Endorsement and Sponsorship Agreement Pitfalls:...
Transcript of Endorsement and Sponsorship Agreement Pitfalls:...
Endorsement and Sponsorship Agreement Pitfalls: Promoting and Protecting Brands Negotiating Exclusivity, Morals Clauses, Termination and IP Rights With Local and National Celebrities and Athletes
Today’s faculty features:
1pm Eastern | 12pm Central | 11am Mountain | 10am Pacific
The audio portion of the conference may be accessed via the telephone or by using your computer's speakers. Please refer to the instructions emailed to registrants for additional information. If you have any questions, please contact Customer Service at 1-800-926-7926 ext. 10.
WEDNESDAY, DECEMBER 18, 2013
Presenting a live 90-minute webinar with interactive Q&A
Seth A. Rose, Partner, Loeb & Loeb, Chicago
Jay Shanker, Of Counsel, McAfee & Taft, Oklahoma City
Steven B. Smith, Partner, Bryan Cave, Colorado Springs, Colo.
Tips for Optimal Quality
Sound Quality If you are listening via your computer speakers, please note that the quality of your sound will vary depending on the speed and quality of your internet connection. If the sound quality is not satisfactory, you may listen via the phone: dial 1-866-961-8499 and enter your PIN when prompted. Otherwise, please send us a chat or e-mail [email protected] immediately so we can address the problem. If you dialed in and have any difficulties during the call, press *0 for assistance. Viewing Quality To maximize your screen, press the F11 key on your keyboard. To exit full screen, press the F11 key again.
FOR LIVE EVENT ONLY
Continuing Education Credits
For CLE purposes, please let us know how many people are listening at your location by completing each of the following steps:
• In the chat box, type (1) your company name and (2) the number of attendees at your location
• Click the SEND button beside the box
If you have purchased Strafford CLE processing services, you must confirm your participation by completing and submitting an Official Record of Attendance (CLE Form).
You may obtain your CLE form by going to the program page and selecting the appropriate form in the PROGRAM MATERIALS box at the top right corner.
If you'd like to purchase CLE credit processing, it is available for a fee. For additional information about CLE credit processing, go to our website or call us at 1-800-926-7926 ext. 35.
FOR LIVE EVENT ONLY
Program Materials
If you have not printed the conference materials for this program, please complete the following steps:
• Click on the ^ symbol next to “Conference Materials” in the middle of the left-hand column on your screen.
• Click on the tab labeled “Handouts” that appears, and there you will see a PDF of the slides for today's program.
• Double click on the PDF and a separate page will open.
• Print the slides by clicking on the printer icon.
FOR LIVE EVENT ONLY
NEGOTIATING ENDORSEMENT AND SPONSORSHIP AGREEMENTS WITH
CELEBRITIES, ATHLETES AND PROPERTIES
Seth Rose Loeb & Loeb LLP
Strafford Publications, Inc. Webinar
December 18, 2013
With a celebrity, athlete or other personality: A brand engages a personality to associate and appear in connection with the brand in various activities and media
With a property (team, league, facility/venue): A brand pays for the right to use assets associated with that property and to be directly associated with that property
In most (if not all) such arrangements, both sides benefit from the mutual association with one another
What are endorsement and sponsorship agreements?
6
T-Mobile and Major League Baseball
Examples
Derrick Rose and Adidas
7
∗ Build brand awareness ∗ Validate product features ∗ Boost brand equity ∗ MAKE MORE MONEY! “recognition at the highest levels of corporations
that sponsorship is a potent answer to the challenge of how to build attention, support, and loyalty for brands…” ∗ IEG, LLC, a leading consultant in the sponsorship industry that
has been providing insights, evaluation, and guidance to the industry for over thirty years
What drives brands to enter into these deals?
8
Endorsement and sponsorship agreements can take on different forms:
Can be fairly short business-term heavy documents, or
Can be long and involved agreements with a myriad of legal provisions and considerations
No matter how long or detailed the agreement, there are several provisions that must be present in properly drafted endorsement and sponsorship agreements.
The Agreement
9
Key Provisions and Considerations
10
What is the personality being asked to do? Commercials, media tour, social media activities, appearances
How many service days? What constitutes a service day? Where will the services take place?
