Secondary Olive Green Secondary Turquoise Secondary Aqua ... · Secondary Olive Green R120 G162 B47...

33
© 2012 The Actuarial Profession www.actuaries.org.uk Highlights of the Life Conference 2012 Paul Fulcher, Nomura International & Simon Richards, Insight Investment There’s more to Life than Solvency II

Transcript of Secondary Olive Green Secondary Turquoise Secondary Aqua ... · Secondary Olive Green R120 G162 B47...

Page 1: Secondary Olive Green Secondary Turquoise Secondary Aqua ... · Secondary Olive Green R120 G162 B47 Secondary colour palette Primary colour palette Secondary Bottle Green Highlights

© 2012 The Actuarial Profession www.actuaries.org.uk

Colour palette for PowerPoint presentations

Actuarial Bright Green

R148 G166 B31

Actuarial Slate

R32 G44 B52*

Secondary Olive Green

R120 G162 B47

Secondary colour palette

Primary colour palette

Secondary Bottle Green

R0 G147 B127

Secondary Turquoise

R0 G138 B176

Secondary Aqua Blue

R26 G160 B170

Secondary Pastel Green

R126 G205 B195

Secondary Light Purple

R123 G149 B174*

Secondary Purple

R97 G107 B156

Secondary Ecru

R186 G163 B171

Secondary Yellow

R215 G176 B18

Secondary Orange

R213 G135 B43

Secondary Red

R238 G52 B36

Secondary Rubine Red

R226 G1 B119

*This colour reference is for screen presentations only

Highlights of the Life Conference 2012 Paul Fulcher, Nomura International & Simon Richards, Insight Investment

There’s more to Life than Solvency II

Page 2: Secondary Olive Green Secondary Turquoise Secondary Aqua ... · Secondary Olive Green R120 G162 B47 Secondary colour palette Primary colour palette Secondary Bottle Green Highlights

Colour palette for PowerPoint presentations

Actuarial Bright Green

R148 G166 B31

Actuarial Slate

R32 G44 B52*

Secondary Olive Green

R120 G162 B47

Secondary colour palette

Primary colour palette

Secondary Bottle Green

R0 G147 B127

Secondary Turquoise

R0 G138 B176

Secondary Aqua Blue

R26 G160 B170

Secondary Pastel Green

R126 G205 B195

Secondary Light Purple

R123 G149 B174*

Secondary Purple

R97 G107 B156

Secondary Ecru

R186 G163 B171

Secondary Yellow

R215 G176 B18

Secondary Orange

R213 G135 B43

Secondary Red

R238 G52 B36

Secondary Rubine Red

R226 G1 B119

*This colour reference is for screen presentations only

Colour palette for PowerPoint presentations

Actuarial Bright Green

R148 G166 B31

Actuarial Slate

R32 G44 B52*

Secondary Olive Green

R120 G162 B47

Secondary colour palette

Primary colour palette

Secondary Bottle Green

R0 G147 B127

Secondary Turquoise

R0 G138 B176

Secondary Aqua Blue

R26 G160 B170

Secondary Pastel Green

R126 G205 B195

Secondary Light Purple

R123 G149 B174*

Secondary Purple

R97 G107 B156

Secondary Ecru

R186 G163 B171

Secondary Yellow

R215 G176 B18

Secondary Orange

R213 G135 B43

Secondary Red

R238 G52 B36

Secondary Rubine Red

R226 G1 B119

*This colour reference is for screen presentations only

Solvency II myopia

1 © 2012 The Actuarial Profession www.actuaries.org.uk

• EMIR, MIFID

• Dodd-Frank

Vickers

Liikanen

• Basel III - CRDIV

• Recovery and Resolution

Directive

• Wheatley review

Page 3: Secondary Olive Green Secondary Turquoise Secondary Aqua ... · Secondary Olive Green R120 G162 B47 Secondary colour palette Primary colour palette Secondary Bottle Green Highlights

Colour palette for PowerPoint presentations

Actuarial Bright Green

R148 G166 B31

Actuarial Slate

R32 G44 B52*

Secondary Olive Green

R120 G162 B47

Secondary colour palette

Primary colour palette

Secondary Bottle Green

R0 G147 B127

Secondary Turquoise

R0 G138 B176

Secondary Aqua Blue

R26 G160 B170

Secondary Pastel Green

R126 G205 B195

Secondary Light Purple

R123 G149 B174*

Secondary Purple

R97 G107 B156

Secondary Ecru

R186 G163 B171

Secondary Yellow

R215 G176 B18

Secondary Orange

R213 G135 B43

Secondary Red

R238 G52 B36

Secondary Rubine Red

R226 G1 B119

*This colour reference is for screen presentations only

Are insurers Systematically Important Financial Institutions?

2 © 2012 The Actuarial Profession www.actuaries.org.uk

“Financial institutions which typically demonstrate a high

degree of leverage, liquidity or maturity mismatch or

financial interconnectedness can transmit, and often

amplify, shocks arising elsewhere in the financial system”

Page 4: Secondary Olive Green Secondary Turquoise Secondary Aqua ... · Secondary Olive Green R120 G162 B47 Secondary colour palette Primary colour palette Secondary Bottle Green Highlights

Colour palette for PowerPoint presentations

Actuarial Bright Green

R148 G166 B31

Actuarial Slate

R32 G44 B52*

Secondary Olive Green

R120 G162 B47

Secondary colour palette

Primary colour palette

Secondary Bottle Green

R0 G147 B127

Secondary Turquoise

R0 G138 B176

Secondary Aqua Blue

R26 G160 B170

Secondary Pastel Green

R126 G205 B195

Secondary Light Purple

R123 G149 B174*

Secondary Purple

R97 G107 B156

Secondary Ecru

R186 G163 B171

Secondary Yellow

R215 G176 B18

Secondary Orange

R213 G135 B43

Secondary Red

R238 G52 B36

Secondary Rubine Red

R226 G1 B119

*This colour reference is for screen presentations only

A regulatory inflexion point?

