Mood in Hungarian Casper de Groot ACLC - Universiteit van Amsterdam.

43
Mood in Hungarian Casper de Groot ACLC - Universiteit van Amsterdam

description

ACLC - November 26, 2009 The three universal moods Declarative Alányokfilmetláttak. thegirlsfilm.ACCthey.saw ‘The girls saw a movie.’ Interrogative Hódmezővásárhely Mayarországonfekszik? Hódmezővásárhely Hungary.inlies ‘Is Hódmezővásárhely situated in Hungary? Imperative Men-j-etek haza! Go-SBJV-2PL home ‘Go home!’

Transcript of Mood in Hungarian Casper de Groot ACLC - Universiteit van Amsterdam.

Page 1: Mood in Hungarian Casper de Groot ACLC - Universiteit van Amsterdam.

Mood in Hungarian

Casper de GrootACLC - Universiteit van Amsterdam

Page 2: Mood in Hungarian Casper de Groot ACLC - Universiteit van Amsterdam.

ACLC - November 26, 2009

The three universal moods

● The basic illocution of a sentence can be defined as the conversational use conventionally associated with the formal properties of that sentence (cf. Sadock & Zwicky 1985), which together constitute a sentence type.

● By their very nature, basic illocutions are restricted to independent sentences and quotations.

● The most frequently attested basic illocutions in languages of the world are Declarative, Interrogative and Imperative (Sadock & Zwicky 1985).

● The declarative sentence in is conventionally associated with an assertion

● the interrogative with a question● the imperative with a command.

Page 3: Mood in Hungarian Casper de Groot ACLC - Universiteit van Amsterdam.

ACLC - November 26, 2009

The three universal moodsDeclarative

A lányok filmet láttak.the girls film.ACC they.saw‘The girls saw a movie.’

InterrogativeHódmezővásárhely Mayarországon fekszik?Hódmezővásárhely Hungary.in lies‘Is Hódmezővásárhely situated in Hungary?

ImperativeMen-j-etek haza!Go-SBJV-2PL home‘Go home!’

Page 4: Mood in Hungarian Casper de Groot ACLC - Universiteit van Amsterdam.

ACLC - November 26, 2009

Defining Mood

● The term mood is used in language descriptions for the morphological category that covers the grammatical reflections of a large semantic area. This area can be subdivided into two smaller ones:

● the first concerns the area of illocutionthe category of illocution is concerned with identifying sentences as instances of specific types of speech act

● the second concerns the area of modalitythe category of modality is concerned with the modification of the content of speech acts.

Page 5: Mood in Hungarian Casper de Groot ACLC - Universiteit van Amsterdam.

ACLC - November 26, 2009

Defining Mood

● Apart from the semantic differences, there are also formal reasons to distinguish between the two areas.

● In the expression of illocution the morphological category of mood has to compete with word order and intonation as markers of particular sub-distinctions

● whereas modality is expressed by mood markers only.

● These distinction is from S.C. Dik (1997) and P.C. Hengeveld (2004)

Page 6: Mood in Hungarian Casper de Groot ACLC - Universiteit van Amsterdam.

ACLC - November 26, 2009

Defining Mood

● A fourth parameter relevant to the discussion of mood in Hungarian is that of Factuality, i.e. the quality of the communicated content being actual (opposed to virtual) or based on fact.

● I will argue that the relations between the four parameters Mood, Illocution, Modality, and Factuality are the following

Page 7: Mood in Hungarian Casper de Groot ACLC - Universiteit van Amsterdam.

ACLC - November 26, 2009

The parameters defining Mood in Hungarian

Mood Indicative Subjunctive Conditional

Illocution Declarative Interrogative Behavioural

Modality Condition

Factuality Factual Non-factual

Page 8: Mood in Hungarian Casper de Groot ACLC - Universiteit van Amsterdam.

ACLC - November 26, 2009

The parameters defining Mood in Hungarian

Illocution Declarative Interrogative Behavioural

Page 9: Mood in Hungarian Casper de Groot ACLC - Universiteit van Amsterdam.

ACLC - November 26, 2009

Declarative

v

Mirative

Polar Interrogative

v

Content Interrogative

Imperative > Prohibitative

v v

Hortative > Dishortative

v

Admonitive

v

Supplicative

Assertive

Questioning

Behavioural

Page 10: Mood in Hungarian Casper de Groot ACLC - Universiteit van Amsterdam.

ACLC - November 26, 2009

Declarative

v

Mirative

Assertive

Page 11: Mood in Hungarian Casper de Groot ACLC - Universiteit van Amsterdam.

