Revised API2000 vs New ISO Standard
-
Upload
thayalan-priyanathan -
Category
Documents
-
view
532 -
download
38
Transcript of Revised API2000 vs New ISO Standard
1
ww
w.o
ri.m
ilano
.it
GROTH CORPORATIONGROTH CORPORATIONINTRODUCTION AND ISO 23800 INTRODUCTION AND ISO 23800
PRESENTATIONPRESENTATION
ww
w.o
ri.m
ilano
.it
GROTH CORPORATIONGROTH CORPORATIONEstablished in 1960 by Ed Groth as Groth EquipmentToday is a Global leader in low pressure protection Equipment
Since 1999 part of the Continental Group [CDC]
Scope of supply:
Pressure Vacuum Relief VentsFlame and Detonation ArrestersBlanket Gas RegulatorsPilot Operated ValvesBio-gas control equipment
HYSTORYHYSTORY
2
ww
w.o
ri.m
ilano
.it
CHEMICAL AND PETROCHEMICALCHEMICAL AND PETROCHEMICALOIL & GASOIL & GASFOOD & BEVERAGEFOOD & BEVERAGEPHARMACEUTICALPHARMACEUTICALBIOBIO--GAS CONTROL EQUIPMENTGAS CONTROL EQUIPMENTTANK FARMSTANK FARMS
MARKETSMARKETSw
ww
.ori.
mila
no.it
FULL TANK PROTECTION SYSTEMFULL TANK PROTECTION SYSTEM
3
ww
w.o
ri.m
ilano
.itFULL PRODUCT RANGEFULL PRODUCT RANGE
• PRESSURE VACUUM RELIEF VENTS
ww
w.o
ri.m
ilano
.it
FULL PRODUCT RANGEFULL PRODUCT RANGE
• EMERGENCY RELIEF VENTS
2000A [Weight loaded] 2050A w/loaded w/vacuum
2100A- spring loaded [Ps>1.0 psig]
2500 – POV Valve2400A Weight Loaded hinged style
4
ww
w.o
ri.m
ilano
.itFULL PRODUCT RANGEFULL PRODUCT RANGE
• PILOT OPERATED RELIEF VENTS
1400
1460
1420
1660
1430w
ww
.ori.
mila
no.it
FULL PRODUCT RANGEFULL PRODUCT RANGE
• BLANKET REGULATORS AND FLAME ARRESTORS
5
ww
w.o
ri.m
ilano
.itFUNDAMENTALS OF TANK PROTECTIONFUNDAMENTALS OF TANK PROTECTION
ww
w.o
ri.m
ilano
.it
API VESSEL STANDARD API 650API VESSEL STANDARD API 650
6
ww
w.o
ri.m
ilano
.itAPI VESSEL STANDARD API 620API VESSEL STANDARD API 620
ww
w.o
ri.m
ilano
.it
DESIGN CODES DESIGN CODES –– RECOMMENDED PRACTICERECOMMENDED PRACTICE
Pressure VesselsASME Section VIIIAPI RP520
Storage TanksAPI 620 & API 650 (< 2.5 psig / 0.172 bar-g)API 2000 VentingAPI 2521 & API 2523 Evaporation Loss
15 Psig [1.034 Bar-g]
7
ww
w.o
ri.m
ilano
.it
VENT VALVE SIZING AND VENT VALVE SIZING AND SELECTION STANDARDSSELECTION STANDARDS
ww
w.o
ri.m
ilano
.it
AGENDAAGENDA
• Background• Scope & Boundary Conditions of Standards• General Venting Overview• Required Outbreathing Venting Capacity• Required Inbreathing Venting Capacity• Sizing and Selection Example• Emergency Case Sizing• Production Testing• Final Notes
8
ww
w.o
ri.m
ilano
.itBACKGROUNDBACKGROUND
• The purpose of the API2000, EN 14015, and ISO28300 standards is to provide a method for and guidance to sizing and selecting venting devices for atmospheric storage tanks
• API2000 has been an industry standard worldwide since being published in 1952
• The European Union developed and released a similar standard based on industry studies (EN14015) in 2004
• ISO 28300 was released in 2008 with the intention that it would be adopted by countries, local regulators, manufacturers, and end users worldwide, replacing the current API 2000 and EN 14015 documents.