3 © 2012 The Actuarial Profession www.actuaries.org.uk

“Importantly, introducing a phased timetable for the

introduction of the LCR, and reaffirming that a bank's stock of

liquid assets are usable in times of stress, will ensure that the

new liquidity standard will in no way hinder the ability of

the global banking system to finance a recovery"

Mervyn King, Chairman of the Group of Governors and

Heads of Supervision and Governor of the Bank of England,

January 2013

Page 5: Secondary Olive Green Secondary Turquoise Secondary Aqua ... · Secondary Olive Green R120 G162 B47 Secondary colour palette Primary colour palette Secondary Bottle Green Highlights

Colour palette for PowerPoint presentations

Actuarial Bright Green

R148 G166 B31

Actuarial Slate

R32 G44 B52*

Secondary Olive Green

R120 G162 B47

Secondary colour palette

Primary colour palette

Secondary Bottle Green

R0 G147 B127

Secondary Turquoise

R0 G138 B176

Secondary Aqua Blue

R26 G160 B170

Secondary Pastel Green

R126 G205 B195

Secondary Light Purple

R123 G149 B174*

Secondary Purple

R97 G107 B156

Secondary Ecru

R186 G163 B171

Secondary Yellow

R215 G176 B18

Secondary Orange

R213 G135 B43

Secondary Red

R238 G52 B36

Secondary Rubine Red

R226 G1 B119

*This colour reference is for screen presentations only

• Central clearing / EMIR

• CSA Discounting

• Other issues (including CVA)

Central clearing and related issues

Page 6: Secondary Olive Green Secondary Turquoise Secondary Aqua ... · Secondary Olive Green R120 G162 B47 Secondary colour palette Primary colour palette Secondary Bottle Green Highlights

Colour palette for PowerPoint presentations

Actuarial Bright Green

R148 G166 B31

Actuarial Slate

R32 G44 B52*

Secondary Olive Green

R120 G162 B47

Secondary colour palette

Primary colour palette

Secondary Bottle Green

R0 G147 B127

Secondary Turquoise

R0 G138 B176

Secondary Aqua Blue

R26 G160 B170

Secondary Pastel Green

R126 G205 B195

Secondary Light Purple

R123 G149 B174*

Secondary Purple

R97 G107 B156

Secondary Ecru

R186 G163 B171

Secondary Yellow

R215 G176 B18

Secondary Orange

R213 G135 B43

Secondary Red

R238 G52 B36

Secondary Rubine Red

R226 G1 B119

*This colour reference is for screen presentations only

Catalyst for change: September 2008

5

Page 7: Secondary Olive Green Secondary Turquoise Secondary Aqua ... · Secondary Olive Green R120 G162 B47 Secondary colour palette Primary colour palette Secondary Bottle Green Highlights

Colour palette for PowerPoint presentations

Actuarial Bright Green

R148 G166 B31

Actuarial Slate

R32 G44 B52*

Secondary Olive Green

R120 G162 B47

Secondary colour palette

Primary colour palette

Secondary Bottle Green

R0 G147 B127

Secondary Turquoise

R0 G138 B176

Secondary Aqua Blue

R26 G160 B170

Secondary Pastel Green

R126 G205 B195

Secondary Light Purple

R123 G149 B174*

Secondary Purple

R97 G107 B156

Secondary Ecru

R186 G163 B171

Secondary Yellow

R215 G176 B18

Secondary Orange

R213 G135 B43

Secondary Red

R238 G52 B36

Secondary Rubine Red

R226 G1 B119

*This colour reference is for screen presentations only

The line in the sand

Increase market transparency, reduce counterparty risk and systemic risk

G20 commitment

“All standardised OTC

derivative contracts should be

traded on exchanges or

electronic trading platforms,

where appropriate, and

cleared through central

counterparties by end-2012 at

latest. OTC derivatives

contracts should be reported to

trade repositories. Noncentrally

cleared contracts should be

subject to higher

capital requirements.”

6

Page 8: Secondary Olive Green Secondary Turquoise Secondary Aqua ... · Secondary Olive Green R120 G162 B47 Secondary colour palette Primary colour palette Secondary Bottle Green Highlights

Colour palette for PowerPoint presentations

Actuarial Bright Green

R148 G166 B31

Actuarial Slate

R32 G44 B52*

Secondary Olive Green

R120 G162 B47

Secondary colour palette

Primary colour palette

Secondary Bottle Green

R0 G147 B127

Secondary Turquoise

R0 G138 B176

Secondary Aqua Blue

R26 G160 B170

Secondary Pastel Green

R126 G205 B195

Secondary Light Purple

R123 G149 B174*

Secondary Purple

R97 G107 B156

Secondary Ecru

R186 G163 B171

Secondary Yellow

R215 G176 B18

Secondary Orange

R213 G135 B43

Secondary Red

R238 G52 B36

Secondary Rubine Red

R226 G1 B119

*This colour reference is for screen presentations only

The scale of the ambition

US GDP

$15tn

Exchange

traded derivatives

$83tn

OTC derivatives

$708tn

Sources: Insight (March 2012), and Bank for International Settlements (November 2011)

7

Page 9: Secondary Olive Green Secondary Turquoise Secondary Aqua ... · Secondary Olive Green R120 G162 B47 Secondary colour palette Primary colour palette Secondary Bottle Green Highlights

Colour palette for PowerPoint presentations

Actuarial Bright Green

R148 G166 B31

Actuarial Slate

R32 G44 B52*

Secondary Olive Green

R120 G162 B47

Secondary colour palette

Primary colour palette

Secondary Bottle Green

R0 G147 B127

Secondary Turquoise

R0 G138 B176

Secondary Aqua Blue

R26 G160 B170

Secondary Pastel Green

R126 G205 B195

Secondary Light Purple

R123 G149 B174*

Secondary Purple

R97 G107 B156

Secondary Ecru

R186 G163 B171

Secondary Yellow

R215 G176 B18

Secondary Orange

R213 G135 B43

Secondary Red

R238 G52 B36

Secondary Rubine Red

R226 G1 B119

*This colour reference is for screen presentations only

EMIR covers more than just mandatory clearing

Mandatory

clearing

• Requirement to clear

certain derivative

transactions

• Pension business of

Insurers has a

temporary exemption

New non-cleared

requirements

• Increased collateral

requirements

• Likely requirement to

post initial margin as

well as variation margin

• Minimum operational

standards

• Applies to all

Insurance business

Reporting

• Report all derivative

contracts to Trade

Repositories

• Applies to all

Insurance business

8

Page 10: Secondary Olive Green Secondary Turquoise Secondary Aqua ... · Secondary Olive Green R120 G162 B47 Secondary colour palette Primary colour palette Secondary Bottle Green Highlights

