Positive Psychology

230
the power of POSITIVE PSYCHOLOGY David D. Nowell, Ph.D.

description

 

Transcript of Positive Psychology

Page 1: Positive Psychology

the power of

POSITIVEPSYCHOLOGYDavid D. Nowell, Ph.D.

Page 2: Positive Psychology

orientation

x

Page 3: Positive Psychology

Is there a negative psychology?

Page 4: Positive Psychology

• Anger: 5,584• Anxiety: 41,416• Depression:

54,040

• Joy: 415• Happiness:

1,710• Life

satisfaction: 2,582

Page 5: Positive Psychology
Page 6: Positive Psychology

Happiness

Page 7: Positive Psychology

Appendix A

Happiness

Page 8: Positive Psychology
Page 9: Positive Psychology
Page 10: Positive Psychology

“PERMA”Positive emotions

Engagement / flowRelationships

MeaningAccomplishment

Page 11: Positive Psychology
Page 12: Positive Psychology

Key findings

Page 13: Positive Psychology
Page 14: Positive Psychology
Page 15: Positive Psychology
Page 16: Positive Psychology

History of PositivePsychology

x

Page 17: Positive Psychology

Assumptions of PositivePsychology

Page 18: Positive Psychology

04/07/2023 © 2011 David D. Nowell, Ph.D. All rights reserved.

18

AANTECEDEN

T

BBEHAVIOR

CCONSEQUENC

ES

Page 19: Positive Psychology

04/07/2023 © 2011 David D. Nowell, Ph.D. All rights reserved.

19

BBEHAVIOR

AANTECEDENT

CCONSEQUENC

ES

Page 20: Positive Psychology

04/07/2023 © 2011 David D. Nowell, Ph.D. All rights reserved.

20

AANTECEDEN

T

cCONSEQUENCES

BBEHAVIOR

Page 21: Positive Psychology

04/07/2023 © 2011 David D. Nowell, Ph.D. All rights reserved.

21

AANTECEDEN

T

BBEHAVIOR

CCONSEQUENC

ES

Page 22: Positive Psychology

THE INTERNETS ARE GREAT!

Page 23: Positive Psychology

Are you already a positive psychology clinician?

Page 24: Positive Psychology

Appendix F

Page 25: Positive Psychology

…a challenge

Page 26: Positive Psychology

…a memory test

Page 27: Positive Psychology

COMMON CLINICAL CONCERNSTHROUGH THE LENS OF POSITIVE PSYCHOLOGY

Page 28: Positive Psychology

trauma

Page 29: Positive Psychology

Re-connecting with coping strengths

Page 30: Positive Psychology

Positive growth after disability

Page 31: Positive Psychology

• Assets / risks• Protective processes / vulnerabilities•Competence / adversity

resilience

Page 32: Positive Psychology
Page 33: Positive Psychology

resilience

Appendix F

Page 34: Positive Psychology

anxiety

Page 35: Positive Psychology

addictions

x

Page 36: Positive Psychology

depression

Page 37: Positive Psychology

SSRI• Strategies• Strengths• Resources• Insights

Page 38: Positive Psychology

The P’s of Depression

• Predisposing factors• Precipitating factors• Perpetuating factors

Page 39: Positive Psychology

The P’s of Depression

• Predisposing factors• Precipitating factors

• Perpetuating factors

Page 40: Positive Psychology

The P’s of Depression

• Predisposing factors• Precipitating factors

• Perpetuating factors• Protective factors

Page 41: Positive Psychology

The P’s of Depression

• Predisposing factors• Precipitating factors

• Perpetuating factors• Protective factors

Appendix F

Page 42: Positive Psychology

Eating disordersWhere are you when you are eating?

Page 43: Positive Psychology

Oppositional-defiant disorder as a learning disorder

Page 44: Positive Psychology
Page 45: Positive Psychology
Page 46: Positive Psychology

PROSOCIAL BEHAVIOR

Social and

Page 47: Positive Psychology
Page 48: Positive Psychology
Page 49: Positive Psychology
Page 50: Positive Psychology

the Righteous Mind

Page 51: Positive Psychology
Page 52: Positive Psychology

forgiveness

x

Page 53: Positive Psychology

Do you want to be right? Or do you want to be

in relationship?

Page 54: Positive Psychology

Do you want to be right? Or do you want to be

in relationship?

