Rainer Kaltenbaek - custom.cvent.com · Ljubljana Science goals II/III 09.04.2019 NASA Fund. Phys.,...

28
A quantum physics platform in space Rainer Kaltenbaek

Transcript of Rainer Kaltenbaek - custom.cvent.com · Ljubljana Science goals II/III 09.04.2019 NASA Fund. Phys.,...

Page 1: Rainer Kaltenbaek - custom.cvent.com · Ljubljana Science goals II/III 09.04.2019 NASA Fund. Phys., Washington Gravitational wave background SCIENCE CASE DECOHERENCE EXPERIMENTS SPACE

A quantum physics platform in spaceRainer Kaltenbaek

Page 2: Rainer Kaltenbaek - custom.cvent.com · Ljubljana Science goals II/III 09.04.2019 NASA Fund. Phys., Washington Gravitational wave background SCIENCE CASE DECOHERENCE EXPERIMENTS SPACE

FMFLjubljana

Science goals I/III

09.04.2019 NASA Fund. Phys., Washington

Quantum to ClassicalTransition (?)

SCIENCE CASE DECOHERENCE OPEN/CLOSED CONCL. THANKSEXPERIMENTS CRITICALSPACE NEW CONF. NEWMAQRO

Page 3: Rainer Kaltenbaek - custom.cvent.com · Ljubljana Science goals II/III 09.04.2019 NASA Fund. Phys., Washington Gravitational wave background SCIENCE CASE DECOHERENCE EXPERIMENTS SPACE

FMFLjubljana

Science goals II/III

09.04.2019 NASA Fund. Phys., Washington

Gravitational wavebackground

SCIENCE CASE DECOHERENCE OPEN/CLOSED CONCL. THANKSEXPERIMENTS CRITICALSPACE NEW CONF. NEWMAQRO

LIGO

Page 4: Rainer Kaltenbaek - custom.cvent.com · Ljubljana Science goals II/III 09.04.2019 NASA Fund. Phys., Washington Gravitational wave background SCIENCE CASE DECOHERENCE EXPERIMENTS SPACE

FMFLjubljana

Science goals III/III

09.04.2019 NASA Fund. Phys., Washington

Quantum gravity?New physics?

SCIENCE CASE DECOHERENCE OPEN/CLOSED CONCL. THANKSEXPERIMENTS CRITICALSPACE NEW CONF. NEWMAQRO

A. Belenchia et al. PRD 98, 126009 (2018)

Page 5: Rainer Kaltenbaek - custom.cvent.com · Ljubljana Science goals II/III 09.04.2019 NASA Fund. Phys., Washington Gravitational wave background SCIENCE CASE DECOHERENCE EXPERIMENTS SPACE

FMFLjubljana

Collapse models

09.04.2019 NASA Fund. Phys., Washington

Introduce mechanism todestroy superpositions

SCIENCE CASE DECOHERENCE OPEN/CLOSED CONCL. THANKSEXPERIMENTS CRITICALSPACE NEW CONF. NEWMAQRO

A. Bassi & H. Ulbricht, J. Phys.: Conf. Series 504, 012023 (2014)

Page 6: Rainer Kaltenbaek - custom.cvent.com · Ljubljana Science goals II/III 09.04.2019 NASA Fund. Phys., Washington Gravitational wave background SCIENCE CASE DECOHERENCE EXPERIMENTS SPACE

FMFLjubljana

Collapse models

09.04.2019 NASA Fund. Phys., Washington

Introduce mechanism todestroy superpositions

Clear deviations expected:m > 109 – 1010 amu

SCIENCE CASE DECOHERENCE OPEN/CLOSED CONCL. THANKSEXPERIMENTS CRITICALSPACE NEW CONF. NEWMAQRO

Page 7: Rainer Kaltenbaek - custom.cvent.com · Ljubljana Science goals II/III 09.04.2019 NASA Fund. Phys., Washington Gravitational wave background SCIENCE CASE DECOHERENCE EXPERIMENTS SPACE

FMFLjubljana

Coupling to the environment

09.04.2019 NASA Fund. Phys., Washington

SCIENCE CASE DECOHERENCE OPEN/CLOSED CONCL. THANKSEXPERIMENTS CRITICALSPACE NEW CONF. NEWMAQRO

Page 8: Rainer Kaltenbaek - custom.cvent.com · Ljubljana Science goals II/III 09.04.2019 NASA Fund. Phys., Washington Gravitational wave background SCIENCE CASE DECOHERENCE EXPERIMENTS SPACE

