Using BioFuelgas under O2 enriched flue gases in steam ......©2016 John Zink Company, LLC 19...

22
©2016 John Zink Company, LLC 1 Using BioFuel gas under O2 enriched flue gases in steam crackers Gilles Theis Jason McAdams Ali Gueniche May, 2018

Transcript of Using BioFuelgas under O2 enriched flue gases in steam ......©2016 John Zink Company, LLC 19...

Page 1: Using BioFuelgas under O2 enriched flue gases in steam ......©2016 John Zink Company, LLC 19 Testingresults: NOx emissions summary Considering a Biofuel gas with 40 vol% CO2, NOx

©2016 John Zink Company, LLC 1

Using BioFuel gas under O2 enriched flue gases in steam crackers

Gilles Theis

Jason McAdams

Ali Gueniche

May, 2018

Page 2: Using BioFuelgas under O2 enriched flue gases in steam ......©2016 John Zink Company, LLC 19 Testingresults: NOx emissions summary Considering a Biofuel gas with 40 vol% CO2, NOx

©2016 John Zink Company, LLC 2

Important Notice

The information contained in these materials is for informational purposes only and is provided “AS IS”, without warranties of any kind. Your use of the information contained herein is at your sole risk. We expressly disclaim any express or implied representations, warranties or guaranties, including without limitation, the implied warranties of merchantability and fitness for a particular purpose. We will have absolutely no liability (whether direct, indirect or consequential) in connection with these materials (and/or the information contained therein) including without limitation, any liability for damage to person or property. We also reserve the right to make subsequent changes to the materials without prior notice. For purposes of this notification, “We” includes John Zink Company LLC and its affiliates and their respective employees, partners, principles, agents and representatives, and any third-party providers or sources of information or data.

For information on patents and trademarks, see johnzinkhamworthy.com/legal-notices.

Page 3: Using BioFuelgas under O2 enriched flue gases in steam ......©2016 John Zink Company, LLC 19 Testingresults: NOx emissions summary Considering a Biofuel gas with 40 vol% CO2, NOx

©2016 John Zink Company, LLC 3

Outline

►Introduction about IMPROOF EU project►JZHC deliverables►Testing setup at JZHC test facility►Testing Results►Conclusion

Page 4: Using BioFuelgas under O2 enriched flue gases in steam ......©2016 John Zink Company, LLC 19 Testingresults: NOx emissions summary Considering a Biofuel gas with 40 vol% CO2, NOx

©2016 John Zink Company, LLC 4

Improof

Introduction

►Improof project funded by EU:

Page 5: Using BioFuelgas under O2 enriched flue gases in steam ......©2016 John Zink Company, LLC 19 Testingresults: NOx emissions summary Considering a Biofuel gas with 40 vol% CO2, NOx

©2016 John Zink Company, LLC 5

Improof Project partners

Introduction

Page 6: Using BioFuelgas under O2 enriched flue gases in steam ......©2016 John Zink Company, LLC 19 Testingresults: NOx emissions summary Considering a Biofuel gas with 40 vol% CO2, NOx

©2016 John Zink Company, LLC 6

Testing objectives

►John Zink Hamworthy Combustion deliverables►Demonstrate the combustion performance of Bio-Fuel

gases and their influence on combustion behaviour using ULN burners under ambient air conditions and oxygen enriched flue gases.

JZHC deliverables

Page 7: Using BioFuelgas under O2 enriched flue gases in steam ......©2016 John Zink Company, LLC 19 Testingresults: NOx emissions summary Considering a Biofuel gas with 40 vol% CO2, NOx

©2016 John Zink Company, LLC 7

COOLStar™ Ultra Low NOx Burner

Air

COOLStar™-burner

JZHC deliverables

Page 8: Using BioFuelgas under O2 enriched flue gases in steam ......©2016 John Zink Company, LLC 19 Testingresults: NOx emissions summary Considering a Biofuel gas with 40 vol% CO2, NOx

©2016 John Zink Company, LLC 8

Furnace 14 at JZHC Tulsa test center

Testing setup at JZHC test facility

F14 test center 2 COOLstar TM burners installed

Page 9: Using BioFuelgas under O2 enriched flue gases in steam ......©2016 John Zink Company, LLC 19 Testingresults: NOx emissions summary Considering a Biofuel gas with 40 vol% CO2, NOx

