Monitor Business Model Innovation 22 Nov

download Monitor Business Model Innovation 22 Nov

of 12

Transcript of Monitor Business Model Innovation 22 Nov

  • 7/31/2019 Monitor Business Model Innovation 22 Nov

    1/12

    by Geoff Tuff and Stephen Wunker

    MONITOR

    PERSPECTIVES

    Beacons for Business

    Model Innovation

    How applying two pattern recognition tools

    can empower companies to pick and develop

    breakthrough winners in their innovation portfolio.

    Business Model Innovation is a hot topic in

    management thinking these days, even though

    there seems to be little agreement about what it

    looks like and even less about how to discover

    it. But there is no reason for Business Model

    Innovation to feel mysterious or hard to achieve.

    By using analytic tools that provide better

    decision-making insights, executives can vastly

    improve their innovation success rateand

    ensure their business model investments generate

    bigger returns.

  • 7/31/2019 Monitor Business Model Innovation 22 Nov

    2/12

    2 BEACONS FOR BUSINESS MODEL INNOVATION

    MONITOR

    PERSPECTIVES

    Tupelo, Mississippi has seen its share o

    people upending tradition. Not only is this

    small Southern town the birthplace o music

    revolutionary Elvis Presley, it is also ground

    zero or a new movement that seeks to trans-

    orm a totally dierent eldhow we care or

    our elders. Rejecting traditional models o

    senior livingones that eature a large medi-

    cal sta tending to hundreds o patients in

    an institutionalized settinga Tupelo doctor

    created the rst Green House senior home.

    These acilities contain no more than a dozen

    residents. The residents interact with each

    other in a large common area, play a role in

    decision-making, and are cared or by a single

    multi-tasking nurses aide. As the name sug-

    gests, the place eels like a house, not a hospi-

    tal or a nursing home. Residents ound the

    Green House experience so compelling that

    the concept has now been replicated more

    than 50 times. The radical approach to care

    is mirrored by an equally unique economic

    model that slashes stang and overhead

    costs. Due to the small scale o the acility

    and the act that there is just one multi-

    tasking worker, total sta time is 30 minutes

    less per resident-day, even while nursing care

    time (what matters most to the residents) is

    1.5 hours more. Green Houses are a new busi-

    ness model ounded on a total rethinking othe customer experience o elder residents.

    By contrast, Business Model Innovation in the

    newspaper industry seems to have lost touch

    with the customer and has instead become

    a euphemism or cost cutting. Even leading

    institutions such as the Tribune Company,

    owner oThe Chicago Tribune and other newspa-

    pers, seem to have been doing little new except

    or cutting journalists and putting articles

    online. Taking an inward-looking view, many

    in this industry seem to think that the simul-

    taneous implosion o advertising and circu-

    lation can be addressed by thinner papers

    carrying more wire service stories, rather than

    through innovations in areas such as syndi-

    cating content and creating ocused reader

    communities. A customer-ocused view might

    have looked at the many touchpoints newspa-

    pers can have in peoples lives and communi-

    ties. There is little reason, or example, that

    newspapers could not have dominated the

    online classied industry rather than ceding

    it to upstarts such as Monster.com and eBay.

    It is not a shock that newspapers have largely

    ailed to create new business models. The

    promise o Business Model Innovationto

    create new product and service categories that

    make money in new ways and achieve acceler-

    ated growthgenerates enthusiasm but comes

    with a big catch: it requires true integrative

    change across many unctions o a company,

    rom nance and operations to manuactur-

    ing, marketing and sales. It requires new

    skills, new behaviors and the courage rom

    leaders to think, act and lead dierently.

    Executives can increase their odds o success

    by using a rigorous set o decision-making

    and pattern recognition tools. In this ar-

    ticle, we will briefy touch on two critical

  • 7/31/2019 Monitor Business Model Innovation 22 Nov

    3/12

    BEACONS FOR BUSINESS MODEL INNOVATION 3

    diagnostic tools, the Ten Types o Innova-

    tion and Economic Value Estimation. By

    taking advantage o the insights these tools

    oer, corporate leaders can analyze which

    Business Model Innovation projects oer the

    most value or customers, allowing them to

    pick the winners and shut down the losers.

