UTTAR PRADESH STATE ROADS PROJECT Under IBRD Loan No. …Final).pdf · Reforms in Road Sector of...
Transcript of UTTAR PRADESH STATE ROADS PROJECT Under IBRD Loan No. …Final).pdf · Reforms in Road Sector of...
PUBLIC WORKS DEPARTMENT Government of Uttar Pradesh, India
UTTAR PRADESH STATE ROADS PROJECT Under IBRD Loan No. 4684-IN
Technical Assistance for Implementation of Institutional Reforms in the Road Sector of Uttar Pradesh
REVIEW REPORT ON IMPLEMENTATION OF IT-BASED BUDGETING AND COSTING SYSTEM ACROSS PWD WITH APPROPRIATE CONTROLS AND REPORTING FUNCTIONS
(FINAL)
Report No. 16
May 2008
LEA International Ltd., Canada in joint venture with
LEA Associates South Asia Pvt. Ltd., India in association with
Ministry of Transportation of Ontario, Canada
Technical Assistance for Implementation of Institutional Reforms in Road Sector of Uttar Pradesh Report No. 16
May 2008 i
TABLE OF CONTENTS 1. BACKGROUND ............................................................................................................................... 1
2. INTRODUCTION .............................................................................................................................. 3
3. REVIEW OF THE EXISTING BUDGETING AND COST CONTROL SYSTEM IN UPPWD .......... 4 3.1 EXISTING BUDGETING PROCEDURE ............................................................................. 4
3.2 EMERGENCY WORKS ...................................................................................................... 7 3.2.1. Natural Calamity ..................................................................................................... 7 3.2.2. Works Related to VIP Visits ................................................................................... 8
3.3 SANCTIONS AND GRANT NUMBERS .............................................................................. 8
3.4 DEPOSIT WORKS ............................................................................................................ 10
3.5 DEFICIENCIES IN THE EXISTING BUDGETING AND COST CONTROL SYSTEM ..... 10
4. OBJECTIVES OF IT BASED BUDGETING AND COST CONTROL SYSTEMS ......................... 12
5. SUGGESTIONS FOR IT BASED BUDGETING SYSTEM ACROSS PWD WITH APPROPRIATE CONTROLS AND REPORTING FUNCTION ................................................................................ 13
5.1 BUDGET SUB-SYSTEM ................................................................................................... 14
5.2 PROPOSED FORMS FOR BUDGET SUB-SYSTEM ...................................................... 16
6. PROPOSED IT BASED COST CONTROL SYSTEM IN SUPPORT OF STANDARD COSTING 29
6.1 COST CENTRES FOR OUT-SOURCED CONTRACTS .................................................. 29
6.2 COST CENTRES FOR IN-HOUSE CONTRACTS ........................................................... 30
6.3 ANALYSIS OF COST INFORMATION ............................................................................. 31 6.3.1. Analysis of Cost Information Arising From Out-Sourced Contracts ..................... 31 6.3.2. Analysis of Cost Information Arising From In-House Contracts........................... 32
6.4 STANDARD COSTING ..................................................................................................... 32
6.5 REGISTER OF WORKS ................................................................................................... 33
7. IMPLEMENTATION PROCESS .................................................................................................... 34
8. CONCLUSION ............................................................................................................................... 35
9. PRESENTATION TO PROJECT STEERING COMMITTEE ......................................................... 36
LIST OF TABLES
Table 1 : GoUP Standard Forms for Budgeting Purposes .......................................................................... 11 Table 2 : Group Wise Proposed Budget Sub-System ................................................................................ 18
LIST OF FIGURES
Figure No. 1 : Flow Diagram for Proposed Forms ...................................................................................... 17
Technical Assistance for Implementation of Institutional Reforms in Road Sector of Uttar Pradesh Report No. 16
May 2008 ii
ANNEXURES
Annexure – 1 : Existing Budget Forms
Annexure – 2 : Proposed Budget Forms
Annexure – 3 : Proposed Costing Forms
Glossary AE Assistant Engineer
BM Budget Manual
CCL Cash Credit Limit
CCIH Cost Control In House
CCOS Cost Control Out Sourced Contracts
CE Chief Engineer
CDO Chief Development Officer
DA Dearness Allowance
DCL Deposit Credit Limit
DDO Drawing and Disbursing Officer
EE Executive Engineer
E-N-C Engineer-in-Chief
FMS Financial Management System
GO Government Order
GoUP Government of Uttar Pradesh
HDM-4 Highway Development and Management-4
HOD Head of the Department
HQ Head Quarters
JE Junior Engineer
LTC Leave Travel Concession
MDR Major District Road
MLA Member of Legislative Assembly
MP Member of Parliament
NH National Highway
NABARD National Bank for Agriculture and Rural Development
ODR Other District Road
PMGSY Pradhan Mantri Gram Sadak Yajana
PWD Public Works Department
RMMS Road Maintenance Management System
SE Superintending Engineer
SH State Highway
SRP State Road Project
TCS Tata Consultancy Services
TO Treasury Officer
UP Uttar Pradesh
UPPWD Uttar Pradesh Public Works Department
UPSHA Uttar Pradesh State Highway Authority
VR Village Road
Technical Assistance for Implementation of Institutional Reforms in Road Sector of Uttar Pradesh Report No. 16
May 2008 1
1. BACKGROUND
A Policy Development and Institutional Study for UP PWD was undertaken by TCE and a Final Report published in June 20021. One of the subjects of the Study was an ‘Effective and standardized PWD wide budgeting and costing system’.
The Final Report listed the following weaknesses in the UP PWD budgeting system:
1. Budgeting system currently followed is line item budget where action control is the motive.
2. Budgets are used as compliance monitoring tools for spending limits and physical progress.
3. Hindrances in Budget preparation due to non availability of relevant data
4. 80% of the budget is allocated to continuing works and still they do not provoke cost minimization or better contract management.
5. Cash budgeting is not in place in the Divisions.
In order to mitigate theses deficiencies the TCE Report made the following recommendations:
a. Budgets to account for contingencies and strategies dealing with them.
b. Budgets to be continuously revised and revalidated against the actual expenditure and initiate corrective actions with each revalidation.
c. The budgeting system should facilitate the process of decision making, therefore the system be designed to serve the following:
• Authorization of actions and spending limits, delegation of responsibilities
• Forecasting and financial planning of the PWD operating plan
• Coordinating mechanism
• Means to motivate the organization for cost and quality
• Performance evaluation tool by setting standards and benchmarks
d. Improve the budgeting process through periodical review and analysis of the feedback of the implementation from the field.
e. Introduce cash budgeting at Circle level. Cash budgets have to be collated for the state at PWD HQ.
f. Revision of budgets and variances with respect to new factors like cost minimization, output quality, and contract management
g. With the help of cost accounting data, bench mark standard costs across the whole state.
h. Systematic data collection in consonance with the budgeting requirements and proper follow up.
i. Budgeting system to help in prioritizing the works.
j. Evolve a comprehensive financial management and budgeting system
1 Policy Support and Institutional Development Study: Final report June 2002 by TCE Consulting Engineers Ltd, TATA Consulting Services and Sir Owen Williams Innovestment Ltd.
Technical Assistance for Implementation of Institutional Reforms in Road Sector of Uttar Pradesh Report No. 16
May 2008 2
Action Milestone
Based on the TCE recommendations the GoUP has targeted the milestone “Implement IT Based budgeting and costing system across PWD with appropriate controls and reporting functions”
The PWD awarded a contract for the computerisation of certain aspects of their accounting system2. The end result was confused but one thing certain: the computer program written for the PWD does not function. There would appear to be a number of reasons for this. It is difficult in retrospect to accurately determine the reasons for failure but some of them, listed below, are given in the hope that when computerisation of the financial management system takes place lessons can be learnt from past failures.
• It would seem that having awarded the contract the PWD had little or no close involvement in the development of the computer program
• input data for testing the program was incomplete
• there are problems with entering data - this should have been determined when attempting to enter data in the first place
Although the platform on which the program was written is now obsolete it is understood that it can still be supported and could be made to function.
2 Agreement for Computerisation of UPPWD on a Turnkey Basis with Tata Consultancy Services (TCS), 26/07/2001
Technical Assistance for Implementation of Institutional Reforms in Road Sector of Uttar Pradesh Report No. 16
May 2008 3
2. INTRODUCTION
The title of this Report assumes that an IT Based Budgeting and Costing System is in place in the PWD. This is not the case. Although TCS carried out some work in this area, as referred to in the previous Section, the computer program does not function. However as part of their work TCS did prepare a software requirement specification for their proposed budgeting system. But this system did not incorporate any form of cost control, or cost centres for decision making purposes.
This Report sets out a proposed budgeting and cost control system together with proposals for the establishment of cost centres as an aid to decision making. This Report also includes proposals for standard types of forms which can be used for budgeting and cost control.
The budgeting process involves compilation of the funding requirement for Plan and Non-Plan works to be undertaken during the following financial year. Plan works relate to new construction works whereas Non-Plan basically relates to maintenance, emergency works, and establishment.
The budget is prepared by PWD Headquarters in September / October for the following Financial Year. It is prepared on the basis of all sanctioned on-going works and proposed new works, including widening / strengthening of roads, rehabilitation / reconstruction of roads and bridges, and maintenance / repair works for roads and bridges. The budget, for Plan and Non-Plan Works, is based on Head Wise, Scheme Wise, Project Wise reports and demands for funds arising in the Divisions and submitted to PWD HQ through Circles and Zones. PWD HQ compiles these budgets requests and submits them to the GoUP.
Details of the sanctioned budget are forwarded to the PWD Engineer-in-Chief who is responsible for the allotment (allocation) of the various budgets to the Zones, Circles, and Divisions.
Roads and related construction activities in UP are funded by various sources, including funds from external funding agencies such World Bank, Asian Development Bank, JBIC, and from internal funding agencies like NABARD, and State Road Funds. In addition State funds are provided for activities such as widening and strengthening of existing roads, and maintenance of all existing roads in the State of UP. The Central Government schemes of National Highways and PMGSY are not part of UP PWD annual budget. Funds for some rural roads are made available to the PWD as Deposit Works through the District Magistrate.
It has become essential to review and reform the budgetary control procedures for UP PWD, which is the primary agency for implementing and monitoring road construction, and maintenance related, activities.
This Report describes the detailed nature of input from the existing PWD budgeting procedures, and detailed output. The Report not only includes comments on the existing budget and costing procedures in PWD, but provides a revised and improved approach to same, together with a series of forms which can be used in the budgeting procedures and costing process.
Technical Assistance for Implementation of Institutional Reforms in Road Sector of Uttar Pradesh Report No. 16
May 2008 4
3. REVIEW OF THE EXISTING BUDGETING AND COST CONTROL SYSTEM IN UPPWD
3.1 EXISTING BUDGETING PROCEDURE
There are two components to the PWD annual budget: one is known as Plan Budget and the other as Non-Plan Budget. Works categorised under the heading of Plan include new construction and widening. Strengthening can also come under this category, especially if it classed as 'reconstruction'.
Non-Plan includes all maintenance activities and budgets for establishment which cover staff salaries, vehicles, and buildings. Strengthening of a road pavement can also come under this category especially if it is classed as 'rehabilitation'.
The current process of preparing annual budgets, which with respect to road maintenance is not needs based, begins with the identification of locations where road related work is considered to be required. The locations are identified in the following manner:
i. Members of public representatives namely, MLA's, MLC's, ex-public representatives of the area, and 'Gram Pradhans' apply to the State Government or the PWD municipal bodies, giving details of locations where they consider there is a need for new roads, and strengthening / widening of the existing roads, or where heavy maintenance / patch works are needed. This is under plan Budget. For resurfacing or renewal works at a specified time interval the annual budget is prepared for the entire road network in the state under Non Plan. Routine maintenance (including patch/pot holes repair) and special repair / rehabilitation of badly damaged stretches of roads also come under Non Plan.
ii. The UP PWD has conducted condition and other surveys in support of maintenance and other works. But these condition surveys have lapsed and have insufficient detail on which to base any maintenance forecasts. The PWD also prepare plans for target areas based on State Government policies and guidelines.
Based on the above two sources the PWD prepares its annual budget forecast for Plan Works and Non-Plan Works.
i. Plan budget proposals are for works which include construction of roads and new asset creation funded through Central Government or State Government, etc. These budget proposals, once sanctioned by State Government, can be carried forward for the next year and do not require fresh approval from State Government. These Plan works are sanctioned under different schemes such as – District Sector, State Sector, NABARD Scheme (Rural Infrastructure Development Fund), State Road Project (World Bank Funded Scheme), State Road Fund (Plan), Ambedkar Gram Vikas Scheme, Purvanchal and Bundelkhand Vikas Nidhi etc.
Technical Assistance for Implementation of Institutional Reforms in Road Sector of Uttar Pradesh Report No. 16
May 2008 5
ii. Non-Plan budget proposals are for works which include Maintenance and Special Repair / Rehabilitation works. Budgets sanctioned for the Non-Plan works must, except in special cases when it can be carried forward to the next financial year, be spent during the same year of sanction. The unspent portion cannot be carried forward, and is required to be surrendered. But this fund can be utilised or re-appropriated, on other Non-Plan works during the same financial year subject to approval from the State Government.
Both Planned and Non-Planned budget proposals require sanction through a voting process in the Legislative Assembly / Council. PWD budgets are classified as follows:
i. 'Voted' Budgets, which are approved by vote in Legislative Assembly / Council. These will be:
(a) original or
(b) supplementary. If the original budget falls short of funds, supplementary budgets can be submitted to Legislative Assembly / Council for approval.
ii. 'State Contingency Budgets', which are funded through Chief Minister’s contingency funds for emergency needs. However the use of these funds requires approval and have to be reimbursed out of the budget for the following year.
iii. 'Dovetailing Budgets' describes the situation under which specific works, included in the Plan budget, such as the construction of new roads, may include some components that are funded by other Departments.
iv. 'Charged Expenditure' describes expenditure which is not to be submitted to the vote of Legislative Assembly under the provisions of the Constitution.
v. 'Cost Sharing' describes works that are executed by the PWD on a cost sharing basis in which part of the project costs are shared with another Department. Such examples include a railway over-bridge, and roads leading to industrial areas.
Following sanction by the GoUP the first three types of budgets are allotted by the Engineer-in-Chief who issues instructions to the Finance Controller regarding release of the Cash Credit Limits to the Divisions. Copies of these instructions are sent to the Treasury Office of the concerned District, to the Zone Chief Engineer, and to the Superintending Engineer in the Circle. The funds are released on a Project by Project basis breaking down the allotted sum for the financial year into quarterly allowances.
Where the budget proposal is 'Scheme Wise' (which may include a number of Projects) and the sanctioned sum is less than the required total amount to complete all the Projects making up the Scheme, which is the normal case, budgets are allocated using the following principles:
20% of amount goes to new projects
80% is allocated to on-going projects prioritised as follows:
100% is allotted to works which are more than 75% complete
Out of the remaining funds preference is given to those works which are between 50% and 75% complete.
Any remaining funds are allotted to those works, which are less than 50% complete
Technical Assistance for Implementation of Institutional Reforms in Road Sector of Uttar Pradesh Report No. 16
May 2008 6
Should some variation in allotment be required, once the sanctioned budgets have been allocated to the Divisions, the request for a variation together with justification for same are sent to the Engineer-in-Chief through the Circle, and the Zone. Form BM -15 is used for this purpose.
Based on the annual allocation of funds the Cash Credit Limit is allocated to the Divisions on a quarterly basis as detailed below:
35% of the total yearly allocation is made for the 1st quarter of the year
15% for the 2nd quarter
35% for the 3rd quarter and
15% for the 4th quarter
However this allocation pattern is flexible and actual allocation may depend on the urgency of the works.
Apart from budget allocations for work related matters the budget for Non-Plan items, such as establishment and contingencies expenditure, is allotted to the Divisions / Drawing and Disbursement Officer’s according to the respective requirements of the Division. If the allocated budget for a Division is in excess of actual requirements the excess budget allocation must be surrendered and returned to the State Government through the Engineer-in-Chief.
Budget re-appropriation: Sometimes the allocated funds for the execution of Projects may be insufficient to cover the cost of work actually done, or sometimes low priority works are accorded a higher priority. The former case requires an increase in funds with the latter case calls for a surrender of funds. Under these circumstances it is possible to transfer savings from works under the same Scheme to cover increased budget requirements on other works. This re-appropriation request is generated from the Division through Circle and Zone offices, to PWD Headquarters who submit the request to GoUP for their approval.
On a monthly basis the Divisions submit progress reports, Scheme Wise and Project Wise, to PWD HQ via the Superintending Engineer in the Circle. These monthly progress reports give details of physical and financial progress of all works undertaken in the Division. The financial figures record actual expenditure against budgeted / allocated funds for all works undertaken during the financial year. Monitoring of progress is carried out for all works on a monthly basis by the Superintending Engineer in the Circle and Chief Engineer in the Zone.
These reports are monitored Scheme Wise on a monthly basis by the Engineer-in-Chief to give details of budget allotments, budget expenditure, and physical progress of all works carried out. These reports are categorised under different headings such as District Plan, State Plan (General), State Road Fund, State Road Project (SRP II), Special Government aided package, and Border Area Development Programme, etc,
Deposit Works: The PWD executes some works against funds from other Government Agencies or Ministries such as Vidhayaks and Sansads. These works can be sub-divided as follows:
Technical Assistance for Implementation of Institutional Reforms in Road Sector of Uttar Pradesh Report No. 16
May 2008 7
1. Works sanctioned under the budgets of other Departments but with PWD as executing agency. The funds for such schemes are allocated by the GoUP to the concerned District Magistrate or Chief Development Officer. Allotment is made by cheque or Bank draft to the concerned Division which then deposits it in the Treasury, hence the name 'Deposit Credit Limit' (DCL). The Division must then submit details of work to be done to the Superintending Engineer, along with the sanctioned amount and the allotment. Once the Superintending Engineer is satisfied with the submissions made the DCL is issued to the Division.
2. For small works requested by different utility service providers such as the Power Corporation, Bharat Sanchar Nigam Limited, Jal Nigam and Nagar Nigam etc. the required fund is deposited in advance in the Division by the concerned utility service. This repair / restoration work is carried out by the Division as a ‘deposit work’ after getting the DCL from the Superintending Engineer in the same manner as stated in 1. above.
3. Maintenance and flood damage repair works to the National Highways is executed by the concerned PWD NH Division against the amount of funds made available by the Government of India to the CE (NH) UP PWD through the GoUP. For this purpose funds are made available through Bank draft to the Accountant General of Uttar Pradesh against which the Finance Controller, under the instruction of Engineer-in-Chief, issues the DCL.
Supplementary Budget: When it is found during the financial year that additional funds are needed for successful completion of a scheme / project a supplementary demand is prepared. This provides details Scheme wise / Project Wise giving full justification and the position of expenditure against the allocation already made during the financial year. This is called the 'supplementary budget' and is required to be passed in the Legislative Assembly / Council.
3.2 EMERGENCY WORKS
Unforeseen or emergency works are required to be undertaken by the PWD for which there is no provision in the PWD Budget. This creates a very serious situation as well as the financial irregularity Such works categorised as below :-
3.2.1. Natural Calamity
When severe damage is caused to the roads and structures as the result of heavy floods and monsoon, repairs to such damaged portions/structures need to be carried out so that disruption to the traffic is minimised. For such emergency repairs there is no provision in the PWD Budget. But the general provision for damages caused to crops, houses, roads, bunds, canals, buildings or schools and colleges, electric poles and equipment etc. is covered in the budget of the Revenue Department. However it takes 18 months or 2 years for PWD to get the funds.
The end result is that the repairs are carried out by the PWD using funds that were sanctioned for other purposes.
Technical Assistance for Implementation of Institutional Reforms in Road Sector of Uttar Pradesh Report No. 16
May 2008 8
3.2.2. Works Related to VIP Visits
Different types of works are required to be done by PWD Executive Engineers in the Divisions under the instructions of District Magistrate and Superintendent of Police in the name of security for VIP visits. Sometimes barricades temporary works, such as rostrum, are required. For such works there is no provision in the PWD budget.
The end result is that funds are made available by PWD from those that were sanctioned for other works. This not only has an adverse effect on project progress but can result in a very serious audit objection by the audit party of the Accountant General.
3.3 SANCTIONS AND GRANT NUMBERS
Grant No. 58
In PWD the sanction / allocation of funds relating to construction, upgradation, improvement, and maintenance of the roads is accorded by GoUP in its budget under Grant No. 58, mainly under the following Major Head of Accounts.
i. 5054 Capital Outlay - PLAN ii. 3054 Maintenance - NON-PLAN
Sanction for each individual work / project is accorded by the GoUP on the basis of Preliminary Estimates submitted by the Divisions through the Circles and Zones to PWD HQ. Following sanction by the GoUP the whole, or part of, the project cost is released in the allocation of funds during the financial year. Any remaining sum is subsequently released as per demand or availability in the Budget provision.
