NEXUS - swaniti.com · 2 Dear Readers: NEXUS is a monthly compilation of briefs, research insights,...

50
NEXUS

Transcript of NEXUS - swaniti.com · 2 Dear Readers: NEXUS is a monthly compilation of briefs, research insights,...

Page 1: NEXUS - swaniti.com · 2 Dear Readers: NEXUS is a monthly compilation of briefs, research insights, visualizations, and papers released by Swaniti. Our mission is to

NEXUS

Page 2: NEXUS - swaniti.com · 2 Dear Readers: NEXUS is a monthly compilation of briefs, research insights, visualizations, and papers released by Swaniti. Our mission is to

1

Disclaimer: The content of this compendium is for information purposes only. No legal liability or other responsibility is

accepted by or on behalf of Swaniti Initiative for any errors, omissions, or statements in the compendium. Swaniti Initiative

accepts no responsibility for any loss, damage or inconvenience caused as a result of reliance on such information.

Page 3: NEXUS - swaniti.com · 2 Dear Readers: NEXUS is a monthly compilation of briefs, research insights, visualizations, and papers released by Swaniti. Our mission is to

2

Dear Readers:

NEXUS is a monthly compilation of briefs, research insights, visualizations, and papers released by Swaniti. Our mission is to

provide information insights on developmental issues that will be catalytic in initiating ground level change. Swaniti’s

research insights are developed through a two-pronged approach: either elected officials request us for research support on

key policy pieces or Swaniti sees contextual value in developing certain research insights. We currently work with

Parliamentarians, policy makers and government enthusiasts on providing research insights on crosscutting issues. While we

make all of our content available online, our intent through this publication is to create a one-stop location for all Swaniti

information.

Since our primary objective is to support the vision and work in development being done by elected representatives, we also

present the experience of our Associates working on different projects pertaining to health, education, gender and livelihood

across the country with the intention of highlighting the challenges and the action initiated on the ground.

Moreover, aligned with our belief that data-driven policy discourse will ensure that decision making is more evidence based,

we have partnered with Indian Express for a web-based series titled 'Data and Democracy'. Through this platform, we

present our analysis on critical and contextual issues to the public and we have also included these visualizations in NEXUS.

The key policy level actions taken by the Government on a weekly basis are also a part of this compendium under the

section Policy Updates.

It is our sincere effort to disseminate our work through this compendium and seek your inputs and feedback to further

innovate and improve as we move forward.

In case you would like to know more about our monthly compendiums please feel free to contact the below signed:

Swati Gautam

Analyst, Swaniti Initiative

Email : [email protected]

About Swaniti: Swaniti is a non-profit, non-partisan group, which works with elected representatives and senior policy

makers to deliver development solutions across the country. The vision of the organization is to create a vibrant, better and

inclusive India. It is in line with this vision that Swaniti provides knowledge support and human resource support to elected

representatives in order to catalyze development at the grassroots.

Page 4: NEXUS - swaniti.com · 2 Dear Readers: NEXUS is a monthly compilation of briefs, research insights, visualizations, and papers released by Swaniti. Our mission is to

3

Dear Readers:

It is with great excitement that I am sharing with you our monthly Swaniti Compendium for the month of December! Every

month we release a series of briefs, information insights, data analysis and research reports on our website in pursuit of

informed policymaking. These releases are a combination of contextual insights and requests from Parliamentarians that we

feel will contribute to the policy discourse. They range from policy analysis on municipal bonds to insight on current

legislation in mental health. The content produced reflects our mission to deliver development solutions by providing

knowledge on key developmental issue. To disseminate our knowledge insights we are going a step further.

In the form of a monthly compendium, the Swaniti team hopes to take our information from online to print in a structured

manner. We figured rather than you needing to visit our website oh-so-frequently why not bring to you the information in a

print version. The goal is that at the first of every month we will be releasing the “monthly compendium” that will bring to

you in a concise and reader friendly manner and the information we have released that month. This compendium will be

available to you online and in print.

We hope that you will gain insights from our compendium. Excited about the new chapter.

Best,

RBA

Page 5: NEXUS - swaniti.com · 2 Dear Readers: NEXUS is a monthly compilation of briefs, research insights, visualizations, and papers released by Swaniti. Our mission is to

4

"Swaniti gives parliamentarians like me a great opportunity to harness the talent of professionals in the

governance of our respective constituencies, and I can tell you from my personal experience that I have

started to benefit hugely from this initiative.”

- Dinesh Trivedi, Lok Sabha MP (Barrakpore)

“By way of saying a big Thank You, I am specifically mentioning Swaniti in my intervention suggesting

that the Finance Minister consult with you and other similar social sector think tanks in preparing the

budget for next year.”

- Mani Shankar Aiyar, Rajya Sabha MP

“The two Swaniti fellows I had earlier worked with had professional degrees in engineering and

management and the current fellow is a professional, she has worked in important organisations

internationally. So, this is a good sign, these are professionals, qualified and they are bringing specific

skills where we have a need for them in the constituency and improving systems of governance.”

- Jay Panda, Lok Sabha MP (Kendrapara)

“The Swaniti Fellows that worked with me were well qualified individuals with a sense of social

responsibility. They analyzed government data, understood local challenges and provided solutions

specific to my constituency. I strongly encourage young individuals to understand our system of

governance and engage with policy makers through fellowships as well as internships. It’s good to have

a new perspective to things and work together to bring about change!”

- Anurag Thakur, Lok Sabha MP (Hamirpur)

“Swaniti has added real value to my constituency work and policy approaches. They have a team of

passionate and committed Fellows who have worked closely and tirelessly with my office and me to

provide high quality deliverables. I am very happy and satisfied with their amazing work.”

- PD Rai, Lok Sabha MP (Sikkim)

Page 6: NEXUS - swaniti.com · 2 Dear Readers: NEXUS is a monthly compilation of briefs, research insights, visualizations, and papers released by Swaniti. Our mission is to

5

About NEXUS ...........................................................................................................................................................................................................................2

From the Desk of the CEO ..................................................................................................................................................................................................3

Parliamentarians Speak........................................................................................................................................................................................................4

Tamra Patra ..............................................................................................................................................................................................................................6

Developing Rural Tourism ...........................................................................................................................................................................................8

Women Entrepreneurship in India ....................................................................................................................................................................... 12

Mid Day Meal Scheme ............................................................................................................................................................................................... 16

Pradhan Mantri Awas Yojana .................................................................................................................................................................................. 20

Disease Surveillance and Response..................................................................................................................................................................... 23

Data and Democracy ......................................................................................................................................................................................................... 28

MPLADs: Where was the money spent? ................................................................................................................................................................ 30

Section 12(1)(c) - Providing Reservation for Economically Weaker Sections ......................................................................................... 32

Research Support and Engagement with Elected Officials ................................................................................................................................ 34

Exploring Welfare Opportunities for the Siddi Tribe ........................................................................................................................................ 36

Nurturing Warm and Welcoming Learning Space in Nagrota ..................................................................................................................... 38

Weekly Policy Updates ...................................................................................................................................................................................................... 40

October 31st – November 6

th (Week 1) .................................................................................................................................................................. 42

November 7th

– November 13th

(Week 2)............................................................................................................................................................. 42

November 14th

– November 20th

(Week 3) .......................................................................................................................................................... 43

November 21st – November 27

th (Week 4) .......................................................................................................................................................... 44

Upcoming... ............................................................................................................................................................................................................................ 45

Page 7: NEXUS - swaniti.com · 2 Dear Readers: NEXUS is a monthly compilation of briefs, research insights, visualizations, and papers released by Swaniti. Our mission is to

6

Page 8: NEXUS - swaniti.com · 2 Dear Readers: NEXUS is a monthly compilation of briefs, research insights, visualizations, and papers released by Swaniti. Our mission is to

7

Tampra Patra is a Swaniti's knowledge repository through which we summarize briefs on government schemes and

programmes. We research implementation strategies and best practices that can be emulated across constituencies. And, we

analyze programme approaches that can be beneficial for policy makers and development specialists. All this information in

form of briefs is disseminated to all the MPs and is also uploaded on our website.

In our December issue of NEXUS, we worked on the following briefs:

Developing Rural Tourism: This brief sheds light upon the various aspects related to rural tourism and the great potential

that India keeps for emerging as a rural tourism icon. After discussing the key factors responsible for the potential growth of

rural tourism, the brief enlists various centrally sponsored schemes for supporting rural tourism in the country. In further

section, a few organizations functioning across the country in this space have been introduced. The penultimate section

discusses a couple of case studies of successful rural tourism projects. The final section analyses the key factors responsible

for successful implementation of rural tourism projects.

Women Entrepreneurship in India: The policy brief addresses the constraints faced by women entrepreneurs in starting

and growing their enterprises. Gender-specific policy initiatives to promote women-owned businesses have also been listed

out.

Mid Day Meal Scheme: This brief discusses the long standing Mid Day Meal Scheme launched as a centrally sponsored

scheme to ensure nutrition in school going children. In its various sections the brief sheds light upon the objectives, statistical

analysis, institutional mechanism, funding mechanism and convergence. The brief concludes by giving examples of best

practices and interventions from across the country.

Pradhan Mantri Awas Yojana (PMAY): It was launched on 25th June, 2015. It seeks to meet the gap in urban housing

units through increased private sector participation and active involvement of the States. It has four broad components-

Slum Rehabilitation, Affordable Housing in partnership with Public and Private Sectors, Beneficiary led individual house

construction and Credit Linked Subsidy. Out of these, the first three components would be implementaed as a Centrally

Sponsored Scheme with active involvement of State Governments, whereas the credit linked subsidy would be implemented

as a Central Sector Scheme directly by the Ministry of Housing and Urban Poverty Alleviation.

Disease Surveillance and Response: Communicable diseases account for more than 37% of the total disease burden in

India and also account for more than 43% of the number of years lost due to ill-health, disability or early death. In 2014

alone, more than 5.2 crore cases of major communicable diseases were reported. This brief sheds light upon the prevailing

communicable disease burden. In further sections, we get to know about the existing framework for disease surveillance and

response, integrated disease surveillance programme, and biological disaster response. The penultimate section provides a

critical analysis and the final section concludes the brief.

Page 9: NEXUS - swaniti.com · 2 Dear Readers: NEXUS is a monthly compilation of briefs, research insights, visualizations, and papers released by Swaniti. Our mission is to

8

Developing Rural Tourism

Promoting Rural Tourism for Sustainable Development and Livelihood Generation

A tourist's paradise, India is a magnum of diverse geography and cultures, offering 30 World Heritage sites, 25 bio-

geographical zones and attractive beaches. The country saw the arrival of 1282 million domestic and 22.57 million foreign

tourists in the year 2013-14. Tourism in India accounts for 6.8% of the GDP, and is the third largest foreign exchange

earner for the country with USD 18.13 Billion. It has been accorded a priority sector status in the 12th

Five-year Plan.

