VFCA--change is good 2018€¦ · Source: “TOP 12 REASONS WHY PEOPLE RESIST CHANGE”. Rick...

17
4/10/2018 1 Sponsored by Change is good . . . You Go First ! SFFMA Fire Chief Development Program 2018‐1 Sponsored by 31 years fire service experience Harris County Fire Marshal Interim EMC for Harris County Asst. Chief, CyFair VFD (retired) Guest Instructor,TEEX Municipal School TXTF1 Logistics Manager TEEX Annual School Advisory Board Lone Star College Advisory Council TX Rural Fire Advisory Council 24 years private sector experience Sponsored by Why change things? Why do people resist change? What is the “change cycle”? How to successfully manage change.

Transcript of VFCA--change is good 2018€¦ · Source: “TOP 12 REASONS WHY PEOPLE RESIST CHANGE”. Rick...

Page 1: VFCA--change is good 2018€¦ · Source: “TOP 12 REASONS WHY PEOPLE RESIST CHANGE”. Rick Torben, 2011. Pinnacle of Inflated Expectations Trough of Disillusionment Plateau of

4/10/2018

1

Sponsored by 

Change is good . . .You Go First !

SFFMA Fire Chief Development Program

2018‐1

Sponsored by 

• 31 years fire service experience

• Harris County Fire Marshal

• Interim EMC for Harris County

• Asst. Chief, Cy‐Fair VFD (retired)

• Guest Instructor, TEEX Municipal School 

• TX‐TF1 Logistics Manager

• TEEX Annual School Advisory Board

• Lone Star College Advisory Council

• TX Rural Fire Advisory Council

• 24 years private sector experience

Sponsored by 

• Why change things?

• Why do people resist change?

• What is the “change cycle”?

• How to successfully manage change.

Page 2: VFCA--change is good 2018€¦ · Source: “TOP 12 REASONS WHY PEOPLE RESIST CHANGE”. Rick Torben, 2011. Pinnacle of Inflated Expectations Trough of Disillusionment Plateau of

4/10/2018

2

Sponsored by 

Sponsored by 

Sponsored by 

Page 3: VFCA--change is good 2018€¦ · Source: “TOP 12 REASONS WHY PEOPLE RESIST CHANGE”. Rick Torben, 2011. Pinnacle of Inflated Expectations Trough of Disillusionment Plateau of

4/10/2018

3

Sponsored by 

Sponsored by 

Sponsored by 

Page 4: VFCA--change is good 2018€¦ · Source: “TOP 12 REASONS WHY PEOPLE RESIST CHANGE”. Rick Torben, 2011. Pinnacle of Inflated Expectations Trough of Disillusionment Plateau of

4/10/2018

4

Sponsored by 

Sources:  “Population Change by County: 2000‐2010”. Glenn Hegar Texas Comptroller of Public Accounts, 2015. http://www.texasahead.org/map/rural_areas.php

“The 2015 Millennial Majority Workforce: Study Results”.  Elance‐oDesk. October 22, 2014http://www.slideshare.net/oDesk/2015‐millennial‐majority‐workforce

• Only 17%of Texas is rural

• Or is it 70%

• 45%of  the workforce are millenials

• A Larger Cohort

• Different Priorities

• The First Digital Natives, Social And Connected

• Less Money to Spend, Encumbered with debt

Sponsored by 

Sponsored by 

• Only 23%of bosses want to supervise others

• 84%don’t know how to measure performance

• Only 37%of staff know there is a strategic plan

• Only 15%believe change is well‐managed 

Source:  “Social Knows: Employee Engagement Statistics (August 2011 Edition)”.  Elizabeth Lupfer.  August 8, 2011 http://www.thesocialworkplace.com/2011/08/08/social‐knows‐employee‐engagement‐statistics‐august‐2011‐edition/

Page 5: VFCA--change is good 2018€¦ · Source: “TOP 12 REASONS WHY PEOPLE RESIST CHANGE”. Rick Torben, 2011. Pinnacle of Inflated Expectations Trough of Disillusionment Plateau of

4/10/2018

5

Sponsored by 

• About 50%of your team gripes about their job

• About 75% say their boss is the cause of job stress 

Source:  “The Leader You Don’t Like Doesn’t Like You Either“ by Dan Rockwell, April 19, 2015https://leadershipfreak.wordpress.com/2015/04/19/the‐leader‐you‐dont‐like‐doesnt‐like‐you‐either/

Sponsored by 

• Crisis management

• Gap management

• Other reasons

Sponsored by 

Managers OfficialsProviders

Source:  “From Buddy to Boss: Effective Fire Service Leadership”, by Chase Sargent, 2006.