Appendix D

Page 55: Positive Psychology

•Empathy•Moral models•Personal principles

Compassion

Page 56: Positive Psychology

04/07/2023 59

Page 57: Positive Psychology

04/07/2023 © 2011 David D. Nowell, Ph.D. All rights reserved.

60

AANTECEDEN

T

BBEHAVIOR

CCONSEQUENC

ES

Page 58: Positive Psychology

Emotional Intelligence

• Perceiving emotion• Using emotions to facilitate thought• Understanding emotions• Managing emotions

Page 59: Positive Psychology

Self-soothing

Page 61: Positive Psychology

“if you knew this about me…”

Page 62: Positive Psychology

Framingham Heart Study

“…happiness, like health, is a collective phenomenon.”

Page 63: Positive Psychology

THE HAPPINESS SET POINT

I would really be happy if…..

Page 64: Positive Psychology

Lyubomirsky, S. (2007)

Page 65: Positive Psychology

Lyubomirsky, S. (2007)

Page 66: Positive Psychology

Lyubomirsky, S. (2007)

Page 67: Positive Psychology
Page 68: Positive Psychology
Page 69: Positive Psychology
Page 70: Positive Psychology
Page 71: Positive Psychology

Lyubomirsky, S. (2007)

Page 72: Positive Psychology

Lyubomirsky, S. (2007)

Page 73: Positive Psychology

Intentional activity

Page 74: Positive Psychology

strengths

Page 75: Positive Psychology

www.viacharacter.org

Page 76: Positive Psychology

KNOWLEDGE & WISDOM1. Creativity2. Curiosity3. Love of learning4. Wisdom / perspective5. Open-mindedness

COURAGE & FIRMNESS6. Bravery7. Persistence8. Integrity9. Vitality

HUMANITY & LOVE 10. Give & receive love11. Kindness12. Social intelligence

JUSTICE & FAIRNESS13. Citizenship14. Fairness15. Leadership

TEMPERANCE 16. Forgiveness / mercy17. Modesty / humility18. Prudence19. Self-regulation

TRANSCENDENCE / SPIRITUAL 20. Appreciate excellence / beauty21. Gratitude22. Hope23. Humor24 Spirituality

Page 77: Positive Psychology

journaling

Page 78: Positive Psychology

journaling

gratitude

x

Page 79: Positive Psychology

journaling

gratitude

activity scheduling

Page 80: Positive Psychology

journaling

gratitude

activity scheduling

Appendix E

Page 81: Positive Psychology

savoring

Page 82: Positive Psychology

x

Page 83: Positive Psychology

flow

Page 84: Positive Psychology

Flow

Mihaly Csikszentmihalyi

Page 85: Positive Psychology

Flow

Page 86: Positive Psychology

Flow

Page 87: Positive Psychology
Page 88: Positive Psychology
Page 89: Positive Psychology

Flow

Page 90: Positive Psychology
Page 91: Positive Psychology

Flow

Page 92: Positive Psychology
Page 93: Positive Psychology

“Challenging assignments that (slightly) stretch one's skills lead to flow…”

Page 94: Positive Psychology

Flow

Page 95: Positive Psychology
Page 96: Positive Psychology
Page 97: Positive Psychology
Page 98: Positive Psychology

physical exercise

Page 99: Positive Psychology

physical exercise

• Neurotrophic factor• Hippocampal growth• Counteract stress-related hormones• Addictions• Attention / focus• Age-related cognitive decline• Anti-depressant qualities

Page 101: Positive Psychology

physical exercise

• Neurotrophic factor• Hippocampal growth• Counteract stress-related hormones• Addictions• Attention / focus• Age-related cognitive decline• Anti-depressant qualities

Page 102: Positive Psychology

optimism

• Hope• Self-efficacy• Goal-setting

Page 103: Positive Psychology

04/07/2023 © 2011 David D. Nowell, Ph.D. All rights reserved.

106

what IS vs. what COULD BE

Appendix G

Page 104: Positive Psychology

04/07/2023 © 2011 David D. Nowell, Ph.D. All rights reserved.

107

what IS…

Page 105: Positive Psychology

04/07/2023 © 2011 David D. Nowell, Ph.D. All rights reserved.