    The Ten Types of Innovation: Meshing

    Inventive Revenue Models with New

    Customer Experiences

    In examining more than 5,000 innovations

    successul and not over the past 15 years, we

    have been able to classiy innovation activi-

    ties into Ten Types o Innovation. Sadly,

    most o these innovations have not been

    successul (dened as returning their cost o

    capital), achieving in aggregate an abysmal

    success rate o 4.5 percent. Why? The vast

    majority o them and especially the ailed

    attempts have been centered on Product

    and Product System innovation (see Exhibit

    1 below). This should not be surprising:

    new product ideas are easy to dream up and

    just as easy to kill in the average companys

    stage-gate process. I they are lucky enough

    to make it through to market launch, many

    product-ocused innovators nd themselves

    vulnerable to competitors. This challenge is

    becoming only more daunting as competi-

    tion heats up in all corners o the world,

    especially in emerging markets where patent

    law may be less eective and mastery o com-

    plex distribution systems can matter more

    than having the best product on the shel.

    By contrast, the most successul innova-

    tions we studied share two important traits.

    First, they ocus on shits in the revenue

    model and the customer experience. And

    second, they employ multiple types o in-

    novationrequently six or moremaking

    them genuinely new and dierent business

    Exhibit 1:

    The Ten Types of Innovation

    The most successful business model innovations combine new ways of making money

    with new, great customer experiences.

    Biggest opportunities are anchored here

    Most companies focus here

    Finance

    Businessmodel

    Enablingprocess

    Coreprocess

    Productperformance

    Productsystem

    Customerexperience

    Networking Service Channel Brand

    Process Offering Delivery

  • 7/31/2019 Monitor Business Model Innovation 22 Nov

    4/12

    4 BEACONS FOR BUSINESS MODEL INNOVATION

    MONITOR

    PERSPECTIVES

    models. These are breakthrough innova-tions that deliver unique value to customers

    and are integrative in nature (across company

    unctions) and thus hard to replicate. In

    our research, only 2 percent o the initia-

    tives demonstrated these attributes and yet

    they delivered 90 percent o the cumula-

    tive value o all the innovations studied.

    In the course o this research we also discov-ered that it is very hard to innovate around

    revenue models and customer experience

    and notpull along other types o innovative

    change. For real Business Model Innovation,

    a company must assemble six or more types

    o innovation, with at least one innovation

    type coming rom each o the our major

    categories (Finance, Process, Oering and

    INSIDE THE BUSINESS MODEL INNOVATIONS AT THREE LEADERS

    Dellrevolutionizesthepersonalcomputermarket.Dell was founded in 1984 on the premise that individual-

    ized computers could be sold directly to customers in order to better understand and meet consumer needs while

    responding more quickly to changes in the marketplace. This approach, combined with the introduction of relatively

    novel supply chain processes such as configure-to-order and just-in-time manufacturing, allowed the company to

    have substantially lower costs than its competitors. Dell rose from dormitory room start-up to global leadership in

    personal computer sales within just 15 years.

    NestlNespressoleveragesbrandawarenesstoopenaboutiqueretailbusiness.The Nespresso offering

    started with an innovative high-end productspecially designed machines and individual coffee capsules that

    enabled consumers to quickly produce a quality and individualized cup of espresso. It has since grown into an

    integrated customer experience. In addition to its 24-hour information and ordering service, Nespresso has opened

    a line of boutique retail outlets designed to provide Nespresso Club Members with an opportunity to learn about

    premium coffee, preparation techniques, and new Nespresso products. In addition to affording the company signifi-

    cant direct access to customers, the global network of 190 boutiques accounts for 30 percent of Nespresso sales.

    Plans are in place to open 30 new locations during 2010.

    HSBCFirstDirectcreatesabranchlessbank.First Direct was founded in 1989 based on the insight that a

    significant number of bank clients did not use branch services and those that did reported relatively low customersatisfaction. In order to serve this market segment, First Direct offered a new approach to banking in the U.K.:

    customers could access all banking services over the telephone 24 hours a day, 7 days a week, 365 days a year.

    This was in stark contrast to traditional banks, which were generally open from 9 a.m. to 4 p.m. and closed for most

    of the weekend. First Direct has continued to lead in innovative services, such as being one of the first banks with

    online and mobile banking. As a result, it has attracted more than one million customers since inception.