ACLC - November 26, 2009

Assertive

● Declarative

● MirativeThere is no distinct form to express Mirative as, for instance, in Albanian.

Page 12: Mood in Hungarian Casper de Groot ACLC - Universiteit van Amsterdam.

ACLC - November 26, 2009

Polar Interrogative

v

Content Interrogative

Questioning

Page 13: Mood in Hungarian Casper de Groot ACLC - Universiteit van Amsterdam.

ACLC - November 26, 2009

Questioning

● Polar InterrogativeBy using the Polar Interrogative, A Speaker requests an Addressee to tell whether a certain proposition is true or false.

● Content InterrogativeBy using the Content Interrogative, a Speaker requests an Addressee to identify or specify some part of a predication.

Page 14: Mood in Hungarian Casper de Groot ACLC - Universiteit van Amsterdam.

ACLC - November 26, 2009

Questioning

● Polar Interrogative

Szegeden voltál?Szeged.in you.were‘Were you in Szeged?’

Page 15: Mood in Hungarian Casper de Groot ACLC - Universiteit van Amsterdam.

ACLC - November 26, 2009

Questioning

● Polar Interrogative

Szegeden voltál?Szeged.in you.were‘Were you in Szeged?’

Page 16: Mood in Hungarian Casper de Groot ACLC - Universiteit van Amsterdam.

ACLC - November 26, 2009

Questioning● Modification of Polar Interrogative

vajon and the enclitic –e express some kind of doubt, desire, or uncertainty on the part of the Speaker. They do not create sub-types of illocutions; they belong to the area of modality.

Vajon jön(-e) Imre holnap?MOD come(-MOD) Imre tomorrow‘Will Imre come tomorrow?’

Gondolkozom, hogy jön-e Imre holnapI.wonder that come-MOD Imre tomorrow‘I wonder whether Imre will come tomorrow.’

Page 17: Mood in Hungarian Casper de Groot ACLC - Universiteit van Amsterdam.

ACLC - November 26, 2009

Questioning

● Content Interrogative

János mikor volt úszni? questionJános when was swim‘When was János off for a swim?’

János ma volt úszni. answerJános today was swim‘János was off for a swim TODAY.’

Page 18: Mood in Hungarian Casper de Groot ACLC - Universiteit van Amsterdam.

ACLC - November 26, 2009

Questioning

● Content Interrogative

János mikor volt úszni? questionJános when was swim‘When was János off for a swim?’

János ma volt úszni. answerJános today was swim‘János was off for a swim TODAY.’

Page 19: Mood in Hungarian Casper de Groot ACLC - Universiteit van Amsterdam.

ACLC - November 26, 2009

Imperative > Prohibitative

v v

Hortative > Dishortative

v

Admonitive

v

Supplicative

Behavioural

Page 20: Mood in Hungarian Casper de Groot ACLC - Universiteit van Amsterdam.

ACLC - November 26, 2009

Behavioural Illocution in HungarianÖl-j-ek ‘Let me kill.’Öl-j-él ‘Kill!’Öl-j-ön ‘Kill!’, ‘Let him/her kill.’Öl-j-ünk ‘Let us kill.’Öl-j-etek ‘Kill!’Öl-j-enek ‘Kill!’, ‘Let them kill.’

Öl-j-em ‘Let me kill it.’Öl-j-ed ‘Kill it!’Öl-j-e ‘Kill it!’, ‘Let him/her kill it’Öl-j-ük ‘Let us kill it.’Öl-j-étek ‘Kill it!’Öl-j-ék ‘Kill it!’, ‘Let them kill it.’

Öl-j-elek ‘Let me kill you.’

Page 21: Mood in Hungarian Casper de Groot ACLC - Universiteit van Amsterdam.

ACLC - November 26, 2009

Behavioural Illocution in HungarianÖl-j-ek ‘Let me kill.’Öl-j-él ‘Kill!’Öl-j-ön ‘Kill!’, ‘Let him/her kill.’Öl-j-ünk ‘Let us kill.’Öl-j-etek ‘Kill!’Öl-j-enek ‘Kill!’, ‘Let them kill.’

Öl-j-em ‘Let me kill it.’Öl-j-ed ‘Kill it!’Öl-j-e ‘Kill it!’, ‘Let him/her kill it’Öl-j-ük ‘Let us kill it.’Öl-j-étek ‘Kill it!’Öl-j-ék ‘Kill it!’, ‘Let them kill it.’

