SETTLEMENT AGREEMENT BETWEEN: PETRA KOHLER and ...
Transcript of SETTLEMENT AGREEMENT BETWEEN: PETRA KOHLER and ...
' -
SETTLEMENT AGREEMENT
~
THIS AGREEMENT ("Settlement Agreement"), dated October ~2015, is made
BETWEEN:
PETRA KOHLER and TYLER COOKE
("Plaintiffs")
AND:
LABORA TORI OS LE6N FARMA SA
("Leon Farma")
PREAMBLE
WHEREAS
A. a proceeding was commenced by the Plaintiffs, in the Court of Queen's Bench of
Alberta, Court File Number 1303 13736 ("Alberta Action"), against Le6n Farma
and Apotex, Inc., pursuant to the Class Proce~4ings Act, SA 2003, c C-16.5 CAct"),
in which it is alleged, inter alia, that Le6n Farma mispackaged Alysena™ 28,
which resulted in damage or loss to members of the Class;
B. Apotex, Inc. had no responsibility or involvement in the packaging of Alysena ™
28;
C. pursuant to the Certification Order, the Alberta Action has been certified as a
multi-jurisdictional class proceeding;
D. the Alberta Action previously included a now dismissed claim against Apotex,
Inc.;
E. a proposed multi-jurisdictional class proceeding was also commenced by Kim
Parker and Jeremie Lafond, in the Superior Court of Quebec, Court File Number
12964648 1
-2-
500-06-000666-137 ("Quebec Action"), against Apotex, Inc. and Le6n Farma,
pursuant to Article 1002 and following of the Code of Civil Procedure, RSQ c. C-25,
in which it is alleged, inter nlin, that Le6n Farrna mispackaged Alysena™ 28;
F. the Quebec Action is currently stayed. Class Counsel shall effect its dismissal
immediately after the Effective Date;
G. a proposed multi-jurisdictional class proceeding was also commenced by
Jasmine Catherine Watkins, in the Ontario Superior Court of Justice, Court File
Number CV-13-0121, against Apotex, Inc. A separate proposed multi
jurisdictional class proceeding was commenced by Carleen Kutlu, Paige Towle,
and Rebekah Thomas, in the Ontario Superior Court of Justice, Court File
Number CV-14-516-761-00CP, against Le6n Farma and Apotex, Inc. (these two
proceedings are hereinafter collectively referred to as the "Ontario Actions").
The Ontario Actions were commenced pursuant to the Class Proceedings Act,
1992, SO 1992, c 6, and relate to the same or similar subject matter as the Alberta
Action and the Quebec Action;
H. there has been no settlement or certification of the Ontario Actions or the Quebec
Action. Furthermore, as a result of a dispute between the plaintiffs' counsel in
the Ontario Actions, it is currently unclear who represents those plaintiffs;
I. the parties seek to avoid incurring additional expense in relation to the above
referenced litigation, and have agreed to settle all claims which Class Members
have, or could have in the future, against Le6n Farma or any other party,
including Apotex, Inc., against whom a claim may be made in respect of the
matters particularized in the originating pleadings in the Alberta Action, tl1e
Ontario Actions, and the Quebec Action;
J. Le6n Farrna has consented to the Settlement Agreement, subject to the approval
of the Court of Queen's Bench for Alberta ("Alberta Court") pursuant to section
35 of the Act; and
12964646.1
-3-
· K. this Preamble forms an integral part of the Settlement Agreement.
IN CONSIDERATION OF LEON FARMA making Compensatory Payments, on a
claims-made basis, and subject to strict proof pursuant to the Claims Administration
Procedure, set out at Article 8 herein, the execution of the Settlement Agreement, the
mutual covenants and agreements contained herein, and other good and valuable
consideration, the receipt and sufficiency of which is hereby acknowledged by the
parties, THE PARTIES HEREBY AGREE AS FOLLOWS:
ARTICLEl: DEFINITIONS
Specific terms used in the Settlement Agreement are defined in this Article. Definitions
expressed in the singular shall mean the plural and vice versa, as the context requires.
"Acknowledgment Letter" shall mean a letter of the Claims Administrator to a
Claimant, acknowledging the existence of the Claimant's Claim. The Acknowledgment
Letter is to be delivered within seven (7) days of receipt of the Claimant's Claim
Package.
"Adjudication" shall mean an assessment of a Claim by the Adjudicator, within the
scope of his jurisdiction under Article 7(4) of the Settlement Agreement, in collaboration
with counsel for Le6n Farma, the Claimant, and his or her respective r·epresentative,
pursuant to procedures that are considered by the Adjudicator to be fair and
reasonable, in accordance with the terms and conditions of the Settlement Agreement.
The Adjudication may be conducted in writing or orally, at the discretion of the
Claimant.
"Adjudicator" shall mean The Honourable Michel Bastarache, Q.C., O.C.
12964648.1
-4-
"Alysena™ 28" shall mean the prescription combination oral contraceptive containing
levonorgestrel and ethinyl estradiol, manufactured, packaged, and labelled at Le6n
Parma's facility in Le6n, Spain, and marketed in Canada by Apotex, Inc. under the
brand name, Alysena™ 28, and comprising Lot numbers LF01899A, LF01898A,
LF01894B, LF01901A, LF01900A, LF01980A, LF01982A, LF01981A, LF01979A,
LF02037 A, LF02036A, and LF02026A.
