Pro-Life -Motion for Recon

8/12/2019 Pro-Life -Motion for Recon

1/23

!


2/23

#

"#$"%&'( )* +,-).&/0 1.*$2343456270

"#$%&'&" ()*) +,) -./..0122345 12 675 8*593:5+6 12 675 *58; 56 ?=)>

.28956:2638* @""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""@5:;?*:1 56 ?=)>

.28956:2638* @""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""@873=3883+5 ?==3?+45 12 D95H3+?*3?+9> 3+4)I8?DJ> K$%$LB %$M%$&$BN$C OP LN& +ANL,BAQ 8%$&LC$BN> ?66E) *34?*:1 H) *356 ?=)>

$23434562780 "#$%&'&" ()*) +,) -./T0U

71+) 8?G;361 +) 1471?> V*)> 5@$W'NL#$9$W%$NA%P> 56 ?=)>

.28956:2638* @""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""@*5E+?=:1 V) 547?X5Y> H: 56 ?=)>

$23434562780 "#$%&'&" ()*) +,) -./FZU

71+) 8?G;361 +) 1471? V*)> 56 ?=)>.28956:2638*

@"""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""@989) 2*?+43941 9) 6?6?: ?+: H?*3? 25++E

4) 6?6?:> S,% NK$[&$Q#$&> NK$L% M,&N$%LNP ABC NK$%$&N ,S NK$ 23=383+1 81965*36E>$23434562780

"#$%&'&" ()*) +,) -./F\T122345 12 675 8*593:5+6 12 675 *58;

.28956:2638* @""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""@!"#$%&'( !*&%&!!&+(, '#-+./0+1 &+2314564575895: ;< %#"+/ =(%(>"&0#1 ?7(@5AB9CD5 .C45A9E41 ?8: C8 F54 6547E8?GA?6?AC9


3/23

&

=#0+ '#" "(2#+,&.("/0+

2#=( +#L1 !(0&0+(", > OP ABC NK%,']K NK$ 'BC$%&L]B$C W,'B&$Q> ABC 'BN, N

7,B,%AOQ$ 4,'%N> OP RAP ,S H,NL,B S,% *$W,B&LC$%ANL,B ,S NK$ :$WL&L,B CAN-.TF> A W,MP ,S RKLWK RA& %$W$L#$C OP 8$NLNL,B$%& ,B ?M%LQ T/> -.TF> K%$&M$WNS'QQP &NAN$ NKAN^

8*52?61*E 96?65H5+6

_KLQ$ NK$ 4,B&NLN'NL,B L& NK$ &'M%$[$ QAR ,S NK$ QABC> LN L& B,N N, O$AMMQL$C LB A &$QS"$BWQ,&$C> &$QS"%$S$%$BNLAQ [ABB$% CL#,%W$C S%,W,B&LC$%ANL,B&) 6K$ 4,B&NLN'NL,B LN&$QS> $&M$WLAQQP LB LN& M%$promote the common good and in Article VIII Sec. 1 thereof, recognizes a higher

&NABCA%C ,S %L]KN %$A&,B N, RKLWK AQQ QAR& ABC AWN& ,S ],#$%B[$BN ['&QAR ,% AWN ,S ],#$%B[$BN NKAN C,$& B,N W,BS,%[ N, NKL& &NABCA%C ,S %L'BW,B&NLN'NL,BAQ> ABC W,'%N& A%$ B,N ,BQP $[M,R$%$C O'N [ABCAN$C N, BQAR& ,% AWN& ,S ],#$%B[$BN)

?993(+H5+6 12 5**1*

H,#ABN& K$%$LB NA`$ $@W$MNL,B N, NKL& &M$WLSLW M,%NL,B LB NK7,B,%AOQ$ 4,'%N CAN$C ?M%LQ U> -.TF^

With resp$WN N, NK$ A%]'[$BN NKAN NK$ *7 =AR#L,QAN$& BAN'%AQ QAR> &'SSLW$ LN N, &AP NKAN NK$ 4,'%N C,$& B,C'QP %$W,]BLa$ LN A& A Q$]AQ OA&L& S,% 'MK,QCLB] ,%LB#AQLCANLB] A QAR) 1'% ,BQP ]'LC$M,&N L& NK$ 4,B&NLN'NL,B)

_KLQ$ $#$%P QAR $BAWN$C OP [AB $[ABAN$C S%,[ RKAN L&M$%W$L#$C A& BAN'%AQ QAR> NK$ 4,'%N L& B,N ,OQL]$C N, &$$ LSA &NAN'N$> $@$W'NL#$ L&&'ABW$ ,% ,%CLBABW$ L& LB W,BS,%[LNPN, LN) 6, O$]LB RLNK> LN L&B,N $BAWN$C OP AB AWW$MNAOQ$ Q$]LNL[AN$ O,CP) H,%$,#$%>BAN'%AQ QAR& A%$ [$%$ NK,']KN& ABC B,NL,B& ,BLBK$%$BN %L]KN& $&M,'&$C OP NK$,%L&N&> MKLQ,&,MK$%&ABC NK$,Q,]L&N&) 6K$ b'%L&N& ,S NK$ MKLQ,&,MKLWAQ &WK,,Q A%LBN$%$&N$C LB NK$ QAR A& AB AO&N%AWNL,B> %ANK$% NKAB LAWN'AQ QAR ,S NK$ MA&N ,% M%$&$BN)

;BQ$&&> A BAN'%AQ %L]KN KA& O$$B N%AB&S,%[$C LBN, AR%LNN$B QAR> LN WABB,N &$%#$ A& A OA&L& N, &N%L`$ C,RB A

QAR) 3B.29; ?* @A6:4BA6 LN RA& $@MQALB$C NKAN NK$ 4,'%N L& B,N C'NO,'BC N, $@A[LB$ $#$%P QAR ,% AWNL,B ABC RK$NK$% LNW,BS,%[& RLNK O,NK NK$ 4,B&NLN'NL,B ABC BAN'%AQ QAR)*ANK$%> BAN'%AQ QAR L& N, O$ '&$C &MA%LB]QP ,BQP LB NK$ [,&NM$W'QLA% ,S WL%W'[&NABW$& LB#,Q#LB] %L]KN& LBK$%$BN N[AB RK$%$ B, QARis applicable. (8A]$ T.."T.TJ


4/23

'

6K$ S,%$],LB]> RLNK AQQ C'$ %$&M$WN> $#,`$& AB 'BS,%N'BAN$ [L&'BC$%&NABBAN'%AQ QAR L& ABC CL&%$]A%C& 8KLQLMMLB$ W,B&NLN'NL,BAQ KL&N,%R$QQ A& NK$ 4,B&NLN'NL,B LN&$QS)

(*1;+:9 21* *541+93:5*?631+

3)

_LNK AQQ C'$ %$&M$WN> NK$ M%,B,'BW$[$BN NKAN NK$ 9'M%$[$Court C,$& B,N C'QP %$W,]BLa$ cBAN'%AQ QARd A& A Q$]AQOA&L& S,% 'MK,QCLB] ,% LB#AQLCANLB] A QAR) 1'% ,BQP]'LC$M,&N L& NK$Constitution is contradictory to PhilippineW,B&NLN'NL,BAQ KL&N,%P ABC b'%L&M%'C$BW$)

33)

_LNK AQQ C'$ %$&M$WN> NK$ M%,B,'BW$[$BN NKAN NK$ 9'M%$[$Court C,$& B,N C'QP %$W,]BLa$ cBAN'%AQ QARd A& A Q$]AQOA&L& S,% 'MK,QCLB] ,% LB#AQLCANLB] A QAR) 1'% ,BQP]'LC$M,&N L& NK$Constitution is itself contradictory to theM%,#L&L,B& ,S NK$ 4,B&NLN'NL,B)