Funds for the special repair of roads on account of damage caused by heavy floods and rains are allocated under the Head 2245 - Special repair and maintenance - Non-Plan. This type of repair work is also known as “Special Repair to Monsoon Damages (SRMD). The funds for such works are made available by the Revenue Department to the concerned District Magistrate. In turn the District Magistrate should make these funds available on the basis of reports / statements regarding the repairs undertaken. The problem with this system is the inordinate delay taken by the District Magistrate to reimburse the PWD.
Sometimes in case of urgency and emergency, and in the absence of non availability of funds or non provision in the budget, the allocation is made by raising CONTINGENCY under the Head 8000 - CONTINGENCY. This fund is subsequently recouped in the next budget to be passed by the legislature.
Grant No. 57
The sanction / allocation of funds relating to construction, reconstruction, rehabilitation and maintenance of structure (bridges, rail over bridges, under bridges, and flyovers) is accorded by GoUP in its budget under Grant No. 57 mainly under 2 major Head of Accounts:-
i. 5054 Capital Outlay - PLAN
ii. 3054 Maintenance - NON-PLAN
Technical Assistance for Implementation of Institutional Reforms in Road Sector of Uttar Pradesh Report No. 16
May 2008 9
Funds for the special repair of structures on account of damages due to heavy floods and rains are allocated under the Head 2245- Special repair and maintenance- Non-Plan.
All establishment related expenditure i.e. for payment of salaries and allowances of the entire staff of PWD, wages of permanent gang labour, expenditure on training etc., funds are allocated under Grant No 54. All the above allocations are related to Major Head of Accounts 2059 PW - Non-Plan.
Grant No. 54
Under Grant No. 54, budget provision for Research and Development is under the Head 2059 - Plan.
Grant Ho. 55
The Construction and Maintenance of Buildings budget provision is made in Grant No. 55. The major head wise details are as follows:-
1. Non-Residential Buildings (Charged)
(a) Original Construction…….. Head of Account 4059
(b) Maintenance………………. Head of Account 2059
For Non Residential Buildings (Voted)
(a) Construction………………..Head of Account 4059
(b) Repair and maintenance.…Head of Account 2059
2. Residential Buildings (Charged)
(a) Original Construction…….. Head of Account 4216
(b) Maintenance……………….Head of Account 2216
For Non-Residential Buildings (Voted)
(a) Construction………………..Head of Account 4216
(b) Repair and maintenance.…Head of Account 2216
Grant. No. 56
Works of special areas are sanctioned and funds allocated under budget Grant No. 56 under the following Head of Accounts:-
(a) Revenue Head 2575 - Activities of other special Areas (b) Capital Head 4575 - Activities of special areas on capital outlay.
Grant. No. 83
Some works related to special areas are sanctioned and allocation is made for the construction, reconstruction and up gradation of Roads and Bridges out of budget provision made under Grant No. 83 in the following head of Accounts:-
i. Capital outlay on Roads and Bridges……………Capital Head of Account 5054
ii. Capital outlay on other special area activities ….Capital Head of Account 4575
Technical Assistance for Implementation of Institutional Reforms in Road Sector of Uttar Pradesh Report No. 16
May 2008 10
3.4 DEPOSIT WORKS
The money made available by other Departments, Agencies, or Corporations for their respective works pertain to Head of Account “8443 Deposit”. It is deposited in the Treasury by the Executive Engineer of the Division through Treasury Challan against which Deposit Credit Limit is demanded by him from the Superintending Engineer for execution of such Deposit Works.
3.5 DEFICIENCIES IN THE EXISTING BUDGETING AND COST CONTROL SYSTEM
Although it may not be a deficiency in the existing budgeting and cost control system the whole process of determining which roads to construct and which to repair is fraught with problems. These can only be realistically addressed once the PWD has established a Road Network Master Plan and implemented a road maintenance management system. All new construction work should be in accordance with the Master Plan, and all road maintenance work should be needs based and prioritised on economic grounds using the road maintenance management system.
The forms listed in Table No. 1 are GoUP standard forms which are applicable to the PWD. Comments with respect to their suitability and use as a management tool have been included in that Table. A copy of the forms is given in Annexure 1.
Under the present system no standard form is available for the Engineer-in-Chief to send allotment details to the Finance Controller who in turn issues the Cash Credit Limits for each Project against the given allotment of funds. Presently the letter through which the CCL is issued by the Finance Controller is addressed to Chief / Senior Treasury Officer of the concerned District and a copy is endorsed to the Zone. With this system, the Superintending Engineer is unaware of the issuance of CCL against the allotted amount of funds for the project.
The forms that are in use do not differentiate between Plan and Non-Plan Works, or between Roads and Structures. From a management perspective this makes it difficult to monitor and control the budgets since all these aspects are muddled up together.
Technical Assistance for Implementation of Institutional Reforms in Road Sector of Uttar Pradesh Report No. 16
May 2008 11
Table 1 : GoUP Standard Forms for Budgeting Purposes
Form Code Problems with the existing forms
BM -1 (Part I) BM -1 (Part II)
Management control is difficult since the form is general making it difficult to find data for a given Zone, Circle, or Division. The form includes both Plan and Non-Plan Works as well as Roads and Structures. Column 1, Major Head, should be defined using the unique 15 digit code
BM - 4
Management control is difficult since the form is general making it difficult to find data for a given Zone, Circle, or Division. The form includes both Plan and Non-Plan Works as well as Roads and Structures. Major Head, should be defined using the unique 15 digit code
BM - 5 Form is not used by the PWD since the data required is provided by form 64 (Public Works Accounts)
BM - 6 This form relates to Taxes and is not applicable to PWD
BM - 7
Management control is difficult since the form is general making it difficult to find data for a given Zone, Circle, or Division. The form includes both Plan and Non-Plan Works as well as Roads and Structures. The details required on the form relate to one project: hence one form per project.
BM - 8
Management control is difficult since the form denotes District but omits Circle and Zone. There are no item headings under which to enter data, only a series of blank columns, so no standard format as regards data entry. Major Head should be defined by unique 15 digit code
BM - 9 Management control is difficult since the form denotes Division but omits Circle and Zone. The form includes both Plan and Non-Plan Works as well as Roads and Structures.
BM - 10 Details description of return of funds but this is covered under from BM - 4, hence BM -10 is not used by the PWD.
BM - 11 Form is not used by the PWD since the data required is provided by form 64
BM - 12 This form is not applicable to PWD since the relevant data is provided using Form BM - 4.
BM - 13 Form is not used by the PWD since the data required is provided by form 64
BM - 15
Management control is difficult since the form denotes Division but omits Circle and Zone. The form includes both Plan and Non-Plan Works as well as Roads and Structures. Columns 1 and 5 should be replaced with one column 'Major Head' which is the 15 digit unique code number.
BM - 17 This form is only used for the return of Establishment funds (salaries)
Technical Assistance for Implementation of Institutional Reforms in Road Sector of Uttar Pradesh Report No. 16
May 2008 12
4. OBJECTIVES OF IT BASED BUDGETING AND COST CONTROL SYSTEMS
The advent of a computerised Budgeting and Cost Control System will greatly increase the accuracy of financial information available to PWD management as well as timely provision of same. These advantages can be summarised as follows:
1. With the proposed computerisation of the budget system effective decision making at various levels in PWD will be possible due to accurate and timely supply of information.
2. Reports based on computerised data processing should be more accurate and easier to handle and produce in specific report formats.
3. The Budget estimates can be prepared using comprehensive cost data held in a well designed database which can be reviewed and updated to present value (ie cost figures for the year 2000 can be automatically updated to the year 2008 so that cost estimates are up to date.)
4. The budgeting and costing system can embrace the whole of PWD, or more probably a Zone. Cost data generated in the Divisions can be fed into the database so that the cost data used in the Zones to prepare the cost estimates is always up to date.
5. A computerised budgeting and cost control system should enable the PWD Zones to prepare detailed annual budgets which can also indicate the probable timing of the required funds.
6. On a monthly basis the Zone can review its budget requirements and consider the most appropriate way to handle any major discrepancies between forecast and actual budget requirements. This is particularly relevant to budgets for Non-Plan works when any unspent money has to be surrendered at the end of the financial year.
7. Estimates, Budgets, Sanctioned Amounts, and Allotments can be recorded for Plan Works - Roads and Structures, Non-Plan Works - Roads and Structures, and Establishment - Plan and Non-Plan. This will provide specific cost information that can aid management decision making.
Technical Assistance for Implementation of Institutional Reforms in Road Sector of Uttar Pradesh Report No. 16
May 2008 13
5. SUGGESTIONS FOR IT BASED BUDGETING SYSTEM ACROSS PWD WITH APPROPRIATE CONTROLS AND REPORTING FUNCTION
The proposed ‘Accounts and Budgeting Cell' in UP PWD, in conjunction with the Policy and Planning Unit, will be responsible for determining the PWD budget for construction (Plan Works) work and maintenance (Non-Plan works) on the road network. This cell will be assisted in this task by the Road Maintenance Management Systems unit which will be charged with the responsibility for preparing the prioritised list of roads for maintenance under a constrained budget. The RMMS Cell will receive various financial data from the Divisions for developing the costs of the various road maintenance interventions and new construction work: which will also cover structures.
Although it is proposed that each Zone, with the support of their Finance Manager, will prepare their own annual budget requirements the Accounts and Budgeting Cell, under the Chief Finance Manager, will have the ultimate responsibility for compiling these budgets for submission to the State Government. The intention is for the Zones to become autonomous and to be responsible for their own budget preparation and allocation of sanctioned budget. PWD Headquarters will play a monitoring and coordinating role in support of the Zones and will be responsible for making the PWD budget submissions to GoUP.
When the State Government has sanctioned and allocated the overall PWD funding the Accounts and Budgeting Cell will be responsible for breaking down the budget into that for each Zone. This unit will also monitor the rate of take up of the allocated budget by each of the Zones to ensure that none of the budget allocated by the State Government remains unspent at the end of the Financial Year. A more even distribution of expenditure will enable the funds to be used in a cost effective and efficient manner, and its surrender for non-use within the time limit can be avoided.
A better way to execute Emergency Works is to make the budget provision in the PWD budget sanctioned by GoUP. Thus the Plan works sanctioned for some project or Non-Plan budget for maintenance etc. would not be adversely affected. This budget provision should be for both special repairs to monsoon damages (SRMD) works as well as for works in connection with VIP visits in the District.
A far better approach would for the GoUP to accept the full risk of emergency works. In this way the PWD would not have to delay any expenditure in case of emergency repairs that might exceed their available budget. The PWD would simply be responsible for the implementation of all works other than emergency repairs, etc. Should an emergency arise the PWD would manage the repairs as usual but would be funded in full directly and without undue delay by the GoUP.
To avoid time overrun, and resultant cost overrun, it is the responsibility of the PWD to arrange for a smooth flow of funds for the works. It should be a simple process to transfer (re-appropriate) funds from one project to another within the same Zone. Presently the powers for sanctioning the re-appropriation of funds are vested in the GoUP. This process takes much time and should be the responsibility of the Zone Chief Engineer suitably empowered to act.
Technical Assistance for Implementation of Institutional Reforms in Road Sector of Uttar Pradesh Report No. 16
May 2008 14
The monthly budgetary performance, as well as actual progress, of the works under execution, or completed, should be reported at Circle and Zone levels. These should include variance reports which are necessary for monitoring the on-going works. Variances of a serious nature should be addressed by the Superintending Engineer in the Circle, whilst those of an even more serious nature should be addressed by the Chief Engineer in the Zone.
If the PWD is to operate in an effective and efficient manner the decision making processes must devolved down to the Zones. The Chief Engineer responsible for a Zone must be given the necessary powers to act without recourse to the GoUP. The role of the PWD HQ is to act as a regulatory and monitoring body. The minimum number of checks and controls should be employed to audit the system and thus avoid mis-appropriation and / or mis-use of funds.
5.1 BUDGET SUB-SYSTEM
The budget sub-system covers all the proposed forms relating to State budgets which have been designed on a step-by-step process covering all budget phases from estimate details, to Cash Credit Limits for each individual Project or works, to reconciliation statements. The individual steps are given below for 'Plan and Non-Plan Works' which involve the issue of Cash Credit Limits, and 'Deposit Credit Limit Works'.
Proposed Procedure for Cash Credit Limit Works:
1. Cost Estimate details for proposed works carried out by the Divisions and submitted to the Zone through the Circle.
2. Each Zone will consolidate these Cost Estimates and forward same to the Policy and Planning Unit in PWD HQ.
3. Consolidation of Cost Estimates by PWD Policy and Planning Unit in conjunction with Finance and Budgeting Unit, and submission to GoUP for sanction.
4. Following GoUP approval cost estimates and annual fund allocation returned to PWD for fund allocation during the financial year.
5. Policy and Planning Unit with Finance and Budgeting Unit to prepare sanctioned budgets for each Zone and send to the Finance Controller (for issue of CCL), and to Zone.
6. Zone Chief Engineer, with support of Finance Manager, to compile Scheme Wise and Project Wise funds for each Circle and Division and send a copy to Divisions through the Circles.
7. The Finance Controller to issue Cash Credit Limits to the Treasury Officer of the concerned District with a copy to the Zone Chief Engineer, Circles, and Divisions.
8. The Treasury Officer to send a letter authorising the State Bank of India for encashment of cheques issued by the Drawing and Disbursement Officer (DDO) in each Division with a copy to the Zone and Circle.
9. When a project is completed a reconciliation statement, or final settlement, will be prepared by the Division and submitted to the Circle which in turn will submit it to the Zone. The Zone will be responsible for submission of same to the Policy and Planning Unit and Accounts and Budgeting Cell in PWD HQ.
Technical Assistance for Implementation of Institutional Reforms in Road Sector of Uttar Pradesh Report No. 16
May 2008 15
Proposed Procedure for Deposit Credit Limit Works:
1. The Utility Service Providers (USP) will first make contact with the PWD Executive Engineer in the concerned Division giving details of the work required and requesting an estimate for same based on the PWD Departmental rates and norms.
2. Upon receipt of the estimate the USP will deposit the requisite amount of money made available to the Division in the form of cheque or Bank Draft. The Divisional Accounts Officer will record details of the work to be undertaken and the money made available and deposit same in the State Treasury under the signature of the Divisional Drawing Office (EE). Copies of all transactions to be sent to the concerned Assistant Finance Manager in the Circle and to the Superintending Engineer in the Circle.
3. The Executive Engineer to request the Superintending Engineer to supply details of the Deposit Works for issue of the DCL by the Assistant Finance Manager. A copy of this DCL will be sent to the Treasury Officer who in turn will authorise payments through the State Bank of India up to the limit of the DCL.
4. Upon completion of the works the Executive Engineer will prepare a Project Completion Report and send a copy to the Superintending Engineer in the Circle and to the Assistant Finance Manager. Any payment will only be made following approval by the Executive Engineer.
5. For ordinary maintenance and repair works of National Highways, as per instruction of the Engineer-in-Chief, Finance Controller will issue the Deposit Credit Limit to the National Highway Division, PWD with a copy to Treasury officer under intimation to the NH Division, Circle and Chief Engineer, National Highway, UP PWD. The Treasury Officer will send a letter to State Bank of India authorising them to make the payments of the cheques issued up to this limit under intimation to the Divisions and Finance Controller.
6. For the PMGSY project, Central Government makes available the funds to the Uttar Pradesh Rural Road Development Authority (UPRRDA). Finance Controller of UPRRDA will issue the Deposit Credit Limit to the Bank (State Bank of India) in the name of project implementing unit (Division) of PMGSY projects.
7. For projects other than those related to National Highways and PMGSY the Superintending Engineer in the Circle will issue the DCL to the Division and send a copy to the Treasury Officer and Assistant Finance Officer. The Treasury Officer will send a letter to the State Bank of India authorising payment of cheques issued by the concerned Division up to this limit with a copy to the Executive Engineer and Divisional Drawing Officer of the concerned Division.
8. After the project is completed, the Project Completion Report (PCR) shall be prepared by the Executive Engineer and submitted to the Superintending Engineer who will examine it and send to the District Magistrate with a copy to Zone Chief Engineer and Engineer-in-Chief (Policy and Planning Unit as well as Accounts and Budgeting Unit). The District Magistrate will send it to concerned Administrative department in the GoUP.
Technical Assistance for Implementation of Institutional Reforms in Road Sector of Uttar Pradesh Report No. 16
May 2008 16
5.2 PROPOSED FORMS FOR BUDGET SUB-SYSTEM
Copies of the forms currently in use in the PWD for budgeting purposes are given in Annexure No. 1. A series of forms have been prepared for the proposed budgeting Sub-System and are included in Annexure 2. In many cases the proposed forms are similar, if not identical, to the forms currently in use by the PWD, but with some significant differences. Figure No. 1 shows the flow diagram for the proposed forms within the PWD and other Government bodies.
Whereas the current forms include Plan and Non-Plan works together with Roads, Structures, and Establishment, the proposed forms separate these different areas as follows:
Plan : Roads, Structures, and New Asset Creation.
Non-Plan : Roads, Structures, Establishment, and Assets.
The forms basically fall into the following groups which follow the way in which the budget requirement estimates are prepared and approved. These steps are:
1. Estimate - the estimates for the Budget requirement are prepared at Division level and compiled at Circle and Zone level before submission to PWD HQ. These estimates will be for Plan Works that conform to the Road Network Master Plan, and Non-Plan works as determined from condition surveys (i.e. which are 'need based'). Each Zone will be responsible for compiling their estimate which will then be submitted to PWD HQ.
2. Budget - Requirement for Establishment Costs and running of the office which, unlike estimates for Works, are fixed costs.
3. Submission to GoUP - the estimates for Works and Budget requirements for Establishment Costs are submitted to the GoUP. The role of PWD HQ is primarily that of monitoring to ensure compliance with strategic plans.
4. Sanction - approval of the budget request is given in the form of sanctions under various headings as detailed in the relevant forms given in Annexure 2. The Sanctioned figures to be sent to PWD HQ whose task will be to assign the sanctioned figures to the Zones who will be responsible for their allocation to different divisions within the Zone.
5. Allotment - At Zone level the sanctioned figures will be broken down into allotments for the various works, etc as detailed in their estimates. The allotment figure is the sum of money which is allocated to each Works, etc.
Table No. 2 gives details of each of these proposed forms which sets out the relevant information regarding Budget Requirements for different purposes and also the allocation / allotment of funds after the sanction by GoUP. In the footnote it has been clearly mentioned as to who will generate the forms and to whom each form is to be forwarded or submitted.
Technical Assistance for Implementation of Institutional Reforms in Road Sector of Uttar Pradesh Report No. 16
May 2008 17
Figure No. 1 : Flow Diagram for Proposed Forms
Department of Finance Accountant General
Finance Controller Treasury Office(Department of Finance)
Engineer-in-Chief
Chief Finance Manager(Accounts & Budgeting Cell)
Head Quarter
Policy and Planning UnitHead Quarter
Finance ManagerZone Chief Engineer (Zone)
Assistant Finance ManagerCircle
Superintending Engineer(Circle)
Suppliers
Contractors
Divisional Accounts OfficerExecutive Engineer
(Division)
Department of FinanceAccountant General OfficeNew Cell in PWD
Existing Cell in PWD
Claim for Payment (Existing Forms : 24, 26, 26A, 27B)
Claim for Payment through personal bill
Claim for payment ofcontractors and suppliers
Existing Forms: 63 Forms
DCL and CCL
DCL and CCL
DCL and CCL
GoUP
110, 150, 140, 130, 120, 160
110, 120, 130, 140, 150, 160
220, 230, 240, 250, 260
220, 230, 240, 250, 260
270, 280
320
320
290
290
170, 180, 190, 200, 210
170, 180, 190, 200, 210
AllotmentSanctionedBudget / Estimates
CCL, DCL, Reappropriation, Liability
270, 280
300, 310, 360, 370
320, 330,340, 350
320, 330,340, 350
320, 330,340, 350
Technical Assistance for Implementation of Institutional Reforms in Road Sector of Uttar Pradesh Report No. 16
May 2008 18
Table 2 : Group Wise Proposed Budget Sub-System
Group Sl. No. Heading
Existing Status
and Form No.
Information Required Location of Generation
and Destination
Form Code PWD BM
Bud
get E
stim
ates
1
Estimate Details: Plan - Roads / Structures
BM - 1 (Part - I)
Plan - Roads / Structures Head Details, PWD ID Code, Name of Work, Sanctioned Cost, Actual Expenditure up to last year.., Budget Estimates for Current year.., Actual Expenditure from April to September of Current Year, Revised Budget Estimate for proposed year…, Budget Estimate for Proposed Year......, Final Provision made by Finance Department.
Generated at Division: compiled at Circle and Zone submitted to GoUP by PWD HQ
110 / 1 110 / 2
2
Estimate Details:
Non-Plan - Roads / Structures
BM – 1 (Part - II)
Non-Plan - Roads / Structures Head Details, PWD ID Code, Name of Work, Sanctioned Cost, Actual Expenditure up to last year.., Budget Estimates for Current year.., Actual Expenditure from April to September of Current Year, Revised Budget Estimate for proposed year…, Budget Estimate for Proposed Year......, Final Provision made by Finance Department.