"Certification Order" shall mean the Multi-Jurisdictional Class Action Certification and
Notice Publication Order, pronounced on June 15, 2015 by Associate Chief Justice J.D.
Rooke, and filed with the Alberta Court on July 14, 2015.
"Claim" shall mean the claim of a Class Member for a Compensatory Payment.
"Claimant" shall mean any Class Member who submits a Claim Package during the
Claim Period.
"Claim Adjudication Decision" shall mean a written decision of the Adjudicator after
an Adjudication.
"Claim Determination Decision" shall mean a written decision of the Claims
Administrator pronouncing a Claimant's eligibility for Compensatory Payments under
the Settlement Agreement.
"Claim Package" shall mean a package provided by the Claims Administrator, to be
submitted by a Claimant pursuant to the Claims Administration Procedure.
"Claim Period" shall commence on the Effective Date, and shall expire at 12.01 a.m.,
Eastern Standard Time, on the one hundred and twentieth (120) day after the Effective
Date.
"Claim Review Decision" shall mean a written decision of the Adjudicator after a
Review.
12964648.1
-5-
"Claims Administration Procedure" shall mean the procedure described in Article 8 of
the Settlement Agreement.
II Claims Administrator" shall mean Trilogy Class Action Services.
1/Classl/ shall be defined as:
(a) all women who were prescribed and ingested Alysena™ 28, purchased in
Canada between November 19,2012 and April15, 2013;
(b) all women who were prescribed Alesse™ 28, but who were instead
dispensed and ingested Alysena™ 28, purchased in Canada between
November 19,2012 and April15, 2013; and
(c) the biological fathers of infants born to women in Part (a) or (b) of this
definition [i.e. Resulting Children], after that time period.
I/ Class Counsel" shall mean Merchant Law Group LLP.
"Class Counsel's Fees and Disbursements" shall mean:
(a) $900,000 plus reasonable disbursements and applicable taxes thereon;
(b) an amount equal to 10% of the aggregate amount of Compensatory
Payments exceeding $2.5 million but not exceeding $4 million, plus
applicable taxes;
(c) an amount equal to 5% of the aggregate amount of Compensatory
Payments exceeding $4 million, plus applicable taxes;
(d) to the extent that an award is paid to a Public Health Insurer on account of
its subrogated claim, 5% of that amount shall be paid to Class Counsel as
fees; and
12964648.1
-6-
(e) any other amount that a Claimant may pay to Class Counsel for assisting
him or her in preparing and submitting a Claim Package, or for
representing him or her on an Adjudication or a Review, plus
disbursements, provided that such amount shall not exceed 12.5% of the
Compensatory Payment awarded to that Claimant. Under no
circumstances shall Le6n Parma be responsible to pay any amount under
sub-section (e) of this definition, in the event of the Claimant's non
payment.
"Class Members" shall mean members of the Class who do not opt out of the Alberta
Action.
"Class Period" shall mean the period of time between November 19, 2012 and April15,
2013.
"Compensatory Payment" shall mean a payment made to a Claimant pursuant to one
of the following categories:
(a) respecting a Claimant who did not become pregnant, but who suffered
psychological distress or anxiety as a result of the apprehension of
pregnancy due to learning of the mispackaging of Alysena™ 28, and
subsequently discovering, before June 2013, that there was no pregnancy:
12964648.1
i. Up to $1,000 for all damages plus any out-of-pocket expenses. The
aggregate amount payable under subsection (a)(i) of this definition
shall be a maximum of $300,000, regardless of the number of
Claimants.
The Claims Administrator shall have the exclusive jurisdiction to
award Compensatory Payments under this subsection.
-7-
If the full amount of $300,000 is not awarded as Compensatory
Payments under this subsection, then the remainder shall be
divided into three equal parts: one part to be paid to Le6n Parma's
insurer, one part to be paid to St. Francis Xavier University, in
Antigonish, Nova Scotia, and one part to be paid to the Children's
Hospital Foundation of Saskatchewan. The latter two parts shall be
paid to Class Counsel, in trust;
(b) respecting a Claimant who became pregnant, but did not carry to term:
12964648.1
i. (a) $2,000 per month of pregnancy, to a maximum of five months,
or (b) for a pregnancy, the duration of which was more than five
months, $20,000, to be determined by the Claims Administrator;
u. an additional special award of up to $20,000 for medical or
psychological damage resulting from or attributable to pregnancy,
as agreed to by counsel for Le6n Parma, or as determined by the
Adjudicator, subject to evidence from a duly qualified physician or
psychologist, provided that any medical, psychological, or
psychiatric opinion was made concurrent with the causal event, or
within three months thereafter;
111. $500 per day of hospital stay, up to a maximum of $2,500, to be
determined by the Claims Administrator;
iv. related out-of-pocket expenses, up to $1,000 to be assessed by the
Claims Administrator, and if $1,000 is determined by the
Adjudicator on a Review to be inadequate, the Adjudicator may
award such amount as is justified on a proper evidentiary record;
v. loss of income, to a maximum of $5,000, to be determined by the
Claims Administrator;
-8-
(c) respecting a Claimant who became pregnant and gave birth to a
Resulting Child:
12964648.1
1. $20,000 on account of pregnancy, to be determined by the Claims
Administrator;
u. $10,000 for pain and suffering as a result of childbirth, inclusive of
stay in hospital for delivery, to be determined by the Claims
Administrator;
iii. up to $50,000 on account of Complications, to be determined by
