Returns to Style using Style Research’s Markets Analyzer Hong Kong End March 2011.

36
Returns to Style using Style Research’s Markets Analyzer Hong Kong End March 2011

Transcript of Returns to Style using Style Research’s Markets Analyzer Hong Kong End March 2011.

Page 1: Returns to Style using Style Research’s Markets Analyzer Hong Kong End March 2011.

Returns to Styleusing Style Research’s

Markets Analyzer

Hong Kong

End March 2011

Page 2: Returns to Style using Style Research’s Markets Analyzer Hong Kong End March 2011.

International Experience

• Style Investing works• Value and Small Cap works long term• Best Value Markets – Japan and Korea• Most markets have small cap premium• High beta stocks do not generally perform well

Page 3: Returns to Style using Style Research’s Markets Analyzer Hong Kong End March 2011.

Overview

• Value works long term– like in other markets– Low Accruals best over 10 years – 5.1% pa xs return

• Small cap performs better than large cap– Like other markets

• High Beta does not work– like other markets

• Nothing works consistently– Top 10 inconsistent over different time periods

Page 4: Returns to Style using Style Research’s Markets Analyzer Hong Kong End March 2011.

Approach

• Benchmark = market– All stocks with market cap of USD 100 million

• Analysis after sector adjustment– Factor screen within sectors– Eliminates sector bias

• Rebalanced every 6 months– Repriced every month– Includes dividends

Page 5: Returns to Style using Style Research’s Markets Analyzer Hong Kong End March 2011.

Value

Page 6: Returns to Style using Style Research’s Markets Analyzer Hong Kong End March 2011.

Book to Price

Page 7: Returns to Style using Style Research’s Markets Analyzer Hong Kong End March 2011.

Dividend Yield

Page 8: Returns to Style using Style Research’s Markets Analyzer Hong Kong End March 2011.

Earnings Yield

Page 9: Returns to Style using Style Research’s Markets Analyzer Hong Kong End March 2011.

Cashflow Yield

Page 10: Returns to Style using Style Research’s Markets Analyzer Hong Kong End March 2011.

Sales to Price

Page 11: Returns to Style using Style Research’s Markets Analyzer Hong Kong End March 2011.

EBITDA to Price

Page 12: Returns to Style using Style Research’s Markets Analyzer Hong Kong End March 2011.

Growth

Page 13: Returns to Style using Style Research’s Markets Analyzer Hong Kong End March 2011.

Return on Equity

Page 14: Returns to Style using Style Research’s Markets Analyzer Hong Kong End March 2011.

Growth in Earnings per Share

Page 15: Returns to Style using Style Research’s Markets Analyzer Hong Kong End March 2011.

Income to Sales

Page 16: Returns to Style using Style Research’s Markets Analyzer Hong Kong End March 2011.

Sales Growth

Page 17: Returns to Style using Style Research’s Markets Analyzer Hong Kong End March 2011.

Forecast Earnings

Page 18: Returns to Style using Style Research’s Markets Analyzer Hong Kong End March 2011.

Forecast Earnings Revisions

Page 19: Returns to Style using Style Research’s Markets Analyzer Hong Kong End March 2011.

Other

Page 20: Returns to Style using Style Research’s Markets Analyzer Hong Kong End March 2011.

Market Cap

Page 21: Returns to Style using Style Research’s Markets Analyzer Hong Kong End March 2011.

Beta

Page 22: Returns to Style using Style Research’s Markets Analyzer Hong Kong End March 2011.

Price Momentum – 6 months

Page 23: Returns to Style using Style Research’s Markets Analyzer Hong Kong End March 2011.

Price Momentum – 12 months

Page 24: Returns to Style using Style Research’s Markets Analyzer Hong Kong End March 2011.

Quality

Page 25: Returns to Style using Style Research’s Markets Analyzer Hong Kong End March 2011.

Low Accrual

Page 26: Returns to Style using Style Research’s Markets Analyzer Hong Kong End March 2011.

Debt to Equity

Page 27: Returns to Style using Style Research’s Markets Analyzer Hong Kong End March 2011.

Stability of Earnings Growth

Page 28: Returns to Style using Style Research’s Markets Analyzer Hong Kong End March 2011.

Sustainable Growth Rate

Page 29: Returns to Style using Style Research’s Markets Analyzer Hong Kong End March 2011.

Stability of Sales Growth

Page 30: Returns to Style using Style Research’s Markets Analyzer Hong Kong End March 2011.

Stability of Forecast Earnings

Page 31: Returns to Style using Style Research’s Markets Analyzer Hong Kong End March 2011.

Returns to Style – last 10 yearsQuality and Value works!

SA, annualised

Page 32: Returns to Style using Style Research’s Markets Analyzer Hong Kong End March 2011.

10 year XS returns

Page 33: Returns to Style using Style Research’s Markets Analyzer Hong Kong End March 2011.

Weight: Market Cap, Rebal 6 mths

Xs Return 5.1% pa

T/over 78% pa

Page 34: Returns to Style using Style Research’s Markets Analyzer Hong Kong End March 2011.

Weight: Market Cap, Rebal 3 mths

Xs Return 5.4% pa

T/over 94% pa

Page 35: Returns to Style using Style Research’s Markets Analyzer Hong Kong End March 2011.

Weight: Total Earnings, Rebal 6 mths

Xs Return 5.5% pa

T/over 102% pa

Page 36: Returns to Style using Style Research’s Markets Analyzer Hong Kong End March 2011.

overview

• Value works long term– like in other markets– Low Accruals best over 10 years

• Small cap works better than large cap– Like other markets

• High Beta does not work– like other markets

• Nothing works consistently– Top 10 inconsistent over different time periods– Rebalance and weighting schemes make a difference