In recent years, there has been an increased realization that the tourism growth potential can be harnessed as a strategy

for Rural Development. With 69% population living in rural India, and almost 6.5 million village units spread across the

country, India foresees itself as a strong platform for harnessing rural tourism. The geographical diversity of India makes it

a unique spot for harnessing rural tourism which can include tourist sites like desert, mountains, plains, plateaus, islands

and coasts in different regions. 2 biodiversity hotspots of the total 34 in the world are located in India, namely, the

Western Ghats and Himalayas, housing a large number of flora and fauna. India showcases a variety of cultural patterns

having different lifestyles, practices, art and craft, and festivals. These can be incorporated and leveraged in the form of

rural tourism. The country is also rich in heritage and offers 30 World Heritage sites.

Factors such as increasing level of awareness, growing interest in heritage and culture, improved accessibility, and

environmental consciousness have shifted trends towards rural tourism. This will not only preserve the culture and

heritage of the country, but will also generate employment in the villages since it can be leveraged to provide skill

development in tourism related job roles such as that of guide, driver, cook, housekeeping and hospitality to the tourists.

Ministry of Tourism specifies that any form of tourism that showcases the rural life, art, culture and heritage at rural

locations, benefits the local community economically and socially, and enables interaction between the tourists and the

locals for a more enriching tourism experience can be termed as rural tourism. Rural tourism may include multiple facets

such as farm tourism, cultural tourism, nature tourism, adventure tourism, and eco-tourism. The country has seen

successful rural tourism models in states such as Kerala’s backwater, Karnataka’s forest, and Tamil Nadu’s temple.

Key Central Government Schemes for Promotion of Rural Tourism

The Government of India has taken various initiatives and introduced policies to grow rural tourism. This section takes a

look at some key schemes and policy decisions.

Page 10: NEXUS - swaniti.com · 2 Dear Readers: NEXUS is a monthly compilation of briefs, research insights, visualizations, and papers released by Swaniti. Our mission is to

9

1. Rural Tourism Infrastructure Development Component under PIDDC scheme – Promoting Village Tourism

The Ministry of Tourism has released a Rural Tourism Infrastructure Development Component, which is part of the Product

Infrastructure Development for Destinations and Circuits (PIDDC) Scheme. 100 percent Central Assistance is provided in

this scheme. The objective of this scheme is to showcase rural life, art, culture and heritage in villages, that have core

competence in art and craft, handloom, textiles, and natural environment. Central Financial Assistance (CFA) up to Rs.50.00

Lakh for infrastructure development and up to Rs.20.00 Lakh for capacity building is provided.

The activities permitted under this scheme are improvement of village surroundings and village connectivity within the

panchayat limits (does not include major roads which connect the village), providing solid waste management and

sewerage management, village illumination, tourism related activities such as procurement of equipments and tourist

accommodation. The State government will identify the region suited for promotion of rural tourism, and is also

responsible for seeking convergence of other schemes and allocations for broader development at the site to benefit local

communities.

2. Swadesh Darshan – Positioning Tourism as an Engine of Growth

The Ministry of Tourism introduced Swadesh Darshan, a Central Sector scheme for Integrated Development of Theme-

Based Tourist Circuits. A Tourist Circuit is a route on which at least three major tourist destinations are located such that

none of them are in the same town, village or city, while a tourist circuit with a consistent theme such as religion, culture,

ethnicity and niche is known as Theme Based Tourist Circuit. These circuits would be identified by the Ministry of Tourism

based on factors such as current tourist traffic, connectivity, potential and significance attached to sites and holistic tourist

experience. The allocated budget for the scheme is Rs.600.00 crore for 2015-16 and components eligible for financing are

infrastructure development; capacity development, skill development and knowledge development; and online presence.

3. Scheme for Organizing Fair, Festival and Tourism related events – Domestic Promotion & Publicity including

Hospitality (DPPH)

Ministry of Tourism provides financial assistance to State Governments to organize fairs and festivals and tourism related

events such as seminars, conclaves and conventions. These events are to be selected by the State Government based on

the tourism potential. Maximum financial assistance to be provided to each State Government during 1 financial year

should not exceed Rs.50.00 lakh.

4. Hunar Se Rozgar Tak (HSRT), Ministry of Tourism

Fully funded by Ministry of Tourism, this programme offers courses in hospitality trades of food production, food and

beverage service, housekeeping and bakery and patisserie. Apart from that courses to bring up tourist escorts, tourist

facilitators, event facilitators, security guards, tour assistants, transfer assistants and office assistants have also been set up.

This programme is delivered by Institutes of Hotel Management, Food Craft Institutes and State Tourism Development

Corporations amongst others. Over 2 lakh persons have been trained under the programme as of 31st March, 2015.

5. Pradhan Mantri Kaushal Vikas Yojana (PMKVY) – Developing Human Capital

This is a flagship outcome-based skill training scheme aimed at benefiting 24 lakh youth across the country. A monetary

reward is provided to trainees on assessment and certification. The National Skill Development Corporation (NSDC) will

implement the scheme and involve the Sector Skill Councils to identify job roles for which training could be imparted

Page 11: NEXUS - swaniti.com · 2 Dear Readers: NEXUS is a monthly compilation of briefs, research insights, visualizations, and papers released by Swaniti. Our mission is to

10

through the PMKVY. A budget of INR 1,500 crore has been allocated for the same which would also include awareness,

mobilization and administrative expenses. NSDC supports vocational training institutes by providing funding up to 75% of

the total project cost in case of for-profit entities and up to 85% of the total project cost in case of not-for-profit entities.

Candidates who successfully complete the courses are given a Skill Card. The trainees are also entitled to a monetary

reward1

upon successful completion of the assessment carried out by the assessment agencies (independent of the TP),

which are appointed by the SSC. Training is Tourism and Hospitality is given under this scheme, where in the trainees are

trained for job roles such as guide, driver, cook, housekeeping and hospitality to the locals.

Major Organisations Functional in India

Certain enterprises and non-governmental organizations have been working towards fostering rural tourism in the

country. Many of these are functional across the country. Grassroutes is one such enterprise working in the rural tourism

market, wherein they help in building the necessary infrastructure in a village from a tourist's point of view. The overall

cost of developing a village ranges from 5-10 lakhs. The Village Tourism Committee is the common link between

Grassroutes and the tourists. Grassroutes works closely with the tourism committee and the local NGO to conduct regular

training programs for the villagers to function as guides, service providers, cooks, etc. and also to learn communications

skills and quality processes. The local NGO monitors the tourists’ village experience in the village and the interactions

between the tourists and the villagers. Another such initiative is Rural Tourism Network Enterprise (RTNE). RTNE works

with a network of Destination Management Companies (DMC). While RTNE provides the core, capital-intensive support

service, the individual DMC focuses on managing relationships with accommodation providers. The architecture of a DMC

network allows delivery of services like hospitality training, rating and credit access to improve infrastructure and service

levels at rural stays.

A few more organizations in this domain, functional across the country are: DHAN Foundation (National Award for Best

NGO Promoting Tourism by Ministry of Tourism), Blue Yonder, Travel Another India, Culture Aangan, Ecospiti,

Baramati Agri Tourism, Village Ways and Eco Login.

Case Studies

1. Rural Tourism for Sansad Adarsh Gram: The following case study exemplifies development of rural tourism in a village

adopted to be developed into a model village.

1 Under the National Skill Qualification Framework, the SSC is a certifying body for Diploma and Certificates awarded on attainment of Levels 1-6. Monetary rewards are

dependent on the corresponding NSQF level attained by the successful trainee.

Promoting Village Tourism in Kitam Manpur – Adopting a Market-driven Approach

Kitam Manpur, the Sansad Adarsh Gram in South District of Sikkim, adopted a "family with family" model of village

tourism wherein tourist families stayed with the Sikkimese families. The market-driven approach was taken up in

partnership with Youth Hostel Association(YHAI) of India. Based on the assurance of arrival of tourists from YHAI,

training on homestays, nature guides and local hospitality was carried out by WWF-India, ECOSS and SIRD. The village

panchayat played a prominent role in promoting this initiative, also ensuring equitable sharing of incomes among the

various wards in the gram panchayat using a rotation based approach for hosting tourist families. The model included

two nights stay for tourists in Kitam Manpur village where they were entertained by cultural shows, exciting visit to the

Kitam Bird Sanctuary and Rangit river side walk. This was followed by a 2-day stay in Tingvong, which offered the

tourists a spectacular view of the mountains and dense forests. Apart from this, the package also included trekking in

the Khangchendzonga Biosphere Reserve, joint cultural show and village walk.

Page 12: NEXUS - swaniti.com · 2 Dear Readers: NEXUS is a monthly compilation of briefs, research insights, visualizations, and papers released by Swaniti. Our mission is to

11

2. Community Tourism in White Desert: Following case study describes the rural tourism opportunities discovered in

Rann of Kutch, as a concerted effort of Ministry of Tourism and United Nations Development Programme(2003-07).

Success Factors

Rural Tourism projects have been carried out at several places across the country. However, only a handful of the projects

have been successful and have resulted in increased tourist inflow as well as enhanced livelihood for the locals. The Impact

and Evaluation Study of Rural Tourism Projects cited the low tourist flow to project areas and difficult access as the key

factors for the failure of almost 31% of the projects evaluated.

Therefore, in order to develop a village as a tourist destination, first step should be to identify the key strength of the

village around which the theme of rural tourism can be developed. These themes can include handicrafts, folk music,

dance, puppet shows, theatre/street dramas, organic farming, herbal, yoga and meditation centers, eco zones within or

around the village, and/or any unique feature (such as the Kila Raipur Rural Olympics, Punjab). Important key factors which

drive growth of tourism, namely, location, proximity to prominent tourist destinations, implementation and maintenance

of hardware and software components must be considered. Further, as a multi-sectoral activity, involving multiple service

providers, rural tourism is an area where a strong public-private partnership is of prime importance, particularly given the

number of schemes under ministries beyond tourism, for instance, rural development, culture, environment and

tribal welfare, convergence of schemes must be considered for a holistic approach. Participation of village panchayat and

Rural Innovation Fund under NABARD may also be leveraged.

Conclusion

Given the geographical and cultural diversity of India, the country has a plethora of opportunities to harness rural tourism.

If implemented and promoted properly, rural tourism projects can become a driver of economic growth by generating

employment for the youth. It keeps the potential of addressing issues such as poverty, empowerment of women and

strengthening the economic status of the rural people.

