Random Simplicial Complexes - University of Oxford...Random Simplicial Complexes CAT-School 2015...

33
Random Simplicial Complexes CAT - School 2015 Oxford 9 / 9 / 2015 Omer Bobrowski Duke University

Transcript of Random Simplicial Complexes - University of Oxford...Random Simplicial Complexes CAT-School 2015...

Page 1: Random Simplicial Complexes - University of Oxford...Random Simplicial Complexes CAT-School 2015 Oxford 9/9/2015 Omer Bobrowski Duke University Part II Random Geometric Complexes Contents

Random Simplicial Complexes

CAT-School 2015

Oxford

9/9/2015

Omer BobrowskiDuke University

Page 2: Random Simplicial Complexes - University of Oxford...Random Simplicial Complexes CAT-School 2015 Oxford 9/9/2015 Omer Bobrowski Duke University Part II Random Geometric Complexes Contents

Part IIRandom Geometric Complexes

Page 3: Random Simplicial Complexes - University of Oxford...Random Simplicial Complexes CAT-School 2015 Oxford 9/9/2015 Omer Bobrowski Duke University Part II Random Geometric Complexes Contents

Contents

Random Geometric Graphs

Random Geometric Complexes

Definitions

Probabilistic Ingredients

Page 4: Random Simplicial Complexes - University of Oxford...Random Simplicial Complexes CAT-School 2015 Oxford 9/9/2015 Omer Bobrowski Duke University Part II Random Geometric Complexes Contents

Contents

Random Geometric Graphs

Random Geometric Complexes

Definitions

Probabilistic Ingredients

Page 5: Random Simplicial Complexes - University of Oxford...Random Simplicial Complexes CAT-School 2015 Oxford 9/9/2015 Omer Bobrowski Duke University Part II Random Geometric Complexes Contents

Contents

Random Geometric Complexes

Definitions

Probabilistic Ingredients

Random Geometric Graphs

Page 6: Random Simplicial Complexes - University of Oxford...Random Simplicial Complexes CAT-School 2015 Oxford 9/9/2015 Omer Bobrowski Duke University Part II Random Geometric Complexes Contents

RANDOM GEOMETRIC GRAPHS Omer Bobrowski

Random Graphs and Neworks

Random Geometric Graphs (RGG)

- undirected graph

• Vertices: P – either the binomial (Xn ) or the Poisson (Pn ) process

• Edges: for every x,y P , x~y iff d(x,y)r

Triangle condition:

Drawback – more difficult to analyze

Common application:

Wireless networks – transceivers with transmission range r are deployed in a region

r

Page 7: Random Simplicial Complexes - University of Oxford...Random Simplicial Complexes CAT-School 2015 Oxford 9/9/2015 Omer Bobrowski Duke University Part II Random Geometric Complexes Contents

RANDOM GEOMETRIC GRAPHS Omer Bobrowski

Connectivity

From here on:

• - the uniform distribution ( )

• = volume of a d-dimensional unit ball

Connectivity threshold:

Other distributions – compact support same results (up to constants)

Compare to Erdős–Rényi :

Theorem [Penrose, 97]

Page 8: Random Simplicial Complexes - University of Oxford...Random Simplicial Complexes CAT-School 2015 Oxford 9/9/2015 Omer Bobrowski Duke University Part II Random Geometric Complexes Contents

RANDOM GEOMETRIC GRAPHS Omer Bobrowski

Cycles in Random Geometric Graphs

From here on:

Acyclicity threshold:

In Erdős–Rényi:

Partial explanation:

The triangle condition “easier” to form tringles in G(n,r) than in G(n,p)

Theorem [?]

very different

Page 9: Random Simplicial Complexes - University of Oxford...Random Simplicial Complexes CAT-School 2015 Oxford 9/9/2015 Omer Bobrowski Duke University Part II Random Geometric Complexes Contents

RANDOM GEOMETRIC GRAPHS Omer Bobrowski

Induced Subgraphs

Induced subgraphs of G(n,r):

All the graphs of the form G(S,r) where S Xn

G = a graph on k vertices

NG = the number induced subgraphs of G(n,r) that are isomorphic to G

Q: What is E{NG}?

a

b

c

d e

f

a

b

c

d a

b

c

d

Page 10: Random Simplicial Complexes - University of Oxford...Random Simplicial Complexes CAT-School 2015 Oxford 9/9/2015 Omer Bobrowski Duke University Part II Random Geometric Complexes Contents

RANDOM GEOMETRIC GRAPHS Omer Bobrowski

The Expected Number of Subgraphs

Recall:

Example – triangles (k=3):

Theorem

acyclicity

Page 11: Random Simplicial Complexes - University of Oxford...Random Simplicial Complexes CAT-School 2015 Oxford 9/9/2015 Omer Bobrowski Duke University Part II Random Geometric Complexes Contents

RANDOM GEOMETRIC GRAPHS Omer Bobrowski

Giant Component

Recall: L = largest connected component

Similar to Erdős–Rényi:

Continuum percolation

Theorem [Penrose & Pisztora, 96; Penrose 03]