How many of each type of service are expected? Is there a maximum or minimum amount?
What happens if the services are not performed to the brand’s satisfaction? Re-shoot? Reduction in payment?
Services
11
What rights are being granted from the personality to the brand?
Name, image, likeness, performance, signature What types of materials are being created? Through what forms of media will the brand be able
to exploit the rights? TV, radio, digital, mobile, print, OOH
What is the duration of the usage rights? Retention of rights for award and trade shows, internal
Rights/Usage
12
What if you are dealing with a property – what other items should be considered?
Designations “Official Partner”, “Exclusive Provider”, etc. Should be delineated, but build in flexibility
Be cognizant of any restrictions on stated rights Ex: certain in-stadium rights may not be granted during special
events, concerts, etc. Ex: certain rights may be precluded in nationally broadcast games Ex: may not have full rights to images (i.e., copyright but not right
of publicity)
Rights/Usage (continued)
13
Must be clearly laid out Be detailed - avoid ambiguities, be certain everything that is
expected to be received is identified and described Often addressed via an exhibit to the Agreement
(particularly when dealing with a property) Include specific assets/activations/benefits that are to be
provided to the brand
Involve the business team and ask questions to make sure everyone is thinking of all possible avenues for receipt and exploitation of rights
Rights/Usage (continued)
Practice Tips
14
What level of approval does each party have over what the other party does?
Brand wants final say on creative and to limit personality’s approval to use of the personality’s name/image/likeness in materials
Personality may push for creative input and approval over more than name/image/likeness, including things such as concepts, themes, final edits, etc.
If new products are being created that bear likeness or will be associated with the personality, then the personality may have more approval/control
Approvals
15
How long is the approval time – i.e., how far in advance does creator need to provide approving party with sample(s) of the materials?
What does “silence” mean? Default position may differ depending on the position of the party
Can the approving party withdraw approval? If so, what are the parameters of withdrawal? Need to have strong justification to withdraw
Allow reasonable sell-off
Try to avoid recall efforts for materials already in distribution
Approvals (continued)
16
Additional considerations for when dealing with a property:
Brand tries to push for property to only have approval over the use of the property’s trademarks in materials
Approval may be different depending on the media (e.g., if the materials are in the property’s stadium/complex, there may be a broader right of approval – and ability to reject for any reason – than when the materials appear on the brand’s website)
Approvals (continued)
17
Particularly in the higher cost and more prestigious arrangements, there will be an expectation that the arrangement is exclusive
Tends to be category-based => the personality/property is precluded from entering into a similar deal, or any type of advertising / marketing / promotional arrangement with any competitors or any entity offering products/services in the brand’s category
Could be current or prospective conflicts
Exclusivity
18
Often a battle – brand wants a broad category, personality (or property) wants a narrow category
Can include listing of specific products and/or specific competitors
Be forward-thinking
What products/services may be related or considered in the category during the Term?
Any new developments or innovations, or new areas of service, that a party wants to make sure are covered in its exclusive category?
Any new property-related offerings during the Term?
Exclusivity (continued)
19
Sometimes only the category-related products or services of a company that may otherwise be a competitor are included within the category
Ex: wireless services of AT&T, but not AT&T U-Verse cable television services Ex: automobiles from General Motors, but not automobile
financing services Ex: credit cards from Chase, but not personal banking
services
Exclusivity (continued)
20
Additional Restrictions and Concessions: Public use of competitive products? The personality may not agree to be precluded
from appearing in entertainment (TV shows, radio, musicals, films, other events) if sponsored by a competitor The property may not agree to be precluded from
selling advertising time (i.e., broadcast television, radio) or space (i.e., print, website) to competitors
Exclusivity (continued)
21
There are certain general things that each party should represent and warrant to in each deal. They include: • Each party has the power and authority to enter into the agreement, to
grant the rights granted, and to perform its obligations under the agreement
• Agreement does not materially conflict with, violate, or result in a breach or default of any other agreement
• Parties will comply with all applicable federal, state and local laws, rules, and regulations
Representations and Warranties
22
• When dealing with a personality, the brand (and the personality) will want to ensure the personality complies with the FTC’s Guides Concerning the Use of Endorsements and Testimonials in Advertising
• Identify material connection • Statements based on true and actual experience • Often push for brand approval over any statements about the brand
Representations and Warranties (continued)
23
• In a sponsorship agreement with a property, may want to include language that the property is responsible for safety and security of all attendees, visitors, staff, players, coaches, vendors and other persons in and around its property
Representations and Warranties (continued)
24
How long is the agreement intended to last?
