“One of the many divine qualities of the Bible is that it does not yield its secrets to the...

48
The Word The Compilation of the Bible

Transcript of “One of the many divine qualities of the Bible is that it does not yield its secrets to the...

Page 1: “One of the many divine qualities of the Bible is that it does not yield its secrets to the irreverent and the censorious.” --James I. Packer.

The WordThe Compilation of the Bible

Page 2: “One of the many divine qualities of the Bible is that it does not yield its secrets to the irreverent and the censorious.” --James I. Packer.

The Word – The Compilation of the Bible

“One of the many divine qualities of the Bible is that it does not yield

its secrets to the irreverent and the censorious.” --James I. Packer

Page 3: “One of the many divine qualities of the Bible is that it does not yield its secrets to the irreverent and the censorious.” --James I. Packer.

The Word – The Compilation of the Bible

How did we get the Bible?

Page 4: “One of the many divine qualities of the Bible is that it does not yield its secrets to the irreverent and the censorious.” --James I. Packer.

The Word – The Compilation of the Bible

“The Bible did not arrive by fax from heaven…The Bible is the product of man, my dear. Not of God. The Bible did not fall magically from the clouds. Man created it

as a historical record of tumultuous times, and it

has evolved through countless translations,

additions, and revisions. History has never had a definitive version of the

book..” --Dan Brown in The Da Vinci

Code

Page 5: “One of the many divine qualities of the Bible is that it does not yield its secrets to the irreverent and the censorious.” --James I. Packer.

The Word – The Compilation of the Bible

Canon

‘Measuring Rod’; ‘Standard’; ‘Rule’

Canon refers to the collection of books that passed a test of authenticity and authority; it also means that those books are our rule

of life – both in this world and the next.

Page 6: “One of the many divine qualities of the Bible is that it does not yield its secrets to the irreverent and the censorious.” --James I. Packer.

The Word – The Compilation of the Bible

•Written over about 1,500 years• 66 books – 39 in the Old; 27 in the New• 40 authors

Page 7: “One of the many divine qualities of the Bible is that it does not yield its secrets to the irreverent and the censorious.” --James I. Packer.

The Word – The Compilation of the Bible

The Old TestamentOrder of original Hebrew Bible

The Pentateuch

Also referred to as “The Law”. Includes

Genesis, Exodus, Leviticus, Numbers, and Deuteronomy

The Prophets

Includes former prophets such as Joshua, Judges,

Samuel, and Kings. Major prophets such as Isaiah, Jeremiah, and Ezekiel. Also 12

minor prophets

The Writings

Psalms, Job, Proverbs, Ruth, Song of Songs, Ecclesiastes,

Lamentations, Esther, Daniel, Ezra,

Nehemiah, Chronicles

Old Testament primarily written in Hebrew and Aramaic. Contained consonants only (no vowels; added later by Masoretes – Jewish

scholars - around A.D. 500). Oldest book is Job (not Genesis) with last book written likely being Nehemiah around 424-400 B.C.

Page 8: “One of the many divine qualities of the Bible is that it does not yield its secrets to the irreverent and the censorious.” --James I. Packer.

The Word – The Compilation of the Bible

The New Testament

The Gospels

Matthew, Mark, Luke, John

Church History

Acts

Apostolic Writings

Paul, writer of Hebrews, Peter,

James, Jude, John

New Testament written in Greek. Earliest book is either Mark or Matthew with the last book being Revelation around A.D. 94-96.

Page 9: “One of the many divine qualities of the Bible is that it does not yield its secrets to the irreverent and the censorious.” --James I. Packer.

The Word – The Compilation of the Bible

The History of the CanonThe Old Testament

Moses writesPentateuch

Pentateuch Put in Ark(Deut 31:24)

Other inspired

texts added to

Ark

David puts books in treasury (1 Kings

8:6)

Books cared for by

priests (2 Kings 22:8)

Page 10: “One of the many divine qualities of the Bible is that it does not yield its secrets to the irreverent and the censorious.” --James I. Packer.

The Word – The Compilation of the Bible

The History of the CanonThe Old Testament

More books added during

Hezekiah

Exile in sixth

century; Canon

scattered

Ezra restores

Canon; last books added

Canon stored in

ark constructe

d for 2nd temple

Canon meticulously

copied

Page 11: “One of the many divine qualities of the Bible is that it does not yield its secrets to the irreverent and the censorious.” --James I. Packer.