333)

6K$ WA&$ AN OA% L& AB AMM%,M%LAN$ &LN'ANL,B N, AMMQP BANQAR)

1'% A%]'[$BN& A%$ A& S,QQ,R&^

3)

_LNK AQQ C'$ %$&M$WN> NK$ M%,B,'BW$[$BN NKAN NK$ 9'M%$[$Court C,$& B,N C'QP %$W,]BLa$ cBAN'%AQ QARd A& A Q$]AQOA&L& S,% 'MK,QCLB] ,% LB#AQLCANLB] A QAR) 1'% ,BQP]'LC$M,&N L& NK$Constitution is contradictory to PhilippineW,B&NLN'NL,BAQ KL&N,%P ABC b'%L&M%'C$BW$)

(;7 @;972D2 E5;73 4382=F GA82D9=5C2: 3G2 6A3;7A= =AH 46 A3

=2A83 IJ :2>4845680 A== 5F HG4>GH2 26;D27A32: 46 5;7 $2343456A6: HA8 822D46B=C 4B6572:


5/23

(

W,B&L&N$BNQP LB#,`$C BAN'%AQ QAR A& OA&L& S,% NK$L% C$WL&L,B& ABC"#&,.#/0 1)2) T INK$ 4,'%N> RKLQ$ SLBCLB] NKAN B, S,%W$ RA& '&$C A]ALB&N NAMM$QQABN> %$W,]BLa$C NK$ %L]KN A]ALB&N S,%W$C W,BS$&&L,B& A& MQARJ>"#&,.# /0 134&$ - I%$W,]BLaLB] NKAN NK$ BAN'%AQ QAR S,%OLC& `LQQLB]J5&4%.# 6%."7%.%,,%'#)* 8'90 /0 :%&92(#)0 INK$ $Q$[$BN ,S M%,[L&$ A& NK$ OA&L& ,S W,BN%AWAB LBSQ'$BW$ ,S BAN'%AQ QARJ>52'%.2 5#;&(%2. "2(< =#;#$#(> /0 =&?($ &@ 1,,#2.)F I$&N,MM$Q A& MA%N ,S BAN'%AQ QARJ>A? =&' /0 8,%. / I,B BAN'%AQ QAR LB [A%LNL[$ QARJ>8'+# B#)$2$# C)$2$# &@ D2(9%)& "2-%..2e I,B NK$ M%,KLOLNL,B ,S 'Bb'&N $B%LWK[$BN NK$ BAN'%AQ QARJ>5&'92-& /0 C. B(%4?'2. -#. "?#4.& > E?2' 50 F2-2G Z ICL&&$BNLB],MLBL,B ,S V'&NLW$ 8$%S$WN, RKLWK %$W,]BLa$& NKAN BAN'%AQ QAR %,ONALB$C NK%,']K AB LQQ$]AQ &$A%WK ABC &$La'%$ A& LBAC[L&&LOQ$J>F2?(#. /0 5%)2U IW,BW'%%LB] ,MLBL,B %$W,]BLaLB] NK$ M%,KLOLNL,B ,S RA%& ,S A]]%$&&L,B ABC BAN'%AQ QARJ> 1')2> /0 B7# H&2(- &@ :%(#9$&() &@ $7# D2$%&'2. :#/#.&,;#'$

=&;,2'> \ I%$W,]BLaLB] NK$ BAN'%AQ QAR OA&L& ,S BAN'%AQ ,OQL]ANL,B&>W,'%N S,'BC NKAN B, BAN'%AQ ,OQL]ANL,B RA& LB#,Q#$C LB NK$ WA&OA%J>"7%.%,,%'# =&;;#(9%2. 2'- 8'-?)$(%2. H2'< /0 D151IJK58L T. I,B NK$BAN'%AQ QAR OA&L& ,S W$%NALB QAO,% W,C$ M%,#L&L,B&J>:# F2 F.2'2 /0 1.42 TT I,B NK$%,Q$ ,S W,B&WL$BW$ LB b'CLWLAQ C$WL&L,B&J>52(M?%'& /0 8'$#(;#-%2$# 1,,#..2$#=&?($ T- I,B NK$ BAN'%AQ QAR OA&L& ,S M%,M$%NP %L]KN&J> ABCJ'%G%-# N2.#) +#2.$> 2'-+#)&?(9#) =&(,&(2$%&' /0 B%$2'K8 A[,B]&N ,NK$%&)

-) 6K$ [,&N %$W$BN C$WL&L,B LB RKLWK NKL& 4,'%N N,'WK$C ,B BANC)$(2-2 /0 C)9(%$&( *IK 3B NK$ &ALCdecision, this Court referred to an authority higherthan the state to which man is accountable. While the case specifically refers toreligious rights, the phrase authority higher than the state is broad enough to$BW,[MA&& ABP [,%AQ ,%C$% RKLWK M%$"$@L&N& NKAN ,S NK$ 9NAN$)

0) 2'%NK$%[,%$> V'&NLW$ 4,B&'$Q, EfA%$&"Santiagos opinion in the sameWA&$ L& N%$BWKABN ABC LBWL&L#$^ LN WKA%AWN$%La$C NK$ [$ABLB]> M,Ob$WNL#$ 'BL#$%&AQ &NABCA%C OA&$C ,B %L]KN %$A&,B NKAN W'N& A

,#$%%LC$& CLSS$%$BW$& ,S %$QL]L,'& ,% W'QN'%AQ O$QL$S&)

F) 3N ['&N O$ $[MKA&La$C NKAN RK$B NKL& 7,B,%AOQ$ 9'M%$[$ 4LB#,`$C NK$ BAN'%AQ QAR LB NK$ AO,#$ WA&$&> LN RA& B,N %$S$%%LB] N, A%$QL]L,'& A%]'[$BN O'N LB&N$AC &N$[[$C S%,[ NK$ W,%%$WN 'BC$%&NABC1 G.R. No. L-47104, November 20, 1940.2 106 SCRA 325 (1981).3 G.R. No. L-26371, September 30, 1969.4 344 SCRA 679 (2000).5 G.R. No. L-10195, December 29, 1916.6 G.R. No. L-48137, October 4, 1943.7 G.R. No. L-824 , January 14, 19488 G.R. No. L-409, January 30, 19479 G.R. No. L-13667, April 29, 1960.10 G.R. No. L-50402, August 19, 1982.11 G.R. No. L-57883, March 12, 1982.12 G.R. No. 72078, June 27, 1994.13 G.R. No. 126619, December 20, 2006.14 A.M. No. P-02-1651 June 22, 2006.