• The API committee is currently voting to adopt the ISO 28300 document as the new edition of API 2000.
ww
w.o
ri.m
ilano
.it
ISO 28300 DocumentISO 28300 Document
• Determination of Normal Venting Requirement using EN 14015 formulas
• Determination of Emergency Venting Requirements using API 2000 tables / formulas
• Inclusion of current API 2000 Normal Venting Requirement formulas in an informative Annex
• Production Testing updates, including a detailed definition of set pressure and a requirement for leakage testing
• Inert-Gas Blanketing guidance for flashback protection (includes instruction for use of flame arresters in conjunction with blanketing)
• Specific guidance for tanks with potentially flammable atmospheres (explosion prevention, blanketing, flame propagation through vent valves)
9
ww
w.o
ri.m
ilano
.it
SCOPE & BOUNDARY SCOPE & BOUNDARY CONDITIONSCONDITIONS
ww
w.o
ri.m
ilano
.it
ScopeScope
Both API 2000 and ISO 28300 share the same scope, as follows:
• Normal and emergency vapor venting requirements for aboveground liquid petroleum storage tanks
• Covers the causes of overpressure and vacuum, determination of venting requirements, means of venting, selection and installation of venting devices, and testing and marking of relief devices
• Can also be applied to tanks containing other liquids; however, sound engineering analysis and judgment must be used when applied to tanks containing other liquids
• Does NOT apply to external floating roof tanks
10
ww
w.o
ri.m
ilano
.itBoundary Conditions ComparisonBoundary Conditions Comparison
API 2000• Full vacuum through 1.034 barg• Aboveground tanks for liquid petroleum or petroleum products and
aboveground and underground refrigerated storage tanks• Fixed roof tanks• Tank volumes up to 28,618m3
• No insulation factor considered for regular venting (emergency only)EN 14015• -20 mbar through 500 mbar• Non-refrigerated tanks• Fixed roof tanks (with or without internal floating roofs)• No limit on tank volume• Insulation considered for regular and emergency ventingISO 28300• Full vacuum through 1.034 barg• Aboveground tanks for liquid petroleum or petroleum products and
aboveground and underground refrigerated storage tanks• Fixed roof tanks• No limit on tank volume• Insulation considered for regular and emergency venting
ww
w.o
ri.m
ilano
.it
GENERAL VENTING OVERVIEWGENERAL VENTING OVERVIEW
11
ww
w.o
ri.m
ilano
.itGeneral SizingGeneral Sizing
• When determining required flow capacities for a process the engineer / designer MUST take into consideration all potential causes of overpressure. Most processes simply take into accountthree cases of potential overpressure (as shown below).
ww
w.o
ri.m
ilano
.it
NORMAL VENTING: NORMAL VENTING: OUTBREATHING SIZINGOUTBREATHING SIZING
12
ww
w.o
ri.m
ilano
.it
API 2000API 2000Required Outbreathing Flow CapacityRequired Outbreathing Flow Capacity
Fluid Movement• Based on boiling point / flash point of liquid, and input flow rate• Required Flow Capacity (NCMH) = Pump In (m3/h) * X
• X = Liquid Factor from table at right
Thermal Effects• Based on Tank Volume, Boiling Point, and Flash Point of liquid• Use table as shown below
Total Required Outbreathing Flow Capacity• Sum of the Liquid Movement and Thermal
Effects
2.02Boiling Point < 148.9º C
2.02Flash Point < 37.8º C
1.01Boiling Point >= 148.9º C