The Word – The Compilation of the Bible

The History of the CanonThe Old Testament

Overview of Old Testament Formation and History

Pre-patriarchal period Creation – 2100 B.C.

Gen. 1:1-11:26

Patriarchal period 2100 – 1800 B.C. Gen. 11:27-50:26

Egyptian captivity/exodus

1800 – 1400 B.C. Ex. 1:1-Deut 34:12

Conquests/judges 1400 – 1050 B .C.

Josh. 1:1-1 – 1 Sam. 10:1

United Kingdom 1050 – 931 B.C. 1 Sam. 10:1 – 1 Kings 12:15

Divided Kingdom to fall of Israel to fall of Judah

931 – 722 B.C. 586 B.C.

1 Kings 12:15 – 2 Kings 16:6 2 Kings 25:26

Babylonian captivity and post-exilic period

586-420 B.C. 2 Kings 25:26-30Ezra; Nehemiah

Page 12: “One of the many divine qualities of the Bible is that it does not yield its secrets to the irreverent and the censorious.” --James I. Packer.

The Word – The Compilation of the Bible

The History of the CanonThe Old Testament

"from the blood of Abel to the blood of Zechariah, who was killed between the altar and the house of God; yes, I tell you, it shall be

charged against this generation.’"(Luke 11:51)

Jesus confirmed the 39 books of the Old Testament in this verse – Abel’s death is found in Genesis and Zechariah’s in 2 Chronicles 24:20-21 (the last

book in the Hebrew Bible)

Page 13: “One of the many divine qualities of the Bible is that it does not yield its secrets to the irreverent and the censorious.” --James I. Packer.

The Word – The Compilation of the Bible

The History of the CanonThe Old Testament

"It is true our history has been written since Artaxerxes very particularly but has not been esteemed of the like authority with the

former by our forefathers, because there has not been an exact succession of the prophets since that time.“

- Josephus, A. D. 95

Statement indicates Old Testament Canon was already intact

Page 14: “One of the many divine qualities of the Bible is that it does not yield its secrets to the irreverent and the censorious.” --James I. Packer.

The Word – The Compilation of the Bible

“Eventually, four Gospels and twenty-

three other texts were canonized into a Bible. This did not occur, however, until the sixth century.”

– Dan Burstein, Secrets of the Code, 116.

Page 15: “One of the many divine qualities of the Bible is that it does not yield its secrets to the irreverent and the censorious.” --James I. Packer.

The Word – The Compilation of the Bible

The History of the CanonThe New Testament

The truth is the composition of the New Testament was officially settled at the Council of Carthage in A. D. 397.

However, the majority of the New Testament was accepted as authoritative much earlier.

Page 16: “One of the many divine qualities of the Bible is that it does not yield its secrets to the irreverent and the censorious.” --James I. Packer.

The Word – The Compilation of the Bible

The History of the CanonThe New Testament

First collection of New Testament books proposed by Marcion in AD 140.

• Marcion was a Docetist. They believe all spirit is good, all material is evil (typically Platonic dualism) and also claim that Jesus only appeared human)

• Excluded Matthew, Mark, John • Included 10 of Paul’s letters,

but edited them

Page 17: “One of the many divine qualities of the Bible is that it does not yield its secrets to the irreverent and the censorious.” --James I. Packer.

The Word – The Compilation of the Bible

The History of the CanonThe New Testament

Next collection of New Testament books is the Muratorian Canon, dated AD 170. Included:

• All four gospels• Acts• 13 of Paul’s letters• 1, 2, 3 John• Jude• Revelation

Page 18: “One of the many divine qualities of the Bible is that it does not yield its secrets to the irreverent and the censorious.” --James I. Packer.

The Word – The Compilation of the Bible

The History of the CanonThe New Testament

The final New Testament Canon was first identified by the Church father Athanasius in A. D. 367 and ratified by the

Council of Carthage in A. D. 397.

Page 19: “One of the many divine qualities of the Bible is that it does not yield its secrets to the irreverent and the censorious.” --James I. Packer.

The Word – The Compilation of the Bible

Proof the New Testament was Recognized Early

"and regard the patience of our Lord as salvation; just as also our beloved brother Paul, according to the wisdom given him, wrote to you, as also in all his

letters, speaking in them of these things, in which are some things hard to understand, which the untaught and unstable distort, as they do also the rest of the

Scriptures, to their own destruction." (2 Peter 3:15-16)

"For the Scripture says, “You shall not muzzle the ox while he is threshing,” and “The laborer is worthy of his

wages.”" (1 Timothy 5:18; cf. Luke 10:7)

Page 20: “One of the many divine qualities of the Bible is that it does not yield its secrets to the irreverent and the censorious.” --James I. Packer.

