MODEL-DERIVED CHEMICAL-LOOPING SYSTEM …...heat + mass transfer in gas Heat transfer between packed...

37
04/04/2014 IASE Seminar Series 1/37 Department of Chemical & Biomolecular Engineering University of Connecticut http://pdsol.engr.uconn.edu MODEL-DERIVED CHEMICAL-LOOPING SYSTEM DESIGNS George M. Bollas

Transcript of MODEL-DERIVED CHEMICAL-LOOPING SYSTEM …...heat + mass transfer in gas Heat transfer between packed...

Page 1: MODEL-DERIVED CHEMICAL-LOOPING SYSTEM …...heat + mass transfer in gas Heat transfer between packed bed and wall Axial dispersion of heat and mass External diffusion across film Reactions

04/04/2014

IASE Seminar Series 1/37

Department of Chemical & Biomolecular Engineering University of Connecticut

http://pdsol.engr.uconn.edu

MODEL-DERIVED CHEMICAL-LOOPING SYSTEM DESIGNS

George M. Bollas

Page 2: MODEL-DERIVED CHEMICAL-LOOPING SYSTEM …...heat + mass transfer in gas Heat transfer between packed bed and wall Axial dispersion of heat and mass External diffusion across film Reactions

04/04/2014

IASE Seminar Series 2/37

Diploma in Chemical Engineering Aristotle University of Thessaloniki – Greece

Ph.D. in Chemical Engineering Aristotle University of Thessaloniki – Greece

Postdoc in Chemical Engineering Massachusetts Institute of Technology – USA

Assistant Professor University of Connecticut NSF CAREER Award 2011 ACS-PRF DNI Award 2013 >$2M in research grants in 2010-2013 9 graduate researchers 10 undergraduate researchers

About

Page 3: MODEL-DERIVED CHEMICAL-LOOPING SYSTEM …...heat + mass transfer in gas Heat transfer between packed bed and wall Axial dispersion of heat and mass External diffusion across film Reactions

04/04/2014

IASE Seminar Series 3/37

Research Group (PDSOL)

Catalysis for renewable fuels

Novel spouted-bed reactor for biomass thermochemical processes (pyrolysis, gasification, chemical-looping combustion)

Comprehensive catalyst characterization and catalyst activity dynamic simulation

FTIR real time analyzer

T

T

T

T

T T

T

Liquid & Gas Analysis

Char & Catalyst Collection

N2

N2

vent

vent

vent

Liquid Collection

Gas Collection

Gas Analysis

Coolant

Reactor

Filter

Flow Meter

AugerFeeder

½

¢µ

µ

z

Annulus:@Ca

@t= D@2Ca

@½2 ¡ uij@Ca

@½+ 2D

½@Ca

½

Spout:@Cs

@t+ @Cs

@z

¡us + 1

2dus

¢= 0

Process Design, Scale-up & Control

Dynamic simulation & optimization Optimal experimental design

Model-assisted scale-up based on dynamic sensitivity analysis

Chemical-looping combustion & reforming

Spouted-bed reactor for biomass pyrolysis

Catalyst characterization (ZSM-5 after pyrolysis)

Fixed-bed reactor developed and simulated in PDSOL. Application of Optimal Experimental Design on the laboratory reactor. Scale-up based on sensitivity analysis of the bench-scale reactor.

Dynamic simulation of a spouted bed

Enabling emerging energy technologies via integration of modeling with experimentation of processes lacking fundamental understanding

Page 4: MODEL-DERIVED CHEMICAL-LOOPING SYSTEM …...heat + mass transfer in gas Heat transfer between packed bed and wall Axial dispersion of heat and mass External diffusion across film Reactions

04/04/2014

IASE Seminar Series 4/37

Carbon capture needs to be deployed to effectively lower the global CO2 portfolio

Climate change urgency

Fig.1: University of Maine Environmental Change Model (UM-ECM) potential

biomes calculated for modern climate. From left to right: input cooled by 4°C; todays

input; input warmed by 2.5°C. Note the effect on the arctic sea ice. Data/images

obtained using Climate Reanalyzer™ (http://cci-reanalyzer.org), Climate Change

Institute, University of Maine, USA.