Endogenous Tourism in Hodka, Rann of Kutch

Home to an ethnically diverse community, Hodka village is a unique cultural mosaic of cattle herders and traditional

crafts persons. Sham-e-Sarhad, Hodka village resort, was an initiative by the Endogenous Tourism Project (ETP) in

collaboration between the United Nations Development Programme (UNDP) and the Ministry of Tourism, Government

of India. Owned and operated by the Village Tourism Committee of Hodka, the resort is run by local community

members and offers an authentic yet incredible experience of the local culture, crafts and heritage. At Sham-e-Sarhad,

sustainable visitor strategies based on art, craft, culture, natural heritage and environment care, have led to larger

tourism yields, which in turn have contributed to the conservation of Hodka’s unique ecology and its community. The

beneficiaries have been the area’s rural poor, women and unemployed youth. The formation of rural self help groups

and local stakeholder participation has been a successful exercise in sustainable capacity building. By facilitating

engaging experiences of rural life for the paying visitor, who is the direct income source for the local communities,

Sham-e-Sarhad has helped improve the local people’s quality of life, and created an opportunity for conscious eco

travelers to experience a whole new perspective.

Page 13: NEXUS - swaniti.com · 2 Dear Readers: NEXUS is a monthly compilation of briefs, research insights, visualizations, and papers released by Swaniti. Our mission is to

12

97.62

2.37 0.01

Classification of Women-owned MSMEs

Micro

Small

Medium

Women Entrepreneurship in India

Creating Opportunities for Livelihood of Women

There are nearly three million micro, small, and medium enterprises (MSME) with full or partial female ownership.

Collectively, these women-owned enterprises contribute 3.09 percent of industrial output and employ over 8 million

people. However, globally men and women are not on a level playing field when it comes to access to resources.

Women-owned businesses face barriers to entry and business growth that include access to education and training, legal

and cultural barriers and infrastructure-related challenges. Access to finance is typically identified as a critical constraint.

While financing is almost always a challenge for MSMEs, the difficulties are often intensified by gender-related factors,

including women’s lack of collateral, weak property rights and discriminatory regulations, laws and customs. In India, as

per the 4th

MSME Census, women enterprises, which work predominantly in the service sector, constitute a total of 7.36%

of the MSME sector. The diagrams below show how majority of women-owned MSMEs, across both registered and

unregistered sector, are classified as micro enterprises.

A state-wise analysis shows us that Meghalaya (33.76%) and Mizoram (33.8%) have the highest percentage of women-

owned enterprises, in rural and urban areas respectively. However, in several states such as Haryana and Uttar Pradesh,

less than 5% of enterprises are owned by women.

Barriers to Women entrepreneurship

While female-run enterprises contribute to household incomes and growth of the national economy, women

entrepreneurs continue to face obstacles to the entry and growth of their businesses. Outlined below are a few major

issues.

a) Access to Finance: On average, women have less access to basic banking services such as checking and saving

accounts. As a result, many female entrepreneurs rely on their own savings, loans from family and friends, or

13.70% 9.09% 7.36%

0%

10%

20%

30%

40%

50%

Registered Sector Unregistered Sector

Total

Percentage of Women MSMEs

Page 14: NEXUS - swaniti.com · 2 Dear Readers: NEXUS is a monthly compilation of briefs, research insights, visualizations, and papers released by Swaniti. Our mission is to

13

micro-loans to finance their business needs. Though, the small size and short-term nature of micro-loans do not

allow women borrowers to make long-term investments in their businesses.

The total finance requirement of women-owned MSMEs in 2012 was around Indian rupees 8.68 trillion ($158

billion). The total supply of formal finance to women-owned MSMEs in 2012 was around Indian rupees 2.31 trillion

($42 billion). This resulted in a finance gap of Indian rupees 6.37 trillion ($116 billion), or 73% of total demand. This

credit supply originated from various types of financial institutions such as public sector banks, non-banking

financial corporations, and self-help group-bank linkage programs. A breakdown of types of institutions financing

women-owned MSMEs is as follows:

b) Informal Sector: Women entrepreneurship is largely skewed towards smaller firms and approximately 90% of these

are in the informal sector. Female ownership and employment also tend to be concentrated in less profitable and more

competitive sectors such as food, garments and retail, while male ownership and employment tend to be in more

profitable sectors such as materials and construction.

c) Access to Markets and Networks: The ability to tap into new markets requires expertise, knowledge and contacts.

Women entrepreneurs often lack access to training and experience and are unable to market the goods and services

effectively. Since majority of women entrepreneurs function on a small scale, they also lack access to sufficient market

information about prices, inputs and competitors, as well as support services they can leverage.

d) Skill gap: Women often lack the

combination of education, vocational and

technical skills, and work experience needed

to support the development of highly

productive businesses. Male entrepreneurs,

for example, are more likely than female

entrepreneurs to have been employed in the

wage sector prior to starting a business.

Women-specific solutions to these issues should

tackle both supply-side issues (such as policy

bias and discrimination, lack of training and

Source Financing Supply Share (percent)

Public sector banks through micro credit 30

Public sector banks to small scale industries 38

Private sector banks 19

Foreign banks 5

Swarna Jayanti Gram Swarozgar Yojana 4

Prime Minister’s Rozgar Yojana 2

Swarna Jayanti Shahari Rozgar Yojana 1

57 56

30

18

44

38

0

30

60

Formal training Informal training

Status of Vocational Training (per 1000 people)

Male

Female

Total

Page 15: NEXUS - swaniti.com · 2 Dear Readers: NEXUS is a monthly compilation of briefs, research insights, visualizations, and papers released by Swaniti. Our mission is to

14

misconceptions about female credit risk) and demand side issues (such as women’s reluctance to enter the business or

expand their work given a lack of business training and higher failure rates).

Various initiatives to expand support to MSMEs have been developed over the past few years, but only some have a

gender-specific component. Given below are women-focused schemes introduced by the government to ease access to

finance, skill development and mentorship for women entrepreneurs.

a) Trade Related Entrepreneurship Assistance and Development (TREAD) Scheme for

Women

The scheme envisages economic empowerment of women entrepreneurs through trade related training, information and

counseling extension activities related to trades, products, services etc. Since such women are not able to have an easy

access to credit, it will be made available to women applicants through NGOs who would be capable of handling funds in

an appropriate manner. These NGOs will not only handle the disbursement of such loans needed by women but would

also provide them adequate counseling, training and assistance in developing markets.

The salient features of the scheme are as follows:

Institutions such as EDIs and MSME-DIs sponsored by State Govt. and any other suitable institution will be provided

need based Government grant primarily for undertaking activities aiming at empowerment of women covered

under the scheme.

The grant shall be limited up to Rs. 5 lakh per project.

Credit

•Government Grant up to 30% of the total project cost as appraised by lending institutions which would finance the

remaining 70% as loan Assistance to applicant women, who have no easy access to credit from banks.

•Government Grant and the loan portion from the lending agencies to assist such women shall be routed through

eligible NGOs engaged in assisting poor women through any kind of income generating activities in non farm

sector.

Training and Counseling

•Training organizations viz. Micro, Small and Medium Enterprises (MSMEs), Entrepreneurship Development

Institutes (EDIs), NISIET and the NGOs conducting training programmes for empowerment of women beneficiaries

identified under the scheme would be provided a grant upto maximum limit of Rs. 1.00 lakh per programme

provided such institutions also bring their share to the extent of minimum 25% of the Government grant.

•The batch size for such a training activity will be at least 20 participants. Duration of the training programme will

be minimum one month.

Eliciting Information

Page 16: NEXUS - swaniti.com · 2 Dear Readers: NEXUS is a monthly compilation of briefs, research insights, visualizations, and papers released by Swaniti. Our mission is to

15

b) Mahila Coir Yojana

Mahila Coir Yojana is a woman oriented self-employment scheme in the coir industry, which provides self-employment

opportunities to the rural women artisans in regions producing coir fibre. The scheme envisages distribution of motorized

ratts for spinning coir yarn to women artisans after giving training.

The salient features of the scheme are as follows:

Women spinners are trained for two months in spinning coir yarn on motorized ratt at the Coir Board’s training

centres.

A stipend of Rs. 500/- p.m. is also paid to the trainees.

The Coir Board provides motorized ratts/ motorized traditional ratts at 75% cost subsidy, subject to a maximum

ceiling of Rs. 7,500/- for motorized ratts and Rs. 2,925/- for traditional ratts.

c) Prime Minister’s Rozgar Yojana

Under the scheme , preference is given to women beneficiaries. While communicating the targets under the Scheme to

the States/ Union Territories and Reserve Bank of India (RBI), standing instructions are issued for ensuring that the number

of women beneficiaries under PMRY should not be less than 30%. Furthermore, in order to facilitate participation of

women beneficiaries under this scheme, the following relaxations are being provided:

Age Relaxation – the upper limit for women applicants is 45 years, as against 35 years for general category

applicants.

Relaxation in residency criteria for married women - the residency criterion of last three years is applicable for

spouse/in-laws in case of married women applicants

In addition, certain government schemes for MSMEs provide special incentives and concessions for women entrepreneurs.

For example, under the MSE Cluster Development Programme by Ministry of MSME, the contribution from the Ministry

of MSME varies between 30-80% of the total project in case of hard intervention, but in the case of clusters owned and

managed by women entrepreneurs, contribution of the M/o MSME could be upto 90% of the project cost. Similarly, under

the Credit Guarantee Fund Scheme for Micro and Small Enterprises, the guarantee cover is generally available up to

75% of the loans extended; however the extent of guarantee cover is 80% for MSEs operated and/ or owned by women.

While an entrepreneur friendly policy ecosystem is the need of the hour, there is also a pressing need to make it more

gender-inclusive. The right blend of suitable policies, empowering ecosystem, provision of infrastructure, access to finance

and incubation are required to energize women-owned business and reduce the gap between men and women.

Page 17: NEXUS - swaniti.com · 2 Dear Readers: NEXUS is a monthly compilation of briefs, research insights, visualizations, and papers released by Swaniti. Our mission is to

16

Other ,

233.43, 89%

MDMS, 29.77, 11%

19.5 19.74 19.9 19.97 19.89

11.77 11.04 10.52 10.68 10.45

2009-10 2010-11 2011-12 2012-13 2013-14

Enrolment in Elementary Education Mid Day Meal Coverage

Other, 652082, 98%

MDMS, 13215,

2%

Mid Day Meal Scheme

A School Meal Programme of the Government of India

With the view to enhancing enrollment, retention and attendance in schools, and simultaneously improving nutritional

levels among children, Mid Day Meal Programme has been prominently present in the Indian education system since the

year 1925, where it was first introduced in Madras Municipal Corporation. In August 1995, National Programme of

Nutritional Support to Primary Education (NP-NSPE) was launched as a Centrally Sponsored Scheme. This scheme was

renamed as 'National Programme of Mid Day Meal in Schools' in October 2007, and since year 2008, covers all children

studying in Government, Local Body and Government-aided primary and upper primary schools and the EGS/AIE centres

including Madarsa and Maqtabs supported under SSA of all areas across the country.

Objectives

The objectives & nutritional targets of the scheme are as follows:

To address hunger in schools by serving hot cooked meals & improve nutritional status of children.

To improve enrolment, retention and attendance rates of children belonging to disadvantaged sections.

To focus on intrinsic educational values such as importance of clean water, good hygiene by imparting good habits

(such as washing hands before & after meals) through a well-organized Mid Day Meal.

