Monetize the Domestic Work Done by a House-moth

8/9/2019 Monetize the Domestic Work Done by a House-moth

1/14Page 1

1

REPORTABLE

IN THE SUPREME COURT OF INDIACIVIL APPELLATE JURISDICTION

CIVIL APPEAL NO.1415 OF 2015(Arising !" # SLP (Ci$i%& N.4'')2014&

JITENDRA *HIMSHAN*AR TRIVEDI + ORS. ..A,,-%%n"s

V-rs!s

*ASAM DAUD *UM/HAR + ORS. ..R-s,n-n"s

J U D M E N T

R. BANUMATHI, J.

D-% 3nn-. L-$- grn"-.

2. /-ing iss"is#i- i" "- 6!n"!7 # 37,-ns"in

r- 8 "- Hig C!r" # !9r" in Firs" A,,-% N. 4021

# 1'': "- 1.1.2012; "- 3%i7n"s $- #i%- "is ,,-%

s--? On 21.'.1''0 r-s,n-n" N.1 i%-

ri$ing "-7, 8-ring r-gis"r"in N. @?4B01 in rs n


2/14Page 2

2

n-g%ig-n" 7nn-r %s" "- 3n"r% $-r i" n i" S7".

J$n"i8-n Ji"-nr Tri$-i (-3-s-& s!8s-6!-n"%

s!33!78- " in9!ri-s. A,,-%%n" N.1 is "- !s8n #

-3-s- n ,,-%%n" Ns. 2 " 5 r- !s8ns sis"-rs;

!g"-r n #"-r?in?% r-s,-3"i$-% # "- -3-s-

J$n"i8-n. C%i7n"s #i%- 3%i7 ,-"i"in 8-#r- "- M"r

A33i-n"s C%i7s Tri8!n%; /!9?*33; !9r"; interalia,

3%i7ing 37,-ns"in !n-r i##-r-n" -s " "- "!n- #

Rs.2;';4:0)? %ng i" in"-r-s" " "- r"- # 1: ,-r 3-n" ,-r

nn!7. T- ,,-%%n"s $-rr- in "- 3%i7 ,-"i"in "" "-

-3-s- s !s-i#- " "- "i7- # 33i-n" n s

g- 22 -rs n "" s- s ing -78ri-r n


3/14Page 3

=

n-g%ig-n" ri$ing # r-s,n-n" N.1. /s- n "- r%

"-s"i7n # i"n-ss-s; "ri8!n% 37- " "- 3n3%!sin ""

-3-s- s -rning Rs.'00)? ,-r 7n". R-%ing !,n "-

-3isin in General Manager, Kerala S.R.T.C. $s. Susamma

Thomas + Ors.1; "- "ri8!n% ss-ss- "- in37- # "-

-3-s- " Rs.1;500)? ,-r 7n". A#"-r -!3"ing 1)=r #r

,-rsn% -,-ns-s n #"-r ,"ing 7!%"i,%i-r # 1:; "ri8!n%

s 3%3!%"- "- %ss # -,-n-n3 " Rs.2;1;000)?. Aing

3n$-n"in% 7g-s Rs.:;000)?; $i- r "- =0.4.1'':;

"- "ri8!n% r- ""% 37,-ns"in # Rs.2;24;000)? i"

in"-r-s" " "- r"- # 15 ,-r 3-n" ,-r nn!7.

5. /-ing ggri-$- 8 "- r # "- "ri8!n%;

r-s,n-n"s #i%- ,,-% 8-ing Firs" A,,-% N.4021)1'':

!n-r S-3"in 1B1 # "- M"r V-i3%-s A3" 1':: 8-#r- "-

Hig C!r" # !9r" " A7-8. Vi- i7,!gn- 9!g7-n"

"- 1.1.2012; "- Hig C!r" ,r"% %%- "- ,,-%

"


4/14Page 4

4

"- "- # #i%ing # "- 3%i7 ,-"i"in "i%% "- "- # r-%i"in.