Generated at Division: compiled at Circle and Zone submitted to GoUP by PWD HQ
120 / 1 120 / 2
Bud
get R
equi
rem
ent
3
Budget Requirement: Non-Plan - Roads Routine Maintenance, Periodic Maintenance / Rehabilitation Special Repair / Reconstruction Non-Plan: Structures
Non-Plan – Roads: Routine / Periodic Maintenance / Special Repairs PWD ID Code, Type of Road (State Highway, Major District Road, District Road, Village Road), Location Reference Point (start and finish), Length of Road, Total Fund Required, Comments. Non-Plan – Structures PWD ID Code, Road and Km, Type of Structure, Average Height in Metres, Location Reference Point (start and finish), Length of Structure, Length of Approaches (Increase Km side, Decrease Km side, Total Length) , Maintenance Funding Required (Routine, Periodic, Other), Total Funding Required Each Structure, Remarks
Generated at Division: compiled at Circle and Zone submitted to GoUP by PWD HQ
130 / 1 130 / 2 130 / 3 130 / 4
Technical Assistance for Implementation of Institutional Reforms in Road Sector of Uttar Pradesh Report No. 16
May 2008 19
Group Sl. No. Heading
Existing Status
and Form No.
Information Required Location of Generation
and Destination
Form Code PWD BM
Bud
get R
equi
rem
ent
4
Budgets Requirement: Non-Plan - Establishment:
Human Resource Expenses
Office Running Costs
BM-8
Non-Plan: Human Resource Expenses Head Details, PWD ID Code, Salary, Dearness Salary, Dearness Allowance, CCA, HRA, Other Allowances, Interim Relief, Auxiliary Allotment for Pay and Allowances, Travelling Allowance, Transfer Travel Expenditure, Travel Allowance for Training, Leave Travel Concession Expenditure, Medical Expenditure, Uniform Expenditure, Total Non-Plan: Office Running Costs Head details, PWD ID Code, Office Expenses, Electric Dues, Water Tax and Charges, Stationery Material and Printing of Forms, Office Furniture and Fittings and Appliances, Telephone and Fax, Maintenance of Vehicles and Purchase of Petrol/Diesel/Lubricants, etc, Rent Surcharge and Tax Ownership , Medical Reimbursement, House Building Advance, Motor Vehicle Advance, Purchase of Computer Hardware/Software , Maintenance of Computers and Purchase of Allied Stationery, Machines Furnishings and Appliance and Plants, Publications, Scholarships and Stipend, Maintenance, Other expenses, Total
Generated at Division: compiled and expanded at Circle and Zone, submitted to GoUP by PWD HQ
140 / 1 140 / 2
5
Budget Requirement: Plan - New Asset Creation:
Buildings (Residential)
Buildings (Non-Residential)
Vehicles
Plant and Equipment
No existing
form
Plan: New Asset Creation - Buildings (Residential) Name and Type of Buildings, Estimated Cost, Sanctioned Cost, Expenditure till Previous Financial Year, Balance Against Sanctioned Cost, Demand During Current Financial Year, Remarks
Plan: New Asset Creation - Buildings (Non-Residential) ) Name and Type pf Buildings, Estimated Cost, Sanctioned Cost, Expenditure till Previous Financial Year, Balance Against Sanctioned Cost, Demand During Current Financial Year, Remarks
Plan: New Asset Creation - Vehicles Type of Vehicle, Number of Vehicles, Cost, Remarks
Plan: New Asset Creation - Plant and Equipment Name Type of Plant and Equipment, No. of Plant and Equipment, Cost, Remarks
Generated at Division: compiled and expanded at Circle and Zone, submitted to GoUP by PWD HQ
150 / 1 150 / 2 150 / 3 150 / 4
Technical Assistance for Implementation of Institutional Reforms in Road Sector of Uttar Pradesh Report No. 16
May 2008 20
Group Sl. No. Heading
Existing Status
and Form No.
Information Required Location of Generation
and Destination
Form Code PWD BM
Bud
get R
equi
rem
ent
6
Budget Requirement: Non-Plan - Assets: Maintenance of Buildings (Residential) Maintenance of Buildings (Non-Residential) Maintenance of Vehicles Maintenance of Plant and Equipment
No existing
form
Non-Plan - Assets: Maintenance Buildings (Residential) Name of Building (Residential), Plinth Ares, Funds Required, Remarks
Non-Plan - Assets: Maintenance Buildings (Non-Residential) Name of Building (Residential), Plinth Ares, Funds Required, Remarks
Non-Plan - Assets: Maintenance Vehicles Type of Vehicle, Number of Vehicles, Funds Required, Remarks
Non-Plan - Assets: Maintenance Plant and Equipment Name of Plant and Equipment, Funds Required, Remarks
Generated at Division: compiled and expanded at Circle and Zone, submitted to GoUP by PWD HQ
160 / 1 160 / 2 160 / 3 160 / 4
Technical Assistance for Implementation of Institutional Reforms in Road Sector of Uttar Pradesh Report No. 16
May 2008 21
Group Sl. No. Heading
Existing Status
and Form No.
Information Required Location of Generation
and Destination
Form Code PWD BM
Sanc
tione
d D
etai
ls
7
Sanctioned Details for Financial Year: Plan - Roads / Structures
No existing
form
Plan - Roads / Structures Grant No, Head Details, PWD ID Code, Name of Work, Reference of Financial / Administrative Approval, Sanctioned Cost, Expenditure up to Last Financial Year, Balance, Allocated Amount for Financial Year, reference of G. O. N o. and Date
Government level to PWD HQ
170 / 1 170 / 2
8
Sanctioned Details for Financial Year: Non-Plan - Roads / Structures
No existing
form
Non-Plan - Roads / Structures Grant No, Head Details, PWD ID Code, Name of Work, Reference of Financial / Administrative Approval, Sanctioned Cost, Expenditure up to Last Financial Year, Balance, Allocated Amount for Financial Year, reference of G. O. N o. and Date
Government level to PWD HQ
180 / 1 180 / 2
9
Sanctioned Details: Non-Plan - Establishment:
Human Resource Expenses
Establishment: Office Running Costs
No existing
form
Non-Plan: Human Resource Expenses Head Details, PWD ID Code, Salary, Dearness Salary, Dearness Allowance, CCA, HRA, Other Allowances, Interim Relief, Auxiliary Allotment for Pay and Allowances, Travelling Allowance, Transfer Travel Expenditure, Travel Allowance for Training, Leave Travel Concession Expenditure, Medical Expenditure, Uniform Expenditure, Total
Non-Plan: Office Running Costs Head details, PWD ID Code, Office Expenses, Electric Dues, Water Tax and Charges, Stationery Material and Printing of Forms, Office Furniture and Fittings and Appliances, Telephone and Fax, Maintenance of Vehicles and Purchase of Petrol/Diesel/Lubricants, etc, Rent Surcharge and Tax Ownership , Medical Reimbursement, House Building Advance, Motor Vehicle Advance, Purchase of Computer Hardware/Software , Maintenance of Computers and Purchase of Allied Stationery, Machines Furnishings and Appliance and Plants, Publications, Scholarships and Stipend, Maintenance, Other expenses, Total
Government level to PWD HQ
190 / 1 190 / 2
Technical Assistance for Implementation of Institutional Reforms in Road Sector of Uttar Pradesh Report No. 16
May 2008 22
Group Sl. No. Heading
Existing Status
and Form No.
Information Required Location of Generation
and Destination
Form Code PWD BM
Sanc
tione
d D
etai
ls
10
Sanctioned Details: Plan - New Asset Creation:
Buildings Residential)
Buildings (Non-Residential)
Vehicles
Plant and Equipment
No existing
form
Plan: New Asset Creation - Buildings (Residential) Name and Type of Buildings, Estimated Cost, Sanctioned Cost, Expenditure till Previous Financial Year, Balance Against Sanctioned Cost, Demand During Current Financial Year, Remarks
Plan: New Asset Creation - Buildings (Non-Residential) ) Name and Type pf Buildings, Estimated Cost, Sanctioned Cost, Expenditure till Previous Financial Year, Balance Against Sanctioned Cost, Demand During Current Financial Year, Remarks
Plan: New Asset Creation - Vehicles Type of Vehicle, Number of Vehicles, Cost, Remarks
Plan: New Asset Creation - Plant and Equipment Name Type of Plant and Equipment, No. of Plant and Equipment, Cost, Remarks
Government level to PWD HQ
200 / 1 200 / 2 200 / 3 200 / 4
11
Sanctioned Details: Non-Plan - Assets: Maintenance of Buildings (Residential) Maintenance of Buildings (Non-Residential) Maintenance of Vehicles Maintenance of Plant and Equipment
No existing
form
Non-Plan - Assets: Maintenance Buildings (Residential) Name of Building (Residential), Allocation of Funds, Remarks
Non-Plan - Assets: Maintenance Buildings (Non-Residential) Name of Building (Residential), Allocation of Funds, Remarks
Non-Plan - Assets: Maintenance Vehicles Type of Vehicle, Number of Vehicles, Allocation of Funds, Remarks
Non-Plan - Assets: Maintenance Plant and Equipment Name of Plant and Equipment, Allocation of Funds, Remarks
Government level to PWD HQ
210 / 1 210 / 2 210 / 3 210 / 4
Technical Assistance for Implementation of Institutional Reforms in Road Sector of Uttar Pradesh Report No. 16
May 2008 23
Group Sl. No. Heading
Existing Status
and Form No.
Information Required Location of Generation
and Destination
Form Code PWD BM
Allo
tmen
t Det
ails
12 Allotment:
Plan - Roads / Structures
No existing
form
Plan Roads and Structures Grant No, Head details, PWD ID Code, Name of Work, Reference of Sanction (Administrative and Expenditure Sanction) Sanctioned Cost, Expenditure up to last Financial Year, Balance Amount against sanctioned cost, Budget allocation for current year, Amount Allotted, Amount Allotted previously in current financial year, Total amount allotted in current financial year, Remarks
Generated at PWD HQ and sent to Division through Zone and Circle
220 / 1 220 / 2
13 Allotment:
Non-Plan - Roads / Structures
No existing
form
Non-Plan Roads and Structures Grant No, Head details, PWD ID Code, Name of Work, Reference of Sanction (Administrative and Expenditure Sanction) Sanctioned Cost, Expenditure up to last Financial Year, Balance Amount against sanctioned cost, Budget allocation for current year, Amount Allotted, Amount Allotted previously in current financial year, Total amount allotted in current financial year, Remarks
Generated at PWD HQ and sent to Division through Zone and Circle
230 / 1 230 / 2
14
Allotment Details: Non-Plan -
Establishment: Human Resource Expenses
Establishment: Office Running Costs
No existing
form
Non-Plan: Human Resource Expenses Head Details, PWD ID Code, Salary, Dearness Salary, Dearness Allowance, CCA, HRA, Other Allowances, Interim Relief, Auxiliary Allotment for Pay and Allowances, Travelling Allowance, Transfer Travel Expenditure, Travel Allowance for Training, Leave Travel Concession Expenditure, Medical Expenditure, Uniform Expenditure, Total
Non-Plan: Office Running Costs Head details, PWD ID Code, Office Expenses, Electric Dues, Water Tax and Charges, Stationery Material and Printing of Forms, Office Furniture and Fittings and Appliances, Telephone and Fax, Maintenance of Vehicles and Purchase of Petrol/Diesel/Lubricants, etc, Rent Surcharge and Tax Ownership , Medical Reimbursement, House Building Advance, Motor Vehicle Advance, Purchase of Computer Hardware/Software , Maintenance of Computers and Purchase of Allied Stationery, Machines Furnishings and Appliance and Plants, Publications, Scholarships and Stipend, Maintenance, Other expenses, Total
Generated at PWD HQ and sent to Division through Zone and Circle
240 / 1 240 / 2
Technical Assistance for Implementation of Institutional Reforms in Road Sector of Uttar Pradesh Report No. 16
May 2008 24
Group Sl. No. Heading
Existing Status
and Form No.
Information Required Location of Generation
and Destination
Form Code PWD BM
Allo
tmen
t Det
ails
15
Sanctioned Details: Plan - New Asset Creation:
Buildings Residential)
Buildings (Non-Residential)
Vehicles
Plant and Equipment
No existing
form
Plan - New Asset Creation: Buildings Residential Name of Building, Sanctioned Cost, Allotment During the Financial Year, Remarks
Plan - New Asset Creation: Buildings Non-Residential Name of Building, Sanctioned Cost, Allotment During the Financial Year, Remarks
Plan - New Asset Creation: Vehicles Type of Vehicle, No. of Vehicles, Sanctioned Cost, Allotment, Remarks
Plan - New Asset Creation: Plant and Equipment Type of Plant and Equipment, No. of Plant and Equipment, Sanctioned Cost, Allocation, Remarks
Generated at PWD HQ and sent to Division through Zone and Circle
250 / 1 250 / 2 250 / 3 250 / 4
16
Allotment Details: Non-Plan - Assets: Maintenance of Buildings (Residential) Maintenance of Buildings (Non-Residential) Maintenance of Vehicles Maintenance of Plant and Equipment
No existing
form
Non-Plan - Assets: Maintenance Buildings (Residential) Name of Building (Residential), Plinth Area, Allocation of Funds, Remarks
Non-Plan - Assets: Maintenance Buildings (Non-Residential) Name of Building (Residential), Plinth Area, Allocation of Funds, Remarks
Non-Plan - Assets: Maintenance Vehicles Type of Vehicle, Number of Vehicles, Allocation of Funds, Remarks
Non-Plan - Assets: Maintenance Plant and Equipment Name of Plant and Equipment, Allocation of Funds, Remarks
Generated at PWD HQ and sent to Division through Zone and Circle
260 / 1 260 / 2 260 /3 260 /4
Technical Assistance for Implementation of Institutional Reforms in Road Sector of Uttar Pradesh Report No. 16
May 2008 25
Group Sl. No. Heading
Existing Status
and Form No.
Information Required Location of Generation
and Destination
Form Code PWD BM
Cas
h C
redi
t Lim
its
17
Details of Cash Credit Limits: Plan - Roads / Structures
No existing
form
Plan- Roads / Structures Grant No., Head Details, PWD ID Code, Name of Sanctioned Work, Budget Allotted in figure (Previous during financial year, This allotment, Total allotment during current financial year), CCL Allotted: 1st Quarter (Issued CCL, Surrender of CCL, Net CCL), 2nd Quarter (Issued CCL, Surrender of CCL, Net CCL), 3rd Quarter (Issued CCL, Surrender of CCL, Net CCL), 4th Quarter (Issued CCL, Surrender of CCL, Net CCL), Total During the Year (CCL Issued, Surrender, Total Net CCL Issued), Expenditure till month, Percentage of Physical Progress till month
Finance Controller Office to send to Chief / Senior Treasury Officer of concerned District with copy to Division, Circle and Zone
270 / 1 270 / 2
18
Details of Cash Credit Limits: Non-Plan - Roads / Structures
No existing
form
Non-Plan- Roads / Structures Grant No., Head Details, PWD ID Code, Name of Sanctioned Work, Budget Allotted in figure (Previous during financial year, This allotment, Total allotment during current financial year), CCL Allotted: 1st Quarter (Issued CCL, Surrender of CCL, Net CCL), 2nd Quarter (Issued CCL, Surrender of CCL, Net CCL), 3rd Quarter (Issued CCL, Surrender of CCL, Net CCL), 4th Quarter (Issued CCL, Surrender of CCL, Net CCL), Total During the Year (CCL Issued, Surrender, Total Net CCL Issued), Expenditure till month, Percentage of Physical Progress till month
Finance Controller Office to send to Chief / Senior Treasury Officer of concerned District, copy to Division, Circle and Zone
280 / 1 280 / 2
Technical Assistance for Implementation of Institutional Reforms in Road Sector of Uttar Pradesh Report No. 16
May 2008 26
Group Sl. No. Heading
Existing Status
and Form No.
Information Required Location of Generation
and Destination
Form Code PWD BM
19 Details of Deposit Credit Limits - Roads / Structures
No existing
form
Roads / Structures Name of Department or Organisation or Agency by which amount made available, Cheque / DD No. and Date, Amount, Chalan No. and Date Amount Deposited in Treasury, Name of Work, Amount of DCL allotted, Remarks
Finance Controller Office for NH and SE for other projects to send to Chief / Senior Treasury Officer of concerned District, copy to Division, Circle and Zone
290 / 1 290 / 2
20
Excess / Saving Statement / Variation Statement: Plan Roads / Structures
BM - 4
Plan: Roads / Structures Head Details, PWD ID Code, Work Name, Budget Provision, Actual Expenditure During Quarter, Cumulative Expenditure up to End of Quarter, Revised Estimate of Expenditure for Whole Year, Excess (Difference Revised), Saving (Proposed), Remarks / Reasons for Excess / Saving
Division to Accountant General, copy to Circle and Zone
300 / 1 300 / 2
Cas
h C
redi
t Li
mits
21
Excess / Saving Statement / Variation Statement: Non-Plan - Roads / Structures
BM - 4
Non-Plan: Roads / Structures Head Details, PWD ID Code, Work Name, Budget Provision, Actual Expenditure During Quarter, Cumulative Expenditure up to End of Quarter, Revised Estimate of Expenditure for Whole Year, Excess (Difference Revised), Saving (Proposed), Remarks / Reasons for Excess / Saving
Division to Accountant General, copy to Circle and Zone
310 / 1 310 / 2
Technical Assistance for Implementation of Institutional Reforms in Road Sector of Uttar Pradesh Report No. 16
May 2008 27
Group Sl. No. Heading
Existing Status
and Form No.
Information Required Location of Generation
and Destination
Form Code PWD BM
Oth
ers
22
Re-appropriation Statement: Plan - Roads / Structures
BM - 15
Plan - Roads/ Structures Head Details, PWD ID Code, Account Head, sub-head of Account, Name of Scheme and Other Details, Name of Work, Sanctioned Cost, Expenditure up to Last Financial Year, Allocation for Present Financial Year, Allocation including change and Supplementary Grant for Present Financial Year, Proposed Excess / Saving, Proposed Allocation for Present Financial Year, Justification for Excess / Saving, Remarks
Division to Zone via Circle. Zone to compile and send reconciled reports to PWD HQ
320 / 1 320 / 2
23
Re-appropriation Statement: Non-Plan - Roads / Structures
BM - 15
Non-Plan - Roads Head Details, PWD ID Code, Account Head, sub-head of Account, Name of Scheme and Other Details, Name of Work, Sanctioned Cost, Expenditure up to Last Financial Year, Allocation for Present Financial Year, Allocation including change and Supplementary Grant for Present Financial Year, Proposed Excess / Saving, Proposed Allocation for Present Financial Year, Justification for Excess / Saving, Remarks
Division to Zone via Circle. Zone to compile and send reconciled reports to PWD HQ
330 / 1 330 / 2
24
Liability Details:
Plan -
Roads / Structures
BM - 7
Plan - Roads / Structures Description of Current Liability, Circumstances in which Liability Created, Name and Designation of Officer who Created Current Liability, Orders of Authority Under which Liability Created, Amount of Current Liability, Month in which the Liability was Created, Liabilities Created Prior to Current Liability, Total Liability, If Liability of State Government Name of Office and Department, Remarks
Prepared Monthly at Division and sent to PWD HQ through Circle and Zone
340 / 1 340 / 2
25
Liability Details:
Non-Plan -
Roads / Structures
BM - 7
Non-Plan - Roads / Structures Description of Current Liability, Circumstances in which Liability Created, Name and Designation of Officer who Created Current Liability, Orders of Authority Under which Liability Created, Amount of Current Liability, Month in which the Liability was Created, Liabilities Created Prior to Current Liability, Total Liability, If Liability of State Government Name of Office and Department, Remarks
Prepared Monthly at Division and sent to PWD HQ through Circle and Zone
350 / 1 350 / 2
Technical Assistance for Implementation of Institutional Reforms in Road Sector of Uttar Pradesh Report No. 16
May 2008 28
Group Sl. No. Heading
Existing Status
and Form No.
Information Required Location of Generation
and Destination
Form Code PWD BM
26
Reconciliation Statement:
Plan -
Roads / Structures
BM - 9
Plan - Roads / Structures Head Details, PWD ID Code, Allotment, Particulars, Types of Transaction, Amount in the Quarter (Month 1, Month 2, Month 3, Total), Expenditure up to Last Quarter, Total Expenditure up to the Present Quarter, Remarks
Division to Accountant General, copy to Circle and Zone
360 / 1 360 /2
27
Reconciliation Statement:
Non-Plan -
Roads / Structures
BM - 9
Non-Plan - Roads / Structures Head Details, PWD ID Code, Allotment, Particulars, Types of Transaction, Amount in the Quarter (Month 1, Month 2, Month 3, Total), Expenditure up to Last Quarter, Total Expenditure up to the Present Quarter, Remarks
Division to Accountant General, copy to Circle and Zone
370 / 1 370 /2
Technical Assistance for Implementation of Institutional Reforms in Road Sector of Uttar Pradesh Report No. 16
May 2008 29
6. PROPOSED IT BASED COST CONTROL SYSTEM IN SUPPORT OF STANDARD COSTING
Because there is no Cost Control System currently operating in PWD it is not possible to review or comment on its implementation. Instead this Section of the Report sets out the basis for a Cost Control System in PWD which will enable management to compare estimated costs, budget allocations, and timing of same, with actual costs and their timing.