108

…what COULD BE

Page 106: Positive Psychology

optimism

• Hope–Pathways thoughts – what causes what–Agency thoughts – who causes what

Page 107: Positive Psychology

optimism

• Hope

Appendices B & C

Page 108: Positive Psychology

optimism

• Hope–Academics–Athletics–Physical health–Social connection

Page 109: Positive Psychology

optimism

• Hope–Academics–Athletics–Physical health• Peled, R. (2008)

–Social connection

Page 110: Positive Psychology

optimism

• Accentuating Hope–Pathways cognitions• “roadblocks”

Page 111: Positive Psychology

optimism

• Accentuating Hope–Pathways cognitions–Agency cognitions

Page 112: Positive Psychology
Page 113: Positive Psychology

Hank:

“ I have things I need to do to

improve my marriage, my health,

and my financial situation, but I

honestly believe that I have

zero chance of actually making

any of those three things get

better.”

Page 114: Positive Psychology

(self-esteem)

Page 115: Positive Psychology
Page 116: Positive Psychology

kindness

Page 117: Positive Psychology

KNOWLEDGE & WISDOM1. Creativity2. Curiosity3. Love of learning4. Wisdom / perspective5. Open-mindedness

COURAGE & FIRMNESS6. Bravery7. Persistence8. Integrity9. Vitality

HUMANITY & LOVE 10. Give & receive love

11. Kindness12. Social intelligence

JUSTICE & FAIRNESS13. Citizenship14. Fairness15. Leadership

TEMPERANCE 16. Forgiveness / mercy17. Modesty / humility18. Prudence19. Self-regulation

TRANSCENDENCE / SPIRITUAL 20. Appreciate excellence / beauty21. Gratitude22. Hope23. Humor24 Spirituality

Page 118: Positive Psychology

kindness

"universal egoism"

Page 119: Positive Psychology

kindness

Appendix F

Page 120: Positive Psychology

The Magic Ratio

3:1

Page 121: Positive Psychology

Coaching

Page 122: Positive Psychology

laser questions

• How will you know when your most important relationship has improved significantly?

• Who will be the first person to notice that you’re happier, … what exactly will they notice?

• How much better do you think your grades can get? And how can you reach that goal while having some fun at the same time?

• What’s really great about this that I have not really noticed before?

Page 123: Positive Psychology

laser questions

• What changes will you need to make in order to get the most out of our work together?

• How much stress will the copay for these sessions cause you?

• What’s the most empowering thing that I can do during our sessions?

• What would have happened if you’d not decided to do this work?

• What is one regret you don’t want to have in this lifetime?

Page 124: Positive Psychology

What our clients want most

• make and keep more money• Get more done in less time• Communicate more effectively• Feel better physically and

emotionally• Feel closer with others• Manage hassles and stressors• Find and stay on a path

Page 125: Positive Psychology
Page 126: Positive Psychology
Page 127: Positive Psychology

Change your client’s brain

…with their consent

Page 128: Positive Psychology

04/07/2023 © 2011 David D. Nowell, Ph.D. All rights reserved.

133

“NeuroMalleability”

Page 129: Positive Psychology

• Physical Exercise• Nutrition• Stress Management• Novel Learning Experience • Sleep

Page 130: Positive Psychology

04/07/2023 © 2011 David D. Nowell, Ph.D. All rights reserved.

135

The reward and planning systems

Page 131: Positive Psychology

© 2011 David D. Nowell, Ph.D. All rights reserved.

136

What Does Dopamine Feel like?

Page 132: Positive Psychology
Page 133: Positive Psychology

04/07/2023 © 2011 David D. Nowell, Ph.D. All rights reserved.

138

The reward and planning systems

Page 134: Positive Psychology

04/07/2023 © 2011 David D. Nowell, Ph.D. All rights reserved.

139

The Executive Functions1. Inhibition

2. Shift

3. Regulation

4. Initiation

5. Working memory

6. Planning / organizing

7. Self-monitoring

Page 135: Positive Psychology
Page 136: Positive Psychology

04/07/2023 © 2011 David D. Nowell, Ph.D. All rights reserved.

141

The Executive Functions• Cognitive Control /

“gain” (Miller & Cohen,

1991)

• “the actor whose hand

controls the flashlight”

(Goldberg, 2009)

Page 137: Positive Psychology

04/07/2023 © 2011 David D. Nowell, Ph.D. All rights reserved.