the Adjudicator;
iv. related out-of-pocket expenses, up to $1,000 to be assessed by the
Claims Administrator, and if $1,000 is determined by the
Adjudicator on a Review to be inadequate, the Adjudicator may
award such amount as is justified on a proper evidentiary record;
v. loss of income, to a maximum of 80 percent of two months of the
Claimant's remuneration, provided that such loss arises from the
act of giving birth to be assessed by the Claims Administrator. If it
is determined by the Adjudicator on a Review that 80 percent of
two months of the Claimant's remuneration is inadequate, the
Adjudicator may award such amount as is justified on a proper
evidentiary record of actual loss arising from the act of giving
birth to a maximum of 80 percent of the Claimant's remuneration
for up to six months. The loss must be restricted to the period of
time that the Claimant was unable to work due to factors
associated with pregnancy and/ or childbirth. No amount shall be
awarded respecting any period of time in which the Claimant
voluntarily ceased work to care for the Resulting Child. The
quantum of this award shall be determined by the Claims
Administrator;
12964648.1
-9-
vi. $5,000 as a special award for a scholarship for the Resulting Child,
to be paid to the Claimant, in trust for the Resulting Child;
vii. contribution to child-rearing costs
(A) for a healthy Resulting Child, $70,000, or
(B) for an extra needs Resulting Child, a minimum of $70,000,
and a maximum of $140,000, to be determined by the
Adjudicator. Entitlement shall be based on such evidence as
may be received by the Adjudicator, and pursuant to
whatever procedure the Adjudicator may determine to be
appropriate.
Payment of such an award for contribution to child-rearing costs
shall be apportioned as follows, depending on the circumstances:
(1) If the biological father of the Resulting Child, who is also a
Claimant, demonstrates that, pursuant to a court order in
favour of a corresponding female Claimant, or pursuant to a
child support agreement in favour of that corresponding
female Claimant, he is required to pay $500 or more per
month, and he has paid at least $5,000 by the date of
submission of the Claim Package, then 50% of the award
shall be paid to the biological father, and 50% shall be paid
to the corresponding female Claimant.
(2) If no such claim is made by the biological father, then the
entire amount of the award shall be paid to the
corresponding female Claimant.
For the purpose of entitlement to a Compensatory Payment, if both
parents are Claimants, they are to be treated as one Claimant.
Either the biological mother or father may apply to the Claims
Administrator for variation of the apportionment set out in
paragraph c.viii(l) above, based upon special circumstances, and
- 10-
the Claims Administrator shall refer the determination of any
equitable re-apportionment to the Adjudicator.
(d) in addition to amounts referred to in subsection (c)(vii) of this definition,
and respecting a Claimant who is the biological father of a Resulting
Child: related out-of-pocket expenses, up to $1,000, to be determined by
the Claims Administrator.
"Complications" shall mean any unusual medical condition arising out of the delivery
of a Resulting Child, but shall not include a Caesarian section, gestational diabetes, or
an episiotomy.
"Damages Brief"
(a) of a Claimant: In accordance with the instructions contained in the Claim
Package, it shall mean a summary of the quantum and itemization of the
damages claimed, all documentary evidence in support of a Claim,
including any will-say statements, and the factual and legal submissions
relied on in support of the Oaim, including an outline of any applicable
statutory or common law authorities.
(b) of Le6n Farma: It shall mean any responding evidence and submissions
as, in the opinion of counsel for Le6n Farma, are appropriate to respond to
the Claimant's Damages Brief.
"Defendants" shall mean Le6n Farma and Apotex, Inc.
"Deficiency Letter" shall mean a letter of the Claims Administrator advising the
Claimant of any deficiencies in his or her Claim Package.
"Effective Date" shall mean the later of the date on which any applicable appeal
periods arising from the Final Settlement Approval Order expire, and the date of the
final disposition of any such appeals.
12964648.1
-11-
"Final Report" shall mean a report, prepared by counsel for Le6n Parma, with the input
of the Claims Administrator, setting out, inter alia:
(a) the number and most recent addresses of the Claimants;
(b) the number of Oaims accepted by the Claims Administrator;
(c) the number of Claims rejected by the Claims Administrator;
(d) the number of Claims considered on a Review;
(e) the number of Claims that proceeded to an Adjudication and that were
allowed or rejected; and
(f) the quantum of Compensatory Payments paid to Class Members, by
category.
"Final Settlement Approval Order" shall mean an order of the Alberta Court
approving the Settlement Agreement pursuant to section 35 of the Act.
"Honourarium" shall mean one or more of the following:
(a) $5,000 to be paid to the Representative Plaintiff,
(b) $3,000 to be paid to Tyler Cooke in the Alberta Action, or
(c) $2,500 to be paid to each petitioner in the Quebec Action,
in recognition of their respective undertakings to act on behalf of members of the Class.
These sums are to be paid to Class Counsel, in trust, within thirty (30) days of the
Effective Date.
"Notice Date" shall mean the date on which notice of the Settlement Agreement and
the date and location of the Settlement Approval Hearing is published on the Website
pursuant to Article 2(3) of the Settlement Agreement.