. L-rn- 3!ns-% #r "- 3%i7n"s s!87i""- "" "-

n-r s n-i"-r #i%- ri""-n s""-7-n" nr 3n"-s"- "-

3%i7 ,-"i"in 8-#r- "- "ri8!n% n i%- s "- ins!rn3-

37,n 3nn" 3%%-ng- "- r n 7-ri"s. I" s #!r"-r

s!87i""- "" "- Hig C!r" i n"


5/14Page 5

5

$ri8-n *i7sn


6/14Page 6

7n" is -%% 7-ri"-. I" is " 8- ,in"- !" "" "-

r-s,n-n"s $- n" !3- n -$i-n3- " ,r$- "" "-

-3-s- s n" ing n -78ri-r r "i%ring r< r "-

%i


7/14Page 7

B

s-r$i3-s # "- 7"-r)i#- is $i%8%- 24 !rs n -r !"i-s

r- n-$-r #i-. C!r"s $- r-3gni- "- 3n"ri8!"in 7-

8 "- i#- " "- !s- is in$%!8%- n "" i" 3nn" 8-

37,!"- in "-r7s # 7n-. A !s-?i#-)7-?7


8/14Page 8

:

H!s-% r< ,-r#r7- 8 7-n "r!g!" Iniis 7r- "n US 12.: 8i%%in ,-r -r ($%angelicalSocial Action orum an! 'ealth (ri!ge; ,. 1B&. G- #"-n

#rg-" "" "- "i7- s,-n" 8 7-n in ing!s-% r< s 7-7


9/14Page 9

'

$s. )nite! In!ia Insurance Company t!.*. As gins" "-

r ,ss- 8 "- "ri8!n% -$-n "!g "- 3%i7n"s $-

n" #i%- n ,,-%; s i" is 8%ig"r n "- ,r" #

3!r"s)"ri8!n%s " r 9!s" n r-sn8%- 37,-ns"in; i"

is ,,r,ri"- " in3r-s- "- 37,-ns"in.

14. In r-r " r 9!s" n r-sn8%- 37,-ns"in

in37- # "- -3-s- is "


10/14Page 10

10

$s. Ra+ir Singh + "rs.-, n i+u Kuru%ila & "rs. $s. Kun+u+amma

Mohan & "rs./; "is C!r" s r- s!8s"n"i% 7!n" #

Rs.1;00;000)? "rs %ss # 3nsr"i!7 n Rs.1;00;000)?

"rs %ss # %$- n ##-3"in. F%%ing "- s7-; in "-

3s- in n; Rs.1;00;000)? is r- "rs %ss #

3nsr"i!7 n Rs.1;00;000)? "rs %ss # %$- n

##-3"in " "- 7inr 3i%r-n. Trs %ss # -s""- n

#!n-r% -,-ns-s; r # 37,-ns"in # Rs.15;000)?

r- 8 "- Hig C!r" is 7in"in-. T!s; "- 3%i7n"s

r- -n"i"%- " ""% 37,-ns"in # Rs.;4B;000)?.

15. As gins" "- r ,ss- 8 "- "ri8!n% -$-n

"!g "- 3%i7n"s $- n" ,r-#-rr- n ,,-% n -$-n

"!g "- 3%i7n"s $- "-n ,r- #r 37,-ns"in #

Rs.2;';4:0)?; #r ing 37,%-"- 9!s"i3- " "- ,r"i-s;

--r3ising 9!risi3"in !n-r Ar"i3%- 142 # "- Cns"i"!"in #

Ini; - --7 i" ,,r,ri"- " r -nn3- 37,-ns"in

# Rs. ;4B;000) " "- 3%i7n"s.

1. In si"!"in # "is n"!r-; #r ing 37,%-"- 9!s"i3-

" "- ,r"i-s; "is C!r" s %s --r3is- "- 9!risi3"in

!n-r Ar"i3%- 142 # "- Cns"i"!"in # Ini. In "riental

6 (2013) 9 SCC 54

7 (2013) 9 SCC 166


11/14Page 11

11

Insurance Company imite! $s. (ri+ Mohan an! "rs.,0 "is C!r"

-% s !n-r>?

1=.H-$-r; R-s,n-n" 1 is ,r %8!r-r. H- s!##-r- gri-$!s in9!ri-s. H- 8-37- is8%- " gr-" -"-n". T- 7!n" # 37,-ns"in r- inis #$!r ,,-rs " 8- n %-r si-. In "-#r-7-n"in- si"!"in; %"!g - r-9-3" "- "-r3n"-n"ins # Ms In! M%"r; - r- in3%in- "--r3is- !r -"rrinr 9!risi3"in !n-r Ar"i3%- 142# "- Cns"i"!"in # Ini s s " ir-3" "" "- r7 8- s"is#i- 8 "- ,,-%%n" 8!" i" !% 8-

-n"i"%- " r-%is- "- s7- #r7 "- n-r # "-"r3"r n "- "r%%- -r-#r i" !% n" 8-n-3-ssr #r i" " ini"i"- n s-,r"- ,r3--ings #rr-3$-r # "- 7!n" s ,r$i- #r !n-r "- M"rV-i3%-s A3".

