The Dialectics of Software Art - PhD Thesis

8/13/2019 The Dialectics of Software Art - PhD Thesis

1/233

!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

"#$%$&'(%() $&' +%",'-$%-( ./ (./$0"1' "1$

234 5678759: ; ?6958753 @A

3=@8D3875> 13>3965D -32836

D88?)TT444EB7C789:V93>8387GEBG

ANTITHESIS:THEDIALECTICSOFSOFTW

AREART

GEOFFCOX

ANTITHESIS:

THE

DIALECTICS

OF

SOFTWARE

ART

GEOFF COX


2/233


3/233


4/233

!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!"#$%$&'(%() $&' +%",'-$%-( ./ (./$0"1' "1$!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

2'.// -.3


5/233

"456578969) 578 +6:;85?:@8 "@5 ABC;6978D CE +6F65:; "8957856 578 C==] 69 :I:6;:C;8 :5 755V)ZZD:@8@84


6/233

!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!"#$%$&'(%() $&' +%",'-$%-( ./ (./$0"1' "1$!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

2'.// -.3

+6F65:; "8957856


7/233


8/233

!!!!!!!!-.#$'#$(!!!!!!!!

LW V@8>:5?:@8 N:58@6:;69NKWY 9=>5?:@8 :@5 7695=@E

YW 8N8@F845 7695=@EYWT 7695=@6


9/233


10/233

9

!!!!!!!!!!LW A1'/"-'!!!!!!!!!!

%5 69 =48 => 578 :998@56=49 => 578 C==] 57:5 9=>5?:@8

CE 8NC=DE64F :=;;=?64F 64656:; 9BVV=@5 >@=N 578 /: "@5 :4D $8 A;EN=B57 >=@ KLLMG 9=N8 D85:6;9 :@8 : ;55;8 =B5N=D8D 64 V;:


11/233


12/233

11

hiZB9@ZC64ZA8@;

V@645 jj:456$&'(%(k

!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

l578 D6:;85?:@8 :@5l!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!TW l645@=DB


13/233

12

$78 578969 C8F649 ?657 : F848@:; =I8@I68? => 9=>5?:@8:@5 :4D


14/233

13

:4D @=N V@8I6=B9 N=D89 `


15/233

14

`:4:;=F=B9 5= V@=V@685:@E N=D8;9 => =@N => : 578=@E :4D V@:

`:9 C=57 :@5?=@] :4D 578969a :4D 578 V=58456:; >=@ 659


16/233

15

.4 : 58


17/233

16

!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!KW l9=>5?:@8 :@5l!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

d':@;68@ NBB56;8 57=BF75 7:D C884 D8I=58D 5= 578

gB8956=4 => ?78578@ V7=5=F@:V7E 69 :4 :@5W $78 V@6N:@EgB8956=4 O ?78578@ 578 I8@E 64I8456=4 => V7=5=F@:V7E7:D 4=5 5@:49>=@N8D 578 4:5B@8 => :@5 O ?:9 4=5 @:698DW

?6D8@


18/233

17

=> 578 58@N d9=>5?:@8 :@5eG 64 D895?:@8 B98D 5= V@=DB5?:@8 6598;> :9 578 :@5?=@] `:4D 5769 699B8 69 D85:6;aW %4 =578@ ?=@D9G 578 V@=F@:NN8@9 VB5 578 V@8O

V@=DB


19/233

18


20/233

19

=> 58@N9W $78 58@N 9=>5?:@8 :@5 7:9 C8


21/233

20

=@ 4=5W ';98?78@8 5==G -@:N8@ 7:9 6496958D 57:5 :;;D6F65:; :@5 69 9=>5?:@8 :@5 64 :9 NB5?:@8 5= @B4G C8 65 :C@=?98@G =V8@:564F 9E958NG =@ 485?=@] V@=5= :;;

D6F65:; :@5 69 9=>5?:@8 :@5G 65 5?:@8 69 F848@:56I8G 64 57:5 65 @B49 : 985 F848@:58 =578@ >=@N9 :4D V@=8956I:; :4D -@:N8@ V@=I6D8D : B98>B; D89


22/233

21

CB5 64 F848@:; 578 >8956I:;e9 =V844899 :55@:8@9 5= :4E :@5 V@:


23/233

22

%4 : F848@:; 98498G 578@8 69 C@=:D :F@88N845 57:5F848@:56I8 :@5 69 : 58@N :VV;68D 5= :@5?=@] 57:5 69:B5=N:58D CE 578 B98 => 6495@B


24/233

23

:4D 8N8@F845 C87:I6=B@G :4D 64 V:@565?:@8 dF84=5EV89e `+#" 64 5?:@8 ?=B;D 8I=;I8 d:B5=4=N=B9;EeW AB5 96NV;EGc


25/233

24

P=57 2:;:458@ :4D c


26/233

25

F@:NN:@e `9=N856N89 @8>8@@8D 5= :9 d5@:49>=@N:56=4:;F@:NN:@eaW -7=N9]E :99BN89 57:5 9=N87=? F@:NN:@ 69F6I84 64 :DI:4=@8 7BN:4