The Word – The Compilation of the Bible

Proof the New Testament was Recognized Early

Writer Lived Gospel Quotes Quotes from Acts

Justin Martyr A.D. 133 268 10

Irenaeus A.D. 125 1,038 194

Clement (alex.)

A.D. 150-212 1,107 44

Origen A.D. 185-253 9,231 349

Tertullian A.D. 160-220 3,822 502

Hippolytus A.D. 165-235 734 42

Eusebius A.D 265-340 3,258 211

Totals - 19,368 1,352

Page 21: “One of the many divine qualities of the Bible is that it does not yield its secrets to the irreverent and the censorious.” --James I. Packer.

The Word – The Compilation of the Bible

Proof the New Testament was Recognized Early

• Matthew• Mark• Luke• Romans• 1 Corinthians• Ephesians• 1 Timothy• Titus• Hebrews• James• 1 Peter

Clement (c. A.D. 95)• Matthew• Mark• Luke• John• Acts• Romans• 1 & 2 Corinthians• Galatians• Ephesians• Philippians • Colossians • 1 Thessalonians • 1 & 2 Timothy

• Titus• Philemon • Hebrews• James• 1 & 2 Peter• 1 & 3 John • Revelation

Ignatius (c. A.D. 107) Polycarp (c. A.D. 110)• Matthew• Mark• Luke• John• Acts• Romans• 1 & 2 Corinthians• Galatians• Ephesians• Philippians • Colossians • 2 Thessalonians • 1 & 2 Timothy• 1 Peter & 1 John

Page 22: “One of the many divine qualities of the Bible is that it does not yield its secrets to the irreverent and the censorious.” --James I. Packer.

The Word – The Compilation of the Bible

A Christocentric View of ScriptureName Aspect Viewpoint

Law Foundation for Christ Downward

History Preparation for Christ Outward

Poetry Aspiration for Christ Upward

Prophecy Expectation of Christ Forward

Gospels Manifestation of Christ Downward

Acts Propagation of Christ Outward

Epistles Interpretation and application of Christ

Upward

Revelation

Consummation of Christ Forward

* Geisler and Nix

Page 23: “One of the many divine qualities of the Bible is that it does not yield its secrets to the irreverent and the censorious.” --James I. Packer.

The Word – The Compilation of the Bible

What was the test for canonicity?

Page 24: “One of the many divine qualities of the Bible is that it does not yield its secrets to the irreverent and the censorious.” --James I. Packer.

The Word – The Compilation of the Bible

1. Written by apostle (defined as person seeing Jesus Christ after His resurrection) or companion of apostle

2. No contradiction in core teachings of the faith (analogy of faith)

3. Accepted early and by majority of churches (catholicity)

Page 25: “One of the many divine qualities of the Bible is that it does not yield its secrets to the irreverent and the censorious.” --James I. Packer.

The Word – The Compilation of the Bible

The Canon and the ChurchIncorrect View Correct View

Determines Canon Discovers Canon

Mother of Canon Child of Canon

Magistrate of Canon Minister of Canon

Regulates Canon Recognizes Canon

Judge of Canon Witness of Canon

Master of Canon Servant of Canon

When the decision was made as to what books were canonical, the Church used the Latin term ‘recipemus’, which means “we receive.” What the Church

said is that we receive these particular books as being canonical, as being apostolic in authority and in origin, and therefore we submit to their authority.

It’s one thing to make something authoritative, and it’s another thing to recognize something that already is authoritative.

Page 26: “One of the many divine qualities of the Bible is that it does not yield its secrets to the irreverent and the censorious.” --James I. Packer.

The Word – The Compilation of the Bible

Challenges to the Canon

Page 27: “One of the many divine qualities of the Bible is that it does not yield its secrets to the irreverent and the censorious.” --James I. Packer.

The Word – The Compilation of the Bible

The Apocrypha“hidden” or “doubtful”

14 books, 11 accepted by CatholicsWas in original King James Bible

Page 28: “One of the many divine qualities of the Bible is that it does not yield its secrets to the irreverent and the censorious.” --James I. Packer.

The Word – The Compilation of the Bible

Why consider the Apocrypha for the Canon?