Within the PWD there is a provision for a Register of Works which could play a useful part in the Cost Control System. However, because it is currently compiled manually, and because of the large number of projects, it is not being maintained in most of the Divisions and is therefore not serving any useful purpose. This form has been included in Annexure 3 because it can be revived in a computerised system and has considerable merits with respect to a cost control system.
In addition two different forms for recording Cost Control details will be required for the cost control system in the proposed PWD Accounts Branch in the Circles. One form will be for Out-sourced contracts and the other for In-house contracts.
The following is a definition of some of the terms used in Cost Control.
a. The term 'Standard Costing' simply means the analysis of differences (variances) between different cost figures, such as Actual Costs and Budget Allocation.
b. Cost Centre is a collection of activities which are to be grouped together and are similar to 'elements'. An example of a Cost Centre is 'Drainage' where all activities related to drainage are grouped together under one common heading. This heading can be further sub-divided as necessary into different types of drain or diameter of pipes.
6.1 COST CENTRES FOR OUT-SOURCED CONTRACTS
For out-sourced works the Cost Centres should be individual works, either on-going or scheduled to start, in each and every Division with project specific data provided as indicated in the sample form number CCOS 100 given in Annexure 3. The following notes relate to form CCOS 100: the figures in rounded brackets e.g. (3) relate to a row number on that form.
Notes:
If the difference between Estimated Contract Value and Contact Value given at the top of the form is positive it indicates that the budget estimate was in excess of the actual contract value. If the difference is negative the opposite is the situation, in which case the budget allocation will be insufficient and additional funding will be required.
Technical Assistance for Implementation of Institutional Reforms in Road Sector of Uttar Pradesh Report No. 16
May 2008 30
Row Description No.
1. Physical Progress: percentage complete - based on estimated/measured percentages
2. Payments made to the Contractor - record of payments made
3. Advances paid to the Contractor - record of advance payments made
4. Payment for Work Done, excluding advances - (2) minus (3)
5. Value of Work Done Based on % Complete - based on estimated % completion of the various elements which make up the contract
6. Value of Work Done According to Contractor's Tender / Bid Programme - Value of Work Done as forecast by the Contractor
7. Actual Progress: (5) minus (6). If the result is positive the Contractor is ahead of programme: if negative the contract is behind programme and in danger of finishing late
8. Variation Orders - where these are issued the value of the Contract will be increased and must be taken into account when carrying out the variance analysis
9. Balance Amount payable to the Contractor against agreement - (5) - (4)
10. Balance amount payable to Contractor including Variation Orders and Extra Items - (8) plus (9)
Form number CCOS 100 will give the following management information:
1. Variance (5) - (4): Compare Actual Payments to Contractor for work done with value based on percentage of work actually completed. If the resultant difference is positive then it would appear that the Contractor has been paid less than he should have been.
If the resultant figure is negative the converse is true. In particular, cases where the resultant figure is negative will need to be investigated since the Contractor has been over-paid.
2. Variance (5) - (6): Compare Actual Value of Work Done with value of work programmed by the Contractor to be completed. If the resultant difference is positive the contract is ahead of anticipated progress, if negative the converse is the case and Project may finish late unless action is taken.
6.2 COST CENTRES FOR IN-HOUSE CONTRACTS
For In-House works the Cost Centres should be individual works, either on-going or scheduled to start, in each and every Division with project specific data provided as indicated in the sample form number CCIH 200 given in Annexure 3.
For In-House Contracts much more cost information will be available than for Out-Sourced Contracts. The PWD will know the costs of all elements of work associated with In-House Contracts which can be used as a management tool. Some of these Cost Elements have been listed on form CCIH 200 but these should be amended to suit each specific contract.
Technical Assistance for Implementation of Institutional Reforms in Road Sector of Uttar Pradesh Report No. 16
May 2008 31
During the preparation of the budge estimate the PWD will have used certain cost data to enable them to prepare the cost of undertaking this work. These figures determined for the cost estimate can be used during the running of the In-House contracts and will, upon completion of the contract, provide the PWD with the actual costs incurred. These costs can then be used as an aid to preparing future estimates for In-House contracts.
The notes given below relate to form number CCIH 200: the figures in rounded brackets eg. (2) relate to a column number on that form.
Note:
i. Budget Based on Actual Work done (1): this is the budget arising from the volume of work completed up to the end of the period under review.
ii. Budget Based on the Work Programme (2): this is the budget arising from the work programmed to be completed up to the end of the period under review.
iii. This is the Actual Cost incurred when completing the work up to the end of the period under review (3).
Form number CCIH 200 will give the following management information for Labour, Plant and Materials:
1. Variances (1) - (3): if the difference is positive it will indicate that the project is proceeding efficiently with costs less than those from which the cost estimates were derived. If however the difference is negative it indicates that the Project is not working as efficiently as it should and this will need to be addressed by the Project Manager (EE)
2. Variances (2) - (3): if the difference is positive it indicates that this element of the Project is ahead of the programme. If the difference is negative the difference is the case and will need to be addressed by the Project Manager (EE).
6.3 ANALYSIS OF COST INFORMATION
The Assistant Finance Manager in the Circles will receive physical and financial reports of all projects undertaken in the respective Divisions and thus prepare the Cost Control data sheets included in Annex 2. These Cost Control data sheets will be transmitted to the Superintending Engineer in the Circle and to the Executive Engineers in the Division for them to take action as appropriate. A copy will also be forwarded to the Chief Engineer in the Zone and one to the Finance Manager in the Zone which will be used to update the cost records held on the computer database.
6.3.1. Analysis of Cost Information Arising From Out-Sourced Contracts
The basic information that can be gained through analysis of these forms covers:
i. Actual Total Project Cost compared with Estimated Total Cost
ii. Actual Project duration compared with estimated project duration
iii. Details of Variation Orders and increased costs associated with same.
Technical Assistance for Implementation of Institutional Reforms in Road Sector of Uttar Pradesh Report No. 16
May 2008 32
This information should be used to update existing PWD records relating to cost and duration of similar types of works.
The Variation Orders should be analysed to determine the reasons for their creation so that future designs or specifications, etc can be amended to reduce the need for such Variation Orders on future similar types of works.
An additional aspect of this work is to compare all the Projects completed by a given Contractor to determine if there are any common threads. For example, does this Contractor always fail to complete Projects on time and within the original contract value? Does the Contractor always manage to secure a high value of Variation Orders when compared with other Contractors on similar types of works?
6.3.2. Analysis of Cost Information Arising From In-House Contracts
The basic information that can be derived through analysis of these forms covers:
i. Basic costs arising from the Project relating to labour, material, and plant for each of the various Cost Elements
ii. Actual Project duration compared with estimated duration
iii. Details of any 'Variation Orders' and increased costs associated with same.
6.4 STANDARD COSTING
Before commencing any works it is necessary to determine the 'Standard Costs'. For the PWD these 'Standard Costs' are in fact the Cost Estimates which are prepared for each Project.
The Cost Control forms have a dual purpose. In the first place they are a management tool to aid decision making with respect to the work done on each Project. Secondly these details should be used to update cost records and hence improve the accuracy and reliability of the cost estimates.
Because of the size of Uttar Pradesh it may be considered feasible to break down these cost figures into Zones. The Zones may well have different characteristics which influence costs in a number of ways making it difficult, if not impossible to compare costs across the whole of Uttar Pradesh.
The advantages to be gained through the introduction of Cost Control and Standard Costing System are:
1. Efficiency Measurement: comparisons can be made between actual and estimated costs which can aid management decision making
2. Variances: this is part of Efficiency Measurement and for In-House Projects provides the Project Manager (EE) with regular cost information which should aid decision making
3. Management by Exception: management only needs to focus on specific areas where the variances are large, and in particular where these variances are negative.
4. Cost Control systems set good financial management example of which Contractors and PWD Labour force will be aware.
Technical Assistance for Implementation of Institutional Reforms in Road Sector of Uttar Pradesh Report No. 16
May 2008 33
6.5 REGISTER OF WORKS
Form PWD ROW 500 / 1 enables a record to be compiled of the Variation Orders and Extra Items included as part of the contract works.
Form PWD ROW 500 / 2 is a compilation of the details obtained for each contact and covers such items as Advance Payment for Procurement to Stock, Direct Payment to Labour, and details of Imprest Accounts.
Technical Assistance for Implementation of Institutional Reforms in Road Sector of Uttar Pradesh Report No. 16
May 2008 34
7. IMPLEMENTATION PROCESS
The implementation process must be carefully planned and monitored. In each and every aspect of implementation there must be frequent inter-action between the Consultant undertaking the writing of the necessary software program and the PWD. The lessons learnt in the past must not be ignored but used to re-affirm the need for the Consultant and PWD to work together in harmony.
The computerisation process must be broken down into what can be termed SMART tasks. SMART is an acronym for:
S Specific
M Measurable
A Achievable
R Relevant
T Timely
The computerisation process should be incremental and initially focus on one Division and one basic component, such as 'Establishment". The software should be written for this and the forms to be used for both presenting the data and for data entry must be discussed with the one selected Division in the PWD.
The forms and software must be tested using real data and the results examined by all parties and modifications, if any, agreed upon. The process should be repeated until all parties are satisfied with the results. The next stage of the process would be to launch the software in one other selected Division, in the same Zone as the initially selected Division where it should be subject to rigorous testing. Only when the two Divisions and all parties, Software Consultant and the PWD, accept the program should it be launched in the whole of the Zone.
Once the first Zone is satisfied with the program should it be launched in all the Zones. In the meantime the next component should be developed and tried and tested in the same way. The end result should be a software program which meets the needs and expectations of the PWD. But the PWD must accept, and be fully aware, of the vital role which they must play in the development of the software program. Tacit approval will not be sufficient. The PWD must make the necessary staff available to work with the Software Consultant. The responsibility for successful computerisation of the Financial Management System rests on the shoulders of the PWD.
Technical Assistance for Implementation of Institutional Reforms in Road Sector of Uttar Pradesh Report No. 16
May 2008 35
8. CONCLUSION
The proposals set out in this Report should improve the budgeting and costing system currently used in the PWD. In particular the whole system, if properly implemented, will provide PWD Managers at all levels with timely detailed financial information with respect to budgets. This should enable the PWD Managers to make better decisions since they will have access to accurate and up to date budget information.
The reforms and modifications suggested in this Report, along with the computerisation of the budgetary control process, if implemented effectively and transparently, will improve the nature and quality of the PWD budgeting system. It will act as an important step towards enhancement and reforms of the PWD’s Accounting system with its enhanced component coverage which at present is absent in the PWD.
Technical Assistance for Implementation of Institutional Reforms in Road Sector of Uttar Pradesh Report No. 16
May 2008 36
9. PRESENTATION TO PROJECT STEERING COMMITTEE
UPSRP IDSReport No. 16: Review Report on Implementation of IT Based Budgeting and Costing
The title of this Report assumes that an IT Based
Systems across PWD with appropriate controls and reporting functions
pBudgeting and Costing System is in place in thePWD.
This is not the case.
This Report sets out a proposed budgeting and costcontrol system together with proposals for thecontrol system together with proposals for theestablishment of cost centres as an aid to decisionmaking This Report also includes proposals formaking. This Report also includes proposals forstandard types of forms which can be used forbudgeting and cost controlbudgeting and cost control.
UPSRP IDSReport No. 16
The budgeting process involves compilation of thefunding requirement for Plan and Non-Plan worksto be undertaken during the following financialyear.
Plan works relate to new construction workswhereas Non-Plan basically relates tomaintenance, emergency works, andestablishment.
Cash budgeting is not in place in the Divisions
UPSRP IDSReport No. 16
A Policy Development and Institutional Study for UPPWD was undertaken by TCE.
The Final Report, published in June 2002, listed thefollowing weaknesses in the UP PWD budgetingsystem:
UPSRP IDSReport No. 16
• Budgets are used as compliance monitoring tools• Budgets are used as compliance monitoring tools for spending limits and physical progress.
• Hindrances in Budget preparation due to non availability of relevant dataavailability of relevant data
• 80% of the budget is allocated to continuing works80% of the budget is allocated to continuing works and still they do not provoke cost minimization or better contract managementbetter contract management.
• Cash budgeting is not in place in the DivisionsCash budgeting is not in place in the Divisions
UPSRP IDSReport No. 16
In order to mitigate theses deficiencies the TCE Report made the following recommendations:
Budgets to account for contingencies and strategies dealing with them.
Budgets to be continuously revised and revalidated against the actual expenditure and initiate corrective actions with eachactual expenditure and initiate corrective actions with each revalidation.
UPSRP IDSReport No. 16
The budgeting system should facilitate the process of decision making, the system to be designed to serve the following:
• Authorization of actions and spending limits delegation of• Authorization of actions and spending limits, delegation of responsibilities
• Forecasting and financial planning of the PWD operating• Forecasting and financial planning of the PWD operating plan
• Coordinating mechanism• Coordinating mechanism• Means to motivate the organization for cost and quality
f• Performance evaluation tool by setting standards and benchmarks
UPSRP IDSReport No. 16
I th b d ti th h i di l iImprove the budgeting process through periodical review and analysis of the feedback of the implementation from the fieldthe field.
Introduce cash budgeting at Circle level. Cash budgets have to be collated for the state at PWD HQ.
R i i f b d t d i ith t tRevision of budgets and variances with respect to new factors like cost minimization, output quality, and contract managementcontract management
UPSRP IDSReport No. 16
With th h l f t ti d t b h k t d dWith the help of cost accounting data, bench mark standard costs across the whole state.
Systematic data collection in consonance with the budgeting requirements and proper follow up.
Budgeting system to help in prioritizing the works.
Evolve a comprehensive financial management and budgeting systembudgeting system
UPSRP IDSReport No. 16
Deficiencies in the Existing System
Although it may not be a deficiency in the existing budgeting andcost control system the whole process of determining which roadsto construct and which to repair is fraught with problems.
These can only be realistically addressed once the PWD hasThese can only be realistically addressed once the PWD hasestablished a Road Network Master Plan and implemented aroad maintenance management system. All new constructionroad maintenance management system. All new constructionwork should be in accordance with the Master Plan, and all roadmaintenance work should be needs based and prioritised oneconomic grounds using the road maintenance managementsystem.
UPSRP IDSReport No. 16
Objectives of IT Based Budgeting and Cost ControlObjectives of IT Based Budgeting and Cost Control
These advantage of a computerised system can be summarised as follows:
1. With the proposed computerisation of the budget system effective decision making at various levels in PWD will be possible due to accurate and timely supply of i f tiinformation.
2. Reports based on computerised data processing should be t d i t h dl d d imore accurate and easier to handle and produce in
specific report formats.
UPSRP IDSReport No. 16
3. The Budget estimates can be prepared using comprehensive t d t h ld i ll d i d d t b hi h bcost data held in a well designed database which can be
reviewed and updated to present value 4 Th b d ti d ti t b th h l f4. The budgeting and costing system can embrace the whole of
PWD, or more probably a Zone. Cost data generated in the Divisions can be fed into the database so that the cost dataDivisions can be fed into the database so that the cost data used in the Zones to prepare the cost estimates is always up to date.
5. A computerised budgeting and cost control system should enable the PWD Zones to prepare detailed annual budgets which can also indicate the probable timing of the required funds.
UPSRP IDSReport No. 16
6 Estimates Budgets Sanctioned Amounts and Allotments can6. Estimates, Budgets, Sanctioned Amounts, and Allotments can be recorded for Plan Works - Roads and Structures, Non-Plan Works - Roads and Structures, and Establishment -,Plan and Non-Plan. This will provide specific cost information that can aid management decision making.
7. On a monthly basis the Zone can review its budget requirements and consider the most appropriate way to h dl j di i b t f t dhandle any major discrepancies between forecast and actual budget requirements. This is particularly relevant to budgets for Non-Plan works when any unspent money hasbudgets for Non-Plan works when any unspent money has to be surrendered at the end of the financial year.
UPSRP IDSReport No. 16
A i f f h b d i d f b th PWDA series of forms have been designed for use by the PWD.
These forms split work into Plan and Non-PlanThese forms split work into Plan and Non Plan
Further sub-divisions into Roads, Structures, Establishment
OBJECTIVE: to enable Senior PWD staff to make decisions based on accurate financial informationbased on accurate financial information
UPSRP IDSReport No. 16
IMPLEMENTATION PROCESS
The implementation process must be carefully plannedand monitored. In each and every aspect ofy pimplementation there must be frequent inter-actionbetween the Consultant undertaking the writing of theg gnecessary software program and the PWD.
The lessons learnt in the past must not be ignored butused to re-affirm the need for the Consultant and thePWD to work together in harmony.
UPSRP IDSReport No. 16
IMPLEMENTATION PROCESS
The computerisation process must be broken down into what can b t d SMART t kbe termed SMART tasks.
S SpecificS Specific
M Measurable
A Achievable
R Relevant
T Timely
UPSRP IDSReport No. 16
DO NOT ATTEMPT TO COMPUTERISE THE WHOLE SYSTEM IN ONE GO
BREAK THE SYSTEM DOWN INTO COMPONENTS, such as Establishment
START in ONE DIVISION and DEVELOP ONE COMPONENT
WHEN COMPLETE TRY THE COMPONENT IN ANOTHER DIVISION IN SAME ZONE
IF ALL IS WELL INSTAL COMPONENT IN ZONE.
MONITOR FREQUENTLY WHILE DEVELOPING THE NEXT COMPONENT.
REPEAT PROCESS and INSTAL COMPONENT IN ALLREPEAT PROCESS and INSTAL COMPONENT IN ALL ZONES
UPSRP IDSReport No. 16
IMPLEMENTATION PROCESS
The implementation process must be carefully plannedand monitored. In each and every aspect ofy pimplementation there must be frequent inter-actionbetween the Consultant undertaking the writing of theg gnecessary software program and the PWD.
The lessons learnt in the past must not be ignored butused to re-affirm the need for the Consultant and thePWD to work together in harmony.
UPSRP IDSReport No. 16
IMPLEMENTATION PROCESS
Train Senior PWD Staff so that they understand Financial Management Systems and can use them inFinancial Management Systems and can use them in
effective decision making.
ANNEXURE - 1 : EXISTING BUDGET FORMS
Technical Assistance for Implementation of Institutional Reforms in Road Sector of Uttar Pradesh Report No. 16
May 2008 i
B.M. - 1 (Part - I) Referred to in paragraph 19, 24 & 55 (b)
Abstract Statement showing the estimates for the year under Grant No. "--------------------------" Revenue Capital Total
(Rs. in Thousand)
Voted : ................................................. .......................................................... ..................................................
Charged : ................................................. .......................................................... ..................................................
Major Head (Revenue & Capital
Separately also voted & charged)
Actual expenditure of Last Year…….
Budget estimate of Current Year……
Actual expenditure from April to September of
Current Year…… Budget estimate of Proposed Year……
Final Provision made by Finance Dept.
Plan Non plan Plan Non Plan Plan Non Plan Plan Non Plan Plan Non Plan
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11
Technical Assistance for Implementation of Institutional Reforms in Road Sector of Uttar Pradesh Report No. 16
May 2008 ii
Form B.M. - 1 (Part - II) Statement showing the detailed estimates for year………..under Grant No……………….
Description of Head of Account (For each Scheme / Provisions)
Major Head : ........................... Sub Major Head : ................................. Minor Head : ............................. Sub Head : ....................... Detail Head : ..........................
(Rs. in Thousands)
Items Code & Name (Say 01 Pay)
Actual Expenditure of last Year ........
Budget Estimates of Current Year ……
Actual Expenditure from April to September of
Current Year ....... Budget Estimate of Proposed Year ........
Final Provision made by the Finance Dept.
Plan Non plan Plan Non Plan Plan Non Plan Plan Non Plan Plan Non Plan
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11
Technical Assistance for Implementation of Institutional Reforms in Road Sector of Uttar Pradesh Report No. 16
May 2008 iii
Form - B.M. 4 (Referred to in Paragraph 54 : 140)
Excess Saving Statement
Grant No : ................. Major Head : ................... Sub Major Head : .................... Minor Head : ........................ Sub Head : ....................... Detail Head : ................
(Rs. in Thousands)
Items Code & Name
(Say 01 Pay)
Budget Provision
Actual Expenditure up to the month (1 April to 30 September) and
final from April to December)
Revised Estimate of Expenditure for whole
year Excess (+)
(Difference Revised) Saving (-) Proposed Remarks / Re-appropriation or Surrender
with reference Plan Non Plan Plan Non Plan Plan Non Plan Plan Non Plan Plan Non Plan
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12
Technical Assistance for Implementation of Institutional Reforms in Road Sector of Uttar Pradesh Report No. 16
May 2008 iv
Form B.M. - 5 (Referred to in paragraph - 69)
Schedule of New Expenditure for the year………..
Name of Organization : ............................................... Administrative Deptt. Secretariat : ....................................... Major Concept / Scheme : ...............................
