Total Cost Of Ownership For ECM - Compares Documentum, SharePoint, OpenText and Alfresco

30
Dr. Ian Howells Alfresco Software January 2009 Reduce your ECM Costs by 90%

description

This is not a flaky 5 Year ROI Study ●  It addresses costs in year one ●  It uses publicly available information – review it yourself ●  It provides tools to help you question your ECM vendors ●  Ask Vendor to Explain Specifically: -  What are you Selling me -  What am I Getting -  What Extra Software do I Need -  Can you Break Down the Cost -  Why does it Cost this Amount - Explain why is it so Expensive Compared to Open Source

Transcript of Total Cost Of Ownership For ECM - Compares Documentum, SharePoint, OpenText and Alfresco

Page 1: Total Cost Of Ownership For ECM - Compares Documentum, SharePoint, OpenText and Alfresco

Dr. Ian Howells Alfresco Software

January 2009

Reduce your ECM Costs by 90%

Page 2: Total Cost Of Ownership For ECM - Compares Documentum, SharePoint, OpenText and Alfresco

TheFocusof2009

●  More Content

●  More Users

●  More Productivity

●  More Compliance

●  Dramatically Less Cost

2

8% Decline in ITSpend

Page 3: Total Cost Of Ownership For ECM - Compares Documentum, SharePoint, OpenText and Alfresco

Goal of Webinar and White Paper

●  Not a Flakey 5 Year ROI Study

●  Cost in the Next Year

●  Publicly Available Information – Review it

●  Tools Customers to Question Vendors

●  Ask Vendor to Explain Specifically:

  What are you Selling me

  What am I Getting

  What Extra Software do I Need

  Can you Break Down the Cost

  Why does it Cost this Amount

3

Explain why is it so Expensive Compared to Open Source

Page 4: Total Cost Of Ownership For ECM - Compares Documentum, SharePoint, OpenText and Alfresco

Agenda

●  ECM Pricing

●  Methodology

●  ECM Vendor Cost

●  ECM Stack Cost

●  Alfresco

●  Summary

●  More Information

Page 5: Total Cost Of Ownership For ECM - Compares Documentum, SharePoint, OpenText and Alfresco

ECMIndustry

High Cost High Complexity Tie-In

Page 6: Total Cost Of Ownership For ECM - Compares Documentum, SharePoint, OpenText and Alfresco

Traditional ECM Pricing and Myths

Pricing Model ●  Complex

  1000’s options

  Hidden Extras Pricing Model

●  Lack Transparency   Audit Implications

Cost ●  Per User

  1 Hour per Year/24 Hours Per Day

  Type Content Accessed

●  Usage   Intranet, Internet, Extranet,

Website

●  SharePoint – Free   WSS, MOSS Standard and

Enterprise 6

Page 7: Total Cost Of Ownership For ECM - Compares Documentum, SharePoint, OpenText and Alfresco

Methodology

●  Basic System – Content Management for the Masses   Office Integration

  Collaboration

  Content Management

  Workflow or BPM

  Transformation/Rendition Management

  Search

●  1000 Enterprise Config and 100 Users Standard Config

●  Publicly Available Pricing

●  Year One Cost 7

Page 8: Total Cost Of Ownership For ECM - Compares Documentum, SharePoint, OpenText and Alfresco

Publicly Available Pricing

●  "the price analysis GSA does to establish the Government's Multiple Award Schedule (MAS) negotiation objective should start with the best discount given to any of the vendor's customers."

8

Page 9: Total Cost Of Ownership For ECM - Compares Documentum, SharePoint, OpenText and Alfresco

EMC/Documentum

●  1000 User   $863,937

●  100 User   $129,078

●  GSA Pricing

9

Page 10: Total Cost Of Ownership For ECM - Compares Documentum, SharePoint, OpenText and Alfresco

OpenText

●  1000 User   $637,304

●  100 User   $196,754

●  GSA Pricing

10

Page 11: Total Cost Of Ownership For ECM - Compares Documentum, SharePoint, OpenText and Alfresco

SharePoint

●  1000 User   $318,738

●  100 User   $24,669

●  Pricing  www.microsoft.com

11

Page 12: Total Cost Of Ownership For ECM - Compares Documentum, SharePoint, OpenText and Alfresco

SharePoint Pricing

●  Complete Microsoft Stack

●  Basic Pricing

●  http://office.microsoft.com/en-us/sharepointserver/FX102176831033.aspx

●  Microsoft Software Assurance

●  http://www.microsoft.com/licensing/mla/default.aspx

12

“To be licensed for the Enterprise Edition functionality of Office SharePoint Server 2007, both the Standard and Enterprise client access licenses are required”

Page 13: Total Cost Of Ownership For ECM - Compares Documentum, SharePoint, OpenText and Alfresco

Alfresco

●  All Products in One Subscription  Document Management, Collaboration and Web Content