142

The reward and planning systems

Page 138: Positive Psychology

The brain’s reward and planning system

• Anticipate goal• Identify tasks• Sequence / problem-solve• Block out distractions• Get the reward

Page 139: Positive Psychology

04/07/2023 © 2011 David D. Nowell, Ph.D. All rights reserved.

144

AANTECEDEN

T

BBEHAVIOR

CCONSEQUENC

ES

Page 140: Positive Psychology

"We're All ADHD Now”

What the Rest of Us Can Learn from People Who Really Struggle with Focus, Distractibility, and Time Management

Page 141: Positive Psychology

04/07/2023 © 2011 David D. Nowell, Ph.D. All rights reserved.

146

Page 142: Positive Psychology

The best defense against the manipulation of our attention is to determine for ourselves – in advance - how we want to invest it.

- E. Goldberg

Page 143: Positive Psychology

04/07/2023 © 2011 David D. Nowell, Ph.D. All rights reserved.

148

(85 – X) x 365

Page 144: Positive Psychology

How to Entirely Remove "Bad," "Lazy," and "Procrastinating" from Our Vocabulary

Page 145: Positive Psychology
Page 146: Positive Psychology
Page 147: Positive Psychology

04/07/2023 © 2011 David D. Nowell, Ph.D. All rights reserved.

152

I’m gonna eat all the gum and

candy I want!

Page 148: Positive Psychology

04/07/2023 © 2011 David D. Nowell, Ph.D. All rights reserved.

153

Asking two questions…

1. “Am I having fun now?”

Page 149: Positive Psychology

04/07/2023 © 2011 David D. Nowell, Ph.D. All rights reserved.

154

Asking two questions…

2. “And is this what I set out to do?”

Page 150: Positive Psychology

04/07/2023 © 2011 David D. Nowell, Ph.D. All rights reserved.

155

YesYes

NoYes

YesNo

NoNo

Am I having fun now?

Is this what I set out to do?

Page 151: Positive Psychology

04/07/2023 © 2011 David D. Nowell, Ph.D. All rights reserved.

156

YesYes

NoYes

YesNo

NoNo

Am I having fun now?

Is this what I set out to do?

I’m having fun.I’m on task.

Page 152: Positive Psychology

04/07/2023 © 2011 David D. Nowell, Ph.D. All rights reserved.

157

YesYes

NoYes

YesNo

NoNo

Am I having fun now?

Is this what I set out to do?

I’m having fun.I’m not on task.

Page 153: Positive Psychology

04/07/2023 © 2011 David D. Nowell, Ph.D. All rights reserved.

158

YesYes

NoYes

YesNo

NoNo

Am I having fun now?

Is this what I set out to do?

I’m not having fun.I’m on task.

Page 154: Positive Psychology

04/07/2023 © 2011 David D. Nowell, Ph.D. All rights reserved.

159

YesYes

NoYes

YesNo

NoNo

Am I having fun now?

Is this what I set out to do?

I’m not having fun.I’m not on task.

Page 155: Positive Psychology

04/07/2023 © 2011 David D. Nowell, Ph.D. All rights reserved.

160

Page 156: Positive Psychology

Increase salience

Page 157: Positive Psychology

easy hard

Page 158: Positive Psychology
Page 159: Positive Psychology

04/07/2023 © 2011 David D. Nowell, Ph.D. All rights reserved.

164

Page 160: Positive Psychology

04/07/2023 © 2011 David D. Nowell, Ph.D. All rights reserved.

165

Page 161: Positive Psychology

04/07/2023 © 2011 David D. Nowell, Ph.D. All rights reserved.

166

Appendix F

Page 162: Positive Psychology

Working withMOTIVATIONAL ISSUES

x

Page 163: Positive Psychology

Motivation for what?

Page 164: Positive Psychology

“…they realized what the solution was and were terrified”

Page 165: Positive Psychology

The Five Reasons That People Do Anything That They Do

Page 166: Positive Psychology

The Two Reasons That People Do Anything That They Do

Page 167: Positive Psychology

The Two Reasons That People Do Anything That They Do

RREWARD

PPUNISHMENT

Page 168: Positive Psychology

The One Reason That People Do Anything That They Do

RREWARD P

“WHAT’S THEIR PAIN?”