  • 7/31/2019 Monitor Business Model Innovation 22 Nov

    5/12

    BEACONS FOR BUSINESS MODEL INNOVATION 5

    Delivery). Changing these undamentals re-quires signicant shits across the business

    value chain. For example, it is a steep chal-

    lenge to build a great, new customer experi-

    ence without also innovating your oering,

    processes, partnerships and payment terms.

    These ndings lead to a relatively basic condi-

    tion or innovation success: i you want to be

    in the small minority o companies that have

    really created value rom innovation, developconcepts that are anchored at the ends o

    the Ten Types spectrum and that contain pos-

    sibilities or at least our other innovation

    Types as well. Sometimes, this will involve

    creating a thrilling experience or your cus-

    tomers and guring out how to make money

    rom it in novel ways think Apples iTunes

    or Nestls Nespresso. Other times, it will

    involve delivering at least an acceptable prod-

    uct-service package much more cost eective-ly than is possible using the accepted business

    models think Dell or Southwest Airlines.

    Estimating the Economic Value of

    Innovative Business Models

    Eective Business Model Innovation is the

    ability to discover new ways o making money.

    It is oten developed by tying scalable revenue

    or margin opportunities to untapped sourceso customer value or by creating value more

    cost-eectively than the competition. For

    decades, precepts o good marketing have

    taught us that oers should satisy cus-

    tomer needs. The diculty, o course, is that

    customers oten cannot provide a ull and

    accurate description o what they want. Theymay not have the language or it, they may

    be (unconsciously) motivated to obscure the

    truth, they may be basing their consideration

    on past experience, and they certainly can-

    not predict how their needs will evolve in the

    uture. Increasingly, companies are tapping

    into the eld o design-driven innovation or

    inspiration about how to explore their cus-

    tomers needs and desires. Especially when

    it comes to discovering what might lead to

    a thrilling customer experience, it is vital

    to use non-traditional research techniques.

    Video ethnography, eld observation and

    in-depth interviews are the tools o cultural

    anthropologists who are behind some o

    todays most exciting customer discover-

    ies. These tools provide insight into not just

    what customers say they want, but also their

    latent, emerging and wholly unmet needs.

    In order to tie insight to protable opportu-

    nities, we like to borrow the Economic Value

    Estimation (EVE) tool pioneered by pricing

    strategist Tom Nagle. EVE is a simple rame-

    work which breaks down the economic value

    o an oer into its component parts and

    compares this value to a next-best competitive

    alternative (see Exhibit 2). By combining EVE

    with non-traditional research techniques

    (ocused on generating new customer experi-ences), companies can begin to hypothesize

    what cost and value would be associated with

    any new oering. Establishing the EVE o a

    potential innovation can help set a thresh-

    old or when a project is worth pursuing.

  • 7/31/2019 Monitor Business Model Innovation 22 Nov

    6/12

    6 BEACONS FOR BUSINESS MODEL INNOVATION

    MONITOR

    PERSPECTIVES

    Me-too or low-payback initiatives should be

    scrutinized early in the development process

    and either killed or reshaped. High-payback

    innovations will either leverage a higher ab-

    solute level o value than alternatives or a

    lower (though still acceptable) level o value

    using a much lower cost structure. Find the

    innovations within your portolio which

    have the highest ratio o Total Economic

    Value to Reerence Value (o course, or a

    breakthrough innovation creating a new

    market, a Reerence Value will not exist and

    that in turn will magniy the innovations

    Economic Value). And out o those, the

    ones that combine multiple types o innova-

    tion at least six are your likely winners.

    It is enlightening to examine a recent innova-

    tion in light o Economic Value Estimation.

    The leading Arican telecom company Celtel

    (now owned by Indias Bharti) launched a

    mobile commerce service targeting business-

    to-business payments, given that so many o

    these transactions occur in cash in the worlds

    least developed markets. Potential corporate

    customers were initially skeptical o paying

    Celtel transaction ees until the companys

    sta rode along with trucking feets and

    discovered just how valuable mobile com-

    merce could be. For example, during a typical

    eight-hour delivery run, three hours could be

    spent counting cash in very small bills, and

    cash could be counted eight times between

    the time it was paid and ultimately

    banked. There were huge ineciencies

    to address. Even more compellingly,

    Celtel saw that distributors were losing

    substantial sales by taking their orders

    during the prior days delivery, and

    that mobile technology could empower

    them to accept orders in real time rom

    handsets so they could adjust or de-

    mand swings as they happened. The

    company calculated that its services

    were worth 1 to 4 percent o the total

    transaction value, depending upon its

    clients circumstances. Ethnographygave Celtel the power to price mobile

    commerce according to the value it

    created and provided insights into

    totally new directions or the service.

