The first assess of the haplotypes from COI gene sequences in...

10
The first assess of the haplotypes from COI gene sequences in species of spittlebugs (Cicadomorpha: Hemiptera) and aquatic true bugs (Gerromorpha and Nepomorpha: Hemiptera) in Brazil M.l\'I.U. Castanhole', S.R.C. Marchesin', L.L.V. Pereira', F.F.F. Moreira', .r.r, Barbosa', .J.R. Valério' and M.\\1. Ttoyama' 'Instituto de Biociências. Letras e Ciências Exatas, Universidade Estadual Paulista. Departamento de Biologia. São José do Rio Preto, SI'. Brasil 'Universidade Paulista. São José do Rio Preto, SI'. Brasil 3Universidade Federal do Rio de Janeiro, Rio de Janeiro, RJ, Brasil 'EMBRAPA Gado de Corte, Campo Grande, MS, Brasil Corresponding author: M.M.U. Castanhole E-mail: [email protected] Genet. MoI. Res. 12 (4): 5372-5381 (2013) Received February 6, 2013 Accepted August 19,2013 Published overnber 7,2013 DOI http://dx.doi.org/10.4238/2013.November.7.12 ABSTRACT. We made the first analysis ofthe cor gene sequences of 22 species of spittlebugs and aquatic true bugs sampled in São Paulo State (Brazil) and used this information to determine the variabi lity within these groups. Considering each codon position, we observed that the third base was the most variable, and the first base was the most conserved. Among species, Mahanarva fimbriolaia and Deois flavopicta had the greatest genetic distance (0.181), and Notozulia entreriana and Mahanarva sp had the srnallest distance (0.055), with an average variation of 0.119. In Gerromorpha, the Genencs and Molecular Research 12 (4): 5372-5381 (2013) ~)FUN PEC-RP W\V\V. funpecrp.corn. br

Transcript of The first assess of the haplotypes from COI gene sequences in...

Page 1: The first assess of the haplotypes from COI gene sequences in …ainfo.cnptia.embrapa.br/digital/bitstream/item/94385/1/... · 2013. 12. 21. · Heteroptera, or true bugs. is lhe

The first assess of the haplotypes from COIgene sequences in species of spittlebugs(Cicadomorpha: Hemiptera) and aquatictrue bugs (Gerromorpha and Nepomorpha:Hemiptera) in Brazil

M.l\'I.U. Castanhole', S.R.C. Marchesin', L.L.V. Pereira', F.F.F. Moreira',.r.r, Barbosa', .J.R. Valério' and M.\\1. Ttoyama'

'Instituto de Biociências. Letras e Ciências Exatas,Universidade Estadual Paulista. Departamento de Biologia.São José do Rio Preto, SI'. Brasil'Universidade Paulista. São José do Rio Preto, SI'. Brasil3Universidade Federal do Rio de Janeiro, Rio de Janeiro, RJ, Brasil'EMBRAPA Gado de Corte, Campo Grande, MS, Brasil

Corresponding author: M.M.U. CastanholeE-mail: [email protected]

Genet. MoI. Res. 12 (4): 5372-5381 (2013)Received February 6, 2013Accepted August 19,2013Published overnber 7,2013DOI http://dx.doi.org/10.4238/2013.November.7.12

ABSTRACT. We made the first analysis ofthe cor gene sequencesof 22 species of spittlebugs and aquatic true bugs sampled in SãoPaulo State (Brazil) and used this information to determine thevariabi lity within these groups. Considering each codon position, weobserved that the third base was the most variable, and the first basewas the most conserved. Among species, Mahanarva fimbriolaiaand Deois flavopicta had the greatest genetic distance (0.181), andNotozulia entreriana and Mahanarva sp had the srnallest distance(0.055), with an average variation of 0.119. In Gerromorpha, the

Genencs and Molecular Research 12 (4): 5372-5381 (2013) ~)FUN PEC-RP W\V\V. funpecrp.corn. br

Page 2: The first assess of the haplotypes from COI gene sequences in …ainfo.cnptia.embrapa.br/digital/bitstream/item/94385/1/... · 2013. 12. 21. · Heteroptera, or true bugs. is lhe

Haplorypes from COl in spirtlebugs anel true bugs 5373

greatest distance occurred between Halobatopsis p/atensis andRhagovelia zela (0.401), while between Cylindrostethus palmarisand Brachymetra albinervis albinervis, the distance was only0.187; the average value observed for the Gerromorpha was 0.265.In the Nepomorpha, the species Buenoa antigone antigone andBelostoma micantulum had lhe greatest genetic distance (0.337),while Martarega brasiliensis and B. a. antigone had the smallest(0.154). The average value observed for Nepomorpha was 0.203. InCicadomorpha (Auchenorrhyncha) and Nepomorpha (Heteroptera),the COI gene has been conserved; however, it is still useful forcharacterization of the different taxa. cal analysis was unable toresolve some of the Gerromorpha groups.