FMFLjubljana

Coupling to the environment

09.04.2019 NASA Fund. Phys., Washington

SCIENCE CASE DECOHERENCE OPEN/CLOSED CONCL. THANKSEXPERIMENTS CRITICALSPACE NEW CONF. NEWMAQRO

Page 9: Rainer Kaltenbaek - custom.cvent.com · Ljubljana Science goals II/III 09.04.2019 NASA Fund. Phys., Washington Gravitational wave background SCIENCE CASE DECOHERENCE EXPERIMENTS SPACE

FMFLjubljana

Coupling to the environment

09.04.2019 NASA Fund. Phys., Washington

SCIENCE CASE DECOHERENCE OPEN/CLOSED CONCL. THANKSEXPERIMENTS CRITICALSPACE NEW CONF. NEWMAQRO

Page 10: Rainer Kaltenbaek - custom.cvent.com · Ljubljana Science goals II/III 09.04.2019 NASA Fund. Phys., Washington Gravitational wave background SCIENCE CASE DECOHERENCE EXPERIMENTS SPACE

FMFLjubljana

Experimental tests

09.04.2019 NASA Fund. Phys., Washington

104 atomic mass units

SCIENCE CASE DECOHERENCE OPEN/CLOSED CONCL. THANKSEXPERIMENTS CRITICALSPACE NEW CONF. NEWMAQRO

S. Eibenberger et al., PCCP 15, 14696 (2013)

Page 11: Rainer Kaltenbaek - custom.cvent.com · Ljubljana Science goals II/III 09.04.2019 NASA Fund. Phys., Washington Gravitational wave background SCIENCE CASE DECOHERENCE EXPERIMENTS SPACE

FMFLjubljana

How massive can our particles be?

09.04.2019 NASA Fund. Phys., Washington

Heavier particles require longer free fall

record Drop tower? SPACE?

SCIENCE CASE DECOHERENCE OPEN/CLOSED CONCL. THANKSEXPERIMENTS CRITICALSPACE NEW CONF. NEWMAQRO

Page 12: Rainer Kaltenbaek - custom.cvent.com · Ljubljana Science goals II/III 09.04.2019 NASA Fund. Phys., Washington Gravitational wave background SCIENCE CASE DECOHERENCE EXPERIMENTS SPACE

FMFLjubljana

Why go to space?

09.04.2019 NASA Fund. Phys., Washington

Rockets/parabolic flightsminutes of free fall

SCIENCE CASE DECOHERENCE OPEN/CLOSED CONCL. THANKSEXPERIMENTS CRITICALSPACE NEW CONF. NEWMAQRO

Page 13: Rainer Kaltenbaek - custom.cvent.com · Ljubljana Science goals II/III 09.04.2019 NASA Fund. Phys., Washington Gravitational wave background SCIENCE CASE DECOHERENCE EXPERIMENTS SPACE

FMFLjubljana

Why go to space?

09.04.2019 NASA Fund. Phys., Washington

Drop tower, Einstein elevatorup to 9s free fall

SCIENCE CASE DECOHERENCE OPEN/CLOSED CONCL. THANKSEXPERIMENTS CRITICALSPACE NEW CONF. NEWMAQRO

Page 14: Rainer Kaltenbaek - custom.cvent.com · Ljubljana Science goals II/III 09.04.2019 NASA Fund. Phys., Washington Gravitational wave background SCIENCE CASE DECOHERENCE EXPERIMENTS SPACE

FMFLjubljana

Progress in space technology

09.04.2019 NASA Fund. Phys., Washington

GAIA (Global AstrometricInterferometer for Astrophysics) LISA Pathfinder

(launched 03/12/2015)

Herschel & Planck Telescopes

SCIENCE CASE DECOHERENCE OPEN/CLOSED CONCL. THANKSEXPERIMENTS CRITICALSPACE NEW CONF. NEWMAQRO

Page 15: Rainer Kaltenbaek - custom.cvent.com · Ljubljana Science goals II/III 09.04.2019 NASA Fund. Phys., Washington Gravitational wave background SCIENCE CASE DECOHERENCE EXPERIMENTS SPACE

FMFLjubljana

Progress in space technology

09.04.2019 NASA Fund. Phys., Washington

SCIENCE CASE DECOHERENCE OPEN/CLOSED CONCL. THANKSEXPERIMENTS CRITICALSPACE NEW CONF. NEWMAQRO

Page 16: Rainer Kaltenbaek - custom.cvent.com · Ljubljana Science goals II/III 09.04.2019 NASA Fund. Phys., Washington Gravitational wave background SCIENCE CASE DECOHERENCE EXPERIMENTS SPACE