27/233

26

>=@ 9BC95:456I8a 69 @8V;:=;;=?64F 6564 : D6 : KLLL ?=@DD6


28/233

27

48? V=58456:;65689 64 5769 ?:EW %4 dA@=98 :4D"456@=N @8V;:


29/233

28

@8>8@@64F 5= 769 =?4 4=I8; b%> =4 : 06458@e9 #6F75 :$@:I8;;8@b `TSQTaG 64 ?76


30/233

29

:@8 @8V@898458D CE 57@88 DE9>B45?:@8 :@5

%4 578 N:4E 5?:@8 :@5 4=? :4D578 =;D8@ V@: 57898 699B89 64N64D 57:5 16


31/233

30

$78 D695648@9 C:


32/233

31

d%4 9=>5?:@8 :@5G 578 [N:58@6:;65E\ => 578 ?@655846495@B


33/233

32

gB8956=464F 578 C64:@E @8;:56=4 => >=@N:;69N `:99= C864F:4D @8;:56=4 `KLLU) TYQaW &8


34/233

33

98V:@:564F 65 >@=N 578 @8:;65E => 659 9=


35/233

34

h 9=>5?:@8


36/233

35

57:5


37/233

36

:I:6;:C;8 5= =578@ B98@9W $769 V=645 V@=_8


38/233

37

P;:]8e9 V=8N D89


39/233

38

69 >B@578@ D8I8;=V8D CE 1=;:4D P:@5789e9 899:E d$78+8:57 => 578 "B57=@e `TSRRa ?69764F 5= N:]8 578 @8:D8@ dD8:57e 69 : N85:V7=@6< F895B@8) d578 C6@57 => 578@8:D8@ NB95 C8 :5 578 578 D8:57 => 578 "B57=@e

5= : 5769u %5 7:9 4=5 96NV;E D69:VV8:@8D CB5 69 @8


40/233


41/233

40

57:5 pI=448 X=;]:@5 D895?:@8 69 B98D :9 : 5==; 64 : N:448@>=@ ?76


42/233

41

%49565B58 >=@ 578 (5BDE => /:9


43/233

42

V@6458D :5 ^M ,6I8@V==; (5@885G ,=4D=4 64 TQ^QaW %4 5769?:EG 578 7:@D?:@8 ?8@8 N:D8 =V84 9=B@5?:@8W $78 B98@e9 FB6D8 ?:9 96NV;E : @8V@645 => b$78-=NNB4695 c:46>895=b 64 578 >=@N => 9 578

:VV@=:


44/233

43

98


45/233

44

$78 9BFF8956=4 => 5769 98 578 =@N:56=4 9=>5?:@8 `?78578@ B98D D6@8:


46/233

45

485?=@]9 O =@ ?7:5 78


47/233

46

";57=BF7 :4E D69 9=>5?:@8 @8gB6@89 :4B4D8@95:4D64F => 659 @8;:56=4976V 5= 7:@D?:@8 `8I84 7:@D?:@8aG 65 69 5?:@8 69 C864F

5=


48/233

47

9=>5?:@8 69 57:5 65 :=@ :4 8NV7:969 =4 9=5?:@8 V@=DB 659 56N89 ?657 659 =I8@5 95@B


49/233

48

:@5695G 8I6D845 64 :@5e9 =@F:469:56=4:; :4D 9E958N6@=N +:D:O695 dV=8NO=C_8=B4DO=C_8


51/233

50

dD8N:58@6:;69:56=4 => :@5eG 5@8:564F :@56959 6458@V@8564F 578 ;8F:


52/233

51

,6;;8N=98 V@=V=989 9=>5?:@8 :@5 :9 : >=B@57 F848@:56=4W$769 69 9V8 :@5 7=;D9 @:D6 578 :I:45OF:@D8 5= D8;6I8@ 659 V@=N6989`8I6D845 64 -=4


53/233

52

95BD8459 ?7= 8:F8@;E V@=DB:657>B;;E :9 48F:56=4 5= @8 578 dV=95 :I:45OF:@D8e `TSQ^a ?657 ?76 578 7695=@6


54/233

53

:C=B5 :@5 :4D 784


55/233

54

5= 578 b% ,=I8 p=Bb I6@B9 `=> KLLLa 57:5 9V@8:D 57@=BF7578 578 %458@485W .V8464F 578 N899:F8d;=I8 ;8558@ >=@ E=Be ?=B;D : CE 984D64F 48? 6598;>