Management, Records Management, Image Management

●  All Components included  BPM, Workflow, Transformation …

●  No CAL’s

●  No Extra for different Client

●  CPU based

13

Page 14: Total Cost Of Ownership For ECM - Compares Documentum, SharePoint, OpenText and Alfresco

Alfresco

●  1000 User   $33,500

  $46,250

●  100 User   $18,500

14

Page 15: Total Cost Of Ownership For ECM - Compares Documentum, SharePoint, OpenText and Alfresco

ECM Stack Costs

●  Application Server

●  Database

●  Operating System

15

Page 16: Total Cost Of Ownership For ECM - Compares Documentum, SharePoint, OpenText and Alfresco

Oracle Database & Application Server

●  1000 User DB   $59,950

●  100 User DB   $21,350

●  Pricing   http://www.oracle.com/corporate/pricing/pricelists.html

16

Page 17: Total Cost Of Ownership For ECM - Compares Documentum, SharePoint, OpenText and Alfresco

Microsoft Database

●  1000 User DB   $17,210

●  100 User DB   $8,605

●  Pricing   http://www.microsoft.com/licensing/mla/default.aspx

17

Page 18: Total Cost Of Ownership For ECM - Compares Documentum, SharePoint, OpenText and Alfresco

MySQL

●  1000 User Gold   $2999

●  100 User Silver   $1999

●  Pricing   http://mysql.com/products/enterprise/features.html

18

Page 19: Total Cost Of Ownership For ECM - Compares Documentum, SharePoint, OpenText and Alfresco

Microsoft Windows

●  1000 User   $3201

●  100 User   $2176

●  Pricing   http://www.microsoft.com/licensing/mla/default.aspx

19

Page 20: Total Cost Of Ownership For ECM - Compares Documentum, SharePoint, OpenText and Alfresco

Red Hat Application Stack

●  Stack   Apache HTTP Server   JBoss Application Server   JBoss Hibernate   MySQL and PostgresSQL   Red Hat Enterprise Linux

20

1000 User Premium Enterprise Stack - $8499 100 User Basic Stack - $1999

Page 21: Total Cost Of Ownership For ECM - Compares Documentum, SharePoint, OpenText and Alfresco

Summary Year 1 Cost Savings

●  1000 Users  Save 85% to 96%

●  100 Users  Save 42% to 85%

21

Page 22: Total Cost Of Ownership For ECM - Compares Documentum, SharePoint, OpenText and Alfresco

Summary

22

Page 23: Total Cost Of Ownership For ECM - Compares Documentum, SharePoint, OpenText and Alfresco

Low Upfront Cost Lower Project Risk Op Ex vs. Cap Ex

OpenSourcevs.EnterpriseSo=wareModel

Increasing Savings

Annual Cost Cumulative Cost

Page 24: Total Cost Of Ownership For ECM - Compares Documentum, SharePoint, OpenText and Alfresco

Summary

Late 1990’s and early 2000’s ●  The ECM Suite

●  Single Vendor Strategy

●  Lock-In

Today ●  Short Approved Vendor

Shortlist

●  Cost this Year

●  Reuse Existing Hardware, Software and Skills

●  Choose per Project   Cost

  Functionality

●  Review Renewals 24

Page 25: Total Cost Of Ownership For ECM - Compares Documentum, SharePoint, OpenText and Alfresco

More Information

●  White Paper – Total Cost of Ownership for Enterprise Content Management  Detailed Breakdown of ECM Vendor Pricing

 Detailed Breakdown of Stack Pricing

 Detailed Comparison Matrix

 URL’s for all Pricelists

 All calculations were performed in November 2008

25

Page 26: Total Cost Of Ownership For ECM - Compares Documentum, SharePoint, OpenText and Alfresco

www.alfresco.com

26

Page 27: Total Cost Of Ownership For ECM - Compares Documentum, SharePoint, OpenText and Alfresco

27

Page 28: Total Cost Of Ownership For ECM - Compares Documentum, SharePoint, OpenText and Alfresco

Dr. Ian Howells January 2009

Reduce your ECM Costs by 90% Questions

Page 29: Total Cost Of Ownership For ECM - Compares Documentum, SharePoint, OpenText and Alfresco

Lessons in FUD

1.  Open Source doesn’t have Support

2.  OK It does have commercial SLA’s but Open Source is More Expensive Really

3.  OK it is Supported, Cheaper But it Doesn’t Scale

4.  OK It is Supported, Cheaper and it Scales to run Web 2.0 but it costs More to Configure

5.  OK, OK, OK

29

Of course you know it is more

expensive really.

Page 30: Total Cost Of Ownership For ECM - Compares Documentum, SharePoint, OpenText and Alfresco

FUD RepellantWeb 2.0 Runs on Open Source

●  Commoditize:

●  Scalability

●  RAS

●  Usability

30

Do More with Less