MVWG Report to TSS May 2014 Stephanie Lu, MVWG Chair Seattle City Light.
-
Upload
laurel-doyle -
Category
Documents
-
view
217 -
download
1
Transcript of MVWG Report to TSS May 2014 Stephanie Lu, MVWG Chair Seattle City Light.
MVWG Report to TSSMay 2014
Stephanie Lu, MVWG ChairSeattle City Light
Recent Meetings PPMDTF Conference Call March 7, 2014 HVDCTF Conference Call March 13, 2014 REMTF Meeting March 18-19, 2014 LMTF Meeting March 19, 2014 MVWG Meeting March 19-20, 2014
MVWG Vice Chair Jun Wen, SCE has been appointed as Vice Chair
MVWG member since 2008
Jun Wen is a Senior Power System Engineer at Southern California Edison (SCE) Transmission Strategy and Special Assessment (TSSA). She received her BSEE and MSEE from Tsinghua University in Electrical Engineering, and Ph.D. from University of California with the focus on modern Power Electronics. She has been leading the development of the Centralized RAS project – an IEC 61850 based Wide Area Monitoring and Protection system since 2008, she is also an active member at the WECC Modeling and Validation Working Group. Before joining SCE, she was advisor for One-Cycle Control, Inc. and consultant for Aegis Technology. She has published over thirty technical articles and holds one US and International Patent on multilevel converter topology and applications.
MVWG Activities Overview Approval Items Renewable Energy Modeling Approved Dynamics Model List Load Modeling System Model Validation Generator Modeling, Testing, and Validation HVDC Modeling Other items: NERC Updates, WECC Project
Updates, RAS/Relay Modeling, Program Updates Next Meetings and Workshops
MVWG Approval ItemsFor TSS Approval: Wind Power Plant Dynamic Modeling Guidelines PV Power Plant Dynamic Modeling Guidelines
For TSS Information: Updates to the Approved Dynamics Model List “Model Validation and System Performance Analysis for
PDCI RAS Event that Occurred on May 30, 2013” Report
Renewable Energy Modeling
Wind/Solar Implementation PlanDescription Date
MVWG Approved Model Specifications November 2012TSS Approved Model Specifications January 2013Complete WECC-scale model testing with model prototypes (Alpha version) September 2013
2-Hr Webinar: cover policy, model development, expected deployment process November 2013
Release version of commercial software programs (at least PSLF) made available to WECC as Beta version Nov/Dec 2013
Complete drafting of MVWG to provide Application Guidelines with ‘typical’ data from major manufacturers March 2014
Update Approved Dynamic Models List (add updated wind and solar models, and plan for removing obsolete models) March 2014
WECC completes process to release to WECC users March/April 2014
Issue request for entities to submit data using new models into WECC case, with grace period (coordinate with SRWG) Summer 2014
User Workshop June 17, 2014Model Validation Guideline (Newly added to list) Fall 2014?