D895@B : I6@B9 =V8@:589 64 578 9V6@65=> :B5=OD895@B


56/233

55

6495:;;:56=49 B4D8@ 578 98@689 4:N8 b(8:;8D -=NVB58@9b 5@:49>=@N:56=4:; V@=


57/233

56

:DI8@56964FG :9 ?8;; :9 64 P:@=gB8 6N:F8@EW $78 B98@e96D;8 56N8 69 D6@8 F@=?57=> 578 V;:45 =4 5786@ D89]5=V >@=N 988D;64F 5= >B;;EF@=?4 V;:45 57@=BF7 5= 659 D8 $6N8bG578 N=@8 6D;8 578 B98@G 578 >:958@ 578 V;:45 F@=?9G

9BFF89564F 6D;84899 :5 ?=@] :9 : =@


58/233

57

!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!YW l8N8@F845 7695=@El!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

d$78@8 69 :4 6@=4E D88V ;:6D 64 578 I8@E @8;:56=49 =>

;6>8W %5 69 578 DB5E => 578 7695=@6:4 :9 => 578 :@5695 TSRK) TTa

$78 V@8I6=B9 =@


59/233

58

D8I8;=V8DW $78 48F:56=4e 69


60/233

59

769 N857=D :9) d;658@:@E N=45:F8W % 488D4e5 b9:Eb:4E5764FW c8@8;E 97=?W % 97:;; :VV@=V@6:58 4= 64F846=B9>=@NB;:56=49G VB@;=64 4= I:;B:C;89W PB5 578 @:F9G 578@8>B98 O 57898 % ?6;; 4=5 D89 5769 B@578@ 5@:49>=@N:56=4G :4D ?78@8 7BN:4 :F84=@8F@=B4D8DW &695=@6


61/233

60

645= 578 >B5B@8 5= ?76@=45 => 76N F@=?9 9]E?:@DW $769 95=@N

$78 :4F8; ?:459 5= F:578@ BV 578 ?@8 58@@6C;8V:95 8I8459G ?:958D ;6I89 :4D ?=@57;899 =C_88@@64F 5= F;:99 :@


62/233

61

64>=@N8D CE :4 B4D8@95:4D64F => 578 N:58@6:; >: P84_:N64e9 d$78969 =4 578 A76;=9=V7E

=> &695=@EeG 578@8 69 : 97=@5 V:99:F8 CE N8:49 =>645@=DB :4 :B5=N:5=4


63/233

62

:9 : 5@6 57:5 : N: 578 V@89845:56=4 ?:9 >=@ J8NV8;84 5=

97=? 578 :BD68458@ J8NV8;84e9 D8:57G f=7:4 #8V=NB] c:8;98; C=BF75 578N:


64/233

63

57:5 7BN:4 :F84


65/233

64

69 26:446 X:556N=G ?7= :@FB8957:5 578 d6D8:; => 8N:4


66/233

65

9B


67/233

66

:4D 578 :


68/233

67

69 9884 :9 : d9B


69/233

68

b(5:589 => %4_B@Eb 5= N:]8 5769 V=645 N=@8 7=? D6:;8


70/233

69

6D84565E V=;656=@N =>@: :;; V=9656I8 B46I8@9:;65EeG 64 &8F8;6:4 58@N9W $78 NB;56 F;=C:; V@=DB


71/233

70

h V@=C;8N => 5=5:;65E

>=@ 7BN:4 B46I8@9:;65EG V:@5;E C8


72/233

71

6458@4:;698DG 69 :4 6N:F64:@E @8V@89845:56=4 => 578 @8:; V@=DB


73/233

72

&=?8I8@G 5769 69 F6I84 : N=@8 V=9656I8 6458@V@85:56=4 5=5:;65EW %4 578 V=;656


74/233

73

V@=:;98


75/233

74

64 769 b(V6@65 => H5=V6:ba CE :VV;E64F 578 d578=@E=> 4=5OE85


76/233

75

@BV5B@8 :4D @895@B V=95N=D8@4 578=@E ?657 659584D84


77/233

76

69 C=57 578 N=5=@ >=@ 578 @848?:; => 659 D8N698W "9 :


78/233

77

2==D?64 KLLL) TLLaW $78 9E958N :VV8:@9 5= D8N=495@:58: D6:;8


79/233

78

9=B@


80/233

79

: 48? @6=@N:56I848F:56=4 O 9= 6NV:@564F 5= =@N9 => ;6>8

TSSQ) UQLaW

$78 6NN:4845 DE4:N6< 69 ?7:5 P7:9]:@ @8>8@9 5= @8N:649 :


81/233

80

96NV;8 C87:I6=@ D89


82/233

81

N:58@6:;69N 5= D8:; ?657

6NV;68D 64 578 ?:E 57:5 5@:49>=@N:56I8 :F84


83/233

82

>=@N9W +85:6; =4 578 4:5B@8 => 578 V@=


84/233

83

OOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO^WT O 58


85/233

84

6D8=;=F6@=N 578 D89578 >=@


86/233

85

$8


87/233


88/233

87

";C8@5O,y9o;z P:@:Cy96 B989 5769 B4D8@95:4D64F => V=?8@ RYaW &8 gB=589 578 ?=@] => 578 %5:;6:4 8@8D= A:@85=G ?7= =C98@I8D 578 dB46I8@9:; ;:?e 57:5QL V8@ V8:9 `=@ V@=V8@5Ea ?8@8 V@=DB