Page 12: Random Simplicial Complexes - University of Oxford...Random Simplicial Complexes CAT-School 2015 Oxford 9/9/2015 Omer Bobrowski Duke University Part II Random Geometric Complexes Contents

Contents

Random Geometric Graphs

Random Geometric Complexes

Probabilistic Ingredients

Definitions

Page 13: Random Simplicial Complexes - University of Oxford...Random Simplicial Complexes CAT-School 2015 Oxford 9/9/2015 Omer Bobrowski Duke University Part II Random Geometric Complexes Contents

DEFINITIONS Omer Bobrowski

The Čech Complex

Take a set of vertices P in a metric space (0-simplexes)

Draw balls with radius r/2

Intersection of 2 balls an edge (1-simplex)

Intersection of 3 balls a triangle (2-simplex)

Intersection of k balls a (k-1)-simplex

Page 14: Random Simplicial Complexes - University of Oxford...Random Simplicial Complexes CAT-School 2015 Oxford 9/9/2015 Omer Bobrowski Duke University Part II Random Geometric Complexes Contents

DEFINITIONS Omer Bobrowski

The Nerve Lemma

Lemma [Borsuk, 48]

Page 15: Random Simplicial Complexes - University of Oxford...Random Simplicial Complexes CAT-School 2015 Oxford 9/9/2015 Omer Bobrowski Duke University Part II Random Geometric Complexes Contents

DEFINITIONS Omer Bobrowski

The Vietoris - Rips Complex

Take a set of vertices P in a metric space (0-simplexes)

Draw balls with radius r/2

Intersection of 2 balls an edge (1-simplex)

All pairwise intersections of 3 balls a triangle (2-simplex)

All pairwise intersections of k balls a (k-1)-simplex

Page 16: Random Simplicial Complexes - University of Oxford...Random Simplicial Complexes CAT-School 2015 Oxford 9/9/2015 Omer Bobrowski Duke University Part II Random Geometric Complexes Contents

DEFINITIONS Omer Bobrowski

Some Useful Facts

Even if it is possible for to have simplexes

in any dimension

Still: for (Nerve Lemma)

Rips “approximates” Čech (de-Silva & Ghrist, 07):

The 1-skeleton of both is the same geometric graph

Page 17: Random Simplicial Complexes - University of Oxford...Random Simplicial Complexes CAT-School 2015 Oxford 9/9/2015 Omer Bobrowski Duke University Part II Random Geometric Complexes Contents

Contents

Random Geometric Graphs

Definitions

Probabilistic Ingredients

Random Geometric Complexes

Page 18: Random Simplicial Complexes - University of Oxford...Random Simplicial Complexes CAT-School 2015 Oxford 9/9/2015 Omer Bobrowski Duke University Part II Random Geometric Complexes Contents

RANDOM GEOMETRIC COMPLEXES Omer Bobrowski

Overview

Goal:

Study the limiting behavior of and as ,

Three main regimes:

Subcritical Critical Supercritical

~ vertex degree

Page 19: Random Simplicial Complexes - University of Oxford...Random Simplicial Complexes CAT-School 2015 Oxford 9/9/2015 Omer Bobrowski Duke University Part II Random Geometric Complexes Contents

RANDOM GEOMETRIC COMPLEXES Omer Bobrowski

Connected Components (H0)

Random Geometric Graphs Theory (Penrose, Bollobás and others)

Subcritical ( ):

Critical ( ):

Supercritical ( ):

Connectivity threshold - :

(dust)

(continuum percolation)

Page 20: Random Simplicial Complexes - University of Oxford...Random Simplicial Complexes CAT-School 2015 Oxford 9/9/2015 Omer Bobrowski Duke University Part II Random Geometric Complexes Contents

RANDOM GEOMETRIC COMPLEXES Omer Bobrowski

The Subcritical Regime ( 0 )

Complex is very sparse

Homology is dominated by minimal & isolated cycles

Čech:

Rips:

k-cycle empty (k+1)-simplex k+2 vertices

k-cycle empty cross-polytope 2k+2 vertices

k=1

3 vertices

k=2

4 vertices

k=1

4 vertices

k=2

6 vertices

Page 21: Random Simplicial Complexes - University of Oxford...Random Simplicial Complexes CAT-School 2015 Oxford 9/9/2015 Omer Bobrowski Duke University Part II Random Geometric Complexes Contents

RANDOM GEOMETRIC COMPLEXES Omer Bobrowski

Betti Numbers Approximation

Consider Čech the complex

Define:

Claim:

We can show:

(sparse regime)

Page 22: Random Simplicial Complexes - University of Oxford...Random Simplicial Complexes CAT-School 2015 Oxford 9/9/2015 Omer Bobrowski Duke University Part II Random Geometric Complexes Contents

RANDOM GEOMETRIC COMPLEXES Omer Bobrowski

Similarly to subgraph counting:

Where:

Theorem [Kahle, 2011]

The Limiting Mean

Page 23: Random Simplicial Complexes - University of Oxford...Random Simplicial Complexes CAT-School 2015 Oxford 9/9/2015 Omer Bobrowski Duke University Part II Random Geometric Complexes Contents