Öl-j-elek ‘Let me kill you.’

Page 22: Mood in Hungarian Casper de Groot ACLC - Universiteit van Amsterdam.

ACLC - November 26, 2009

Imperative > Prohibitative

v v

Hortative > Dishortative

v

Admonitive

v

Supplicative

Behavioural

Page 23: Mood in Hungarian Casper de Groot ACLC - Universiteit van Amsterdam.

ACLC - November 26, 2009

Behavioural: Imperative● Imperative

The Speaker commands an Addressee to perform some action. The Addressee may be singular or plural. There is an informal and a polite form.

2 pers. sing. várj(ál) ‘Wait!’ [informal singular]3 pers. sing. várjon ‘Wait!’ [polite singular]2 pers. pl. várjatok ‘Wait!’ [informal plural]3 pers. pl. várjanak ‘Wait!’ [polite plural]

2 pers. sing. vár(ja)d Pált ‘Wait for Paul!’ [informal singular]

3 pers. sing. várja Pált ‘Wait for Paul!’ [polite singular]2 pers. pl. várjátok Pált ‘Wait for Paul!’ [informal plural]3 pers. pl. várják Pált ‘Wait for Paul!’ [polite plural]

Page 24: Mood in Hungarian Casper de Groot ACLC - Universiteit van Amsterdam.

ACLC - November 26, 2009

Behavioural: Imperative● Modification of the Imperative

When the Imperative is used, the perfectivizing prefix is standard as a default and is placed after the verb. The Imperative may be modified. It may be reinforced and becaome a ‘threat’ if the verbal prefix is placed in front of the verb.

Zsuzsát vár-j-ad meg az állomáson.Zsuzsa.ACC wait-SBJV-2p ASP the station.at‘Go to meet Zsuzsa at the station’

Zsuzsát meg-vár-j-ad az állomáson.Zsuzsa.ACC ASP-wait-SBJV-2p the station.at‘Go to meet Zsuzsa at the station, or ….’

Page 25: Mood in Hungarian Casper de Groot ACLC - Universiteit van Amsterdam.

ACLC - November 26, 2009

Imperative > Prohibitative

v v

Hortative > Dishortative

v

Admonitive

v

Supplicative

Behavioural

Page 26: Mood in Hungarian Casper de Groot ACLC - Universiteit van Amsterdam.

ACLC - November 26, 2009

Behavioural: Hortative● Hortative

The interpretation of Hortative occurs in all person distinctions in the verbal paradigm.

Men-j-ünk tovább.Go-SBJV-1PL further‘Let’s go on.’

Válassz, melyikkel öl-j-elek meg!choose.SBJV.2SG which.with kill-SBJV.1SG.2SG/PL ASP‘Choose the one I kill you with.’

Page 27: Mood in Hungarian Casper de Groot ACLC - Universiteit van Amsterdam.

ACLC - November 26, 2009

Imperative > Prohibitative

v v

Hortative > Dishortative

v

Admonitive

v

Supplicative

Behavioural

Page 28: Mood in Hungarian Casper de Groot ACLC - Universiteit van Amsterdam.

ACLC - November 26, 2009

Behavioural: Prohibitive● Prohibitive

Utterances used as an Imperative together with a negation yield a Prohibitive interpretation.

Ne men-j el.NEG.SBJV go-SBJV-2SG ASP‘Don’t go away!’

● Note the use of the negative ne instead of nem. The negation element used with the Subjunctive is always ne, glossed as NEG>SBJV, whereas nem is used with the Indicative and Conditional.

Page 29: Mood in Hungarian Casper de Groot ACLC - Universiteit van Amsterdam.

ACLC - November 26, 2009

Imperative > Prohibitative

v v

Hortative > Dishortative

v

Admonitive

v

Supplicative

Behavioural

Page 30: Mood in Hungarian Casper de Groot ACLC - Universiteit van Amsterdam.

ACLC - November 26, 2009

Behavioural: Dishortative● Dishortative

The Hortative use of the behavioural together with a negation yield the Dishortative interpretation.

Téged, kedves ellenség, meg ne öl-j-elek !you.ACC dear enemy ASP NEG.SBJV kill-SBJV-I.You‘You, dear enemy, I do not kill !’

Page 31: Mood in Hungarian Casper de Groot ACLC - Universiteit van Amsterdam.

ACLC - November 26, 2009

Imperative > Prohibitative

v v

Hortative > Dishortative

v

Admonitive

v

Supplicative

Behavioural

Page 32: Mood in Hungarian Casper de Groot ACLC - Universiteit van Amsterdam.