12964648.1
-12-
' "Objection and Notice of Intention to Appear" shall mean a written objection to the
Settlement Agreement of a member of the Class, and a statement of whether he or she
intends to appear and make submissions at the Settlement Approval Hearing.
"Objection Period" shall mean the period of thirty (30) days commencing on the
Notice Date, which is for the purpose of filing an Objection and Notice of Intention to
Appear.
"Opt-Out Form" shall mean the written confirmation of a member of the Class to opt
out of this class proceeding.
"Other Counsel" shall mean any counsel other than Class Counsel who represent a
Claimant in the Claims Administration Procedure.
"Public Health Insurer" shall mean any statutory Canadian provincial or territorial
health or medical care body, plan, commission or other entity (for example, the Ontario
Health Insurance Plan), which is specifically empowered by its respective enabling
legislation to make direct or subrogated claims to recover the costs of providing
healthcare or other valid medical services to Class Members respecting Released
Claims.
"Preliminary Settlement Approval Order" shall mean the order granted by the Alberta
Court pursuant to Article 2 of the Settlement Agreement.
"Released Claims" shall mean any and all claims, demands, actions, suits, causes of
action, whether class, individual or otherwise in nature, including assigned claims,
whether known or unknown, asserted or unasserted, whether accrued, in whole or in
part, regardless of legal theory, existing now or arising in the future by any and all of
the Representative Plainti££ or the Class Members, arising out of or relating to the
purchase, use, manufacture, sale, dispensing, distribution, promotion, marketing,
regulatory approval, prescription, ingestion or labelling of Alysena™ 28 including
without limitation all claims arising out of the allegations set out in the pleadings of the
12964648.1
-13-
Alberta Action, the Ontario Actions and the Quebec Action and all subrogated claims of
Public Health Insurers. Released Claims shall include, without limitation, all claims for
damages or remedies of whatever kind or character, known or unknown, which are
now recognized in law or equity, or that may be created and recognized in the future by
statute, regulation, judicial decision, or in any other manner, for personal injury and/ or
bodily injury, damage, death, fear of disease or injury, mental or physical pain or
suffering, emotional or mental harm, or loss of enjoyment of life; damages including but
not limited to punitive, aggravated, statutory and other multiple damages or penalties
of any kind; loss of wages, income, earnings, and earning capacity; medical expenses;
doctor, hospital, nursing and drug bills; loss of support, services, consortium,
companionship, society or affection, or damages to familial relations; consumer fraud,
refunds, unfair business practices, deceptive trade practices, and other similar claims
whether arising under statute, regulation, or judicial decision; wrongful death and
survival actions; medical screening and monitoring; injunctive and declaratory relief;
economic or business losses, or disgorgement of revenues or profits; costs or lawyers'
fees; and prejudgment and post-judgment interest.
"Released Parties" shall mean:
(a) the Defendants and each of their direct and indirect parents, subsidiaries,
affiliates, and divisions, together with each of their respective current and
former officers, directors, employees, trustees, representatives, lawyers,
agents, and insurers; any and all predecessors, successors, and/ or
shareholders of the Defendants, and each of their direct and indirect
parents, subsidiaries, affiliates, and divisions;
(b) any and all suppliers of components, materials, services, and technology
used in the manufacture of Alysena™ 28 including the labelling and
packaging thereof, and their respective affiliates, divisions, parents,
predecessors, subsidiaries, successors, and trustees, and each of their
12964648.1
... -14-
respective agents, directors, employees, insurers, lawyers, officers, and
current and former shareholders;
(c) all distributors of Alysena™ 28, including wholesale distributors, private
label distributors, retail distributors, hospitals, and clinics;
(d) any other person against whom the Class Members could attempt to
assert any claim, liability, or right to payment arising out of or related in
any way to the packaging of AlysenaTM 28, whether as a joint tortfeasor or
otherwise, under any theory of law or equity; and
(e) any past, present or future officer, director, shareholder, subsidiary,
employee, agent, servant, attorney, predecessor, trustee, successor, or
assignee of any of the above.
"Releasors" shall mean the Class Members, and their respective heirs, executors,
trustees, administrators, assigns, attorneys, representatives, partners, and insurers and
their predecessors, successors, heirs, executors, trustees, administrators, and assignees.
~~Representative Plaintiff" shall mean Petra Kohler.
"Resulting Child" shall mean a child born to a female Class Member after the Class
Period as a result of the alleged mispackaging of Alysena™ 28.
"Review" shall mean a review by the Adjudicator of a Claim Determination Decision.
"Settlement Approval Hearing" shall mean the hearing at which the parties seek the
Final Settlement Approval Order.
"Website" shall mean the website that is established by the Claims Administrator
pursuant to Paragraph 10(d) of the Certification Order, and whereon the Opt-Out Form,
hearing dates, court documents, and other court-approved communications,
information, and updates relating to this class proceeding shall be published.
12964648.1
ARTICLE2:
-15-
PRELIMINARY SETTLEMENT APPROVAL HEARING AND NOTICE OF SETTLEMENT APPROVAL HEARING
1. Upon the execution of the Settlement Agreement, the parties shall jointly move
for a Preliminary Settlement Approval Order to include the following relief:
(a) that the Claims Administrator undertakes all obligations required of it
before the Effective Date pursuant to the applicable terms of the
Settlement Agreement;
(b) that the forms of the notices to be given under Article 2(3) of the
Settlement Agreement, and the Objection and Notice of Intention to
Appear, are approved;
(c) that any means of giving notice of the Settlement Agreement, the
Settlement Approval Hearing, and the right of a member of the Class to
file an Objection and Notice of Intention to Appear, which supplements
the means of giving notice pursuant to Article 2(3) of the Settlement
Agreement, are approved; and
(d) that a date be set for tl1e Settlement Approval Hearing.
