TJ Kim, Ph.D., P.E. Clark P.E. - Los Angeles County, California · 2019. 5. 29. · 7 District 37...

26
Issam Najm, Ph.D., P.E. Water Quality & Treatment Solutions, Inc. TJ Kim, Ph.D., P.E. Clark Ajwani, P.E. Los Angeles County Department of Public Works Water Works Division Water Quality Technology Conference Long Beach, California; November 2013

Transcript of TJ Kim, Ph.D., P.E. Clark P.E. - Los Angeles County, California · 2019. 5. 29. · 7 District 37...

Page 1: TJ Kim, Ph.D., P.E. Clark P.E. - Los Angeles County, California · 2019. 5. 29. · 7 District 37 serves drinking water to approx. 4,400 people in Acton, California (near Palmdale)

Issam Najm, Ph.D., P.E.Water Quality & Treatment Solutions, Inc.

TJ Kim, Ph.D., P.E.Clark Ajwani, P.E.

Los Angeles County Department of Public WorksWater Works Division

Water Quality Technology ConferenceLong Beach, California; November 2013

Page 2: TJ Kim, Ph.D., P.E. Clark P.E. - Los Angeles County, California · 2019. 5. 29. · 7 District 37 serves drinking water to approx. 4,400 people in Acton, California (near Palmdale)

2

District 37

WQTS:Nancy Patania Brown, P.E.Brian GallagherKarl GramithEric Seo

LA County DPW:Adam Ariki

Project Advisory Committee:Patrick Evans, Ph.D. – CDM SmithKhadija Durbas – LA Dept. of Water & PowerJoAnn Silverstein, Ph.D. – Univ. of Nevada Reno

Water Research Foundation:Hsiao‐Wen Chen, Ph.D.

Biological Treatment Pilot Testing Results General Observations

Page 3: TJ Kim, Ph.D., P.E. Clark P.E. - Los Angeles County, California · 2019. 5. 29. · 7 District 37 serves drinking water to approx. 4,400 people in Acton, California (near Palmdale)

1. LA County Dept. of Public Works & Waterworks Districts

2. Configuration of the Biological Denitrification (BDN) System Evaluated

3. Pilot Testing Results

4. General Observations

3

District 37 Biological Treatment Pilot Testing Results General Observations

Page 4: TJ Kim, Ph.D., P.E. Clark P.E. - Los Angeles County, California · 2019. 5. 29. · 7 District 37 serves drinking water to approx. 4,400 people in Acton, California (near Palmdale)

Formed in 1985

Consists of 34 divisions & groups

3400 employees in 500 job classifications

Annual operating budget of $2 Billion

Responsible for design, construction, operation, maintenance and repair of roads, airports, sewers, water supply, flood control, water quality, and water conservation facilities

4

District 37 Biological Treatment Pilot Testing Results General Observations

Page 5: TJ Kim, Ph.D., P.E. Clark P.E. - Los Angeles County, California · 2019. 5. 29. · 7 District 37 serves drinking water to approx. 4,400 people in Acton, California (near Palmdale)

A division of the LA County Dept. of Public Works

Supplies water to 200,000 residents in LA County

Five LA County Waterworks Districts

5

District Established ConnectionsEstimatedPopulation

District 21; Kagel Canyon 1935 250 990

District 29; Malibu 1959 7450 20,120

District 36; Val Verde 1963 1,320 4,650

District 37; Acton 1963 1,390 4,330

District 40; Antelope Valley 1993 54,640 170,440

District 37 Biological Treatment Pilot Testing Results General Observations

Page 6: TJ Kim, Ph.D., P.E. Clark P.E. - Los Angeles County, California · 2019. 5. 29. · 7 District 37 serves drinking water to approx. 4,400 people in Acton, California (near Palmdale)

6

You are Here

District 37

District 37 Biological Treatment Pilot Testing Results General Observations

Page 7: TJ Kim, Ph.D., P.E. Clark P.E. - Los Angeles County, California · 2019. 5. 29. · 7 District 37 serves drinking water to approx. 4,400 people in Acton, California (near Palmdale)