• New Testament cites it (e.g. Jude 6)• Greek Old Testament contained the books• Some early Church fathers cite them• Early catacombs had pictures from them• St. Augustine accepted them• Eastern Church accepts them• Early King James Bible had them• Cave with the Dead Sea Scrolls had them

Page 29: “One of the many divine qualities of the Bible is that it does not yield its secrets to the irreverent and the censorious.” --James I. Packer.

The Word – The Compilation of the Bible

• New Testament never refers to Apocrypha as Scripture; simply mentions statements in passing. Also cites pagan poets. • No one knows if original Greek Old Testament

contained it. • No Hebrew Bible ever had them• Many early Church fathers rejected them (e.g. Jerome,

who was a greater Biblical scholar than Augustine). Again, they may allude to them, but never cite them as Scripture (it is written…)• The catacomb pictures simply proves they contained

religious history• St. Augustine accepted them because he said they

contained stories of Christian martyrs; not test for canonicity• Eastern Church has not always accepted them• King James Bible had them in the middle; not included

in either Testament

Protestant Response to the Apocrypha

Page 30: “One of the many divine qualities of the Bible is that it does not yield its secrets to the irreverent and the censorious.” --James I. Packer.

The Word – The Compilation of the Bible

• Were found with the Dead Sea Scrolls, but no indication they were considered inspired. I have many books in my library too along with a number of Bibles. • No commentaries ever written on Apocrypha• Special parchment was used for Scripture; not used for

Apocrypha• No Apocryphal book written by prophet or apostle of

God• Contains non-Biblical doctrines (e.g. references to

works salvation; prayers for the dead)• Contains errors in geography • Never mentioned as being inspired in first 400 years of

the Church• Never quoted by Jesus • Never quoted by Philo (Jewish teacher who quoted

from all Old Testament books) or by Josephus as being Scripture

Protestant Response to the Apocrypha

Page 31: “One of the many divine qualities of the Bible is that it does not yield its secrets to the irreverent and the censorious.” --James I. Packer.

The Word – The Compilation of the Bible

The Documentary Hypothesis

The documentary hypothesis is a theory that challenges the authorship of the Pentateuch by Moses. It asserts many authors

wrote the first five books of the Bible and did so many years after the events took place. The theory was first asserted by a priest named H. B. Witter who noticed that two distinct names for God

(Elohim and Yahweh) were used throughout the book of Genesis. A French physician named Jean Astruc published a work on the same theory, but the one who provided the most force to the theory was

Julius Wellhausen who divided the Torah up into four distinct sections – J.E.D.P.

Page 32: “One of the many divine qualities of the Bible is that it does not yield its secrets to the irreverent and the censorious.” --James I. Packer.

The Word – The Compilation of the Bible

• Exodus 17:14: “Then the Lord said to Moses, ‘Write this in a book as a memorial and recite it to Joshua…”

• Exodus 24:4,7: “Moses wrote down all the words of the Lord…Then he took the book of the covenant and read it in the hearing of the people.”

• Exodus 34:27: “Then the Lord said to Moses, ‘Write down these words…”

• Numbers 33:2: “Moses recorded their starting places according to their journeys by the command of the Lord, and these are their journeys according to their starting places.”

• Deuteronomy 31:9: “So Moses wrote this law and gave it to the priests…”

• 1 Kings 2:3: ““Keep the charge of the Lord your God, to walk in His ways, to keep His statutes, His commandments, His ordinances, and His testimonies, according to what is written in the Law of Moses…”

• Matthew 19:8: “He said to them, “Because of your hardness of heart Moses permitted you to divorce your wives; but from the beginning it has not been this way.”

Biblical Support for Mosaic Authorship

Page 33: “One of the many divine qualities of the Bible is that it does not yield its secrets to the irreverent and the censorious.” --James I. Packer.

The Word – The Compilation of the Bible

• Mark 12:26: ““But regarding the fact that the dead rise again, have you not read in the book of Moses…”• John 5:46-47: “For if you believed Moses, you would

believe Me, for he wrote about Me. But if you do not believe his writings, how will you believe My words?” • John 7:19: “Did not Moses give you the Law, and yet

none of you carries out the Law? Why do you seek to kill Me?”• Acts 3:22: ““Moses said, ‘The Lord God will raise up for

you a prophet like me from your brethren; to Him you shall give heed to everything He says to you.”• Romans 10:5: “For Moses writes that the man who

practices the righteousness which is based on law shall live by that righteousness.”