©2016 John Zink Company, LLC 9

Testing setupCO2 Storagetrucks

Steam Boiler truck

Test Furnace F14

Testing setup at JZHC test facility

Page 10: Using BioFuelgas under O2 enriched flue gases in steam ......©2016 John Zink Company, LLC 19 Testingresults: NOx emissions summary Considering a Biofuel gas with 40 vol% CO2, NOx

©2016 John Zink Company, LLC 10

Air flow stream composition: Ambient

Testing results

►Ambient air testing: 21% O2, 79% N2

►Test fuel 1: 100% Tulsa Natural gas (TNG fuel)►Test fuel 2: 10 vol% CO2 in 90 vol% Natural gas►Test fuel 2: 20 vol% CO2 in 80 vol% Natural gas ►Test fuel 2: 30 vol% CO2 in 70 vol% Natural gas ►Test fuel 3: 40 vol% CO2 in 60 vol% Natural gas

Page 11: Using BioFuelgas under O2 enriched flue gases in steam ......©2016 John Zink Company, LLC 19 Testingresults: NOx emissions summary Considering a Biofuel gas with 40 vol% CO2, NOx

©2016 John Zink Company, LLC 11

0

1

2

3

4

5

6

7

8

9

10

11

0 100 200 300 400

Furn

ace

Elev

atio

n (m

)

Heat Flux - kW/m2

Heat Flux Profile, F-14

NG 10% CO2 20% CO2 30% CO2 40% CO2

Relative Heat Flux, ambient air testingAbsolute Heat Flux, ambient air testing

Testing results: Ambient air

Page 12: Using BioFuelgas under O2 enriched flue gases in steam ......©2016 John Zink Company, LLC 19 Testingresults: NOx emissions summary Considering a Biofuel gas with 40 vol% CO2, NOx

©2016 John Zink Company, LLC 12

Testing results: NOx emissions

0

10

20

30

40

50

60

70

80

90

100

0 5 10 15 20 25 30 35 40 45

% o

f m

axim

um N

OX e

miss

ions

% CO2 in the natural gas

Comparison % of NOx emissions- Ambient air and Oxyfiring vs different CO2 vol% concentration in natural gas fuel

Ambient NOx in %

Page 13: Using BioFuelgas under O2 enriched flue gases in steam ......©2016 John Zink Company, LLC 19 Testingresults: NOx emissions summary Considering a Biofuel gas with 40 vol% CO2, NOx

©2016 John Zink Company, LLC 13

Air stream: Oxy-firing 21% O2

►Oxy-firing: 21 vol% Oxygen, 26 vol% CO2 and 53 vol% H2O(g)►Test fuel 1: 100% Tulsa Natural gas (TNG fuel)►Test fuel 2: 20 vol% CO2 in 80 vol% Natural gas ►Test fuel 3: 40 vol% CO2 in 60 vol% Natural gas

Testing results

Page 14: Using BioFuelgas under O2 enriched flue gases in steam ......©2016 John Zink Company, LLC 19 Testingresults: NOx emissions summary Considering a Biofuel gas with 40 vol% CO2, NOx

©2016 John Zink Company, LLC 14Absolute Heat flux, simulated air, 21 vol% O2 Relative Heat flux, simulated air, 21 vol% O2

Testing results: Oxy-firing

Page 15: Using BioFuelgas under O2 enriched flue gases in steam ......©2016 John Zink Company, LLC 19 Testingresults: NOx emissions summary Considering a Biofuel gas with 40 vol% CO2, NOx

©2016 John Zink Company, LLC 15

Air stream: Oxy-firing 18% , 21%, and 24% O2

►TNG fuel gas for all cases►Ambient air ►O2 concentration: 21% vol

Testing results

Page 16: Using BioFuelgas under O2 enriched flue gases in steam ......©2016 John Zink Company, LLC 19 Testingresults: NOx emissions summary Considering a Biofuel gas with 40 vol% CO2, NOx