Colour palette for PowerPoint presentations

Actuarial Bright Green

R148 G166 B31

Actuarial Slate

R32 G44 B52*

Secondary Olive Green

R120 G162 B47

Secondary colour palette

Primary colour palette

Secondary Bottle Green

R0 G147 B127

Secondary Turquoise

R0 G138 B176

Secondary Aqua Blue

R26 G160 B170

Secondary Pastel Green

R126 G205 B195

Secondary Light Purple

R123 G149 B174*

Secondary Purple

R97 G107 B156

Secondary Ecru

R186 G163 B171

Secondary Yellow

R215 G176 B18

Secondary Orange

R213 G135 B43

Secondary Red

R238 G52 B36

Secondary Rubine Red

R226 G1 B119

*This colour reference is for screen presentations only

Changes from OTC clearing

© 2010 The Actuarial Profession www.actuaries.org.uk

Current structure Future structure

• Post trade risk management not execution

• End user still trades with chosen bank counterparty (Cpty)

• Transfer trade to clearing member who registers it at a CCP

End

user

Cpty

A

Cpty

C

Cpty

B

CCP

End

user

CM CM

End

user

CM CM

End

user

End

user

9

Page 11: Secondary Olive Green Secondary Turquoise Secondary Aqua ... · Secondary Olive Green R120 G162 B47 Secondary colour palette Primary colour palette Secondary Bottle Green Highlights

Colour palette for PowerPoint presentations

Actuarial Bright Green

R148 G166 B31

Actuarial Slate

R32 G44 B52*

Secondary Olive Green

R120 G162 B47

Secondary colour palette

Primary colour palette

Secondary Bottle Green

R0 G147 B127

Secondary Turquoise

R0 G138 B176

Secondary Aqua Blue

R26 G160 B170

Secondary Pastel Green

R126 G205 B195

Secondary Light Purple

R123 G149 B174*

Secondary Purple

R97 G107 B156

Secondary Ecru

R186 G163 B171

Secondary Yellow

R215 G176 B18

Secondary Orange

R213 G135 B43

Secondary Red

R238 G52 B36

Secondary Rubine Red

R226 G1 B119

*This colour reference is for screen presentations only

Changes from OTC clearing contd.

10 © 2010 The Actuarial Profession www.actuaries.org.uk

Current position Expected centrally

cleared

Expected non-

cleared regime

Legal

agreements

ISDA/CSA with each

counterparty.

Need documentation with

each counterparty and a

clearing member bank

(CM) to access clearing

house (maybe >1 CM)

Need documentation with

each counterparty

Initial margin Typically none Only cash or gilts Flexible

Variation

margin

Varies; typically cash and

gilts

Only cash Flexible

Default risk Exposed to default of the

counterparty you trade

with

Directly affected only if

your CM defaults

Loss mitigated by initial

margin

Back-up CM

recommended

Exposed to default of the

counterparty you trade

with

Loss mitigated by initial

margin

Page 12: Secondary Olive Green Secondary Turquoise Secondary Aqua ... · Secondary Olive Green R120 G162 B47 Secondary colour palette Primary colour palette Secondary Bottle Green Highlights

Colour palette for PowerPoint presentations

Actuarial Bright Green

R148 G166 B31

Actuarial Slate

R32 G44 B52*

Secondary Olive Green

R120 G162 B47

Secondary colour palette

Primary colour palette

Secondary Bottle Green

R0 G147 B127

Secondary Turquoise

R0 G138 B176

Secondary Aqua Blue

R26 G160 B170

Secondary Pastel Green

R126 G205 B195

Secondary Light Purple

R123 G149 B174*

Secondary Purple

R97 G107 B156

Secondary Ecru

R186 G163 B171

Secondary Yellow

R215 G176 B18

Secondary Orange

R213 G135 B43

Secondary Red

R238 G52 B36

Secondary Rubine Red

R226 G1 B119

*This colour reference is for screen presentations only

Value added?

11 © 2010 The Actuarial Profession www.actuaries.org.uk

Potential benefits Potential disadvantages

Provides a range of protection in

case of default

Likely to increase cost and reduce

returns

Greater regulatory transparency,

may help regulators detect systemic

risk build up

Interest rate swaps likely to be

cleared, but inflation swaps not

likely to be cleared initially

- reduces possibility of netting

margin between the two

All trades going through a limited

number of CM enables more

opportunities to net margin calls

Only cash variation margin accepted

by clearing houses

- insurers and pension schemes

generally don’t hold significant cash

Political need for regulators to be seen

to take action

Less flexibility from a requirement to

deliver initial margin

Page 13: Secondary Olive Green Secondary Turquoise Secondary Aqua ... · Secondary Olive Green R120 G162 B47 Secondary colour palette Primary colour palette Secondary Bottle Green Highlights

Colour palette for PowerPoint presentations

Actuarial Bright Green

R148 G166 B31

Actuarial Slate

R32 G44 B52*

Secondary Olive Green

R120 G162 B47

Secondary colour palette

Primary colour palette

Secondary Bottle Green

R0 G147 B127

Secondary Turquoise

R0 G138 B176

Secondary Aqua Blue

R26 G160 B170

Secondary Pastel Green

R126 G205 B195

Secondary Light Purple

R123 G149 B174*

Secondary Purple

R97 G107 B156

Secondary Ecru

R186 G163 B171

Secondary Yellow

R215 G176 B18

Secondary Orange

R213 G135 B43

Secondary Red

R238 G52 B36

Secondary Rubine Red

R226 G1 B119

*This colour reference is for screen presentations only

What next?