Biblical Support for Mosaic Authorship

Page 34: “One of the many divine qualities of the Bible is that it does not yield its secrets to the irreverent and the censorious.” --James I. Packer.

The Word – The Compilation of the Bible

The Documentary Hypothesis

“Clap your hands, all peoples; Shout to God (יםRִהTֹלVֱא - Elohim) with the voice of joy. For the Lord (ִהR Yִהִו (Yahweh - י

Most High is to be feared, A great King over all the earth.”

- Psalm 47:1-2

Notice that the writer uses two different names for God in these verses.

Page 35: “One of the many divine qualities of the Bible is that it does not yield its secrets to the irreverent and the censorious.” --James I. Packer.

The Word – The Compilation of the Bible

The Documentary Hypothesis

Fifty-four Israeli scholars subjected the Pentateuch to the most rigorous linguistic syntactical evaluation that

any portion of the Bible has been submitted to by a computer program. The software analyzed objectively the work of those books, and in the end, the conclusion was this: There is no question that, from a statistical

standpoint, the first 5 books of the Bible were written by a single individual.

Page 36: “One of the many divine qualities of the Bible is that it does not yield its secrets to the irreverent and the censorious.” --James I. Packer.

The Word – The Compilation of the Bible

The Gnostic ‘Gospels’

“More than eighty gospels were considered for the New

Testament, and yet only a relatively few were chosen for

inclusion – Matthew, Mark, Luke, and John among them. . . . The

early church needed to convince the world that the mortal

prophet Jesus was a divine being. Therefore, any gospels that described earthly aspects of Jesus’ life had to be omitted

from the Bible.” --Dan Brown in The Da Vinci

Code

Page 37: “One of the many divine qualities of the Bible is that it does not yield its secrets to the irreverent and the censorious.” --James I. Packer.

The Word – The Compilation of the Bible

The Gnostic ‘Gospels’

• Accidentally discovered in 1945 near the Egyptian village of Nag Hammadi.

• Six Bedouin camel drivers were digging for fertilizer when one of them uncovered a human skeleton buried next to an earthenware jar.

• Inside the jar, they found thirteen leather-bound volumes containing fifty-two treatises.

• The books included Gospels (e.g. Thomas, Philip), Acts (e.g. Peter and the Twelve Apostles), letters (e.g. Peter to Philip) and Apocalypses (e.g. Paul, Peter).

Page 38: “One of the many divine qualities of the Bible is that it does not yield its secrets to the irreverent and the censorious.” --James I. Packer.

The Word – The Compilation of the Bible

The Gnostic ‘Gospels’

• Clearly Gnostic in their writing• Departure from core teachings of Scripture

(Nature of God, person of Christ, nature of mankind, salvation, view of women, etc.)

• Not written by apostle or companion of apostle• Rejected by early churches (e.g. Irenaeus)

Page 39: “One of the many divine qualities of the Bible is that it does not yield its secrets to the irreverent and the censorious.” --James I. Packer.

The Word – The Compilation of the Bible

The Mormon Version of Scripture

Joseph Smith, by ‘divine inspiration’, introduced thousands of changes

(additions, deletions, etc.) to the King James Version

of the Bible. Smith went so far as to add a passage in Genesis 50 that predicted

his own coming: “That seer will I bless . . . And his name shall be called

Joseph.”

Page 40: “One of the many divine qualities of the Bible is that it does not yield its secrets to the irreverent and the censorious.” --James I. Packer.

The Word – The Compilation of the Bible

The Book of Mormon

• The book of Mormon has been edited and revised over four thousand times – strange for something called out letter by letter by Joseph Smith from letters that divinely appeared to him, and something Smith called “the most correct of any book on earth.”

• Plagiarisms from the Bible are found in the book of Mormon – whole chapters in Isaiah from the 1611 version of the KJV have been lifted, including the italicized words, which are words inserted by the KJV translators (i.e. they are not divine).

Page 41: “One of the many divine qualities of the Bible is that it does not yield its secrets to the irreverent and the censorious.” --James I. Packer.

The Word – The Compilation of the Bible

The Canon We Have is Complete

• Jesus promised His followers would have “everything I have said to you” brought to them by the Holy Spirit (John 14:26); nothing would be omitted

• God’s providence ensures that what God revealed through inspiration would be preserved with nothing lost

• The meticulous preservation by the saints guarantees nothing was lost

• The end of the apostolic period removes any chance of extra-Biblical inspiration – the Church was built on their foundation (Eph. 2:20)

Page 42: “One of the many divine qualities of the Bible is that it does not yield its secrets to the irreverent and the censorious.” --James I. Packer.