The Public

Page 6: VFCA--change is good 2018€¦ · Source: “TOP 12 REASONS WHY PEOPLE RESIST CHANGE”. Rick Torben, 2011. Pinnacle of Inflated Expectations Trough of Disillusionment Plateau of

4/10/2018

6

Sponsored by Source:  adapted from “Event Management: Reactive, Proactive or Predictive?”. Larry Dragich, 2012.

• Anticipate opportunities

• Forecast results

• Strategic Planning

• Respond to failures

• Measure output

• Historic Planning

• Respond to needs

• Measure Outcomes 

• Tactical Planning

Sponsored by Source:  “From Buddy to Boss: Effective Fire Service Leadership”, by Chase Sargent, 2006.

85%10%

5%

Frontline Members

  Operate the System

  Improve the System

  Create Change

50% 40%

10%

Middle Managers

  Operate the System

  Improve the System

  Create Change

5%

20%

75%

Senior Staff

  Operate the System

  Improve the System

  Create Change

Sponsored by Source:  “Building the Right Skill Set”, HCFMO, by Mike Montgomery, 2012.

70%

20%

10%

Frontline Members

Technical

People

Conceptual

40%30%

30%

Middle Managers

Technical

People

Conceptual

10%

50%

40%

Senior Staff

Technical

People

Conceptual

Page 7: VFCA--change is good 2018€¦ · Source: “TOP 12 REASONS WHY PEOPLE RESIST CHANGE”. Rick Torben, 2011. Pinnacle of Inflated Expectations Trough of Disillusionment Plateau of

4/10/2018

7

Sponsored by 

Sponsored by 

• Inertia

• Resistance

• Reaction

Source:  NEWTON’S LAWS of MOTION by Georgia Louviere , 10/24/06http://teachertech.rice.edu/Participants/louviere/index.html

Sponsored by 

Source:  “Sources of Power: How people make decisions”, MIT Press, Cambridge, MA, Gary Klein, © 1998

• Quick size‐up

• Recognize past outcomes

• Decide

• Act

• Evaluate

Page 8: VFCA--change is good 2018€¦ · Source: “TOP 12 REASONS WHY PEOPLE RESIST CHANGE”. Rick Torben, 2011. Pinnacle of Inflated Expectations Trough of Disillusionment Plateau of

4/10/2018

8

Sponsored by 

GoreFrago

Pence Alleyn

April 1970

Sponsored by 

• Changes in procedures and training

• Spent brass

• Traffic stops vs. felony stops

• Arrest procedures

• New protective tools issued to all officers

• Speedloaders

• Standard ammo

• Body armor 

Source:  “Badges of Honor: 1970‐1979”, California Highway Patrol.© 2015http://www.chp.ca.gov/memorial/newhall.html

Sponsored by 

• Changes in procedures and training

• Communications equipment operation

• Crew integrity

• IDLH operating conditions

• New protective tools issued to personnel

• Protective clothing

• Accountability aids

• Thermal Image Camera 

Source:  “Badges of Honor: 1970‐1979”, California Highway Patrol.© 2015http://www.chp.ca.gov/memorial/newhall.html

Page 9: VFCA--change is good 2018€¦ · Source: “TOP 12 REASONS WHY PEOPLE RESIST CHANGE”. Rick Torben, 2011. Pinnacle of Inflated Expectations Trough of Disillusionment Plateau of

4/10/2018

9

Sponsored by Photo By Johnny Hanson / Houston Chronicle

Sponsored by 

Sponsored by Source:  “The Change Resistant Myth” by Kimberly Alyn, PhD.© 2011http://www.firehouse.com/article/10464224/the‐change‐resistance‐myth?page=2

Page 10: VFCA--change is good 2018€¦ · Source: “TOP 12 REASONS WHY PEOPLE RESIST CHANGE”. Rick Torben, 2011. Pinnacle of Inflated Expectations Trough of Disillusionment Plateau of

4/10/2018

10

Sponsored by 

Sponsored by 

TIME

EXPEC

TATIONS

Source:  “TOP 12 REASONS WHY PEOPLE RESIST CHANGE”.  Rick Torben, 2011.

Trigger

New Set Point

Sponsored by 

Negative

Positive

Expectation

Expectation

TIME

EXPEC

TATIONS

Source:  “TOP 12 REASONS WHY PEOPLE RESIST CHANGE”.  Rick Torben, 2011.

Trigger

New Confidence

Page 11: VFCA--change is good 2018€¦ · Source: “TOP 12 REASONS WHY PEOPLE RESIST CHANGE”. Rick Torben, 2011. Pinnacle of Inflated Expectations Trough of Disillusionment Plateau of

4/10/2018

11

Sponsored by 

TIME

EXPEC

TATIONS

Source:  “TOP 12 REASONS WHY PEOPLE RESIST CHANGE”.  Rick Torben, 2011.