89/233

88

%4 7BN:4:F84=@ :4:


90/233

89

:@@:4F8D 64 D85 >@=N 964F;884565689 => @=N 57898 6458@: 5:9]9 `TSSM) K^^aW &8


91/233

90

64 58@N9 => 578 64 ?=@] :4D578 >@:FN845:56=4 => 9= 5769 98


92/233

91

&8 >=@NB;:589


93/233

92

`$@:49N6996=4 -=45@=; A@=5=


94/233

93

?65764 578 9E958N :9 : ?7=;8W $769 9E958N9) >:6;8D @=B58@9 ?65764578 %458@485G =@ 9V8


95/233

94

%4 : 7695=@E =>


96/233

95

57:5 64 578 ;:95 98


97/233

96

584D84 578 I8@E ;6N658D ?8:;57E N84G :4D 578 >B@578@ >: 578 :I84B895= V=;656


98/233

97

:4D 5784 :VV;68D 5= 9=


99/233

98

,:5=B@G 9


100/233

99

:4D 768@:@


101/233

100

8gB6;6C@6BNW $7@=BF7 >88DC:


102/233

101

5?= 95:589 `L =@ TaG : => : =@N:56I8W #8?

?:E9 => E64F :4D V@==;;=?9 #8?5=46:4 V7E96 :5=N6< V:@56 5?= 95:589 :5 578 9:N8 56N8e `/;=@6D6 TSSS) TQSaWc6F75 5769 9BFF895 : dgB:45BN D6:;895:D58@ VB59 65 `KLLL) RTaW &8 9


103/233

102

=> :4E ?@65584 578969 `9B


104/233

103

7:I8 =I8@?78;N64F


105/233

104

D6:;8


106/233

105

'4F8;9e9 d%45@=DB=;;=?64F

58@N9) V:@56


107/233

106

578 &8F8;6:4 V=9656=4 64 58@N9 => 578 9E4578969 64 : B46I8@9:; =@N8@We `TSSM) QQa 976>5 5= ?7:5 0B @8>8@9 5= :9 d9E48@F856< 8gB6;6C@6BNeG?78@8 d578 ?7=;8 9E958N 8@84 dD6996V:56I895@B


108/233

107

=@D8@ N6F75 64D88D C8 F848@:58D 57@=BF7 D69=@D8@W $769 :;; 9E958N9 88DC:B@578@ D8I8;=VN845 => : V@= B4D:N845:; :4D B4>=@8988:C;8 578 :9 65 8NV7:96989 578 B@


109/233

108

699B8 => B4V@8D6


110/233

109

:4D C:D V=;656 =@B; :@FBN845 CB5 =48 4=5 ?657=B5


111/233

110

9==@ 5@:49>=@N:56=4e `KLL^) YaW

$78 9BFF8956=4 69 57:5 9=>5?:@8 @8;8:989 578 9==@ 5@:49>=@N:56=4 5==W $78 >=;;=?64F


112/233

111


113/233

112

d9E958N:56< D69=@F:469:56=4eG 57:5 V;:E9 :4 6NV=@5:45V:@5 64 B4D8@95:4D64F C=57 64D6I6DB:; :4D 9BC_8


114/233

113

@8;:56=49e `TSSU) ULaW

%4 >=@F64F 48? ?:E9 =>


115/233

114

F895B@89W $78:5@8 :;9= 5:]89 F895B@89 :4D D8I8;=V9578N 5= 578 ;6N65W fB95 ;6]8 578 V;:FB8G 65 @8>=@F89

: 578 V=58456:;9=;B56=4 >=@ c:@8@9


116/233

115

5= C8 D8:D @:578@ 57:4 18D 69 4=@N:;W " N:4 ?7= 9:E9 787:9 ;=95 769 9=B; 69 N:DW " N:4 ?7= 9:E9 57:5 N84 :@8N:


117/233

116

=@F:49 ;689 64 =VV=9656=4 5= D896@64F N: d:456V@=DB


118/233

117

V=99899 5?=


119/233

118

:@8 84F6488@8D 8I8@ N=@8 =I8@5;EW

PB6;D64F BV=4 578 5764]64F => +8;8Bo8G #8F@6 9889 5769

@8V@898459 : @85B@4 5= 578 b2@B4D@6998b => TQUROQ `TSQTa>=@ 659


120/233

119

?78578@ 65 ?:9 V=996C;8 :5 :;; 5=


121/233

120

9E958N9 578=@EG :4D 578 6NV=@5:4 578 N:


122/233

121

578 >:


123/233

122


124/233

123

?8:;57 ?6;; C8 N8:9B@8D 4=5 =4 ;:C=B@ 56N8 64 V@=DB


125/233

124

"9 : 9=>5?:@8 64 F848@:;G 578 64>=@N:56=4 69 (5:;D8@ :4D f8998 &6@97


126/233

125

`KLLKaW $78E V=645 5= =V84 9=B@ 64I=;I8N845 :4D @89V=496C6;65E 57:5 :@8 :;; D8@6I8D>@=N V@:


127/233

126

@=N 9;:I8@E 5= V@=V@685:@E 9=>5?:@8W &8 7:9V@=DB5?:@8G : V=;656


128/233

127

578 9:N8 56N8G 65 69 :@FB8D CE +E8@O06578>=@D `KLLUaGD@:?64F BV=4 ,:oo:@:5= :4D #8F@6G 57:5 5769 :;9= `976>564F :45:F=469N >@=N 578 64DB95@6:; >::


129/233

128

b$78 "@5 => H#%3 A@=F@:NN64Fb KLL^a 69 5895:N845 5= 5769aW

N:58@6:; F==D9 :4D 5= :D=V5 659 ;8F:; V@=58 84DOV@=DB58@ 578 N:]64F :=@N:56=4 645= :6;9 :;58@4:56I8 ;6=@9=>5?:@8 :@5G 578 699B8 => V@=V8@5E 69 9=N85764F 57:5 A@=V8@5E :9 : -@6969 64 A@:


130/233

129

:9 :


131/233

130

=V84 9=B@@88 9=>5?:@8 N=I8N845 C6F CB964899 :4D 578 ;8F:; :VV:@:5B9G 64:558NV564F 5= V=;6@88 9=>5?:@8 :4D 5


132/233

131

VBC;6< 9V78@8b) 78@8 69 578 48F:56I8 96D8 O 578 8I6; 6>

$7898 699B89 :@=B4D =V84 9=B@


133/233

132

;:C=B@ 64 578 :N6;6:@ 5= :@59V@:8@@64F 5= 168@84


134/233

133

9B5?:@8=V8@:589 64 96N6;:@ ?:E9 CB5 584D9 5=?:@D9 :4 8NV7:969

=4 9=


135/233

134

d?@=58 578 =V8@:564F N:4B:;e >=@ d84F6488@64F 578 B98 => 64D8V84D845 @88;:4 : 5= 578 B98@W $78 =V8@:564F 9E958N d\N:9]9\ 578 [@8:;\


136/233

135

=V8@:56=4 => 578 C85?884578 B98@ :4D 578 -845@:; A@= 578 F@:V76:


137/233

136

6458;;6F84=@ :B;;895 98498W P:5?:@8 57:5 578E B98 :5 ?=@]G

86578@ ?=@]64F :5 7=N8 ;658@:;;E =@ B4?65564F;E :5 ;869B@8W

h 7:


138/233

137

:@8 V:@56B@578@644=I:56=4 CE B98@9 ?657 58


139/233

138

?:9 D8I8;=V8D 64 TSSQ CE 578 ';8


140/233

139

V=VB;:@ ;8I8;aW 0:@] =@N:56=4 ?:459 5= C8>@88 CB5 8I8@E?78@8 69 64 B;;E 895=e `TSSRaW %5 69:@FB8D 57:5 5769 5@:49>=@N:56=4 =@N:56=4 => : dI6@5B:;=@NB;:56=49


141/233

140

584D 5=?:@D9 578 :99BNV56=4 57:5 d:@56956< ;:C=B@ 69V@=DB


142/233

141

:4D 5= 988 65G 584D8456:;;EG 64 659 =?4 DE4:N69Nk

$78 V@=C;8N #8F@6 7:9 ?657 D6:;8


143/233

142

9E958N =>


144/233

143

>:@ 84=BF7 64 5@:49>=@N64F ;:C=B@ `:4D 5769 69 ?7E 78


145/233

144

9:C=5:F8W $78 : 7: 9884 :;=4F96D8=578@ :45:F=4695 95@:58F689 57:5 5:]8 5764F9 :V:@5G 64I=;I8 9=>5?:@8W %4


146/233

145

(=>5?:@8 C=57 ?=@]9 :4D 69 ?=@]8D BV=4W %5 >=;;=?957:5 9=>5?:@8 :@5 7=;D9 578 V=58456:; 5= N:]8:VV:@845


147/233

146

N8:464F>B; :4D 58958D CE V@:


148/233


149/233


150/233


151/233

150

V@=F@:N CE V8=V;8 O B4;6]8 578 dNB


152/233

151

578 "B57=@eG TSRRa O CB5 64 P84_:N64 578 V=;656 : 2H% =V8@:564F 9E958N 57:584


153/233

152

6478@845 64 578 >=@N => 659 V@=DB=;;=?9 57898 @8=@ :