• Increased costs (both

direct and indirect)

• Opportunity cost of

increased and new collateral

requirement

• Reduced flexibility

• Liquidity costs

• Splitting of netting sets

• Asset allocation

• Repo and collateral

financing

• Synthesising assets

• Tactical, strategic and

structural solutions

• New documentation

• Reporting and disclosure

• Appointing clearing agents

• Developing appropriate

client models with clearers

Strategy & Innovation Cost Implementation

12

Page 14: Secondary Olive Green Secondary Turquoise Secondary Aqua ... · Secondary Olive Green R120 G162 B47 Secondary colour palette Primary colour palette Secondary Bottle Green Highlights

Colour palette for PowerPoint presentations

Actuarial Bright Green

R148 G166 B31

Actuarial Slate

R32 G44 B52*

Secondary Olive Green

R120 G162 B47

Secondary colour palette

Primary colour palette

Secondary Bottle Green

R0 G147 B127

Secondary Turquoise

R0 G138 B176

Secondary Aqua Blue

R26 G160 B170

Secondary Pastel Green

R126 G205 B195

Secondary Light Purple

R123 G149 B174*

Secondary Purple

R97 G107 B156

Secondary Ecru

R186 G163 B171

Secondary Yellow

R215 G176 B18

Secondary Orange

R213 G135 B43

Secondary Red

R238 G52 B36

Secondary Rubine Red

R226 G1 B119

*This colour reference is for screen presentations only

• Central clearing / EMIR

• CSA Discounting

• Other issues (including CVA)

OTC Derivatives

13

Page 15: Secondary Olive Green Secondary Turquoise Secondary Aqua ... · Secondary Olive Green R120 G162 B47 Secondary colour palette Primary colour palette Secondary Bottle Green Highlights

Colour palette for PowerPoint presentations

Actuarial Bright Green

R148 G166 B31

Actuarial Slate

R32 G44 B52*

Secondary Olive Green

R120 G162 B47

Secondary colour palette

Primary colour palette

Secondary Bottle Green

R0 G147 B127

Secondary Turquoise

R0 G138 B176

Secondary Aqua Blue

R26 G160 B170

Secondary Pastel Green

R126 G205 B195

Secondary Light Purple

R123 G149 B174*

Secondary Purple

R97 G107 B156

Secondary Ecru

R186 G163 B171

Secondary Yellow

R215 G176 B18

Secondary Orange

R213 G135 B43

Secondary Red

R238 G52 B36

Secondary Rubine Red

R226 G1 B119

*This colour reference is for screen presentations only

CSA discounting

© 2010 The Actuarial Profession www.actuaries.org.uk

Some terminology:

• SONIA is the Sterling Overnight Interbank Average rate

• It tracks actual Sterling overnight funding rates

experienced by market participants

• OIS is Overnight Index Swap

• a fixed rate interest rate swap against a SONIA floating

rate index

14

Page 16: Secondary Olive Green Secondary Turquoise Secondary Aqua ... · Secondary Olive Green R120 G162 B47 Secondary colour palette Primary colour palette Secondary Bottle Green Highlights

Colour palette for PowerPoint presentations

Actuarial Bright Green

R148 G166 B31

Actuarial Slate

R32 G44 B52*

Secondary Olive Green

R120 G162 B47

Secondary colour palette

Primary colour palette

Secondary Bottle Green

R0 G147 B127

Secondary Turquoise

R0 G138 B176

Secondary Aqua Blue

R26 G160 B170

Secondary Pastel Green

R126 G205 B195

Secondary Light Purple

R123 G149 B174*

Secondary Purple

R97 G107 B156

Secondary Ecru

R186 G163 B171

Secondary Yellow

R215 G176 B18

Secondary Orange

R213 G135 B43

Secondary Red

R238 G52 B36

Secondary Rubine Red

R226 G1 B119

*This colour reference is for screen presentations only

CSA discounting

© 2010 The Actuarial Profession www.actuaries.org.uk

• Traditional method of swap valuation: 6m Libor swap curve

• LIBOR was previously recognised as bank funding rate

• Market moving to: CSA specific discounting

• Discount rate for future cashflows based on collateral

held / posted

• Cost of collateral more closely aligned to OIS for ‘clean’

CSAs

15

Page 17: Secondary Olive Green Secondary Turquoise Secondary Aqua ... · Secondary Olive Green R120 G162 B47 Secondary colour palette Primary colour palette Secondary Bottle Green Highlights

Colour palette for PowerPoint presentations

Actuarial Bright Green

R148 G166 B31

Actuarial Slate

R32 G44 B52*

Secondary Olive Green

R120 G162 B47

Secondary colour palette

Primary colour palette

Secondary Bottle Green

R0 G147 B127

Secondary Turquoise

R0 G138 B176

Secondary Aqua Blue

R26 G160 B170

Secondary Pastel Green

R126 G205 B195

Secondary Light Purple

R123 G149 B174*

Secondary Purple

R97 G107 B156

Secondary Ecru

R186 G163 B171

Secondary Yellow

R215 G176 B18

Secondary Orange

R213 G135 B43

Secondary Red

R238 G52 B36

Secondary Rubine Red

R226 G1 B119

*This colour reference is for screen presentations only

CSA discounting

© 2010 The Actuarial Profession www.actuaries.org.uk

What does this mean?

• Under central clearing:

• Discount future cashflows based on OIS rates

• Some CSAs allow wider collateral e.g. corporate bonds

• Discount rate may remain linked to Libor

• SONIA curve below Libor curve so lower discount rate

16

Page 18: Secondary Olive Green Secondary Turquoise Secondary Aqua ... · Secondary Olive Green R120 G162 B47 Secondary colour palette Primary colour palette Secondary Bottle Green Highlights

Colour palette for PowerPoint presentations

Actuarial Bright Green

R148 G166 B31

Actuarial Slate

R32 G44 B52*

Secondary Olive Green

R120 G162 B47

Secondary colour palette

Primary colour palette

Secondary Bottle Green

R0 G147 B127

Secondary Turquoise

R0 G138 B176

Secondary Aqua Blue

R26 G160 B170

Secondary Pastel Green

R126 G205 B195

Secondary Light Purple

R123 G149 B174*

Secondary Purple

R97 G107 B156

Secondary Ecru

R186 G163 B171

Secondary Yellow

R215 G176 B18

Secondary Orange

R213 G135 B43

Secondary Red

R238 G52 B36

Secondary Rubine Red

R226 G1 B119

*This colour reference is for screen presentations only

Why does this matter?