6/23

)

7,B,%AOQ$ 9'M%$[$ 4,'%N NKAN NK$%$ A%$ LBC$$C ,Ob$WNL#$ &NABCA%C& ACK$%$C N, A%L&LB] S%,[ NK$ '&$ ,S %L]KN %$A&,B)

L;73G27D5720 &63276A3456A= =AH 5FHG4>G 3G2 $G4=4994628 48 5B64M28 3G2 84B64F4>A6>2 5F6A3;7A= =AH 46 72=A3456 35 3G2 DA33275F 74BG38*

/) 1B$ WAB $A&LQP &$$ NKL& LB NK$ W%$ANL,B ,S NK$ ;BLN$C +ANLA& L[M,%NABN C,W'[$BN& ,B K'[AB %L]KN& &'WK A& NK$ T\FU ;+ :$WQA%A7'[AB *L]KN&> NK$ T\ee 3BN$%BANL,BAQ 4,#$BABN ,B 5W,B,[LW> 9,WLAQ ABC

*L]KN&> ABC NK$ 3BN$%BANL,BAQ 4,#$BABN ,B 4L#LQ ABC 8,QLNLWAQ *,NK$%&)T/ 6K'&> ,B$ OA&L& ,S LBN$%BANL,BAQ QAR L& &ALC N, O$ NK$ BAN'%RKLWK ,'% W,BW$MN& ,S N;8 >5B268 IA& R$QQ A&27BA 5D628J L& %,,N$C)

e) It must be considered that in the Philippine legal system, weW,B&LC$%$C NK$ ;BLN$C +ANL,B& LB&N%'[$BN& N, RKLWK NK$ 8KLQLMMLBBA[$QP NK$ ;:7* RKLWK R$ KA#$ %'Q$C LB &$#$%AQ WA&$& A& OLBCLB] Philippines, the ICCPR and the ICESCR.Te 6KL& L& &L]BLSLWABN O$WA'&$ LB NK$ WA+#,?4.%9 /) N2'-%32'42>2' >TZ LN RA& %'Q$C NKAN C'%LB] NK$ LBN$%%$]B'[ O$NR$

T\Z0 4,B&NLN'NL,B ABC NK$ 8%,#L&L,BAQ I2%$$C,[J 4,B&NLN'NL,B> $#$B NK,']K [AP B,N LB#,`$ NK$ $@WQ'&L,BA%P %L]KN 'BC$% NK$ 34594*> ABC ;+:7* %$[ALB$C LB $SS$WN)

Z) 9'WK L& &L]BLSLWABN O$WA'&$ LN $@M%$&&$& NK$ N%'NK AO,'NQ$]AQ &P&N$[^ NKAN ,'% W,BW$MN ,S K'[AB %L]KN& &N$[ S%,[ BAN'%AQ QAR);BL#$%&AQ :$WQA%ANL,B ,S 7'[AB *L]KN& L& $&&$BNLAQQP AB $[O,CL[$BN%L]KN&) 6KL& WAB O$ &$$B S%,[ NK$ M%$A[OQ$ NK$%$,S> A&&$%NLB] N

LBAQL$BAOQ$^ g%$W,]BLNL,B ,S NK$ LBK$%$BN CL]BLNP ABC ,S NK$ $h'AQ ABC,S AQQ [$[O$%& ,S NK$ K'[AB SA[LQP L& NK$ S,'BCANL,B ,S S%$$C,[> b'&NLW$ ALB NK$ R,%QC)g +,N$ NKAN NK$ 4,[[L&&L,B ,B 7'[AB *L]KN&> A NK$B &NABCLBNK$ ;BLN$C +ANL,B&> RA& W,B&NLN'N$C N, 'BC$%NA`$ NK$ R,%` ,S M%$M$#$BN'AQQP O$WA[$ NK$ ;+:7* KAC NK$ 8KLQLMMLB$& A& A [$[O$%)TU

U) 1'% LBN$%BANL,BAQ QAR &P&N$[> ,S RKLWK NK$ 8KLQLMMLB$&%$W,]BLa$& BAN'%AQ QAR A& A OA&L& S,% C$N$%[LBLB] RK$NK$% ,NK$% L

!(

*+,-./0 1+234 506787-0 96.2.324 :06+;.?72;7@724 A: B3C !D'E)F4 #! *+


7/23

E

B,%[& I&'WK A& N%$ANL$&J A%$ #AQLC> A SAWN W,B&NABNQP %$W,]BLa$C4,'%N O'N B,R &$$[LB]QP &$N A&LC$ OP NK$ M%$&$BN [$[O$%& ,S 9'M%$[$ 4,'%N)

(;7 F5;6:46B G48357C 48 729=232H43G 6A3;7A= =AH 72F2726>28*

\) ?Q&,> S,% NK$ 7,B,%AOQ$ 9'M%$[$ 4,'%N N, &AP NKAN BAN'%AQ QARmere NK,']KN& ABC B,NL,B& ,B LBK$%$BN %L]KN& $&M,'&$C OP NK$,%L&N&>ABCtheologists (sic) is to ignore the meaning of natural law, the role it played inNK$C%ASNLB] ,S ,'% 4,B&NLN'NL,B> ABC NK$ MKLQ,&,MKLWAQ S,'BCANL,B& 'MW,B&NLN'NL,BAQ &P&N$[ L& OA&$C) 3N L& A& LS NK$ M%,#L&L,B& ,S ,'% 4,B,'% QAR&J KA#$ B, MKLQ,&,MKP> A%$ RLNK,'N KL&N,%P> ABC KA& A& W,BN$@

T.) 8KLQLMMLB$W,B&NLN'NL,BAQL&[ RA& K$A#LQP LBSQ'$BW$C OP ?[$%LWAB W,B&NLN'NL,B4;86A3;7A=483 ,%L$BNANL,B KAC AQ%$ACP O$$B CL&W'&&$C LB MA%A]%AMK& $2343456)-. 6K$ T\0/> T\Z0> ABC T\UZ 4,B&NLN'NL,B& ,S NK$ 8KLQLMMLB$& LBW,NK$ RKLWK L& $&&$BNLAQQP AB $[O,CL[$BN ,S BAN'%AQ %-T 6K$ T\UZ

4,B&NLN'NL,B $B'[$%AN$& ,NK$% LB&NABW$& ,S ACK$%$BW$ N, BAN'%AQ QANK$ M%,&W%LMNL,B A]ALB&N A]]%$&&L#$ RA%> NK$ M%$&$%#ANL,B ,S NK$ ,S NK$ $B#L%,B[$BN> A[,B] ,NK$%&)--

TT) ?BC LN ],$& ,B)The acknowledged Brains of the PhilippineRevolution, lawyer Apolinario Mabini has in his Decalogue-0 A M,R$%S'Q BAN'%AQ QARLBSQ'$BW$> C$&MLN$ LN& S%$h'$BN [$BNLon of God. In addition, it appears MabinisM$%&M$WNL#$ L& NKAN NK$ AOLQLNP N, CL&W$%B O$NR$$B ],,C ABC $#Lconscience of Man, but is a product both of Gods providing him discernment and

L[M,&LB] 'M,B KL[ AB ,OQL]ANL,B> A& R$QQ A& NK$ M%,C'WN ,S KL& ,RB %$A&M$%S$WNL,B K'[ABLNP &$$[& N, %$h'L%$ B$$C& NK$ AMMQLWANL,B ,S %ANNALB[$BN> A& &$$B OP NK$ QLB$ IAQO$LN AC[LNN$CQP [$Q,C%A[ANLWJ C$Philippines a Kingdom of Reason and Justice.

