North Dakota Geological Survey Deep Geothermal Resources ... maps/Williston100k/… · 163!( 180...

1
" " " " " " " " " " ! ( ! (! ( ! ( ! ( ! ( ! ( ! ( ! ( ! ( ! ( ! ( ! ( ! ( ! ( ! ( ! ( ! ( ! ( ! ( ! ( ! ( ! ( ! ( ! ( ! ( ! ( ! ( ! (! ( ! ( ! ( ! ( ! ( ! ( ! ( ! ( ! ( ! ( ! ( ! ( ! ( ! ( ! ( ! ( ! ( ! ( ! ( ! ( ! ( ! ( ! ( ! ( ! ( ! ( ! ( ! ( ! ( ! ( ! ( ! ( ! ( ! ( ! ( ! ( ! ( ! ( ! ( ! ( ! ( ! ( ! ( 163 180 181 183 Banks 1806 1804 1804 ( / 85 ( / 2 ( / 2 1804 Tren ton ( / 2 ( / 2 ( / 85 ( / 2 ( / 85 W I LL I AM S C O U N T Y M C K EN Z I E C O U N T Y W I L L I A M S C O U N T Y M C K E N ZI E C O U N TY W I L L I A M S C O U N T Y M C K E NZI E C O U N TY M I S S O U R I R I V E R W h i t e T a il B a y T o b a c c o G a r d e n B a y T o b a c c o G a r d e n C r e e k S a n d C r e e k S i x m i l e C r e e k C r e e k E i g h t m i l e P a i n t e d C r e e k W o o d s C r e e k S a n d L i t t l e M u d d y R i v e r Twin Lakes B l a c k t a i l C r e e k Blacktail Lake O t t e r T r a i l C r e e k C o w C r e e k C o w C r e e k W i l l o w C r e e k L i t t l e M u d d y R i v e r Lo ne Tr ee Lake E a s t F o r k E a s t F o r k L i t t l e M u d d y R i v e r McLeod Lake S t o n y C r e e k E p p i n g D a m S t o n y C r e e k W i l l o w C r e e k L o n e C r e e k C r e e k G a m a c h e T o b a c c o G a r d e n C r e e k N e l s o n C r e e k B e a v e r C r e e k B e a v e r C r e e k L A K E S A K A K A W E A L A K E S A K A K A W E A 5250 5000 4750 5250 5250 Ray Avoca Epping Temple Marmon Marley Wheelock Williston Bonetraill Lake Jessie Spring Brook West Bonetraill 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 6 1 6 6 1 6 6 1 1 6 1 6 1 6 6 1 1 1 6 6 6 6 6 6 1 1 1 6 1 1 1 1 6 1 1 1 6 1 1 6 1 1 1 1 1 1 6 1 1 6 1 1 6 1 6 6 6 6 1 1 1 6 6 6 6 1 1 6 6 1 6 1 6 1 6 6 1 6 6 6 6 6 6 6 6 6 6 6 6 6 36 36 36 31 36 31 36 36 36 31 36 36 36 31 31 36 31 36 36 36 31 36 36 36 36 31 31 36 31 36 36 36 36 36 31 31 36 31 36 36 36 36 36 36 31 31 31 31 31 31 36 31 31 36 36 36 31 36 31 31 36 36 31 36 36 31 31 31 36 31 31 36 36 31 36 31 31 31 31 36 36 36 31 31 31 31 31 36 31 31 31 31 31 31 6 31 31 31 31 104 o 00 ' 48 o 30 ' 103 o 00 ' 48 o 30 ' 104 o 00 ' 48 o 00 ' 103 o 00 ' 48 o 00 ' North Dakota Geological Survey 100K Series: Wlst - g - Kik Deep Geothermal Resources: Estimated Temperatures on Top of the Inyan Kara Formation R. 103 W. T. 1 57 N . T. 1 55 N . T. 1 53 N . T. 1 52 N . T. 1 54 N . R. 101 W. R. 100 W. R. 99 W. R. 98 W. R. 96 W. R. 97 W. R. 104 W. R. 102 W. R. 103 W. R. 101 W. R. 100 W. R. 99 W. R. 98 W. R. 97 W. T. 1 56 N . Carto graphic Compilation : Elroy L. Kadrmas R. 95 W. R. 102 W. Edward C. Murphy, State Geologist Lynn D. Helms, Director Dept. of Mineral Resources T. 1 58 N . R. 96 W. Williston 100K Sheet, North Dakota 1983 Magnetic North Declinati on at Center of S hee t 13 o 30 ' Note: This map was expanded beyond the normal Williston 100k Sheet to include an additional width of two miles to the Montana border. Williston 100K Sheet, North Dakota 153 154 155 156 157 158 160 161 162 163 164 165 166 168 169 170 171 172 173 174 176 182 Temperature/ o F 152 177 178 179 180 181 Geologic Symbols Depth (in feet from surface) To Top of Inyan Kara Formation Adjoining 100K Maps Mercator Projection 1927 N orth American Datum Shaded Relief - Vertical Exaggeration 9x Stand ard parallel 48 o 00 ' Central meridian 103 o 30 ' 0 1 2 3 4 Mil es Scale 1:100,000 ! Data Points. Selected points show temperature in o F 183 175 Other Features Wa ter County Boundary Unpaved Road Stream - Intermittent Paved Road River/Stream - Perennial State Highway ( / 85 Federal Highway 1806 167 159 Lorraine A. Manz 2007 References Gosnold, W.D. Jr., 1984, Geothermal Resource Assessment for North Dakota. Final Report: U.S. Department of Energy Bulletin No. 84-04-MMRRI-04. Where: T o = Surface temperature (in o C) Z i = Thickness