Page 5: MODEL-DERIVED CHEMICAL-LOOPING SYSTEM …...heat + mass transfer in gas Heat transfer between packed bed and wall Axial dispersion of heat and mass External diffusion across film Reactions

04/04/2014

IASE Seminar Series 5/37

Estimated total storage capacity of over 100 Gt in the continental US

US-wide CO2 storage capacity

Page 6: MODEL-DERIVED CHEMICAL-LOOPING SYSTEM …...heat + mass transfer in gas Heat transfer between packed bed and wall Axial dispersion of heat and mass External diffusion across film Reactions

04/04/2014

IASE Seminar Series 6/37

Back in 2008 Resource: America’s Energy Future Technology And Transformation, Committee On America’s Energy Future, National Academy Of Sciences, National Academy of Engineering, National Research Council of The National Academies, The National Academies Press

CO2 Capture Options

Page 7: MODEL-DERIVED CHEMICAL-LOOPING SYSTEM …...heat + mass transfer in gas Heat transfer between packed bed and wall Axial dispersion of heat and mass External diffusion across film Reactions

04/04/2014

IASE Seminar Series 7/37

Boot-Handford ME, Abanades JC, Anthony EJ, Blunt MJ, Brandani S, Mac Dowell N, et al. Carbon capture and storage update. Energy Environ Sci 2014.

Chemical-looping progress

Page 8: MODEL-DERIVED CHEMICAL-LOOPING SYSTEM …...heat + mass transfer in gas Heat transfer between packed bed and wall Axial dispersion of heat and mass External diffusion across film Reactions

04/04/2014

IASE Seminar Series 8/37

A method for inherent CO2 separation Oxygen carriers M : metal

MO : metal oxide

Reduction: endothermic CH4 + 4MO CO2 + 2H2O + 4M

Oxidation: exothermic M + ½ O2 MO

Circulating oxygen carrier: active metal oxides (Ni, Cu, Fe, Mn) supported over Al2O3, MgAl2O4, NiAl2O4, YSZ, TiO2, ZrO2. Reactivity testing: TGA, fixed-bed, interconnected fluidized-beds.

Chemical-looping combustion (CLC)

Reducer Oxidizer

CO2 H2O

Fuel

N2 O2

Air

MO

M

water

steam

Page 9: MODEL-DERIVED CHEMICAL-LOOPING SYSTEM …...heat + mass transfer in gas Heat transfer between packed bed and wall Axial dispersion of heat and mass External diffusion across film Reactions

04/04/2014

IASE Seminar Series 9/37

[1] Zhou Z, Han L, Bollas GM. Model-based analysis of bench-scale fixed-bed units for chemical-looping combustion. Chem Eng J 2013;233:331–48. [2] Han L, Zhou Z, Bollas GM. Heterogeneous Modeling of Chemical-Looping Combustion. Part 1: Reactor Model. Chem Eng Sci 2013;104:233 – 249. [3] Han L, Zhou Z, Bollas GM. Heterogeneous Modeling of Chemical-Looping Combustion. Part 2: Particle Model. Chem Eng Sci 2014;in press. [4] Zhou Z. Han L, Bollas GM. Overview of Chemical-Looping Reduction in Fixed Bed and Fluidized Bed Reactors Focused on Oxygen Carrier Utilization and Reactor Efficiency. Aerosol Air Qual Res 2014;14:559–71. [5] Zhou Z, Han L, Bollas GM. Kinetics of NiO reduction by H2 and Ni oxidation at conditions relevant to chemical-looping combustion and reforming. Int J Hydrogen Energy 2014;in press. [6] Han L, Zhou Z, Bollas GM. Chemical-looping combustion in a reverse-flow fixed-bed reactor. Appl Energy 2014;in review. [7] Zhou Z, Han L, Bollas GM. Model-assisted analysis of fluidized bed chemical-looping reactors. AIChE J 2014;in review. [8] Han L, Zhou Z, Bollas GM. Optimal Experimental Design for Fixed Bed Chemical-Looping Experiments. Comput Chem Eng 2014;in preparation.

Our work

Page 10: MODEL-DERIVED CHEMICAL-LOOPING SYSTEM …...heat + mass transfer in gas Heat transfer between packed bed and wall Axial dispersion of heat and mass External diffusion across film Reactions

04/04/2014

IASE Seminar Series 10/37

OED for process scaling of chemical-looping: Measurements of bench- and pilot- scale processes are used to develop state/space models. These models are subsequently used to identify time-varying experimental conditions that maximize the statistical significance of the measurements with respect to process scale, subject to constraints.

The “dream concept”

maximize information content of experiments integrate experimentation with reactor design obtain scale-independent process models estimate model parameters that increase the accuracy of process scale-up/scale-down reduce risk of technology scale-up/scale-down.