Key words: Heteroptera: Auchenorrhyncha; Gerromorpha; Nepomorpha;MtDNA

INTRODUCTION

The order Herniptera is currently classified into four suborders: Auchenorrhyncha,Coleorrhyncha, Sternorrhyncha, and Heteroptera (Carver et al., 199 I ; Forero, 2008). The sub-arder Auchenorrhyncha (part of the paraphyletic clade Homoptera in former classifications)includes, among others, the spittlebugs, a group ofhemipterans belonging to the superfamilyCercopoidea, which are important components of grass entomofauna. The family Cercopidae,an important member ofthis superfamily, is one of the largest groups of sucking insects. withrepresentatives being phytophagous and feeding predominantly on xylem. Approximately1500 species in 150 genera have so far been described in this family (Liang and Webb. ::wo:n.where they are distributed mainly in tropical and subtropical regions. Of these, approximately400 species are present in South America, with several irnportant pests of forage grasses andsugar cane (Costes and Webb, 2004; Castanhole et aI., 20 IO). In Brazil, these sharpshootersare also pests of sugar cane and pastures, and are therefore of great importance for biologicalcontrol studies and systematics (Milanez et aI., 1983; Zanol, 1996).

Heteroptera, or true bugs. is lhe largest and most diverse group of insects withincomplete metamorphosis. This suborder has seven infraorders, including Gerrornorpha anelNepomorpha, and approximately 80 families, which can be found on ali continents exceprAntarctica and on some islands (Schuh and Slater, 1995). In the São José do Rio Preto regionof Brazil, Heteroptera families that are commonly found include Belostomatidae, Coreidae,Gelastocoridae, Gerrielae, Lygaeidae, Notonectielae, Pentatomidae, Phyrrocoridae, Reduviidae,Rhopalidae and Veliidae. They can be either phytophagous, predatory or hematophagous.Specifically, these insects can live as parasites ofbirds and marnmals. feed on plants and fungior capture other arthropods in spider webs or water, .AIso. a few Heteroptera species reside inthe ocean (Schuh and Slater, 1995).

Insects are extremely cornplex groups due to their great diversity ofmitochondrial genomeswith rearrangements anel recombinations. related to substitution rates and nucleotide cornposition.suggesting lhe need for additional studies, including molecular approaches (l-lua et al., 2008).

Molecular analysis not only reveals lhe DNA sequence. but also polymorphisrns

Geneticsand Molecular Research 12 (4) 5372·5381 (:!OI3) «;')FUNPEC-RP www.funpecrp.com.br

Page 3: The first assess of the haplotypes from COI gene sequences in …ainfo.cnptia.embrapa.br/digital/bitstream/item/94385/1/... · 2013. 12. 21. · Heteroptera, or true bugs. is lhe

M.M.U. Castanhole et al. 5374

whose genetic basis and particular modes of transmission can be precisely determined(Avise, 2004). Thus, the molecular data in several studies collected for different taxonomicgroups have contributed to considerable advances in understanding the species' biology,ecology, behavior, genetics and evolution (Sunnucks, 200ú; Avise, 2004). Given thediverse characteristics of these suborders (Auchenorrhyncha and Heteroptera) and theevolutionary proximity of the groups, lhe use of molecular markers may be necessaryfor genetic characterization of these individuais. Such analyses could provide a betterunderstanding of lhe group.

The objective ofthis study was to carry out the first assessment of different haplotypesfor 22 species belonging to spittlebugs and aquatic true bugs (Hemiptera) sampled in Brazil,using mitochondrial cytochrome c oxidase subunit 1 gene (COl) sequences, and to use thisinforrnation to determine the variability within this group of insects.

MATERIAL AND METHODS

Taxon sampling

A total of 22 species were used in this study, including four species belonging to thesuborder Auchenorrhyncha (Cicadomorpha, Cercopidae) and 18 species ofthe aquatic and serni-aquatic infraorders (Gerromorpha and Nepomorpha) ofthe suborder Heteroptera (Table I).

