Planktonic Foraminifera in Sediment Samples from the Eastern...
Transcript of Planktonic Foraminifera in Sediment Samples from the Eastern...
Indian Journal of Marine SciencesVol. 1, June 1972,pp. 1-7
Planktonic Foraminifera in Sediment Samples from theEastern Arabian Sea
K. KAMESWARA RAO
National Institute of Oceanography, ~anaji
ManuscriPt received 24 January 1972
Twenty-two. species af planktanic Faraminifera have been identified fram the battam sediments af the Arabian Sea aff Bambay and their percentage accurrence has been studied.Species campasitian has shawn that the sediments af the cantinental slape regian aff Bambayare represented by a larger number af 'species than the shelf sediments. The farms which arecamman in the eastern part af the Arabian Sea are: Glabigerina bullaides, Glabigerinoidesruber, G. sacculiJer, Globigerinita glutinata, Globigerinella aequilateralis, Orbulina unillersa,Pulleniatina obliquilaculata, Globarotalia menardii and G. tumida. Cancentratian af the planktanic Faraminifera decreases fram the affshare regians to. regians tawards the caast. In theslape sediments the per cent af CaCOs is prapartianal to. the number af planktanic Foraminifera. The presence af high latitude cald water species alang with the warm water species inthe Arabian Sea aff Bambay suggests the mixing af Antarctic water with ather types af waterfaund alang the west caast af India. Similarity af the planktanic Faraminifera of the easternArabian Sea with that af Red Sea has been shawn an the basis af species campasitian anddaminance af certain species in bath the seas. On the basis af this abservatian, it is cancludedthat Red Sea water has spread into. the affshare regian of Bombay.
PLANKTONIC Foraminifera in the ArabianSea were first studied by Chapmanl whoreported 17 species from the Laccadive
region. Stubbings2 recorded 18 species flom theArabian Sea during John Murray Expedition. Inthe north-eastern part of the Arabia,n Sea whichincludes Gulf of Cambay, Kameswara Rao3,4 fourid9 species. Recently Be' and McIntyre5 reportedthe presence of an 'extinct' subspecies, Globorotalia men£lrdii flexuosa (Koch), from the samplescollected for the present investigation. From theforegoing account it is obviGUS that there is nothorough quantitative documentation of variousspecies of planktonic Foraminifera present in thewest coast of India, although their presence in different regions of the Arabian Sea has been noted.
In this paper the quantitative distribution ofvarious planktonic foraminiferal species presentin the bottom sediments of the Arabian Sea offBombay is reported. Such a study has a bearingon oceanographic conditions of the sea and alsoit will be useful for the (omparison of the faunawith other regions.
During a cruise sponsored by the Institute onboard INS 'Darshak' in January J 969 into theArabian Sea off Bombay, several bottom sedimentsamples were collected using Lafond-Dietz snapper.Altogether 7 snapper samples were obtained andthe sampling stations are shown in Fig. 1. Thepurpose of the collectioW' of these samples is todetermine species composition of planktonic Foraminifera and their quantitative distribution in thebottom sediments of the Arabian Sea off Bombay. The study area extends between longitudes69°30·4'E and n022·0'E and latitude,> between18°33·5'N and 19°15·0'N. The water depths at thesites in the area range between 62 and 1820 m.
The continental shelf off Bombay coast haf amaximum width of about 161 km. The inner shelf
is flat whereas the outer shelf is highly irregularall the way to its edge (140 m) being formed ofpinnacles and knolls with intervening depressions.The continental slope of the west coast of Indiais gradual.
Materials and Methods
Eight stations were covered during the saidcruise. At the station 47 (lat. 19°15·0'N andlong. 69°45·0'E), a pipe dredge was used andit came up with coral rocks and oolite limestones.The snapper did not get any sample at this localityand therefore for planktonic foraminiferal analysisonly 7 samples Were taken. The method of separating the Foraminifera from the ~amples is sameas earlier4. Percentages of various planktonicspecies present in the samples have been calculated (Table 2). Station locations, sampling times andbottom character are given in Table 1 and data onwater deptbs, salinity, temperature, calcium carbonateand total number of Foraminifera are presentedin Figs. 2 to 6. Calcium carbonate content of thesediment samples was determined using the method
ARABIAN I SEA
19· I _46
."
