Novel High Temperature Carbide and Boride Ceramics for ... › sites › default › files ›...
Transcript of Novel High Temperature Carbide and Boride Ceramics for ... › sites › default › files ›...
Novel High Temperature Carbide and Boride Ceramics for Direct Power ExtractionElectrode ApplicationsPI: Zhe Cheng ([email protected])
Presentation By: Andrés Behrens ([email protected])
Crosscutting Research Portfolio Review
3‐23‐17
Funding Provided By: United States Department of Energy
Grant Number: DE‐FE0026325
FOA Information: DE‐FOA‐0001242
Institution: Florida International University
Project Duration: 10.01.2015 – 09.30.2018
3/27/2017 1
Goal & ObjectivesGoalDevelop nano carbide and boride ceramic solid solution via novel synthesis and processing for hot electrodes for direct powder extraction (e.g., magnetic hydrodynamic, MHD) systems and gain understanding of the fundamental composition‐processing‐structure‐property relationships for the material systems
Specific Objectives (SO) Synthesize nano composites powders of
solid solution for selected carbides and borides via solution‐based processing
Process dense nano‐structured carbide and boride solid solutions and related composites via novel flash sintering process
Test various composition‐processing‐structure‐property relationships for nano carbide and boride solid solutions for their potential as electrodes for direct powder extraction (DPE)
3/27/2017 2
OutlineBackgroundDPE via MHDBoride & carbide solid solution for DPE
MethodsNovel synthesis via solution processing Fast densification via flash sintering
Results (Hf‐Zr)B2 nano powder synthesisPreparation for flash sintering Green body formation Other experimental setup
Summary
Future Work
Acknowledgements
3/27/2017 3
Direct Power Extraction (DPE) via Magnetic Hydrodynamic Power (MHD) How Does DPE via MHD Work? Transform energy of moving ‘seeded’ (via Na+ or K+ ) plasma into electrical power in a magnetic field
Where Can DPE be Applied? Current Implementations: Add‐on Tech to Current Power Plants
Future Implementations: Space, Jet, and Rocket Exhaust
4
https://www.netl.doe.gov/newsroom/news‐releases/news‐details?id=7e0fa3a4‐8bba‐4464‐9245‐de7d94570e11
3/27/2017
Advantages of MHD GenerationNo moving mechanical parts Reduces mechanical lossesMore dependable operation
Reaches full power immediately
Potentially higher efficiency & lower cost
3/27/2017 5
Geo. A. Richards, https://www.netl.doe.gov/File%20Library/events/2013/co2%20capture/G‐Richards‐NETL‐Future‐Combustion.pdf
Why DPE via MHDs Not Widely Used?Extreme operational temperature Lack of feasible (electrode) material choices
Expensive to buildComplex materials processing
• High synthesis temperatures• Long processing times
3/27/2017 6
http://solarflower.forumactif.com/t4‐hydrodyne‐electrical‐generator
Challenges with DPE Electrode MaterialsRequirements for DPE electrodesGood electrical conductivity (>0.01 S/cm) & adequate thermal conductivityResistance to electrochemical corrosion (seed) & erosionResistance to thermal shock & arc attackCompatibility with other system materialsLimitations with DPE electrode materials studiedLow temperature DPE electrode (e.g., Cu): arching that decreases efficiencyHigher temperature DPE electrodes (~1200‐2000 oC): SiC: low conductivity and significant oxidation above ~1500 oC Doped LaCrO3: Cr vaporization at high temperature Doped ZrO2: Low electrical conductivity and susceptibility to electrochemical attack
7
Yongfei Lu, Vertically Aligned Carbon Nanotubes Embedded in Ceramic Matrices for Hot Electrode Applications (2014)
Rigel Woodside, IPT – Direct Power Extraction (2015), http://www.netl.doe.gov/File%20Library/Events/2015/crosscutting/Crosscutting_20150427_1600B_NETL.pdf
Boride and Carbide Solid Solutionsfor DPE ElectrodesBoride and Carbides are Attractive DPE Electrode MaterialsHigh melting points (e.g., ~3245 oC for ZrB2)Electrical and thermal conductivity close to metals (e.g., ~105 S/cm for ZrB2)