T-) 3BN$%$&NLB]ly, the Philippines national hero, Jose Rizal, in hisProspectus for a Colegio Moderno, recommended that natural law be taught so asto S,%[ ABC $C'WAN$ P,'B] [$B ,S ],,C SA[LQP ABC [$AB& LB AWW,%CABW$ RLNKC$[ABC& ,S [,C$%B NL[$& ABC WL%W'[&NABW$&. Rizals draft curriculum for what he

19 Preamble, Malolos Constitution of 1899.20 See Separate Opinion of J. Reynato Puno in Republic v. Sandiganbayan , G.R. No. 104768,July 21, 2003.21 See Sales v. Sandiganbayan , G.R. No. 143802, November 16, 2001, citing Allado v. Diokno ,G.R. No. 113630, May 5, 1994.## 5004 O38 0$7K6


8/23

F

believed would be the essential Modern College included education on natural LawN, O$ AO&,Q'N$QP [ABCAN,%P S,% $#$%P,B$)-F

T0) Aguinaldos inaugural address-/ &$$[& N, KA#$ A &L]BLSLWABN BAN'%AQAR NK$[$ N, LN> MA%NLW'QA%QP LB QL]KN ,S NK$ SAWN NKAN NK$ ACC%$&most of the paragraphs contain some form of reference to it. His mention of just andwise precepts to which we owe blind obedience seems to have some kind ofW,BB,NANL,B N, QAR& KL]K$% NKAB M,&LNL#$ QAR) 7L& [$BNL,B ,S NK$ solidarities and eternal truths also carries the same interpretation, while the lineregarding intelligence and hearts perfectly in accord could be a reference to right%$A&,B ABC LBN$QQ$WN> ABC W,B&$h'$BNQP LN& AOLQLNP N, C$N$%[LB$ BAN

TF) 7$BW$> V'&NLW$ 8'B, ILB+#,?4.%9 /)0 N2'-%32'42>2' J RA&W,[MQ$N$QP W,%%$WN LB &APLB] NKAN^

In sum, natural law and natural rights are not%$QLW NK$,%L$& S,% AWAC$[LW CL&W'&&L,B> O'N KA#$ KACW,B&LC$%AOQ$ AMMQLWANL,B ABC LBSQ'$BW$) +AN'%AQ QARABC BAN'%AQ %L]KN& NK$,%L$& KA#$ MQAP$C AB L[M,%NABN%,Q$ LB NK$ :$WQA%ANL,B ,S 3BC$M$BC$BW$> NK$ ?O,QLNL,B IABNL"&QA#$%PJ [,#$[$BN> ABC MA%N& ,S NK$

[,C$%B 4L#LQ *L]KN& [,#$[$BN) 3B WKA%]LB] +AaLand Japanese leaders with crimes againsthumanity at the end of the Second World War, ?QQL$C N%LO'BAQ& LB T\F/ LB#,`$C NK$ N%ACLNL,BAQW,BW$MN ,S BAN'%AQ QAR N, ,#$%%LC$ NK$ C$S$B&$ NKANNK,&$ WKA%]$C KAC ,BQP O$$B ,O$PLB] NK$ QAR& ,SNK$ %$]L[$& NK$P &$%#$C) =L`$RL&$> BAN'%AQ QAR>albeit called by another name such as substantivedue process which is grounded on reason andSAL%B$&&> KA& &$%#$C A& Q$]AQ &NABCA%C S,%LBN$%BANL,BAQ QAR> W$BN'%L$& ,S C$#$Q,M[$BN LB NK$5B]QL&K W,[[,B QAR> ABC W$%NALB A&M$WN& ,S American constitutional law.-e

(;7 >56>293 5F G;DA6 74BG38 48


9/23


10/23

!D

NK$ LBN$%M%$NANL,B ,% AMMQLWANL,B ,S QAR&> LN L& M%$&'[$C NKANintended right and justice to prevail, thus making reference to an objective order of%L]KN LBC$M$BC$BN ,S R%LNN$B QAR&)

TZ) 6K'&> LN WAB O$ &ALC NKAN NK$ 8KLQLMMLB$ 4,B&NLN'NL,B IA8KLQLMMLB$ Q$]AQ &P&N$[ A& A RK,Q$J LB&NLN'NL,BAQLa$& BAN'%AQ QAR N

TU) Given this Honorable Courts history of invoking the natural law asOA&L& S,% LN& C$WL&L,B&> A& $@$[MQLSL$C OP NK$ WA&$& WLN$C AOC,WN%LB$ ,S83A72 :2>48480SJ 8$NLNL,B$%& %$&M$WNS'QQP &'O[LN NKAN NK$%$ L&S,% LN N, C$WLC$ NK$ WA&$ AN OA% OA&$C ,B BAN'%AQ QAR)

T\) 3N L& WQ$A% S%,[ NK$ S,%$],LB] CL&W'&&L,B NKAN B,N ,BQP7,B,%AOQ$ 4,'%N AW`B,RQ$C]$C NK$ $@L&N$BW$ ,S BAN'%AQ QARi BAN'%AQ QAformed the basis for several of this Honorable Courts decisions. PetitL,B$%& S'%NK$%&'O[LN NKAN BAN'%AQ QAR> LB SAWN> S,%[& NK$ S,'BCANL,B ,S NK$ 8KLQLMM

33)

_LNK AQQ C'$ %$&M$WN> NK$ M%,B,'BW$[$BN NKAN NK$ 9'M%$[$

Court C,$& B,N C'QP %$W,]BLa$ cBAN'%AQ QARd A& A Q$]AQOA&L& S,% 'MK,QCLB] ,% LB#AQLCANLB] A QAR) 1'% ,BQP]'LC$M,&N L& NK$Constitution is itself contradictory to theM%,#L&L,B& ,S NK$ 4,B&NLN'NL,B)

%289432 3G2 72=A34?2=C =4D432: 95H27 5F 3G2 ,@ @;972D2E5;73 T>5D9A72: 35 5;7U5657AA8280 HG4>G H2D2634562: 46 5;7 923434560HG4>G 5;7 @;972D2 E5;734B6572:*

-.) 3N ['&N O$ B,N$C NKAN $#$B LS NK$ ;9 4,B&NLN'NL,B C,$& B,N KAM%,#L&L,B &L[LQA% N, ?%NLWQ$ X333 9$WNL,B T ,S NK$ 8KLQLMMLB$ 4,B&NL

W,'%N& N, C$N$%[LB$ RK$NK$% ,% B,N A ]%A#$ AO'&$ ,S CL&W%$NL,B KA& O$OP ABP O%ABWK ,% LB&N%'[$BNAQLNP ,S ],#$%B[$BN> NK$ ;9 9'M%$[$ 4,'%N KA,WWA&L,B&> C$WLC$C WA&$& OA&$C ,B BAN'%AQ QAR> &'WK A& LBEA=:27 ?* +;== >0e

&( 57?+.-?+.- =C 1036


11/23

!!

EG4=8G5=D ?* -257B4A>0Z '277233 ?* 'AC=57 >0U NK$W2BA= '26:27 EA828>0\ W5A6 )885>4A3456 ?* '592XA0KY A[,B] ,NK$%&) 2,% A S'%NK$% IABC [,%$ $@N$B&L#$discussion on the US Supreme Courts use of natural law in its decisions, a concise%$&,'%W$ L& 6K$ ;)9) 9'M%$[$ 4,'%N ABC +AN'%AQ =AR IM'OQL&K$C ,B +AN'%+AN'%AQ *L]KN&> ABC ?[$%LWAB 4,B&NLN'NL,BAQL&[J)FT 4,B&LC$%LB] NK$ AO,#$"WLN$C ?%NLWQ$ X333 9$WNL,B T ,S NK$ 8KLQLMMLB$ 4,B&NLN'NL,B ABC NK$ AO,#$"WL& AQQ NK$ [,%$ B, %$A&,B S,% NKL& 7,B,%AOQ$ 4,'%N B,N N, AMMQP BAN'%C$WL&L,B&)

,6=4X2 3G2 ,@ @;972D2 E5;7305;7 U5657A 9$WNL,B T ,S NK$ T\UZ 4,B&NLN'NL,B C$SLB$& b'CLW

the duty of the courts of justice to settle actual controversie& LB#,Q#LB] %L]KN& RKLWKA%$ Q$]AQQP C$[ABCAOQ$ ABC $BS,%W$AOQ$> ABC N, C$N$%[LB$ RK$NK$% ,%O$$B A ]%A#$ AO'&$ ,S CL&W%$NL,B A[,'BNLB] N, QAW` ,% $@W$&& ,S b'%L&CLpart of any branch or instrumentality of Government. I;BC$%&W,%LB] &'MMQL$C)J

-0) It may be asked, What standard do courts use to determine whetherNK$%$ KA& O$$B A ]%A#$ AO'&$ ,S CL&W%$NL,B A[,'BNLB] N, QAW` ,% $ jurisdiction on the part of any branch or instrumentality of Government?