154/233

153

57:5 B5B@8V=996C6;65689W 07:58I8@ 95@:58FE 69 D8 :4 =4F=64F :D:V56I8 V@=8


155/233

154

D69564


156/233

155

NB96 9=>5?:@8G 57@=BF7 659 @8;:56=45= 9V88


157/233

156

D858@N648 :


158/233

157

78@8 69 7=? 578 ?=@] => :@5 :4D 9=>5?:@8 :@5 B4D8@N648 D89 5769 B;e

:99BNV56=4 N6F75 C8 N:D8 57:5 9=>5?:@8 69 F848@:;;EB98>B;G B4;6]8 578 ?=@] => :@5G 578 ?=@] => 9=>5?:@8 :@569 N=@8 :NC6FB=B9 64 5769 578


159/233

158

6598;> `KLL^) UKaW /B@578@N=@8G 65 =V8@:589 64 @8:;O V:@:;;8; 5= 578 ?:E 57:5 :


160/233

159

B; 6458@I8456=4G :9 dV@=F@:NN64Fe B558@:4


161/233

160

6598;>W %4 578 >=@N8@G 578 ;695848@ 69 84 NB96=@N:56I8 :9V8?=@]64F ?657=B5 : 9


162/233

161

?78@8


163/233

162

578969 K)l$7@=BF7 D69=@D8@G 9=>5?:@8 :@5 F848@:589 5@:49>=@N:56I8:


164/233

163

V8=V;8 :4D N:


165/233

164

@8V@89845 : ?=@] 64 V@=F@899G :9 9=N85764F 5= C8 :@FB8D:F:6495G >B@578@ :D:V58DG :4D :=@N64F :4 :456$&'(%(

B98 #85))/$Ak

;= `}9=B@5V ! #85))/$AOn48?`[578969W:456O578969W485\ak }>5V On ;=F64`[:456578969\G [969875654:\ak }>5V On


166/233


167/233


168/233

167

!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!RW l@8>8@84b(=>5?:@8 (5BD689b 8D658D CE c:5578? /B;;8@a 69:I:6;:C;8 =4;648 `755V)ZZ???W9=>5?:@895BD689W=@FZaW

$= @B4 65 =4


169/233

168

;8F:; :VV:@:5B9W %5 578@8CE @8_8@88 9=>5?:@8G N8:464F E=B E 65 B4D8@ 578 9:N8 58@N9 :9

A8@; 6598;> `755V)ZZ???WV8@;W


170/233

169

:9 64 578 F848@:56I8 NB96< => P@6:4 '4= `B964F (98E=e9

57:5 =@N:; N857=D=;=FE :4D V9E


171/233

170


172/233

171

@89V8


173/233


174/233

173

=VV=964F 8N8@F845 4=56=49 => V=95ON=D8@465E :4D V=95O7695=@E :5 57:5 56N8W c=D8@465E D89 578 c8


175/233

174

cB98BN => -=458NV=@:@E "@5 64 -76


176/233

175

95:58N845 => TSTQ) d$78@8 69 : F@8:5 48F:56I8 ?=@]=> D895@B


177/233

176

D69@:FN845:56=4 :4D : 8:5B@8 57:5 % V@8I6=B9;E ?@=58 64 KLL^`755V)ZZ@B4N8W=@FZV@=_8


178/233

177

>:45:9689 => 578 56N8W

b$78 P@6D8 (5@6VV8D P:@8 CE &8@ P:


179/233


180/233

179

578 5@: V@=DB FB6;5W

d6D8=;=F6


181/233

180

C:D D@8:N => 895=b VBC;6978D :9: 98V:@:58 I=;BN8 `TSSQaW ';98?78@8G 64 b$78 $6B;;E C8F649) d" 9V8=;;=?9) d+:@?64 D6D 4=5 ]4=? ?7:5 : C6558@9:56@8 78 ?@=58 =4 N:4]64DG :4D 89V8


182/233

181

:9 578 76F7895 7695=@6=@8 6@@8I8@96C6;65EG 8458@ 645= 659 D89


183/233

182

9BC98gB845;E 578 6D8: => 84F6488@64F ;6>8 7:9 C8


184/233

183

578 ?=@]8@ dF848@:;;E C8


185/233

184

@8>8@@64F 5= 578 565;8 => : C==] CE f:N89 1=984:B :4D'@495O.55= -o8NV68; `TSSKaW ';98?78@8G 5769 NE57 => : D8N=


186/233


187/233

186

V8469 :4D I:F64:G :;; N:]8 d;=I8;E


188/233

187

TSS^a 5== 8:96;E 8gB:589 5769 98498 => B4


189/233

188

5= 578 "@695=58;6:4 6D8: => 4:5B@:; 768@:@ 578 9=


190/233

189

-&"A$'1 U)