Limitations with Borides and Carbide as DPE ElectrodesInvestigated more than 40 years ago and “lost favor”Less than ideal oxidation resistance: e.g., up to ~1000 oC for ZrB2 and up to ~1500 oC for ZrB2‐SiC composites
New ApproachBorides and Carbide solid solutions for Improved Performance via Novel Processing
8
Indrajit Charit and Krishnan Raja, “Boride Based Electrode Materials for MHD Direct Power Extraction” http://www.netl.doe.gov/File%20Library/Research/Coal/cross‐cutting%20research/awards‐kick‐off‐2014/2014_UCR‐HBCU‐Kickoff_UIdaho.pdf
93/27/2017
http://physics.aalto.fi/groups/nanospin/facilities/pulsed-laser-deposition/
Hf or Zr(randomly mixed)
Solid Solution – an Example
(Hf‐Zr)B2
Three Systems ProposedHfB2‐ZrB2
HfC‐TiC
ZrB2‐CeB6
Potential AdvantagesTunable oxide shell composition for improved oxidation resistance & electrical propertiesTunable microstructure for improved thermal & mechanical propertiesNovel processing for reduced cost
Boride and Carbide Solid Solutionsfor DPE Electrodes
Experiment Methods OverviewSynthesis of Nano Solid Solution Powders via Solution‐based ProcessingNano powdersHigh purity and great uniformityVersatility in processingLow cost
Consolidation of Nano Powders into DPE Electrodes via Flash SinteringNew and fast (seconds rather than hours!)Low cost (energy & equipment)Nanostructure and better (mechanical) properties
3/27/2017 10
Carb
on p
recu
rsor
(e.g
., su
cros
e)
Met
al p
recu
rsor
s (e
.g.,
ZrO
Cl2,
HfCl
4)
Hydrolysis-Condensation
Mixed solution
Concentrationand drying
Pyrolysis(e.g., ~800 oC)
Carbothermal reduction reaction (CTR)
at 1100-1500 oC
Boro
n pr
ecur
sor
(e.g
., bo
ric a
cid)
Synthesis via Solution‐based ProcessingStarting MaterialsMetal precursorsWater soluble: HfCl4 , ZrCl4 , TiCl4Solvent soluble: Ti‐Butoxide, Zr‐PropoxideCarbon precursorsWater soluble: SucroseSolvent soluble: Phenolic ResinBoron precursorsWater soluble: Boric Acid (H3BO3)Solvent soluble: e.g., Tri‐Ethyl Borate (TEB)
Procedure using (Hf‐Zr)B2 as an ExampleUnderlying Carbothermal Reduction (CTR) Reaction:
113/27/2017
xZrO2 + (1-x) HfO2 + B2O3 + 5C (Hf1-xZrx)B2 + 5CO
Solution‐basedProcessing
A. (Aqueous) precursor solution mixing
A. Solution drying
B. Pyrolysis heat treatment at 700oC to obtain oxide‐carbon mixture
C. CTR heat treatment at >1450oC to obtain nano boride or carbide solid solution powder
D. Final product after CTR
12
A
3/27/2017
D
B C
E
3/27/2017 13
Pyrolyzed Material Composition
Solution processing and subsequent pyrolysis yields an oxide and (amorphous) carbon mixture
XRD for R1 Sample after 700oC/1Hr pyrolysis in Argon
3/27/2017 14
Pyrolyzed Material ‐ Morphology
Sample appears dense and uniform after pyrolysis
SEM images for R1 Sample after 700oC/1Hr pyrolysis in Argon
3/27/2017 15
Post CTR Material ‐ Composition
Solid solution for (Hf‐Zr)B2 obtained Trace carbide and oxide impurities remain
XRD for R1 Sample after 1500oC/1Hr CTR in Argon
3/27/2017 16
Verification of Solid Solution Formation
(Hf‐Zr)B2 XRD peaks rest in‐between those of pure HfB2 and ZrB2 confirming solid solution formation
Zoom‐in of XRD for R1 Sample after 1500oC/1Hr CTR in Argon
3/27/2017 17
Post CTR Material ‐ Morphology
Nano‐grained powder with agglomeration Variations in morphology typical of borides
SEM images for R1 sample after 1500oC/1Hr CTR in Argon
Recap on SynthesisSolution‐based processing advantagesNano powdersSimple processingLow Cost
Nano (Hf‐Zr)B2 solid solution powder obtained
Optimization neededTrace carbide & oxide impuritiesVariations In product morphology
3/27/2017 18
SEM for R1 sample after 1500oC/1Hr CTR in Argon
Green Body FormationDog‐bone shaped samples often used for flash sintering (Rishi Raj and co‐workers)
Two approaches explored for dog‐bone shaped green body formation
Slip Casting
Laser Cutting
3/27/2017 19
Green Body Formation via Slip Casting
3/27/2017 20
Slip castingA green body formation process of ceramics via pouring ceramic slip into a mold and allowing it to solidify
FeaturesSuitable for complex shapeLow costMass‐production ready
Green Body Formation via Slip Casting