-F) Grave abuse of discretion is frequently defined as "capricious orRKL[&LWAQ $@$%WL&$ ,S b'C][$BN A& L& $h'L#AQ$BN N, QAW` ,S b'%L&CLWNLF- 3B ACCLNL,B>explanations of the concept of grave abuse of discretion frequently state that, [t]heAO'&$ ,S CL&W%$NL,B ['&N O$ MAN$BN ABC ]%,&& A& N, A[,'BN N, AB $#A&M,&LNL#$ C'NP ,% A #L%N'AQ %$S'&AQ N, M$%S,%[ A C'NP $Bb,LB$C OP QAR> ,%W,BN$[MQANL,B ,S QAR> A& RK$%$ NK$ M,R$% L& $@$%WL&$C LB AB A%OLN[ABB$% OP %$A&,B ,S MA&&L,B ABC K,&NLQLNP)F0

37 2 US (2 Dall) 419 (1793).38 13 US 43 (1815).39 79 US 457 (1870).40 87 US 655 (1874).'! 500 L--6M__```C2


12/23

!#

-/) 3B $@MQALBLB] NK$ W,BW$MN ,S CL&W%$NL,B> :$ =$,B ABC :$ =$,B

When anything is left to any officer to be done

AWW,%CLB] N, KL& CL&W%$NL,B> NK$ QAR LBN$BC& LN N, O$C,B$ RLNK A &,'BC CL&W%$NL,B ABC AWW,%CLB] N, QAR)

7$BW$> AQNK,']K NK$ N$%[& ,S NK$ QAR W%$ANLB] NK$A'NK,%LNP W,BS$% 'M,B NK$ ,SSLW$% ]$B$%AQCL&W%$NL,BA%P M,R$% RLNK,'N h'AQLSLWANL,B&> KL&A'NK,%LNP L& B,N C$$[$C N, O$ AB 'BQL[LN$C ,B$) 6K$exercise of the officers discretion is still limited, byQ$]AQ W,B&N%'WNL,B> N, NK$ $#LC$BN M'%M,&$& ,S NK$

AWN> ABC N, RKAN L& `B,RB A& A &,'BC ABC Q$]AQCL&W%$NL,B> $@WQ'CLB] AQQ A%OLN%A%P> WAM%LWL,'&>LBh'L&LN,%LAQ ABC ,MM%$&&L#$ M%,W$$CLB]&) @@@gFF

-e) ?MMQPLB] NK$&$ M%LBWLMQ$& N, NK$ Q$]L&QAN'%$> NK$ O%,ANK$ Q$]L&QAN'%$ $Bb,P& LB $BAWNLB] QAR& L& B,N AO&,Q'N$> O'N ['&N others, the standards being sound, of fairness and reasonableness. When an act ofCongress exceeds the bounds of right reason, instead acting with passion andK,&NLQLty, such act is tainted with grave abuse of discretion, and aggrieved parties

A%$ $BNLNQ$C N, KA#$ LN B'QQLSL$C OP NKL& 4,'%N)

&6 DAX46B 438 7;=46B80 3G2@;972D2 E5;73 72=428 5672A856 HG4>G 48 2RA>3=C HGA36A3;7A= =AH 48*

-Z) 3N ['&N O$ $[MKA&La$C NKAN NK$ R,%C& '&$C OP NK$ 9'M%$[$ 4,'%LN& %'QLB]& N, C$N$%[LB$ RKAN W,B&NLN'N$& ]%A#$ AO'&$ ,S CL&W%$gWAM%LWL,'& ,% RKL[&LWAQ $@$%WL&$ ,S b'C][$BN A& L& $h'L#AQ$BN b'%L&CLWNL,B>gF/ or [t]he abuse of discretion must be patent and g%,&& A& N, A[,'BN N,AB $#A&L,B ,S A M,&LNL#$ C'NP ,% A #L%N'AQ %$S'&AQ N, M$%S,%[ A C'NP $Bb,LN, AWN AN AQQ LB W,BN$[MQANL,B ,S QAR> A& RK$%$ NK$ M,R$% L& $@$%Wand despotic manner by reason of passion and hostility, Fe A%$ B,N S,'BC LB NK$4,B&NLN'NL,B ABC A%$ S,%['QAN$C OP NK$ 9'M%$[$ 4,'%N NK%,']K NK$ '&$ ,S LN&

-U) 6K$ S,%$],LB] %$BC$%& W,[MQ$N$QP B']AN,%P NK$ &NAN$[$BN Honorable Court that its only only guidepost is the Constitution.3S NKAN R$%$ N%'$>then concepts such as substantial due process would be invalid IAB,NK$% W,BW$MNnot expressly stated in the Constitution). Other examples would be the moderating

44 De Leon, Hector S. and De Leon, Hector M. The Law on Public Officers and Election Law . RexBook Store, Inc.: Quezon City, 2003, pp. 134-135.45 See, for example, De Vera v. De Vera , G.R. No. 172832, April 7, 2009.46 Ibid. Citation omitted.


13/23

!&

power of courts,FZ or of residual powers.FU 3N ['&N O$ $[MKA&La$C NKAN RKANBAN'%AQ QARis, is simply an objective standard determined through the use ofreason. To put it in even simpler terms, natural law is but an operation of our%$A&,B)

-\) 6KAN L& RKP NK$ 9'M%$[$ 4,'%N M%$#L,'&QP ABC RL&$QP [AC$ LN N, &AP NKAN LN& %'QLB]& A%$ OA&$C B,N ,BQP A C%P> QLN$%AQ> #AW''[ %$Aalso on natural reason and logic (see"7%.%,,%'# H.&&;%'3 5%..) C;,.&>;#'$6(32'%O2$%&' /0 "7%.%,,%'# H.&&;%'3 5%..) =&0* 8'90F\J or conscience (see:#F2 F.2'2 /0 1.42 /. J> RKLWK A%$ O'N b'&N NR, $@A[MQ$&)

0.) Therefore, the Supreme Court, by now saying that the Court does not

C'QP %$W,]BLa$ cBAN'%AQ QARd A& A Q$]AQ OA&L& S,%upholding or invalidating a law isAWN'AQQP &APLB] LN C,$& B,N %$W,]BLa$ NK$ '&$ ,S %$A&,B RK$B [A`LB] LN&M,&LNL,B NKAN R$ AQQ WAB A]%$$ C,$& B,N AWW'%AN$QP %$SQ$WN NK$ AWN4,'%N)

333)

6K$ WA&$ AN OA% L& AB AMM%,M%LAN$ &LN'ANL,B N, AMMQP BANQAR)

0T) The Honorable Supreme Court, in its decision, stated that naturalQAR L& N, O$ '&$C &MA%LB]QP ,BQP LB NK$ [,&N M$W'QLA% ,S WL%W'[&NABWLBK$%$BN N, [AB RK$%$ B, QARis applicable.