    PositiveDifferentiation

    Value

    ReferenceValue

    Negative

    DifferentiationValue

    Differentiation Value: Thevalue to the customer (bothpositive and negative) ofany differences betweenyour offering and thereference product

    Reference Value: The price(adjusted for differences in

    units) of the customersbest alternative

    Exhibit 2: How EVE Pinpoints High-Value Innovations

    Source: Thomas T. Nagle, John E. Hogan and Joseph Zale,The Strategy and Tactics ofPricing, Fifth Edition (Saddle River, N.J.: Prentice Hall), 20.

    TotalEconomic

    Value

  • 7/31/2019 Monitor Business Model Innovation 22 Nov

    7/12

    BEACONS FOR BUSINESS MODEL INNOVATION 7

    Where to Start

    Any company that wants to take ac-

    tion on Ten Types and EVE diagnostic

    work will need to start with two un-

    damental requirements or success:

    1. Understand the basic operat-

    ing parameters o your company

    to be able to determine what is

    economically and organization-

    ally viable and what is not

    2. Know the collection orevenue

    models that the business world has

    used over time and understand how

    these analogs mightand might

    notbe applied to your company

    Operating parameters. The rst require-

    ment or success is that you understand the

    basic operating parameters o your company

    to determine what is viable. To think about

    the hidden shackles that prevent business

    model change, untangle the web o business

    processes, supply chain partnerships and oth-

    er relationships that enable a rm to succeed.

    These include the suppliers, sales channels,

    and even the types o customers to target.

    Which o these operating parameters would

    be threatened by a new business model? How

    could a new model start o the radar sokey stakeholders were not threatened? Think

    through all o the companys competencies,

    rules and behaviors that acilitate the cur-

    rent model, and how these might need to

    change. For instance, will sales compensation

    need to emphasize more teamwork than at

    present? Will the emphasis be on a dierent

    sort o buyerone with an oce and not a

    cubicle? Proactively addressing these hurdles

    in ocused pilots can reduce an organiza-

    tions reluctance towards change while at the

    same time revealing unseen dependencies.

    Prototyping via pilots enables you to test the

    fexibility o your companya key need or

    Business Model Innovation. Because these

    approaches are not simply window dressing

    and checklists or one-o projects, they must

    become corporate capabilities that enable a

    company to sustain its position over time.

    Senior executives need to lead by example and

    embed fexibility into their company. Some-

    times, the solution is not to invent a com-

    pletely new way o doing business, but instead

    to do old things in new ways and discover

    undamentally cheaper methods to deliver

    existing sources o value to your customers.

    Revenue models. The second requirement

    or success is to understand the types o rev-

    enue models that exist across the business

    landscape today. Through our retrospective

    look at past successul innovations, we have

    catalogued 20 dierent revenue models that

    are typically used by corporations today.

    These are shown in Exhibit 3 on pages 8 and 9.

    Knowing these models is necessary but not

    sucient; to really unlock the potential

    behind alternate revenue models, rst un-

    derstand company and industry orthodox-

    ies i.e., just the way things are done around

  • 7/31/2019 Monitor Business Model Innovation 22 Nov

    8/12

    8 BEACONS FOR BUSINESS MODEL INNOVATION

    MONITOR

    PERSPECTIVES

    Exhibit 3: 20 Sample Revenue Models from Successful InnovatorsTACTIC DEFINITION EXAMPLE

    Subscription Create predictable cash flows by charging customersup front (a one time or recurring fee) to have access tothe product/service over time.

    NETFLIX turned the video rental industry on its head withthe implementation of a subscription model (no morelate fees!).

    Float Receive payment prior to building the offeringuse the cash to earn interest prior to makingmargins.

    DELL chose to carry no inventory and only built eachcomputer after it was ordered and paid for: earninginterest instead of carrying inventory risk.

    Freemium Offer basic services for free, while charging apremium for advanced or special features.

    SKYPE developed free Skype-to-Skype calls, but chargeda premium for outgoing and incoming calls to landlinesand mobiles.