The Word – The Compilation of the Bible

Why do we have different translations of the Bible?

Page 43: “One of the many divine qualities of the Bible is that it does not yield its secrets to the irreverent and the censorious.” --James I. Packer.

The Word – The Compilation of the Bible

John Wycliffe (ca. A. D. 1330-1384) is credited with creating the

first English translation of the whole Bible from the Latin

Vulgate. Later, William Tyndale created the first English

translation to draw directly from Hebrew and Greek texts, and the first to take advantage of the new medium of print, which allowed for its wide distribution. Tyndale

was arrested on the orders of King Henry VIII, jailed in the castle of Vilvoorde outside Brussels for

over a year, tried for heresy and burned at the stake. He was

strangled before his body was burnt.

Page 44: “One of the many divine qualities of the Bible is that it does not yield its secrets to the irreverent and the censorious.” --James I. Packer.

The Word – The Compilation of the Bible

Philosophies of Biblical Translation• Free Translation or Paraphrase: Translates the ideas from

the original text but without being constrained by the original words or language. Readable, but not always exact because interpretation depends upon the translators. Example: Peterson’s "The Message."

• Dynamic/Functional Equivalence: Does not translate by structural units or words but by “meaningful mouthfuls” or “thought by thought” with the goal being to reproduce a response in the reader that is equivalent to the response of the original readers. Examples: NIV, New English Bible.

• Literal or Formal: Starts with a word for word translation but will conform to the target language grammar (e.g. adding words); however it still remains lexically word-for-word. Examples: NASB, King James, New King James, ESV.

Page 45: “One of the many divine qualities of the Bible is that it does not yield its secrets to the irreverent and the censorious.” --James I. Packer.

The Word – The Compilation of the Bible

“Either the translator leaves the writer alone as

much as possible and moves the reader toward the writer, or he leaves

the reader alone as much as possible and moves the writer toward the

reader”- Friedrich

Schleiermacher

Page 46: “One of the many divine qualities of the Bible is that it does not yield its secrets to the irreverent and the censorious.” --James I. Packer.

The Word – The Compilation of the Bible

Example of Dynamic vs. Literal" Now when he saw the crowds, he went up on a mountainside and sat down. His disciples came to him, and he began to teach them,

saying:"(Matthew 5:1-2; Dynamic – NIV)

" When Jesus saw the crowds, He went up on the mountain; and after He sat down, His disciples came to Him. He opened His mouth and began to teach them, saying,"(Matthew 5:1-2; Literal - NASB)

Why does Matthew say Jesus “opened His mouth”? Is there anything important lost in the NIV by that omission? The Sermon on the Mount

is a parallel in Scripture to the giving of the law at Sinai. God gave Israel principles for the Theocratic kingdom and Jesus gives His

disciples principles for the Messianic kingdom. Deut. 8:3 says, “man does not live by bread alone, but man lives by everything that

proceeds out of the mouth of the Lord”

Matthew is depicting Jesus as reenacting the history of God’s Son, Israel; the Spirit inspires him to make this link between Christ and

God’s giving of the Law.

Page 47: “One of the many divine qualities of the Bible is that it does not yield its secrets to the irreverent and the censorious.” --James I. Packer.

The Word – The Compilation of the Bible

So What Bible Should I Use?Dynamic/Functional

EquivalenceLiteral/Formal Equivalence

Essence of Thought-for-Thought Sentence-for-Sentence

Proper Setting Target Language Source Language

Interpretation Thematic Interpretation Linguistic Interpretation

Meaning/Words Meaning Expressed without Words (Know Thought Apart from Words)

No Meaning Expressed without Words (Know Thought Through Words)

Locus of Meaning In the Mind In the Text

Goal Reproduce Same Effect Reproduce Same Meaning

Focus Response to the Message Form of the message

For Bible study, many conservative theologians recommend a Bible produced from a literal / formal equivalence framework (e.g. NASB, ASV, ESV, KJV, NKJV). It doesn’t mean you should throw out your Bible if it’s not one of these, but it may be good to have one as a

reference.

Page 48: “One of the many divine qualities of the Bible is that it does not yield its secrets to the irreverent and the censorious.” --James I. Packer.

The WordThe Compilation of the Bible