14. I" is -%% s-""%- "" in si"!"in # "is n"!r- "isC!r" in --r3is- # i"s 9!risi3"in !n-r Ar"i3%- 142 #"- Cns"i"!"in # Ini r- i" Ar"i3%- 1= "-r-#3n iss!- s!i" ir-3"ins #r ing 37,%-"- 9!s"i3- "

"- ,r"i-s.

In 1e!!appa & "rs. $s. (ranch Manager, National Insurance

Company imite!,2 i" s 8s-r$- s !n-r>?

2. H-$-r; s "- ,,-%%n" i%s #r7 "- %-s"s"r" # s3i-"; - r- # "- ,inin "" in 3s- #"is n"!r-; - s!%; in --r3is- # !r -"rrinr 9!risi3"in !n-r Ar"i3%- 142 # "- Cns"i"!"in # Ini;

ir-3" R-s,n-n" 1 " , "- 7!n" # 3%i7 " "-,,-%%n"s -r-in n r-3$-r "- s7- #r7 "- n-r# "- $-i3%- $i. R-s,n-n" 2; ,r"i3!%r% in $i- #"- #3" "" n ,,-% s ,r-#-rr- 8 i7. G- ir-3"33ring%.

1B. T- n-" 6!-s"in #%%ing #r !r 3nsi-r"in is "-

r"- # in"-r-s" " 8- r-. T- "ri8!n% s r-

8 (2007) 7 SCC 56

9 (2008) 2 SCC 595


12/14Page 12

12

in"-r-s" " "- r"- # 15 ,-r 3-n" i3 s r-!3- " 12 ,-r

3-n" 8 "- Hig C!r". T- r"- # in"-r-s" r- 8 8"

"- 3!r"s is n ig-r si-. In Amresh Kumari $s. Niran+an al

ag!ish 3rasa! ain & "rs.45 n Mohin!er Kaur + Ors. $s. 'ira

Nan! Sin!hi 6Ghoriwala7 an! Anr.44; "is C!r" s r- "-

37,-ns"in 7!n" ,8%- " "- 3%i7n"s i" in"-r-s" "

"- r"- # ' ,-r 3-n".

1:. T- 37,-ns"in r-!3- 8 "- Hig C!r" #r7

Rs.2;24;000)? " Rs.2;0';400)? is -nn3- " Rs.;4B;000)?. T-

6!n"!7 # 37,-ns"in 3%i7- is Rs.2;';4:0)? i.-. ,8%-

i" in"-r-s" " "- r"- # ' ,-r 3-n" #r7 "- "- # "- #i%ing

# "- 3%i7 ,-"i"in "i%% "- "- # ,7-n". S #r s "-

-nn3- 37,-ns"in # Rs.=;50;520)? is ,8%- i"

in"-r-s" " "- r"- # ' ,-r 3-n" #r7 "- "- # #i%ing # "-

s,-3i% %-$- ,-"i"in "i%% "- "- # r-%i"in. T- -nn3-

37,-ns"in # Rs.=;50;520)? %ngi" 33r!- in"-r-s" s%%

8- -6!%% i$i- 8-"--n "- ,,-%%n"s N.1 n 4 Ji"-nr

*i7sn


13/14Page 13

1=

*i7sn


14/14

14

ITEM NO.1B-For Judgment COURT NO.12 SECTION IX

S U P R E M E C O U R T O F I N D I A RECORD OF PROCEEDINS

C!"!# A$$e%# No&'(........)2*1+ %r!'!ng ,rom SP&C(No./0/)2*1

JITENDRA IMSANAR TRI3EDI 4 ORS. A$$e##%nt&'(

3ERSUS

ASAM DAUD UMBAR 4 ORS. Re'$ondent&'(

D%te 5 *6)*2)2*1+ T7!' $et!t!on 8%' 9%##ed on ,or $ronoun9ement o, JUDMENT tod%:.

For A$$e##%nt&'( Mr. A;7!;#e Mr'. Ju't!9e R. B%num%t7! $ronoun9ed t7e

;#e Mr'. Ju't!9e R. B%num%t7!.

e%"e gr%nted.

T7e %$$e%# !' $%rt#: %##o8ed !n term' o, t7e '!gned

Re$ort%;#e

Monetize the Domestic Work Done by a House-moth

Documents

Transcript of Monetize the Domestic Work Done by a House-moth