7

District 37 serves drinking water to approx. 4,400 people in Acton, California (near Palmdale)

The District’s water supply is primarily groundwater from 3 wells, and treated surface water from AVEK’s treatment plant

All three wells contain nitrate at various levels

The District’s service area is not sewered, limiting waste disposal options from groundwater treatment systems

District 37 Biological Treatment Pilot Testing Results General Observations

Page 8: TJ Kim, Ph.D., P.E. Clark P.E. - Los Angeles County, California · 2019. 5. 29. · 7 District 37 serves drinking water to approx. 4,400 people in Acton, California (near Palmdale)

8

District 37 Biological Treatment Pilot Testing Results General Observations

Page 9: TJ Kim, Ph.D., P.E. Clark P.E. - Los Angeles County, California · 2019. 5. 29. · 7 District 37 serves drinking water to approx. 4,400 people in Acton, California (near Palmdale)
Page 10: TJ Kim, Ph.D., P.E. Clark P.E. - Los Angeles County, California · 2019. 5. 29. · 7 District 37 serves drinking water to approx. 4,400 people in Acton, California (near Palmdale)

10

Acetic Acid

O2 & then NO3–

Phosphate(Nutrient)

Nitrogen Gas (N2)

More Bacteria

CO2

District 37 Biological Treatment Pilot Testing Results General Observations

Page 11: TJ Kim, Ph.D., P.E. Clark P.E. - Los Angeles County, California · 2019. 5. 29. · 7 District 37 serves drinking water to approx. 4,400 people in Acton, California (near Palmdale)

11

High Nitrate

Coag.

Chlorin

e

Acetic Acid & Phosphoric 

Acid

Low NitrateLow oxygen

Excess nitrogen gasHigh bacterial count

Air

Biological Process Aeration Filtration

Low NitrateLow oxygen

Excess nitrogen gasHigh bacterial count

Disinfection

Low NitrateLow oxygen

Excess nitrogen gasHigh bacterial count

District 37 Biological Treatment Pilot Testing Results General Observations

Page 12: TJ Kim, Ph.D., P.E. Clark P.E. - Los Angeles County, California · 2019. 5. 29. · 7 District 37 serves drinking water to approx. 4,400 people in Acton, California (near Palmdale)

Parameter Value

Biological Contactor EBCT 10 min

Filtration Rate 3.0 gpm/sf

Runtime Between Backwashes 24 – 48 hrs

Unit Backwash Volume ~150 gal/sf

Water Wastage Rate 6% to 12%

12

District 37 Biological Treatment Pilot Testing Results General Observations

Page 13: TJ Kim, Ph.D., P.E. Clark P.E. - Los Angeles County, California · 2019. 5. 29. · 7 District 37 serves drinking water to approx. 4,400 people in Acton, California (near Palmdale)

13Ch

lorin

e

Coag

ulan

t

Acetic Acid

Phosph

oric Acid

Well Pump

Clearwell / Reservoir

AirCompressor

Waste Washwater Tank

District 37 Biological Treatment Pilot Testing Results General Observations

Page 14: TJ Kim, Ph.D., P.E. Clark P.E. - Los Angeles County, California · 2019. 5. 29. · 7 District 37 serves drinking water to approx. 4,400 people in Acton, California (near Palmdale)

14Ch

lorin

e

Coag

ulan

t

Acetic Acid

Phosph

oric Acid

Well Pump

Clearwell / Reservoir

AirCompressor

Coag. & Cl2

Waste Washwater Recovery Tank

Sewer, Septic System, orOff‐Site Disposal

District 37 Biological Treatment Pilot Testing Results General Observations

Page 15: TJ Kim, Ph.D., P.E. Clark P.E. - Los Angeles County, California · 2019. 5. 29. · 7 District 37 serves drinking water to approx. 4,400 people in Acton, California (near Palmdale)
Page 16: TJ Kim, Ph.D., P.E. Clark P.E. - Los Angeles County, California · 2019. 5. 29. · 7 District 37 serves drinking water to approx. 4,400 people in Acton, California (near Palmdale)