of the overlying rock layer (in meters) K i = Thermal conductivity of the overlying rock layer n = Number of overlying rock layers Q = Regional heat flow T = T o + Z i (Q/K i ) n i 1 There are no reliable data sets for North Dakota that either list, or enable determination by extrapolation, subsurface temperatures for Cretaceous rocks. Bottom hole temperatures from oil well logs are unreliable and to assume that a simple linear relationship exists between temperature and depth would be incorrect. Although grossly linear the geothermal gradient in the upper lithosphere is significantly affected by thermal variables (heat flow and thermal conductivity) in the earth's crust. Any method used to accurately calculate subsurface temperatures must therefore take these factors into account. Provided the subsurface stratigraphy is known, Gosnold (1984) showed that at a given depth (Z) the temperature (T) can be represented by the following equation: Figure 1. Generalized stratigraphy of the Dakota Group. Age (MYr) Per iod 100 140 Rock Column Rock Unit De scr ip tion Mowry Newcastle Skull Creek Inyan Kara CRETACEOUS Sandstone, light-gray, fine- to medium-grained, silty; shale, medium- to dark-gray, soft, lumpy, fissile, micaceous. Shale, medium- to dark- gray, soft, micaceous, lumpy to massive, spongy; includes beds of bentonitic clay. Shale, medium- to dark- gray, micaceous, soft flaky to lumpy; sandstone, fine-grained, friable, calcareous, light-gray, glauconiti c; traces of pyrite and white bentonitic clay. Upper part: marine sandstone, light-gray, fine to coarse, quartzose; shale, gray, silty, lumpy. Lower part: nonmarine sandstone, medium to coarse, quartzose; occasi onal lenses of gray, bentonitic shale commonly contains Mn-FeCo3 spherulites. o F The Dakota Group contains the shallowest of four major geothermal aquifers that occur in the Williston Basin. The map shows calculated temperatures ( ) for the top of the Inyan Kara Formation, the oldest of the four rock units that comprise the Dakota Group (fig. 1). http://www.smu.edu/geothermal/ 100 o Geothermal energy is a renewable resource capable of producing an uninterrupted supply of electrical power and heat. In stable sedimentary basins, low-temperature energy ( < F) is extracted from the shallow subsurface (~8-400 feet) for use in domestic and commercial heating and cooling systems. Historically, deeper, hotter resources in these regions have not been developed because they were not economical. However, as the nation explores ways to reduce its dependency on foreign energy sources and also begins to look more closely at renewable energy, accessing deep geothermal energy resources, particularly via existing oil and gas wells, is attracting a great deal of interest ( ). For the data set used to produce this map K and Q were assumed to be constants. Mean surface temperature was calculated from monthly station normals (at Bismarck Municipal Airport, Fargo Hector Airport, Grand Forks International Airport, and Williston Sloulin Airport) for the period 1971 to 2000 (T 0 = 5.1 o C [41 o F]) T 0 , http://cdo.ncdc.noaa.gov/climatenormals/clim81/NDnorm.pdf ( ). Thermal conductivities (K) for formations overlying the Inyan Kara are shown in Table 1. Formation Thermal Conductivity (W/M K) Late Cretaceous, Paleogene and Neogene clays, silts and sands Pierre Greenhorn Mowry, Newcastle, Skull Creek 1.7 1.2 1.2 1.2 Table 1: Thermal conductivity estimates from Gosnold (1984) Regional heat flow (Q= 62 mW/m 2 ) was averaged from statewide data. Rock units and thicknesses were obtained from oil well log tops (July 2006 update). Temperatures were only calculated for wells where all relevant log tops were given since omissions (particularly for the Pierre Formation) do not necessarily imply that units are absent. Metadata used in the compilation of this map is available on CD.