© 2010 The Actuarial Profession www.actuaries.org.uk

Implications:

• Insurers swaps are typically ITM – increase to valuation

– Re-coupon swaps to generate cash

• Solvency II currently uses a 6m Libor curve

– Creates a basis exposure for insurers hedging using

swaps valued off OIS

17

Page 19: Secondary Olive Green Secondary Turquoise Secondary Aqua ... · Secondary Olive Green R120 G162 B47 Secondary colour palette Primary colour palette Secondary Bottle Green Highlights

Colour palette for PowerPoint presentations

Actuarial Bright Green

R148 G166 B31

Actuarial Slate

R32 G44 B52*

Secondary Olive Green

R120 G162 B47

Secondary colour palette

Primary colour palette

Secondary Bottle Green

R0 G147 B127

Secondary Turquoise

R0 G138 B176

Secondary Aqua Blue

R26 G160 B170

Secondary Pastel Green

R126 G205 B195

Secondary Light Purple

R123 G149 B174*

Secondary Purple

R97 G107 B156

Secondary Ecru

R186 G163 B171

Secondary Yellow

R215 G176 B18

Secondary Orange

R213 G135 B43

Secondary Red

R238 G52 B36

Secondary Rubine Red

R226 G1 B119

*This colour reference is for screen presentations only

• Central clearing / EMIR

• CSA Discounting

• Other issues (including CVA)

OTC Derivatives

Page 20: Secondary Olive Green Secondary Turquoise Secondary Aqua ... · Secondary Olive Green R120 G162 B47 Secondary colour palette Primary colour palette Secondary Bottle Green Highlights

Colour palette for PowerPoint presentations

Actuarial Bright Green

R148 G166 B31

Actuarial Slate

R32 G44 B52*

Secondary Olive Green

R120 G162 B47

Secondary colour palette

Primary colour palette

Secondary Bottle Green

R0 G147 B127

Secondary Turquoise

R0 G138 B176

Secondary Aqua Blue

R26 G160 B170

Secondary Pastel Green

R126 G205 B195

Secondary Light Purple

R123 G149 B174*

Secondary Purple

R97 G107 B156

Secondary Ecru

R186 G163 B171

Secondary Yellow

R215 G176 B18

Secondary Orange

R213 G135 B43

Secondary Red

R238 G52 B36

Secondary Rubine Red

R226 G1 B119

*This colour reference is for screen presentations only

Basel III/CRD IV

• Capital Requirement Directive IV sets up risk management

framework for banks potentially impacting OTC derivatives

– Likely to be delayed from target of 1 January 2013

– CVA charges for OTC derivatives transactions

– Impact of CVA charges likely to be minimal where initial

margin is required in the new regime

– Pension business of insurers may be exempt from CVA

charges

19

Page 21: Secondary Olive Green Secondary Turquoise Secondary Aqua ... · Secondary Olive Green R120 G162 B47 Secondary colour palette Primary colour palette Secondary Bottle Green Highlights

Colour palette for PowerPoint presentations

Actuarial Bright Green

R148 G166 B31

Actuarial Slate

R32 G44 B52*

Secondary Olive Green

R120 G162 B47

Secondary colour palette

Primary colour palette

Secondary Bottle Green

R0 G147 B127

Secondary Turquoise

R0 G138 B176

Secondary Aqua Blue

R26 G160 B170

Secondary Pastel Green

R126 G205 B195

Secondary Light Purple

R123 G149 B174*

Secondary Purple

R97 G107 B156

Secondary Ecru

R186 G163 B171

Secondary Yellow

R215 G176 B18

Secondary Orange

R213 G135 B43

Secondary Red

R238 G52 B36

Secondary Rubine Red

R226 G1 B119

*This colour reference is for screen presentations only

CVA charging

• Credit Value Adjustment (CVA charge) takes account of counterparty

risk in assessing cost of capital

• Default Value Adjustment (DVA charge) which is an allowance for the

institution’s own risk of default that can offset the CVA charge

• Bank should adjust trade price for CVA charge to reflect counterparty

risk of client and arguably offset DVA charge to represent own

counterparty risk

– Cost of trading increases for more risky counterparty and reduces

for less risky counterparty

– Impact greatest for long maturity contracts (e.g. may be 1.5-2bp for

20 year interest rate swap)

20

Page 22: Secondary Olive Green Secondary Turquoise Secondary Aqua ... · Secondary Olive Green R120 G162 B47 Secondary colour palette Primary colour palette Secondary Bottle Green Highlights

Colour palette for PowerPoint presentations

Actuarial Bright Green

R148 G166 B31

Actuarial Slate

R32 G44 B52*

Secondary Olive Green

R120 G162 B47

Secondary colour palette

Primary colour palette

Secondary Bottle Green

R0 G147 B127

Secondary Turquoise

R0 G138 B176

Secondary Aqua Blue

R26 G160 B170

Secondary Pastel Green

R126 G205 B195

Secondary Light Purple

R123 G149 B174*

Secondary Purple

R97 G107 B156

Secondary Ecru

R186 G163 B171

Secondary Yellow

R215 G176 B18

Secondary Orange

R213 G135 B43

Secondary Red

R238 G52 B36

Secondary Rubine Red

R226 G1 B119

*This colour reference is for screen presentations only

Bank deleveraging

21 © 2012 The Actuarial Profession www.actuaries.org.uk

• Capital

• Funding

• Liquidity

• Leverage

“Give me a lever long

enough and a place to

stand and I will move the

entire earth”, Archimedes

Page 23: Secondary Olive Green Secondary Turquoise Secondary Aqua ... · Secondary Olive Green R120 G162 B47 Secondary colour palette Primary colour palette Secondary Bottle Green Highlights