ACLC - November 26, 2009

Behavioural: Admonitive● Admonitive

There are no clear examples of the Bahavioural with the interpretation of the Admonitive.

This would then constitute a counter example against the idea that the implicational relations between the subtypes of illocutions also apply to the interpretations, because the Supplicative interpretation does occur in Hungarian.

Page 33: Mood in Hungarian Casper de Groot ACLC - Universiteit van Amsterdam.

ACLC - November 26, 2009

Imperative > Prohibitative

v v

Hortative > Dishortative

v

Admonitive

v

Supplicative

Behavioural

Page 34: Mood in Hungarian Casper de Groot ACLC - Universiteit van Amsterdam.

ACLC - November 26, 2009

Behavioural: Supplicative● Supplicative

With the form hadd it is possible to express a request for permission

Hadd men-j-ek a moziba!Let.SBJV.2SG go-SBJV-1SG the movie.to‘Please, let me go to the movies.’

Hadd beszél-j-enek tovább!Let.SBJV.2SG speak-SBJV-3PL further‘Please, let them speak further.’

Page 35: Mood in Hungarian Casper de Groot ACLC - Universiteit van Amsterdam.

ACLC - November 26, 2009

Imperative > Prohibitative

v v

Hortative > Dishortative

v

(Admonitive)

v

Supplicative

Behavioural

Page 36: Mood in Hungarian Casper de Groot ACLC - Universiteit van Amsterdam.

ACLC - November 26, 2009

Declarative

v

(Mirative)

Polar Interrogative

v

Content Interrogative

Imperative > Prohibitative

v v

Hortative > Dishortative

v

(Admonitive)

v

Supplicative

Assertive

Questioning

Behavioural

Page 37: Mood in Hungarian Casper de Groot ACLC - Universiteit van Amsterdam.

ACLC - November 26, 2009

The parameters defining Mood in Hungarian

Mood Indicative Subjunctive Conditional

Illocution Declarative Interrogative Behavioural

Modality Condition

Factuality Factual Non-factual

Page 38: Mood in Hungarian Casper de Groot ACLC - Universiteit van Amsterdam.

ACLC - November 26, 2009

Conditional● Condition

Hungarian distinguishes a Conditional Mood. The Conditional is marked by the suffix –n on the verbal stem.

Bár / Ha / Bárha tud-ná-nak olvasni!Though / If know-COND-3PL read.INF‘If they could read!.’

● The Conditional is used in both the protasis and apodosis.

Jó lenne, ha többet lát-n-ám!good be-COND if more.ACC see-COND-1SG‘It would be good, if I could see him/her/it more.’

Page 39: Mood in Hungarian Casper de Groot ACLC - Universiteit van Amsterdam.

ACLC - November 26, 2009

Conditional● Counter factuals

Past tense Conditionals form counter factuals.

Jó lett volna, ha többet láttam volna.good be.PST COND if more.ACC see.PST.1SG COND‘It would have been good, if I had seen more.’

Page 40: Mood in Hungarian Casper de Groot ACLC - Universiteit van Amsterdam.

ACLC - November 26, 2009

Conditional● Conditional sentence

Ha nem / *ne késztél volna el …If not / NEG.SBJV be-PST.2SG COND ASP‘If you had not been late, ….’

● Optative sentence

Bárcsak ne / *nem késztél volna el!if.only NEG.SBJV / not be-PST.2SG COND ASP‘If only you had not been late!’

Page 41: Mood in Hungarian Casper de Groot ACLC - Universiteit van Amsterdam.

ACLC - November 26, 2009

The location of the Optative

Mood Indicative Subjunctive Conditional

Illocution Declarative Interrogative Behavioural

Modality Condition

Factuality Factual Non-factual

Page 42: Mood in Hungarian Casper de Groot ACLC - Universiteit van Amsterdam.

ACLC - November 26, 2009

The location of the Optative

Mood Indicative Subjunctive Conditional

Illocution Declarative Interrogative Behavioural

Modality Condition

Factuality Factual Non-factual

Ne COND

Page 43: Mood in Hungarian Casper de Groot ACLC - Universiteit van Amsterdam.

ACLC - November 26, 2009

Conclusions● Mood covers the areas of Illocution and Modality ● Illocution uses word order and intonation as markers in

competition with other sub-distionctions● Modality uses special markers only● Intonation● Word order: the position of the particle● Negation marker: nem versus ne● Optative construction

[email protected]://home.medewerkers.uva.nl/c.degroot