2. Le6n Farma shall have the Settlement Agreement, the contents of the Website,
the notice of the Settlement Agreement and the Settlement Approval Hearing,
and any other communications that will be posted on the Website, translated into
French. The Claims Administrator shall supply this material in English to
counsel for Le6n Farma for the purpose of such translation.
3. At least twenty (20) days before the Settlement Approval Hearing, the Claims
Administrator shall publish on the Website the notice of application for the Final
Settlement Approval Order, and the date and location of the Settlement
Approval Hearing, and shall notify the Public Health Insurers in writing.
12964648.1
-16-
· 4. Le6n Parma shall pay the cost of giving any notices ordered by the Alberta Court
under this Article, or in the further administration of the Settlement Agreement.
5. Before the Settlement Approval Hearing, the Claims Administrator shall file with
the Alberta Court all Objections and Notices of Intention to Appear, received
during the Objection Period, and shall provide copies of them to Class Counsel
and counsel for Le6n Parma.
ARTICLE3: OPTING OUT, OBJECTING, AND INTENTION TO APPEAR
1. Class Counsel shall not act for any opted-out member of the Class against any
Released Party with respect to a Released Claim.
2. During the Objection Period, any member of the Class may submit an Objection
and Notice of Intention to Appear, but a member of the Class who opts out shall
not appear or be heard at the Settlement Approval Hearing.
ARTICLE4: FINAL SEmEMENT APPROVAL ORDER AND SETTLEMENT APPROVAL HEARING
1. After the Objection Period, the parties shall jointly move for a Final Settlement
Approval Order, in which it shall be ordered, inter alia, that:
(a) the Settlement Agreement is fair, reasonable, and in the best interests of
the Class;
(b) Le6n Parma shall pay Compensatory Payments to eligible Claimants, any
Honorarium, Class Counsel's Fees and Disbursements, and the fees and
disbursements of the Claims Administrator and the Adjudicator, as
agreed to herein;
12964648.1
-17-
(c) The Claims Administrator shall be appointed to administer the Claims
Administration Procedure;
(d) the Adjudicator shall be appointed to determine Claims submitted to him
for Review or Adjudication under the Claims Administration Procedure;
(e) the Released Claims of the Releasers shall be released, and the Releasers
shall be forever barred from commencing or continuing actions against
Released Parties with respect to Released Claims, in accordance with
Article 11 hereof;
(f) any Party may bring a motion to the Alberta Court to seek directions with
respect to the implementation or interpretation of the Settlement
Agreement, such motion to be on notice to the parties; and
(g) within ninety (90) days of the day on which the last Claim is administered
pursuant to the Claims Administration Procedure, counsel for Le6n Farma
shall file the Final Report with the Alberta Court.
2. At least twenty (20) days before the return of the application, the Claims
Administrator shall post on the Website the notice of application for the Final
Settlement Approval Order, and the date of the Final Settlement Approval
Hearing.
3. The Settlement Agreement shall become effective on the Effective Date.
ARTICLES: EFFECT OF NON-APPROVAL, OR AMENDMENT OF THE SETTLEMENT AGREEMENT
1. If the Settlement Agreement is not preliminarily or finally approved by the
Alberta Court, in its entirety and without modification, the offensive clause[s] or
terrn[s] may be severed or modified by the parties.
12964648.1
-18-
· 2. Class Counsel shall not enter into any agreement, of any kind whatsoever, with
any other counsel who represent a putative class relating to the same or similar
subject-matter that is addressed in the Settlement Agreement, except with the
prior, written consent of counsel for Le6n Farma.
3. The Settlement Agreement, and all negotiations, statements, and proceedings
related to it, shall be without prejudice to the rights of the parties.
4. The parties agree that irrespective of whether it is approved by the Alberta
Court, the Settlement Agreement (and the fact of its negotiation and execution)
shall not constitute an admission of liability by Le6n Farma, or be used against
Le6n Farma for any purpose in this or any other proceeding in Canada or
elsewhere with respect to Released Claims. Furthermore, the Settlement
Agreement (and the fact of its negotiation and execution) shall not be used by
any entity, whether or not a party to these proceedings, in an effort to establish
any of the alleged facts, the jurisdiction of the Canadian courts over any foreign
party, or the certification of any other proceedings in any province of Canada.
Le6n Farma further specifically denies that the Settlement Agreement constitutes
an admission that the definition of Oass contained herein constitutes a class or
classes appropriate for litigation purposes.