Head of Account as per Budget literature level:
Grant No : ................. Major Head : ................... Sub Major Head : .................... Minor Head : ........................ Sub Head : ....................... Detail Head : ................
(Rs. in Thousand)
Items name (say purchase
of Machine)
Part - I (Recurring Expenditure)
Part - II (Non- recurring Expenditure) Corresponding
Receipts (indicate
source; say Central,
Foreign, etc.)
Remarks & Justification
in short Cost in Budget
year… Ultimate Cost as
far as ascertained Aggregate Cost Cost in Budget year…
Ultimate Cost as far as ascertained
Plan Non Plan Plan Non
Plan Plan Non Plan Plan Non
Plan Plan Non Plan
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13
Technical Assistance for Implementation of Institutional Reforms in Road Sector of Uttar Pradesh Report No. 16
May 2008 v
Form B.M. - 6 (Referred to in Paragraph 100 and 103)
Statement of Receipts for the Month………. Year…………
Unit : .......................................... Controlling officer : ........................................................ Administrative Dept. In Secretariat : .......................................................
Description of Class : ................................................................ (Say Tax Revenue, Non Tax Revenue, Public Account on Separate Statement)
Major Head : ........................... Sub Major Head : ................................. Minor Head : ............................. Sub Head : ....................... Detail Head : ..........................
(Rs. in Thousands)
Sl. No.
Budget Estimate During Year…
Target for the Month
being reported
Target up to the Month
(Progressive)
Target achieved
for the month
Target achieved up to the month (Progressive)
Percentage achieved of
Budget Estimates
Budget Estimate of last year…
(Just Before Current)
Target achieved last year for the
month (c.f. column-8)
Target achieved in the
same period (progressive) last year…..
(c.f. column -8)
Percentage achieved
during same
period last year
Remarks (indicating cause of downfall
etc.)
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12
N.B. The controlling officer must compile the receipts of different units/schemes under his control. Accountant General will report on this format to Finance Department with specific comments on the Revenue receipt and Public Account.
Technical Assistance for Implementation of Institutional Reforms in Road Sector of Uttar Pradesh Report No. 16
May 2008 vi
Form B.M. – 7 Liability Register/Form
(Referred to in Paragraph 104,116 and 118)
Unit : .......................................... Controlling officer : ........................................................ Administrative Dept. In Secretariat : .......................................................
Grant No : ................. Major Head : ................... Sub Major Head : .................... Minor Head : ........................ Sub Head : ....................... Detail Head : ................
(Rs. in Thousands)
Sl. No.
Nature of
liability
Circumstances in which
liability created
Rules & orders under which
liability created
Estimated cost of liability
Liabilities created prior to
proposed liability
Total Liability
If liability of State Govt.
name of office &
Dept.
Probable Date/
Month in which the liability is
to be cleared.
Name & Designation
of officer who created
liability
Detail of Liability already cleared.
Balance Liability
(Col 7 – Col 11)
Remarks (Adjustment & Irregularities)
Plan Non Plan Plan Non
Plan Plan Non Plan Plan Non
Plan Plan Non Plan
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13
Technical Assistance for Implementation of Institutional Reforms in Road Sector of Uttar Pradesh Report No. 16
May 2008 vii
Form B.M. - 8 (Referred to in paragraph 112,116 & 118)
Scheme-wise : Disbursing Officer Register Of Expenditure Office : .............................. District :.................................. Month : ...................................... Year : .......................................... Grant No : ................................ Plan or Non-Plan (on separate register)
Amount in Rs.
Voucher No. Date
Description from Major
Head to Detail Head
(13 Digit Code)
ITEMS (Standard Object as per budget literature and write code and name in each column) Total Remarks
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15
Rs. Rs. Rs. Rs. Rs. Rs. Rs. Rs. Rs. Rs. Rs. Rs. Rs. Rs. Rs.
Standard object wise monthly total of each scheme Expenditure up to previous month Progressive total up to current month Up to date allotment of budget Balance in the budget after progressive expenditure upto current month
Technical Assistance for Implementation of Institutional Reforms in Road Sector of Uttar Pradesh Report No. 16
May 2008 viii
Form B.M. - 9 (Referred to in paragraph 112 to 117 & 129)
Reconciliation Statement
Name of D.D.O : .................................. Month : ............................................... Year : ......................................................... Grant No : ........................................
Amount in Rs.
Voucher No. Date
Description (15 digit code) major head to
standard object.
Sector (Plan / Non Plan, District
/ State etc)
Gross amount
of Voucher
Total Deductions Cheque No. Date on which
cheque issued Cheque Amount
Remark of DDO for
correction
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10
Sig. T. O…………………………………… Sig. D.D.O.…………………………………
Technical Assistance for Implementation of Institutional Reforms in Road Sector of Uttar Pradesh Report No. 16
May 2008 ix
Form B.M. – 10 Broad Sheet of Controlling Officer
(Referred to in paragraph 117)
Office of Controlling Officer : ..........................................................................................
Sl. No.
Description of Return
Designation of officer liable to send the return
April May June July August Sept. Oct. Nov. Dec. Jan. Feb. March
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12
Note : Controlling Officer must watch the receipt of returns every month as per para 117 of the budget manual.
Technical Assistance for Implementation of Institutional Reforms in Road Sector of Uttar Pradesh Report No. 16
May 2008 x
Form B.M. - 11 (Referred to in paragraph 118)
Scheme-wise : Monthly Expenditure Register of Controlling Officer
Month : ............................................................................... Year : ................................................................................. Grant No : ....................................................
Major Head : ........................... Sub Major Head : ................................. Minor Head : ............................. Sub Head : ....................... Detail Head : ..........................
Amount in Rs.
Sl. No.
Designation of disbursing officer ITEMS (Standard Object code & name in separate column; P. for Plan & N.P. for Non-Plan) Remark
Plan Non Plan Plan Non Plan Plan Non Plan Plan Non Plan Plan Non Plan
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13
Total of the Month Expenditure up to Previous Month Progressive total up to current Month Up to date Allotted Budget Balance in the Budget after Progressive expenditure up to current month
Technical Assistance for Implementation of Institutional Reforms in Road Sector of Uttar Pradesh Report No. 16
May 2008 xi
Form B.M. – 12 Monthly return to Accountant General by Controlling Officer
(Referred to in paragraphs 119&123)
Controlling Officer : ................................................. Month : .................................................... Year : ..................................... Grant No : .....................................
Major Head : ........................... Sub Major Head : ................................. Minor Head : ............................. Sub Head : ....................... Detail Head : ..........................
Standard Object
wise code and name
Budget provision Year ........
Expenditure in the Month .......
Expenditure up to Current Month ......
(progressive) including adjustment
Liabilities beyond budget provision Details of Adjustment Remark
Plan Non Plan Plan Non Plan Plan Non Plan Plan Non Plan Plan Non Plan
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12
Note -1 : Originally copy of B.M. - 8 is attached with this Statement to Accountant General Note -2 : Any adjustment or cause of liability must be shown in remark column
Note -3 : Compilation at Grant, Major Head, Sub Major Head, Minor Head must be shown against provision in Budget Literature of issuing Year.
Technical Assistance for Implementation of Institutional Reforms in Road Sector of Uttar Pradesh Report No. 16
May 2008 xii
Form B.M. – 13 Progressive Expenditure Statement of Controlling Officer
(Referred to in paragraphs 122)
Controlling Officer : ................................................. Month : .................................................... Year : ..................................... Grant No : .....................................
Major Head : ........................... Sub Major Head : ................................. Minor Head : ............................. Sub Head : ....................... Detail Head : ..........................
(Rs. in Thousands)
Standard Object wise
code and name
Total Budget provision for the Year ........
Budget allotted against the provision
Expenditure up to the Month (progressive)
Percentage Expenditure Detail of expenditure of previous Year......... Estimated
variation Excess (+) Saving (-) Remarks Of total
Budget Allotted Budget
Total Budget
Actual Expenditure
Percentage Expenditure
Plan Non Plan Plan Non
Plan Plan Non Plan Plan Non
Plan Plan Non Plan Plan Non
Plan Plan Non Plan Plan Non
Plan Plan Non Plan
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20
Technical Assistance for Implementation of Institutional Reforms in Road Sector of Uttar Pradesh Report No. 16
May 2008 xiii
Form B.M. 15 Re-appropriation Statement (Referred in paragraph 158)
Controlling Officer : ................................................................... Administrative Department : .................................................. Grant No : .........................................
(Voted or Charged on Separate Register) (Rs. in Thousands)
Total Budget Provision
Major Head
Sub Major Head
Minor Head
Sub Head
Detailed Head
Standard Object
Rs.
Standard Object Wise
(Expenditure upto)
Current Month ……..
Rs.
Anticipated Expenditure for the remaining part of the year
Rs.
Surplus Amount
Rs.
Proposed Transfer of Fund to Head of Accounts ;
Major Head …………
Sub Major Head …….
Minor Head ………….
Sub Head……………
Detail Head………….
Standard Object ……….
Rs.
Amount available after re-appropriation in head of account shown in column – 5
Rs.
Amount balance in head of account shown in column -1 after re-appropriation
Rs.
Remark & Justification. In case of works dept. amount of sanctioned estimate and outlay should be enclosed.
Plan N-Plan Plan Non-Plan Plan Non-plan Plan Non-plan Plan Non-Plan Plan Non-Plan Plan Non-Plan
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8
. Signature of Controlling Officer Date ……………..
Technical Assistance for Implementation of Institutional Reforms in Road Sector of Uttar Pradesh Report No. 16
May 2008 xiv
Form B.M. 17 Budget Control Register (Referred in paragraph 91)
Grant No. : .............................................................
Name of Administrative Department : ...................................................................... Plan/Non-Plan
Detail of Heads of Account Date & G.O. No. of the Budget Allotment to Head of Department/Controlling Officer
Major Head …………………………………..….. 1. ……………………………………….…………………
Sub-Major Head …………………………………..….. 2. ………………………………………..…………………
Minor Head …………………………………..….. 3. ………………………………………..…………………
Sub-head …………………………………..….. 4. ………………………………………..…………………
Detail head …………………………………..….. 5. ………………………………………..…………………
Budget at the disposal of Controlling Officer/Head of Department
Standard Object
Budget allotted by Controlling Officer/Head of Department to sub-ordinate offices
Amount1 Amount2 Amount3 Amount4 Amount5 Amount1 Amount2 Amount3 Amount4 Amount5
01-Pay
02-Wages
03-DA
................
................
45-LTC
Total :
Date and allotment order number of controlling officer/Head of Department to sub-ordinate offices:
1. ....................................................... 2. ....................................................... 3. ....................................................... 4. ....................................................... 5. ....................................................... Note : 1. The progressive total of the allotted amount should be shown in bracket. 2. Separate page shall be allotted for Plan & Non-Plan budget
ANNEXURE - 2 : PROPOSED BUDGET FORMS
Technical Assistance for Implementation of Institutional Reforms in Road Sector of Uttar Pradesh Report No. 16
May 2008 i
ESTIMATE DETAILS: PLAN - ROADS PWD BM - 110 / 1
Zone: …………….. ................... Circle : .............................. .. District: …………………………… Division: .................................. .. Month ........................
Grant No.: ……..…….. Voted / Charged: ………….……… Revenue / Capital: …………….……… Scheme :…………….………… Financial Year: ……………..
(Rs. Thousands)
Sl. No.
Head Details
(15 Digit Code)
PWD ID Code Name of work Sanctioned
Cost
Actual Expenditureup to Last Year.....…
Budget Estimates
for Current
Year.....….
Actual Expenditure from April to September of
Current Year…...
Revised Budget
Estimate for Current
Year ………
Budget Estimate for
Proposed Year…...... (5 - 6 - 9)
Final Provision
made by the Finance Dept.
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11
Note:
Step - 1 : Form generated at Division level and submitted to Circle Step - 2 : Circle to scrutinize, compile and forward the estimate to Zone Step - 3 : Zone to scrutinize, compile and forward the estimate to PWD HQ (Finance Manager - Accounts and Budgeting Cell) Step - 4 : PWD HQ to scrutinize, compile and submit the estimate to GoUP for sanction
Technical Assistance for Implementation of Institutional Reforms in Road Sector of Uttar Pradesh Report No. 16
May 2008 ii
ESTIMATE DETAILS: PLAN - STRUCTURES PWD BM - 110 / 2
Zone: …………….. ................... Circle : .............................. .. District: …………………………… Division: .................................. .. Month ........................
Grant No.: ……..…….. Voted / Charged: ………….……… Revenue / Capital: …………….……… Scheme :…………….………… Financial Year: ……………..
(Rs. Thousands)
Sl. No.
Head Details
(15 Digit Code)
PWD ID Code Name of work Sanctioned
Cost
Actual Expenditureup to Last Year.....…
Budget Estimates
for Current
Year.....….
Actual Expenditure from April to September of
Current Year…....
Revised Budget
Estimate for Current
Year ……..
Budget Estimate for
Proposed Year…...... (5 - 6 - 9)
Final Provision
made by the Finance Dept.
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11
Note:
Step - 1 : Form generated at Division level and submitted to Circle Step - 2 : Circle to scrutinize, compile and forward the estimate to Zone Step - 3 : Zone to scrutinize, compile and forward the estimate to PWD HQ (Finance Manager - Accounts and Budgeting Cell) Step - 4 : PWD HQ to scrutinize, compile and submit the estimate to GoUP for sanction
Technical Assistance for Implementation of Institutional Reforms in Road Sector of Uttar Pradesh Report No. 16
May 2008 iii
ESTIMATE DETAILS: NON-PLAN - ROADS PWD BM - 120 / 1
Zone: …………….. ................... Circle : .............................. .. District: …………………………… Division: .................................. .. Month ........................
Grant No.: ……..…….. Voted / Charged: ………….……… Revenue / Capital: …………….……… Scheme :…………….………… Financial Year: ……………..
(Rs. Thousands)
Sl. No.
Head Details
(15 Digit Code)
PWD ID Code Name of work
Actual Expenditure during last year…….
Budget Estimates for
Current Year……..
Actual Expenditure from April to September of
Current Year……
Revised Budget
Estimate for Current
Year ……..
Budget Estimate for
Proposed Year…….
Final Provision
made by the Finance Dept.
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10
Note:
Step - 1 : Form generated at Division level and submitted to Circle Step - 2 : Circle to scrutinize, compile and forward the estimate to Zone Step - 3 : Zone to scrutinize, compile and forward the estimate to PWD HQ (Finance Manager - Accounts and Budgeting Cell) Step - 4 : PWD HQ to scrutinize, compile and submit the estimate to GoUP for sanction
Technical Assistance for Implementation of Institutional Reforms in Road Sector of Uttar Pradesh Report No. 16
May 2008 iv
ESTIMATE DETAILS: NON-PLAN - STRUCTURES PWD BM - 120 / 2
Zone: …………….. ................... Circle : .............................. .. District: …………………………… Division: .................................. .. Month ........................
Grant No.: ……..…….. Voted / Charged: ………….……… Revenue / Capital: …………….……… Scheme :…………….………… Financial Year: ……………..
(Rs. Thousands)
Sl. No.
Head Details
(15 Digit Code)
PWD ID Code Name of work
Actual Expenditure during last year……
Budget Estimates for
Current Year…….
Actual Expenditure from April to September of
Current Year……
Revised Budget
Estimate for Current
Year ……..
Budget Estimate for
Proposed Year……
Final Provision
made by the Finance Dept.
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10
Note:
Step - 1 : Form generated at Division level and submitted to Circle Step - 2 : Circle to scrutinize, compile and forward the estimate to Zone Step - 3 : Zone to scrutinize, compile and forward the estimate to PWD HQ (Finance Manager - Accounts and Budgeting Cell) Step - 4 : PWD HQ to scrutinize, compile and submit the estimate to GoUP for sanction
Technical Assistance for Implementation of Institutional Reforms in Road Sector of Uttar Pradesh Report No. 16
May 2008 v
BUDGET REQUIREMENT: NON PLAN – ROADS: ROUTINE MAINTENANCE PWD BM - 130 / 1
Zone: ……………………… Circle: ……………………………….. District: …………………………………. Division: ………………………… Financial Year: ………..
(Rs Thousands)
S. No.
PWD ID Type of Road
(SH, MDR, ODR, VR)
Location Reference Point Length of Road (kms)
Total Fund Required
(Rs. in ThousandsComments
Start Finish
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8
Note:
Column 8: Comments: these comments should relate to the type of maintenance treatment required Step - 1 : Form generated at Division level and submitted to Circle Step - 2 : Circle to scrutinize, compile and forward the estimate to Zone Step - 3 : Zone to scrutinize, compile and forward the estimate to PWD HQ (Finance Manager - Accounts and Budgeting Cell)
Technical Assistance for Implementation of Institutional Reforms in Road Sector of Uttar Pradesh Report No. 16
May 2008 vi
BUDGET REQUIREMENT: NON PLAN – ROADS: PERIODIC MAINTENANCE / REHABILITATION PWD BM - 130 / 2
Zone: ……………………… Circle: ……………………………….. District: …………………………………. Division: ………………………… Financial Year: ………..
(Rs Thousands)
S. No.
PWD ID Type of Road
(SH, MDR, ODR, VR)
Location Reference Point Length of Road (kms)
Total Fund Required
(Rs. in ThousandsComments
Start Finish
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8
Note:
Column 8: Comments: these comments should relate to the type of periodic maintenance / rehabilitation treatment required Step - 1 : Form generated at Division level and submitted to Circle Step - 2 : Circle to scrutinize, compile and forward the estimate to Zone Step - 3 : Zone to scrutinize, compile and forward the estimate to PWD HQ (Finance Manager - Accounts and Budgeting Cell)
Technical Assistance for Implementation of Institutional Reforms in Road Sector of Uttar Pradesh Report No. 16
May 2008 vii
BUDGET REQUIREMENT: NON PLAN – ROADS: SPECIAL REPAIR / RECONSTRUCTION PWD BM - 130 / 3
Zone: ……………………… Circle: ……………………………….. District: …………………………………. Division: ………………………… Financial Year: ………..
(Rs Thousands)
S. No.
PWD ID Type of Road
(SH, MDR, ODR, VR)
Location Reference Point Length of Road (kms)
Total Fund Required
(Rs. in ThousandsComments
Start Finish
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8
Note:
Column 8: Comments: these comments should relate to the Special Repair / Reconstruction required Step - 1 : Form generated at Division level and submitted to Circle Step - 2 : Circle to scrutinize, compile and forward the estimate to Zone Step - 3 : Zone to scrutinize, compile and forward the estimate to PWD HQ (Finance Manager - Accounts and Budgeting Cell)
Technical Assistance for Implementation of Institutional Reforms in Road Sector of Uttar Pradesh Report No. 16
May 2008 viii
BUDGET REQUIREMENT: NON-PLAN - STRUCTURES: MAINTENANCE PWD BM - 130 / 4
Zone: ……………………… Circle: ……………………………….. District: …………………………………. Division: ………………………… Financial Year: ………..
(Rs Thousands)
S. No.
PWD ID
Road and km
Type of Structure (Type of Bridge, Culvert,
Retaining Wall, etc.)
Ave. height
in metres
Location Reference Points
Length of Structure
metres
Length of approaches in metres
Maintenance Funding Required (Routine, Periodic,
Other)
Total Funding
Required for Each
Structure Rs.
Thousands
Remarks Start Finish Increase km side
Decreasekm side
Total Kms.
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14
Note:
Column 4: Details with respect to the type of structure to be entered in this Column.
Column 12: Details with respect to type of maintenance work to be carried out given in this column – one row for each different funding requirement
Column 13: This should be the total funding required for each structure
Column 14: This should be used to provide greater details of the type / form of maintenance work required Step - 1 : Form generated at Division level and submitted to Circle Step - 2 : Circle to scrutinize, compile and forward the estimate to Zone Step - 3 : Zone to scrutinize, compile and forward the estimate to PWD HQ (Finance Manager - Accounts and Budgeting Cell)
Technical Assistance for Implementation of Institutional Reforms in Road Sector of Uttar Pradesh Report No. 16
May 2008 ix
BUDGET REQUIREMENT: NON-PLAN - ESTABLISHMENT: HUMAN RESOURCE EXPENSES PWD BM - 140 / 1
Financial Year : ........................ Zone : ................................... Circle : ................................. Division : ............................. Month : .........................................
Grant No : ...................................................... (Rs. Thousands)
Sl. N
o.
Hea
d D
etai
ls (1
5 D
igit
Cod
e)
PWD
ID C
ode
Sala
ry
Dea
rnes
s Sa
lary
Dea
rnes
s A
llow
ance
CC
A
HR
A
Oth
er A
llow
ance
Inte
rim R
elie
f
Aux
iliar
y A
llotm
ent f
or
pay
and
allo
wan
ce
Trav
ellin
g A
llow
ance
Tran
sfer
Tra
vel
Expe
nditu
re
Trav
el A
llow
ance
for
Trai
ning
etc
.