To foster social equality as children from varied social backgrounds learn to sit together and share a meal which helps

to break barriers of caste & class in a school.

To provide 450 calories & 12 gms of protein at primary level, and, 700 calories & 20 gms of protein at upper primary

level per child per meal

To provide adequate quantities of micro-nutrients like Iron, Folic Acid & Vitamin A.

Statistical Analysis

Institutional Mechanism

The mechanism of Mid Day Meal Programme is as follows:

A National Steering-cum-Monitoring Committee (SMC) serves asthe nodal agency for the program. It monitors the

programme, assess its impact, and coordinate among concerned departments and agencies and provides policy

advice to Central and State Governments. After submission of annual work plan by States/UTs, the Programme

Budget Expenditure 2013-14 Foodgrain Allocation 2013-14

*Figures in crores *Figures in crores *Figures in crores

Page 18: NEXUS - swaniti.com · 2 Dear Readers: NEXUS is a monthly compilation of briefs, research insights, visualizations, and papers released by Swaniti. Our mission is to

17

• The cooking is done primarily in the school kitchen by engaging cook cum helpers or self-help

groups.

• The village education committee or parent teacher association are in charge of the cooking.

Decentralized Model

• A centralized kitchen is set-up mostly through public-private partnership. An external organization

cooks and delivers the meals to schools.

•This is primarily found in the urban areas. Many organizations such as Akshay Patra Foundation,

Naandi Foundation, etc are providing mid day meals in cities such as Bangalore, Hyderabad, Bhopal,

Ajmer, etc.

Centralized Model

Approval Board (PAB) releases central assistance bi-annually. Both the SMC & PAB are under the chairmanship of

Secretary, Dept. of School Education & Literacy.

States and UTs are also required to set up Steering-cum-Monitoring Committees (SMC) at the State/District/Block

levels to monitor implementation of the programme. Every State Government/UTs has to authorize one of its

departments as the Nodal Department to take overall responsibility for implementation of the programme.

The Panchayat/Urban Local Bodies are to be in charge of the implementation of the programme in states where

primary education is entrusted to them. Gram Panchayat/Municipality may assign the supervision of the programme

at school level to the Village Education Committee (VEC)/School Management and Development Committee

(SMDC) or Parent Teacher Association (PTA), as the case may be, to be accountable to the Gram

Panchayat/Municipality.

There are two models being followed as far as the cooking and distribution of food is concerned.

Funding Mechanism

Under the scheme the Central Government provides for supply of 100 grams of free food grains (wheat/rice) per child per

school day from the nearest FCI (Food Corporation of India) godown. The Central Government also reimburses the actual

cost of transportation of food grains from nearest FCI godown subject to a ceiling of Rs. 100/- per quintal for 11 special

category states (N.E states along with J&K, H.P, Uttaranchal& Sikkim) and Rs. 75/- per quintal for other states & U.Ts.

The Centre also provides assistance for cooking cost at Rs. 1.80/- per child per school day provided the State Government

contributes a minimum of 20 paise (for N.E States) and at Rs. 1.5/- per child per school day provided the State

Government contributes a minimum of 50 paise (for other states/U.Ts).

Centre also provides assistance to construct kitchen-cum-store at Rs. 60,0000/- per unit and for provisioning and

replacement of kitchen devices at Rs. 5000/- per school.

Convergence

The efficient implementation of the MDMS requires convergence with several other development programmes (which

provide for MDMS needs) in order to meet all the requirements of the scheme.

Page 19: NEXUS - swaniti.com · 2 Dear Readers: NEXUS is a monthly compilation of briefs, research insights, visualizations, and papers released by Swaniti. Our mission is to

18

Initiatives and Measures Taken by Governments

1. Public Private Partnership

•Ministry of Rural Development-Sampurna Grameen Rozgar Yojana(SGRY)as a useful public asset in

rural areas.

•Ministry of Housing and Urban Poverty Alleviation -Urban Wage Employment Programme(as useful

public asset), a component of Swarna Jayanti Shahri Rozgar Yojana (SJSRY) for urban areas

outside slums.

•Ministry of Human Resource Development - Sarva Shiksha Abhiyan (SSA) for new school

construction.

Construction of Kitchen-cum-Store

•Ministry of Drinking Water and Sanitation: National Rural Drinking Water Programme (NRDWP)

for drinking water supply in schools. Nirmal Bharat Abhiyan(NBA) for sanitation facilities in schools.

Water Supply

•Ministry of Human Resource Development: Funds available under Sarva Shiksha Abhiyan(SSA)

Annual school grant of Rs 2000/- per annum per school and, grant of Rs 1000/- per annum for EGS

Centers (Under Education Guarantee Scheme(EGS) centers. They are set up in un-served habitations

where no school exists within a radius of 1km and at least 15 children in age group of 6-14 & not

going to school are available)

Kitchen Devices

Use of Ultra Rice in Andhra Pradesh

The Centralized Model of implementation of Mid Day Meal scheme was adopted in Vishakhapatnam, Andhra Pradesh

in 2008. PATH and Global Alliance for Improved Nutrition (GAIN) partnered with Naandi foundation to provide iron-

fortified lunches every day to 61,000 school children that comes in the form of Ultra Rice. The National Institute of

Nutrition conducted a study from 2007-2008 to assess the impact of Ultra Rice on the iron status of school children

participating in the Mid Day Meal programme. The study showed a significant increase in the iron stores (measured by

serum ferritin levels) of the children. The children also experienced significant reduction in incidence of morbidity in

comparison to the control group.

In Centralized kitchens, the incremental cost of adding Ultra Rice to rice-based meals is nominal because the fortified

grains are easily blended with traditional rice either during or right before cooking. The incremental cost per day per

child comes out to be Rs 0.1. Given the proven benefits of Ultra Rice on child health, this is an intervention which

deserves attention and can be implemented in other regions for better results. The Mid Day Meal programme can thus

be utilized to achieve the goals of greater student attendance as well as making focused interventions in the field of

child health and nutrition.

Page 20: NEXUS - swaniti.com · 2 Dear Readers: NEXUS is a monthly compilation of briefs, research insights, visualizations, and papers released by Swaniti. Our mission is to

19

2. Added Nutrition

3. Health

Tithi Bhojan in Gujarat

'Tithi Bhojan' is a community participatory model followed by the Gujarat government in the midday meal

programme. Under this, food is voluntarily served among school children by villagers in several forms like sweet and

namkeen with the regular midday meal and supplementary nutritive items like sprouted beans. The community

members also contribute to improve quality of the school mid day meals on a happy occasion/event in the family or

festivals. Around 2 lakh children were benefited through Thithi Bhojan initiative.

This scheme would now be replicated across the country by the HRD Ministry, where greater public participation as

well as involvement of religious and charitable to ensure more effective community monitoring is planned.

Breakfast Scheme in Puducherry

Government of Puducherry started additional meals for children in schools such as the Rajiv Gandhi Breakfast Scheme

and Rajiv Gandhi Evening Milk Scheme. Under this, a glass of hot milk and biscuits are provided to the students. This

scheme also ensures food security to poor children.

As a result of its enactment, the school attendance and enrolment of students in the schools have seen improvement

and enhancement in the student’s nutritional status and thereby reducing the status of malnutrition. It contributes to

gender equality by reducing the gender gap in Education by boosting female attendance in schools. It also

contributes all round development of the entire school system. The height and weight of the students have also shown

marked improvement. According to a 2010-11 MDMS Puducherry report, the dropout ratio drastically reduced to Nil in

Primary level and 3% in the upper primary level due to the implementation of these welfare schemes.

Apna Swasthya Apne Haath in Jharkhand

This programme is directly related to children of schools who ensure their good health and sanitation keeping them

clean. The Bal Sansad (Student Body) does health check-ups by using tazos (small cards carrying health logos)

indicating cleanliness of Ear, Eye, Nose, Teeth, Nail, Dress, Hair and Bath. The Bal Sansad ensures the cleanliness of

school premises, classroom, kitchen, hand pump. The Bal Sansad ensures that the soap is kept near the hand pump so

that children use it after using toilet and before taking MDM. The Bal Sansad also ensures the use of dustbin in every

class.

Page 21: NEXUS - swaniti.com · 2 Dear Readers: NEXUS is a monthly compilation of briefs, research insights, visualizations, and papers released by Swaniti. Our mission is to

20

Pradhan Mantri Awas Yojana

Housing for All (Urban) Scheme by Government of India

India is experiencing urbanization at a very rapid pace. While it presents a number of opportunities, it has also created

several devellopmental challenges. One such challenge is the urban housing shortage prevalent across 4041 statutory

towns in the country. The issue is more acute in the Economically Weaker Sections (EWS) and Lower Income Groups (LIG).

The Technical Group on Urban Housing Shortage, 2012-17 estimated the total housing shortage at 18.78 million in

2012. EWS and LIG categories account for 96% of this housing shortage.

Pradhan Mantri Awas Yojana was launched on 25th June, 2015. It seeks to meet the gap in urban housing units through

increased private sector participation and active involvement of the States. It has four broad components- Slum

Rehabilitation, Affordable Housing in partnership with Public and Private Sectors, Beneficiary led individual house

construction and Credit Linked Subsidy. Out of these, the first three components would be implementaed as a Centrally

Sponsored Scheme with active involvement of State Governments, whereas the credit linked subsidy would be

implemented as a Central Sector Scheme directly by the Ministry of Housing and Urban Poverty Alleviation.

Components of the Scheme

In Situ Slum Rehabilitation

Under this component, in-situ slum redevelopment will be carried out. Central grant of Rs 1,00,000

per household will be provided for the same.

A slum redevelopment project would be expected to have two components- rehabilitation to

provide housing and basic civic amenities to current and existing slum dwellers, and free sale

under which a portion of the land would be available to developers for selling in the market.

The project would be implemented by private developers, selected through an open transparent

bidding, on criteria decided by States or ULBs. The developers would also be responsible for

providing transit accommodation to slum dwellers.

Affordable Housing in Partnership

The component targets creating housing for Economically Weaker Section (EWS) households,

with annual income up to Rs 3 lakh and current house sizes up to 30 sq m.

Central government would provide assistance to State governments for undertaking housing

projects targeted towards EWS households. Each such project should have at least 250 houses,

with at least 35% earmarked for EWS households. Assistance would amount to Rs 1.5 lakh for

each EWS household covered under the project.

The State governments have the flexibility of involving the private sector in the housing projects.

Page 22: NEXUS - swaniti.com · 2 Dear Readers: NEXUS is a monthly compilation of briefs, research insights, visualizations, and papers released by Swaniti. Our mission is to

21

Funding under the Scheme

Under the Scheme, indicative State-wise allocation has been made by Ministry of Housing and Urban Poverty Alleviation

based on urban population and estimated slum population. A total of Rs 4000 crore has been allocated to all State/UTs.

Component wise allocation will be decided on the basis of proposals received from States. Given below is the State-wise

indicative allocation.