Page 169: Positive Psychology

Which Techniques Should Absolutely Be Avoided with Under-motivated Clients

x

Page 170: Positive Psychology

Which Techniques Should Absolutely Be Avoided with Under-motivated Clients

• Finessing our Questions

x

Page 171: Positive Psychology

Dangers of Failing to Recognize Our Clients Stage of Change

Page 172: Positive Psychology

Yes or No ?

 #1. I solved my biggest problem more than six months ago. 

 #2. I have taken action on my problem within the past six months. 

 #3. I am intending to take action in the next month. 

  #4. I am intending to take action in the next six months.   

Page 173: Positive Psychology

Stages of Change

PrecontemplationContemplationPreparationActionMaintenance

Page 174: Positive Psychology

Stages of Change

PrecontemplationContemplationPreparationActionMaintenance

Appendix F

Page 175: Positive Psychology

What Key Motivational Interviewing Techniques Can Be Applied to Any Clinical Situation?

Page 176: Positive Psychology

What Key Motivational Interviewing Techniques Can Be Applied to Any Clinical Situation?

• Express empathy• Create discrepancy• Roll with resistance• Support self-efficacy

Page 177: Positive Psychology

Is relapse inevitable?

Page 178: Positive Psychology

A complete

RETHINKING OF BEHAVIORAL PROBLEMS

Strategic Behavioral Inquiry

Page 179: Positive Psychology

What’s the kid’s deal?

Page 180: Positive Psychology

The Magic IfWhat "Method Actors "Have To Teach Clinicians

Page 181: Positive Psychology
Page 182: Positive Psychology

Inna:

student struggling with

difficult assignments,

feeling demoralized and

anxious.

Page 183: Positive Psychology

Inna:

“I just get blank. I usually start sitting more

slouched, hold my head with my left hand…

you freeze and instead of being able to

think of alternatives, you start thinking

to yourself that you cannot find a

logical answer and you are tempted to

avoid it as if it poses a threat

somehow to you.”

Page 184: Positive Psychology

STRATEGIC BEHAVIORALINQUIRY

Hëdÿdt?

Page 185: Positive Psychology
Page 186: Positive Psychology
Page 187: Positive Psychology

04/07/2023 © 2011 David D. Nowell, Ph.D. All rights reserved.

197

Strategic Behavioral Inquiry

A. Respectful approach to client’s interior experience

B. Introduces client to the “culture” of self-management

C. Specific applicable self-knowledge (meta-cognition)

Page 188: Positive Psychology

04/07/2023 © 2011 David D. Nowell, Ph.D. All rights reserved.

198

Strategic Behavioral Inquiry

Hëdÿdt – How Exactly Did You Do That?

Page 189: Positive Psychology

04/07/2023 © 2011 David D. Nowell, Ph.D. All rights reserved.

199

Strategic Behavioral Inquiry

Obstacles to good inquiry

Page 190: Positive Psychology
Page 191: Positive Psychology
Page 192: Positive Psychology

04/07/2023 © 2011 David D. Nowell, Ph.D. All rights reserved.

202

AANTECEDEN

T

BBEHAVIOR

CCONSEQUENC

ES

….the ad absurdum

Page 193: Positive Psychology

The reward-and-planning system

• Anticipate goal• Identify tasks• Sequence / problem-solve• Block out distractions• Get the reward

Page 194: Positive Psychology

Alicia R. Ruelaz, M.D.:

“the biggest issue for me, and

others I've seen, has been

maintaining motivation

between the excitement of

setting a goal and not losing

interest before it is

completed.”

Page 195: Positive Psychology

Juzer :

“my biggest problem is that

I want to do everything

all at once!”

Page 196: Positive Psychology

Preferred states inventory

• Archeology of a Memory, Appendix H

Page 197: Positive Psychology

RTW

Page 198: Positive Psychology

Marie Jahoda

Connecting with Return to Work Clients around the Key Human Needs Served by Employment

Page 199: Positive Psychology

• 1. It imposes a time structure on the day.• 2. It enlarges the scope of relationships.• 3. It provides shared purposes and

activities of a social group.• 4. It assigns social status and clarifies

personal identity.• 5. It requires regular activity.