Pinnacle of InflatedExpectations

Trough of Disillusionment

Plateau of Productivity

Slope of EnlightenmentTrigger

Sponsored by 

Rejection

Check-out

EXPEC

TATIONS

Trigger

Source:  “Change is Good – You Go First”.  Montgomery, 2015.

Crisis

Depression

Confusion

AngerDenial

TIME

Sponsored by 

EXPEC

TATIONS

Trigger

Source:  “Change is Good – You Go First”.  Montgomery, 2015.

TIME

Page 12: VFCA--change is good 2018€¦ · Source: “TOP 12 REASONS WHY PEOPLE RESIST CHANGE”. Rick Torben, 2011. Pinnacle of Inflated Expectations Trough of Disillusionment Plateau of

4/10/2018

12

Sponsored by 

EXPEC

TATIONS

Source:  “Change is Good – You Go First”.  Montgomery, 2015.

TriggerTrigger

Trigger

TIME

Sponsored by 

Sponsored by 

Rejection

Check-out

EXPEC

TATIONS

Trigger

Source:  “Change is Good – You Go First”.  Montgomery, 2015.

Crisis

Depression

Confusion

AngerDenial

TIME

Page 13: VFCA--change is good 2018€¦ · Source: “TOP 12 REASONS WHY PEOPLE RESIST CHANGE”. Rick Torben, 2011. Pinnacle of Inflated Expectations Trough of Disillusionment Plateau of

4/10/2018

13

Sponsored by 

Sponsored by Source:  “Peopleware: Productive Projects and Teams ”.  DeMarco, Liste, 1999.

Blindly LoyalAsk no questionsBlindly Loyal

Ask no questions

QuestionersQuestioners

Skeptics“Show Me”Skeptics

“Show Me”

Passive Fence‐Sitters“What’s In It for Me?”Passive Fence‐Sitters“What’s In It for Me?”

OpposedFear of change

OpposedFear of change

OpposedFear of Loss of Power

OpposedFear of Loss of Power

Militantly opposedUndermine & DestroyMilitantly opposed

Undermine & Destroy

Sponsored by 

• Point  out  what  is staying  the  same

• Identify  things  of  value to  be  preserved 

4• Discuss what you believe to  be  their  concerns 

• Describe how you will help  them  to  overcome their  concerns 

3

• Describe  the  benefits  of  the  future  state

• Explain  how  we  will  get  there  ‐‐ together

2• Convey  a  heightened sense  of  urgency

• Convey  a  compelling need  for change

1

Page 14: VFCA--change is good 2018€¦ · Source: “TOP 12 REASONS WHY PEOPLE RESIST CHANGE”. Rick Torben, 2011. Pinnacle of Inflated Expectations Trough of Disillusionment Plateau of

4/10/2018

14

“Would you tell me, please, which way I ought to go from here?”

“That all depends on where you want to get to,” said the Cat.

“I don’t remember where ---” said Alice.

“Then it really doesn’t matter which way you go,” said the Cat.

Source:  “Alice’s Adventures in Wonderland”, Lewis Carroll. 1865.

Sponsored by 

HCFMO

Source:  “Good to Great”, Jim Collins, © 2005

• Get the RIGHT PEOPLE on the Bus

• Get Everyone in the RIGHT SEAT

• DRIVE

• From time to time, CHECK THE MAP

Sponsored by Source:  adapted from the U.S. Coast Guard

Page 15: VFCA--change is good 2018€¦ · Source: “TOP 12 REASONS WHY PEOPLE RESIST CHANGE”. Rick Torben, 2011. Pinnacle of Inflated Expectations Trough of Disillusionment Plateau of

4/10/2018

15

Sponsored by 

world . . .

be thechange

you wishto see in the

-- gandhi

Sponsored by Change is Inevitable, Growth is Optional . . . Don’t Be a Victim

Sponsored by 

Page 16: VFCA--change is good 2018€¦ · Source: “TOP 12 REASONS WHY PEOPLE RESIST CHANGE”. Rick Torben, 2011. Pinnacle of Inflated Expectations Trough of Disillusionment Plateau of

4/10/2018

16

Sponsored by 

Sponsored by Source:  irldefender.files.wordpress.com, 2012.

Sponsored by Source:  irldefender.files.wordpress.com, 2012.

Page 17: VFCA--change is good 2018€¦ · Source: “TOP 12 REASONS WHY PEOPLE RESIST CHANGE”. Rick Torben, 2011. Pinnacle of Inflated Expectations Trough of Disillusionment Plateau of

4/10/2018

17

Sponsored by