2nd Generation Wind Models Type 1 Type 2 Software Platform PSLF™ PSS®E PW PSLF™ PSS®E PW Generator wt1g WT1G1 wt1g, WT1G1 wt2g WT2G1 wt2g, WT2G1 Excitation wt2e WT2E1 wt2e, WT2E1 Turbine wt1t WT12T1 wt1t, WT12T1 wt2t WT12T1 wt2t, WT12T1 Pitch Controller wt1p WT12A1 wt1p, WT12A1 wt2p WT12A1 wt2p, WT12A1 Type 3 Type 4 Software Platform PSLF™ PSS®E PW PSLF™ PSS®E PW Plant Controller repc_a REPCAU1 repc_a repc_a REPCAU1 repc_a Generator/Converter regc_a REGCAU1 regc_a regc_a REGCAU1 regc_a Electrical Control reec_a REECAU1 reec_a reec_a REECAU1 reec_a Turbine wtgt_a WTDTAU1 wtgt_a wtgt_a WTDTAU1 wtgt_a Aerodynamics wtga_a WTARAU1 wtgar_a Pitch Controller wtgp_a WTPTAU1 wtgpt_a Torque Controller wtgq_a WTTQAU1 wtgtrq_a PSLF™ PSS®E PowerWorld Voltage / Frequency Protection (optional)
lhrvt / lhfrt vtgtpa / frqtpa lhrvt / lhfrt
Photovoltaic Models
Distributed and Small PV Plants = PVD1
Module PSLF™ modules PSS®E modules PowerWorld Grid interface regc_a REGCAU1 regc_a Electrical controls reec_b REECBU1 reec_b Plant controller (optional) repc_a REPCAU1 repc_a Voltage/frequency protection (optional)
lhvrt / lhfrt VRGTPA / FRQTPA lhvrt / lhfrt
Wind and PV Dynamic Modeling Guidelines
Guidelines for Wind and PV dynamic modeling were developed and approved by MVWG
Motion: Approve the Wind Power Plant Dynamic Modeling Guidelines
Motion: Approve the PV Power Plant Dynamic Modeling Guidelines
REMTF – Next Steps Wind Type 3 torque controller model – reviewing a
proposal to keep the more complex model as a separate module
Distributed PV model in composite load model More discussion is needed between REMTF, program vendors
and LMTF to implement a distributed PV model in the composite load model CMPLDW
Energy Storage Modeling – NEW Plant Level Control Modeling – NEW
Approved Dynamics List
Approved Dynamics Model List MVWG updated the Approved Dynamic Models List with
the following Added the 2nd generation wind and 1st generation PV models
Added approval dates
In coordination with SRWG implementation plan for new wind models, will remove superseded wt3x and wt4x models
REPC_A – Plant controller for PV, WT3/4
REEC_A – Electrical controls for WT3/4 REEC_B – Electrical controls for PV REGC_A – Generator/Converter for
PV, WT3/4
WTGT_A – Drive Train for WT3/4 WTGA_A – Aerodynamics for WT3 WTGP_A – Pitch control for WT3 WTGQ_A – Torque control for WT3 PVD1 – new model for small PV
Status of Model DevelopmentModel Description Model Name Model Spec
Approved?User Guide Available?
WECC Approved?
Composite load model CMPLDW Need to post X X1st generation wind WTxx models X X XOver excitation model OEL1 PSLF Manual - XSVS models SVSMO1, 2, 3 X X XGenerator model GENTPJ X - XOvercurrent relay model LOCTI & TIOCRS X See Model Spec XVolt and freq ride through LHVRT, LHFRT - - XHydro turbine governor model H6B X - X2nd gen wind/1st gen PV RExx and WTGxx models X X XDistributed PV model PVD1 X X XDirectional Overcurrent relay TIOCRS (revision) X See Model Spec Distance relay model DISTRELAY X See Model Spec Under excitation relays UEL1 & UEL2 IEEE 421.5
(2005)-
Excitation system models See IEEE 421.5 efforts Composite load model with DG Under development Colstrip ATR Under development (NWE) Generator protection Under development (MSRATF)
Other See Approved Dynamics List X
Load Modeling
Load Modeling – Experience with CMPLDW Phase 1 CMPLDW is being provided with 2014 WECC base
cases CAISO, SCE, and WECC reported that high voltages
(1.2-1.3 pu) were seen during the simulations Overvoltages are most sensitive to protection trip set
points and load composition Need data from actual events to validate how much load
trips during actual events and compare against simulation
Load Modeling – Composite Load Model Data Tools Tools available on the TSS Base Cases website
in the Composite Load Model Tools folder Load Model Data Tool LMDT4A
“2012 WECC CMPLDW.zip” Updated Load Composition Data *NEW*
“CMPLDW Load Composition Data_032514.zip” PNNL Tool to create PSSE dyr format