    Flexible Pricing Vary prices for offering based on expected demand. AMERICAN AIRLINES implemented Super Saverfares in 1977 that enabled variable pricing dependingon demand patterns in an effort to fill seats during less-

    traveled times.

    Installed Base Offer a core product for slim margins or loss todrive demand, realize profit on follow-up productsand services.

    HEWLETT PACKARD subsidized the initial cost of printersand made its profits on high margin replacement inkcartridges and paper.

    Auction Allow a market to set the price for goods andservices.

    SECOND LIFE, an online virtual world, auctioned offparcels of virtual land for player development; thewinning bidder could pay with either US dollars orLindens (the in-world currency).

    User-Defined Invite customers to set a price they wish to pay. RADIOHEAD went direct to fans when it offered its albumIn Rainbowsonline and allowed fans to set the price theywanted to pay for the entire album.

    Ad-Supported Provides content / services for free to one party whileselling listeners, viewers or eyeballs to another party.

    GOOGLEs AdSense charged sponsors to place links onusers (free) search results pages; the revenue supportedthe majority of Googles operations.

    Forced Scarcity Limit the number of offerings available, by quantity ortime frame, to drive up demand and price point. GROUPON, a bulk-buying website, chose to offereverything from yoga classes to teeth whitening torestaurant discounts but only one deal is available perday, starting promptly at midnight and ending at 11:59p.m. or when it sells out ... whichever comes first.

    Volume Earn outsized margins on large-size products ortransactions by keeping cost per unit fixed, regardlessof unit size.

    MORGAN STANLEYs costs for managing large sumsof money were roughly the same as for small sums,but fees and thus profit escalated with largertransactions.

    Cost Leadership Keep variable costs low and sell high volumes at lowprices.

    BIC created the first low-cost ballpoint pens andobliterated the fountain pen market with its low marginproduct sold in immense quantities.

    Multi-LevelMarketing

    Sell bulk or packaged goods to a sales force that turnsaround and sells it.

    AMWAY sold its beauty, wellness, and home productsdirectly to its network of independent business ownerswho took on the responsibility of selling the productsthrough personal referrals.

    Premium Price at a higher margin than competitors, usually fora superior product, offering, experience, service orbrand.

    APPLE typically priced its products well above thecompetitionnonetheless, customers purchased Appleproducts for their design, ease of use, and cachet.

    Licensing Grant permission to some other group or individualto use your offering in a defined way for a specifiedpayment.

    MONSANTO applied a yearly software licensing modelto a batch of its seeds to ensure yearly revenues fromgrowers.

  • 7/31/2019 Monitor Business Model Innovation 22 Nov

    9/12

    BEACONS FOR BUSINESS MODEL INNOVATION 9

    here and then consider how analogous

    models rom other industries might be put

    to use. As an example o industry orthodoxy,consider the Installed Base model represented

    by Hewlett-Packards approach to the print-

    ing business. HP built a ormidable market

    position through selling printers at a small

    loss and attempting to lock users into buying

    its highly lucrative ink cartridges. Kodak, a

    latecomer to this industry, has had to play the

    game dierently to gain traction. Rather than

    copy the HP model, Kodak reversed it. It sells

    printers at a healthy margin and provides theink at relatively low prices. The model caters

    to customers who print extensively and un-

    derstand that ink cartridge purchases can add

    up to cost serious money. As a result o this

    novel approach, inkjet printers have become

    one o Kodaks principal growth drivers.

    Finding and using analogies across indus-

    triesto apply the business model o one

    industry to anothercan reveal exciting newopportunities. Analogies are a antastic way

    to think beyond orthodoxies in one industry

    by imagining how borrowing rom other

    industries can turn a companys model on its

    head. Consider the GE Aviation jet engine

    business model, in which the company has an-

    alyzed real-world airline engine maintenance

    data and priced its leasing and service oering

    to be more cost eective than customers own-

    ing their engines. This is a model increasinglyollowed by competitors and quite a dierent

    approach rom the traditional one o product-

    ollowed-by-parts-and-service. This predictive

    analytics modelwell known among retail-

    ers who mine consumer data to anticipate

    uture spending behaviorscould very well

    have applicability in many other industries.

    TACTIC DEFINITION EXAMPLE

    Microtransac-tions

    Sell many items that cost close to a dollar or as low asone cent to create acceptable impulse purchases.