RANDOM GEOMETRIC COMPLEXES Omer Bobrowski

Limit Theorems

The Betti numbers:

- not independent

Poisson Approximation

The Central Limit Theorem (CLT)

Page 24: Random Simplicial Complexes - University of Oxford...Random Simplicial Complexes CAT-School 2015 Oxford 9/9/2015 Omer Bobrowski Duke University Part II Random Geometric Complexes Contents

RANDOM GEOMETRIC COMPLEXES Omer Bobrowski

Limiting Distribution

Theorem [Kahle & Meckes, 2013]

Proofs use Stein’s method (limits of sums of “weakly dependent” variables)

Čech:

Page 25: Random Simplicial Complexes - University of Oxford...Random Simplicial Complexes CAT-School 2015 Oxford 9/9/2015 Omer Bobrowski Duke University Part II Random Geometric Complexes Contents

RANDOM GEOMETRIC COMPLEXES Omer Bobrowski

The Subcritical Regime ( 0 )

Exact limit values are known, as well as limit distributions

For example:

• Čech:

• Rips:

Phase transition - appearance:

Behavior is independent of f (constants might be different)

Čech: Rips:

Kahle, 2011Kahle & Meckes, 2013

B & Mukherjee, 2015

Page 26: Random Simplicial Complexes - University of Oxford...Random Simplicial Complexes CAT-School 2015 Oxford 9/9/2015 Omer Bobrowski Duke University Part II Random Geometric Complexes Contents

RANDOM GEOMETRIC COMPLEXES Omer Bobrowski

The Critical Regime ( l )

Cycles are neither minimal nor isolated

Inequality:

No longer true that:

Scale is known:

Law of large number & central limit theorems are proved

Limiting constants are unknown

Euler characteristic (later)

Behavior is independent of f and supp(f)

Kahle, 2011B. & Adler, 2014

Yogeshwaran, Subag & Adler, 2014B. & Mukherjee, 2015

Page 27: Random Simplicial Complexes - University of Oxford...Random Simplicial Complexes CAT-School 2015 Oxford 9/9/2015 Omer Bobrowski Duke University Part II Random Geometric Complexes Contents

RANDOM GEOMETRIC COMPLEXES Omer Bobrowski

The Subcritical Regime ( )

Highly connected, almost everything is covered

decays from (critical) to (coverage)

Recall: supp(f)=d-dimensional torus

Phase transition – “vanishing”:

Threshold: (connectivity threshold = logn)

NSW, 2008Kahle, 2011

B. & Mukherjee, 2015B. & Weinberger, 2015

Page 28: Random Simplicial Complexes - University of Oxford...Random Simplicial Complexes CAT-School 2015 Oxford 9/9/2015 Omer Bobrowski Duke University Part II Random Geometric Complexes Contents

RANDOM GEOMETRIC COMPLEXES Omer Bobrowski

The Expected Betti Numbers

Using Morse Theory, we can show in addition that:

Theorem [B. & Weinberger, 15]

Page 29: Random Simplicial Complexes - University of Oxford...Random Simplicial Complexes CAT-School 2015 Oxford 9/9/2015 Omer Bobrowski Duke University Part II Random Geometric Complexes Contents

RANDOM GEOMETRIC COMPLEXES Omer Bobrowski

sub-critical critical super-critical

Summary

(connectivity) (coverage)

B & Kahle –Topology of Random Geometric Complexes: a survey

Page 30: Random Simplicial Complexes - University of Oxford...Random Simplicial Complexes CAT-School 2015 Oxford 9/9/2015 Omer Bobrowski Duke University Part II Random Geometric Complexes Contents

RANDOM GEOMETRIC GRAPHS Omer Bobrowski

Topological Inference

Objective: Study the homology of an unknown space from a set of samples

Example:

Problem: How should we choose r ?

Larger sample Smaller radius

Page 31: Random Simplicial Complexes - University of Oxford...Random Simplicial Complexes CAT-School 2015 Oxford 9/9/2015 Omer Bobrowski Duke University Part II Random Geometric Complexes Contents

RANDOM GEOMETRIC COMPLEXES Omer Bobrowski

More General Manifolds

- closed manifold, with

- a probability density function, with

- iid random samples, generated from f

Similar to the torus , but here – showing coverage is not enough

Morse Theory helps (later)

Theorem [B & Mukherjee]

Page 32: Random Simplicial Complexes - University of Oxford...Random Simplicial Complexes CAT-School 2015 Oxford 9/9/2015 Omer Bobrowski Duke University Part II Random Geometric Complexes Contents

RANDOM GEOMETRIC COMPLEXES Omer Bobrowski

Clique complexes - if :

Geometric Complexes - if:

Geometric vs. Clique Complexes

Different degrees coexist

Different degrees are almost separated

Degree:

(past connectivity)

0(way before connectivity)

Page 33: Random Simplicial Complexes - University of Oxford...Random Simplicial Complexes CAT-School 2015 Oxford 9/9/2015 Omer Bobrowski Duke University Part II Random Geometric Complexes Contents

Next:Extensions and Applications