Colour palette for PowerPoint presentations

Actuarial Bright Green

R148 G166 B31

Actuarial Slate

R32 G44 B52*

Secondary Olive Green

R120 G162 B47

Secondary colour palette

Primary colour palette

Secondary Bottle Green

R0 G147 B127

Secondary Turquoise

R0 G138 B176

Secondary Aqua Blue

R26 G160 B170

Secondary Pastel Green

R126 G205 B195

Secondary Light Purple

R123 G149 B174*

Secondary Purple

R97 G107 B156

Secondary Ecru

R186 G163 B171

Secondary Yellow

R215 G176 B18

Secondary Orange

R213 G135 B43

Secondary Red

R238 G52 B36

Secondary Rubine Red

R226 G1 B119

*This colour reference is for screen presentations only

Colour palette for PowerPoint presentations

Actuarial Bright Green

R148 G166 B31

Actuarial Slate

R32 G44 B52*

Secondary Olive Green

R120 G162 B47

Secondary colour palette

Primary colour palette

Secondary Bottle Green

R0 G147 B127

Secondary Turquoise

R0 G138 B176

Secondary Aqua Blue

R26 G160 B170

Secondary Pastel Green

R126 G205 B195

Secondary Light Purple

R123 G149 B174*

Secondary Purple

R97 G107 B156

Secondary Ecru

R186 G163 B171

Secondary Yellow

R215 G176 B18

Secondary Orange

R213 G135 B43

Secondary Red

R238 G52 B36

Secondary Rubine Red

R226 G1 B119

*This colour reference is for screen presentations only

Clouds on the banking horizon

© 2012 The Actuarial Profession www.actuaries.org.uk

Basel III Sovereign

Stress

Concentration

of exposure Commitments to

capital providers

Return on

Risk Capital

State-aid

penalties

Source: Nomura 22

Page 24: Secondary Olive Green Secondary Turquoise Secondary Aqua ... · Secondary Olive Green R120 G162 B47 Secondary colour palette Primary colour palette Secondary Bottle Green Highlights

Colour palette for PowerPoint presentations

Actuarial Bright Green

R148 G166 B31

Actuarial Slate

R32 G44 B52*

Secondary Olive Green

R120 G162 B47

Secondary colour palette

Primary colour palette

Secondary Bottle Green

R0 G147 B127

Secondary Turquoise

R0 G138 B176

Secondary Aqua Blue

R26 G160 B170

Secondary Pastel Green

R126 G205 B195

Secondary Light Purple

R123 G149 B174*

Secondary Purple

R97 G107 B156

Secondary Ecru

R186 G163 B171

Secondary Yellow

R215 G176 B18

Secondary Orange

R213 G135 B43

Secondary Red

R238 G52 B36

Secondary Rubine Red

R226 G1 B119

*This colour reference is for screen presentations only

The bank crisis-sovereign crisis

© 2012 The Actuarial Profession www.actuaries.org.uk Source: OECD

Losses on holdings of sovereign debt

Reduction in the value of collateral

Potential credit rating downgrades

Reduced value of explicit/implicit guarantees Banks

weakening Sovereigns weakening

Deleveraging pressures detrimental to real

activity

Bank failures reduce investor base

Increase in sovereign outlays, actual and

potential liabilities

Negative feedback on sovereigns

Negative feedback on banks

23

Page 25: Secondary Olive Green Secondary Turquoise Secondary Aqua ... · Secondary Olive Green R120 G162 B47 Secondary colour palette Primary colour palette Secondary Bottle Green Highlights

Colour palette for PowerPoint presentations

Actuarial Bright Green

R148 G166 B31

Actuarial Slate

R32 G44 B52*

Secondary Olive Green

R120 G162 B47

Secondary colour palette

Primary colour palette

Secondary Bottle Green

R0 G147 B127

Secondary Turquoise

R0 G138 B176

Secondary Aqua Blue

R26 G160 B170

Secondary Pastel Green

R126 G205 B195

Secondary Light Purple

R123 G149 B174*

Secondary Purple

R97 G107 B156

Secondary Ecru

R186 G163 B171

Secondary Yellow

R215 G176 B18

Secondary Orange

R213 G135 B43

Secondary Red

R238 G52 B36

Secondary Rubine Red

R226 G1 B119

*This colour reference is for screen presentations only

Colour palette for PowerPoint presentations

Actuarial Bright Green

R148 G166 B31

Actuarial Slate

R32 G44 B52*

Secondary Olive Green

R120 G162 B47

Secondary colour palette

Primary colour palette

Secondary Bottle Green

R0 G147 B127

Secondary Turquoise

R0 G138 B176

Secondary Aqua Blue

R26 G160 B170

Secondary Pastel Green

R126 G205 B195

Secondary Light Purple

R123 G149 B174*

Secondary Purple

R97 G107 B156

Secondary Ecru

R186 G163 B171

Secondary Yellow

R215 G176 B18

Secondary Orange

R213 G135 B43

Secondary Red

R238 G52 B36

Secondary Rubine Red

R226 G1 B119

*This colour reference is for screen presentations only

Basel III capital changes

© 2012 The Actuarial Profession www.actuaries.org.uk

Source: Deutsche Bundesbank 24

Page 26: Secondary Olive Green Secondary Turquoise Secondary Aqua ... · Secondary Olive Green R120 G162 B47 Secondary colour palette Primary colour palette Secondary Bottle Green Highlights

Colour palette for PowerPoint presentations

Actuarial Bright Green

R148 G166 B31

Actuarial Slate

R32 G44 B52*

Secondary Olive Green

R120 G162 B47

Secondary colour palette

Primary colour palette

Secondary Bottle Green

R0 G147 B127

Secondary Turquoise

R0 G138 B176

Secondary Aqua Blue

R26 G160 B170

Secondary Pastel Green

R126 G205 B195

Secondary Light Purple

R123 G149 B174*

Secondary Purple

R97 G107 B156

Secondary Ecru

R186 G163 B171

Secondary Yellow

R215 G176 B18

Secondary Orange

R213 G135 B43

Secondary Red

R238 G52 B36

Secondary Rubine Red

R226 G1 B119

*This colour reference is for screen presentations only

Basel III – other key areas

© 2012 The Actuarial Profession www.actuaries.org.uk

• Liquidity and net stable funding ratios

• Limits on leverage ratios

• Increase to capital charges – including CVAs

25 Source: BCBS

Page 27: Secondary Olive Green Secondary Turquoise Secondary Aqua ... · Secondary Olive Green R120 G162 B47 Secondary colour palette Primary colour palette Secondary Bottle Green Highlights