Two recipes give good resultsDense, non‐porous structureNo chipping or cracksRespectable mechanical strength –sustaining a fall from the workbench (~4ft)
3/27/2017 21
Recipe YSZContent
BinderContent
Solvent(s)Content
5.2 21.1 wt.% 1.4 wt. %Arabic Gum (AG)
Water: 54.6 wt. %Ethanol: 22.9 wt.%
6.2 49.9 wt.% 1.76% PVA Water: 48.3wt.%
Plastic mold
Dog‐bone shaped green body samplefrom slip casting
Green Body Formation via Slip Casting
3/27/2017 22
Demonstration of Scalability Pre‐embedding of Lead Wires
Green Body Formationvia Laser CuttingLaser cuttingUse of high power pulsed laser to cut dry‐pressed samples
FeaturesSimple and fastAdaptable to intricate shapesLimited to low thickness
233/27/2017
Green Body Formationvia Laser Cutting
3/27/2017 24
Laser cutting at FIU CeSMECQuanta Ray Nd: YAG LaserMax Output: 50 J/Pulse Q‐Switch capability
Automated mechanical stage X, Y and Z functionality
Interfaced with computer/LabVIEW control
Green Body Formationvia Laser Cutting
Successful sample preparation via laser cutting5 laps at ~3 min/lap for clean cutSimple and good flexibilityLimitation: sample thickness only 0.250 mm
253/27/2017
Dry‐pressed Pellet Post‐cut Pellet Isolated Dog‐bone Shaped Sample
Recap on Green Body FormationSlip CastingSuccessful sample preparation using optimized recipe
Laser Cutting Successful sample preparation with
reasonable speed and flexibility Concern with sample thickness
3/27/2017 26
Optimization expected for BOTH when using in‐house synthesized nano carbide or boride solid solution materials
Ceramics often need sintering/densification
Traditional approaches to sintering Long processing times High energy consumption
Flash SinteringPioneered by Dr. Rishi Raj of U Colorado – Boulder
Rapid densification (in seconds!)Driven by applied (DC) electrical fieldSaves time & energyCarbides and borides not extensively studied
Flash Sintering for Ceramics Densification
3/27/2017 27
Cologna and Raj, Univ Colorado
In situ Flash Sintering
3/27/2017 28
Raj, Rishi. "Joule Heating during Flash‐sintering." Journal of the European Ceramic Society32.10 (2012): 2293‐301. Web.
Dr. Raj Group’s Video Showing Flash Sintering Change in Electrical Power Consumption in Flash Sintering
In House Flash Sintering Set‐up
29
Furnace
Electrical power supply
Metal wires (Ag) fed into furnace for conduction & power
Software/Computer for control
3/27/2017
Flash Sintering Preliminary TrialParameters Attempted: Voltage: 1V, 5V 25V, 50V and 100V
Current: 1A, 2A, 5A, 15A
Temperature: 850, 900, 950oC
303/27/2017
Flash Sintering Preliminary TrialApplied electrical field
Ramped up T & monitored if power surge would occur
Ag wire failed before flash due to creep
313/27/2017
SummaryNano Solid Solution Powder SynthesisNano crystalline (Hf‐Zr)B2 solid solution obtained via solution‐based synthesisOptimization needed due to trace carbide and oxide impurities & variations morphology
Preparation for Flash SinteringGreen bodies prepared successfully using both slip casting and laser cutting methodsIn house flash Sintering set up implemented, but prelimary trial not yet successful due to Ag electrical wires used
3/27/2017 32
Future WorkNano Solid Solution Powder SynthesisFine tune recipe and processingOxide impurities Increase Carbon precursor or alternativepyrolysis conditionCarbide impurities Increase Boron precursorMorphological non‐uniformity Optimize thermal processingWork on the other two systems
Densification of Nano Solid Solution Powders via Flash SinteringSwitch to Pt wireOptimization of flash sintering processModelingExperimental screening (Voltage, Ampere, Flash On Set Temperature)
3/27/2017 33
Composition‐Processing‐Structure‐Property
Relationships
AcknowledgementsDOE NETL Program Manager: Maria Reidpath
Co‐PI: Dr. Arvind Agarwal
Research Engineer: Dr. Andriy Durygin
Other Students: Driany Alfonso, Jose Fernandez Urdaneta
FIU Advanced Materials Research Engineering Institute (AMERI)
FIU Center for the Study of Matters Under Extreme Conditions (CeSMEC)
3/27/2017 34
¿Questions?