578 N:46VB;:56=4 => F8489e `TSSU) ^MaW

5= :4 6458@D69 7858@=F84=B9V=9656=49W

5786@ b"456O.8D6VB9) -:V65:;69N :4D (


191/233

190

:9 d578 D:BF758@ C=@4 ?657=B5 : N=578@e `64 2B:55:@6TSSU) TKUaW

?=B;D ;6]8 5= @8645@=DB8 64 F848@:;W

58@@:64 => 6NN:484


192/233

191

64 95BD8459G 578B48NV;=E8D :4D B4V:6D 7=B98 ?=@]8@9W 'I84 58


193/233

192

>=;;=?64F) d%4=@ NE ]4=?;8DF8G ?8 D= 4=5 lE85l 7:I8 : F;=C:;95:58G :4D


194/233

193

8:95 :5 ?76


195/233

194

CB5 8N8@F89 >@=N : F@=BV => N8D6: : [F;=C:;69N\ 7:I8 8458@8D 645= :4

:4D +6948EG 578 0=@;D $@:D8 .@F:46o:56=4G 578 H4658D(5:589 -=4F@899 :4D 578 'B@=V8:4 -=NN6996=4W 078@8 :@8578 :DI= >@88D=N 64 578 48? D6F65:; 9= 578 (V8 /@88%4>=@N:56=4 ?657 : c:46>895= => =B@ =?4We `KLLY) KTMa c:46>895=bG 0:@]


196/233

195

V=VB;:@ 64 578 :


197/233

196


198/233

197

9:N8) d%4 578 9=>5?:@8 64DB95@E 578


199/233

198

=@FZa ?7= V8@>=@N NB96< B964F ;6I8 I6@5B=965E :9 :4 64D6I6DB:;698DD69V;:E => 9]6;;aG CB5 7=;D9 578 V=58456:; 5= C8 : =B@ 7:4D9e `KLLL) TRLaW (78 :DD9 57:5 N=95'B@=V8:4 ;:4FB:F89 N:]8 96N6;:@ D69564:C@6


200/233

199

%458@485 :4D 578 ABC;6< (V78@8e `TSSRaW

X6@4=e9 b" 2@:NN:@ => 578 cB;565BD8b `KLL^aW

OOOOOOOOOOOOOOOORWK C6C;6=F@:V7EOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO

LTLLTLTTTLTLTTLTW.12 `KLLTa d+:5:O#BD69NeG :4 6458@I68??657 c:5578? /B;;8@ :C=B5 ;6>8b97:@64FG b#8556N8bG "V@6; Z 0:;]8@ "@5 -845@8G 755V)ZZ???W?:;]8@:@5W=@FZF:;;8@ESZ

"D6;]4= `TSSQa d07:5 69 +:5: -@656


201/233


202/233

201

"448 P:@@=4 `KLLKaG d$78 ,8F:; A@=V8@5689 => "@5eG H46I8@965E -=;;8F8 ,=4D=4W

1=;:4D P:@5789 `TSRRa d$78 +8:57 => 578 "B57=@eG 64

/=45:4:G VVW T^KOT^QW

16


203/233

202

&:@@E |=74G 64 b%;;BN64:56=49bG ,=4D=4) A6N;6


204/233

203

'N:4 #=@57-:@=;64: A@899W

f:E +:I6D P=;58@ m 16


205/233

204

(6N=4 A;8:9:4 9=>5?:@8 :@5 57@8:DG b176o=N8b`I6: "4D@8:9 P@=8


206/233

205

084DE P@=?4 `TSSMa b(5:589 => %4_B@EbG (5:4>=@D)(5:4>=@D H46I8@965E A@899W

(B9:4 PB 578 "B57=@)8bG 5@:49W (58I84 /W 184D:6;G

-=NVB564FbG -:NC@6DF8G c:99W) c%$ A@899W

&:FB8) c=B5=4W


207/233

206

0:@D `KLLYa d,6I8 -=D64F 64 ,:V5=V A8@>=@N:4 2848@:56I8 -=D8eG 64 'BF848 $7:5?:@8 O A:@568956I:;


208/233

207

/;=@6:4 -@:N8@ `KLLTa d.4 ,658@:5B@8 :4D (E958N9$78=@EeG ;8@=N $:58 c=D8@4G "V@6; QG

/;=@6:4 -@:N8@ `KLLK:a d-=45?:@8 d(=>5?:@8 "@5) $7=BF759eG b18:DbN8 >8956I:; TWKbG