Subordcr Farruly

Tahle I. Species used in this study, broken down by farnily, suborder and infraorder

SpeciesInfraorder

Auchenorrhyncha Cicadomorpha Cercopidae

Heteroptera Gerromorpha Gerridae

Veludae

Nepomorpha BelostornatidaeGelastocondaeNotonectidae

Deoisflovopicta (Stâl, 1954)Mahumnva fimbriolatu (Stâl, 1854)Mchonarva sp (Stâl, 1854)NOIO=u/ia entrvriana (Berg. 1879)Hrachyrnetra albinervis otbinervts= (Amyor and Servilte, !843)Bruchymetra albinervts atbtnervís=" (Amyot and Serville. 1843)Cyiindrostethns potmarts (Drake and Harrrs, 1934)Halobatopsis ptatensts (Berg, 1879)l.inmogonns aduncus (Orake and Harris, 1933)Rhenmatobotes crassifemur crosstfenntr (Esaki 1926)Mscrovetta longtpes {Uhler, 1894)Rhagoveho robusta (Gould, 1931)Rhagovelio tcmnpes (Champion, 1898)Rhagovetia zela (Drake, 1959)Belostonta nucontntnm (Stál, 1858)Getastocons ftovus flavus (Guérin-Ménevillc. 1835)Buenoa amnigenus (White, 1879)Buenoa amígone antígone [Kirkaldy, 1899)Buenoa unglff.\·(Truxal, 1953)Manorega brastlíensts (Truxal, 1949)Monarega membranaceo (White 1879)Monaregn urugnayensss [Berg, 1883)

*Population 1 collected in São José do Rio Preto; **Population 2 collected in Jales.

Auchenorrhyncha species were collected in Campo Grande, MS, Brazil (20026'S,54°38'W). Heteroptera species were colJected in the cities of Américo de Campos (20° 18'S,49°44'W), Guaraci (20030'S, 48°S6'W), Jales (20° 16'S, S0032'W), Mirassol (20049'S,49°30'W), Sales t21 °20'S, 49°29'W), and São José do Rio Preto (20047'S, 49°21 'W) in São

Genetics and lVIolecular Research 12 (4): 5372-5381 (2013) ©FUNPEC-RP www.funpecrp.corn.br

Page 4: The first assess of the haplotypes from COI gene sequences in …ainfo.cnptia.embrapa.br/digital/bitstream/item/94385/1/... · 2013. 12. 21. · Heteroptera, or true bugs. is lhe

Haplotypes from COI in spirtlebugs and true bugs 5375

Paulo State, Brazil. Two populations of Brachymetra albinervis albinervis, population I (*)and population 2 (**), were collected in São José do Rio Preto and Jales, respectively. Alisamples were stored at -20°C in absolute ethanol at the Laboratory of Cytogenetic and Mo-lecular of lnsects (LACIMI), Instituto de Biociências, Letras e Ciências Exatas, UniversidadeEstadual Paulista (UNESP), Campus São José do Rio Preto, SP, Brazil.

Molecular data

mtDNA was extracted using the protocol described by Tartarotti (2002) and the Ge-nomic DNA Extraction kit protocol from Machery Nagel Tissue. To obtain the sequence oflhe COI gene, we used two primers (1 and 2, Table 2) to first amplify the gene. The gene wasamplified by PCR with the following conditions: denaturation at 94°C for I min; 35 cycles ofdenaturation (94°C for 30 s), annealing (temperature gradient 48 - 55°C for 1 min), extension(72°C for I min); and extensionat 72°C for 7 mino The reaction consisted ofO.3 ~L nucleo-tides (ATeG), 11.6 ~L ddHP, 0.44 ul, MgCI2, 1.5 ~L PCR buffer, 0.06 ~lLDNA Platinum Taqpolymerase, and 0.3 ~L primers (10 mM).

Table 2. Prirners used for the amplification and sequencing otthe COI gene.

Primers Foward Reverse Measure (+-) Reference

TTICAACAAATCATAAAGATATIGG TAAACTICAGGGTGACCAAAAAATCACAACAT1TA1TrTGATTTrnGG Gi\/\JACTGCTCCTi\TGGATA

700 bp500 bp

Folmer <1.1. (1994)Simon et al. (1994).Damgaard and Sperling (100 I)

A fter the amplification reactions, sequencing was perforrned. a total of 22 sequenceswere used for the species of the suborders Auchenorrhyncha (infraorder Cicadomorpha) andHeteroptera (infraorders Gerromorpha and Nepomorpha). The primers used for sequencingannealed to the 5' portion of the COI gene (prirner 1) and the middle of the gene (primer 2),Sequencing using primers I and 2 generated fragments of 650 and 350 bp, respectively. Thesefragments were used to construct the distance matrices and dendrograms and for analysis ofnucleotide composition.