ARTICLE6: APPOINTMENT AND ROLE OF THE CLAIMS ADMINISTRATOR
1. The Claims Administrator shall offer services in French and English.
2. The Claims Administrator shall be responsible for:
(a) receiving, reviewing, and creating and storing electronic copies of every
submitted Claim Package;
12964648.1
-19-
(b) setting up and maintaining the Website to disseminate information about
the Claims Administration Procedure, to answer commonly asked
questions, and to publish the Settlement Agreement and related
documentation;
(c) establishing a toll-free telephone number whereby members of the Class
can direct inquiries about this class proceeding;
(d) periodically advising Class Counsel and counsel for Le6n Farma of the
number of Claim Packages received, as well as providing the names,
addresses, telephone numbers, fax numbers, and e-mail addresses of
Claimants;
(e) forwarding completed Claim Packages to counsel for Le6n Farma;
(£) providing notices of Claims and other matters required by the Settlement
Agreement to Public Health Insurers;
(g) forwarding the Claim Package, Damages Brief, and any other supporting
documentation to the Adjudicator with respect to any Claim that is
submitted for a Review or Adjudication;
(h) preparing and sending Acknowledgment Letters, Deficiency Letters,
Claim Determination Decisions and redeterminations of Claim
Determination Decisions, lists of Claimants authorized for payment
pursuant to Article 10(9) of the Settlement Agreement, and any other
necessary correspondence or communications to, from, or between
Claimants, Class Counsel, Other Counsel, Public Health Insurers, counsel
for Le6n Farma, and the Adjudicator, as required by, or incidental to the
administration of, the Settlement Agreement;
(i) seeking final authority and agreement from counsel for Le6n Farma with
respect to any award for a Compensatory Payment;
12964648.1
-20-
G) requisitioning funds from counsel for Le6n Farma to pay Compensatory
Payments and other amounts under the Settlement Agreement; and
(k) anything that is required by, or incidental to, the duties of the Claims
Administrator, described in Article 8 or any other relevant provision of
the Settlement Agreement.
3. The Claims Administrator shall be entitled to fair and reasonable compensation
and disbursements, in satisfaction of its obligations under the Settlement
Agreement, including the establislunent and maintenance of the electronic
infrastructure that is required to implement it.
4. The Claims Administrator shall provide itemized billing, on a monthly basis or
as otherwise agreed to by Le6n Farma and the Claims Administrator.
5. The Claims Administrator shall properly and prudently delegate to its
employees all work associated with its obligations under the Settlement
Agreement, commensurate with the degree of skill required.
6. Any information provided by or regarding Class Members, or otherwise
obtained pursuant to the Settlement Agreement, shall be kept strictly confidential
and shall not be disclosed except to appropriate persons, and only to the extent
necessary to process Claims or to provide benefits under the Settlement
Agreement, as otherwise expressly provided for in the Settlement Agreement, or
as required by law.
7. The Claims Administrator, the Adjudicator, and/ or any persons appointed by
them to assist in the administration of the Settlement Agreement shall execute a
confidentiality agreement, in a form satisfactory to the parties, pursuant to which
they shall agree to keep confidential any information whatsoever concerning
Claims, except information that is required to be disclosed to Public Health
Insurers, as specified herein.
12964648.1
-21-
· 8. The Claims Administrator shall institute and maintain strict internal procedures
to reasonably protect the identity of all Claimants and all information regarding
their Claims. In particular, Claim Packages and Damages Briefs shall be kept
strictly confidential and shall not be provided to any person or entity unless
provided for in the Settlement Agreement or as required by law.
9. Class Counsel and counsel for Le6n Farma shall have access to all information
maintained by the Claims Administrator regarding Claimants and the processing
and payment of Claims. Other Counsel shall have access to all information
maintained by the Claims Administrator regarding only their own Claimants
and the processing and payment of Claims relating to only their own Claimants.
10. All written communications with Claimants shall be conducted by e-mail or by
regular mail to the last address provided by the Claimant. Each Claimant shall
keep the Claims Administrator apprised of his or her current contact
information.
11. If, for any reason, the Claims Administrator becomes unable or unwilling to
continue to act in this role, the parties may choose an alternate claims
administrator, subject to the approval of the Alberta Court.
ARTICLE 7: APPOINTMENT AND ROLE OF THE ADJUDICATOR
1. The parties agree that the Honourable Michel Bastarache shall be appointed as
the Adjudicator for any Reviews and Adjudications that arise pursuant to the
terms and conditions of the Settlement Agreement.
2. The Adjudicator shall be entitled to compensation of $500 per hour plus
applicable taxes. His full-day rate (8 hours) shall be $4,000, and his half-day rate
shall be $2,000.
12964648.1
-22-
· 3. The Adjudicator may employ a qualified individual, if necessary, to assist him in
discharging his role under the Settlement Agreement, and that individual shall
be entitled to compensation in the amount of up to $250 per hour.
4. The Adjudicator shall act strictly in accordance with the terms of the Settlement
Agreement and the procedures outlined in the Claim Package. The Adjudicator
shall have jurisdiction to:
(a) conduct Adjudications of parts of Claims referred to him by the Claims
Administrator; and
(b) affirm or vary Claim Determination Decisions by way of a Review.
5. Once the Adjudicator has reached a decision with respect to an Adjudication or a
Review, he shall prepare and submit a Claim Adjudication Decision or a Oaim
Review Decision to the Claims Administrator.
6. There shall be no right of appeal or review by the Alberta Court, or any court,
with regard to a Claim Adjudication Decision or a Claim Review Decision.
7. If the Adjudicator is unable or unwilling to continue to act, a substitute
adjudicator shall be appointed, by agreement of the parties or by order of the
Alberta Court.
ARTICLE 8: CLAIMS ADMINISTRATION PROCEDURE
1. Claims under this Settlement Agreement shall be administered, as described in
the Claim Package and as set out in this Article.