FMFLjubljana

MAQRO – suggested experiments

09.04.2019 NASA Fund. Phys., Washington

Free expansion of the wavefunction Matter-wave interference

SCIENCE CASE DECOHERENCE OPEN/CLOSED CONCL. THANKSEXPERIMENTS CRITICALSPACE NEW CONF. NEWMAQRO

Page 17: Rainer Kaltenbaek - custom.cvent.com · Ljubljana Science goals II/III 09.04.2019 NASA Fund. Phys., Washington Gravitational wave background SCIENCE CASE DECOHERENCE EXPERIMENTS SPACE

FMFLjubljana

Before QPPF study: passive radiative cooling

09.04.2019 NASA Fund. Phys., Washington

+ Low vibrations+ “unlimited” lifetime+ Outgassing to space

- Electron bombardment- Not easily testable- Outgassing plume

SCIENCE CASE DECOHERENCE OPEN/CLOSED CONCL. THANKSEXPERIMENTS CRITICALSPACE NEW CONF. NEWMAQRO

A. Pilan Zanoni et al. Appl. Therm. Egin. 107, 689 (2016)

Page 18: Rainer Kaltenbaek - custom.cvent.com · Ljubljana Science goals II/III 09.04.2019 NASA Fund. Phys., Washington Gravitational wave background SCIENCE CASE DECOHERENCE EXPERIMENTS SPACE

FMFLjubljana

Open to space environment(?) I/II

09.04.2019 NASA Fund. Phys., Washington

J.I. Thorpe et al, J. Phys.: Conf. Ser. 840, 012007 (2017)

SCIENCE CASE DECOHERENCE OPEN/CLOSED CONCL. THANKSEXPERIMENTS CRITICALSPACE NEW CONF. NEWMAQRO

Page 19: Rainer Kaltenbaek - custom.cvent.com · Ljubljana Science goals II/III 09.04.2019 NASA Fund. Phys., Washington Gravitational wave background SCIENCE CASE DECOHERENCE EXPERIMENTS SPACE

FMFLjubljana

Open to space environment(?) I/II

09.04.2019 NASA Fund. Phys., Washington

J.I. Thorpe et al, J. Phys.: Conf. Ser. 840, 012007 (2017)

SCIENCE CASE DECOHERENCE OPEN/CLOSED CONCL. THANKSEXPERIMENTS CRITICALSPACE NEW CONF. NEWMAQRO

Page 20: Rainer Kaltenbaek - custom.cvent.com · Ljubljana Science goals II/III 09.04.2019 NASA Fund. Phys., Washington Gravitational wave background SCIENCE CASE DECOHERENCE EXPERIMENTS SPACE

FMFLjubljana

Open to space environment(?) II/II

09.04.2019 NASA Fund. Phys., Washington

Ion densitywake behind disk

Electron densityno wake

Plasma density behind 1.5m diam. disk

SCIENCE CASE DECOHERENCE OPEN/CLOSED CONCL. THANKSEXPERIMENTS CRITICALSPACE NEW CONF. NEWMAQRO

Page 21: Rainer Kaltenbaek - custom.cvent.com · Ljubljana Science goals II/III 09.04.2019 NASA Fund. Phys., Washington Gravitational wave background SCIENCE CASE DECOHERENCE EXPERIMENTS SPACE

FMFLjubljana

New cooling & vacuum approach

09.04.2019 NASA Fund. Phys., Washington

Payload inside a box• getter film • outgassing to space(?)

Passive cooling (V-grooves)+ hydrogen sorption cooler=> 20K

SCIENCE CASE DECOHERENCE OPEN/CLOSED CONCL. THANKSEXPERIMENTS CRITICALSPACE NEW CONF. NEWMAQRO

Page 22: Rainer Kaltenbaek - custom.cvent.com · Ljubljana Science goals II/III 09.04.2019 NASA Fund. Phys., Washington Gravitational wave background SCIENCE CASE DECOHERENCE EXPERIMENTS SPACE

FMFLjubljana

New orbit configuration

09.04.2019 NASA Fund. Phys., Washington

Ariane 6direct launch to L2

SCIENCE CASE DECOHERENCE OPEN/CLOSED CONCL. THANKSEXPERIMENTS CRITICALSPACE NEW CONF. NEWMAQRO

Page 23: Rainer Kaltenbaek - custom.cvent.com · Ljubljana Science goals II/III 09.04.2019 NASA Fund. Phys., Washington Gravitational wave background SCIENCE CASE DECOHERENCE EXPERIMENTS SPACE