Page 11: MODEL-DERIVED CHEMICAL-LOOPING SYSTEM …...heat + mass transfer in gas Heat transfer between packed bed and wall Axial dispersion of heat and mass External diffusion across film Reactions

04/04/2014

IASE Seminar Series 11/37

Heterogeneous model Fluid phase

𝜀𝑏𝜕𝐶𝑖𝜕𝑡

+𝜕𝐹𝑖𝜕𝑉

=𝜕

𝜕𝑧𝜀𝑏𝐷𝑎𝑥,𝑖

𝜕𝐶𝑖𝜕𝑧

+ 𝑘𝑐,𝑖𝑎𝑣 𝐶𝑐,𝑖|𝑅𝑝 − 𝐶𝑖

𝜀𝑏𝐶𝑝𝑓𝐶𝑇𝜕𝑇

𝜕𝑡+ 𝐶𝑝𝑓𝐹𝑇

𝜕𝑇

𝜕𝑉 =

𝜕

𝜕𝑧𝜀𝑏𝜆𝑎𝑥

𝜕𝑇

𝜕𝑧

+ℎ𝑓𝑎𝑣 𝑇𝑐|𝑅𝑝 − 𝑇 +4𝑈

𝐷𝑅(𝑇𝑤 − 𝑇)

Solid phase

𝜀𝑐𝜕𝐶𝑐,𝑖𝜕𝑡

=1

𝑟𝒄2

𝜕

𝜕𝑟𝑐𝐷𝑒,𝑖 𝑟𝑐

2𝜕𝐶𝑐,𝑖𝜕𝑟𝑐

+ 𝜌𝑠 𝑅𝑖

1 − 𝜀𝑐 𝜌𝑠𝐶𝑝𝑠 + 𝜀𝑐𝐶𝑝𝑐𝐶𝑇,𝑐𝜕𝑇𝑐𝜕𝑡

=

𝜆𝑠𝑟𝑐2

𝜕

𝜕𝑟𝑟𝑐2𝜕𝑇𝑐𝜕𝑟𝑐

+ 𝜌𝑠 (−𝛥𝐻𝑖)(𝑅𝑖)

Pressure drop 𝑑𝑃

𝑑𝑧= −

1 − 𝜀𝑏𝜀𝑏

3

𝜌𝑢02

𝐷𝑝

150

𝑅𝑒𝑝+ 1.75

Fixed-bed model description

Fu

rna

ce

wa

ll

Tube wall

Oxygen carrier

particles

Axial convective

heat + mass

transfer in gas

Heat transfer between

packed bed and wall

Axial dispersion of

heat and mass

External diffusion

across film

Reactions on

pore surface

Pore diffusion

Bulk

fluid

Solid

phase

Heat conduction

Heat conduction

through packed-bed

Han, L.; Zhou, Z.; Bollas, G. M. Heterogeneous Modeling of Chemical-Looping Combustion. Part 1: Reactor Model. Chemical Engineering

Science 2013

Page 12: MODEL-DERIVED CHEMICAL-LOOPING SYSTEM …...heat + mass transfer in gas Heat transfer between packed bed and wall Axial dispersion of heat and mass External diffusion across film Reactions

04/04/2014

IASE Seminar Series 12/37

Application to experimental data of CLC by Iliuta et al. (2010), Ryden et al. (2008) and CLR data by Jin (2002)

Fixed-bed model application

Han, L.; Zhou, Z.; Bollas, G. M. Heterogeneous Modeling of Chemical-Looping

Combustion. Part 1: Reactor Model. Chemical Engineering Science 2013

Page 13: MODEL-DERIVED CHEMICAL-LOOPING SYSTEM …...heat + mass transfer in gas Heat transfer between packed bed and wall Axial dispersion of heat and mass External diffusion across film Reactions

04/04/2014

IASE Seminar Series 13/37

Reduction reactions with NiO

Oxygen carrier

reduction

reactions

CH4 oxidation CH4 + 2NiO ↔ 2Ni + CO2 + 2H2 ΔH°= 165 kJ/mol

H2 oxidation H2 + NiO ↔ Ni + H2O ΔH°= -2.2 kJ/mol

CO oxidation CO + NiO ↔ Ni + CO2 ΔH°= -43.3 kJ/mol

Partial CH4 oxidation CH4 + NiO ↔ Ni + 2H2+CO ΔH°= 203 kJ/mol

Reactions

catalyzed by Ni

Steam reforming CH4 + H2O ↔ 3H2 + CO ΔH°= 205 kJ/mol

Water gas shift CO + H2O ↔ H2 + CO2 ΔH°= -41.1 kJ/mol

Dry reforming CH4 + CO2 ↔ 2CO + 2H2 ΔH°= 247 kJ/mol

Methane

decomposition

CH4 ↔ 2H2 + C ΔH°= 88 kJ/mol

Carbon gasification by

steam

C + H2O ↔ CO + H2 ΔH°= 131 kJ/mol

Carbon gasification by

CO2

C + CO2 ↔ 2CO ΔH°= 173 kJ/mol

Zhou, Z.; Han, L.; Bollas, G. M. Model-based Analysis of Bench-Scale Fixed-Bed Units for Chemical-Looping Combustion. Chemical