The samples were purified using a purification kit frorn GE Healthcare. BigDye se-quencing was performed by the Center for Human Genome Studies at the University of SãoPaulo-USP, Brazil, according to a standard protocol (http://genoma.ib.usp.br).

The analysis of sequence alignments and determination of nucleotidc composition anddistance rnatrix learning were performed using BioEdit (Hall, 1999) and MEGA 5 (Tamuraet al., 2011). For the distance matrix analysis and in order to obtain the dendrograms usingthe neighbor-joining method (NJ), Kimura-Z-Parameter (K2P, nucleotide substitution ruodel)and the support branches estimated from 1000 bootstrap replicates, using the program MEGA5. Neomaskellia andropogonis Corbett 1926 (Aleyrodidae), which belongs to the orderHemiptera, suborder Sternorrhyncha, was used as an outgroup. The complete sequence oftheN andropogonis mitochondrial genome can be found in the NCBl database (http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/). The choice of this species was based on the work of Maddison (1995), whoreported that the suborders Auchenorrhyncha and Heteroptera are derived from Sternorrhyncha.

The sequences were submitted to NCBl with the following GenBank accession nUI11-bers: JN202451- JN20247I , JN681122-JN681148, and JN689483-JN689505.

Genetics and Molecular Research 12 (4): 5372-5381 (2013) ©FUNPEC-RP wwwfunpecrp.com.br

Page 5: The first assess of the haplotypes from COI gene sequences in …ainfo.cnptia.embrapa.br/digital/bitstream/item/94385/1/... · 2013. 12. 21. · Heteroptera, or true bugs. is lhe

M.M.U. CastanhoJe et al. 5376

RESULTS AND DISCUSSION

Variability analysis

The greatest genetic diversity for the COI sequences among the Cicadomorpha(Auchenorrhyncha) species was found between Mahanarva fimbriolata and Deois fiavopicta(0.181), whereas the least variation occured between Notozulia entreriana and Mahanarva sp.(0.055). Overall, the mean variation for the infraorder Cicadomorpha was 0.119.

For the infraorder Gerromorpha (Heteroptera), the largest distance was observedbetween H. platensis and R. zela (0.401), whi1e the smallest was between C. palmaris and B.a. albinervis=" (0.187). Overall, the mean distance value was 0.265 for Gerromorpha. For theinfraorder Nepomorpha (Heteroptera), the average value was 0.203, and the greatest variationwas between B. a. antigone and B. micantulum (0.337). M. brasiliensis and B. a. antigoneshowed the lowest variation (0.154) (Table 3). These results indicate that, on the basis of theCOI marker, the species ofCicadomorpha (Auchenorrhyncha) have greater genetic similaritythan those ofthe infraorders Gerromorpha and Nepomorpha.

Table 3. Highcst and lowest values of interspecific and Intraspecífic distancegroups analyzed using the K2P model of nucleotide súbstítution.

mean for thé three~"",

Group Distance

lruerspectfic lntrageneric

High Low MeanMean

Ctcadomorpha 0.181(lv/. ,fjmbrio/lIfa! V Jlaropic'la)OAOI(11. zelaIH. ptatenstss

0.055(N emrenanolsíahanarvn sp)0.187(C patmans / 13.a. albinel'l'is**')0.154(/\1. brostltenssstb. o. lJl1llgone)

0119 o 100 - Malumarva

Gerromorpha 0.265 0.291 - Rhugovetto

Nepomorpha 0.337 0.203 o. J 22 - BIlé'110(}

0.119 - Monarego(ll I11ICul1ft'/lImIB. o. amigone)

Taking into account intrageneric variation, the genus Rhagovelia had an average dis-tance value of 0.291, indicating that this genus has twice the genetic diversity of species ofMahanarva (Cicadomorpha, 0.1), Buenoa (Nepomorpha, 0.122), and Martarega (Nepomor-pha, 0.119) (Table 3).

Specimens of B. a. albinervis" and B. a. albinervis=" had an intraspecific valueof 0.087, whereas this was 0.055 for species of the genus Notozulia and Mahanarva ofCicadomorpha , showing the variation that exists within these groups (Tables SI, S2, and S3).

Overall, despite the variation observed, the distance values are low in the three groupsstudied. Sosa-Górnez et al. (2005) used the RAPD genetic marker and found that for otherI-leteroptera neotropical species (Nezara viridula Linnaeus 1758, Pentatomidae), this type ofgenetic similarity was associated with a high gene flow in the populations evaluated.