Will there be an opportunity to renew? If so, will it be exclusive and how long of
a window will there be for renewal negotiations?
Term
25
When dealing with a property… Is there a right of first refusal to enter into a
renewal?
ROFR: gives a party the exclusive right to enter into a deal with the property before anyone else can.
What about a right of last refusal?
ROLF: gives the sponsor the right to match any third party offer to enter into a deal with the property.
Term (continued)
26
Brand can terminate agreement with personality for various reasons Uncured breach Death/disability Morals violation
Termination
27
Morals clauses ∗ Not just convicted of a felony ∗ Anything that negatively affects the brand,
as determined by the brand in its sole discretion
Termination (continued)
28
Brand can terminate agreement with property for various reasons Uncured breach Bankruptcy events Not usual for these types of
agreements to include the right to terminate for convenience
Termination (continued)
29
∗ What are the remedies if a brand has to terminate early? ∗ Scale of remedies
∗ Full return of compensation ∗ Pro-rata refund ∗ No further payments
Termination (continued)
30
∗ Other panelists will address other considerations and provisions (Term, Territory, Compensation, Union issues, Indemnities, Publicity, etc.)
Other Provisions
31
Example Clauses
32
Exclusivity (when dealing with a personality)
During the Term, Talent will not: (a) appear in any commercial or participate in other services or advertising or promotional activities for the purpose (or with the effect) of advertising, endorsing or promoting any other product or service from any company that provides ______________ (each, a “Company Competitor”), whether or not compensated for such activities, nor shall Talent grant anyone the right to use Talent’s name, picture, image, likeness, voice, or performance in connection with the advertising, promotion, or endorsement of any Company Competitor or any Company Competitor’s products or services; (b) disparage or denigrate Company, its products or services, the materials created hereunder, or Talent’s association with Company; or (c) publicly use any product or services of a Company Competitor.
Example Clauses
33
Exclusivity (when dealing with a property)
During the Term of this Agreement, Property shall not grant any rights to use Property’s intellectual property to any third party other than Sponsor in the category of ___________ [Define “Category”], nor shall Property enter into any agreement similar in nature to this Agreement, or grant any advertising, marketing, promotional, or sponsorship rights to any third party other than Sponsor in the Category.
Example Clauses
34
Morals clause
Company shall have the right to terminate this Agreement by written notice to Talent in the event that, during the Term, Talent is charged with or convicted of any criminal conduct amounting to a felony, or has committed or commits any act or becomes involved in any conduct that is likely to adversely affect Company or Company’s image, brand, reputation, products or services. Company’s decision on all matters arising under this section shall be conclusive, and its rights under this section shall be in addition to any other rights or remedies, which Company may have hereunder or at law or in equity.
Example Clauses
35
Right of First Refusal Sponsor shall have the right of first refusal to renew the Term with Property on materially similar terms as herein by giving written notice to Property during the Term. Property and Sponsor shall then have a ________ day exclusive negotiation period (“Negotiation Period”) from Property’s receipt of Sponsor’s written notice. During the Negotiation Period, Property will not solicit or negotiate with another entity with products or services that fall within Sponsor’s Category (as defined herein) for any sponsorship, advertising, marketing, or promotional rights. In the event Sponsor and Property cannot come to agreement during this Negotiation Period, despite good faith efforts to do so, Property may enter into negotiations and an agreement with any third parties, including entities with products or services that fall within Sponsor’s Category, regarding any sponsorship, advertising, marketing, or promotional rights.
Example Clauses
36
Right of Last Refusal
Include the ROFR language, and then follow with this language:
If the resulting terms of those negotiations are more favorable to the entity in Sponsor’s position than the terms discussed during the Negotiation Period, Property shall present such terms to Sponsor and shall provide Sponsor with thirty (30) days to evaluate and attempt to match those terms. If Sponsor decides not to match those terms, Property may enter into an agreement with the applicable third party.