2. During the Claim Period, a Claimant shall submit a completed Claim Package to
the Claims Administrator.
12964648.1
-23-
3. The Claims Administrator shall review the Claim Package to determine
completeness. If the Claim Package is incomplete or in any way deficient, the
Claims Administrator shall send a Deficiency Letter to the Claimant, and shall
grant the Claimant forty-five (45) days to amend or supplement it.
4. Once the Oaim Package is complete, the Claims Administrator shall assess the
Claim for eligibility for Compensatory Payments, and shall prepare and send a
Claim Determination Decision to the Claimant.
5. Claims that are subject to an Adjudication under the Settlement Agreement shall
be forwarded to the Adjudicator.
6. Within thirty (30) days of the date of the Claim Determination Decision,
(a) a Claimant may request a reconsideration of all or part of the Claim
Determination Decision, based upon information that was not available to
the Claimant with reasonable diligence at the time he or she submitted his
or her Claim Package. In that event, the Claims Administrator may
reconsider the Claim Determination Decision, in which case the thirty
(30)-day period shall start to run from the date that the Claims
Administrator informs the Claimant, in writing, of the result of the
reconsideration; or
(b) a Claimant may request a Review of all or part of the Claim Determination
Decision by submitting a written request to the Claims Administrator, in
which the basis of the request shall be particularized, together with a
Damages Brief. The Claims Administrator shall forward the Claim
Package, Damages Brief, and the request to the Adjudicator for a Review.
7. A Review or reconsideration of a Claim Determination Decision shall be based
on the contents of the Claim Package as originally submitted, or as amended or
supplemented in accordance with Article 8(3) or Article 8(6)(a).
12964648.1
-24-
8. A Review shall be made by the Adjudicator within thirty (30) days of receiving a
request for a Review. Forthwith, a Claim Review Decision shall be provided to
the Claimant and to the Claims Administrator.
9. In relation to a Claimant entitled to an Adjudication, the Claims Administrator
shall submit a Claim Package, together with the applicable Damages Brief, to the
Adjudicator for an Adjudication. The Adjudicator shall review the Claim
Package and Damages Brief, and shall conduct an Adjudication. Upon
completing the Adjudication, a Claim Adjudication Decision shall be provided to
the Claimant and to the Claims Administrator.
ARTICLE 9: SETTLEMENT BENEFITS
1. Pursuant to the terms and conditions of the Settlement Agreement, Le6n Farma
shall pay:
(a) Compensatory Payments in accordance with the Claims Administration
Procedure;
(b) any amounts due to Public Health Insurers;
(c) Honouraria;
(d) all costs associated with any notices required to be gtven under the
Settlement Agreement, including French translations thereof;
(e) all costs associated with the administration and implementation of the
Settlement Agreement including the Claims Administration Procedure;
(f) all fees and disbursements of the Claims Administrator and the
Adjudicator, as set out herein;
12964648.1
-25-
(g) Class Counsel's Fees and Disbursements, as stipulated in the Settlement
Agreement; and
(h) any other amounts provided for in the Settlement Agreement.
12964648.1
-26-
ARTICLElO: PAYMENT SCHEDULE
1. Le6n Parma shall be responsible for the French translation of the Settlement
Agreement, and the provision and translation of any notices required to be given
under the Settlement Agreement.
2. Within thirty (30) days of the Effective Date, Le6n Parma shall pay to Class
Counsel the amount of $900,000 plus reasonable disbursements and applicable
taxes, and thereafter shall pay any additional sums required pursuant to the
definitions of Class Counsel's Fees and Disbursements and Compensatory
Payments, as and when they can be quantified.
3. Within thirty (30) days of the date of a Oaim Determination Decision, Le6n
Parma shall pay any Compensatory Payments that are not subject to a Review,
directly to Claimants who are unrepresented, and to Class Counsel or Other
Counsel on behalf of represented Claimants.
4. Within thirty (30) days of the date of a Claim Adjudication Decision or a Claim
Review Decision, Le6n Parma shall pay any remaining Compensatory Payments
that are not subject to a Review, directly to Claimants who are unrepresented,
and to Class Counsel or Other Counsel on behalf of represented Claimants.
5. Le6n Parma shall pay any remaining amounts owed to Class Counsel on account
of Class Counsel's Fees and Disbursements, within sixty (60) days of the date
that the Claims Administrator determines that the last Claim has been
administered pursuant to the terms of the Settlement Agreement.
6. Le6n Parma shall pay the fees and disbursements of the Claims Administrator
and the Adjudicator on an ongoing basis.
7. As a condition precedent to the receipt o£ a Compensatory Payment, a Claimant
must provide his or her name, address, Public Health Insurer(s), and public
health insurance number to the Claims Administrator, together with a written
12964648.1
-27-
consent to permit the Claims Administrator to forward that information to his or
her Public Health Insurer(s).
8. Respecting any direct or subrogated claims of Public Health Insurers, and subject
to the 5% of any award to be paid to Class Counsel under Part (d) of the
definition of Class Counsel's Fees and Disbursements, Le6n Farma shall pay the
Public Health Insurers in full on account of their subrogated claims to which they
are entitled, and in accordance with the Settlement Agreement.