Park et al. (2011) and Jung et al, (2011) conducted a large study of insects of thesuborder Heteroptera and observed different patterns of intraspecific and interspecificdivergence using COI as a marker gene. Tn these studies, intraspecific variations were notuncommon within the suborder. The authors concluded that inrraspecific divergence couldbe due to ancestral polymorphisms or introgression, but did not rule out the possibility of acryptic species divergence. This observation may explain why the observed genetic distance

Genetics and Molecular Research 12 (4) 5372-5381 (2013) (gFUNPEC-RP www.funpecrp.com.br

Page 6: The first assess of the haplotypes from COI gene sequences in …ainfo.cnptia.embrapa.br/digital/bitstream/item/94385/1/... · 2013. 12. 21. · Heteroptera, or true bugs. is lhe

Haplorypes from COl in spittlebugs and true bugs 5J77

values for the species B. a. albinervis were above the lower values observed for differentspecies ofthe family Cercopidae.

Figure IA-C depicts the dendrograms formed from the genetic distance measurements.For Cicadomorpha (Auchenorrhyncha), the species M fimbriolata and Mahanarva sp. weresister groups with a bootstrap value of 94%, and the species N. entreriana was more externalwith a 100% bootstrap value, The species D. fiavopicta was external to the other groups(Figure IA). In Nepomorpha, the species of the genera Buenoa and Martarega belongingto the same family (Notonectidae) were grouped together with bootstrap values of 89 and80%, respectively. In addition, the species B. micantulum (Belostomatidae) and G. f fiavus(Gelastocoridae) were more externa! to the family Notonectidae (Figure 1B). Some of theGerromorpha species belonging to the same family had unresolved clusters, For example, AIlongipes (Veliidae) and R. c. crassifemur (Gerridae) were grouped together as sisters, and thebetween-group in relation to species ofthe same genus, with R. zela grouped outside the genusRhagovelia and ali other species studied. However, the grouping B. a. albinervis" and B. a.albinervis=" (Gerridae) showed a bootstrap value of 98% (Figure 1C).

A

,,_.---Uf;:'I;;)l<xs:el~M$P ::""(~-'u!><:

,---- ----i~~~~{~Y..i I t~1Xt~norrt:••~,

'c -e.eece'-------------- •• e-:d~!.s I <;:'!fWA:tp,,>C!,)

B 8. a. antigme

_=.,--8. unguis

B.~

Mb_".

....... C>/.tI.MJsL- N~·I

I Veludae

'-- R. c. t:r.I$Sifem.x I

[_..~.~.-___1'______~~ I ::~:::

'-.. N.~ I Sterucrrhyneha

,-- R""""' ••

0.1

Figure I. Dendrograms based on the neighbor joining method and lhe K2P model for the taxa oí: A. Cicadomorpha(Auchenorrhyncha): B. Nepomorpha; C. Gerromorpha (Heteroptera). The numbers at lhe nodes of the branchesrcfer to the bootstrap vaiues.

Geneties and Molecular Research 12 (4) 5372-5381 (2013) ':0FUNPEC-RP www.funpecrp.com.br

Page 7: The first assess of the haplotypes from COI gene sequences in …ainfo.cnptia.embrapa.br/digital/bitstream/item/94385/1/... · 2013. 12. 21. · Heteroptera, or true bugs. is lhe

M.M.U. Castanhole et a!. 5378

Thus, we found that the clusters generated for Cicadomorpha were satisfactorybecause they formed congeneric groups (Mahanarva). The same result was obtained for theinfraorder Nepomorpha genera Buenoa and Martarega, which constitute a group within thefamily Notonectidae and differslightly more from the families Belostornatidae (B. micantulum)and Gelastocoridae (G. fiavus flavus). Unlike the results that were previously reported forCicadomorpha (Auchenorrhyncha) and Nepomorpha (I-Ieteroptera), the close relationshipsbetween specimens belonging to the infraorder Gerromorpha were presented as an unresolvedmixture ofterminal taxa. Two ofthe taxa belonging to the genus Rhagovelia (R. robusta + R.tenuipes) were closely related, yet R. zela was paraphyletic. Damgaard (2008) showed thattheir studies ditfered most significantly by rejecting the family Veliidae and the superfamilies"Gerroidea" (comprising Gerridae + Veliidae + Hermatobatidae) and "Hydrometroidea"(comprising I-Iydrometridae + Macroveliidae + Paraphrynoveliidae) as paraphyletic entities,compared to earl ier studies of global gerromorphan diversity (Andersen, 1982; Andersenand Weir, 2004). 1n addition, species traditionally grouped in different families resulted assister-groups. Such is the case of M. longipes (Veliidae), which resulted as sister-group of R.c. crassifemur (Gerridae). This result corroborates the paraphyletic condition of the familyVeliidae presented by Damgaard (2008), in which Microvelia and other Microveliinae generaare more closely related to the Gerridae than to other Veliidae. The confidence values generatedby bootstrap in this analysis ranged from 72 to 98%.