Engineering Journal 2013

Page 14: MODEL-DERIVED CHEMICAL-LOOPING SYSTEM …...heat + mass transfer in gas Heat transfer between packed bed and wall Axial dispersion of heat and mass External diffusion across film Reactions

04/04/2014

IASE Seminar Series 14/37

Mass balance

Intraparticle velocity (forced convection)

Boundary Conditions

Mass Balance around the crucible

Boundary Conditions

TGA Model

, 2 2

, eff, ,2 2

1 1 

c i

c c c i c i c i s

c c c c

j

c

c

Cr C r D C

t r r r r rv R

1

,

1

j

j

c

i

c

c i

R

r

v

C

eff, ,

, c, ,( )cc p c p

c p

p

i c i

c c i i c i ir r r rr rc

r r

D Cv C k C C

r

0

,

0

0c

c

r

r

c i

c

c

Cv

r

,   c,   ,( ) 

c pv r r

i ib b ax i i c i ia

C CD k C C

t z z

,

,  

0

0( )TGA

iz

m iib ax i i

zz

CDC

D C

0i

z h

C

z

Han, L.; Zhou, Z.; Bollas, G. M. Heterogeneous Modeling of Chemical-Looping

Combustion. Part 2: Particle Model. Chemical Engineering Science 2013

Page 15: MODEL-DERIVED CHEMICAL-LOOPING SYSTEM …...heat + mass transfer in gas Heat transfer between packed bed and wall Axial dispersion of heat and mass External diffusion across film Reactions

04/04/2014

IASE Seminar Series 15/37

Analysis of available literature on reduction of supported and unsupported NiO by H2

Models of varying degree of fidelity (number of parameters) F-test Akaike Information Criterion

Non-catalytic gas-solid reactions

Zhou, Z.; Han, L.; Bollas, G. M. Kinetics of NiO reduction by H2 and Ni oxidation at conditions relevant to chemical-looping

combustion and reforming. Int. Journal of Hydrogen Energy, 2014

Page 16: MODEL-DERIVED CHEMICAL-LOOPING SYSTEM …...heat + mass transfer in gas Heat transfer between packed bed and wall Axial dispersion of heat and mass External diffusion across film Reactions

04/04/2014

IASE Seminar Series 16/37

Fixed-bed apparatus NiO/Al2O3 oxygen carrier preparation

Dry impregnation with loading of 20 wt% Ni Particle size: 50-150 μm Surface area: 90 m2/g

Current experimental setup

Experimental conditions

Reduction temperature

800°C

Reduction time 1 min

Reducing gas flow 20 CH4 + 80 Ar ml/min

Solid loading 2 g

Purge time 3 min

Oxidizing gas 100 air ml/min

Oxidation time 3 min

Tube ID 0.99 cm

Tube length 30 cm

Ar

Air

CH4

Filter

Mass

selective

detectorVent

Reactor

Oxygen

Carrier

F

MFC3

F

MFC2

F

MFC1

T1

T2

Vent

Pressure

Regulator

Furnace

Page 17: MODEL-DERIVED CHEMICAL-LOOPING SYSTEM …...heat + mass transfer in gas Heat transfer between packed bed and wall Axial dispersion of heat and mass External diffusion across film Reactions

04/04/2014

IASE Seminar Series 17/37

Page 18: MODEL-DERIVED CHEMICAL-LOOPING SYSTEM …...heat + mass transfer in gas Heat transfer between packed bed and wall Axial dispersion of heat and mass External diffusion across film Reactions

04/04/2014

IASE Seminar Series 18/37

Model, system of DAE’s 𝐟 𝐱 𝑡 , 𝐱 𝑡 , 𝐮 𝑡 ,𝐰 , 𝛉, 𝑡 = 0 𝐲 𝑡 = 𝐡(𝐱 𝑡 )

Sensitivity matrix

𝑸 =

𝜕𝑦 1

𝜕𝜃𝑖⋯

𝜕𝑦 1

𝜕𝜃𝑝

⋮ ⋱ ⋮𝜕𝑦 𝑛

𝜕𝜃𝑖⋯

𝜕𝑦 𝑛

𝜕𝜃𝑝

Dynamic Sensitivity Analysis

Local methods Differentiation of model equations

d

dt

𝜕𝐲

𝜕𝛉=𝜕𝐟

𝜕𝐲 ∙𝜕𝐲

𝜕θ+𝜕𝐟

𝜕𝛉

𝐟 : continuous function

𝐱 𝑡 ∶ differential state variables

𝐮 𝑡 ∶ time-varying controls

𝐰 ∶ time-constant controls

𝛉 ∶ parameter vector

𝐡 𝐱 𝑡 : measured state variables

𝐲 t ∶ measured responses

Results for CLC fixed-bed reactor:

00.2

0.40.6

0.81

05

10

15

20

25

300

20

40

60

Length (normalized)Time [sec]

No

rma

lize

d s

en

sitiv

ity

00.2

0.40.6

0.81

05

10

15

20

25

300

0.2

0.4

0.6

0.8

Length (normalized)TIme [sec]

No

rma

lize

d s

en

sitiv

ity

00.2

0.40.6

0.81

05

10

15

20

25

300

0.5

1

1.5

Length (normalized)Time [sec]

No

rma

lize

d s

en

sitiv

ity

k1 k2

k3 k4

00.2

0.40.6

0.81

0

5

1015

20

25

300

0.2

0.4

0.6

0.8

Length (normalized)Time [sec]

Norm

alized s

ensitiv

ity

Page 19: MODEL-DERIVED CHEMICAL-LOOPING SYSTEM …...heat + mass transfer in gas Heat transfer between packed bed and wall Axial dispersion of heat and mass External diffusion across film Reactions

04/04/2014

IASE Seminar Series 19/37

Structural local identifiability test (SLI) (1) Correlation of sensitivity matrix is different from ±1 (2) Fisher information matrix is non-singular

Structural global identifiability test (SGI) Verifies if parameter sets do not provide the same model responses

Identifiability Analysis

SLI test Design

experiment SGI test det (𝐻𝜃

∗) = 0

?

Y

N

Change model structure

𝑃𝑎𝑠𝑠? End Y

N

*

1 1

ytsNN

T

θ ij i j

i j

H Q Q

* *

, *max ε

TI

θ θ θ θ

θ θ W θ θ

y

τ

y

Tdt ε,,,, 00

0

00 **θuyθuyWθuyθuy

Subject to:

𝛉, 𝛉∗: parameter sets 𝐲 ∶ model trajectory 𝒖𝟎 ∶ initial controls 𝐖 ∶ weights 𝜀𝜃 , 𝜀𝑦 ∶ small numbers

Page 20: MODEL-DERIVED CHEMICAL-LOOPING SYSTEM …...heat + mass transfer in gas Heat transfer between packed bed and wall Axial dispersion of heat and mass External diffusion across film Reactions

04/04/2014

IASE Seminar Series 20/37

Arrhenius Expression: SLI results:

1 experiment High correlation Unidentifiable

2 experiments Identifiable

SGI results: Φ𝐼 = 4E-10 < εθ = 1E-6 ε𝑦 = 1E-3

Identifiability Analysis: Arrhenius Expression

Optimal experiments

T [℃] 600 800

QCH4 [sccm] 30 30

Solids [g] 1.2 2.2

Ea1 Ea2 Ea3 Ea4 k1 k2 k3 k4

Ea1 1.000

Ea2 -0.394 1.000

Ea3 -0.247 -0.022 1.000

Ea4 -0.140 -0.143 -0.589 1.000

k1 -0.817 0.287 0.644 -0.271 1.000

k2 -0.396 1.000 -0.025 -0.140 0.289 1.000

k3 -0.290 -0.017 0.999 -0.575 0.666 -0.019 1.000

k4 -0.052 0.316 -0.165 -0.573 0.045 0.317 -0.158 1.000

Ea1 Ea2 Ea3 Ea4 k1 k2 k3 k4

Ea1 1.000

Ea2 -0.108 1.000

Ea3 -0.917 0.199 1.000

Ea4 -0.726 0.164 0.810 1.000

k1 -0.385 0.035 0.213 -0.002 1.000

k2 -0.134 -0.044 0.317 0.339 -0.048 1.000

k3 -0.758 0.193 0.886 0.818 -0.214 0.333 1.000

k4 0.027 0.166 0.047 -0.050 -0.291 -0.053 0.145 1.000

Correlation matrix of Arrhenius parameters

Correlation matrix of Arrhenius parameters

Han L, Zhou Z, Bollas GM. Optimal Experimental Design for Fixed Bed

Chemical-Looping Experiments. Comput Chem Eng 2014

k = kref exp −E

R

1

T−

1

Tref

Page 21: MODEL-DERIVED CHEMICAL-LOOPING SYSTEM …...heat + mass transfer in gas Heat transfer between packed bed and wall Axial dispersion of heat and mass External diffusion across film Reactions

04/04/2014

IASE Seminar Series 21/37

Build first principles process model

T

Design optimal experiment

Conduct experiment at

specified conditions

Estimate parameters &

confidence intervals

Interval #1 Interval #2

Model-guided experiment

Page 22: MODEL-DERIVED CHEMICAL-LOOPING SYSTEM …...heat + mass transfer in gas Heat transfer between packed bed and wall Axial dispersion of heat and mass External diffusion across film Reactions