    KARTRIDER, on online multiplayer racing game, offeredplayers virtual items in-game, including different types ofvehicles and spray paint that added new functionality fornominal fees.

    Financing Capture revenue not directly from the sale of aproduct, but from structured payment plans and after-sale interest.

    GMAC provided profitable automotive leasing andfinancing options to give customers the ability to lease orown a General Motors vehicle.

    Switchboard Connect multiple sellers with multiple buyers; themore buyers and sellers who join, the more valuablethe switchboard.

    eBay collected fees for posting items and took apercentage of every item sold; in return it offered sellerscentralized access to millions of buyers and collectors.

    Membership Charge a time-based payment to permit access to

    locations, offerings, or services that non-membersdont have.

    SAMS CLUB collected an annual membership fee to

    provide members access to wholesale prices and bulkdeals that could not be matched in traditional retail.

    PredictiveAnalytics

    Model past performance data to predict futureoutcomes and price offerings accordingly.

    GE AVIATION analyzed real-world airline enginemaintenance data and precisely priced its leasing andservice offering to be more cost-effective for airlines thanowning their engines.

    Metered Use Allow customers to pay for only what they use. BETTER PLACE, an electric car charging system,developed a model that sells mobility miles to driverson a pay-as-you-go basis.

    All company examples are used for illustrative purposes only.

  • 7/31/2019 Monitor Business Model Innovation 22 Nov

    10/12

    10 BEACONS FOR BUSINESS MODEL INNOVATION

    MONITOR

    PERSPECTIVES

    Taking Action

    The best way to start tapping into the enor-

    mous value oered by Business Model In-

    novation is to take a look at what you have in

    your portolio already. Using the Ten Types

    o Innovation and EVE models as pattern

    recognition tools, carve out the ew initia-

    tives which appear to have the characteristics

    o uture winners. I there is nothing there,

    then ocus your team on creating unique,

    unimagined customer experiences with

    revenue models that break your industrys

    conventional wisdom. Lest you get dragged

    down the route o incrementalism, start by

    looking or inspiration outsideseek insights,

    perspectives on your industry orthodoxies,

    and understanding o where the real value

    lies or your customer base, as well as or

    those who are not your customers yet. It

    is most important to ocus on the demand

    side o this work and then wend backwards

    through the capability, asset, and cost im-

    plications. As with most breakthrough in-

    novation, think about back-o-the-envelope

    cost calculations, not detailed economic

    models, and always look or opportunities

    to take out pieces o the cost structure as you

    explore new user and revenue possibilities.

    Many companies have a well-dened process

    or creating new products, but very ew have

    articulated a means or shaping new busi-

    ness models. Without a deliberate approach

    to the task, companies run several risks: the

    subtle re-direction o new business model

    eorts to look more like the core business,

    resistance by business unctions impacted by

    THE CHALLENGE OF

    CONTINUOUS REINVENTION

    Even successful business model innovators have

    trouble sustaining their innovations over time.

    Examining the shareholder return for three hugely

    successful Business Model innovators (Dell, Home

    Depot and Southwest) highlights how even com-

    panies with Innovation DNA can get complacent,

    wedded to tradition, and stymied when trying to

    create a second breakthrough.

    Dell

    Home Depot

    Soutwest Airlines

    200

    150

    100

    50

    0

    200

    150

    100

    50

    0

    200

    150

    100

    50

    0

    0 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 1 0 1 1 1 2 1 3 1 4 1 5 1 6 1 7 1 8 1 9 2 0 2 1 2 2 2 3 2 4 2 5 2 6 2 7 2 8 2 9 3 0 3 1

    Cumulative

    IndexedTSR

    Years Since IPO

    Note: TSR = (closing price opening price + dividends) / opening price; prices are

    adjusted for stock splits and special events

    Source: Yahoo Finance

    Indexed Cumulative Total Shareholder Return

  • 7/31/2019 Monitor Business Model Innovation 22 Nov

    11/12

    BEACONS FOR BUSINESS MODEL INNOVATION 11

    the new model, an inability to rapidly iterate,

    and an overload o organizational change.

    Circumventing these barriers requires care-

    ul attention to process rom the beginning.

    A cross-unctional governing team o senior

    executives should establish a clear strategic

    mandate and set realistic success metrics.