FMFLjubljana

State-of-the-art experimental results

09.04.2019 NASA Fund. Phys., Washington

Coherent scattering into cavityBig step towards ground-state cooling

U. Delic et al., PRL 122, 123602 (2019) - Aspelmeyer groupD. Windey et al., PRL 122, 123601 (2019) - Novotny group

U. Delic et al., PRL 122, 123602 (2019)

SCIENCE CASE DECOHERENCE OPEN/CLOSED CONCL. THANKSEXPERIMENTS CRITICALSPACE NEW CONF. NEWMAQRO

Page 24: Rainer Kaltenbaek - custom.cvent.com · Ljubljana Science goals II/III 09.04.2019 NASA Fund. Phys., Washington Gravitational wave background SCIENCE CASE DECOHERENCE EXPERIMENTS SPACE

FMFLjubljana

Critical issues I/II

09.04.2019 NASA Fund. Phys., Washington

To avoid gas collisions:Pressure: ≲ 𝟏𝟎−𝟏𝟑Pa

(for fused silica)

SCIENCE CASE DECOHERENCE OPEN/CLOSED CONCL. THANKSEXPERIMENTS CRITICALSPACE NEW CONF. NEWMAQRO

Page 25: Rainer Kaltenbaek - custom.cvent.com · Ljubljana Science goals II/III 09.04.2019 NASA Fund. Phys., Washington Gravitational wave background SCIENCE CASE DECOHERENCE EXPERIMENTS SPACE

FMFLjubljana

Critical issues II/II

09.04.2019 NASA Fund. Phys., Washington

Particle loadingPaul Trapp

Particles coated on

surface

Charge / mass selector

UV source

Guiding electrodes

TBD Batch selector

• Desorb particles• Trap & characterize• Guide to experiment• Discharge• Optically trap

SCIENCE CASE DECOHERENCE OPEN/CLOSED CONCL. THANKSEXPERIMENTS CRITICALSPACE NEW CONF. NEWMAQRO

Page 26: Rainer Kaltenbaek - custom.cvent.com · Ljubljana Science goals II/III 09.04.2019 NASA Fund. Phys., Washington Gravitational wave background SCIENCE CASE DECOHERENCE EXPERIMENTS SPACE

FMFLjubljana

Critical issues II/II

09.04.2019 NASA Fund. Phys., Washington

Particle loadingPaul Trapp

Particles coated on

surface

Charge / mass selector

UV source

Guiding electrodes

TBD Batch selector

Option: Replace surface coating

with a MEMS modulator

• Desorb particles• Trap & characterize• Guide to experiment• Discharge• Optically trap

SCIENCE CASE DECOHERENCE OPEN/CLOSED CONCL. THANKSEXPERIMENTS CRITICALSPACE NEW CONF. NEWMAQRO

Page 27: Rainer Kaltenbaek - custom.cvent.com · Ljubljana Science goals II/III 09.04.2019 NASA Fund. Phys., Washington Gravitational wave background SCIENCE CASE DECOHERENCE EXPERIMENTS SPACE

FMFLjubljana

Conclusions

• Tests of macroscopic quantum physics as a ”future science idea“

• Performed CDF study

• overall feasibility confirmed but 2 critical issues need addressing

• Key technologies need focused technology development

• CDF proposed possible launch by ~2038

• May be possible to speed up to ~2034

09.04.2019 NASA Fund. Phys., Washington

SCIENCE CASE DECOHERENCE OPEN/CLOSED CONCL. THANKSEXPERIMENTS CRITICALSPACE NEW CONF. NEWMAQRO

Page 28: Rainer Kaltenbaek - custom.cvent.com · Ljubljana Science goals II/III 09.04.2019 NASA Fund. Phys., Washington Gravitational wave background SCIENCE CASE DECOHERENCE EXPERIMENTS SPACE

FMFLjubljana

THANKS

09.04.2019 NASA Fund. Phys., Washington

MQES study (ESA contract Po P5401000400)NanoTrapS project (ESA contract4000105799/127NL/Cbi)QPPF CDF Study 2018

Austrian Research Promotion Agency (MAQROsteps, Project no. 840089)(ULE-Cavity-Access, Project no. 854036)(QuantumShield, Project no. 865996)

QTSpace COST action (CA15220)10/16 – 10/2026 countries

www.maqro-mission.org

SCIENCE CASE DECOHERENCE OPEN/CLOSED CONCL. THANKSEXPERIMENTS CRITICALSPACE NEW CONF. NEWMAQRO

QPPF CDF Study – Final Report (2019): http://sci.esa.int/future-missions-department/61074-cdf-study-report-qppf/