0-) 6K$ S,%$],LB] &NAN$[$BN> R$ O$QL$#$> ASN$% AQQ L& &ALC ABC#LBCLWANL,B LB NK$ $BC ,S ,'% M,&LNL,B^ NKAN BAN'%AQ QAR C,$& MQAP A,'% W,B&NLN'NL,BAQ &P&N$[ ABC L& A M%,M$% &NABCA%C N, C$N$%[LB$ N

QAR)

00) ?N NK$ ,'N&$N> LN L& WQ$A% NKAN W,BN%AW$MNL,B L& B,RK$$@M%$&&QP LB NK$ 4,B&NLN'NL,B)

0F) 3N L& $h'AQQP WQ$A%> K,R$#$%> NKAN IA& C$[,B&N%AN$C AO,#$JMQAP& A &L]BLSLWABN %,Q$ LB ,'% b'%L&M%'C$BNLAQ ABC W,B&NLN'NL,B7,B,%AOQ$ 9'M%$[$ 4,'%N $[MQ,P& %$A&,B ABC Q,]LW LB [A`LB] LN& C$WL&L,BL& $@AWNQP RKAN BAN'%AQ QAR L&J ABC NKAN ABP Q$]L&QANL,B ['&preambular mandate of common good.

'E )& 1L.


14/23

!'

0/) 9,> NK$ h'$&NL,B B,R L&> RKAN C,$& BAN'%AQ QAR &AP AW,BN%AW$MNL,Bj

0e) 3B NKL&> NK$ AB&R$% L& AQ&, WQ$A%> W,B&L&N$BN> ABW,BN%AW$MNL,B #L,QAN$& NK$ BAN'%AQ QAR)

0Z) 5#$%P M%,[LB$BN NKLB`$% ,B NK$ BAN'%AQ QAR> &'WK A& ($%[ALV,KB 2LBBL&> VAB$N 9[LNK> ABC HA%NLB *K,BK$L[$%> N, BA[$ A S$R> KAW,B&L&N$BNQP> ABC W,BWQ'&L#$QP K$QC NKL& SAWN^ W,BN%AW$MNL,B #L1B NK$ ,NK$% KABC> B, BAN'%AQ QAR NKLB`$% ,S B,N$ KA& $#$% $#$B ANN$[MNKAN W,BN%AW$MNL,B L& LB W,BS,%[LNP RLNK BAN'%AQ QAR)

0U) *$W,]BLa$C ABC A'NK,%LNANL#$ BAN'%AQ QAR $@M$%N ($%[AL$@MQALB& K,R W,BN%AW$MNL,B #L,QAN$& BAN'%AQ QAR^ NK$ LBLNLANL,BS'BCA[$BNAQ K'[AB ],,C CL&NLBWN S%,[ NKAN ,S K'[AB QLS$ A& &'WK> O$WM%,W%$ANL#$ ],,C L& NK$ ,Ob$WN ,S AB AWNL,B RK,&$ $BC L& A M$%&,B CLA]$BN> ABC O$WA'&$ M%,W%$ANL,B L& ,Ob$WN ,S NK$ 'QNL[AN$ S'BWNL,B,%]ABL&[& LB&,SA% A& NK$P A%$ ,%]ABL&[&) 2'%NK$%[,%$> A RK,Q$ C,[ALBAWNL,B &'WK A& NK$ $BNL%$ LB&NLN'NL,B ,S [A%%LA]$ L& C$#,N$C N, M%,W%$ANL,B) (%L&$aNK$B $@MQALB& NKAN $#$%P K'[AB AWN> N, O$ ],,C> ['&N B,N &$N LN&S'BCA[$BNAQ K'[AB ],,C& RKLWK A%$ MA%NLWLMANL,B& LB (,,CB$&

4,BN%AW$MNL,B> OP LN& #$%P BAN'%$> L& A WK,LW$ N, AWN LB A RAP ,MM,&,S K'[AB QLS$> RKLWK> N, %$M$AN> L& A S'BCA[$BNAQ K'[AB ],,C) 3N L& WAM%$#$BN NK$ LBLNLANL,B ,S NK$ ],,C NKAN R,'QC ,NK$%RL&$ W,[$ AO,'N A& Asexual act. In short, contraception is an act of setting ones will against aS'BCA[$BNAQ K'[AB ],,C)/T

0\) 3B A MAM$% K$ W,"A'NK,%$C RLNK ,NK$% $&NAOQL&K$C ABC A'NK,%LNL$& ,B Q$]AQ NK,']KN ABC BAN'%AQ QAR IV,KB 2LBBL&> V,&$MK (%L&$a R%LN$&^

Insofar as contraception is contralife, it is similarN, C$QLO$%AN$ K,[LWLC$) 3S W,BN%AW$MNL,B L& &L[LQA% N,K,[LWLC$> NK$ SL%&N h'$&NL,B L&^ _KAN L& R%,B] RLNKK,[LWLC$j 3B &`$NWKLB] ,'N NK$ AB&R$% N, NKL&h'$&NL,B> R$ A%$ B,N W,BW$%B$C RLNK `LQQLB] RKLWK[AP O$ b'&NLSL$C> &'WK A& `LQQLB] LB RA%> O'N RLNK NK$LBN$BNL,BAQ `LQQLB] ,S NK$ LBB,W$BN> RKLWK W$%NALBQP L&R%,B])

8A%N ,S NK$ %$A&,B RKP C$QLO$%AN$ K,[LWLC$ L& R%,B]L& NKAN LN L& R%,B] N, KA%[ M$,MQ$> ABC Q,#$ C,$& B,KA%[) kLQQLB] M$,MQ$ L& AB $@N%$[$ WA&$ ,S KA%[LB]

51 See Grisez, Germain, A New Formulation of a Natural Law Argument against Contraception,The Thomist, XXX, 4, October 1966, pp. 343-361.


15/23

!(

NK$[) H,%$,#$%> LB NKL& WA&$ NK$ KA%[ N, NK$ M$%&,BL& CL%$WN ABC &'%$> 'BQL`$ KA%[& RKLWK ,B$ C,$& N,M$,MQ$ RK$BS,% $@A[MQ$> OP &N$AQLB],B$#L,QAN$& W$%NALB ,S NK$L% ,NK$% %L]KN&> ,BQP LBCL%$WNQPKA%[LB] NK$ M$%&,B) 1B$l& QLS$ L& ,B$l& #$%P %$AQLNP)6K'&> QAPLB] C,RB ,B$l& ,RB QLS$ S,% AB,NK$% L& NK$]%$AN$&N &AW%LSLW$ ,B$ WAB [A`$)

7,R$#$%> `LQQLB] &,[$,B$ L& B,N [,%AQQP R%,B] ,BQPO$WA'&$ NK$ M$%&,B RK, L& `LQQ$C Q,&$& NK$ ],,C ,SQLS$) 3S NKAN R$%$ NK$ WA&$> LN AQ&, R,'QC O$ [,%AQQPR%,B] N, `LQQ ABP,B$ OP AWWLC$BN> &LBW$ AWWLC$BNAQ`LQQLB] AQ&, %$&'QN& LB Q,&& ,S QLS$) ?B $&&$BNLAQW,BCLNL,B ,S NK$ L[[,%AQLNP ,S C$QLO$%AN$ K,[LWLC$ L&NKAN LN LB#,Q#$& A W,BN%AQLS$ RLQQ) ?QNK,']K NK$],,CB$&& ,S NK$ QLS$ RKLWK L& C$&N%,P$C M%,#LC$& NK$%$A&,B RKP C$QLO$%AN$ `LQQLB] L& R%,B]> NK$ [,%AQ $#LQ,S `LQQLB] M%L[A%LQP L& LB NK$ `LQQ$%l& K$A%N)