Beneficiary-led individual house construction

The component is targeted towards EWS households looking to construct new houses or

enhance existing ones. Central assistance of Rs 1.5 lakh is provided all such households.

A beneficiary desirous of availing assistance under the component may approach the

relevant ULB.

State governments may also contribute financially for such individual house

construction.

Credit linked Subsidy Scheme

The component provides interest subvention subsidy to EWS and Low Income Group (LIG)

households (income between 3-6 lakh and house sizs up to 60 sq m) seeking housing loan from

banks.

Interest subsidy is provided at 6.5% for a tenure of 15 years for loans up to Rs 6 lakhs.

Housing and Urban Development Corporation (HUDCO) and National Housing Bank (NHB) have

been identified as central nodal agencies to channelize the subsidy amount to lending

institutions.

State / ULBs will be responsible for linking beneficiary identification to Aadhar, Voter Card or any

other unique identification.

Arunachal Pradesh 25.00 Kerala 79.42

Assam 140.00 Maharashtra 561.74

Bihar 87.46 Punjab 86.25

Chhattisgarh 83.82 Rajasthan 139.05

Delhi 122.48 Sikkim 25.00

Goa 5.67 Tamil Nadu 314.55

Gujarat 172.99 Tripura 70.00

Haryana 84.28 Uttar Pradesh 369.96

Himachal Pradesh 50.11 Uttarakhand 27.25

Jammu and Kashmir 34.13 West Bengal 307.34

Jharkhand 55.14 Odisha 79.94

Karnataka 204.51 Madhya

Pradesh

253.23

Page 23: NEXUS - swaniti.com · 2 Dear Readers: NEXUS is a monthly compilation of briefs, research insights, visualizations, and papers released by Swaniti. Our mission is to

22

Role of State Governments

The State Governments have a major role to play in ensuring that the urban housing provision is equitable and effective.

Hence the policy initiatives taken by the State have a major role to play in the effective implementation of the scheme.

Some of the initiatives which States have to take mandatorily include-

The State Government of Gujarat has taken several steps which has facilitated the implementation of housing projects in

the State. Given below is a brief summary of the initiatives.

• Preparation and amendment of master plans earmarking land for affordable housing.

• Dispensing need for separate non- agricultural (NA) permission if land falls under a residential zone

earmarked under the master plan of the city.

• Provision of single-window clearance time bound clearance for layout approval and building permissions at

ULB level.

• Amendment of existing rental laws on the lines of the Model Tenancy Act prepared by the Ministry.

• Provision of additional Floor Area Ratio / Floor Space Index / Transferable Development Rights for slum

redevelopment and affordable housing

Under the Mukhya Mantri Gruh Yojana, Gujarat government aimed to provide affordable housing to EWS / LIG with

a focus on in situ rehabilitation of slums. Assistance of up to Rs 1,50,000 per household and exemption from stamp

duty was provided by the government. The State played a major role in creating an enabling environment for

affordable housing to be implemented efficiently. These included-

Technology neutral tendering process- Earlier the tendering process varied as per building types and was

cumbersome and time consuming. This was streamlined and made more transparent.

Incentives provided to developer- Provisions for cross subsidization were allowed opening avenues for

commercial development of up to 10% of land. This helped in attracting private sector participation.

Government land made available at token price- Land owned by government and ULB were made available

through a simplified process by giving advanced possession for a token value of Re 1. This helped enhance project

viability.

Housing allotment during the beginning of the project- Earlier allotment was done after the completion of

construction of houses. This limited involvement of community during the construction process. Allotment at the

beginning of the project ensured additional quality checks and ownership by the community.

Organizing loan melas- Earlier beneficiaries had to arrange loans on their own without the support of

implementation agency. Loan melas provided platform for beneficiaries and banks and ensured financial inclusion,

reduced and streamlined paper work, and shortened processes making project implementation more effective.

Creation of ICT platform- State level web enabled MIS was set up. This ensured effective monitoring and

transparency in the implementation of the scheme.

Due to the proactive role played by the State Government, construction of 1,15,900 houses was completed within one

year. More than 88,300 slum families have already been rehabilitated. The Pradhan Mantri Awas Yojana is a centrally

sponsored scheme, but States have a major role to play in its implementation. Creation of an enabling environment by

States for effective implementation of the scheme can provide a major boost to the Urban Housing for All mission.

Page 24: NEXUS - swaniti.com · 2 Dear Readers: NEXUS is a monthly compilation of briefs, research insights, visualizations, and papers released by Swaniti. Our mission is to

23

Disease Surveillance and Response

Communicable diseases account for more than 37% of the total disease burden in India and also account for more than

43% of the number of years lost due to ill-health, disability or early death. In 2014 alone, more than 5.2 crore cases of

major communicable diseases were reported. The working group on communicable diseases for the 12th Five Year Plan

noted that most of these cases have been endemic and geographically limited but may frequently attain epidemic

proportions. Multifold increase in global trade and travel has also lead to an elevated exposure to foreign pathogens and

pandemics. A biological outbreak, in addition to being a major public health threat, also puts excessive stress on the

routine health functions and can disrupt economic activity. Early detection and identification of an imminent epidemic

threat is important to limit the fallout of the biological event and formulate effective response strategy to mitigate the

damage.

Current Communicable Disease Burden

As per the “Global Disease Burden Report 2008” by World Health Organization, communicable diseases contributed to

37% of the total disease burden in India. Various communicable diseases like Malaria, Chikungunya, Dengue, Influenza,

Leptospirosis, Water-borne diarreahol diseases are a major point of concern. Over 1 million cases of malaria were

reported in India in 2014. Pulmonary Tuberculosis was responsible for more than 63000 deaths in the 2014. Nearly 11

million cases of acute diarreahol diseases were reported, mainly among low-income groups in the states of Bihar and

West Bengal. Rapid urbanization and poor waste management practices have increased the incidence of vector-borne

diseases like Dengue (40000 cases) and Chikungunya (15000 cases). The 12th Five-year plan also noted that evolution of

antimicrobial resistant varieties of pathogens has made the task of containing communicable diseases more complex.

Endemic Recurring Diseases

•Acute Diarreahol disease

•Acute Respiratory Infection

•Acute Encephalitis Syndrome

•Dengue

•Chikungunya

•Malaria

•Entric Fever

•Tuberculosis

Large-Scale Epidemic/Pandemic

•Avian Influenza (H5N1) (in 2006)

•Swine Flu (H1N1) (in 2019-13)

•SARS (in 2003)

•Plague (in 1994 and 2001)

1584

1961

1562

0

500

1000

1500

2000

2500

2012 2013 2014

Reported Outbreaks in India

Page 25: NEXUS - swaniti.com · 2 Dear Readers: NEXUS is a monthly compilation of briefs, research insights, visualizations, and papers released by Swaniti. Our mission is to

24

In addition to the recurring diseases, various large-scale pandemic outbreaks also pose a major challenge. The Swine

Flu (H1N1) epidemic caused more than 7300 deaths between 2009 and 2013, with more than 1700 deaths in one single

year (2010). A Hepatitis B outbreak in Gujarat in 2009 caused 49 deaths. Similarly, the global breakout of SARS in 2003 and

Ebola in West Africa in 2014 caused global panic; though the impact in India was small (3 reported cases of SARS and

none for Ebola).

Existing Framework for Disease Surveillance and Response

Health is a state subject under the constitution and but The National Health Policy of 2002 recognized that the “…(then)

existing surveillance network is rudimentary…”and envisaged a “full operationalization of an integrated disease control

network from the lowest rung of public health administration to the Central Government, by 2005”. The draft

National Health Policy 2015 also reiterates the intent to “respond to localized outbreaks as and when they occur and

before they become generalized epidemics” through “public health capacity to collect, analyze and respond to the

disease outbreaks using the state of the art public health knowledge”. The working group on Communicable Disease for

the 12th five year plan identified “an efficient disease surveillance and response system for early detection and

treatment of cases and for early detection and control of outbreaks of epidemic prone disease” as a key strategy to

deal with the high incidence of communicable diseases. Similarly, WHO’s International Health Regulations (2005), to

which India is a signatory, requires all member states to strengthen their core capacity to detect, report and respond

rapidly to public health events and to notify WHO, within 24 hours, of all events that may constitute a public health

emergency of international concern (PHEIC).

In 1996, the National Apical Advisory Committee for National Disease Surveillance and Response System (NAAC) was

created followed by the establishment of National Surveillance Programme on Communicable Diseases (NSPCD) in

1997 on a pilot basis initially in 5 districts. The programme was eventually expanded to cover 101 districts over years. The

programme was designed to report outbreaks on occurrence and weekly reporting of epidemic prone diseases. The states

acted as the implementing agencies and the National Institute for Control of Diseases (NICD) was the nodal agency for

co-ordination. In 2004, Government of India launched the Integrated Disease Surveillance Programme (IDSP) with World

Bank assistance. IDSP is the primary disease surveillance and response mechanism currently in place.

Integrated Disease Surveillance Programme

Integrated Disease Surveillance Programme (IDSP) is administratively and financially a part of National Centre for Disease

Control (NCDC), which is the successor of NICD. The objectives of IDSP are as follows:

1) To establish a decentralised state-based system of surveillance for communicable and non-communicable

diseases so that timely and effective public health action can be initiated in response to health challenges in the

country at the state and national levels

2) To improve the efficiency of the existing surveillance activities of disease control programmes and facilitate

sharing of relevant information with the health administration, community and other stakeholders so as to detect

disease trends over time and evaluate control strategies

Page 26: NEXUS - swaniti.com · 2 Dear Readers: NEXUS is a monthly compilation of briefs, research insights, visualizations, and papers released by Swaniti. Our mission is to

25

The IDSP has established District Surveillance Units (DSUs) and State Surveillance Units (SSUs) in all the states and

districts of the country, each headed by headed by a surveillance officer and supported by epidemiologists,

microbiologists and data management staff. A national “Central Surveillance Unit” (CSU) has also been established in

Delhi as a part of NCDC.

Disease incidence data is collected on weekly basis to provide information on the disease trends and seasonality of

diseases. The data is collected on a syndromic surveillance basis where the suspected case is reported at the Primary

Health Centre or lower units. Confirmed case reporting is also done after clinical tests of the suspected cases.Whenever

there is a visible trend of illnesses in any area, it is investigated by the Rapid Response Teams (RRT) to diagnose and

control the outbreak. A defined set of triggers for a disease is used to decide the level and the scale of response

required. In case of local outbreak District Rapid Response Team responds in real time, investigate the outbreak & take all

preventive measures. A physician, epidemiologist and a pathologist are the members of District RRT. If the outbreak is of

serious nature, RRT from regional medical college assists the District RRT to control the epidemic. The State RRT will be

activated in case of major epidemic situation.

The working of the DSU is overseen by a District Surveillance Committee comprising of relevant officials across line

departments from the district administration. A State Surveillance Committee is formed at the state level to oversee the

functioning of the SSU.

.