209/233

208

26;;89 +8;8Bo8 m "45=46= #8F@6 `TSSLa b-=NNB46959 ,6]8

26;;89 +8;8Bo8 `TSSLa d-=45@=; :4D P8 c=B@464FG m 578 #8?%458@4:56=4:;bG 5@:49W A8FFE J:NB>G ,=4D=4) 1=B5;8DF8W

"@6> +6@;6] `TSSRa b$78 A=95 2;=C:; -:V65:;69NbG P=B;D8@)0895I68? A@899W

-6@ (5@BFF;8 64 &6F7O$8


210/233

209

,B &695=@E :4D 578 ,:95c:4bG #8? p=@]) $78 /@88 A@899W

c:5578? /B;;8@ `KLLYa bP8764D 578 P;6V) 899:E9 =4 578-B;5B@8 => (=>5?:@8bG #8? p=@]) "B5=4=N8D6:W

c:5578? /B;;8@ `KLL^a d$78 +6F65:; .C_8 -=458NV=@:@E "@5 641=9]6;D8) %4>=@N:56=49 /=@;:FG VVW T^SOTMYW


211/233

210

-7:@;68 28@8G 8DW `KLLMa b07658 &8:5G -=;D ,=F68956I:; TWKG5?:@8 :@5bG &8;964]6) #%/-"VBC;6


212/233

211

fx@F84 &:C8@N:9 `TSQ^a b$78=@E => -=NNB46P=B@F8=69 (= ,6C8@:; "@59W

c64DZ(V6@65bG 5@:49W fWPW P:6;;68G #8? p=@]) &:@V8@ m1=?W


213/233

212

28=@F 0W /W &8F8; `TSMSa b&8F8;e9 ( 578 /B5B@8bG |:F@8C)"@]o64W

P@6:4 &=;N89 `KLLYaG d"@56956< "B5=4=NE :4D 578


214/233

213

m -7@695648 (G 8D9W b-=D8 O $78 ,:4FB:F8 => .B@$6N8bG "@9 ';8 578 /@:4]>B@5 ( (==@46: A@899W

-7@69 f84]9 `TSSYa d%45@=DB5?:@8"@5) " -=NN845 5= /;=@6:4 -@:N8@eG 64 .;F: 2=@6B4=I: m

'D656=4 KLL^bG "@7B9) +"1-G VVW TULOTUSW

1:4D:;; f=749=4 `TSSYa d'D65=@e9 %45@=DB5?:@8bG ,=4D=4) A84FB64W

"N8@6 c:


215/233

214

,=4D=4) 1=B5;8DF8W

,B &:@D?:@8eG b#8556N8bG755V)ZZ???W48556N8W=@FZ48556N8W?Y:@


216/233

215

+=N646gB8 ,:V=@58 `KLLLa b&695=@E => (765bG ,=4D=4) c%$A@899W

+:I6DO.;6I68@ ,:@56F:BD `KLL^a d%45@=DB


217/233

216

'9578@ ,89;68 `KLL^a d2;=C:;6


218/233

217

288@5 ,=I64] `KLLKa b+:@] /6C8@) $@:8;D `KLLKa d(4:V 5= 2@6DeG gB=58D 64 b

,6I64F95=48G -:NC@6DF8G c:99W) c%$ A@899W

"D@6:4 c:=@N:56I65E => -=D8)(=>5?:@8 :4D -B;5B@89 => -6@


219/233


220/233


221/233

220

2:N89 :4D 'B@5 :N c:64W

&695=@EeG 64 f=DE P8@;:4D m (:@:7 J8NC8@G 8D9W b#8?/=@N:56=49) $8


222/233

221

b"C95@:5?:@8w(5@B


223/233


224/233

223

16 ,6>8) &=?

-=@48;6: (=;;>@:4] `KLLTa d&:


225/233

224

#=W KG +B@7:N) +B]8 H46I8@965E A@899G VVW YYOUQW

$6o6:4: $8@@:4=I: `KLLKa d$78 D8F@88 o8@= => V=;656 ,6>8bG 5@:49W %9:C8;;:

c:@64: X697N6D5 `KLLUa dA@8


226/233

225

pI=448 X=;]:@5 `KLL^aG d-:;


227/233

226

:4D 9==@N:56=4 "@59) %458@98 "@5G (


228/233

227

&:B4564F 08958@4 "578 0=@;D\eG 64 b$78 $6


229/233

228


230/233

229

??????????bG 755V)ZZ??????????W_=D6W=@F

f.+% `KLLKa bf85 (85 06;;E TSQ^bG 755V)ZZ_85985?6;;EW_=D6W=@FZ

f.+% `KLLKa bcE+89]5=Vb `988 -=44=@ KLL^a

f.+% `KLL^a b+89]5=V %NV@=I69:56=49) cE+89]5=V ,6I8bGV8@>=@N:4


231/233

230

.@DB@8W=@F `KLLLa b+B95bG 755V)ZZDBNVW=@DB@8W=@FZ???W=@DB@8W=@FZKSTZDB95W75N;

=B;6V=W485Z

bVL89T9) +6F65:;8 A=8968b `KLL^aG 755V)ZZ???WVL89T9W485Z

A@=_8


232/233

231

b(=>5?:@8G %4>=@N:56=4 $8=@ "@5b

,8=4:@D= (=;::9 `KLLUa b.B59=B@


233/233

The Dialectics of Software Art - PhD Thesis

Documents

Transcript of The Dialectics of Software Art - PhD Thesis