Example Clauses
37
Representations and Warranties Each party hereto represents and warrants to the other as follows:
• It has the full power and authority to enter into this Agreement and to perform its obligations hereunder;
• Its execution and delivery of its performance under this Agreement have been duly authorized by all necessary corporate or other action (as applicable), and, to its knowledge, have not, do not, and will not materially conflict with, violate, result in a breach or default of or otherwise materially adversely affect any existing agreement to which it is a party or any rights of any third person or entity, whether now existing or hereafter arising or occurring;
• This Agreement is a legal, valid, and binding obligation of it, enforceable against it in accordance with its terms;
• It owns all right, title and interest in and to, or has the right to license the use of any of its intellectual property granted hereunder; and
• It will comply with all applicable federal, state, and local laws, rules and regulations in connection with its performance hereunder and in connection with the operation, management, and administration of its business.
Example Clauses
38
Endorsement and Sponsorship Agreement Pitfalls: Promoting and Protecting Brands
Navigating the Deal with the Individual
Artist/Musician/Athlete/Celebrity
JAY SHANKER, OF COUNSEL
(405) 552-2385
© 2013 All Rights Reserved
THE “WHY”: WHAT DRIVES DEALS?
THE “BUYER” PERSPECTIVE -- Company, Brand, Agency, Etc.:
1. Is there a Story? (“Fit” Should be Credible)
2. Will Affiliation Hold/Expand Audience/Clientele/Customer Base?
3. Will Affiliation Provide Advantages Against Competing Brands/Products (Market Share)?
4. Will Affiliation Increase Revenues/Profitability (Sales Volume and/or Premium Pricing)?
THE “ARTIST” PERSPECTIVE -- Entertainers / Athletes / Celebrities:
1. Money (But not Always)
2. Brand/Product Affinity - Integrity of Match Up?
3. Exposure/Overexposure Issues
AGENTS / BROKERS – And if involved, Who is the “Client”; Territories; Fees.
40
WHO/WHEN/WHERE? (with “WHAT”, to follow)
THE PARTIES: 1. Buyer (Company, Agency, Other) 2. Artist (Individual Athlete/Musician/Actor/Celebrity (or their “Corporation”)) 3. Any Other Party(s) with Relevant Consultation, Approval or IP Controls?
BRAND/PRODUCT/ SERVICE TO BE SUPPORTED:
Event, Venue, Product, Brand, Other (One, Bundle, Etc.)
TERRITORY: 1. Local, State, Regional, National or International (or a Particular Foreign Country/Region) 2. Options to Expand/Contract
TERM: 1. Initial Term 2. Optional Renewal(s) / Extensions / Expansions? 3. “Post Term” Liquidation Period (Products, Media, Etc.)
41
THE “WHAT”?
SCOPE (AND LIMITATIONS) OF RIGHTS / SERVICES REQUIRED
1. Rights
A. Name, Photo/Likeness/Signature/Voice/Artist’s (or Affiliated) Marks/Logos
B. For Use In/With – Products, Ads (TV, Radio, Web, Print, Billboards, In-Store and Point of Purchase), Product (Venue) Name/Labeling, Etc.
2. Services
A. Commercials (#, media, time required, location and scheduling issues)
Guild Issues
Third Party Consult/Approval Requirements re Rights/Scheduling
B. Appearances -- Press and Media Junkets, Events, Conventions/Tradeshows, Corporate Events, and (Musical) “Performances”
42
FOR EXTRA “POINTS” ENDORSEMENT:
1. Scope
2. Additional Services Required?
3. FTC Rules Compliance (http://www.ftc.gov/sites/default/files/documents/one-stops/advertisement-endorsements/091005revisedendorsementguides.pdf)
A. Disclose Consideration
B. Endorsement Must Reflect Real Use
C. Affidavit Requirement From Artist Regarding Use
EXCLUSIVITY:
1. Category – i.e., Brand/Product/Service/Etc.?
2. Term
3. Territory
4. Conflicting Artist Commitments/Third Party Approvals Required
5. Artist Requirements re “Buyer” Exclusivity
GENERALLY, PRICE GOES UP WITH INCREASED FORMAL ENDORSEMENT AND/OR EXCLUSIVITY REQUIREMENTS/RESTRICTIONS
43
“SHOW ME THE MONEY”
COMPENSATION AND PAYMENT SCHEDULE:
1. Fixed Fees
A. Advance/Guaranty – Tied to Days/Usage, End-of-Term “Shortfalls”, etc.
B. Pay or Play?
C. Payment Schedule
2. Contingent Fees
A. “Fixed” Triggered by Events within Talent Control vs. Buyer “Control”
B. Percentage of Sales (or Sales Increases) During Term or Beyond - Gross; Adj. Gross; Net;
C. Stock, Etc.
3. Trade-Outs (Travel, Goods, Services, Etc.)
4. Expenses
44
“COMMUNICATIONS”
CONSULTATION/APPROVALS:
1. Use of Name/Likeness/Photo (Both as to Images Selected and Where/How Used?)
2. Product & Packaging Design/Quality
3. Ads/Commercials/Promotional Materials/Promo Goods
4. REPORTING OF BUYER MEDIA / SALES – USAGE AND PERFORMANCE
PUBLICIZING THE DEAL:
1. Publicity Coordination (Who Controls Announcement(s)?)
2. Confidentiality (Terms of Deal; Business/Product Information)
3. Non-Disparagement (Individuals/Entities/Products/Services)
4. Other Restrictions/Holdbacks
WHO’S DESIGNATED TO CONTROL CONSULTATION/APPROVALS/COMMUNICATIONS FOR EACH SIDE?
45
IN THE EVENT OF FIRE, BREAK GLASS INDEMNITIES AND INSURANCE:
1. Buyer Concerns – Artist Death/Disability/Disfigurement/Material Change in Stature; Failure to
Perform
2. Artist Concerns – Accident/Injury Coverage during Services; General Liability and E&O re Product
and Ad/Marketing Campaign; Change in “Brand” Stature
SUSPENSION / EXTENSION / TERMINATION:
1. Death / Disability
2. Failure To Perform
3. Materially Changed Circumstances
4. Force Majeure
5. Morals Clauses
6. Effect Of Early Termination -- Kill Fees/Penalties
7. Remedies - Damages vs. Equitable Relief; Suspend/Accelerate Payments; Etc.
REMEDIES:
1. Jurisdiction/ Choice Of Law / Court vs Arbitration
2. Economic (including Liquidated Damages) vs. Equitable Relief (By Brand? By Talent?)
46
“AND SHOULD YOU WISH TO RECONSIDER….”
DECEASED CELEBRITIES
ENTERTAINMENT (AND SPORTS) PROPERTIES AND CHARACTERS
47
ENDORSEMENT AND SPONSORSHIP AGREEMENT PITFALLS DECEMBER 18, 2013 STEVEN SMITH BRYAN CAVE LLP [email protected]
SPONSORSHIPS INVOLVING LEAGUES, GOVERNING BODIES AND FACILITIES
49
Corporate Sponsorships
The focus of this portion of the presentation is on several types of corporate sponsorships that often don’t involve athletes: Naming rights – the naming of a facility; Title sponsorships – adding corporate name or brand to
the title of an event; Facility sponsorships – acquiring signage or other
advertising in stadiums, arenas, etc. Governing body sponsorships and event – associating
with a league or event
50
Why These Sponsorships?
Companies enter into these types of sponsorships for a couple of reasons: Advertising – these sponsorships promote a company or
brand before many (sometimes millions) of loyal, passionate potential customers.
Goodwill – sometimes companies gain a great deal of goodwill by being associated with an event or league (Olympics);
Desire to help a cause
51
Key Issues
There are a number of key issues that sponsors must be aware of when negotiating these kinds of deals.
Failure to anticipate these issues can make the sponsorship much less valuable and can leave the sponsor unhappy, or worse.
52
Definition of Goods and Services
Typically, these deals are “exclusive” to the sponsor within its category of goods and services.
So, making sure that this definition is accurate and appropriately broad is key. Failure to get this correct can open the sponsor to ambush marketing.
Sometimes this is easy, but often it can be quite complex.
53
Definition of Goods and Services
Who are your main competitors? Make sure the definition clearly excludes them.
Who might become your main competitors? Make sure your definition can catch those potential future
competitors. Do you have any key subsidiaries/affiliates who need
protection? This may need to be included.