9. The Claims Administrator shall, from time to time, provide to the Public Health
Insurers a list of Claimants who have been awarded Compensatory Payments in
accordance with the Settlement Agreement, together with any information
provided by Claimants pursuant to Article 10(7). Thereafter, a Public Health
Insurer may submit a claim to counsel for Le6n Farma within thirty (30) days of
notification. It shall have a further sixty (60) days to attempt to reach agreement
with Le6n Parma respecting the quantum of compensation.
10. The parties agree that Le6n Farma shall not be liable for, or be a proper party to,
any dispute related to any alleged harm or injury suffered by any Class Member
by reason of the use or alleged misuse of funds administered under the
Settlement Agreement, or of any erroneous disbursement(s) or other action
taken, or failure to act, with respect to such funds.
ARTICLE 11: RELEASE
1. On the Effective Date, the Releasers shall forever and absolutely release the
Released Parties from the Released Claims, save and except that the Releasers
shall not release Le6n Farma with respect to any and all subrogated claims of any
Public Health Insurer, in accordance with Article 10(9) of the Settlement
Agreement.
12964648.1
-28-
· 2. Upon the approval of the Settlement Agreement, the Releasors and Class
Counsel shall not now or hereafter institute, continue, maintain or assert, either
directly or indirectly, whether in Canada or elsewhere, on their own behalf or on
behalf of any class or any other person, any action, suit, cause of action, claim, or
demand against any Released Party or any other person who may claim
contribution or indemnity from any Released Party in respect of any Released
Claim or any matter related thereto, except as otl1erwise provided for in the
Settlement Agreement.
3. If approved by the Alberta Court, the Settlement Agreement shall be binding
upon, and enure to the benefit of, the Representative Plaintiff, the Class
Members, the Defendants, the Released Parties, and the Releasors, on the
Effective Date.
4. Without limiting the generality of the foregoing, each and every covenant and
agreement made herein by the Representative Plaintiff shall be binding upon all
Releasors, and each and every covenant and agreement made herein by the
Defendants shall be binding upon all of the Released Parties.
5. In the event that litigation, commenced or continued by any Class Member
against another person, or by another person against a Class Member, arising out
of or in any way relating to the Released Claims, results in a claim over or
judgment against the Defendants and/ or any other Released Party, that Class
Member shall fully hold harmless, reimburse, and indemnify the Defendants
and/ or such other Released Party for such amount.
ARTICLE12: MISCELLANEOUS
1. The Settlement Agreement constitutes the entire agreement between the parties
pertaining to the subject-matter hereof, and supersedes all prior understandings,
12964648.1
-29-
representations, negotiations, discussions, and agreements, either oral or written,
which may have occurred prior to or subsequent to the execution of the
Settlement Agreement.
2. If the parties believe that an amendment to the Settlement Agreement is
necessary, a motion may be brought to the Alberta Court, on consent, to approve
the proposed amendment.
3. There are no other representations between the parties in connection with the
subject-matter of the Settlement Agreement except as specifically set forth herein,
and none has been relied upon by the parties in entering into the Settlement
Agreement.
4. The Alberta Court shall retain continuing jurisdiction over the Alberta Action,
including the parties and Class Members, respecting matters that arise pursuant
to or as a result of the Settlement Agreement. In particular, it shall retain
continuing jurisdiction over:
(a) all disputes relating to the proper interpretation of the Settlement
Agreement, and any matters arising during the course of its
implementation may be resolved on application to the Alberta Court;
(b) the reasonableness of amounts claimed by Class Counsel under clause (e)
of Class Counsel's Fees and Disbursements and any amounts claimed by
Other Counsel for representing Claimants in the Claims Administration
Procedure; and
(c) the Settlement Agreement to ensure that all payments and disbursements
are properly made, and to interpret and enforce its terms and conditions.
5. The Settlement Agreement shall be governed by and interpreted in accordance
with the applicable laws of Alberta and Canada. All disputes arising out of or in
12964648.1
-30-
connection with the Settlement Agreement shall be submitted to and be subject to
the exclusive jurisdiction of the Alberta Court.
6. All dollar amounts set forth in the Settlement Agreement are expressed m
Canadian currency.
7. The parties and their respective counsel agree that when publicly commenting on
the Claims that have been settled pursuant to the Settlement Agreement, they
shall, amongst other things:
(a) inform the inquirer that all Claims have been settled pursuant to the
Settlement Agreement and to the satisfaction of the parties and the
Claimants;
(b) inform the inquirer that the settlement of the Claims, which are subject to
the Settlement Agreement, is fair, reasonable, and in the best interests of
the Class; and
(c) decline to comment in a manner that would cast the conduct of any party
in a negative light, or reveal anything expressed, either orally or in
writing, during settlement negotiations.
8. The Settlement Agreement shall be deemed to have been mutually prepared by
the parties and shall not be construed against any of them solely by reason of
authorship.
9. The parties and their respective counsel shall expeditiously do all things that
may reasonably be required to give effect to the Settlement Agreement.
10. The parties agree that the Settlement Agreement may be executed by their
respective counsel and in counterparts, each of which shall be deemed to be an
original. Executed counterparts taken together shall constitute the complete
Settlement Agreement.
12964648.1
EXECUTED this Cj~ day of October, 2015
EXECUTED this 9th day of October, 2015
12964648.1
-31-
oratorios Leon Farrna SA
MERCHANT LAW GROUP LLP on behalf of the Plaintiffs