04/04/2014

IASE Seminar Series 22/37

Motivation: maximize information content for parameter estimation

𝝋𝑜𝑝𝑡 =argmin𝛗

det 𝑯𝛉−1 𝛉,𝛗

subject to: 𝐟 𝐱 𝑡 , 𝐱 𝑡 , 𝐮 𝑡 ,𝐰 , 𝛉, 𝑡 = 0

φ𝑖𝐿 ≤ φ𝑖

≤ φ𝑖𝑈

Model + experimental results

Optimal experimental design (OED)

Kinetics Nominal exp. Optimal exp.

k1 0.3880 0.1654

k2 1.4416 0.8379

k3 0.6005 0.1461

k4 3.2706 0.3118

Norm 95% confidence interval

0 5 10 15 20 25 300

0.02

0.04

0.06

0.08

0.1

0.12

0.14

0.16

0.18

0.2

Time [sec]

Mol

e fr

actio

n of

gas

spe

cies

Comparison of optimal (-) and baseline (--) experiments

CO2

CO

CH4

data4

data5

data6

data7

data8

data9

data10

data11

Design criterion: D-OPTIMALITY

Improves parameter estimation

for all uncertain kinetic

parameters

Experiments

Standard Optimal

T [℃] 700 700

QCH4 [sccm] 10 20

Solids [g] 2 2

Page 23: MODEL-DERIVED CHEMICAL-LOOPING SYSTEM …...heat + mass transfer in gas Heat transfer between packed bed and wall Axial dispersion of heat and mass External diffusion across film Reactions

04/04/2014

IASE Seminar Series 23/37

Kunii & Levenspiel 3-phase model

ub

uo

us

ue

Bubble phase

us

Wake

Emulsion phase

Dense phase

Freeboarduf us,f

Fluidized bed model

Zhou, Z.; Han, L.; Bollas, G. M. Modeling

Chemical-Looping Combustion in

Bubbling Fluidized Bed Reactors. AIChE

J. 2014

Page 24: MODEL-DERIVED CHEMICAL-LOOPING SYSTEM …...heat + mass transfer in gas Heat transfer between packed bed and wall Axial dispersion of heat and mass External diffusion across film Reactions

04/04/2014

IASE Seminar Series 24/37

Fluidized Bed chemical-looping – prediction and analysis

Model is predictive (kinetic mechanism and constants of the fixed bed models used)

Freeboard contributes significantly to CH4 conversion and completion of oxidation

Consistent with all relevant experimental observations from various laboratories

Fluidized bed operation

- Zhou, Z.; Han, L.; Bollas, G. M. Modeling Chemical-Looping Combustion in Bubbling Fluidized Bed Reactors. AIChE J. 2014

- Zhou, Z.; Han, L.; Bollas, G. M. Overview of chemical-looping reduction in fixed-bed and fluidized-bed reactors focused on oxygen carrier utilization

and reactor efficiency. Aerosol & Air Quality Research. 2014

Page 25: MODEL-DERIVED CHEMICAL-LOOPING SYSTEM …...heat + mass transfer in gas Heat transfer between packed bed and wall Axial dispersion of heat and mass External diffusion across film Reactions

04/04/2014

IASE Seminar Series 25/37

Comprehensive comparison of two reactor designs (fixed and fluidized bed) of the same oxygen carrier loading The fixed bed reactor is inferior in all aspects including

CO2 selectivity Carbon formation Bed isothermality

Fixed/Fluidized beds comparison

Zhou Z, Han L, Bollas GM, Overview of Chemical-Looping Reduction in Fixed Bed and

Fluidized Bed Reactors Focused on Oxygen Carrier Utilization and Reactor Efficiency.

Aerosol Air Qual Res 2014;14:559–71

Page 26: MODEL-DERIVED CHEMICAL-LOOPING SYSTEM …...heat + mass transfer in gas Heat transfer between packed bed and wall Axial dispersion of heat and mass External diffusion across film Reactions

04/04/2014

IASE Seminar Series 26/37

Chemical-Looping Most efficient method for CO2 capture Very high research effort Tremendous research expenditure Combustion or reforming are feasible Mature process

Summary of background

Our work Modeled all fixed bed reactors with CH4 and NiO Predicted all fluidized beds with CH4 & NiO Compared fixed and fluidized bed CLC and CLR Setup a bench-scale fixed bed reactor

Process Options Fluidized beds Fixed beds Rotary beds Rotating beds Moving beds

Reactor options for Chemical-looping Combustion (CLC): (a) circulating fluidized-bed; (b) rotating reactor; and (c) alternating flow over a fixed-bed.