@@@

3B &K,%N> W,BN%AW$MNL,B L& &L[LQA% N, C$QLO$%AN$K,[LWLC$> C$&MLN$ NK$L% L[M,%NABN CLSS$%$BW$&>M%$WL&$QP LBA&['WK A& O,NK LB#,Q#$ A W,BN%AQLS$ RLQQ31'% NK$&L& L& NKAN NK$ W,BN%AQLS$ RLQQ RKLWKcontraception involves also is morally evil./-

F.) =,B] NL[$ W,[[$BNAN,% ABC $@M$%N ,B NK$ W,BN%AW$MNL,B C$OA9[LNK A%]'$& NK$ L[[,%AQLNP ,S W,BN%AW$MNL,B OP M%,W$$CLB] S%,[ NK$ LB,S NK$ &$@'AQ AWN A& ]$A%$C N,RA%C& M%,W%$ANL,B) 4,BN%AW$MNL,B L

NKAN S%'&N%AN$& NK$ LBK$%$BN M'%M,&$ ,S NK$ &$@'AQ AWN) 2'%NK$%[,%W,BN%A%P N, NK$ BAN'%$ ,S NK$ &$@'AQ AWN A& AB $@M%$&&L,B ,S N,NAQ &&M,'&$&)/0

FT) _LQQLA[ HAP> ,B NK$ ,NK$% KABC> ]L#$& KL& ,RB NA`$ ,B W,BN%AABC NK$ BAN'%AQ QAR> ABC RKP NK$ &A[$ L& ABissue not merely for Catholics but forall human beings:

... one contracepts when one chooses to4D92:23G2


16/23

!)

LBN$QQL]LOQ$ O$KA#L,%> LN KA& A M,LBN ,% A M'%M,&$) ?W,'MQ$ C,$& B,N WK,,&$ N, W,BN%AW$MN LS NK$P A%$MQAPLB] N$BBL& ,% K,QCLB] KABC& ,% `L&&LB] O$WA'&$W,BN%AW$MNLB] NK$B [A`$& B, &$B&$) M$%KAM& A ],,C ,B$ I$)]))> N,$@M%$&& NK$L% Q,#$ S,% ,B$ AB,NK$% ,% M$%KAM& NK$L%C,WN,% KA& N,QC NK$ RLS$ NKAN &K$ O$NN$% B,N ]$NM%$]BABN O$WA'&$ LS &K$ CLC &K$ W,'QC M,&&LOQP CL$J>NK$P NK$%$S,%$ WK,,&$> K$%$ ABC B,R> N, W,BN%AW$MN>

L)$)> N, L[M$C$ NK$ O$]LBBLB] ,S B$R K'[AB QLS$) 3S>C$&MLN$ NK$L% M%$WA'NL,B N, C, &,> NK$ RLS$ &K,'QC ]$NM%$]BABN> NK$ WKLQC LBLNLAQQP W,[$& N, O$ A]ALB&N NK$L%RLQQ&^ LB NKL& &$B&$ NK$ WKLQC L&;6HA632: > $#$B LS NK$W,'MQ$ C,$& B,N %$&,%N N, AO,%NL,B O'N %ANK$% h'LW`QPaccepts the child./F

F-) ?B,NK$% BAN'%AQ QAR $@M$%N> HA%NLB *K,BK$L[[$% Ccontraceptions violation of natural law as follows:

Contraception is wrong because it involves aNPM$ ,S &$@'AQ O$KA#L,% NKAN L& LBW,B&L&N$BN RLNKM%,W%$ANL#$ %$&M,B&LOLQLNPi NKL& LBW,B&L&N$BWP L& C'$N, NK$ SAWN NKAN W,BN%AW$MNL#$ &$@'AQ O$KA#L,%:28375C8 3G2 ,BABL&[> ABC [A&N'%OANL,B) O'N %ANK$% A M%LBWLMQ$ NKAN 'BC$%[LB$& NK$W,[['BL,B ,S M$%&,B&) 3B&,SA% A& LN L& M%AWNLW$CRLNKLB [A%%LA]$> W,BN%AW$MNL#$ O$KA#L,% ACCLNL,BAQQP,MM,&$& NK$ 'BL,B LB ,B$ SQ$&K ,S NK$ NR, M$%&,B&

(' P32-87/06-.32M Z W7--08 3O P32/082 B3- 92


17/23

!E

W,[[LNN$C N, %$&M,B&LOQP &$%#LB] NK$ N%AB&[L&&L,B ,Shuman life.//

Contraception not only signifies acting a]ALB&N&,[$ C$N$%[LBAN$ M%$W$MN ,S BAN'%AQ QAR> A& LB NK$WA&$ ,S &,[$,B$ RK,> `B,RLB] NK$ &$%L,'& B$$C N,A#,LC A W,BW$MNL,B> B$#$%NK$Q$&& &L[MQP S,QQ,R& NK$CPBA[L&[ ,S KL& &$@'AQ L[M'Q&$&i &'WK A M$%&,BR,'QC AWN A]ALB&N %$A&,B ABC A]ALB&N #L%N'$> NKAN L&>intemperately./e I;BC$%&W,%LB] &'MMQL$CJ

F0) H,%$ L[M,%NABNQP ABC RKAN ['&N O$ $[MKA&La$C L& NKAN> SA%

A [$%$ AWAC$[LW ,% NK$,%$NLWAQ CL&W'&&L,B> NKL& 7,B,%AOQ$ 9'M%$[$RL&$QP ABC W,%%$WNQP %$W,]BLa$C NK$ LBK$%$BN M%,W%$ANL#$ ABC 'B&$@'AQ AWN I&L[LQA% N, NKAN CL&W'&&$C OP NK$ BAN'%AQ QAR $@M$%RK$B LN %'Q$C LB NK$ WA&$ ,SEG4 Z46B '854 ?* E5;73 5F )992A=8[JP

While the law provides that the husband and theRLS$ A%$ ,OQL]$C N, QL#$ N,]$NK$%> ,O&$%#$ ['N'AQQ,#$> %$&M$WN ABC SLC$QLNP I?%N) eU> 2A[LQP 4,C$J> NK$sanction therefor is actually the spontaneous,

['N'AQ ASS$WNL,B O$NR$$B K'&OABC ABC RLS$ ABC B,NABPlegal mandate or court order (Cuaderno vs.4'AC$%B, T-. 8KLQ) T-\UJ) =,#$ L& '&$Q$&& 'BQ$&& LNL& &KA%$C RLNK AB,NK$%) 3BC$$C> B, [AB L& AB L&QABC>the cruelest act of a partner in marriage is to say Icould not have cared less. This is so because an'B]L#$B &$QS L& AB 'BS'QSLQQ$C &$QS) 6K$ $],L&N KA&B,NKLB] O'N KL[&$QS) 3B NK$ BAN'%AQ ,%C$%> LN L& &$@'AQLBNL[AWP RKLWK O%LB]& &M,'&$& RK,Q$B$&& ABC,B$B$&&) 9$@'AQ LBNL[AWP L& A ]LSN ABC A MA%NLWLMANL,BLB NK$ [P&N$%P ,S W%$ANL,B) 3N L& A S'BWNL,B RKLWK$BQL#$B& NK$ K,M$ ,S M%,W%$ANL,B ABC $B&'%$& NK$W,BNLB'ANL,B ,S SA[LQP %$QANL,B&)/U I;BC$%&W,%LB]&'MMQL$C)J

FF) *$M'OQLW ?WN +,) T.0/F M%,[,N$&> ]'A%ABN$$&> S'BC&> ABC $#$B ,%AWW$&& N, W,BN%AW$MNL#$&> A& 8$NLNL,B$%& KA#$ M,LBN$C ,'N LB MANK$L% 8$NLNL,B) _KLQ$ NKL& 7,B,%AOQ$ 4,'%N KA&> LB LN& :$WL&L,B> W,%%9$WNL,B TZ> M,%NL,B& ,S 9$WNL,B Z ABC -0> ABC NK$ W,%%$&M,BCLB] M,%3[MQ$[$BNLB] *'Q$& ABC *$]'QANL,B ,S *$M'OQLW ?WN +,) T.0/F> NK$ $BNL%$ Q'MK$QC A& B,N 'BW,B&NLN'NL,BAQ) 3N ['&N O$ $[MKA&La$C NKAN NK$ M%,#L&

(( I-L./, 3O 183/807-.324 W78-.2 :L32L0.KK084 #D!D4 6C!#'%!#(() I-L./, 3O 183/807-.324 W78-.2 :L32L0.KK084 #D!D4 6!&D57 AC:C B3C !!R!RD4 *72+78@ !)4 !RREC 58 Ibid.