    Then these executives should ollow a model

    set by venture capitalists or how they interact

    with project leaders. Venture capitalists use

    requent board meetings o their portoliocompanies to ocus on solving problems, not

    reviewing presentations. They expect rms

    to discover many unknowns, and early on

    they measure progress in terms o risk mitiga-

    tion rather than rapid revenue growth. They

    prize fexibility. Moreover, they concentrate

    companies on just a small handul o issues

    at a time, which minimizes the downside o

    ast change while maximizing the impact

    o lessons learned rom the marketplace.

    Reasons abound or employees to resist al-

    tering the way the company operates. But

    with the right amount o rabid pull rom

    deep customer insight, supported by illustra-

    tive analogies and deliberate process, every

    company can take advantage o this source

    o competitive advantage. This is not a drill.

    Most companies ace competitive threatsrom upstarts or aster-moving competitors.

    The time or Business Model Innovation is

    now, beore one o them orces your hand or

    steals the customers you thought you had.

    THREE BUSINESS MODELS TO WATCH

    SkypeforBusiness Leveraging the Freemium business model, Skype provides users with free voice and

    video calls made within its network. For businesses whose employees frequently Skype, the company has begun

    to sell premium services that integrate Skype into the central PBX phone system, allow easy distribution of credit

    to individual accounts for calls made to non-Skype phones, and facilitate both instant messaging and file sharing.

    VirginHealthMiles Challenging the Pay for Performance business model orthodoxy, Richard Bransons Virgin

    Group has created a model it calls Pay for Prevention. Virgin HealthMiles backs corporate wellness programs

    through engaging employees in measurable activities such as pedometer wearing and biometric monitoring. The

    firms pay some participants reward points based on how effectively they are meeting fitness goals.

    AmazonWebServices Pity the poor businesses that fork out big money for computing power, bandwidth and

    other infrastructure which they then under-use. Amazon is using its vast IT resources to provide companies with

    Metered Use cloud-based technology such as servers, storage and database services.

  • 7/31/2019 Monitor Business Model Innovation 22 Nov

    12/12

    MONITOR

    PERSPECTIVES

    About

    MONITOR GROUP

    Monitor works with the worlds leading corporations, governments and

    social sector organizations to drive growth in ways that are most important

    to them. Monitor Group offers a range of servicesadvisory, capability-

    building and capital servicesdesigned to unlock the challenges of

    achieving sustained growth.

    Monitors innovation practice brings together an entrepreneurial, global

    team with exper tise in a broad spectrum of disciplines. It includes in-

    novation specialists at Doblin as well as a proprietary network of external

    technology and industry exper ts that suppor ts our clients around the globe.

    About Geoff Tuff Geoff Tuff is a Senior Partner at Monitor and a leader of the firms Innovationand Sustainability practices. He has been at the firm since the early 1990s.

    Geoff has worked in a wide range of industries including pharmaceuticals,

    medical devices, consumer products, beverages, information services,

    financial services, telecommunications, metals, and both commodity and

    specialty chemicals. His work is focused entirely on helping companies

    grow organically through innovation and commercial excellence. Throughout

    his career, he has been instrumental in developing some of Monitors core

    methodologies related to driving top-line growth for clients, and he is cur-

    rently an account manager for several of the firms leading clients. His writing

    frequently appears in the Monitor Perspectives series and has been published

    in journals such asMarketing Management. Geoff received his B.A. with

    honors from Dartmouth College, and also holds an MBA from Harvard Busi-

    ness School. He is based in the firms office in Cambridge, Massachusetts,

    and can be reached via e-mail at [email protected].

    C i ht 2009 2010 M it C G Li it d P t hi All i ht d

    About Stephen Wunker Stephen Wunker is Managing Director of New Markets Advisors. As aspecialist in building innovation capabilities and creating new markets, he

    has focused on the healthcare, financial services, and telecom industries. He

    has published articles on innovation in a wide array of industry and general

    business publications, includingForbes andBusinessWeek. Steve has four

    patent filings for business model innovations. In addition to his consultingcareer, he has been a successful entrepreneur and corporate venturer in

    both developed and emerging markets. Steve received his B.A. with honors

    from Princeton University, a Masters in Public Administration from Columbia

    University, and an MBA from Harvard Business School. He can be reached

    via e-mail at [email protected].

    The authors wish to acknowledge the contributions of

    David Shear in the preparation of this article.