The diversification observed for R. ::.elacould be a natural characteristic of thisspecies. Alternatively, this diversity could be due to variation at the collection site (Américo deCampos, SP, Brazil), which was different from other similar groups of Rhagovelia (Mirassol,SP, Brazil), and was therefore liable to undergo differentiaJ selective pressure, Garcia et a!.(2003) noted that the differences observed in Triatoma infestans (Reduviidae, Heteroptera)are not necessarily related to gene ftow in these populations, but they could be eventuallyattributed to local selection pressure or genetic drift. However, additional studies are needed,including population analysis of R. zela collected in different regions to determine ifthis kindof diversification is natural or if the population is subject to different selective forces.

For Cicadomorpha (Auchenorrhyncha) and Nepomorpha (Heteroptera), the dendro-grams and distance matrices suggest that the cal gene had been conserved, yet it was efficientfor lhe characterization ofthe different taxa analyzed. Cal analysis was unable to resolve thegroups in Gerromorpha. However, this diversification may be a natural characteristic of somespecies analyzed, or it may be related to the environment.

Nucleotide composition

The nucleotide composition, or AT%, for the species ofthe infraorder Cicadomorpha(Auchenorrhyncha, Group 1) studied ranged 60.41-72.10% with an average of 68.15%. Thespecies of Heteroptera of the infraorder Gerromorpha (Group 2) had an AT% ranging 64.34-70.51 % and an average of 67.56%. Overall, the species ofthe infraorder Nepomorpha (Group3) had an average AT% of 67.77%, and AT% ranged 63.62-69.7\ % for lhe individual species.

The Af% was high for ali three groups, but the highest value was observed in Group1 (68.15%), and the lowest value was found in Group 2 (67.56%) (Table 4). These resultsrevealed that among the different haplotypes of the cal gene, the nucleotide composition wasabove average, with an increased frequency ofadenines and thymines. In line with these results,

Genetics and Molecular Research 12 (4) 5372-5381 (2013) ©FUNPEC-RP www.funpecrp.com.br

Page 8: The first assess of the haplotypes from COI gene sequences in …ainfo.cnptia.embrapa.br/digital/bitstream/item/94385/1/... · 2013. 12. 21. · Heteroptera, or true bugs. is lhe

Haplotypes from COI in spittlebugs and true bugs 5379

Hua et a!. (2008) analyzed the mitochondrial genome ofPentatomomorpha (Heteroptera) andnoted that the nucleotide composition was 68.86 to 77.8%. This study also found that generearrangements were not correlated with rates of nucleotide substitution and that differentevolutionary patterns between genes were due to variation in GC content.

Tabkt: •.:.!~l~latn~no. acid . . ." .' ." .. polYl11orphlc,s:te8, r3!JO of transitionand tnln!WerSu)l1s (Tlf(v) agefrequen A +Tofthe t ps for lhe subnrder Auchenorrhvncha(1) and tl1e infraorder Gerromorpha (2) and Nepomorpha (3) of lhe suborder Heteroprera.

Groups Sires Arninoacids NucJeotide composirion

Total Polymorphics Total Polymorphics rvr, %AT

1010 42 336 I 1271 68.151015 264 338 88 0.983 67561013 191 337 27 0.818 67.77

The total nurnber of sites analyzed for Groups I, 2 and 3 were 1010, 10 15 and 1013,respectively. Of these, Group 2 showed the highest number ofpolymorphic sites (264), folIowedby Group 3 with 191 sites. The total number ofthese polymorphic sites that caused an amino acidchange was relatively small. For Group 1, onJy DNA polymorphism resultedin an amino acidchange. This result was different frorn what was observed for Gerrornorpha and Nepornorphainfraorders, which had 88 and 27 polyrnorphic amino acids, respectively (Table 4).

Analysis of the ratio between the number of transitions (Ti) and transversions (Tv)showed that Ti occur more often, which was indicated by a shorter genetic distance. In regardsto this. the shortest distance was observed for Group 3 (0.818), and the largest distance wasfound for Group 1 (1.271) (Table 4).