Colour palette for PowerPoint presentations

Actuarial Bright Green

R148 G166 B31

Actuarial Slate

R32 G44 B52*

Secondary Olive Green

R120 G162 B47

Secondary colour palette

Primary colour palette

Secondary Bottle Green

R0 G147 B127

Secondary Turquoise

R0 G138 B176

Secondary Aqua Blue

R26 G160 B170

Secondary Pastel Green

R126 G205 B195

Secondary Light Purple

R123 G149 B174*

Secondary Purple

R97 G107 B156

Secondary Ecru

R186 G163 B171

Secondary Yellow

R215 G176 B18

Secondary Orange

R213 G135 B43

Secondary Red

R238 G52 B36

Secondary Rubine Red

R226 G1 B119

*This colour reference is for screen presentations only

Colour palette for PowerPoint presentations

Actuarial Bright Green

R148 G166 B31

Actuarial Slate

R32 G44 B52*

Secondary Olive Green

R120 G162 B47

Secondary colour palette

Primary colour palette

Secondary Bottle Green

R0 G147 B127

Secondary Turquoise

R0 G138 B176

Secondary Aqua Blue

R26 G160 B170

Secondary Pastel Green

R126 G205 B195

Secondary Light Purple

R123 G149 B174*

Secondary Purple

R97 G107 B156

Secondary Ecru

R186 G163 B171

Secondary Yellow

R215 G176 B18

Secondary Orange

R213 G135 B43

Secondary Red

R238 G52 B36

Secondary Rubine Red

R226 G1 B119

*This colour reference is for screen presentations only

Banks responses

26 © 2012 The Actuarial Profession www.actuaries.org.uk

Capital strengthening

Change in funding mix

Optimisation of capital methodologies

Reduction in new origination of loans and run-off of certain sectors

Outright sale of legacy loan positions

Page 28: Secondary Olive Green Secondary Turquoise Secondary Aqua ... · Secondary Olive Green R120 G162 B47 Secondary colour palette Primary colour palette Secondary Bottle Green Highlights

Colour palette for PowerPoint presentations

Actuarial Bright Green

R148 G166 B31

Actuarial Slate

R32 G44 B52*

Secondary Olive Green

R120 G162 B47

Secondary colour palette

Primary colour palette

Secondary Bottle Green

R0 G147 B127

Secondary Turquoise

R0 G138 B176

Secondary Aqua Blue

R26 G160 B170

Secondary Pastel Green

R126 G205 B195

Secondary Light Purple

R123 G149 B174*

Secondary Purple

R97 G107 B156

Secondary Ecru

R186 G163 B171

Secondary Yellow

R215 G176 B18

Secondary Orange

R213 G135 B43

Secondary Red

R238 G52 B36

Secondary Rubine Red

R226 G1 B119

*This colour reference is for screen presentations only

Colour palette for PowerPoint presentations

Actuarial Bright Green

R148 G166 B31

Actuarial Slate

R32 G44 B52*

Secondary Olive Green

R120 G162 B47

Secondary colour palette

Primary colour palette

Secondary Bottle Green

R0 G147 B127

Secondary Turquoise

R0 G138 B176

Secondary Aqua Blue

R26 G160 B170

Secondary Pastel Green

R126 G205 B195

Secondary Light Purple

R123 G149 B174*

Secondary Purple

R97 G107 B156

Secondary Ecru

R186 G163 B171

Secondary Yellow

R215 G176 B18

Secondary Orange

R213 G135 B43

Secondary Red

R238 G52 B36

Secondary Rubine Red

R226 G1 B119

*This colour reference is for screen presentations only

Sources of deleveraging

27 © 2012 The Actuarial Profession www.actuaries.org.uk

Source: IMF

Page 29: Secondary Olive Green Secondary Turquoise Secondary Aqua ... · Secondary Olive Green R120 G162 B47 Secondary colour palette Primary colour palette Secondary Bottle Green Highlights

Colour palette for PowerPoint presentations

Actuarial Bright Green

R148 G166 B31

Actuarial Slate

R32 G44 B52*

Secondary Olive Green

R120 G162 B47

Secondary colour palette

Primary colour palette

Secondary Bottle Green

R0 G147 B127

Secondary Turquoise

R0 G138 B176

Secondary Aqua Blue

R26 G160 B170

Secondary Pastel Green

R126 G205 B195

Secondary Light Purple

R123 G149 B174*

Secondary Purple

R97 G107 B156

Secondary Ecru

R186 G163 B171

Secondary Yellow

R215 G176 B18

Secondary Orange

R213 G135 B43

Secondary Red

R238 G52 B36

Secondary Rubine Red

R226 G1 B119

*This colour reference is for screen presentations only

Colour palette for PowerPoint presentations

Actuarial Bright Green

R148 G166 B31

Actuarial Slate

R32 G44 B52*

Secondary Olive Green

R120 G162 B47

Secondary colour palette

Primary colour palette

Secondary Bottle Green

R0 G147 B127

Secondary Turquoise

R0 G138 B176

Secondary Aqua Blue

R26 G160 B170

Secondary Pastel Green

R126 G205 B195

Secondary Light Purple

R123 G149 B174*

Secondary Purple

R97 G107 B156

Secondary Ecru

R186 G163 B171

Secondary Yellow

R215 G176 B18

Secondary Orange

R213 G135 B43

Secondary Red

R238 G52 B36

Secondary Rubine Red

R226 G1 B119

*This colour reference is for screen presentations only

Asset classes available

© 2012 The Actuarial Profession www.actuaries.org.uk

Source: Deloitte 28

Page 30: Secondary Olive Green Secondary Turquoise Secondary Aqua ... · Secondary Olive Green R120 G162 B47 Secondary colour palette Primary colour palette Secondary Bottle Green Highlights

Colour palette for PowerPoint presentations

Actuarial Bright Green

R148 G166 B31

Actuarial Slate

R32 G44 B52*

Secondary Olive Green

R120 G162 B47

Secondary colour palette

Primary colour palette

Secondary Bottle Green

R0 G147 B127

Secondary Turquoise

R0 G138 B176

Secondary Aqua Blue

R26 G160 B170

Secondary Pastel Green

R126 G205 B195

Secondary Light Purple

R123 G149 B174*

Secondary Purple

R97 G107 B156

Secondary Ecru

R186 G163 B171

Secondary Yellow

R215 G176 B18

Secondary Orange

R213 G135 B43

Secondary Red

R238 G52 B36

Secondary Rubine Red

R226 G1 B119

*This colour reference is for screen presentations only

Colour palette for PowerPoint presentations

Actuarial Bright Green

R148 G166 B31

Actuarial Slate

R32 G44 B52*

Secondary Olive Green

R120 G162 B47

Secondary colour palette

Primary colour palette

Secondary Bottle Green

R0 G147 B127

Secondary Turquoise

R0 G138 B176

Secondary Aqua Blue

R26 G160 B170

Secondary Pastel Green

R126 G205 B195

Secondary Light Purple

R123 G149 B174*

Secondary Purple

R97 G107 B156

Secondary Ecru

R186 G163 B171

Secondary Yellow

R215 G176 B18

Secondary Orange

R213 G135 B43

Secondary Red

R238 G52 B36

Secondary Rubine Red

R226 G1 B119

*This colour reference is for screen presentations only

Role for Insurers?