“LMDT_install.zip”
Load Modeling – CMPLDW Phase 2 Work (Bill Price) Reduced computation time by not performing network matrix rebuilding and
factorization every time the taps are changed by LTC (v18.1_03) Added protective functions to MOTORC model (v18.1_03) Implemented request to force initial far-end voltage to be no less than 0.95
by changing taps instead of reducing feeder R&X (v18.1_03) Instead of these solutions, a new request by LMTF is to add a new parameter Vmin to block
the model if the voltage is less than Vmin
Benchmarking will be performed between improved MOTORC and LD1PAC models to determine if MOTORC model option should be added to CMPLDW
Results with transformer saturation modeled showed very minor voltage differences, there is no plan to add this complexity to the model
Distributed PV will be incorporated into CMPLDW Presented a method to simply data management - CMPLDW2
Load Modeling – Voltage Dip Criteria WECC-0100 project is to develop a guideline for items remaining
from RBP and other needs for TPL-001-4, including acceptable voltage response TPL-001-WECC-RBP-2.1 retirement on 12/31/2015
Whitepaper discussed: For small and frequent events, focus on preservation of load For large events, multiple contingencies, or major capacity imbalances,
need to contain it Sensitivity studies with respect to modeling uncertainty are required for
events that are initiated by large faults
MVWG will perform studies and come up with recommended performance guidelines that align with the white paper to support WECC-0100 regarding the transient voltage performance criteria
System Model Validation
May 30 2013 Event Validation Report
MVWG approved the “Model Validation and System Performance Analysis for PDCI RAS Event that Occurred on May 30, 2013” Report
Posted on website:WECC MVWG > Documents > Approved Documents
System Model Validation WECC staff has developed a Sep 8, 2011 case for model
validation, available to operating entities on request MVWG is continuing to improve the process to develop
future model validation cases Using WSM data, EMS data, PI data Created a spreadsheet of key info to collect data from utilities
Additional event cases are being developed: April 29, 2013 July 2, 2013 July 4, 2013
System Model Validation MVWG is participating in the TSS WBRTF effort MVWG contract with GE to convert WECC dyd data to
an “element code” definition with WSM GE presented update of node-breaker capabilities in PSLF
version 19 beta Uses EMS labels for devices (e.g. bus LID) – provides capability
to import WSM node-breaker model data into PSLF Has provided benefits to reconciling modeling differences,
identifying and fixing modeling discrepancies Final deliverable should be completed in the next few months
PTI presented PSSE node-breaker format features – under development
Generator Modeling, Testing, and Model Validation
Synchronous Generator, Excitation and Turbine Control Models Frequency Response Tool Recent Disturbance Events Power Plant Model Validation Tools Power Plant Model Data Task Force Excitation Model Update Governor Modeling
Frequency Response Tool
BPA Generator Frequency Response Tool available Uses PI data
Eric Bakie (IPCO) presented an improved Generator Frequency Response Tool Incorporates PPMV tool for model validation Includes batch processing, for multiple units and
multiple events Training will be provided when tool is made available
Recent Disturbance Events
Jan 29, 2014 @ 6:47:06 PT – Freq dropped to 59.75 Hz Jan 29, 2014 @ 7:03:58 PT – Freq dropped to 59.78 Hz Feb 2, 2014 @ 11:29:32 PT – Freq dropped to 59.87 Hz Feb 21, 2014 @ 10:14:16 PT – Freq dropped to 59.88 Hz Apr 9, 2014 @ 17:33 PT – Freq dropped to 59.92 Hz Apr 15, 2014 @ 05:46:00 PT – Freq dropped to 59.89 Hz Apr 15, 2014 @ 14:43:10 PT – Freq dropped to 59.85 Hz Apr 17, 2014 @ 16:21:03 PT – Freq dropped to 59.89 Hz Apr 21, 2014 @ 10:41:43 PT – Freq dropped to 59.87 Hz Apr 29, 2014 @ 05:23:28 PT – Freq dropped to 59.89 Hz