Transcript of North Dakota Geological Survey Deep Geothermal Resources ... maps/Williston100k/… · 163!( 180...

Page 1: North Dakota Geological Survey Deep Geothermal Resources ... maps/Williston100k/… · 163!( 180 181 183 banks 1806 1804 1804 (/85 (/ (/2 2 1804 trenton (/2 (/ 2 (/85 (/85 w i l i

"

"

"

"

"

"

"

"

"

"

!(

!( !(

!(

!(

!(

!(

!(

!(

!(!(

!(!(

!(

!(

!(

!(

!(

!(

!(

!(

!(

!(

!(!(

!(

!(

!(

!( !(

!(

!(

!(

!(

!(!(!(

!(

!(

!(

!(

!(

!(

!(

!(

!(

!(

!(

!(

!(

!(

!(

!(

!(

!(

!(

!(

!(

!(

!(

!(

!(

!(

!(

!(

!(

!(

!(

!(

!(

!(

!(

!(

!(

!(163

180

181

183

Banks

1806

1804

1804

(/85

(/2(/2

1804

Tren ton

(/2

(/2

(/85

(/2

(/85

WILLIAMS C OUNTY

MCKENZIE COUNTY

WILL IAMS COUNT

Y

MC KENZIE

COUNTY

WI LL

IAMS

COUN

TY

MCK E

NZIE

CO

UNTY

MISS

OURI

RIVE

R

White Tail Bay

To bacc

o Gar

d en B

ay

T o b a c c o

G a r

d e n

C r e e

k

S a n dC r e e k

S i x m i l e

C r e e k

C r e e k

E i g h t m i l e

P a i n t e d

C r e e k

W o o d s

C r e e k

S a n d

L i t t l e

M u d d y

R i v e r

TwinLakes

B l a c k t a i l

C r e ek

Blackta ilLake

O t t e r

T r a i l

C r e e kC o w C r e e k

C o w

C r e e k

W i l l o w C r e e k

L i t t

l e

M u d d

yR

i v e r

Lone TreeLake

E a s tF o r k

E a s t

F o r k

L i t t l e

M u d d y

R i v

e r

McLeodLake

S t o n yC r e e k

E p p i n gD a m

S t o n

y

C r e e

k

W i l l o

w

C r e e k

L o n eC r e e k

C r e e k

G a m a c h e

TobaccoGar den

Creek

N e l s o n

C r e e k

B e a v e rC r e e k

B e a v e rC r e e k

L A K E S A K A K A W E A

L A K E S A K A K A W E A

5250

5000

4750

5250

5250

Ray

Avoca

Epping

TempleMarmon

Marley

Wheelock

Williston

Bonetrail l

Lake Jessie

Spring Brook

WestBonetrail l

11 111 11 616 6

1

6 6

11

6

1

6

1

6

61 11666 66 6

1

1

1

6

11 1 16 1

1

1 6

1

1

6

1 1

1

1

1 1

6

1

1

6

1

1 61

6

66 6

1

1 1

6

6

66 1

1

6

61

6

1616

6

16

66

6

6

6

6 6

6

6

6

6

6

36

3636

31

36

31

36

36

36

31

36

3636 31

31

36

31

36

36

36

31

36

36

3636

31 31

36

31

36

36

3636

36

31 31

36

31

36

36 36

36

3636 31

31

31

31

31

3136

31

31

36

36

363136

31 3136

36 31

36

3631

31

31

36

31

31 3636

31

36

31 31

31

31

36

36

36

31

31

31

3131

36

31

31

31

3131

31

6

31

31

31

31

104o 00 '48o 30 '

103o 00 '

48o 30 '

104o 00 '48o 00 '

103o 00 '48o 00 '

North Dakota Geological Survey100K Series: Wlst - g - Kik Deep Geothermal Resources: Estimated Temperatures on Top of the Inyan Kara Formation

R. 103 W.

T. 15

7 N.

T. 15

5 N.

T. 15

3 N.

T. 15

2 N.

T. 15

4 N.

R. 101 W. R. 100 W. R. 99 W. R. 98 W. R. 96 W.R. 97 W.

R. 104 W. R. 102 W.R. 103 W. R. 101 W. R. 100 W. R. 99 W. R. 98 W. R. 97 W.

T. 15

6 N.

Carto graphic Compilation : Elroy L. Kadrmas

R. 95 W.R. 102 W.

Edward C. Murphy, State GeologistLynn D. Helms, Director Dept. of Mineral Resources

T. 15

8 N.

R. 96 W.

Williston 100K Sheet, North Dakota 1983 Magne tic NorthDeclinati on at Center of S hee t

13o 30'

Note: This map was expanded beyond the normal Williston 100k Sheet to include anadditional width of two miles to the Montana border.