O2

N2

Air

CO2

H2O

Fuel

MeO

Me

Reducer Reactor Oxidizer Reactor

O2

N2

AirCO2

H2O

Rotating Reactor

MeO

Me

O2

N2

Air

CO2

H2O

Fuel

Alternating Flow

Fuel MeO

Me

Me

MeO

(a) (b) (c)

Page 27: MODEL-DERIVED CHEMICAL-LOOPING SYSTEM …...heat + mass transfer in gas Heat transfer between packed bed and wall Axial dispersion of heat and mass External diffusion across film Reactions

04/04/2014

IASE Seminar Series 27/37

Typical fixed-bed experiment

Experimental settings

Reduction temperature

800°C

Reduction time 1 min

Reducing gas flow

10 CH4 in 100 ml/min

Solid loading 2 g

Oxygen carrier conversion

Page 28: MODEL-DERIVED CHEMICAL-LOOPING SYSTEM …...heat + mass transfer in gas Heat transfer between packed bed and wall Axial dispersion of heat and mass External diffusion across film Reactions

04/04/2014

IASE Seminar Series 28/37

Design of the novel reactor setup

Reverse-Flow Fixed-bed CLC Reactor

Page 29: MODEL-DERIVED CHEMICAL-LOOPING SYSTEM …...heat + mass transfer in gas Heat transfer between packed bed and wall Axial dispersion of heat and mass External diffusion across film Reactions

04/04/2014

IASE Seminar Series 29/37

A novel fixed-bed chemical-looping reactor configuration was invented, in which the fuel flow direction is periodically switched during each cycle. The new design significantly improves the performance of fixed-bed chemical-looping reactors, making them competitive to their fluidized-bed equivalents, while overcoming their operating bottlenecks. The novel system enables:

(1) improved oxygen carrier utilization, (2) higher CO2 capture efficiency (by up to 50%), (3) mitigation of hot and cold zones, (4) elimination of gas-solids separation steps, (5) resistance to carbon deposition.

Advantages relevant to the oxygen carrier used (as compared to current process configurations) relate to the elimination of:

(6) need for oxygen carrier fluidizability, (7) attrition, (8) toxic solid fines effluents, (9) need for oxygen carrier addition.

Patent Claims (Bollas, Han 2014)

Page 30: MODEL-DERIVED CHEMICAL-LOOPING SYSTEM …...heat + mass transfer in gas Heat transfer between packed bed and wall Axial dispersion of heat and mass External diffusion across film Reactions

04/04/2014

IASE Seminar Series 30/37

Model Description

1D heterogeneous model

Dusty-gas model (concentrated transport)

Time varying boundary conditions for the

fluid phase

Full heterogeneous design equations

Reverse-Flow Fixed-bed Reactor Model

, 2

2

( 1 

)c c i

c s ii

c c

Cr R

t r rJ

,i

1 ij i

1Nc i

k i i ke ejc K

C Jy J y J

r D D

, , ,

2

2

1  

1( ) 

cc s p s c p c T c

cc s s i i

c c

TC C C

tT

r H Rr r r

Solid

ph

ase

Flu

id p

ha

se , , ,

)( ( ) 

c P

b i i i

b ax i c i v rc iri

C uC CD k a C C

t z z z

, ,( ) (C )

 c P

b p f T T p f

b ax f v c r r

uC C T C T Th a T

t z z zT

2

0

3

1 1501.75b

b p p

udP

dz d Re

outz LP P

0

0

0 c

c

ci r

c r

TJ

r

, ,  

Pc cpi c i c i ir rr r

J k C C

 c p

c p

cs f c r r

c r r

Th T T

r

U t t u

1, 1 , 1 2  

1,  1 2 ,   

s s

s s

t n t n tt

t n t nt

,in

,

,in

1,

20

1,

2

i ii

b ax i

i i

C zt

C

u CC

Dz t

u C z L

,

,

, 01

2

1,

2

in T p f

b ax

in T p f

tu T T C C

T

z tu T T C C

z

z L

Han L, Zhou Z, Bollas GM. Chemical-looping combustion in a reverse-

flow fixed-bed reactor. Applied Energy 2014

Page 31: MODEL-DERIVED CHEMICAL-LOOPING SYSTEM …...heat + mass transfer in gas Heat transfer between packed bed and wall Axial dispersion of heat and mass External diffusion across film Reactions

04/04/2014

IASE Seminar Series 31/37

CH4 conversion and CO2 selectivity

Reactor in this study is suboptimal for fair comparison with existing fixed bed reactors

Performance metrics I

Table: CO2 capture efficiency for varying oxygen carrier conversion

← Bench-scale reactor

Industrial-scale reactor →

Han L, Zhou Z, Bollas GM. Chemical-looping combustion in a reverse-

flow fixed-bed reactor. Applied Energy 2014

Bollas GM, Han L. Reverse-Flow Reactor for Chemical-Looping

Combustion and Reforming of Gaseous Fuels; US Provisional Patent -

University of Connecticut, 2014.

