Problem

3
Problem: pipe 3”, SCH 40, L=3m. Calculate moments and forces at restraints? When node B, C, G are not modeled as bend (elbow): - The result as per structural analysis: - The result as per Ceasar II:

description

prob

Transcript of Problem

  • Problem: pipe 3, SCH 40, L=3m. Calculate moments and forces at restraints?

    When node B, C, G are not modeled as bend (elbow):

    - The result as per structural analysis:

    - The result as per Ceasar II:

  • Point Node Point Node

    A 10 E 50

    B 20 G 60

    C 30 H 70

    D 40 RESTRAINTS REPORT: Loads On Restraints CASE 1 (SUS) W+F1

    NODE FX N. FY N. FZ N. MX

    N.m.

    MY

    N.m.

    MZ

    N.m.

    10 0 -734 0 0 0 0 Rigid +Y

    50 0 -2084 0 0 0 0 Rigid +Y

    70 0 -497 0 0 0 0 Rigid +Y

    GLOBAL ELEMENT FORCES EXTENDED REPORT: Forces on Elements CASE 1 (SUS) W+F1

    NODE

    Axial

    Force

    N.

    Shear

    Force

    N.

    Bending

    Moment

    N.m.

    Torsion

    Moment

    N.m.

    FX N. FY N. FZ N. MX

    N.m.

    MY

    N.m.

    MZ

    N.m.

    10 0 734 0 0 -0 734 -0 0 0 0

    20 -0 71 2415 0 0 -71 0 2415 -0 0

    20 71 0 2415 0 -0 71 -0 -2415 0 -0

    30 260 0 2415 -0 0 260 0 2415 -0 0

    30 0 260 2415 0 -0 -260 -0 -2415 0 -0

    40 -0 591 1138 -0 0 591 0 1138 -0 0

    40 0 1255 1138 0 -0 -1255 -0 -1138 0 -0

    50 -0 1421 870 -0 0 1421 0 -870 -0 0

    50 0 663 870 0 -0 663 -0 870 0 -0

    60 -0 497 0 -0 0 -497 0 0 0 0

    60 0 497 0 0 0 497 0 0 -0 -0

    70 0 497 0 -0 0 497 -0 -0 0 0

    They are same.

    When node B, C, G are modeled as bend (elbow):

    The result as per Ceasar II is quite different.

    RESTRAINTS REPORT: Loads On Restraints

    CASE 1 (SUS) W+F1

  • NODE FX N. FY N. FZ N. MX

    N.m. MY

    N.m. MZ

    N.m.

    10 0 -730 0 0 0 0 Rigid +Y

    50 0 -2071 0 0 0 0 Rigid +Y

    70 0 -497 0 0 0 0 Rigid +Y GLOBAL ELEMENT FORCES EXTENDED REPORT: Forces on Elements CASE 1 (SUS) W+F1

    NODE Axial

    Force N.

    Shear Force

    N.

    Bending Moment

    N.m.

    Torsion Moment

    N.m. FX N. FY N. FZ N.

    MX N.m.

    MY N.m.

    MZ N.m.

    10 0 730 0 0 -0 730 -0 -0 0 -0

    18 -0 80 2384 -0 0 -80 0 2384 -0 0

    18 -0 80 2384 0 0 80 0 -2384 0 -0

    19 -50 50 2390 -0 -0 -70 0 2390 -0 -0

    19 50 50 2390 0 0 70 0 -2390 0 -0

    20 -60 0 2392 -0 -0 -60 -0 2392 -0 0

    20 60 0 2392 0 0 60 -0 -2392 0 0

    28 246 0 2392 -0 -0 246 0 2392 -0 -0

    28 -246 0 2392 0 -0 -246 -0 -2392 0 0

    29 181 181 2383 -0 0 256 0 2383 -0 -0

    29 -181 181 2383 0 0 -256 0 -2383 0 0

    30 0 266 2362 0 -0 266 -0 2362 -0 -0

    30 0 266 2362 -0 -0 -266 -0 -2362 0 0

    40 -0 585 1135 0 0 585 0 1135 -0 -0

    40 0 1249 1135 -0 -0 -1249 -0 -1135 0 0

    50 -0 1414 862 0 0 1414 0 -862 -0 -0

    50 0 657 862 -0 -0 657 -0 862 0 0

    58 -0 504 57 0 0 -504 0 -57 -0 -0

    58 -0 504 57 -0 -0 504 0 57 0 0

    59 0 494 0 -23 0 -494 -0 -16 0 17

    59 -0 494 0 23 -0 494 0 16 -0 -17

    60 0 484 56 0 0 -484 -0 0 -0 56

    60 0 484 56 -0 0 484 -0 -0 0 -56

    70 0 497 0 0 0 497 0 0 -0 -0