Fig. 1 - Station locations in the Arabian Sea off Bombaywhere sediment samples were collected
1
INDIAN J. MAR. SC1., VOL. 1, JUNE 1972 ,I
is of importance a~ it will give an idea on theproblem of eustatic changes in sea level along theWtst coast of India.
Planktonic foraminiferal species - Twenty-t\\Ospecies of planktonic Foraminifera belonging to9 genera and 2 families, viz. Globigerinidae andGloborotaliidae, are identified. The fauna isdominated by warm water species and with theexception of Globigerina bulloides, all ot.her coldwater species reported in this paper are uncommon.The collection of planktonic Foraminifera in theArabian Sea off Bombay is typical of Indo-Pacificregion and the list of species is as follows:
Hastigerina pelagica (d'Orbigny), Fig. 7Orbulina universa d'Orbigny, Fig. 8Globigerinoides conglobatus (Brady), Fig. 9Globigerinoides ruoer d'Orbigny, Fig. 11Glooigerinoides sacculifer (Brady), Fig. 10Globigerina rubescens Hofkel', Fig. 12Globigerina quinqueloba Natland, Fig. 13Globigerina pachyderma (Ehrenberg), Fig. 14
Globigerina falconensis Blow, Fig. 15GlolJigerina bulloides d'Orbigny, Fig. 16Glubigerina calida Parker, Fig. 17Globigerinella aequilateralis (Brady), Fig. 18Globigerinella adamsi (Banner and Blow), Fig. 20Globigerinita glutinata (Egger), Fig. 19Globoquadrina dutertrei (d'Orbigny), Fig. 21Globoquadrina conglomerata (Schwager), Fig. 22PuZleniatina obliquitoculata (Parker and Jones),
Fig. 23Globorotalia truncatulinoides (d'Orbigny), Fig. 24Globorotalia hirsuta (d'Orbigny), Fig. 25Globorotalia menardii (d'Orbigny), Fig. 26Globorotalia tumida (Brady), Fig. 27Globorotalia menardii jlexuosa (Koch), Fig. 28
The total population of planktonic Foraminifera shows greater variation in abundance atvarying depths in the continental shelf region ofthe Bombay coast and the sediments in the sloperegion are quite rich in planktonic Foraminifera.The area of greatest planktonic foraminiferalabundance (34750 specimensfg dry sediment) is thesite No. 44. High concentrations of planktonicForaminifera have been observed in the slope regionoff Bombay. In the shelf region concentration ofplanktonic Foraminifera varies from 750 to 9150specimens{g dry sediment.
Planktonic foraminiferal species found in allthe samples are: Hastigerina pelagica, Orbulinauniversa, Globigerinol:des conglobams, G. ruber, G.sacculifer, Globigerina falconensis, G. bulloides, Globigerinella aequilateralis, Globigerinita glutinata, Globoquadrina dutertrei, PulZeniatina obliquiloculata, Globorotalia menardii and G. tumida ..
Three of the 22 species recorded are found at4 sites only, they being Globigerina quinqueloba,G. calida and G. pachyderma.
Planktonic foraminiferal species found at 2 sitesare: Globigerinella adamsi and Globorotalia hirsuta.
Planktonic forms observed at one station onlyare: Globorotalia truncatulinoides and Globorotalia
menardii jlexuosa.The general relationship between planktonic for
aminiferal number (number of planktonic foraminiferal specimens present in one gram of dry sediment)and depth indicated that the number increases
46
FIG.6
FIG.5
f1G.4
FIG.3
45STATION NUMBER
2 43
Ecological data and distributional trend of planktonic foraminiferal fauna
f..:2: 1000
l;: wCla: 1500w i
o
TV!.OOO« '"~ __~ 27D. '" •••::E",a:w::>::> 26•...• 1-C11--"':=-25
500
TABLE'1 - DATA ON BOTTOM SEDIMENTS FROM THEARABIAN SEA OFF BOMBAY
..~. 35z~::; 34«~---33'ioWU 70U"a:U
~ 50-----30~ffi 30000•..Z
!~20f::E
::>
yZZ~ 10'"z~D.