Leav
e Tr
avel
C
once
ssio
n Ex
pend
iture
Med
ical
Exp
ense
s
Uni
form
Exp
endi
ture
Tota
l (R
s. in
Tho
usan
ds)
(01) (50) (03) (02) (06) (04) (38) (43) (05) (44) (45) (49) (51) 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18
Note:
(A) Step - 1 : Form generated at Division level and submitted to Circle Step - 2 : Circle to scrutinize, compile and forward the estimate to Zone Step - 3 : Zone to scrutinize, compile and forward the estimate to PWD HQ (Finance Manager - Accounts and Budgeting Cell) Step - 4 : PWD HQ to scrutinize, compile and submit the estimate to GoUP for sanction (B) The same format will be generated at Circle / Zone / PWD HQ level for Budgets requirement for their respective offices and will be submitted finally to GoUP
through proper channel.
Technical Assistance for Implementation of Institutional Reforms in Road Sector of Uttar Pradesh Report No. 16
May 2008 x
BUDGET REQUIREMENT: NON-PLAN - ESTABLISHMENT: OFFICE RUNNING COSTS PWD BM - 140 / 2
Financial Year : ........................ Zone : ................................... Circle : ................................. Division : ............................. Month : .........................................
Grant No : ...................................................... (Rs. in Thousands)
Sl. N
o.
Hea
d D
etai
ls (1
5 D
igit
Cod
e)
PWD
ID C
ode
Offi
ce E
xpen
ses
Elec
tric
Due
s
Wat
er T
ax a
nd C
harg
es
Stat
ione
ry M
ater
ial a
nd
Prin
ting
of F
orm
s
Offi
ce F
urni
ture
and
Fi
tting
and
App
lianc
es
Tele
phon
e an
d Fa
x
Mai
nten
ance
of v
ehic
les
and
purc
hase
of p
etro
l /
Die
sel /
Lub
rican
ts e
tc.
Ren
t, su
rcha
rge
and
tax
owne
rshi
p
Med
ical
Rei
mbu
rsem
ent
Hou
se B
uild
ing
Adv
ance
(7
610-
00-2
01-0
4-04
)
Mot
or V
ehic
le A
dvan
ce
Purc
hase
of c
ompu
ter
hard
war
e / s
oftw
are
Mai
nten
ance
of c
ompu
ter
and
purc
hase
of a
llied
st
atio
nery
Mac
hine
s Fu
rnis
hing
and
A
pplia
nce
and
Plan
ts
Publ
icat
ion
Scho
lars
hip
and
Stip
end
Mai
nten
ance
Oth
er E
xpen
ses
Tota
l (R
s. in
Tho
usan
ds)
(08) (09) (10) (11) (12) (13) (15) (17) 49 (K) (46) (47) (26) (18) (21) (29) (42)
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22
Note:
(A) Step - 1 : Form generated at Division level and submitted to Circle Step - 2 : Circle to scrutinize, compile and forward the estimate to Zone Step - 3 : Zone to scrutinize, compile and forward the estimate to PWD HQ (Finance Manager - Accounts and Budgeting Cell) Step - 4 : PWD HQ to scrutinize, compile and submit the estimate to GoUP for sanction (B) The same format will be generated at Circle / Zone / PWD HQ level for Budgets requirement for their respective offices and will be submitted finally to GoUP
through proper channel.
Technical Assistance for Implementation of Institutional Reforms in Road Sector of Uttar Pradesh Report No. 16
May 2008 xi
BUDGET REQUIREMENT: PLAN - NEW ASSET CREATION: BUILDINGS (RESIDENTIAL) PWD BM - 150 / 1
Financial Year: ……………. Zone: ………………………… Circle: …………………………………. District: ……………………….. Division: ………………………….
Grant No : .................................................... Major Head of Accounts ................................ : (Rs. in Thousands)
Sl. No. Name and Type of
Buildings (Residential) Estimated Cost Sanctioned Cost
Expenditure till previous
financial year
Balance against
sanctioned cost
Demand during current
financial year Remarks
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8
Total
Note:
Step - 1 : Form generated at Division level and submitted to Circle Step - 2 : Circle to scrutinize, compile and forward the estimate to Zone Step - 3 : Zone to scrutinize, compile and forward the estimate to PWD HQ (Finance Manager - Accounts and Budgeting Cell) Step - 4 : PWD HQ to scrutinize, compile and submit the estimate to GoUP for sanction
Technical Assistance for Implementation of Institutional Reforms in Road Sector of Uttar Pradesh Report No. 16
May 2008 xii
BUDGET REQUIREMENT: PLAN - NEW ASSET CREATION: BUILDINGS (NON-RESIDENTIAL) PWD BM - 150 / 2
Financial Year: ……………. Zone: ………………………… Circle: …………………………………. District: ……………………….. Division: ………………………….
Grant No : .................................................... Major Head of Accounts ................................ : (Rs. in Thousands)
Sl. No. Name and Type of
Buildings (Non-Residential) Estimated Cost Sanctioned Cost
Expenditure till previous
financial year
Balance against
sanctioned cost
Demand during current
financial year Remarks
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8
Total
Note:
Step - 1 : Form generated at Division level and submitted to Circle Step - 2 : Circle to scrutinize, compile and forward the estimate to Zone Step - 3 : Zone to scrutinize, compile and forward the estimate to PWD HQ (Finance Manager - Accounts and Budgeting Cell) Step - 4 : PWD HQ to scrutinize, compile and submit the estimate to GoUP for sanction
Technical Assistance for Implementation of Institutional Reforms in Road Sector of Uttar Pradesh Report No. 16
May 2008 xiii
BUDGET REQUIREMENT: PLAN - NEW ASSET CREATION: VEHICLES PWD BM - 150 / 3
Financial Year : ........................................................ Zone : .................................................................... Circle : ............................................................................
Division : .................................................... Grant No : .................................................... Major Head of Accounts : ...................................................................
(Rs. in Thousands)
Sl. No. Type of Vehicle No. of Vehicle Cost Remarks
1 2 3 4 5
Total
Note:
Step - 1 : Form generated at Division level and submitted to Circle Step - 2 : Circle to scrutinize, compile and forward the estimate to Zone Step - 3 : Zone to scrutinize, compile and forward the estimate to PWD HQ (Finance Manager - Accounts and Budgeting Cell) Step - 4 : PWD HQ to scrutinize, compile and submit the estimate to GoUP for sanction
Technical Assistance for Implementation of Institutional Reforms in Road Sector of Uttar Pradesh Report No. 16
May 2008 xiv
BUDGET REQUIREMENT: PLAN - NEW ASSET CREATION: PLANT AND EQUIPMENT PWD BM - 150 / 4
Financial Year : ........................................................ Zone : .................................................................... Circle : ............................................................................
Division : .................................................... Grant No : .................................................... Major Head of Accounts : ...................................................................
(Rs. in Thousands)
Sl. No. Name of Plant / Equipment No. of Plant and Equipment Cost Remarks
1 2 3 4
Total
Note:
Step - 1 : Form generated at Division level and submitted to Circle Step - 2 : Circle to scrutinize, compile and forward the estimate to Zone Step - 3 : Zone to scrutinize, compile and forward the estimate to PWD HQ (Finance Manager - Accounts and Budgeting Cell) Step - 4 : PWD HQ to scrutinize, compile and submit the estimate to GoUP for sanction
Technical Assistance for Implementation of Institutional Reforms in Road Sector of Uttar Pradesh Report No. 16
May 2008 xv
BUDGET REQUIREMENT: NON-PLAN - ASSETS: MAINTENANCE BUILDINGS (RESIDENTIAL) PWD BM - 160 / 1
Financial Year : ........................................................ Zone : .................................................................... Circle : ............................................................................
Division : .................................................... Grant No : .................................................... Major Head of Accounts : ...................................................................
(Rs. in Thousands)
Sl. No. Name of Building (Residential) Plinth Area (sq.m) Funds Required Remarks
1 2 2 3 4
Total
Note:
Step - 1 : Form generated at Division level and submitted to Circle Step - 2 : Circle to scrutinize, compile and forward the estimate to Zone Step - 3 : Zone to scrutinize, compile and forward the estimate to PWD HQ (Finance Manager - Accounts and Budgeting Cell) Step - 4 : PWD HQ to scrutinize, compile and submit the estimate to GoUP for sanction
Technical Assistance for Implementation of Institutional Reforms in Road Sector of Uttar Pradesh Report No. 16
May 2008 xvi
BUDGET REQUIREMENT: NON-PLAN -ASSETS: MAINTENANCE BUILDINGS (NON-RESIDENTIAL) PWD BM - 160 / 2
Financial Year : ........................................................ Zone : .................................................................... Circle : ............................................................................
Division : .................................................... Grant No : .................................................... Major Head of Accounts : ...................................................................
(Rs. in Thousands)
Sl. No. Name of Building (Non-Residential) Plinth Area (sq.m) Funds Required Remarks
1 2 2 3 4
Total
Note:
Step - 1 : Form generated at Division level and submitted to Circle Step - 2 : Circle to scrutinize, compile and forward the estimate to Zone Step - 3 : Zone to scrutinize, compile and forward the estimate to PWD HQ (Finance Manager - Accounts and Budgeting Cell) Step - 4 : PWD HQ to scrutinize, compile and submit the estimate to GoUP for sanction
Technical Assistance for Implementation of Institutional Reforms in Road Sector of Uttar Pradesh Report No. 16
May 2008 xvii
BUDGET REQUIREMENT: NON-PLAN - ASSETS: MAINTENANCE VEHICLES PWD BM - 160 / 3
Financial Year : ........................................................ Zone : .................................................................... Circle : ............................................................................
Division : .................................................... Grant No : .................................................... Major Head of Accounts : ...................................................................
(Rs. in Thousands)
Sl. No. Type of Vehicle No. of Vehicle Funds Required Remarks
1 2 3 4 5
Total
Note:
Step - 1 : Form generated at Division level and submitted to Circle Step - 2 : Circle to scrutinize, compile and forward the estimate to Zone Step - 3 : Zone to scrutinize, compile and forward the estimate to PWD HQ (Finance Manager - Accounts and Budgeting Cell) Step - 4 : PWD HQ to scrutinize, compile and submit the estimate to GoUP for sanction
Technical Assistance for Implementation of Institutional Reforms in Road Sector of Uttar Pradesh Report No. 16
May 2008 xviii
BUDGET REQUIREMENT: NON-PLAN - ASSETS: MAINTENANCE PLANT AND EQUIPMENT PWD BM - 160 / 4
Financial Year : ........................................................ Zone : .................................................................... Circle : ............................................................................
Division : .................................................... Grant No : .................................................... Major Head of Accounts : ...................................................................
(Rs. in Thousands)
Sl. No. Name of Plant / Equipment No. of Plant / Equipment Funds Required Remarks
1 2 3 4 5
Total
Note:
Step - 1 : Form generated at Division level and submitted to Circle Step - 2 : Circle to scrutinize, compile and forward the estimate to Zone Step - 3 : Zone to scrutinize, compile and forward the estimate to PWD HQ (Finance Manager - Accounts and Budgeting Cell) Step - 4 : PWD HQ to scrutinize, compile and submit the estimate to GoUP for sanction
Technical Assistance for Implementation of Institutional Reforms in Road Sector of Uttar Pradesh Report No. 16
May 2008 xix
SANCTIONED DETAILS FOR FINANCIAL YEAR: PLAN - ROADS PWD BM - 170 / 1
Financial Year of Budget Sanction: .................................. Zone: . .................................... Circle: .. ............................. District: ……………… Division: … ................
Voted / Charged: …………………………… Revenue / Capital: ........ ……………………………… Scheme: ……………………….. Month: ………………………….. ..
(Rs. Thousands)
Sl. No.
Grant No.
Head Details
(15 Digit Code)
PWD ID Code Name of Work
Reference of Financial /
Administrative Approval
Sanctioned Cost
Rs. Thousand
Expenditure up to last
Financial Year
Balance (7-8)
Allocated amount
for Financial Year
Reference of G.O.
No. and date
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11
Generated at Government level and sent to PWD HQ
Technical Assistance for Implementation of Institutional Reforms in Road Sector of Uttar Pradesh Report No. 16
May 2008 xx
SANCTIONED DETAILS FOR FINANCIAL YEAR: PLAN - STRUCTURES PWD BM - 170 / 2
Financial Year of Budget Sanction: .................................. Zone: . .................................... Circle: .. ............................. District: ……………… Division: … ................
Voted / Charged: …………………………… Revenue / Capital: ........ .……………………… Scheme: …………………………..…….. Month: …...………………………
(Rs. Thousands)
Sl. No.
Grant No.
Head Details
(15 Digit Code)
PWD ID Code Name of Work
Reference of Financial /
Administrative Approval
Sanctioned Cost
Rs. Thousand
Expenditure up to last
Financial Year
Balance (7-8)
Allocated amount
for Financial Year
Reference of G.O.
No. and date
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11
Generated at Government level and sent to PWD HQ
Technical Assistance for Implementation of Institutional Reforms in Road Sector of Uttar Pradesh Report No. 16
May 2008 xxi
SANCTIONED DETAILS FOR FINANCIAL YEAR: NON-PLAN - ROADS PWD BM - 180 / 1
Financial Year of Budget Sanction: .................................. Zone: . .................................... Circle: .. ............................. District: ……………… Division: … ................
Voted / Charged: …………………………… Revenue / Capital: ……………………………… Scheme: ……………………………….. Month: …………………………..
(Rs. Thousands)
Sl. No.
Grant No.
Head Details (15 Digit
Code)
PWD ID
Code
Name of Work
Reference of Financial / Administrative
Approval
Sanctioned Cost
Expenditure up to last
Financial Year
Balance (7-8)
Allocated amountfor Financial Year
Reference of G.O. No.
and date
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11
Generated at Government level and come to PWD HQ
Technical Assistance for Implementation of Institutional Reforms in Road Sector of Uttar Pradesh Report No. 16
May 2008 xxii
SANCTIONED DETAILS FOR FINANCIAL YEAR: NON-PLAN - STRUCTURES PWD BM - 180 / 2
Financial Year of Budget Sanction: .................................. Zone: . .................................... Circle:... ............................. District: ……………… Division: … ................
Voted / Charged: …………………………… Revenue / Capital: ……………………………… Scheme: ……………………………….. Month: …………………………..
(Rs. Thousands)
Sl. No.
Grant No.
Head Details (15 Digit
Code)
PWD ID
Code
Name of Work
Reference of Financial / Administrative
Approval
Sanctioned Cost
Expenditure up to last Financial Year
Balance(7-8)
Allocated amountfor Financial Year
Reference of G.O. No.
and date
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11
Generated at Government level and come to PWD HQ
Technical Assistance for Implementation of Institutional Reforms in Road Sector of Uttar Pradesh Report No. 16
May 2008 xxiii
SANCTIONED DETAILS: NON-PLAN - ESTABLISHMENT: HUMAN RESOURCE EXPENSES PWD BM - 190 / 1
Financial Year : ................... PWD HQ : Zone : ......................................... Circle : ............................ Division : ......................... Month : ..................
Grant No. : ...................................................... (Rs. in Thousands)
Sl. N
o.
Hea
d D
etai
ls (1
5 D
igit
Cod
e)
PWD
ID C
ode
Sala
ry
Dea
rnes
s Sa
lary
Dea
rnes
s A
llow
ance
CC
A
HR
A
Oth
er A
llow
ance
Inte
rim R
elie
f
Aux
iliar
y A
llotm
ent f
or
pay
and
allo
wan
ce
Trav
ellin
g A
llow
ance
Tran
sfer
Tra
vel
Expe
nditu
re
Trav
el A
llow
ance
for
Trai
ning
etc
.
Leav
e Tr
avel
C
once
ssio
n Ex
pend
iture
Med
ical
Exp
ense
s
Uni
form
Exp
endi
ture
Tota
l (R
s. in
Tho
usan
ds)
(01) (50) (03) (02) (06) (04) (38) (43) (05) (44) (45) (49) (51) 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18
Generated at Government level and sent to PWD HQ, Zone, Circle and Division
Technical Assistance for Implementation of Institutional Reforms in Road Sector of Uttar Pradesh Report No. 16
May 2008 xxiv
SANCTIONED DETAILS: NON-PLAN - ESTABLISHMENT: OFFICE RUNNING COSTS PWD BM - 190 / 2
Financial Year : ................... PWD HQ : Zone : ......................................... Circle : ......... Division : ......................... Month : ..................
Grant No. : ...................................................... (Rs. in Thousands)
Sl. N
o.
Hea
d D
etai
ls (1
5 D
igit
Cod
e)
PWD
ID C
ode
Offi
ce E
xpen
ses
Elec
tric
Due
s
Wat
er T
ax a
nd C
harg
es
Stat
ione
ry M
ater
ial a
nd
Prin
ting
of F
orm
s
Offi
ce F
urni
ture
and
Fi
tting
and
App
lianc
es
Tele
phon
e an
d Fa
x
Mai
nten
ance
of v
ehic
les
and
purc
hase
of p
etro
l /
Die
sel /
Lub
rican
ts e
tc.
Ren
t, su
rcha
rge
and
tax
owne
rshi
p
Med
ical
Rei
mbu
rsem
ent
Hou
se B
uild
ing
Adv
ance
(7
610-
00-2
01-0
4-04
)
Mot
or V
ehic
le A
dvan
ce
Purc
hase
of c
ompu
ter
hard
war
e / s
oftw
are
Mai
nten
ance
of c
ompu
ter
and
purc
hase
of a
llied
st
atio
nery
Mac
hine
s Fu
rnis
hing
and
A
pplia
nce
and
Plan
ts
Publ
icat
ion
Scho
lars
hip
and
Stip
end
Mai
nten
ance
Oth
er E
xpen
ses
Tota
l (R
s. in
Tho
usan
ds)
(08) (09) (10) (11) (12) (13) (15) (17) 49 (K) (46) (47) (26) (18) (21) (29) (42)
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22
Generated at Government level and sent to PWD HQ, Zone, Circle and Division
Technical Assistance for Implementation of Institutional Reforms in Road Sector of Uttar Pradesh Report No. 16
May 2008 xxv
SANCTIONED DETAILS: PLAN - NEW ASSET CREATION: BUILDINGS (RESIDENTIAL) PWD BM - 200 / 1
Financial Year : ................................ Zone : ..................................... Circle : ................................................................. Month : ..............................................
Division : .................................................... Grant No : .................................................... Major Head of Accounts : ...................................................................
(Rs. in Thousands)
Sl. No.
Name and type of Building
(Residential) Sanctioned
Cost Expenditure up to
Previous Financial Year
Balance cost against sanction
Allotment for the Current
Financial Year Remarks
1 2 3 4 5 6 7
Total
Generated at Government level and sent to PWD HQ, Zone, Circle and Division
Technical Assistance for Implementation of Institutional Reforms in Road Sector of Uttar Pradesh Report No. 16
May 2008 xxvi
SANCTIONED DETAILS: PLAN - NEW ASSET CREATION: BUILDINGS (NON-RESIDENTIAL) PWD BM - 200 / 2
Financial Year : ................................ Zone : ..................................... Circle : ................................................................. Month : ..............................................
Division : .................................................... Grant No : .................................................... Major Head of Accounts : ...................................................................
(Rs. in Thousands)
Sl. No.
Name and type of Building
(Non-Residential) Sanctioned
Cost Expenditure up to
Previous Financial Year
Balance cost against sanction
Allotment for the Current
Financial Year Remarks
1 2 3 4 5 6 7
Total
Generated at Government level and sent to PWD HQ, Zone, Circle and Division
Technical Assistance for Implementation of Institutional Reforms in Road Sector of Uttar Pradesh Report No. 16
May 2008 xxvii
SANCTIONED DETAILS: PLAN - NEW ASSET CREATION: VEHICLES PWD BM - 200 / 3
Financial Year : ................................ Zone : ..................................... Circle : ................................................................. Month : ..............................................
Division : .................................................... Grant No : .................................................... Major Head of Accounts : ...................................................................
(Rs. in Thousands)
Sl. No. Type of Vehicle No. of Vehicles Sanctioned Cost Allocation Remarks
1 2 3 4 5 6
Total
Generated at Government level and sent to PWD HQ, Zone, Circle and Division
Technical Assistance for Implementation of Institutional Reforms in Road Sector of Uttar Pradesh Report No. 16
May 2008 xxviii
SANCTIONED DETAILS: PLAN - NEW ASSET CREATION: PLANT AND EQUIPMENT PWD BM - 200 / 4
Financial Year : ................................ Zone : ..................................... Circle : ................................................................. Month : ..............................................
Division : .................................................... Grant No : .................................................... Major Head of Accounts : ...................................................................
(Rs. in Thousands)
Sl. No. Type of Plant / Equipment No. of Plant / Equipment Sanctioned Cost Allocation of Funds Remarks
1 2 3 4 5 6
Total
Generated at Government level and sent to PWD HQ, Zone, Circle and Division
Technical Assistance for Implementation of Institutional Reforms in Road Sector of Uttar Pradesh Report No. 16
May 2008 xxix
SANCTIONED DETAILS: NON-PLAN - ASSETS: MAINTENANCE BUILDINGS (RESIDENTIAL) PWD BM - 210 / 1
Financial Year : ................................ Zone : ..................................... Circle : ................................................................. Month : ..............................................