353/27/2017
Participants
PI: Dr. Zhe Cheng Ph.D. Georgia Tech (2008) Assistant Professor in Mechanical &
Materials Engineering of FIU Group website: https://ac.fiu.edu
Minority Ph.D. Student: Andrés Behrens B.S Rutgers University (2014) Joined FIU Materials Science & Engineering
Program in 2016 Summer
3/27/2017 36
TimelineTimeline for the project
37
MilestonesBudget period 1 Oct 2015 to Sep 2016
Sep 2016 Achieve <100 nm powders of HfC‐TiC and ZrB2 – HfB2 solid solution and/or related composites
Budget period 2 Oct 2016 to Sep 2017Dec 2016 Achieve <100 nm powders of ZrB2 – CeB6 solid solution and/or related
composites Jun 2017 Demonstrate flash sintered ceramics with >90% relative density
Budget period 3 Oct 2017 to Sep 2018Mar 2018 Achieve flash sintered HfC‐TiC, ZrB2 – HfB2 and ZrB2 – CeB6 solid
solution/composites with >90% relative densityJun 2018 Finish oxidation resistance evaluation for flash sintered solid
solution/compositesSep 2018 Finish electrical measurement for flash sintered solid
solution/composites
38
3/27/2017 39
PRESENTATION INSTRUCTIONS Please refer to the agenda for the time of your presentation and confirm when you arrive at the conference in case of last‐minute changes. A laptop and LCD projector will be available for your presentation, which must be in PowerPoint format (.pptor .pptx) uploaded to the conference website. Presentation files are to be named in the following filename format:PresentationDate_TimeSession_AgreementNumber_OrganizationAbbreviation.ppt(i.e., 20170320_0930A_FE0000xxxx_NETL.ppt) Projectors will be set to 16:9 widescreen format. Department of Energy and National Energy Technology Laboratory logos are attached for your use. Presentations are to follow the outline below:
Proposed Presentation FormatProjector Format: 16:9 widescreen
Slides 4 –N: Expand on Project on Each Project Outline Topic Should address each topic in the outline
COPYRIGHT LICENSE RELEASE INSTRUCTIONS Fill out release form, sign, and scan. Submit electronically in PDF format to Crosscutting‐Technology‐[email protected] 15, 2017. Please use the following format for the filename:2017_PresentationRelease_AgreementNumber_OrganizationAbbreviation.pdf(i.e.,2017_PresentationRelease_FE00000xxxx_NETL.doc) Copy the completedPROJECT METADATA table and paste in the body of the email with scanned PDF form.
INSTRUCTIONS REMOVE!!!!Slide 2: Project Goals and Objectives Include brief description of project goals and objectivesMilestones
3/27/2017 40
INSTRUCTIONS REMOVE!!!!Slide 3: Presentation Outline List topics to be covered in presentation background, methods, results, accomplishments, summaries, Status (?) future work
3/27/2017 41
Materials Systems to be Studied
42
(B) HfC‐TiCComplete solid solution w/ a miscibility gap
(A) HfB2‐ZrB2Continuous solid solution
(C) ZrB2‐CeB6Eutectic system with very limited solubility in solid
ZrB2 HfB2
Adjaoud, PHYS REV B (2009) 134112Ordan'yan, Soviet Powder Metallurgy and Metal Ceramics (1983) 946Fahrenholtz J. Am. Ceram. Soc., (2007) 1347
3/27/2017
XRD P. Pyro and Post CTR
3/27/2017 43
Evolution of Oxide, Boride and Carbide after CTR
Results: SyP. PYRO AND P. CTR NO FOIL
After Pyrolysis B2O3 RemainsMaybe be caused from reformation due to the absorption of moisture.