The IDSP is also building capacity at the district laboratories and designated regional laboratories to strengthen the

laboratory diagnosis systems. In addition, all IDSP DSUs are networked with IT-enabled systems and video conferencing

facilities to enable real-time reporting of outbreaks. The CSU also includes a media monitoring cell and a 24/7 helpline to

detect any unusual outbreak which is not captured by IDSP’s local units.

Trigger-1

•Response by Health Workers

Trigger-2

•Outbreak Investigation & Response (PHCs/ CHCs)

Trigger-3

• Outbreak Investigation & Response (DSU)

Trigger-4

•Epidemic Response (SSU)

Trigger-5

•Disaster Response (CSU)

Field Health

Workers

•Reporting of suspected

cases

•Awareness

Sub Centre

•Compilation of data

•Collection of Samples

•Reporting to PHC

PHC/CHC

•Outbreak Response

•Reporting to DSU

•Information, Education

and Communication

DSU

•Data entry & analysis

(incl. data from private

hospitals)

•Outbreak investigation

•Outbreak response

•Training

Page 27: NEXUS - swaniti.com · 2 Dear Readers: NEXUS is a monthly compilation of briefs, research insights, visualizations, and papers released by Swaniti. Our mission is to

26

Biological Disaster Response

The Disaster Management Act of 2005 mandates the National Disaster Management Authority to formulate guidelines

for all disasters including biological incidents. NDMA prepared a guideline for management of biological disasters in 2008.

The guidelines defined the response and disaster management mechanisms at central, state and district levels. However,

the guidelines have not been in effect pending notification.

Response to an epidemic event (natural or otherwise) is coordinated by the Ministry of Health and Family Welfare’s

(MoHFW) Emergency Medical Relief (EMR) division. It is provided technical support by the NCDC and other subordinate

technical institutions. MoHFW is responsible for co-coordinating efforts and response of all departments in case of a

biological disaster, under the supervision of the national crisis management committee. NCDC also acts as the national

focal point for International Health Regulation 2005 and is responsible for reporting public health emergencies to

WHO and receiving international emergency alerts related to public health.

During the anticipated spread of Ebola in 2014, the NCDC issued guidelines informing the IDPS surveillance officers of the

measures to be taken to detect the cases, possible contact, spread of infection and procedures for isolation and treatment

of suspected cases. The overall effort was co-ordinated by EMR with technical support from NCDC and international

liaison by the International Health division of MoHFW.

Critical Analysis

IDSP has been successful in detecting and reporting a majority of outbreak cases. On an average, the CSU receives over 30

outbreak alerts from the field. Over 90% districts regularly report outbreak data. As the information is reported by the

ground level health worker, reporting integration has been achieved across various communicable diseases

programmes like National Vector Borne Diseases Programme (NVBDP), National TB Programme, etc. The reporting

format also requires reporting on investigation of and response to the outbreak which has ensured accountability in SSUs

and DSUs. A multilevel trigger based response system enables immediate response at all levels beginning from the D-

RRT which is in best position to respond immediately. A lab network of 65 labs has been established in 9 states for

providing diagnostic services. Provision of a strong IT network has enabled rapid reporting of outbreaks resulting in

shorter response times. Even in case of large-scale biological disaster cases, the mechanisms are in place for a rapid

response as seen in case of Ebola.

However, the reporting from private hospitals is in many cases incomplete and can lead to undetected cases. Many

DSUs are still reporting data through emails instead of the portal, thus adding some delay in reporting. The quality of

investigations in reported outbreaks and efficiency of response has also been inconsistent across states. A review

conducted by Center for Disease Control, USA on request of MoHFW identified some issues with IDSP. The lack of

trained manpower like epidemiologists, entomologists etc. is a major cause of concern for effective functioning of the

disease surveillance programme. The review also noted inadequate prioritization of the programme by state and

district administrations. The division of authority between directorates of health services and medical education has led

to hampering of the diagnostic services through medical colleges.

Page 28: NEXUS - swaniti.com · 2 Dear Readers: NEXUS is a monthly compilation of briefs, research insights, visualizations, and papers released by Swaniti. Our mission is to

27

The IDSP needs increased co-ordination under International Health Regulations 2005 at state-level and constant

communication with other stakeholders like the airport, ports and ground borders authorities. The notification of the

NDMA guidelines on biological disasters will help formalize the response mechanism with clear demarcation of

responsibilities of various stakeholders.

Conclusion

A robust disease surveillance and response mechanism is important to effectively address the heavy disease burden and

challenges posed by pandemics. IDSP has considerably improved case and outbreak detection. The gaps in the design and

performance of IDSP need to be addressed to improve its performance from the current levels. Adequate human

resources and addition of response capacity are necessary to make it better.

Page 29: NEXUS - swaniti.com · 2 Dear Readers: NEXUS is a monthly compilation of briefs, research insights, visualizations, and papers released by Swaniti. Our mission is to

28

Page 30: NEXUS - swaniti.com · 2 Dear Readers: NEXUS is a monthly compilation of briefs, research insights, visualizations, and papers released by Swaniti. Our mission is to

29

Data brings objectivity and efficiency in the delivery and assessment of development. There's a scope of leveraging the

data available in public domain to understand the state of development across sectors. Swaniti, in partnership with Indian

Express, runs a Data and Democracy page, where such raw data is analyzed to seek trends and present crisply to our

audience. The page can be viewed at visualdata.indianexpress.com.

We analyzed the following in the month of November, as a result of the recently occurred events:

MPLADs: Where was the money spent?: Despite many criticisms on the utilization of funds, about 88% of

the MPLAD funds released since inception have been spent on asset creation under the scheme. The quality of work,

however, seems to be lacking a robust monitoring mechanism. The write-up in this section sheds light on where this

money was spent.

Section 12(1)(c) - Providing Reservation for Economically Weaker Sections: The Right to Education Act provides that

every child in the 6-14 age group shall have a right to free and compulsory education in a neighbourhood school. The Act

also provides for certain time targets that Governments must adhere to. In particular, Secton 12 (1) (c) of the Act

mandates that Private unaided institutions and special category schools shall provide free and compulsory education to at

least 25% (of the strength of class) to children belonging to disadvantaged groups and weaker sections. The Supreme Court

in 2012 upheld the Constitutional validity of this section. However a study by Central Square Foundation in 2015 found

that many states are not strictly adhering to this provision.

Page 31: NEXUS - swaniti.com · 2 Dear Readers: NEXUS is a monthly compilation of briefs, research insights, visualizations, and papers released by Swaniti. Our mission is to

30

MPLAD scheme was introduced on 23rd December 1993 by former Prime Minister, P.V. Narasimha Rao. The basis for the

scheme was that Members of Parliament (MP) be able to recommend developmental works of capital nature in their

respective constituencies. Initially starting with Rs 5 lakh per MP per year, the amount was increased to Rs. 1 Crore per

year per MP during 1994-95 till 1997-98. It was further increased to Rs. 2 crores from the years 1998-99 and since 1st April

2011 each MP can recommend works worth Rs. 5 crore per year under MPLADS. Emphasis under the scheme is creation of

durable community assets based on the locally felt needs. For the development of areas inhabited by SCs and STs, MPs

are also supposed to recommend every year, works costing at least 15% and 7.5% of the MPLADS entitlement for the year.

The Guidelines specify that all recommended eligible works should be sanctioned within 75 days from the date of receipt

of the recommendation, after completing all formalities. The time-limit for completion of the works should generally not

exceed one year (it is not feasible to prescribe precise time-frames for all the different types of works).

The Ministry of Statistics and Programme Implementation (MOSPI) monitors the overall position of funds released, cost of

works sanctioned, funds spent while the Nodal Department in the State is responsible for coordination with the Ministry

and proper and effective supervision of the MPLADS implementation in the State.

MPLADS scheme has been a subject of intense media scrutiny over the years with reports usually focussed on % of

utilization every year. However, despite many criticisms on the utilization, about 88% of the funds released, under the

scheme, since inception have been spent on asset creation.

Most of the funds are spent on constructing roads, pathways & bridges and other public facilities. These two sectors

constitute to about 61% of the works and 64% of the funds. Infrastructure for education stands third with 15% of the

funds directed towards these works.

1,310.00 1,433.90 1,451.50 1,470.55 1,580.00 1,531.50 1,533.32

2,507.68

3,722.00

88.35 90.88 91.92 93.04 94.35

92.58 92.73

88.72 87.98

50

55

60

65

70

75

80

85

90

95

100

-

500

1,000

1,500

2,000

2,500

3,000

3,500

4,000

2004-05 2005-06 2006-07 2007-08 2008-09 2009-10 2010-11 2011-12 2012-13

Funds Released (In Cr) % of Cummulative Utilization

Page 32: NEXUS - swaniti.com · 2 Dear Readers: NEXUS is a monthly compilation of briefs, research insights, visualizations, and papers released by Swaniti. Our mission is to

31

Some of the major criticisms remain on the quality of work, improper use of funds and lack of robust monitoring

mechanism. Several reports have been commissioned to evaluate the scheme. Programme Evaluation Organization of

erstwhile Planning Commission had conducted an evaluation of the Scheme for the reference period 1994-95 to 1998-99.

The report submitted in 2001 mentions monitoring as the weakest part as the weakest part of the scheme. The CAG in its

2010-11 report had identified few lapses in the scheme including: selection of prohibited works, improper documentation

of works, Assets not being put to use and has made recommendations accordingly.

In a survey conducted during 2012-13 by an independent monitoring agency, Agricultural Finance Corporation Limited

(AFC), it was found that 82% of the works were in rural areas and 18% in Urban / Semi Urban areas. The share of rural and

urban area in aggregate cost was 78% and 22% respectively. This survey spanned over 5615 works across.

Roads Pathways

and Bridges 32%

Other Public Facilities

28%

Education 13%

Drinking Water Facility

12%

Electricity 5%

Sanitation and Public

Health 4%

Sports 2%

Others 4%

Roads Pathways and

Bridges 38%

Other Public Facilities

26%

Education 14%

Drinking Water Facility

7%

Electricity 4%

Sanitation and Public

Health 4%

Sports 2%

Others 5%

Page 33: NEXUS - swaniti.com · 2 Dear Readers: NEXUS is a monthly compilation of briefs, research insights, visualizations, and papers released by Swaniti. Our mission is to

32

The Right of Children to Free and Compulsory Education Act was passed in 2009 making education a right for children in

the age group 6-14. Section 12(1)(c) of the Act mandated that schools provide admission for children belonging to

economically weaker sections (EWS) and disadvantageous groups in the neighbourhood schools. These admissions are

from Class I to the extent of at least 25% of the strength of that class. The Act also provides that such schools shall be

reimbursed expenditure incurred by these schools on providing education to these children. The SSA Framework has been

amended to assist the States/UTs towards reimbursement of costs incurred with respect to admissions.