©2016 John Zink Company, LLC 16

Testing results: Flux profile

Absolute Heat flux, TNG, 21% O2 concentration Absolute Heat flux, TNG, at 21% O2 concentration

0

1

2

3

4

5

6

7

8

9

10

11

40% 50% 60% 70% 80% 90% 100%

Furn

ace

Elev

atio

n (m

)

Heat Flux - Normalized

Heat Flux Profile, Normalized, TNG at 21%O2

ambient TNG Oxy 21 O2 - TNG

0

1

2

3

4

5

6

7

8

9

10

11

0 100 200 300 400

Furn

ace

Elev

atio

n (m

)

Heat Flux - kW/m2

Heat Flux Profile, TNG at 21% O2

ambient TNG Oxy 21 O2 - TNG

Page 17: Using BioFuelgas under O2 enriched flue gases in steam ......©2016 John Zink Company, LLC 19 Testingresults: NOx emissions summary Considering a Biofuel gas with 40 vol% CO2, NOx

©2016 John Zink Company, LLC 17

Testing results: summary

► The test results show that there is no difference in the heat flux profile of the COOLStar™ burner if operated on a same fuel, irrespective if it is operated with ambient combustion air, or under oxyfiring conditions.

►A difference is observed between a typical natural gas and biofuel gas, where the CO2 is reducing the heat transferred by the flame, as it is causing a flame temperature reduction.

► For most of the cases, the achieved relative heat fluxes of all tested fuels on a same oxidant composition are very similar, which is beneficial for the practical operation of the cracker during fuel changes.

Page 18: Using BioFuelgas under O2 enriched flue gases in steam ......©2016 John Zink Company, LLC 19 Testingresults: NOx emissions summary Considering a Biofuel gas with 40 vol% CO2, NOx

©2016 John Zink Company, LLC 18

Testing results: NOx emissions

0

10

20

30

40

50

60

70

80

90

100

0 10 20 30 40 50

% m

axim

um N

Ox

vol% CO2 in Natural Gas

Comparision NOx emissions - Ambient Air and Oxyfiring

Ambient NOx in % Oxy NOx, 21% vol O2

Page 19: Using BioFuelgas under O2 enriched flue gases in steam ......©2016 John Zink Company, LLC 19 Testingresults: NOx emissions summary Considering a Biofuel gas with 40 vol% CO2, NOx

©2016 John Zink Company, LLC 19

Testing results: NOx emissionssummary

► Considering a Biofuel gas with 40 vol% CO2, NOx measured during

oxyfiring showed to be few percent of the emission recorded during

ambient air operation.

► The NOx measured during testing is caused by Nitrogen contained

in the Natural gas. Some ambient air will have leaked into the test

furnace, to which amount cannot be quantified, but it is expected to

be very low, especially at the burner level. The furnace tightness

was tested prior the combustion test.

Page 20: Using BioFuelgas under O2 enriched flue gases in steam ......©2016 John Zink Company, LLC 19 Testingresults: NOx emissions summary Considering a Biofuel gas with 40 vol% CO2, NOx

©2016 John Zink Company, LLC 20

Conclusion:

► Several tests have been performed to evaluate the performance of the burner if

operated on an oxygen enriched flue gas. In addition, simulated biogas was

simulated and evaluated.

► With respect to the combustion system only and focusing on the radiation zone, it

has shown the furnace temperature and relative flux profiles are comparable. It

can be therefore expected that an existing cracking furnace can be operated on

both oxygen enriched flue gas and biofuel at the same time.

► The NOx emissions have been reduced by as much as 95%, as hardly no nitrogen

is avaible in the combustion process.

Page 21: Using BioFuelgas under O2 enriched flue gases in steam ......©2016 John Zink Company, LLC 19 Testingresults: NOx emissions summary Considering a Biofuel gas with 40 vol% CO2, NOx

©2016 John Zink Company, LLC 21

Questions?

Page 22: Using BioFuelgas under O2 enriched flue gases in steam ......©2016 John Zink Company, LLC 19 Testingresults: NOx emissions summary Considering a Biofuel gas with 40 vol% CO2, NOx

©2016 John Zink Company, LLC 22

Thank You!