punditsNon-news media

Development of organization

Obama v. Clinton Mass volunteer organizations Early preparation Online organizing

GOTV

Phone remindersTransporting likely supporters to the pollsRegistering potential votersTracking supporters