1.01Flash Point >= 37.8º C
XFlash / Boiling Point
ww
w.o
ri.m
ilano
.it
EN14015 / ISO 28300EN14015 / ISO 28300Required Outbreathing Flow CapacityRequired Outbreathing Flow Capacity
Fluid Movement• Based on storage temperature and vapor pressure of liquid and input flow rate• Required Flow Capacity (NCMH) = Pump In (m3/h)
• For storage below 40ºC with a vapor pressure less than 5 kPa• EXCEPTION: For products stored above 40ºC or with a vapor pressure higher than
5kPA, increase the outbreathing by the evaporation rate
Thermal Effects• Based on installation latitude, tank volume, and insulation• Required Flow Capacity (NCMH) = Y*VTK
0.9*Ri
• Y = Latitude Factor (from table at right)• VTK = Tank Volume (m3)• Ri = Insulation Factor (separate formula)
Total Required Outbreathing Flow Capacity• Sum of the Liquid Movement and Thermal Effects
0.2Above 58º
0.25Between 42º and 58º
0.32Below 42º
YLatitude
13
ww
w.o
ri.m
ilano
.it
OUTBREATHING COMPARISON(Total Required Flow Capacity vs. Tank Volume)
0
500
1000
1500
2000
2500
3000
3500
10 16 79 159
31847
763
679
515
9023
8531
803975
4770
556563
597154
7949
953911
129
1271
914
309
1589
919078
2225
825438
2861
8
Tank Volume (Cubic Meters)
Requ
ired
Vent
ing
Cap
acity
(NCM
H)
API 2000 EN 14015 / ISO 28300
ww
w.o
ri.m
ilano
.it
NORMAL VENTING: NORMAL VENTING: INBREATHING SIZINGINBREATHING SIZING
14
ww
w.o
ri.m
ilano
.it
API 2000API 2000Required Inbreathing Flow CapacityRequired Inbreathing Flow Capacity
Fluid Movement• Based on boiling point, flash point of liquid, and output flow rate• Required Flow Capacity (NCMH) = Pump Out (BPH) * X
• X = Liquid Factor from table at right
Thermal Effects• Based on Tank Volume, Boiling Point, and Flash Point of liquid• Use table as shown below
Total Required Inbreathing Flow Capacity• Sum of the Liquid Movement and Thermal
Effects
0.94Boiling Point < 148.9º F
0.94Flash Point < 37.8º F
0.94Boiling Point >= 148.9º F
0.94Flash Point >= 37.8º F
XFlash / Boiling Point
ww
w.o
ri.m
ilano
.it
EN 14015 / ISO 28300EN 14015 / ISO 28300Required Inbreathing Flow CapacityRequired Inbreathing Flow Capacity
Fluid Movement• Based on output flow rate• Required Flow Capacity (NCMH) = Pump Out (m3/h)
Thermal Effects• Based on installation latitude, vapor pressure, average storage temperature, tank volume,
and insulation• Required Flow Capacity (NCMH) = C*VTK
0.7*Ri• C = Latitude / Vapor Pressure / Average Storage Temperature Factor (from table at right)• VTK = Tank Volume (m3)• Ri = Insulation Factor (separate formula)
Total Required Inbreathing Flow Capacity• Sum of the Liquid Movement and Thermal Effects
Vapor Pressure –Higher than Hexane or Unknown
Vapor Pressure –Hexane or Similar
Average Storage Temperature (º C)
C-Factor for Given Conditions
2.5
3
4
<25
4
5
6.5
>25
4
5
6.5
<25
4Above 58º
5Between 42º and 58º
6.5Below 42º
>25
Latitude
15
ww
w.o
ri.m
ilano
.it
INBREATHING COMPARISON(Total Required Flow Capacity vs. Tank Volume)
0
1000
2000
3000
4000
5000
6000
7000
10 16 79 15931
8477
636
795159
023
85318
039
75477
055
656359
7154
794995
3911
129
12719
1430
9158
9919
078222
5825
4382861
8
Tank Volume (Cubic Meters)
Requ
ired
Ven
ting
Capa
city
(NC
MH
)
API 2000 EN 14015 / ISO 28300
ww
w.o
ri.m
ilano
.it
WHY IS IT NECESSARY TO HAVE SO MUCH WHY IS IT NECESSARY TO HAVE SO MUCH VACUUM PROTECTION?VACUUM PROTECTION?