Upon undergoing Carbon Thermal Reduction (CTR) Production of Monoclinic Oxide phase Production of both (Hf‐Zr)C (Hf‐Zr)B2
P. CTR NO FOIL AND P.CTR G. FOIL
Addition of graphite foil helped reduce oxidation.Maybe help reduce any impurities in
inert gas source (Ar) or leaks Should be noted that foil will reduce
the diffusion of CO2 away from sample Processing parameters for all samples
were as follows: 1500oC for 1Hr for CTR700oC for 1Hr for pyrolysis.
3/27/2017 44
Green Body Formation via Slip Casting (1)
3/27/2017 45
Green Body Formation via Laser Cutting (3)Initial Attempt Parameters: Pellet Diameter: 10mm *Better Photos,
Ruler* Thickness: .250mm Dog Bone Size: 8mm Power Setting‐ 50J/Pulse Backing: Steel Plate 5 laps at ~2 Min Per laps 10 Mins Per Sample. With and Without Q‐switch
Problems & FindingsToo Small Sample To handleTape damaged sampleQ‐switch did not help too powerful
463/27/2017
Green Body Formation via Laser Cutting (3)
Pellet Diameter: 38 mm Thickness: 0.250 mm Dog Bone Gauge Length: 20mm Power Setting‐ 50J/Pulse Backing: Construction Paper 5 laps at ~3 Min Per laps 15 Mins for 3 Samples. (5 mins per Sample)
Improvements Construction Paper BackingProtected stage from damageEasier to transport samples to work station
Increased pellet size Increased product yieldEasier to remove and handle sample
Decreased sample time by half1 sample was 10 mins3 sample are 15 mins
473/27/2017
XRD P. Pyro and Post CTR
3/27/2017 48
Evolution of Oxide, Boride and Carbide after CTR
Ultra High Temperature Ceramics (UHTC)A Class Of Ceramics ‐ Inorganic, and Non‐metallic Solid (Compounds)UHTC Characteristics…High Melting Temperature (Tm)High Ultimate Usage TemperatureUHTC Chemical Composition
BoridesNitridesCarbides
3/27/2017 49
Where Are UHTCs Used
Leading Edge (Wing) Technology
Molten Metal Confinement
Furnace Insulation Wear Resistant
Surfaces High Temperature
Electrodes (HTEs)
3/27/2017 50
http://www.raytheon.com/news/feature/hypersonics_01.html https://c1.staticflickr.com/7/6073/6026390438_fe32e2371a_b.jpg
http://www.lubisol.com/furnace‐crown‐insulation.html http://p.globalsources.com/IMAGES/PDT/BIG/396/B1054545396.jpg
Flash Sintering for Ceramics DensificationTechniques Used to Improve Material Properties:
Field Assisted Sintering Techniques (F.A.S.T) Flash Sintering (FS)1.Rapid Solidification (RS) Spark Plasma Sintering (SPS)
Hot Pressing (HP)2.Vapor Deposition (VP)
3.Mechanical Alloying & Chemical Doping
3/27/2017 51
Flash Sintering Flash sintering is that the sudden onset of sintering which is accompanied by an equally abrupt increase in the conductivity of the specimen. The power supply must be switched to current control to prevent electrical runaway. For current control mode, power into the specimen declines, since the resistance continues to fall • Negative Feedback Loop Specimen temperature rises gradually during the power‐spike towards a quasi‐steady state value in current controlled mode
3/27/2017 52
Raj, Rishi. "Joule Heating during Flash‐sintering." Journal of the European Ceramic Society32.10 (2012): 2293‐301. Web.
Improvements To Be MadeImprovements To Make Platinum Wires Platinum Paint Primary Power
Supply limitsVoltage: 100 VAmpere: 15.75 Ω Secondary Power
Supply limitsVoltage: 20 VAmpere: 20 Ω
533/27/2017
SummarySynthesis Nano crystalline (Hf‐Zr)B2 solid solution obtained via solution‐based synthesis Optimization needed due to trace carbide and oxide impurities & variations
morphology.Green body formationGreen body prepared successfully using both slip casting and laser cutting
Flash SinteringDue to the usage of silver wires the maximum temperature we where able to reach in the furnace was ~950oC After holding at 950oC the wire mechanical reliability gave out and sample became detached
(Previous photo) According to the literature (R.Raj) 3YSZ has a flash on set temperature as low as 850oC for an
applied field of 120 V/cm
3/27/2017 54