Page 32: MODEL-DERIVED CHEMICAL-LOOPING SYSTEM …...heat + mass transfer in gas Heat transfer between packed bed and wall Axial dispersion of heat and mass External diffusion across film Reactions

04/04/2014

IASE Seminar Series 32/37

Performance metrics II

Oxygen carrier conversion Bed Temperature Profile

Carbon Formation Solid Carbon selectivity and Max Bed T drop

Han L, Zhou Z, Bollas GM. Chemical-looping combustion in a reverse-

flow fixed-bed reactor. Applied Energy 2014

Page 33: MODEL-DERIVED CHEMICAL-LOOPING SYSTEM …...heat + mass transfer in gas Heat transfer between packed bed and wall Axial dispersion of heat and mass External diffusion across film Reactions

04/04/2014

IASE Seminar Series 33/37

Scaled-up Performance metrics I

Scale-up procedure Commercially realistic industrial-scale fixed-bed reactor Small particle size (300 µm) to minimize diffusion effects Significant pressure drop in the system =>

Constraint: bed height should not exceed 1 m

Scaling factors: L/D ratio and Froude number

Reactor still suboptimal Performance enhancement improved

Han L, Zhou Z, Bollas GM. Chemical-looping combustion in a reverse-

flow fixed-bed reactor. Appl Energy 2014

Bollas GM, Han L. Reverse-Flow Reactor for Chemical-Looping

Combustion and Reforming of Gaseous Fuels; US Provisional Patent -

University of Connecticut, 2014.

Bench-scale reactor Industrial-scale reactor L [m] 0.22 1.0

D [m] 0.055 0.25

Q (L/min) 16.68 (100% CH4) 3000 (100% CH4) Fr 0.34 0.39

L/D 4 4

Rep 0.80 6.9

ΔP [bar] 0.3 4

Page 34: MODEL-DERIVED CHEMICAL-LOOPING SYSTEM …...heat + mass transfer in gas Heat transfer between packed bed and wall Axial dispersion of heat and mass External diffusion across film Reactions

04/04/2014

IASE Seminar Series 34/37

Scaled-up Performance metrics II

Han L, Zhou Z, Bollas GM. Chemical-looping combustion in a reverse-

flow fixed-bed reactor. Applied Energy 2014

Oxygen carrier conversion Bed Temperature Profile

Carbon Formation Solid Carbon selectivity and Max Bed T drop

Page 35: MODEL-DERIVED CHEMICAL-LOOPING SYSTEM …...heat + mass transfer in gas Heat transfer between packed bed and wall Axial dispersion of heat and mass External diffusion across film Reactions

04/04/2014

IASE Seminar Series 35/37

What we should have done (Model-Based Development) Statistical Analysis of Existing Data and Kinetics Models (F-test, AICc) Fixed-bed model utilizing statistically significant kinetics Optimal Experimental Design for derivation/validation of unknown kinetics Fluidized-bed model prediction and validation Fixed-bed / Fluidized-bed comparison Reverse-flow fixed-bed reactor invention

What we accomplished so far: A novel reactor concept was invented that addresses the roadblocks to commercialization of existing chemical-looping processes

Our Aim to put chemical-looping research and technology on a fundamentally new learning curve; one that relaxes the requirement for fluidized-bed reactor systems and is capable of making chemical-looping a disruptive new technology

Conclusions

Page 36: MODEL-DERIVED CHEMICAL-LOOPING SYSTEM …...heat + mass transfer in gas Heat transfer between packed bed and wall Axial dispersion of heat and mass External diffusion across film Reactions

04/04/2014

IASE Seminar Series 36/37

Zhiquan Zhou 4th year PhD Student, CBE UConn Fluidized bed modeling, dynamic parameter estimation, statistical analysis

Lu Han 3rd year PhD Student, CBE UConn gPROMS, sensitivity analysis, optimal experimental design

Acknowledgments

NSF CAREER Award No. 1054718 Process and Reaction Engineering Program, CBET

UCONN Prototype Fund Office of the Vice President for Research

Ari Fischer Oscar Nordness Catherine Cheu

Kyle Such Clarke Palmer

Page 37: MODEL-DERIVED CHEMICAL-LOOPING SYSTEM …...heat + mass transfer in gas Heat transfer between packed bed and wall Axial dispersion of heat and mass External diffusion across film Reactions

04/04/2014

IASE Seminar Series 37/37

Thank you!

Department of Chemical & Biomolecular Engineering University of Connecticut

http://pdsol.engr.uconn.edu

George M. Bollas