Williston 100K Sheet, North Dakota

153154155156157158

160161162163164165166

168169170171172173174

176

182Temperature/oF

152177178179180181

Geologic SymbolsDepth (in feet from surface)To Top of Inyan Kara Formation

Adjoining 100K Maps

Mercato r Projection 1927 N orth American Datum

Shaded Relief - Vertical Ex ag geration 9 xStand ard parallel 48 o 00' Central meridian 1 03o 30'

0 1 2 3 4

Miles

Scale 1:100,000

! Data Points. Selected points show temperature in oF

183

175Other Features

Water

County Boundary

Unpaved Road

Stream - Inte rmittent

Paved Road

River/Stream - Perennial

Sta te Highway(/85 Federal Highway

1806

167 159

Lorraine A. Manz2007

ReferencesGosnold, W.D. Jr. , 1984, Geothermal Resource Assessment for North Dakota. Final Report: U.S. Departmentof Energy Bulletin No. 84-04-MMRRI-04.

Where:To = Surface temperature (in oC)Zi = Thickness of the overlying rock layer (in meters )Ki = Thermal conductivity of the overlying rock layern = Number of overlying rock layersQ = Regional heat flow

T = To + Zi(Q/Ki) n

i 1

There are no reliable data sets for North Dakota that either list, or enable determination byextrapolation, subsurface temperatures for Cretaceous rocks. Bottom hole temperatures from oilwell logs are unreliable and to assume that a simple linear relationship exists betweentemperature and depth would be incorrect. Although grossly linear the geothermal gradient inthe upper lithosphere is significantly affected by thermal variables (heat flow and thermalconductivity) in the earth's crust. Any method used to accurately calculate subsurfacetemperatures must therefore take these factors into account. Provided the subsurfacestratigraphy is known, Gosnold (1984) showed that at a given depth (Z) the temperature (T) canbe represented by the following equation:

Figure 1. Generalized stratigraphy of the Dakota Group.

Age (

MYr

)Pe

riod

100

140

Rock Column Rock Unit Descr iption

Mowry

Newcastle

Skull Creek

Inyan Kara

CRET

ACEO

US

Sandstone, l ight-gray, f ine- to me dium-gra ine d, silty; sha le,medium- to da rk-gra y, soft, lumpy, fissile, micac eous.

Sha le, me dium- to da rk- gray, soft, mic aceous, lumpyto ma ssive, spongy; includes beds of bentonitic cla y.

Sha le, me dium- to da rk- gray, micace ous, soft flaky tolumpy; sa ndstone , fine-grained, fr iable, c alcareous,light-gray, glauconiti c; trace s of pyrite and whitebentonitic cla y.

Upper pa rt: marine sa ndstone , light-gra y, fi ne to coarse,quartzose ; shale, gra y, silty, lumpy. Lower part: nonma rine sa ndstone , me dium to coarse ,quartzose ; occa si onal lense s of gray, be ntonitic shalecommonly contains Mn-FeCo3 spherulit es.

oFThe Dakota Group contains the shallowest of four major geothermal aquifers that occur in theWilliston Bas in. The map shows calculated temperatures ( ) for the top of the InyanKara Formation, the oldest of the four rock units that comprise the Dakota Group (fig. 1).

http://www.smu.edu/geothermal/

100oGeothermal energy is a renewable resource capable of producing an uninterrupted supply ofelectrical power and heat. In stable sedimentary basins, low-temperature energy ( < F)is extracted from the shallow subsurface (~8-400 feet) for use in domestic andcommercial heating and cooling systems. Historically, deeper, hotter resources in these regionshave not been developed because they were not economical. However, as the nationexplores ways to reduce its dependency on foreign energy sources and also begins to lookmore closely at renewable energy, accessing deep geothermal energy resources,particularly via existing oil and gas wells, is attracting a great deal of interest( ).

For the data set used to produce this map K and Q were assumed to be constants. Mean surface temperature was calculated from monthly station normals (atBismarck Municipal Airport, Fargo Hector Airport, Grand Forks International Airport,and Williston Sloulin Airport) for the period 1971 to 2000

(T0 = 5.1o C [41o F])T0,

http://cdo.ncdc.noaa.gov/climatenormals/clim81/NDnorm.pdf( ).Thermal conductivities (K) for formations overlying the Inyan Kara are shown in Table 1 .

Formation Thermal Conductivity (W/M K)Late Cretaceous, Paleogene and Neogeneclays, s ilts and sands PierreGreenhornMowry, Newcastle, Skull Creek

1.71.21.21.2

Table 1: Thermal conductivity estimates from Gosnold (1984)Regional heat flow (Q= 62 mW/m2) was averaged from statewide data.Rock units and thicknesses were obtained from oil well log tops (July 2006 update).Temperatures were only calculated for wells where all relevant log tops were given sinceomissions (particularly for the Pierre Formation) do not necessarily imply that units are absent.Metadata used in the compilation of this map is available on CD.