18/23

!F

OP M$NLNL,B$%& LB MA%A]%AMK& U\"\/ ,S NK$ 8$NLNL,B W,B&NLN'N$ NK$S'BCA[$BNAQ M%,#L&L,B& ,S *? T.0/F) 6K'&> [$%$QP &$#$%LB] &'WK M%,#L&L,BW'%$ *? T.0/F ,S LN& LBK$%$BN 'BW,B&NLN'L,BAQLNP) 6KL& 7,B,%AOQ$ 4,'%N R$QQ RLNKLB LN& %L]KNS'Q A'NK,%LNP LB %$BC$%LB] ABC B'QQLSPLB] NKO$LB] 'BW,B&NLN'NL,BAQ> LN W,B&NLN'NLB] AB AWN ,S ]%A#$ AO'&$ ,S CL&WN, QAW` ,S ,% $@W$&& ,S b'%L&CLWNL,B)

&6 F462 \ \

F/) Natural law was originally included in the list of issues to be arguedorally before this Honorable Court as per the Proposed Issues in the Oral ArgumentCL&N%LO'N$C C'%LB] NK$ V'B$ e> -.T0 M%$",%AQ A%]'[$BN &$&&L,B) 7,R$#$%

AC#L&,%P L&&'$Cbefore the oral arguments, the issue of natural law was'BS,%N'BAN$QP $@WQ'C$C)

Fe) +AN'%AQ QAR L& ,B$ ,S NK$ O$C%,W` M%LBWLMQ$& 'M,B R4,B&NLN'NL,B ABC NK$ $BNL%$ 8KLQLMMLB$ Q$]AQ &P&N$[ %$&N) 3N L&7,B,%AOQ$ 4,'%N N, $B&'%$ NKAN B, AWN ,S NK$ ],#$%B[$BN C$#LAN$& S%,[ NKQAR> RKLWK L& AB,NK$% RAP ,S &APLB] NKAN B, AWN ,S ],#$%B[$BN &K,'QC %L]KN %$A&,B)

FZ) 6KL& C'NP C,$& B,N A%L&$ S%,[ #A]'$> AO&N%AWN NK$,%L$& O'N Lconsequence of the judiciarys mandAN$ N, 'MK,QC NK$ 4,B&NLN'NL,B) 6K$ 4,B&NLN'NKA& $BC'%LB] M%LBWLMQ$& NKAN B$$C N, O$ 'MK$QC> B,N CL&WA%C$C> N,MA&&L,B ABC N%$BC&)

FU) 6K$ [$[O$%& ,S NKL& 7,B,%AOQ$ 4,'%N A%$ M%$WL&$QP 'B$Q$WN$CA& A WK$W` ,B NK$ MA&&LB] MA&&L,B& ABC M,QLNLWAQ W,B&LC$%ANL,B&,S 4,B]%$&& RK$B NK$&$ M,QLNLWAQ W,B&LC$%ANL,B& #L,QAN$ NK$ W$BNRKLWK NK$ 4,B&NLN'NL,B L& S,'BC$C)JQ

F\) 6KL& 7,B,%AOQ$ 9'M%$[$ 4,'%N> RK$B [A`LB] LN& C$WL&L,B& K,QCLB] 'M QAR& S,% &W%'NLBP> C,$& B,N [$%$QP Q,,` AN NK$ OQAW` ABC RKNK$ QAR) 3N '&$& W,[[,B &$B&$> LN& `B,RQ$C]$ ,S KL&N,%P ABC ,S b'%L&M%'C$ [,&N L[M,%NABNQP %$A&,B ABC Q,]LW)

/.) +AN'%AQ QAR L& O'N A &NABCA%C A%%L#$C AN NK%,']K NK$ '&$ ,&,[$NKLB] N, #L,QAN$ BAN'%AQ QAR L& $h'L#AQ$BN N, &APLB] NKAN &'WK #

3BA&['WK A& NKL& 7,B,%AOQ$ 4,'%N KA& NK$ %$&M,B&LOLQLNP N, 'MK,QC ,%depending on whether such is tantamount to grave abuse of discretion, it is butQ,]LWAQ S,% NKL& 7,B,%AOQ$ 4,'%N N, C$N$%[LB$ LS &'WK QAR& A%$ [AC$ RLN(rather than capricious, arbitrary, or whimsical).

(R !"#$%&% () *+, -%.%#$/0, *#12+ 3%44"55"%. %6 7898: ! C:C B3C !R#R&(4 Y0/0K;08 E4 #D!DC


19/23

!R

/T) _$ &'O[LN NKAN O$WA'&$ NKL& 7,B,%AOQ$ 9'M%$[$ 4,'%N NA']KN&'WK> NKAN S,% A QAR N, O$ %$A&,BAOQ$ ABC B,N A%OLN%A%P ,% RKL[&LWAN, %$A&,B) ?BC NK$ ,M$%ANL,B ,S %$A&,B L& RKAN BAN'%AQ QAR L&)

/-) 6KAN L& RKP QAR $@M$%N V,%]$ 4,h'LA C$&W%LO$& BAN'%AQ Q&NABCA%C RKLWK M%,N$WN& M,&LNL#$ QAR S%,[ A%OLN%A%LB$&&^

One standard that can serve as a guiC$S,% W,'%N& LB %$&,Q#LB] W,BW%$N$ WA&$& LB#,Q#LB]W,BSQLWN& ,S NK$ S'BCA[$BNAQ S%$$C,[& ,S&M$$WK> M%$&&> M%,M$%NP ABC %$QL]L,B L& +AN'%AQ=AR) @@@ 8,&LNL#$ QAR B$$C& NK$ $BC'%LB] W%LNLW

M%,#LC$C OP +AN'%AQ =AR) 3N ['&N O$ W,BS%,BN$COP ,Ob$WNL#$ b'&NLW$.e.

gH,&N RK, %$b$WN NK$ #AQLCLNP ,S BAN'%AQ QARWQAL[ NK$[&$Q#$& A& lQLO$%AQl ,% lM%,]%$&&L#$l) -.TF O$ %$ABC &$N A&LC$ LB&,SA% A& LN AJ C$WQA%$& NKAN NKL& 7,B,%AOQ$ 4

60 Coquia, Jorge, Church and State Laws and Relations , 4th Edition, 2007, p.160.61 Coquia, Jorge, Readings In Legal Philosophy And Theory, For A Revival of Natural LawDoctrine In Philippine Jurisprudence , 2005, p.239.


20/23

#D


21/23

#!


22/23

##


23/23

Pro-Life -Motion for Recon

Documents

Transcript of Pro-Life -Motion for Recon