Power Plant Model Validation Tools Enhanced tool for verifying generator response
“Dynamic Generator Testing.zip” is available on the WECC TSS Base Cases > Data Checking Tools website
Power Plant Model Validation (PPMV) version 1B using PSLF play-in function is available on the WECC MVWG PPMDTF Documents website
Frequency response tool “Gen_Freq_Response.zip” is available to help analyze generator response to frequency disturbances
John Undrill’s data checking tool is posted in the For Generators area in Generator Testing Program Folder
Power Plant Model Data Task Force Reviewed the most recent list of suspected errors – if
there are additional errors suspected, continue to send them to Kent
Will include suspect data errors related to “xcomp” model – sister units should not have a positive xcomp unless there is a ccomp model
Include check that Pmax in powerflow should be less than the governor capability mwcap or there will be an initialization error
MVWG will work with SRWG to incorporate additional data checks into the base case review process
Excitation Models IEEE Standard 421.5 on excitation models is hopefully
up for ballot soon Includes approximately 30 excitation models All include HV and LV gates to incorporate OEL and UEL models
More discussion will be needed to determine which model(s) WECC will recommend to be the approved
Currently OEL1 is WECC approved UEL1 and UEL2 have been recommended to be
implemented in the programs
Governor Modeling Starting an effort to review hydro turbines and hydro
governors – lead TBD Hydro governor models and corresponding
documentation are to be reviewed and changed as necessary in the programs to include the non-windup limits on the PI controller: h6b, pidgov, hyg3 and gpwscc (or wshygp in PSSE).
HVDC Modeling
HVDC Modeling
Conventional point-to-point HVDC Dynamic model: under development
Investigating discrepancies between the EPRI and Siemens benchmark test case
Additional tests will be performed to ensure consistent results
Updates to report will be made as an ongoing effort
VSC point-to-point HVDC Powerflow model
Implemented in PSSE, beta in PowerWorld, beta in PSLF Testing is underway
Dynamic model: two proposals are being discussed Memo by Siemens is currently under review by task force
HVDC Modeling
Ongoing Issues Trans Bay DC model still needs to be validated PDCI Modeling
Sylmar model still needs to be validated Celilo is expected to be replaced in 2016, the updated model
is in progress
Other Items
Other Items
NERC Updates WECC Project Updates
MSRATF Update – RAS/Relay Modeling Program Updates – PSLF, PSSE,
PowerWorld, and Powertech
NERC Updates
Eric Allen (NERC) provided updates MOD-032-1 (modeling data) and MOD-033-1 (validation)
are approved and filed for regulatory approval Update: FERC approved on May 1, 2014
NERC MWG efforts: Node-breaker modeling – implementation targeted for December
2015 Standardization of models – initial draft for powerflow and
dynamic models are completed, not intended to override interregional lists
Developing a list of issues for sharing data between entities when events occur
WECC Project Updates
WECC-0101 SAR Gen Validation Policy Drafting team chaired by Shawn Patterson USBR Draft variance has been posted for comment, due April 28th
WECC-0099 PSS Effectiveness Drafting team formed (consists of Control Work Group), chaired
by Martin Bauer USBR First meeting held in March 2014 Additional studies by MVWG will be performed to support this
effort
Next Meetings & Workshops
Next Meetings & Workshops
June 17-19 in Salt Lake City, hosted by WECC Renewable (Wind/Solar) Modeling Workshop -- June 17th all day MVWG Meeting -- June 18th all day & June 19th morning
November 18-20 in Albuquerque NM, hosted by Sandia National Laboratories REMTF Meeting -- Nov 18th afternoon & Nov 19th morning MVWG Meeting -- Nov 19th afternoon & Nov 20th all day
LMTF, HVDCTF and PPMDTF will meet independently from the main M&VWG meeting.
Questions ?