Figs. 2-6
of Hutc~inson and Maclennan as described byBarnes6•
Results
The b ttom sediment samples can he classifiedinto 5 c tegories, viz. silty clay, silty sand, sand,sandy si and silt. The sediments from the shoreto a de h of 62 m are silty clay; from depths of62 to 96 the deposits are either silty sand or sandand fro the outer shelf towards the sea the deposits a found to be sandy silt or silt. Seawardfrom 62 m to a depth of 96 m a calcareom: zoneis found It i~ possible that the calcareous material mus have been derived largely from the flagmentati of coral rocks as well as from oolitelimeston s. Evidence for this observation couldbe made on the basis of rock fragments and coralsthat Wer dredged from sites 42 and 47. The finding of t e oolites and coral rocks at these otatiom
Station ateLatitudeLongitudeBottomNo.
969) character
40
71118°34'5'Nn022'0'ESilty clay41
71118°35·7'N71°33'5'ESilty sand42
81118°36'0'N70039'4'ESand43
8/118°33·5'N70021'6'ESandy silt44
81118°35'0'N70003'O'ESilt45
81118°49'O'N69°47'5'Edo46
81119°03'O'N69°30'4'Edo
2
KAMESW ARA RAO: PLANKTONIC FORAMINIFERA FROM E. ARABIAN SEA
O.3mm O.8mm O.Smm
7 8 90
130
11011b
O·3mm
O·1mm
13b
10b
03Smm
O·2mm
12b120
100
140O.15mm
14b
O·2mm
15b 150
Figs. 7-15 - Planktonic foraminiferal species [(7) Hastigerina pelagica, (8) Orbulina universa, (9) Globigerinoides conglobatus, (10) Globigerinoides sacculifer, (11) Globigerinoides ruber, (12) Globigerina rubescens, (13) Globigerina quinqueloba,
(14) Globigerina pachyderma, and (15) Globigerina falconensis. a, dorsal view; and t, ventral view]
3
INDIAN J. MAR. SCI., VOL. 1, JUNE 1972
O.2mm
16b0.35 mrn
230
21b
19b
0·2mm
0.35mm
17b
O.3mm
23b
190
170
18b
O.35mm
22b
Figs. 16-23 -t Planktonic foraminiferal species [(16) Globigerina bulloides, (17) Globigerina calida, (18) Globigerinellaaequilateralis, I (19) Globigerinita glutinata, (20) Globigerinella adamsi, (21) Globoquadrina dutertrei, (22) Globoquadrina conglomej'ata, and (23) Pulleniatina obliquiloculata. a, dorsal view; and b, ventral view]
4
KAMESW ARA RAO: PLANKTONIC FORAMINIFERA FROM E. ARABIAN SEA
240O.2mm.--J24b 250
L-0·2mm
25b
260Q.5mm
26b 270
O.4mm
27bJ
2801·0mm
28b
Figs. 24-28 - Planktonic foraminiferal species [(24) Globorotalia truncatulinoides, (25) Globorotalia hirsHta, (26) Globorotalia menardii, (27) Globorotalia tumida, and (28) Globorotalia menardii flexuosa. a, dorsal view; and b, ventral view]
5
INDIAN J. MAR. SCI., VOL. 1, JUNE 1972
TABLE 2 - PERCENTAGE OCCURRENCES OF PLANKTONIC FORAMINIFERAL SPECIES
Plttnktonic Station number;pecies
-----_.~---40
414243444546
Depth, m:
628796204182016601460
Hastigerin
pelagica 1·21-42·61·21-60·20·4Orbulina
iversa 9,69·87·25·22·62·03·2Globigerin 'des conglobatus
3-23,03,41·01·01·01'2Globigerin des ruber
30,832·033·036·238·228·841·0
Globigerin 'des sacculifer
4-63-01·01'211·23,65,0Globigerin
rubescens 0'60'60·40,60,40·2
Globigerinquinqueloba --1·01·00·20'4
Globigerinpachyderma 0·20·41·22·0
Globigerinfalconensis 2·83,04'82·22·03-45·2
Globigerinbulloides 15·815·216·020'16,812'68,8
Globigerincalida -0,4-0·21·2-1·0
Globigerine la aequilateralis4,84,43·65,05·21·83,0
Globigerine la adamsi
---1·00·2--Globigerini a glutinata
14,815·416·216,610'818·212·8Globoquadr na dutertrei
5·24,81-41-63,85,84,6Globoquadr na conglomerata
1·6-0·8-1·00'40·2Pulleniati
obliquiloculata 0,81-43·22·66·010·06·2Globorotali
truncatulinoides ---0'2
Globorotalihirsuta --1·80·4
Globorotalimenardii 2·60,80'40,43·22'81·0
Globorotalitumida 1·23,81'60'43-48,86,4
Globorotalimenardii flexuosa ----1'2
<
{~-
j
It
I
with dep and di5tance from the shore (Fig. 6). Theslope se 'ments are represented by larger numberof specie.