Division : .................................................... Grant No : .................................................... Major Head of Accounts : ...................................................................
(Rs. in Thousands)
Sl. No. Name of Building (Residential) Allocation of Funds Remarks
1 2 3 4
Total
Generated at Government level and sent to PWD HQ, Zone, Circle and Division
Technical Assistance for Implementation of Institutional Reforms in Road Sector of Uttar Pradesh Report No. 16
May 2008 xxx
SANCTIONED DETAILS: NON-PLAN - ASSETS: MAINTENANCE BUILDINGS (NON-RESIDENTIAL) PWD BM - 210 / 2
Financial Year : ................................ Zone : ..................................... Circle : ................................................................. Month : ..............................................
Division : .................................................... Grant No : .................................................... Major Head of Accounts : ...................................................................
(Rs. in Thousands)
Sl. No. Name of Building (Non-Residential) Allocation of Funds Remarks
1 2 3 4
Total
Generated at Government level and sent to PWD HQ, Zone, Circle and Division
Technical Assistance for Implementation of Institutional Reforms in Road Sector of Uttar Pradesh Report No. 16
May 2008 xxxi
SANCTIONED DETAILS: NON-PLAN - ASSETS: MAINTENANCE VEHICLES PWD BM - 210 / 3
Financial Year : ............................................. Zone : ................................................ Circle : .................................................. Month : ...................................
Division : .................................................... Grant No : .................................................... Major Head of Accounts : ...................................................................
(Rs. in Thousands)
Sl. No. Type of Vehicle No. of Vehicles Allocation of Funds Remarks
1 2 3 4 5
Total
Generated at Government level and sent to PWD HQ, Zone, Circle and Division
Technical Assistance for Implementation of Institutional Reforms in Road Sector of Uttar Pradesh Report No. 16
May 2008 xxxii
SANCTIONED DETAILS: NON-PLAN - ASSETS: MAINTENANCE PLANT AND EQUIPMENT PWD BM - 210 / 4
Financial Year : ............................................. Zone : ................................................ Circle : .................................................. Month : ...................................
Division : .................................................... Grant No : .................................................... Major Head of Accounts : ...................................................................
(Rs. in Thousands)
Sl. No. Name of Plant / Equipment No. of Plant / Equipment Allocation of Funds Remarks
1 2 3 4 5
Total
Generated at Government level and sent to PWD HQ, Zone, Circle and Division
Technical Assistance for Implementation of Institutional Reforms in Road Sector of Uttar Pradesh Report No. 16
May 2008 xxxiii
ALLOTMENT: PLAN - ROADS PWD BM - 220 / 1
Financial Year of Budget Sanction: .................................. Zone: . .................................... Circle: .. ............................. District: ……………… Division: … ................
Voted / Charged: …………………………… Revenue / Capital:……………………………… Scheme: ……………………….. Month: …………………………..
(Rs. in Thousands)
Sl. No.
Grant No.
Head Details
(15 Digit Code)
PWD ID
Code
Name of Work
Reference of Sanction
(Administrative and
Expenditure Sanction)
Sanctioned Cost
Expenditure up to Last Financial
Year
Balance Amount against
sanctioned cost on 1st
April of Current
Financial Year
Budget Allocation for Current
Year
Amount Allotted
Amount allotted
previously in Current Financial
Year
Total amount
allotted in Current
Financial Year
(11+12)
Remarks
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14
Generated from HQ and sent to Division through Zone and Circle with a copy to Finance Controller.
Technical Assistance for Implementation of Institutional Reforms in Road Sector of Uttar Pradesh Report No. 16
May 2008 xxxiv
ALLOTMENT: PLAN - STRUCTURES PWD BM - 220 / 2
Financial Year of Budget Sanction: .................................. Zone: . .................................... Circle: .. ............................. District: ……………… Division: … ................
Voted / Charged: …………………………… Revenue / Capital: :……………………………… Scheme: ……………………….. Month: …………………………..
(Rs. in Thousands)
Sl. No.
Grant No.
Head Details
(15 Digit Code)
PWD ID
Code Name of
Work
Reference of Sanction
(Administrative and
Expenditure Sanction)
Sanctioned Cost
Expenditure up to Last Financial
Year
Balance Amount against
sanctioned cost on 1st
April of Current
Financial Year
Budget Allocation for Current
Year
Amount Allotted
Amount allotted
previously in Current Financial
Year
Total amount
allotted in Current
Financial Year
(11+12)
Remarks
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14
Generated from HQ and sent to Division through Zone and Circle with a copy to Finance Controller.
Technical Assistance for Implementation of Institutional Reforms in Road Sector of Uttar Pradesh Report No. 16
May 2008 xxxv
ALLOTMENT: NON-PLAN - ROADS PWD BM - 230 / 1
Financial Year of Budget Sanction: .................................. Zone: . .................................... Circle: .. ............................. District: ……………… Division: … ................
Voted / Charged: …………………………… Revenue / Capital: ……………………………… Scheme: ……………………….. Month: …………………………..
(Rs. in Thousands)
Sl. No.
Grant No.
Head Details
(15 Digit Code)
PWD ID
Code Name of
Work
Reference of Sanction
(Administrative and
Expenditure Sanction)
Sanctioned Cost
Expenditure up to Last Financial
Year
Balance Amount against
sanctioned cost on 1st
April of Current
Financial Year
Budget Allocation for Current
Year
Amount Allotted
Amount allotted
previously in Current Financial
Year
Total amount
allotted in Current
Financial Year
(11+12)
Remarks
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14
Generated from HQ and sent to Division through Zone and Circle with a copy to Finance Controller.
Technical Assistance for Implementation of Institutional Reforms in Road Sector of Uttar Pradesh Report No. 16
May 2008 xxxvi
ALLOTMENT: NON-PLAN - STRUCTURES PWD BM - 230 / 2
Financial Year of Budget Sanction: .................................. Zone: . .................................... Circle: .. ............................. District: ……………… Division: … ................
Voted / Charged: …………………………… Revenue / Capital: ……………………………… Scheme: ……………………….. Month: …………………………..
(Rs. in Thousands)
Sl. No.
Grant No.
Head Details
(15 Digit Code)
PWD ID
Code Name of
Work
Reference of Sanction
(Administrative and
Expenditure Sanction)
Sanctioned Cost
Expenditure up to Last Financial
Year
Balance Amount against
sanctioned cost on 1st
April of Current
Financial Year
Budget Allocation for Current
Year
Amount Allotted
Amount allotted
previously in Current Financial
Year
Total amount
allotted in Current
Financial Year
(11+12)
Remarks
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14
Generated from HQ and sent to Division through Zone and Circle with a copy to Finance Controller.
Technical Assistance for Implementation of Institutional Reforms in Road Sector of Uttar Pradesh Report No. 16
May 2008 xxxvii
ALLOTMENT: NON-PLAN - ESTABLISHMENT: HUMAN RESOURCE EXPENSES PWD BM - 240 / 1
Financial Year : ................................ Zone : ................................... Circle : ................................. Division : ........................................ Month : ..........................
Voted / Charged : .................................................................................................. Revenue / Capital : ...........................................................................................
(Rs. in Thousands)
Sl. N
o.
Hea
d D
etai
ls (1
5 D
igit
Cod
e)
PWD
ID C
ode
Sala
ry
Dea
rnes
s Sa
lary
Dea
rnes
s A
llow
ance
CC
A
HR
A
Oth
er A
llow
ance
Inte
rim R
elie
f
Aux
iliar
y A
llotm
ent f
or
pay
and
allo
wan
ce
Trav
ellin
g A
llow
ance
Tran
sfer
Tra
vel
Expe
nditu
re
Trav
el A
llow
ance
for
Trai
ning
etc
.
Leav
e Tr
avel
C
once
ssio
n Ex
pend
iture
Med
ical
Exp
ense
s
Uni
form
Exp
endi
ture
Tota
l (R
s. in
Tho
usan
ds)
(01) (50) (03) (02) (06) (04) (38) (43) (05) (44) (45) (49) (51) 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18
Generated from HQ and sent to Division through Zone and Circle
Technical Assistance for Implementation of Institutional Reforms in Road Sector of Uttar Pradesh Report No. 16
May 2008 xxxviii
ALLOTMENT: NON-PLAN - ESTABLISHMENT: OFFICE RUNNING COSTS PWD BM - 240 / 2
Financial Year : ................................ Zone : ................................... Circle : ................................. Division : ........................................ Month : ..........................
Voted / Charged : .................................................................................................. Revenue / Capital : ...........................................................................................
(Rs. in Thousands)
Sl. N
o.
Hea
d D
etai
ls (1
5 D
igit
Cod
e)
PWD
ID C
ode
Offi
ce E
xpen
ses
Elec
tric
Due
s
Wat
er T
ax a
nd C
harg
es
Stat
ione
ry M
ater
ial a
nd
Prin
ting
of F
orm
s
Offi
ce F
urni
ture
and
Fi
tting
and
App
lianc
es
Tele
phon
e an
d Fa
x
Mai
nten
ance
of v
ehic
les
and
purc
hase
of p
etro
l /
Die
sel /
Lub
rican
ts e
tc.
Ren
t, su
rcha
rge
and
tax
owne
rshi
p
Med
ical
Rei
mbu
rsem
ent
Hou
se B
uild
ing
Adv
ance
(7
610-
00-2
01-0
4-04
)
Mot
or V
ehic
le A
dvan
ce
Purc
hase
of c
ompu
ter
hard
war
e / s
oftw
are
Mai
nten
ance
of c
ompu
ter
and
purc
hase
of a
llied
st
atio
nery
Mac
hine
s Fu
rnis
hing
and
A
pplia
nce
and
Plan
ts
Publ
icat
ion
Scho
lars
hip
and
Stip
end
Mai
nten
ance
Oth
er E
xpen
ses
Tota
l (R
s. in
Tho
usan
ds)
(08) (09) (10) (11) (12) (13) (15) (17) 49 (K) (46) (47) (26) (18) (21) (29) (42)
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22
Generated from HQ and sent to Division through Zone and Circle
Technical Assistance for Implementation of Institutional Reforms in Road Sector of Uttar Pradesh Report No. 16
May 2008 xxxix
ALLOTMENT: PLAN - NEW ASSET CREATION: BUILDINGS (RESIDENTIAL) PWD BM - 250 / 1
Financial Year : ............................ Zone : ........................................................... Circle : ......................................................... Month : .......................................
Division : .................................................... Grant No : .................................................... Major Head of Accounts : ...................................................................
(Rs. in Thousands)
Sl. No. Name of Building (Residential) Sanctioned Cost Allotment during the Financial Year Remarks
1 2 3 4 5
Total
Generated from HQ and sent to Division through Zone and Circle with a copy to Finance Controller.
Technical Assistance for Implementation of Institutional Reforms in Road Sector of Uttar Pradesh Report No. 16
May 2008 xl
ALLOTMENT: PLAN - NEW ASSET CREATION: BUILDINGS (NON-RESIDENTIAL) PWD BM - 250 / 2
Financial Year : ............................ Zone : ........................................................... Circle : ......................................................... Month : .......................................
Division : .................................................... Grant No : .................................................... Major Head of Accounts : ...................................................................
(Rs. in Thousands)
Sl. No. Name of Building (Non-Residential) Sanctioned Cost Allotment during the Financial Year Remarks
1 2 3 4 5
Total
Generated from HQ and sent to Division through Zone and Circle with a copy to Finance Controller.
Technical Assistance for Implementation of Institutional Reforms in Road Sector of Uttar Pradesh Report No. 16
May 2008 xli
ALLOTMENT: PLAN - NEW ASSET CREATION: VEHICLES PWD BM - 250 / 3
Financial Year : ............................ Zone : ........................................................... Circle : ......................................................... Month : .......................................
Division : .................................................... Grant No : .................................................... Major Head of Accounts : ...................................................................
(Rs. in Thousands)
Sl. No. Type of Vehicle No. of Vehicles Sanctioned Cost Allotment Remarks
1 2 3 4 5 6
Total
Generated from HQ and sent to Division through Zone and Circle with a copy to Finance Controller.
Technical Assistance for Implementation of Institutional Reforms in Road Sector of Uttar Pradesh Report No. 16
May 2008 xlii
ALLOTMENT: PLAN - NEW ASSET CREATION: PLANT AND EQUIPMENT PWD BM - 250 / 4
Financial Year : ............................ Zone : ........................................................... Circle : ......................................................... Month : .......................................
Division : .................................................... Grant No : .................................................... Major Head of Accounts : ...................................................................
(Rs. in Thousands)
Sl. No. Type of Plant / Equipment No. of Plant / Equipment Sanctioned Cost Allocation Remarks
1 2 3 4 5 6
Total
Generated from HQ and sent to Division through Zone and Circle with a copy to Finance Controller.
Technical Assistance for Implementation of Institutional Reforms in Road Sector of Uttar Pradesh Report No. 16
May 2008 xliii
ALLOTMENT: NON-PLAN - ASSETS: MAINTENANCE BUILDINGS (RESIDENTIAL) PWD BM - 260 / 1
Financial Year : ............................ Zone : ........................................................... Circle : ......................................................... Month : .......................................
Division : .................................................... Grant No : .................................................... Major Head of Accounts : ...................................................................
(Rs. in Thousands)
Sl. No. Name of Building (Residential) Plinth Area (sq.m) Allocation of Funds Remarks
1 2 3 4 5
Total
Generated from HQ and sent to Division through Zone and Circle with a copy to Finance Controller.
Technical Assistance for Implementation of Institutional Reforms in Road Sector of Uttar Pradesh Report No. 16
May 2008 xliv
ALLOTMENT: NON-PLAN - ASSETS: MAINTENANCE BUILDINGS (NON-RESIDENTIAL) PWD BM - 260 / 2
Financial Year : ............................ Zone : ........................................................... Circle : ......................................................... Month : .......................................
Division : .................................................... Grant No : .................................................... Major Head of Accounts : ...................................................................
(Rs. in Thousands)
Sl. No. Name of Building (Non-Residential) Plinth Area (sq.m) Allocation of Funds Remarks
1 2 3 4 5
Total
Generated from HQ and sent to Division through Zone and Circle with a copy to Finance Controller.
Technical Assistance for Implementation of Institutional Reforms in Road Sector of Uttar Pradesh Report No. 16
May 2008 xlv
ALLOTMENT: NON-PLAN - ASSETS: MAINTENANCE VEHICLES PWD BM - 260 / 3
Financial Year : ............................ Zone : ........................................................... Circle : ......................................................... Month : .......................................
Division : .................................................... Grant No : .................................................... Major Head of Accounts : ...................................................................
(Rs. in Thousands)
Sl. No. Type of Vehicle No. of Vehicles Allocation Remarks
1 2 3 4 5
Total
Generated from HQ and sent to Division through Zone and Circle with a copy to Finance Controller.
Technical Assistance for Implementation of Institutional Reforms in Road Sector of Uttar Pradesh Report No. 16
May 2008 xlvi
ALLOTMENT: NON-PLAN - ASSETS: MAINTENANCE PLANT AND EQUIPMENT PWD BM - 260 / 4
Financial Year : ............................ Zone : ........................................................... Circle : ......................................................... Month : .......................................
Division : .................................................... Grant No : .................................................... Major Head of Accounts : ...................................................................
(Rs. in Thousands)
Sl. No. Type of Plant / Equipment No. of Plant / Equipment Allocation Remarks
1 2 3 4 5
Total
Generated from HQ and sent to Division through Zone and Circle with a copy to Finance Controller.
Technical Assistance for Implementation of Institutional Reforms in Road Sector of Uttar Pradesh Report No. 16
May 2008 xlvii
DETAILS OF CASH CREDIT LIMITS: PLAN - ROADS PWD BM - 270 / 1
Financial Year : ...................... Zone : ................................ Circle : ................................ Division : .......................... Code No. of Division : ......................
Reference Letter No and Date of Allotment by E-N-C : ................................................................ (Rs. in Thousands)
Sl. N
o.
Gra
nt N
o.
Hea
d D
etai
ls
(15
Dig
it C
ode)
PWD
ID C
ode
Nam
e of
San
ctio
ned
Wor
k
Budget allotted in figure (Rs. in Thousand)
CCL Issued / Surrender (Rs. In Thousand) Total during the year
Expe
nditu
re ti
ll m
onth
(Rs.
Th
ousa
nd)
Perc
enta
ge o
f Phy
sica
l Pr
ogre
ss ti
ll m
onth
Prev
ious
dur
ing
Fina
ncia
l Yea
r
This
allo
tmen
t
Tota
l allo
tmen
t dur
ing
curr
ent f
inan
cial
yea
r 1st Quarter 2nd Quarter 3rd Quarter 4th Quarter
Issu
ed C
CL
Surr
ende
r of C
CL
Net
CC
L
Issu
ed C
CL
Surr
ende
r of C
CL
Net
CC
L
Issu
ed C
CL
Surr
ende
r of C
CL
Net
CC
L
Issu
ed C
CL
Surr
ende
r of C
CL
Net
CC
L
CC
L Is
sued
Surr
ende
r
Tota
l Net
CC
L is
sued
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15
Finance Controller will send this to Chief / Senior Treasury Officer of the concerned District with copy endorsed to Division, Circle and Zone
Technical Assistance for Implementation of Institutional Reforms in Road Sector of Uttar Pradesh Report No. 16
May 2008 xlviii
DETAILS OF CASH CREDIT LIMITS: PLAN - STRUCTURES PWD BM - 270 / 2
Financial Year : ...................... Zone : ................................ Circle : ................................ Division : .......................... Code No. of Division : ......................
Reference Letter No and Date of Allotment by E-N-C : ................................................................
(Rs. in Thousands)
Sl. N
o.
Gra
nt N
o.
Hea
d D
etai
ls
(15
Dig
it C
ode)
PWD
ID C
ode
Nam
e of
San
ctio
ned
Wor
k
Budget allotted in figure (Rs. in Thousand) CCL Issued / Surrender (Rs. In Thousand) Total during the
year
Expe
nditu
re ti
ll m
onth
(Rs.
Th
ousa
nd)
Perc
enta
ge o
f Phy
sica
l Pr
ogre
ss ti
ll m
onth
Prev
ious
dur
ing
Fina
ncia
l Yea
r
This
allo
tmen
t
Tota
l allo
tmen
t dur
ing
curr
ent f
inan
cial
yea
r 1st Quarter 2nd Quarter 3rd Quarter 4th Quarter
Issu
ed C
CL
Surr
ende
r of C
CL
Net
CC
L
Issu
ed C
CL
Surr
ende
r of C
CL
Net
CC
L
Issu
ed C
CL
Surr
ende
r of C
CL
Net
CC
L
Issu
ed C
CL
Surr
ende
r of C
CL
Net
CC
L
CC
L Is
sued
Surr
ende
r
Tota
l Net
CC
L is
sued
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15
Finance Controller will send this to Chief / Senior Treasury Officer of the concerned District with copy endorsed to Division, Circle and Zone
Technical Assistance for Implementation of Institutional Reforms in Road Sector of Uttar Pradesh Report No. 16
May 2008 xlix
DETAILS OF CASH CREDIT LIMITS: NON-PLAN - ROADS PWD BM - 280 / 1
Financial Year : ...................... Zone : ................................ Circle : ................................ Division : .......................... Code No. of Division : ......................
Reference Letter No and Date of Allotment by E-N-C :...................................................................................
(Rs. in Thousands)
Sl. N
o.
Gra
nt N
o.
Hea
d D
etai
ls
(15
Dig
it C
ode)
PWD
ID C
ode
Nam
e of
San
ctio
ned
Wor
k
Budget allotted in figure (Rs. in Thousand) CCL Issued / Surrender (Rs. In Thousand) Total during the
year
Expe
nditu
re ti
ll m
onth
(Rs.
Th
ousa
nd)
Perc
enta
ge o
f Phy
sica
l Pr
ogre
ss ti
ll m
onth
Prev
ious
dur
ing
Fina
ncia
l Yea
r
This
allo
tmen
t
Tota
l allo
tmen
t dur
ing
curr
ent f
inan
cial
yea
r 1st Quarter 2nd Quarter 3rd Quarter 4th Quarter
Issu
ed C
CL
Surr
ende
r of C
CL
Net
CC
L
Issu
ed C
CL
Surr
ende
r of C
CL
Net
CC
L
Issu
ed C
CL
Surr
ende
r of C
CL
Net
CC
L
Issu
ed C
CL
Surr
ende
r of C
CL
Net
CC
L
CC
L Is
sued
Surr
ende
r
Tota
l Net
CC
L is
sued
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15
Finance Controller will send this to Chief / Senior Treasury Officer of the concerned District with copy endorsed to Division, Circle and Zone
Technical Assistance for Implementation of Institutional Reforms in Road Sector of Uttar Pradesh Report No. 16
May 2008 l
DETAILS OF CASH CREDIT LIMITS: NON-PLAN - STRUCTURES PWD BM - 280 / 2
Financial Year : ...................... Zone : ................................ Circle : ................................ Division : .......................... Code No. of Division : ......................
Reference Letter No and Date of Allotment by E-N-C :...................................................................................
(Rs. in Thousands)
Sl. N
o.
Gra
nt N
o.