Till September 2014, about 14.22 lakh students benefitted through Section 12(1)(c). In the year 2015-16 alone, the Union

Government approved funds to the tune of Rs. 250 crores for reimbursements of over 5 lakh children in 7 states. There is

also a divide among different states in implementing – with Madhya Pradesh, Rajasthan, Karnataka and Tamil Nadu having

the most admissions.

ASER 2014 found that the learning gap between Private and Public schools is increasing putting the latter at a

disadvantage. A learning gap of 9.8 percentage points in 2006 doubled to 20.3 percentage points in 2014. This has

resulted in more parents enrolling their children in private schools. Data from Unified District Information System for

Education (UDISE) shows that for classes I-V, % enrolment in private unaided schools increased from 25.93% in 2008-09 to

34.38% in 2013-14.

This makes the implementation of Section 12(1)(c) even more important so as the EWS and disadvantageous groups do

not lose out on opportunities and quality education.

While the intention of this provision was to make schools socially and economically inclusive, its implementation has faced

many roadblocks. The section was also challenged for its constitutional validity in the Supreme Court and was

subsequently upheld – with the exception of minority institutions.

127.81 195.94 207.75

238.37 247.09 240.30

5.49

14.82 25.00 31.72 30.46 33.89

0

50

100

150

200

250

300

2009-10 2010-11 2011-12 2012-13 2013-14 2014-15

Rs.

Hu

nd

red

cro

res

SSA - Releases RMSA - Releases

Page 34: NEXUS - swaniti.com · 2 Dear Readers: NEXUS is a monthly compilation of briefs, research insights, visualizations, and papers released by Swaniti. Our mission is to

33

A study by IIM Ahmedabad and Central Square foundation has shown that the implementation has been far from the

targets. In 2013-14, roughly 610,000 (6.1 lakh) seats were filled out of approximately 2.11 million (21.1 lakh) seats available.

While this is a substantial improvement from the 21.5% fill rate the previous year, it still falls way short of the intended

goal. The study has further listed 4 legal lacunae in the implementation as: 1) Income limits for determining economically

weaker sections 2) Grievance redressal 3) Issues with the admission process 4) Exemptions for minority schools.

Another issue is lack of awareness among the EWS and disadvantageous groups. A study by J-PAL in Delhi has found that

only 3% of the eligible families in Delhi are aware of this opportunity. In another survey conducted by INDUS ACTION, it

was found that only 4% families were aware of the provision and less than 1% were aware of the documentation required.

0 10 20 30 40 50 60 70 80 90

100

A &

N Is

lan

ds

An

dh

ra P

rad

esh

Aru

nac

hal

Pra

des

h

Ass

am

Bih

ar

Ch

and

igar

h

Ch

hat

tisg

arh

Dad

ra &

Nag

ar H

avel

i

Dam

an &

Diu

Del

hi

Go

a

Gu

jara

t

Har

yan

a

Him

ach

al P

rad

esh

Jam

mu

& K

ash

mir

Jhar

khan

d

Kar

nat

aka

Ker

ala

Laks

had

wee

p

Mad

hya

Pra

des

h

Mah

aras

htr

a

Man

ipu

r

Meg

hal

aya

Miz

ora

m

Nag

alan

d

Ori

ssa

Pu

du

cher

ry

Pu

nja

b

Raj

asth

an

Sikk

im

Tam

il N

adu

Trip

ura

Utt

ar P

rad

esh

Utt

arak

han

d

Wes

t Ben

gal

All

Stat

es

Page 35: NEXUS - swaniti.com · 2 Dear Readers: NEXUS is a monthly compilation of briefs, research insights, visualizations, and papers released by Swaniti. Our mission is to

34

Page 36: NEXUS - swaniti.com · 2 Dear Readers: NEXUS is a monthly compilation of briefs, research insights, visualizations, and papers released by Swaniti. Our mission is to

35

Swaniti Initiative aims to inform MPs about development issues through dissemination of information on development

topics like health, education, gender or livelihood in the form of analysis of schemes, briefs, research insights etc. Our

research content is developed through consistent feedback and discussion with MPs. Additionally, Swaniti also provides on-

ground support and grassroots level development insight at the constituency level in certain cases, where the area of

intervention is focused on our 4 core sectors (health, education, gender and livelihood). As part of engagements, members

from the Swaniti team travel to the constituency to study the issue at hand, interact with the different stakeholders and

subsequently draw a plan of action to address the issue. The Swaniti team also follows up with the stakeholders at regular

intervals to ensure that the project is completed in a time-bound manner.

Our team members recently visited Uttara Kannada and Nagrota to assess the ground situation and evaluate the potential

of growth in certain sectors. In this section, let's find out what they have to say about their visits.

Page 37: NEXUS - swaniti.com · 2 Dear Readers: NEXUS is a monthly compilation of briefs, research insights, visualizations, and papers released by Swaniti. Our mission is to

36

Swaniti provides many platforms to hold conversations with the Members of Parliament to better understand their interest

areas and passions. On one such occasion, we had the pleasure to sit across and sip tea with a member of Rajya Sabha

from Karnataka. The MP shared how even after years of development, some of the scheduled tribes in his state were still

not able to reach their potential. The particular tribe in consideration here were the Siddis of the African descent who

came to India almost 400 years ago.

The next thing we know we were in Uttara Kannada to know more about the tribe and their needs. For ground support, we

had members from the local MLA’s office to guide us in the right direction. To best utilize our time there and meet as

many community members as possible, we decided to hit the road from the first day. On our journey to the tribal

habitations, we were taken aback by the vastness of the land and the beauty of the dense forests that covered more than

two-third of the district’s total land. Soon, we were on the doorsteps of our new hosts and unlike the popular myth

surrounding the behavior of the tribals towards strangers, Siddis were one of the most hospitable people that we have

ever met.

After exchanging pleasantries and spending a considerable time with them, we began to realize the depth of their

problems. Though most children went to school, they dropped out after the upper primary education and began to work

as agricultural laborers in the farms nearby, a common way to earn livelihood for most of the community members. At

first, we considered it as a simple lack of secondary schools or a financial constraint problem, but on further examination

we realized though these were some of the challenge, there was more to it. Uttara Kannda being a large district by area

and the availability of the higher education at the Taluka level, made it difficult for the children to reach schools despite

their willingness. To complicate this further, the poor public transport and the landscape of the region did not help either.

Page 38: NEXUS - swaniti.com · 2 Dear Readers: NEXUS is a monthly compilation of briefs, research insights, visualizations, and papers released by Swaniti. Our mission is to

37

On expanding this, we understood the challenge of being unconnected or unreachable was not just limited to children but

was impacting the lives of other members of the community as well. Since, the members were spread throughout the

district, meeting and interacting with each other was not so easy and frequent. This was not a good sign as we have all

realized that if communities have to sustain, especially the ones such as Siddis with numbers only in mere thousands, they

need to stay united. What was even more discouraging was the dearth of the central places where the community could

hold social gatherings, public meetings and promote cultural activities.

Now that we had identified some of the problems and the challenges associated, it was time for us to figure out the

solutions. However, as we had been away from office for too long, we had to bid adieu to our new friends, only to

continue the work from Delhi. That evening on our flight back, we made a promise in our hearts to find a way to send

those children to school and to find a place where the community could build itself and endure its heritage.

Page 39: NEXUS - swaniti.com · 2 Dear Readers: NEXUS is a monthly compilation of briefs, research insights, visualizations, and papers released by Swaniti. Our mission is to

38

The Honorable Member of Legislative Assembly representing Nagrota in the Jammu & Kashmir Assembly, sough to

transform it into a model constituency in J&K by developing it along modern lines. It was in this context that he held

discussions with Swaniti and invited the team to study the current situation in Nagrota and draw a roadmap for the

development of the constituency.

Nagrota is an Assembly (Vidhan Sabha) Constituency in Jammu District, located at a strategic location as it is very close to

the winter capital of J&K, Jammu and is the gateway to the revered shrine of Mata Vaishno Devi. It is a predominantly rural

area and agriculture and animal husbandry is the primary occupation for the vast majority of the people in this

constituency, which has approximately 23,000 households. Nagrota also houses a large cantonment that is home to the 16

Corps as well as one of the largest ammunition depots in the country.

With all this in the backdrop, the team set off to Nagrota to understand the issues and assess the current state of facilities

so as to design and execute a set of interventions to address the issues. The visit revealed to us that despite the

advantages offered by virtue of its location, rural communities in the constituency remained backward in terms of literacy

and education. The current state of schools and school education was not up to the mark and most government schools

Page 40: NEXUS - swaniti.com · 2 Dear Readers: NEXUS is a monthly compilation of briefs, research insights, visualizations, and papers released by Swaniti. Our mission is to

39

don’t have an environment that is conducive for learning. We interacted with the different stakeholders in the education

domain i.e. the Department of Education (Jammu), Panchayat members, the parents, the teachers and the students to seek

their inputs and understand their perspective. Among all the challenges and issues, the heartening aspect is that there is a

strong realization among the parents, students and the local community regarding importance of good education in

changing their lives. It was felt that improving the condition of schools and the quality of education in the constituency

would help in laying down a strong edifice for development in Nagrota and help harness the immense potential and

strategic location of Nagrota.

Thereby, we designed a plan of action, incorporating a series of interventions, to improve the quality and access to

education for students in the rural areas of Nagrota based on extensive inputs from experts in the domain and the

feedback from the local community. The interventions focused on imparting holistic and integral education to the

students, while touching upon physical, emotional and aesthetic development in addition to academics. Taking inspiration

from the quote mentioned below, the team also focused on the creation of classrooms, which would not just push each

child to imagine a life of limitless opportunities but also ensure that each second in the classroom counts!

"Art in the classroom not only spurs creativity, it also inspires learning"

Accordingly, the team worked with a Mumbai based organization to execute a Classroom Canvas Project, wherein

professional and budding artists came to Nagrota and painted the classrooms in 2 schools with murals based on different

themes, which best suited the learning needs of the students and were based on the ideas and thoughts expressed by

them.

At the end of the project, the white, unimaginative walls with a ubiquitous blakcboard had been well and truly transformed

into warm and welcoming learning spaces, marking a successful beginning to the idea of developing happy and learning

schools across Nagrota, as envisaged at the onset of the project. While some students were transported right into the

middle of a Jungle Carnival in one of the classrooms whilst enouraging them to imagine a life of limitless possibilities

through a dream sequence in another classroom. Enthused by the response from the students, teachers and the local

community and the wonderful end product, it was decided that the project would also be implemented in more schools in

a phased manner in the coming months.

The entire experience was best encapsulated in this quote by one of the artists:

“Hope they learnt something after painting here. Hope they are a bit hopeful. Hope, the colors we used in their rooms change

a bit of them. Hope they have hope now. Hope”

At the same time, the happiness and the smiles on the faces of the students and everybody associated with the project

gives us the inspiration to work harder to play a part in the transformation of Nagrota, as envisaged by the Honorable

MLA.