Studie on this group have shown that in theslope se 'ments the percentage of CaCOa increaseswith the abundance of planktonic Foraminifera.
Discuss' n
Quant' ative analysis of planktonic Foraminiferafrom the sediments bas shown that the silty sandand san dep05it,; contain only a few forms whereasthe sand silt and silt deposits are fairly rich invariety nd numerical abundance. The sedimentsof the c ntinental slope region are represented bya larger number of specimens of planktonic Foraminifer than th05e of the shelf. It can be infeaedthat low concentrations of planktonic Foraminiferain the sl elf region is due to low productivity ofthis gro p in the shelf waters.
The s diments in the shelf region off Bombayare fairl rich in CaCOa and the content of CaCOavaries f m 38 to 66%. Seaward from 62 m toa depth f 96 m, a calcareous sand zone exi5ts andin this a ea CaCOa varies from 52 to 66% and thecalcareo s material is largely derived from thecoral ro s and oolite limestones. From the edgeof the ntinental shelf and continuing into theslope, C COa content in the dep05its varies from30 to 4 X>. The content of CaCOa in the pelagicsedimen is actually the balance of the two processes, iz. produotivity of calcareous organismsand the action of water on the deposited calcareousremains7 It has been found that in this region thesource 0 calcareous material is dominantly fromfloating calcareous organisms, namely planktonicForamin era, and in the deposits of this area CaCOacontent nCleases with the number of planktonicForamin ela (Fig. 5). This confirms the observationof Corre S8 that the amount of CaCOa in the siltis propo ional to the number of foraminiferal tests.
6
The planktonic foraminiferal species from theeastern part of the Arabian Sea can be classifiedinto two categories: warm and cold water species.Some dominant warm water species in the ArabianSEa off Bombay are: Hastigerina pelagica, Globigerinoides ruber, G. sacculifer, Globigerinetla aequilateralis, Orbulina universa :md Gioborotalia tumida.All the cold water species which ale rare with theexception of Globigerina bulloides are Globigerinapachyderma and G. quinqueloba. The occmrenceof cold water species with warm water species inthe bottom sediments of tllf Arabi2n Sea off Bombay is an indication of the mixing of the Antarcticwater with other types of water, viz. the Indianequatorial water, the Red Sea water and the Indi?ncentral water found along the west coast of India.It is also known that the upwelling of the coldbottom "\-vaters of the Antarctic comes to thesurface in the Arabian Sea when confronted with theCarlsberg Ridge9.
In connection with the mixing of the two typesof faunal elements, it is worth mentioning aboutan interesting species, namely GlobOiotalia mcnardiiflexuosa (Koch). Ericson et al.lO observed specimen,; of GI. m. flexuosa at certain Quaternarylevels of Atlanitc deep-sea cores and it was considered by these authors on the basis of this observatron that this subspecies became extinct afterhaving lived about 90000 to 125000 yeals ago ina circumtropical belt in the Atlantic, Indian andPacific Oceans during the warm Interstadial ofthe Wisconsin and the Sargamon Interglacial.Furthermore, this subspecies has not been recordedso far in the recent deposits of the Atlanticand Pacific Oceans. Based on this available information that this subspecies is an extinct one,Bhattll reported by the presence of forms resembling Gl. m. flexuosa along with other sp~cies ofplanktonic Foraminifera flOm a sample flOm theouter shelf region off the Visakhapatnam coast,
(
KAMESW ARA RAO: PLANKTONIC FORAMINIFERA FROM E. ARABIAN SEA
that the mixing of the two faunal categorie!' is• relict' in nature but this conclusion is not truein view of the fact that Be' and McIntyre5 coulddiscover living specimens of the same species inthe northern Indian Ocean which includes Bay ofBengal and Arabian Sea. From this report wecan conclude that it is still living dnce its inception. Report of Be' and McIntyre5 about the presence of Gl. m. flexuosa from the sediment samplesof the present investigation is further an evidenceof its presence in the Arabian Sea besides Bay ofBEngal and other adjacent seas of northern IndianOcean.