© 2012 The Actuarial Profession www.actuaries.org.uk

Banks won’t realise losses

Need expertise

“Shadow-banking”

Solvency II

Liquidity Swaps

New Origination

Excess liquidity

Dearth of

opportunities

Long-dated

secured

cashflows

29

More natural buyers

Page 31: Secondary Olive Green Secondary Turquoise Secondary Aqua ... · Secondary Olive Green R120 G162 B47 Secondary colour palette Primary colour palette Secondary Bottle Green Highlights

Colour palette for PowerPoint presentations

Actuarial Bright Green

R148 G166 B31

Actuarial Slate

R32 G44 B52*

Secondary Olive Green

R120 G162 B47

Secondary colour palette

Primary colour palette

Secondary Bottle Green

R0 G147 B127

Secondary Turquoise

R0 G138 B176

Secondary Aqua Blue

R26 G160 B170

Secondary Pastel Green

R126 G205 B195

Secondary Light Purple

R123 G149 B174*

Secondary Purple

R97 G107 B156

Secondary Ecru

R186 G163 B171

Secondary Yellow

R215 G176 B18

Secondary Orange

R213 G135 B43

Secondary Red

R238 G52 B36

Secondary Rubine Red

R226 G1 B119

*This colour reference is for screen presentations only

A final thought….

30 © 2012 The Actuarial Profession www.actuaries.org.uk

“If you have ten thousand regulations you destroy all respect for the law.”

“This report, by its very length, defends itself against the risk of being read.”

Page 32: Secondary Olive Green Secondary Turquoise Secondary Aqua ... · Secondary Olive Green R120 G162 B47 Secondary colour palette Primary colour palette Secondary Bottle Green Highlights

Colour palette for PowerPoint presentations

Actuarial Bright Green

R148 G166 B31

Actuarial Slate

R32 G44 B52*

Secondary Olive Green

R120 G162 B47

Secondary colour palette

Primary colour palette

Secondary Bottle Green

R0 G147 B127

Secondary Turquoise

R0 G138 B176

Secondary Aqua Blue

R26 G160 B170

Secondary Pastel Green

R126 G205 B195

Secondary Light Purple

R123 G149 B174*

Secondary Purple

R97 G107 B156

Secondary Ecru

R186 G163 B171

Secondary Yellow

R215 G176 B18

Secondary Orange

R213 G135 B43

Secondary Red

R238 G52 B36

Secondary Rubine Red

R226 G1 B119

*This colour reference is for screen presentations only

Questions or comments?

Expressions of individual views by

members of The Actuarial Profession

and its staff are encouraged.

The views expressed in this presentation

are those of the presenter.

31 © 2012 The Actuarial Profession www.actuaries.org.uk

Page 33: Secondary Olive Green Secondary Turquoise Secondary Aqua ... · Secondary Olive Green R120 G162 B47 Secondary colour palette Primary colour palette Secondary Bottle Green Highlights

Colour palette for PowerPoint presentations

Actuarial Bright Green

R148 G166 B31

Actuarial Slate

R32 G44 B52*

Secondary Olive Green

R120 G162 B47

Secondary colour palette

Primary colour palette

Secondary Bottle Green

R0 G147 B127

Secondary Turquoise

R0 G138 B176

Secondary Aqua Blue

R26 G160 B170

Secondary Pastel Green

R126 G205 B195

Secondary Light Purple

R123 G149 B174*

Secondary Purple

R97 G107 B156

Secondary Ecru

R186 G163 B171

Secondary Yellow

R215 G176 B18

Secondary Orange

R213 G135 B43

Secondary Red

R238 G52 B36

Secondary Rubine Red

R226 G1 B119

*This colour reference is for screen presentations only

Colour palette for PowerPoint presentations

Actuarial Bright Green

R148 G166 B31

Actuarial Slate

R32 G44 B52*

Secondary Olive Green

R120 G162 B47

Secondary colour palette

Primary colour palette

Secondary Bottle Green

R0 G147 B127

Secondary Turquoise

R0 G138 B176

Secondary Aqua Blue

R26 G160 B170

Secondary Pastel Green

R126 G205 B195

Secondary Light Purple

R123 G149 B174*

Secondary Purple

R97 G107 B156

Secondary Ecru

R186 G163 B171

Secondary Yellow

R215 G176 B18

Secondary Orange

R213 G135 B43

Secondary Red

R238 G52 B36

Secondary Rubine Red

R226 G1 B119

*This colour reference is for screen presentations only

References / further reading

© 2012 The Actuarial Profession www.actuaries.org.uk

HM Treasury (2012), White Paper on Banking Reform http://www.hm-treasury.gov.uk/d/whitepaper_banking_reform_140512.pdf

International Monetary Fund (2012), Global Financial Stability Report, April 2012 http://www.imf.org/External/Pubs/FT/GFSR/2012/01/pdf/text.pdf

Stanworth et al (2005), How Valuable is Liquidity, report of Liquidity Working Party http://www.actuaries.org.uk/research-and-resources/documents/how-valuable-liquidity-liquidity-working-party-report

OECD (2012), Implicit Guarantees for Bank Debt: Where Do We Stand? http://www.oecd.org/finance/financialmarkets/50586138.pdf

BCBS (2012), Results of the Basel III monitoring exercise as of 31 December 2011 http://www.bis.org/publ/bcbs231.pdf

Bank of England (2012), The dog and the frisbee http://www.bankofengland.co.uk/publications/Documents/speeches/2012/speech596.pdf

32