Page 41: NEXUS - swaniti.com · 2 Dear Readers: NEXUS is a monthly compilation of briefs, research insights, visualizations, and papers released by Swaniti. Our mission is to

40

Page 42: NEXUS - swaniti.com · 2 Dear Readers: NEXUS is a monthly compilation of briefs, research insights, visualizations, and papers released by Swaniti. Our mission is to

41

Weekly Policy Updates as a product was first released in the month of April. The idea behind starting it was to keep the

elected officials updated on policy development by providing them crisp information. This initiative of ours has been

recognized by many MPs during our interactions with them.

This section includes the key policy initiatives which were announced in the month of November. These included

developments in agriculture, infrastructure, urban development and health. The Accessible India campaign was launched

to provide equal opportunity to Persons with Disabilities and the Central sector scheme ‘Nai Manzil’ was approved with a

total expenditure of Rs. 650 crore. The month of November also saw further developments under existing schemes and

Acts with amendments introduced in the Constitution (Scheduled Castes) Order to modify the list of scheduled castes in

certain states and changes made in the funding pattern of Sarva Shiksha Abhiyan to be in the ratio of 60:40 between

Centre and states. Weekly policy updates sent out to elected representatives have been summarized in subsequent pages.

Page 43: NEXUS - swaniti.com · 2 Dear Readers: NEXUS is a monthly compilation of briefs, research insights, visualizations, and papers released by Swaniti. Our mission is to

42

1. Approval for UDAY (Ujjwal DISCOM Assurance Yojana)

Union Cabinet has given its approval for UDAY (Ujjwal

DISCOM Assurance Yojana), to be implemented by the

Ministry of Power. The scheme provides for a financial

turnaround and revival of power distribution companies.

The scheme would target improving operational efficiency of

DISCOMs, reducing cost of power, reduction in interest cost

of DISCOMs, and enforcing financial

discipline of DISCOMs through alignment with state finances.

States not meeting milestones envisioned under the scheme

will be liable to forfeit grants under Integrated Power

Development Scheme (IPDS) and Deen Dayal Upadhyay Gram

Jyoti Yojana (DDUGJY).

2. Launch of SATYAM (Science and Technology of Yoga and Meditation)

A new program SATYAM has been launched under Ministry of Science and Technology to strengthen research in

the area of yoga and meditation.

The program will encourage research on the effects of yoga and meditation on physical and mental health, and

basic body processes. Knowledge obtained in academic institutions and other related agencies will be harnessed

under the program.

3. Additional allocation of food grains to States and UTs

20 States have begun implementing National Food Security

Act (NFSA), which came into force w.e.f 5.07.2013, while the

rest are under TPDS. Additional allocation for APL and BPL

families during the current financial year was made to non

NFSA States/UTs only upto September, 2015.

The non-NFSA states, however, are under active preparation

to implement the NFSA within the next few months. Hence

the Government has decided to continue the monthly

additional APL and BPL allocation to the non-NFSA States/UTs

from October, 2015 to March, 2016 or till implementation of the Act in these States/UTs, whichever is earlier, at

APL and BPL rates.

1. Chief Minister’s Sub-group Report on Centrally Sponsored Schemes

The CM’s sub-group was constituted on March 9th, 2015 to consider the design of Centrally Sponsored Schemes

and recommending ways to make their implementation more effective and outcome oriented.

Page 44: NEXUS - swaniti.com · 2 Dear Readers: NEXUS is a monthly compilation of briefs, research insights, visualizations, and papers released by Swaniti. Our mission is to

43

The sub-group has recommended that the number of schemes should be reduced for improving their visibility

and impact. It has highlighted that the investment in core schemes should be maintained at least at their current

level. Furthermore, special attention must be given to North-Eastern and Himalayan States and UTs while

determining their funding pattern.

According to the sub-group, existing Centrally Sponsored Schemes must be divided into two types- Core Schemes

and Optional Schemes. While investment levels under core schemes will be maintained, funds under optional

schemes will be transferred to states as lumpsum amounts with states having the freedom to chose the schemes

they wish to implement.

2. Launch of E-Pathshala, Saransh and Shaala Siddhi Portals

Ministry of Human Resource Development has launched various ICT based initiatives for school education such as

e-Pathshala, Saransh and National Programme on

School Standards and Evaluation Framework

(Shala Siddhi).

E-Pathshala is a web portal which hosts

educational resources for students, teachers,

parents, researchers and educators. Saransh is a

tool which allows the schools to identify areas of

improvement in students, teachers and curriculum

to facilitate and implement change. Shaala Siddhi

is a comprehensive instrument for school

evaluation which enables the schools to evaluate

their performance in more focused and strategic

manner to facilitate them to make professional judgment for continuous improvement.

3. States to progress on rural electrification in mission mode

Power Ministers of all States and Union Territories have unanimously decided to ensure electrification of all the

remaining un- electrified villages by 31st March 2017 in mission mode under Deendayal Upadhyaya Grameen

Jyoti Yojana ( DDUGJY).

States have resolved to set targets for replacement for all existing conventional street lights and incandescent

bulbs with LED by 2019. Nine States namely Haryana, Uttar Pradesh , Punjab, Maharashtra , Karnataka, Tamil Nadu

, Madhya Pradesh , Andhra Pradesh and Telangana have decided to replace 10% of existing agricultural water

pumps with energy efficient pumps including solar within one year. States whose plan documents on Power For

All have not been prepared should get it expedited with the help of consultants and central team members so

that all these documents are completed by 31st December 2015.

1. Launch of TADF (Technology Acquisition and Development Fund)

Aimed at bridging technological gap at an affordable cost, TADF was launched under National Manufacturing

Policy being implemented by Department of Industrial Policy & Promotion (DIPP).

Page 45: NEXUS - swaniti.com · 2 Dear Readers: NEXUS is a monthly compilation of briefs, research insights, visualizations, and papers released by Swaniti. Our mission is to

44

The scheme provides for upto 50% or max ₹20 lakh support in direct and indirect (Eg. Patent pool) technology

acquisition by MSMEs. It also provides for subsidy in technology/equipment manufacturing and incentives for

green manufacturing.

2. Unified Committee to make Curricula for Skill Development.

The Ministry of Skill Development & Entrepreneurship has approved the creation of “Sector Mentor Committees”

that would act as integrated committees for creating model curricula for skill training courses, both long-term and

short-term, in each sector.

The Committee will comprise of members from Government as well as Private sectors and will focus on providing

long-term vocational education opportunities in various sectors. It will also be responsible for aligning all existing

curricula in short-term and long-term skill competency based courses with corresponding National Occupation

Standards (NOSs), Qualification Packs (QPs) and National Skill Qualification Framework (NSQF).

3. Extension of the IDEA (Indian Development and Economic Assistance) Scheme

The Cabinet Committee on Economic Affairs approved the 2nd extension of IDEA scheme i.e. from 2015-16 to

2019-20. Under this scheme, the GoI has been extending Lines of Credit (LoC) to developing countries since 2005.

The projects under IDEA are selected by Ministry of External Affairs (MEA) based on diplomatic considerations and

specific requests from countries, and are approved by Department of Economic Affairs (DEA). The LoCs are

extended at a concessional rate through Exim Bank.

1. Target date for full completion of rural road connectivity under PMGSY forwarded by 3 years

The Government has brought forward the target

date from 2022 to 2019 to achieve complete rural

connectivity through all-weather roads under the

Pradhan Mantri Gram Sadak Yojana.

The accelerated implementation will be achieved by

providing enhanced financial allocation and

through modified funding pattern. The annual

allocation will increase by Rs. 5,000 crore during

2015-16 and the accepted fund sharing pattern will

be in the ratio of 60:40 between the Centre and

States for all States except for 8 North Eastern and 3

Himalayan States for which it will be 90:10.

As a result, 29,000 new habitations will be connected between 2015 to 2017 as against 13,500 between 2012 to

2014.

2. Basic urban infra investment plans for 102 cities approved under AMRUT

MoUD has approved an investment of Rs.3,120 cr for enhancing water supply, sewerage network services, storm

water drains, non-motorised transport and availability of public spaces in 102 cities, under AMRUT. The ministry

will provide an assistance of Rs.1,540 cr which is about 50% of the total project expenditure.

Page 46: NEXUS - swaniti.com · 2 Dear Readers: NEXUS is a monthly compilation of briefs, research insights, visualizations, and papers released by Swaniti. Our mission is to

45

State level Annual Action Plans for 2015-16 have been approved with an investment of Rs.438 cr for Haryana

which has 18 Amrut cities, Rs.573 cr for Chattisgarh (9 cities), Rs.416 cr for Telangana (12 cities), Rs.588 cr for

Kerala (9 cities) and Rs.1,105 cr for West Bengal which has 54 Atal Mission cities.

With the approval, the Ministry has so far cleared a total investment of Rs.11,654 cr in 272 Atal Mission cities.

3. 10 new/ revised schemes announced for the disabled under the National Trust

On December 3rd, Sugamya Bharat Abhiyan or Accessible India

Campaign will be launched as a nationwide flagship campaign for

achieving universal accessibility for Persons with Disabilities and to

create an enabling and barrier free environment.

The following schemes will be launched: DISHA (Early Intervention and

School Readiness Scheme), VIKAAS (Day Care), SAMARTH (Respite

Care), GHARAUNDA (Group Home for Adults), NIRAMAYA (Health

Insurance Scheme), SAHYOGI (Caregiver training scheme), GYAN

PRABHA (Educational support), PRERNA (Marketing Assistance),

SAMBHAV (Aids and Assisted Devices) and BADHTE KADAM

(Awareness and Community Interaction).

The number of categories of disability will also be increased from 7 to

19, so that more number of disabled could be brought into the ambit

of the new initiatives.

Page 47: NEXUS - swaniti.com · 2 Dear Readers: NEXUS is a monthly compilation of briefs, research insights, visualizations, and papers released by Swaniti. Our mission is to

46

In Our Next Edition, grab hold of the following:

1. Tamra Patra

Women in Agriculture

E-health records

Insolvency and Bankruptcy Code

2. Data and Democracy

Lagging behind the herd: Livestock in India

MUDRA: Targeting micro and unorganized businesses

3. Research Support and Engagement with Honorable MPs

Indian Women Parliamentarians’ Forum Round-table session: Generating Livelihood for Women

Round-table session on Water: Water Quality and Fluoride Mitigation

Round-table session on Agriculture: Post Harvest Scenario and Opportunities in India

4. Weekly Policy Updates from January, 2016

Page 48: NEXUS - swaniti.com · 2 Dear Readers: NEXUS is a monthly compilation of briefs, research insights, visualizations, and papers released by Swaniti. Our mission is to

47

Page 49: NEXUS - swaniti.com · 2 Dear Readers: NEXUS is a monthly compilation of briefs, research insights, visualizations, and papers released by Swaniti. Our mission is to

48

Page 50: NEXUS - swaniti.com · 2 Dear Readers: NEXUS is a monthly compilation of briefs, research insights, visualizations, and papers released by Swaniti. Our mission is to