• Typical tank failures happen under vacuum conditions (implosion)
• Tank rupture under positive is less frequent due to the tank being designed properly for this condition
16
ww
w.o
ri.m
ilano
.it
SELECTION EXAMPLESELECTION EXAMPLE
ww
w.o
ri.m
ilano
.it
Example Process ConditionsExample Process Conditions
• API 650 Vertical Tank (not insulated)• Volume = 12,734 m3
• MAWP/MAWV = 20 mbar / -10 mbar• Pump In = 795 m3/h• Pump Out = 1272 m3/h• Texas Installation, Storing Hexane at 15º C• Utilize Model 1220A (Vent to Header)• Set Pressure = 10 mbar• Set Vacuum = 5 mbar
*This example was used in a presentation during an ISO Working Group meeting in Braunschweig, Germany
17
ww
w.o
ri.m
ilano
.itRequired Flow CapacityRequired Flow Capacity
API 2000• Outbreathing = 3,089 NCMH• Inbreathing = 2,671 NCMH
0
1000
2000
3000
4000
5000
6000
7000
Req
uire
d Fl
ow C
apac
ity (N
CM
H)
API2000 - Outbreathing
API2000 - Inbreathing
ISO28300/EN14015 - Outbreathing
ISO28300/EN14015 - Inbreathing
FLUID MOVEMENTTHERMAL EFFECTS
EN14015 / ISO 28300• Outbreathing = 2,407 NCMH• Inbreathing = 6,246 NCMH
ww
w.o
ri.m
ilano
.it
Groth Model 1220A Rated Flow CapacitiesSet Pressure = 10 mbar, flow at 100% Overpressure
• 6” = 3,100 NCMH• 8” = 4,880 NCMH• 10” = 7,960 NCMH• 12” = 10,300 NCMH
Set Vacuum = 5 mbar, flow at 100% Overpressure• 6” = 1,450 NCMH• 8” = 2,350 NCMH• 10” = 3,810 NCMH• 12” = 5,390 NCMH
• Thus, a tank sized per API2000 would require one (1) 10” Model 1220A while a tank sized per EN 14015 / ISO 28300 would require two (2) 10” Model 1220A
• An interesting note is that a valve selected per the API 2000 standard is dictated by the required outbreathing flow capacity while a valve selected per the EN14015 / ISO 28300 standard is dictated by the required inbreathing flow capacity
Valve SelectionValve Selection
Required Outbreathing Flow Capacity
API 2000 = 3,089 NCMH
EN 14015 / ISO 28300 = 2,407 NCMH
Required Inbreathing Flow Capacity
API 2000 = 2,671 NCMH
EN 14015 / ISO 28300 = 6,246 NCMH
18
ww
w.o
ri.m
ilano
.it
EMERGENCY CASE SIZINGEMERGENCY CASE SIZING
ww
w.o
ri.m
ilano
.it
API 2000 & ISO 28300API 2000 & ISO 28300Required Emergency Flow CapacityRequired Emergency Flow Capacity
• The sizing for emergency relief valves is equivalent in both API2000 and ISO28300
• Sizing is based on tank volume, flash point / boiling point of liquid, insulation, latent heat of vaporization, wetted surface area, design pressure, and temperature of relieving vapor.
• One of two methods can be used to calculate required emergency flow capacity; one which requires little knowledge of the process (typically conservative), and one which requires very detailed knowledge of the process and typically requires much less flow capacity
19
ww
w.o
ri.m
ilano
.it
PRODUCTION TESTINGPRODUCTION TESTING
ww
w.o
ri.m
ilano
.it
PRODUCTION TESTINGPRODUCTION TESTING
• Previous editions of API 2000 and EN 14015 were not specific in the testing required at time of manufacture
ISO 28300
• All products must be tested for set pressure and seat leakage at the factory, prior to shipment
• Set pressure definition is now included
• Seat Leakage testing parameters defined
20
ww
w.o
ri.m
ilano
.it
FINAL NOTESFINAL NOTES
ww
w.o
ri.m
ilano
.it
FINAL NOTESFINAL NOTES
• Current edition of API 2000 standard will change this year. The ISO 28300 standard is being voted to be adopted as the next edition of API 2000
• Changes to the methods used to calculate required flow capacities(both inbreathing and outbreathing)
• API2000 “Determination of Venting Requirements” (currently Section 4.3) included as an INFORMATIVE Annex A in the ISO28300 standard.
• Existing installations WILL NOT be required to change installed vent valves due to changes in the standard, however, the API andISO committees highly recommend an evaluation of all installations to determine if they are at risk.
21
ww
w.o
ri.m
ilano
.itFINAL NOTESFINAL NOTES
• Production testing section was included to identify the tests that MUST be executed at the factory
• Leakage testing is now a required test, Groth has conducted this test on ALL valves for several years.
• Definition of set pressure is now published
ww
w.o
ri.m
ilano
.it
WHY NEEDED???WHY NEEDED???