When considering the potential infonnation for each codon position, we observed thatfor alI ofthe groups, the third base in a codon was the rnost variable, and the first base was themost conserved. The third base position for the infraorder Nepomorpha was the most variable(229 polymorphisms), and it was the least variable (126) in Auchenorrhyncha. The infraorderGerromorpha showed the third base with more nucleotide information (142) (Table 5). This isa characteristic that has been described by Hebert et a!. (2003), who found that the for the cmgene, there is great variation in the base in the third position ofits codons, although changes inthe COI amino acid sequence occur more slowly than for other mitochondrial genes. The COIgene, when cornpared with other genes, has a slower rate of protein evolution.

Table 5. Number 01"variable sites based on the parsirnonious nucleotide in a codon.

Subordcr Infraordcr Sues

Variables Parsimomous

l st 2nd 3rd 1st 2nd Jrd

Auchenorrhyncha Cicadomorpha 36.00 6.00 1~600 6.00 1.00 3500Heteroprera Gcrromorpha 139.02 62.60 198.00 85.00 36.60 142.00

Nepomorpha 80.75 12.00 229.00 48.00 9.00 134.00

These ana1yses provi de important information in studies such as strand asymmetry,which help in understanding the variations of selection on amino acid sequences and rnutationduring replication and transcription ofrnitochondrial DNA for evolution studies (Wei et al., 2010).

Genetics and Molecular Research 12 (4): 5372-5381 (2013) ©FUNPEC-RP www.funpecrp.com.br

Page 9: The first assess of the haplotypes from COI gene sequences in …ainfo.cnptia.embrapa.br/digital/bitstream/item/94385/1/... · 2013. 12. 21. · Heteroptera, or true bugs. is lhe

M.M. U. Castanhole et aI. 5380

Studies analyzing the diversity of Hemiptera are rare but extrernely important forunderstanding the genetic characteristics of this group, including the nucleotide compositionand the variation of genes within and between species and related groups. 1n this study, weobserved that the mitochondrial COl gene region (l kb) appears to be a good marker. Thesefindings are consistent with what had been described for other species ofHemiptera.

Additional studies and analyses with different markers should be conducted to confirmthe observations of this study; meanwhile, these results contribute to taxonomic, systematicand genetic variability studies ofthe populations ofthe entomologic community.

ACKNOWLEDGMENTS

Research supported by FAPESP and FUNDUNESP. The identification of aquatic in-sects was performed by the research group of Praf. Dr. Jorge Luiz Nessimian (Contributor,UFRJ, RJ), and the Auchenorrhyncha sarnples were supplied by Prof. Dr. Jose Raul Valerio(EMBRAPA-CENARGEN, Campo Grande, MS).

Supplementary material

REFERENCES

Andersen NM (1982). The Semiaquatic Bugs (Hemiptera, Gerromorpha): Phylogeny, Adaptations, Biogeography andClassification. Scandinavian Science Press, Klampenborg.

Andersen Nlvl and Weir TA (20041. Mesoveliidae. Hebridae, and Hydrometridae of Austrália (Herniptera: Heteroptera:Gerrornorpha), with a reanalysis ofthe phylogeny of semiaquatic bugs. lnvert. Systemaucs 18: 467-522.

Avise JC (2004). Molecular Markers, Natural History and Evolution. 2nd edn. Associares, lnc. Publishers, Massachusetts.Carver M. Gross GF and Woodward TE (1991). Herniptera. ln: Cornmon Wealth Scientific and Industrial Research

Organization (CSIROl, The Insects of Australia, A Textbook for Students and Research Workers. MelbourneUniversiry Press & Cornell Universiry Press.

Castanhole MM, Pereira LL, de Souza HV, Valerio JR, et aI. (20 IO). Meiotic chromosornes and nucleolar behaviorin testicular cells of the grassland spinlebugs Deois flavoptcta, Mahanarva [unbriolata and Notozulio entreriana(Hemiptera, Auchenorrhyncha). Genet. Moi. Bio!. 33: 244-252.

Costes DH and Webb MD (2004). Four new species ofNeotropical spittlebugs (Hemiprera, Cercopidae, Tomaspidinae).Rev. Hras. Enromol. 48: 391-393.

Damgaard .I and Sperlíng FAH (2001). Phylogeny of the water strider genus Gerris Fabricius (Heteroptera: Gerridae)based on COI mtDNA, EF-Ia nuclear DNA and morphology. Syst. Entomol. 26: 241-254.

Damgaard J (2008). Phylogeny ofthe semiaquatic bugs (Hemiprera-Heteroptcra, Gerromorpha). lnsect Sysiematics Evol.39 431-460.

Folmer O, Black M, Hoeh W, Lutz R, et aI. (1994). DNA primers for amplification ofmitochondrial cytochrome c oxidasesubunit I from diverse metazoan invertebrates. Moi. Mar. Biol. Biotechnol. 3: 294-299.