Hea
d D
etai
ls
(15
Dig
it C
ode)
PWD
ID C
ode
Nam
e of
San
ctio
ned
Wor
k
Budget allotted in figure (Rs. in Thousand) CCL Issued / Surrender (Rs. In Thousand) Total during the
year
Expe
nditu
re ti
ll m
onth
(Rs.
Th
ousa
nd)
Perc
enta
ge o
f Phy
sica
l Pr
ogre
ss ti
ll m
onth
Prev
ious
dur
ing
Fina
ncia
l Yea
r
This
allo
tmen
t
Tota
l allo
tmen
t dur
ing
curr
ent f
inan
cial
yea
r 1st Quarter 2nd Quarter 3rd Quarter 4th Quarter
Issu
ed C
CL
Surr
ende
r of C
CL
Net
CC
L
Issu
ed C
CL
Surr
ende
r of C
CL
Net
CC
L
Issu
ed C
CL
Surr
ende
r of C
CL
Net
CC
L
Issu
ed C
CL
Surr
ende
r of C
CL
Net
CC
L
CC
L Is
sued
Surr
ende
r
Tota
l Net
CC
L is
sued
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15
Finance Controller will send this to Chief / Senior Treasury Officer of the concerned District with copy endorsed to Division, Circle and Zone
Technical Assistance for Implementation of Institutional Reforms in Road Sector of Uttar Pradesh Report No. 16
May 2008 li
DETAILS OF DEPOSIT CREDIT LIMITS - ROADS PWD BM - 290 / 1
Financial Year of DCL : ..............................................
Zone : .............................. Circle : .......................................... Division : .............................................. Code No. of Division : ...........................................
(Rs. in Thousands)
Sl. No.
Name of Department or Organisation / Agency by which
amount made available
Cheque / D. D. No. and Date
Amount
Chalan No. and Date of Amount
deposited in Treasury
Name of Work Amount of DCL allotted
Remarks
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8
Finance Controller for National Highway works of MoRT&H and Superintending Engineer for other projects issue DCL and send to Chief / Senior Treasury Officer of concerned District with copy endorsed to Division, Circle, Zone and also to Secretary Finance, GoUP.
Technical Assistance for Implementation of Institutional Reforms in Road Sector of Uttar Pradesh Report No. 16
May 2008 lii
DETAILS OF DEPOSIT CREDIT LIMITS - STRUCTURES PWD BM - 290 / 2
Financial Year of DCL : ..............................................
Zone : ...................................... Circle : ......................................... Division : ..................................... Code No. of Division : .....................................................
(Rs. in Thousands)
Sl. No.
Name of Department or Organisation / Agency by which
amount made available
Cheque / D. D. No. and Date
Amount
Chalan Number and Date of Amount
deposited in Treasury
Name of Work Amount of DCL allotted
Remarks
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8
Finance Controller for National Highway works of MoRT&H and Superintending Engineer for other projects issue DCL and send to Chief / Senior Treasury Officer of concerned District with copy endorsed to Division, Circle, Zone and also to Secretary Finance, GoUP.
Technical Assistance for Implementation of Institutional Reforms in Road Sector of Uttar Pradesh Report No. 16
May 2008 liii
EXCESS / SAVING STATEMENT / (VARIATION STATEMENT): PLAN - ROADS PWD BM - 300 / 1
Financial Year : .............................. Zone : ..................................... Circle : .......................................... Division : ............................... Month : .................................
Grant No.: …………………………………………….. Report for Quarter: ………………………………… (Rs. Thousands)
Sl. No.
Head Details
(15 Digit Code)
PWD ID Code
Name of work Budget Provision
Expenditure during quarter
Cumulative Expenditure up
to end of Quarter
Revised estimate of
expenditure forwhole year
Excess (+) (Difference Revised)
Saving (-) Proposed
Remarks / Reasons for
Excess / Saving
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11
Generated from Division level sent to Accountant General and copy to Circle, Zone and compiled at HQ
Technical Assistance for Implementation of Institutional Reforms in Road Sector of Uttar Pradesh Report No. 16
May 2008 liv
EXCESS / SAVING STATEMENT / (VARIATION STATEMENT): PLAN - STRUCTURES PWD BM - 300 / 2
Financial Year : .............................. Zone : ..................................... Circle : .......................................... Division : ............................... Month : .................................
Grant No.: …………………………………………….. Report for Quarter: ………………………………… (Rs. Thousands)
Sl. No.
Head Details
(15 Digit Code)
PWD ID Code
Name of work Budget Provision
Expenditure during quarter
Cumulative Expenditure up
to end of Quarter
Revised estimate of
expenditure forwhole year
Excess (+) (Difference Revised)
Saving (-) Proposed
Remarks / Reasons for
Excess / Saving
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11
Generated from Division level sent to Accountant General and copy to Circle, Zone and compiled at HQ
Technical Assistance for Implementation of Institutional Reforms in Road Sector of Uttar Pradesh Report No. 16
May 2008 lv
EXCESS / SAVING STATEMENT: NON-PLAN - ROADS PWD BM - 310 / 1
Financial Year : .............................. Zone : ..................................... Circle : .......................................... Division : ............................... Month : .................................
Grant No.: …………………………………………….. Report for Quarter: ………………………………… (Rs. Thousands)
Sl. No.
Head Details
(15 Digit Code)
PWD ID Code Name of work Budget
Provision
Expenditure during quarter
Cumulative Expenditure up
to end of Quarter
Revised estimate of
expenditure forwhole year
Excess (+) (Difference Revised)
Saving (-) Proposed
Remarks / Reasons for
Excess / Saving
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11
Generated from Division level sent to Accountant General and copy to Circle, Zone and compiled at HQ
Technical Assistance for Implementation of Institutional Reforms in Road Sector of Uttar Pradesh Report No. 16
May 2008 lvi
EXCESS / SAVING STATEMENT: NON-PLAN - STRUCTURES PWD BM - 310 / 2
Financial Year : .............................. Zone : ..................................... Circle : .......................................... Division : ............................... Month : .................................
Grant No.: …………………………………………….. Report for Quarter: ………………………………… (Rs. Thousands)
Sl. No.
Head Details
(15 Digit Code)
PWD ID Code Name of work Budget
Provision
Expenditure during quarter
Cumulative Expenditure up
to end of Quarter
Revised estimate of
expenditure forwhole year
Excess (+) (Difference Revised)
Saving (-) Proposed
Remarks / Reasons for
Excess / Saving
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11
Generated from Division level sent to Accountant General and copy to Circle, Zone and compiled at HQ
Technical Assistance for Implementation of Institutional Reforms in Road Sector of Uttar Pradesh Report No. 16
May 2008 lvii
RE-APPROPRIATION STATEMENT: PLAN - ROADS PWD BM - 320 / 1
Zone : ............................................... Circle : .................................................... Division : .................................................................... Month : .....................
Grant No : ..................................... Voted / Charged : .................................................... (Rs. in Thousands)
Sl. No.
Head Details
(15 Digit Code)
PWD ID Code
Account head, sub
head of Account, Name of
scheme and other details
Name of work
Sanctioned cost
Expenditure up to Last Financial
Year
Allocation for Present Financial
Year
Allocation including
change and supplementary
grant for Present Financial
Year
Proposed Excess / Saving
Proposed allocation
for Present
Financial Year
Justification for excess /
saving Remarks
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11
Generated from Division level and sent to Zone through Circle where it will be compiled and reconciled amongst the works of the same scheme of different Divisions and there after reconciled reports will be sent to HQ.
Technical Assistance for Implementation of Institutional Reforms in Road Sector of Uttar Pradesh Report No. 16
May 2008 lviii
RE-APPROPRIATION STATEMENT: PLAN - STRUCTURES PWD BM - 320 / 2
Zone : ............................................... Circle : .................................................... Division : .................................................................... Month : .....................
Grant No : ..................................... Voted / Charged : .................................................... (Rs. in Thousands)
Sl. No.
Head Details
(15 Digit Code)
PWD ID Code
Account head, sub
head of Account, Name of
scheme and other details
Name of work
Sanctioned cost
Expenditure up to Last Financial
Year
Allocation for Present Financial
Year
Allocation including
change and supplementary
grant for Present Financial
Year
Proposed Excess / Saving
Proposed allocation
for Present
Financial Year
Justification for excess /
saving Remarks
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11
Generated from Division level and sent to Zone through Circle where it will be compiled and reconciled amongst the works of the same scheme of different Divisions and there after reconciled reports will be sent to HQ.
Technical Assistance for Implementation of Institutional Reforms in Road Sector of Uttar Pradesh Report No. 16
May 2008 lix
RE-APPROPRIATION STATEMENT: NON-PLAN - ROADS PWD BM - 330 / 1
Zone : ............................................... Circle : .................................................... Division : .................................................................... Month : .....................
Grant No : ..................................... Voted / Charged : .................................................... (Rs. in Thousands)
Sl. No.
Head Details
(15 Digit Code)
PWD ID Code
Account head, sub
head of Account, Name of
scheme and other details
Name of work
Sanctioned cost
Expenditure up to Last Financial
Year
Allocation for Present Financial
Year
Allocation including
change and supplementary
grant for Present Financial
Year
Proposed Excess / Saving
Proposed allocation
for Present
Financial Year
Justification for excess /
saving Remarks
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11
Generated from Division level and sent to Zone through Circle where it will be compiled and reconciled amongst the works of the same scheme of different Divisions and there after reconciled reports will be sent to HQ.
Technical Assistance for Implementation of Institutional Reforms in Road Sector of Uttar Pradesh Report No. 16
May 2008 lx
RE-APPROPRIATION STATEMENT: NON-PLAN - STRUCTURES PWD BM - 330 / 2
Zone : ............................................... Circle : .................................................... Division : .................................................................... Month : .....................
Grant No : ..................................... Voted / Charged : .................................................... (Rs. in Thousands)
Sl. No.
Head Details
(15 Digit Code)
PWD ID Code
Account head, sub
head of Account, Name of
scheme and other details
Name of work
Sanctioned cost
Expenditure up to Last Financial
Year
Allocation for Present Financial
Year
Allocation including
change and supplementary
grant for Present Financial
Year
Proposed Excess / Saving
Proposed allocation
for Present
Financial Year
Justification for excess /
saving Remarks
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11
Generated from Division level and sent to Zone through Circle where it will be compiled and reconciled amongst the works of the same scheme of different Divisions and there after reconciled reports will be sent to HQ.
Technical Assistance for Implementation of Institutional Reforms in Road Sector of Uttar Pradesh Report No. 16
May 2008 lxi
LIABILITY DETAILS: PLAN - ROADS PWD BM - 340 / 1
Zone : ............................................... Circle : .................................................... Division : .................................................................... Month : .....................
(Rs. in Thousands)
Sl.
No.
Description of current
liability
Circumstances in which
liability created
Name and designation
of officer who created current
liability
Orders of Authority under which liability
created
Reference: of Instrument by which liability was created
Amount of current liability
Month in which the
current liability was
created
Liabilities Created prior
to current liability
Total Liability
(7+9)
If Liability of State Govt.
Name of Office and Dept.
Remarks
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12
Prepared at Division level on a monthly basis and sent to PWD HQ through Circle and Zone
Technical Assistance for Implementation of Institutional Reforms in Road Sector of Uttar Pradesh Report No. 16
May 2008 lxii
LIABILITY DETAILS: PLAN - STRUCTURES PWD BM - 340 / 2
Zone : ............................................... Circle : .................................................... Division : .................................................................... Month : .....................
(Rs. in Thousands)
Sl.
No.
Description of current
liability
Circumstances in which
liability created
Name and designation
of officer who created current
liability
Orders of Authority under which liability
created
Reference: of Instrument by which liability was created
Amount of current liability
Month in which the
current liability was
created
Liabilities Created prior
to current liability
Total Liability
(7+9)
If Liability of State Govt.
Name of Office and Dept.
Remarks
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12
Prepared at Division level on a monthly basis and sent to PWD HQ through Circle and Zone
Technical Assistance for Implementation of Institutional Reforms in Road Sector of Uttar Pradesh Report No. 16
May 2008 lxiii
LIABILITY DETAILS: NON-PLAN - ROADS PWD BM - 350 / 1
Zone : ............................................... Circle : .................................................... Division : .................................................................... Month : .....................
(Rs. in Thousands)
Sl.
No.
Description of current
liability
Circumstances in which
liability created
Name and designation
of officer who created current
liability
Orders of Authority under which liability
created
Reference: of Instrument by which liability was created
Amount of current liability
Month in which the
current liability was
created
Liabilities Created prior
to current liability
Total Liability
(7+9)
If Liability of State Govt.
Name of Office and Dept.
Remarks
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12
Prepared at Division level on a monthly basis and sent to PWD HQ through Circle and Zone
Technical Assistance for Implementation of Institutional Reforms in Road Sector of Uttar Pradesh Report No. 16
May 2008 lxiv
LIABILITY DETAILS: NON-PLAN - STRUCTURES PWD BM - 350 / 2
Zone : ............................................... Circle : .................................................... Division : .................................................................... Month : .....................
(Rs. in Thousands)
Sl.
No.
Description of current
liability
Circumstances in which
liability created
Name and designation
of officer who created current
liability
Orders of Authority under which liability
created
Reference: of Instrument by which liability was created
Amount of current liability
Month in which the
current liability was
created
Liabilities Created prior
to current liability
Total Liability
(7+9)
If Liability of State Govt.
Name of Office and Dept.
Remarks
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12
Prepared at Division level on a monthly basis and sent to PWD HQ through Circle and Zone
Technical Assistance for Implementation of Institutional Reforms in Road Sector of Uttar Pradesh Report No. 16
May 2008 lxv
RECONCILIATION STATEMENT: PLAN - ROADS PWD BM - 360 / 1
Financial Year: …… ............ Zone: ………..……………. Circle……………………….. Division: …………………..… Account General’s Code: ……………………..
Grant No.: ……………………… Quarter period: ……………………………… Rs. in Thousands)
SL. No.
Head Details
(15 Digit Code)
PWD ID
Code Allotment Particulars Types of
Transaction
Amount in the Quarter
(month wise) Expenditure up to last quarter
Total Expenditure
up to the present Quarter
Remarks
Month Month Month Total
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13
Prepared at Division level and submitted to Accountant General for reconciliation and return after verification in his office
Technical Assistance for Implementation of Institutional Reforms in Road Sector of Uttar Pradesh Report No. 16
May 2008 lxvi
RECONCILIATION STATEMENT: PLAN - STRUCTURES PWD BM - 360 / 2
Financial Year: …… ............ Zone: ………..……………. Circle……………………….. Division: …………………..… Account General’s Code: ……………………..
Grant No.: ……………………… Quarter period: ……………………………… Rs. in Thousands)
SL. No.
Head Details
(15 Digit Code)
PWD ID
Code Allotment Particulars Types of
Transaction
Amount in the Quarter
(month wise) Expenditure up to last quarter
Total Expenditure
up to the present Quarter
Remarks
Month Month Month Total
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13
Prepared at Division level and submitted to Accountant General for reconciliation and return after verification in his office
Technical Assistance for Implementation of Institutional Reforms in Road Sector of Uttar Pradesh Report No. 16
May 2008 lxvii
RECONCILIATION STATEMENT: NON-PLAN - ROADS PWD BM - 370 / 1
Financial Year: …… ............ Zone: ………..……………. Circle……………………….. Division: …………………..… Account General’s Code: ……………………..
Grant No.: ……………………… Quarter period: ……………………………… Rs. in Thousands)
SL. No.
Head Details
(15 Digit Code)
PWD ID
Code Allotment Particulars Types of
Transaction
Amount in the Quarter
(month wise) Expenditure up to last quarter
Total Expenditure
up to the present Quarter
Remarks
Month Month Month Total
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13
Prepared at Division level and submitted to Accountant General for reconciliation and return after verification in his office
Technical Assistance for Implementation of Institutional Reforms in Road Sector of Uttar Pradesh Report No. 16
May 2008 lxviii
RECONCILIATION STATEMENT: NON-PLAN - STRUCTURES PWD BM - 370 / 2
Financial Year: …… ............ Zone: ………..……………. Circle……………………….. Division: …………………..… Account General’s Code: ……………………..
Grant No.: ……………………… Quarter period: ……………………………… Rs. in Thousands)
SL. No.
Head Details
(15 Digit Code)
PWD ID
Code Allotment Particulars Types of
Transaction
Amount in the Quarter
(month wise) Expenditure up to last quarter
Total Expenditure
up to the present Quarter
Remarks
Month Month Month Total
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13
Prepared at Division level and submitted to Accountant General for reconciliation and return after verification in his office
ANNEXURE - 3 : PROPOSED COSTING FORMS
Technical Assistance for Implementation of Institutional Reforms in Road Sector of Uttar Pradesh Report No. 16
May 2008 i
COST CENTRE FOR OUT – SOURCED CONTRACTS PWD CCOS 100
Zone : ........................................................ Circle : ........................................................................
Division : .................... Project Name and Code : .....................................................................
Grant No. : .................... Account Head No. : ............................ Project Duration : ...................
Estimated Value : ................................................ Date of Technical sanction of estimate: ............
Contract Value : .................................................. Date of Start of Contract : ................................
Date of completion as per contract: ....................
Difference between estimated value and contract value : ..............................................................
Sl. No. Particulars
Monthly Status
1 2 3 4 5 6
1. Progress: Percentage Complete
2. Payment to Contractor
3. Advances including Mobilisation /Machinery and secured etc.
4. Payment for work done excluding advances (2) – (3)
5. Value of work done based on actual % complete
6. Value of work done according to Contractor's original Tender / Bid programme
7. Progress (5) - (6)
8. Value of Variation Orders and extra item etc.
9. Balance amount payable to contractor against agreement: (5) - (4)
10. Balance amount payable to contractor including variation orders and extra items : (7+8)
Technical Assistance for Implementation of Institutional Reforms in Road Sector of Uttar Pradesh Report No. 16
May 2008 ii
COST CENTRE FOR IN HOUSE PROJECT PWD CCIH 200
Zone : ............................................ Circle : .............................................. Division : ............................................................ Month : ..........................................
Name of the Project : ................. Grant No. : ................... Account Head No. : .............. Estimated Contract Value : ................ Contract Duration : ..................
Cost Elements
Labour Materials Plant Total
1 2 3 4 5 1 2 3 4 5 1 2 3 4 5 1 2 3 4 5
Budget based
on work done
Budget based
on prog.
Actual Cost
Variance (1) - (3)
Variance (2) - (3)
Budget based
on work done
Budget based
on prog.
Actual Cost
Variance (1) - (3)
Variance (2) - (3)
Budget based
on work done
Budget based
on prog.
Actual Cost
Variance (1) - (3)
Variance (2) - (3)
Budget based
on work done
Budget based
on prog.
Actual Cost
Variance (1) - (3)
Variance (2) - (3)
Excavation (Cut)
Fill
Drainage
Sub-Base
Base Course
Wearing Course
Shoulders
Pot-Hole Filling
Patching
Other
Technical Assistance for Implementation of Institutional Reforms in Road Sector of Uttar Pradesh Report No. 16
May 2008 iii
REGISTER OF WORKS FORM (CONTRACT WISE) PWD ROW 500 / 1
Financial Year : .................. Zone : ...................... Circle : .......................... Division : ................................................ Account Head : ....................................
Name of the Project/Work : .......................... PWD ID : ................ Contract No & Date : .................. Contract Cost : .......................... Month : ............................
(Rs. in Thousands)
Sl. No.
B.O.Q. /Extra
Item No.Unit
B.O.Q. / Extra. Rate (Rs.)
B.O.Q. / Extra ItemQuantity
Sanctioned Variation
(Quantity.)
Total Quantity to
be executed
Cost (Rs.)
Description of Item as per
B.O.Q. and extra item sanctioned
later on
Sum Paid Amount
Up to previous payment
For this payment
Up to present payment
Up to previous payment
For this payment
Up to present payment
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15
Note: Maintained in the Division Office for control of expenditure on the Project.
Technical Assistance for Implementation of Institutional Reforms in Road Sector of Uttar Pradesh Report No. 16
May 2008 iv
REGISTER OF WORKS (PROJECT WISE) PWD ROW 500 / 2
Financial Year : .................. Zone : ...................... Circle : .......................... Division : ................................................ Account Head : ....................................
Name of the Project/Work : ........................ PWD ID : .......... Sanctioned Cost : .............. Expenditure up to Last F.Y.: ................ Allocation during F.Y. : ............
(Rs. in Thousands)
Sl. No. Item Expenditure During Month April May June Jul Aug Sept Oct Nov Dec Jan Feb Mar Remarks
1 (i) Contract I
1 (ii) Contract II
1 (iii) Contract III
2 (i) Issues of materials from stock
2 (ii) Advance payment for procurement to stock
Direct payment to labour
3 (i) (i) Advances for opening of imprest
3 (ii) (ii) Adjustment of imprest
4 Transfer Entry
5 Month wise total (1 to 4)
6 Total during current financial year
7 Cumulative total up to month from beginning of project
Note : (i) To be generated by Division and sent to Circle, Zone and (ii) Zone will send the extract expenditure project wise to HQ.