Our knowledge of planktonic Foraminifera present in the Red Sea is mainly from the contJibutions of Said12, Herman13 and Berggren andBoersma14• Said12 recorded 5 plankton~c forms.Herman13 reported 16 species from the samples ofthe Red Sea. Further studies on ~his g10Up fromthe Red Sea by Berggren and Boersma14 have shownthat some species like Orbulina universa, Gloligerinella acquilateralis, Globigerinoidcs ruber andG. sacculifer are dominant. In the off~hore regionof Bombay, the above-mentioned species are quiteabundant. Globigerinoides ruber which is knownto tolerate high salinity conditions in the Red Seais very dominant in the offshore region of Bombay.Out of the 16 species reported by Hermanl3, 14of them are encountered in the samples of the dudyarea. From the results of the present investigation and those of earlier studies by Chapman1 andStubbings2 it is ::ieen that thEre is some identityof the pla.nktonic foraminiferal fauna of the RedSea with that of Arabian Sea. This similarity ofplanktonic foraminiferal fauna in both the seassuggests that the Red Sea watEr has spread intothe offshore region of Bombay. This finding isof importance as it i", the only available biologicalevidence so far for the mixing of Red Sea waterwith that of Arabian Sea. Physical evidence forthis phenomenon is that of Rochford15 who hasshown the presence of Red Sea water along the
west coast of India on the basis of T-S characteristics.
AcknowledgementThe author expresses his deep gratitude to Dr
N. K. Panikkar, Director, for advice and suggestions during the C(,Ulse of the investigations andto Dr Allan W. H. Be' of Lamont GeologicalObservatofY, Pali~ades, New YOlk, USA, for discussions on certain protlems during the study.Thanks are due to CaptaiL F. L. Fraser and otherofficer s and crew of INS 'Darshak' for theircooperation in collecting samples. The authoris also thankful to Dr T. S. S. Rao, Regional Centreof National Institute of Oceanography, Cochin,for his encouragement and to his colleagne ShriC. V. Gangadhara Reddy, for help in the determination of the chemIcal composition of sediments.
References1. CHAPMAN,F., Proc. Zool. Soc., (1895), 1.2. STUBBINGS, H. G., Scient. Rep. John Murray Exped.,
1933-34; 3(1939), 31.3. KAMESWARARAO, K., J. Bombay nat. Hist. Soc., 66
(1969), 584; 67 (1970), 137; 68 (1971), 9.4. KAMESWARARAO, K., Proc. Indian Acad. Sci., 73 (1971),
155.5. BE', A. W. H. & McINTYRE, A., Deep Sea Res., 17 (1970),
595.6. BARNES, H., Apparatus and methods of oceanograPhy
(George Allen & Unwin Ltd, London), 1959, 341.7. MURATA,K. J. & ERD, R. C., J. sedim. Petrol., 34 (1964),
633.8. CORRENS,C. W., Naturwissenschaften, 26 (1937), 196.9. SEWELL, R. B. S., Mem. Asiat. Soc., Beng., 9 (1929),207.
10. ERICSON,D. W., EWING, M. & WOLLIN, G., Deep Sea Res.,3 (1956), 104.
11. BHATT, D. K., Contr. Cushman Fdn foramin. Res., 20(1969), 30.
12. SAiD, R., Contr. Cushman Fdn foramin. Res., 1 (1950), 9.13. HERMAN, Y., Etude des sediments quaternaires de laMer
Rouge, Doctoral thesis, University of Paris, 1965.14. BERGGREN, W. A. & BOERSMA, A., cited in Hot brines
and recent heavy metal deposits in the Red Sea, edited byE. T. Degens & D. A. Ross (Springer-Verlag Inc.,New York), 1969, 282.
15. ROCHFORD,D. J., Aust. J. mar·freshwat. Res., 15 (1964), 1.
7