RTW

Page 200: Positive Psychology

• The Rule of Thirds

RTW

Page 201: Positive Psychology

The Three Don'ts of Employment Assistance

• Don’t talk about work• Don’t present work as a goal

in itself• Don’t impose our values on

clients

Page 202: Positive Psychology

Four Signs That You Are Working Harder Than Your Clients

• Fighting with client• Client is “yes butting” you• You worry more than they do• You dread the session

Page 203: Positive Psychology

Four Signs That You Are Working Harder Than Your Clients

And what you might be thinking….

Page 204: Positive Psychology
Page 205: Positive Psychology

How to Get Clients to Start Talking about Change

• Slow down (tolerate silence)• Respect resistance• Be agnostic• Encourage agnosia• Why, specifrically, is this a problem?• Identify exceptions to the problem• Frame goals in the positive• Help clients talk like behaviorists

Page 206: Positive Psychology

How to Get Clients to Start Talking about Change

• Slow down• Respect resistance• Be agnostic• Encourage agnosia• Why, specifrically, is this a problem?• Identify exceptions to the problem• Frame goals in the positive• Help clients talk like behaviorists– More of what and less of what?

Page 207: Positive Psychology

How to Get Clients to Start Talking about Change

Accurate empathy + “more of what”

Connecting the dots…

Page 208: Positive Psychology

• “Sell me on why this absolutely positively must change…”

• Letter from the future

Connecting the Dots: Linking up Treatment Goals to What Our Client Already Loves

x

Page 209: Positive Psychology

You cannot not change

Page 210: Positive Psychology

How to make somebody love you forever

Page 211: Positive Psychology

…yeah butIt Won’t Work with this ClientOBJECTIONS

Page 212: Positive Psychology

04/07/2023 © 2011 David D. Nowell, Ph.D. All rights reserved.

223The “Big Five”

1. Daily focus time

2. Values/motivational clarity

3. Nutrition

4. Movement

5. Connection

Page 213: Positive Psychology

04/07/2023 © 2011 David D. Nowell, Ph.D. All rights reserved.

224

Page 214: Positive Psychology

04/07/2023 © 2011 David D. Nowell, Ph.D. All rights reserved.

225

…the most important 10 minutes of the day….

Page 215: Positive Psychology

04/07/2023 © 2011 David D. Nowell, Ph.D. All rights reserved.

226

Appendix I

Page 216: Positive Psychology

04/07/2023 © 2011 David D. Nowell, Ph.D. All rights reserved.

227

1. Daily focus time

2. Values/motivational clarity

3. Nutrition

4. Movement

5. Connection

Page 217: Positive Psychology

04/07/2023 © 2011 David D. Nowell, Ph.D. All rights reserved.

228

Page 218: Positive Psychology

04/07/2023 © 2011 David D. Nowell, Ph.D. All rights reserved.

229

Page 219: Positive Psychology

04/07/2023 © 2011 David D. Nowell, Ph.D. All rights reserved.

230

Page 220: Positive Psychology

04/07/2023 © 2011 David D. Nowell, Ph.D. All rights reserved.

231

1. Daily focus time

2. Values/motivational

clarity

3. Nutrition

4. Movement

5. Connection

Page 221: Positive Psychology

04/07/2023 © 2011 David D. Nowell, Ph.D. All rights reserved.

232

1. Daily focus time

2. Values/

motivational

clarity

3. Nutrition

4. Movement

5. Connection

Page 222: Positive Psychology

04/07/2023 © 2011 David D. Nowell, Ph.D. All rights reserved.

233

Page 223: Positive Psychology

04/07/2023 © 2011 David D. Nowell, Ph.D. All rights reserved.

234

1. Daily focus time

2. Values/motivational

clarity

3. Nutrition

4. Movement

5. Connection

Page 224: Positive Psychology

Cultural Competence

What culture?

Page 225: Positive Psychology

Cultural Competence

What competencies?

Cultural Competence

Page 226: Positive Psychology

Positive Ethics

• “professional ethics”• “research ethics”• “ethics training”

Page 227: Positive Psychology

Positive Ethics

• Comprehensive• Aspirational• Positive virtues• Support clinicians in taking care of

themselves

Page 228: Positive Psychology

Positive Ethics

• “He shook my hand”

Page 229: Positive Psychology

…a challenge

Page 230: Positive Psychology

the power of

POSITIVEPSYCHOLOGYDavid D. Nowell, Ph.D.