Forero D (2008). The systernatics of the Hemiptera. Rcv. Colomb. Entomol. 34: 1-21.García BA, Manfredí C, Fichera L and Segura EL (2003). Short report: variation in mitochondrial 12S and 16S ribosomal

DNA sequences in natural populations 01' Triatomo intestuns (Hemiptera: Reduviidae). Am . .J. Trop. Med. Hyg. 68:692-694.

Hall TA (1999). Bioêdit: a user-friendly biological sequence alignmenl editor and analysis prograrn for Windows 95i98!NT Nucleic Actds Svmp. Ser. 41 95-98.

Hebert PD, Cywinska A, Ball SL and dcWaard JR (2003). Biological idenufications through DNA barcodes. Proc. Btol.Sei. 270 313-321.

Hua J, Li IV1.Dong P, Cui Y, et al. (2008). Cornparative and phylogenornic studies on the mitochondrial genomes ofPentatomomorpha (lnsecta: Hemiptera: Heteroptera). BtvlC Genomics 9: 610 .

.lung S, Duwal RK and Lee S (2011 l. COI barcoding of Irue bugs (lnsecta, Heteroptera). Mol. Ecol. Resour. 11' 266-270.Liang A-P and Webb MD (2002). New taxa and revisionary notes in Rhinaulacini spittlebugs from southern Asia

(Hornoptera: Cercopidae). .J. Nat. Hist. 36: 729-756.

Genetics and Molecular Research 12 (4): 5372-5381 (2013) ©FUNPEC-RP www.funpecrp.com.br

Page 10: The first assess of the haplotypes from COI gene sequences in …ainfo.cnptia.embrapa.br/digital/bitstream/item/94385/1/... · 2013. 12. 21. · Heteroptera, or true bugs. is lhe

Haplotypes from COI in spittlebugs and true bugs 5381

Maddison DR (1995). Hemiptera. True Bugs. Cicadas, Leafhoppers, Aphids, etc. Version January I, 1995 (Temporary).Available at [http://tolweb.orgIHemiptera/8239/1995.01.01] in The Tree of Life Web Project, [hnp.z'rolweb.org/].Accessed October 18,2012.

Milanez .1M, Milde LCE and Parta JRP (1983). Estimativa da constante térmica das cigarrinhas das pastagens Zulia(Nolo=lIba) entreriana (Berg, 1879) e Deois (Acumhodeoisíftavopicta (Sral, 1854) (Homoptera: Cercopidae) emcondições de campo. An. Soe. Entomol. Bras. 12: 151-163.

Park DS, Foottir R, Maw E and Hebert PD (2011). Barcoding bugs: DNA-based identification ofthe true bugs (Insecta:Hemiptera: Heteroptera). PLoS One 6: e 18749.

Schuh RT and Slater JA (1995). True Bugs of the World (Hemiptera; Heteroptera: Classification and Natural History).Cornell Universiry Press, London.

Simon C, Frati F, Beckenbach A, Crespi B, et al. (1994). Evolution, weighting, and phylogenetic utility ofmitochondria!gene sequences and a compilation of conserved polymerase chain reaction primers. Anil. Entomol. Soe. Am. 87:651-701.

Sosa-Gómez DR, da Silva JJ, Costa F, Binneck E, et al. (2005). Population structure ofthe Brazilian southern green stinkbug, Nezara vindula . .J. lnsect Sei. 5: 23.

Sunnucks P (2000). Efficient geneuc rnarkers for population biology. Trends Ecol. Evol. 15: 199-203.Tamura K. Peterson D. Peterson N, Stecher G. et at. (2011). MEGA5: molecular evolutionary genetics analysis usíng

maximum likelihood, evolutionary distance, and maximum parsimony methods. Moi. Biol. Evol. 28: 2731-2739.Tartarotti E (2002). Variabilidade Genética e Filogenia em Triatomíneos (Triatominae, Heteroptera). Doctoral thesis,

Universidade Estadual Paulista, Instituto de Biociêncías, Letras e Ciências Exatas, São Jose do Rio Preto.Wei SJ, Shi M. Chen XX, Sharkey MJ, et at. (2010). New views on strand asymmetry in insect mitochondria1 genomes.

P/,oS One 5: e In08.Zanol KI\1H (1996). Descrição de cinco espécies novas de Bahita Oman (Hornoptera, Cicadellidae, Deltocephalinae). Rev.

Bras. Zoo/.13: 727-735.

Genetics and Molecular Research 12 (4): 5372-5381 (2013) ©FUNPEC-RP www.funpecrp.com.br