How might your business change in the near future? Make sure this new business will be adequately protected.
54
Scope of Exclusivity
Understand the extent of your exclusivity. Many sports are set up such that sponsorship of one
area does not give you exclusivity over the entire sport.
For example, NASCAR. Sponsorship of NASCAR does not cover the cars or
drivers in almost all cases. Are you OK with this? If not, do you need to buy out
those other assets?
55
Dominant Sponsor
In larger deals, particularly naming rights, a sponsor wants to be sure it is seen by the public as “the” main sponsor of a property. For example, there should be no confusion as to who is the naming rights partner.
However, surveys have shown that the existence of another large sponsor with significant benefits can be confused with the naming rights or title sponsor.
Often, we include provisions that prohibits a property from having another sponsor with a certain ratio of signage to the naming rights partner or title sponsor.
There are other ways to lock in this protection.
56
Payment
Believe it or not, structuring the payment can be a big issue.
Often, a sponsor wants to hold back payment of a portion of the sponsorship fee until the end of the term to “maintain leverage” over the property to fulfill its obligations.
The property, on the other hand, wants as much money as possible as quickly as possible.
This issue tends to be heavily negotiated. Is any part of the payment being made through “value-
in-kind” goods or services? If so, how are those valued?
57
Intellectual Property Issues
Sponsorship Agreements create a whole host of intellectual property issues: Is there a joint logo involved? If so, who owns it? What is the scope of the sponsor’s license rights to use the
sports property’s logo and other marks? Don’t assume that you have a blanket right to use the marks in any circumstances.
Under what circumstances may the sports property use the sponsor’s logos?
What kind of approval rights does the sponsor have over advertising and promotions?
Who is responsible for quality control?
58
Naming Rights and Title Sponsorships
If your sponsorship involves any naming rights or title sponsorship, there are a number of additional issues to consider: To what extent does the sports property have control to
ensure the naming rights or title sponsorship is recognized by others (media, other sponsors, etc.)?
Who is responsible to protect against ambush marketing? Does the sports property have the wherewithal to handle that enforcement?
What happens if your business changes? What happens if your name changes?
59
Renewal or Extension of Sponsorship
The right to renew or extend the agreement can be extremely important for a number of reasons: If the property is successful, you want to be able to
maintain the relationship; You may have invested a lot into the relationship, you
don’t want to lose it when it is becoming valuable.
60
Renewal or Extension of Sponsorship
There are a few different ways to structure renewal/extension rights: Option to extend Right of first refusal Right of first negotiation
Some protection is important, because you do not want to give the sports property an incentive to be focusing on other prospective sponsors in your product category in the latter stages of your sponsorship.
61
Protection in Case of Certain Occurrences
Because your sponsorship is tied so closely to the success or failure of an event or organizations, you want to make sure you have protection (such as the ability to terminate) in case things go bad.
Some examples: Occurrences that put the event or organization, and by
association the sponsor, in a bad light (Janet Jackson wardrobe malfunction)
Bad acts by the sports property or key individuals
62
Protection in Case of Certain Occurrences
Some examples (cont.): Poorly maintained facility Acts of God that force a cancellation of an event or
certain benefits that are important to you.
There is no set formula for the remedies for these occurrences. So, it is important that you think through what might happen and what remedies you want in place in case these things happen.
63
Assignment and Changes
One issue that tends to be negotiated heavily, particularly in longer deals, is what happens if there is a significant change in the sponsor. Some examples include: Merger or acquisition; Acquisition of new businesses The sports property expands.
64
Assignment and Changes
If your company is going through a merger, the last thing you want to happen is for a sponsorship to hold it up or create issues to address.
So, many sponsors try to build in a liberal assignment provision. However, keep in mind that the property will push back on this, as it wants to control with whom it does business.
65
Conclusion
Obviously, this is just a sample of some of the issues that arise in connection with a sponsorship.
However, you can see from this cross-section of issues that anticipation and careful planning up front is critical and will help avoid disputes, frustration and perhaps even litigation down the road.
66
Thank You
Seth Rose Loeb & Loeb LLP [email protected] Jay Shanker McAfee & Taft [email protected] Steven Smith Bryan Cave LLP [email protected]
67