16

District 37 Biological Treatment Pilot Testing Results General Observations

Page 17: TJ Kim, Ph.D., P.E. Clark P.E. - Los Angeles County, California · 2019. 5. 29. · 7 District 37 serves drinking water to approx. 4,400 people in Acton, California (near Palmdale)

Parameter Value

Coagulant Type Ferric Chloride

Coagulant Dose (Bio. Contactor WBW) 75 mg/L

Coagulant Dose (Filter WBW) 50 mg/L

Clarification Time 2 hrs

Return Flow (as % of Feed Flow) 10% to 15%

17

District 37 Biological Treatment Pilot Testing Results General Observations

Page 18: TJ Kim, Ph.D., P.E. Clark P.E. - Los Angeles County, California · 2019. 5. 29. · 7 District 37 serves drinking water to approx. 4,400 people in Acton, California (near Palmdale)

Parameter Unit Ave. Value

Nitrate mg/L as N 8.2

Dissolved Oxygen mg/L 8.2

Turbidity NTU 0.15

pH ‐‐ 7.5

Temperature oC 21.4

Alkalinity mg/L CaCO3 174

Hardness mg/L CaCO3 320

TOC mg/L 0.54

18

District 37 Biological Treatment Pilot Testing Results General Observations

Page 19: TJ Kim, Ph.D., P.E. Clark P.E. - Los Angeles County, California · 2019. 5. 29. · 7 District 37 serves drinking water to approx. 4,400 people in Acton, California (near Palmdale)

Parameter UnitBiologicalContactor

MediaFilter

Turbidity NTU 20 3

Iron mg/L 14 5

Chromium µg/L 16 4

HPC CFU/mL 2 × 106 0.6 × 106

TOC mg/L 50 4.6

Odor TON 100 200

19

District 37 Biological Treatment Pilot Testing Results General Observations

Page 20: TJ Kim, Ph.D., P.E. Clark P.E. - Los Angeles County, California · 2019. 5. 29. · 7 District 37 serves drinking water to approx. 4,400 people in Acton, California (near Palmdale)

20

Intentional Shutdown of Acetic Acid Feed

MCL

District 37 Biological Treatment Pilot Testing Results General Observations

Page 21: TJ Kim, Ph.D., P.E. Clark P.E. - Los Angeles County, California · 2019. 5. 29. · 7 District 37 serves drinking water to approx. 4,400 people in Acton, California (near Palmdale)

21

District 37 Biological Treatment Pilot Testing Results General Observations

Page 22: TJ Kim, Ph.D., P.E. Clark P.E. - Los Angeles County, California · 2019. 5. 29. · 7 District 37 serves drinking water to approx. 4,400 people in Acton, California (near Palmdale)

22

Proposed Cr6 MCL

District 37 Biological Treatment Pilot Testing Results General Observations

Page 23: TJ Kim, Ph.D., P.E. Clark P.E. - Los Angeles County, California · 2019. 5. 29. · 7 District 37 serves drinking water to approx. 4,400 people in Acton, California (near Palmdale)

23

District 37 Biological Treatment Pilot Testing Results General Observations

Page 24: TJ Kim, Ph.D., P.E. Clark P.E. - Los Angeles County, California · 2019. 5. 29. · 7 District 37 serves drinking water to approx. 4,400 people in Acton, California (near Palmdale)

24

District 37 Biological Treatment Pilot Testing Results General Observations

Page 25: TJ Kim, Ph.D., P.E. Clark P.E. - Los Angeles County, California · 2019. 5. 29. · 7 District 37 serves drinking water to approx. 4,400 people in Acton, California (near Palmdale)

Biological treatment is highly effective at removing nitrate.

Biological treatment also achieves effective removal of Cr(VI).

Recovery of waste backwash water is technically feasible.

Wastage rate can be reduced from about 12% without washwater recovery, to <1% with washwater recovery.

However, washwater recovery adds operational and water quality challenges that should be taken into consideration.

25

District 37 Biological Treatment Pilot Testing Results General Observations